Conceptual quandaries about genetic data - A comparative perspective

European Journal of Health Law

Volumn 16, Issue 1, 2009, Pages 7-26

  Krajewska, Atina ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF EXETER   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Bioethics; Biomedicine; Biotechnologies; Council of Europe; Data protection law; Genetic data; Genetics; Genomics; International law; Medical law; OECD

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE; BIOETHICS; BIOTECHNOLOGY; DATA EXTRACTION; GENOMICS; HUMAN; HUMAN GENETICS; HUMAN RIGHTS; LAW; MEDICAL RESEARCH; PRIVACY; PROTECTION; SYSTEMS BIOLOGY; EUROPE; FACTUAL DATABASE; GENETIC PRIVACY; LEGAL ASPECT;

BIOETHICAL ISSUES; DATABASES, FACTUAL; EUROPE; GENETIC PRIVACY; HUMANS;

EID: 66149147527     PISSN: 09290273     EISSN: 15718093     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1163/157180909X400204     Document Type: Article

References (70)

1. H. Kennedy, QC The Hamlyn Lectures: Legal Conundrums in our Brave New World, (London, Sweet and Maxwell, 2004), p. 21.
2. L. Peltonen V. A. McKusick"Dissecting Human Disease in the Postgenomic Era" 291 Science, No. 5507, 16 February 2001, 1224-1229. (Pubitemid 32173078)
3. Institute for Systems Biology"Systems Biology: the 21st Century Science", retrieved June 30, 2008 http://www.systemsbiology.org/Intro-to- ISB-and-Systems-Biology/Systems-Biology-the-21st- Century-Science.
4. J. Dupré Darwin's Legacy. What Evolution Means Today, (London, Oxford University Press, 2003), p. 83.
5. R. Dworkin "Playing God: Genes, Clones and Luck", in: R. Dworkin (ed.) Sovereign virtue: The theory and practice of Equality, (Cambridge, Mass Harvard University Press, 2000) pp. 427-52.
6. This popular notion has been used in a recently published book by J. D. Watson See: J. D. Watson A. Berry DNA: The Secret of Life, (New York, Knopf, 2003).
7. A. C. Ahn M. Tewari Ch.-S. Poon R. S. Phillips"The limits of reductionism in Medicine: Could systems Biology Offer an Alternative?", 3 FLOS Medicine, No. 7, July 2006, 0709. (Pubitemid 43987803)
8. Supra.
9. S. Nagl"Genetic Essentialism and the Discursive Subject" Twentieth World Congress of Philosophy, Boston 10-15 August 1998, retrieved June 21, 2008 http://www.bu.edu/wcp/MainBioe.htm.
10. J. Dupré, The Disorder of Things. Metaphysical Foundations of the Disunity of Science, (Cambridge, Harvard University Press, 1996), p. 171.
11. P. S. Greenspan"Free Will and the Genome Project", 22 Philosophy and Public Affairs, 1993, 31-43.
12. A short description of each of these diseases can be found at the WHO webpage. In case of autosomal dominant genetic disorders such as Huntington's disease results close to certainty can be expected only when both parents carry the defective gene. Retrieved June 30, 2008 http://www.who.int/genomics/public/ geneticdiseases/en/index2.html.
13. The study of the proteome, the complete set of proteins expressed by a genome, cell, tissue or organism, using the technologies of large-scale protein separation and identification. The term proteomics was coined i. n. 1994 by Marc Wilkins from the UNSW School of Biotechnology and Bimolecular Sciences. Retrieved June 30, 2008 http://www.babs.unsw.edu.au/staff-directory/wilkinsm. html.
14. l4) Metabolomics istThe global analysis of metabolites, small molecules generated in the process of metabolism. See also: H. Jenkins et al., A proposed framework for the description of plant metabolomics experiments and their results, 22 Nature Biotechnology, 6 December 2004, 1601-1606.
15. A. C. Ahn M. Tewari Ch.-S. Poon R. S. Phillips"The limits of reductionism in Medicine: Could systems Biology Offer an Alternative?", 3 PLOS Medicine 6, (June 2006), 0711. (Pubitemid 43987803)
16. A. D. Weston L. Hood"Systems Biology, Proteomics and the Future Health Care: Toward Predictive, Preventive and Personalized Medicine", 3 Journal of Proteome Research, 2004, 180. (Pubitemid 38500984)
17. A. C. Ahn M. Tewari Ch.-S. Poon R. S. Phillips supra note 8.
18. A. C. Ahn M. Tewari Ch.-S. Poon R. S. Phillips"The Clinical Applications of a Systems Approach", 3 PLOS Medicine, No. 7, (July 2006), 0959. (Pubitemid 44125973)
19. J. Dupré Darwin's Legacy. What Evolution Means Today, (Oxford University Press, London, 2003), pp. 23-25.
20. A. Lippman (1998) cited by: D. Hellman"What makes genetic discrimination exceptional?", 29 American Journal of Law and Medicine, No. 1, 2003, 119.
21. F. Ewald"Foucault and the Contemporary Scene", 25 Philosophy and Social Criticism, No. 3, 1999, 81-91.
22. Article 2 UNESCO International Declaration on Human Genetic Data, 16 October 2003 r., Records of the General Conference of the 32nd Session, Paris 23 September-17 October 2003. 〈http://portal. unesco.org/en/ev. php-URL-ID=17720&URL-DO=DO-TOPIC&URL-SECTION=20l.html〉
23. M. Albers Informationlle Selbstbestimmung, (Baden-Baden, Nomos-Verlag, 2005), p. 217.
24. Article 2 UNESCO Declaration (2003) supra note 22.
25. A. Cambom-Thomsen C. Sallée E. Rial-Sebbag B. M. Knoppers"Population Genetic Databases. Is a specific ethical and legal framework necessary?" 13 Gen Edit No. 1, 2005, 1.
26. C. Grand K. Atia-Off"Genmedizin und Datenschutz", in: Winter, Fenger, Schreiber (eds.) Genmedizin undRecht, (Munich, C. H. Beck, 2001), pp. 538-540.
27. See also: D. Brückl Rechtsfragen zurVerwendung von genetischen Informationen über den Menschen. Ein Beitrag zur Steuerungder Verwendung von Wissen (Berlin, Weißensee-Verlag, 2001), p. 120.
28. For a similar argument with relation to body parts and the right to informational self-determination see: Ch. Halasz Das Recht auf bio-materielle Selbstbestimmung (Berlin-Heidelberg, Springer, 2003).
29. Human Genetics Commission 2002, Inside information. Balancing interest regarding personal genetic data, London, May 2002, p. 2-7. In this report the HGC confirmed its view presented two years earlier in a discussion document on the storage protection and use of genetic information. See: Human Genetics Commission 2000 Whose hands on your genes?, London, November 2000, p. 3-5.
30. Enquete-Kommission des Deutschen Bundestag 14. Wahlperiode. Recht undEthik in modernen Medizin. Drucksache 14/9020, May 14, 2002 〈http://dip.bundestag.de/btd/14/090/1409020.pdf〉.
31. Bündnis 90/Die Grünen. Gesetz zur Regelung von Analysen des menschlichen Erbgutes (Gendiagnostikgesetz 2001). Drucksache 16/3233, November 3, 2006. Retrieved May 10, 2008 〈http://dip21.bundestag.de/dip21/btd/16/ 032/1603233.pdf〉.
32. Entschließungen der 62. Konferenz der Datenschutzbeauftragten des Bundes und der Länder. 24-26 October 2001 Gesetz zur Sicherung der Selbstbestimmungbei genetschen Untersuchungen. Datenschutzbeauftragte des Bundes 2001. Retrieved May 10, 2008. 〈http://www.informationsfreiheit-mv.de/ dschutz/beschlue/ent62.html#nr7〉.
33. See e.g.: R. Damm"Gesetzgebungsprojekt Gentestgesetz - Regelungsprinzipien und Regelungsmaterien", 1 Medizin und Recht, No. 1, 2004, 6-19 and U. Riedel"Das geplante Gentestgesetz". Public lecture given on 27 January 2004. Retrieved May 10, 2008 〈http://www.ulrike-riedel. de/pdf/Gentestgesetz%20-%20Rechtsprobleme%20und%20Regelungsbedarf.pdf〉.
34. Council of Europe, Council of Ministers, Recommendation R (97) 5 on the protection of medical data, 13 February 1997. 〈http://www.coe.int/t/e/ legal-affairs/legal-co-operation/data-protection/documents/international-legal- instruments/Rec(97)5-EN.pdf〉.
35. Explanatory Memorandum to the Recommendation R (97) 5 on the protection of medical data, 13 February 1997. Retrieved 〈http://www.coe.int/t/e/legal- affairs/legal-co%2Doperation/data-protection/documents/international-legal- instruments/EM-R(97)15-EN.pdf〉.
36. Supra, para. 42.
37. Penetrance is the proportion of individuals with a specific genotype who express that character in the phenotype. If an allele is highly penetrant, the trait it produces will always or almost always be apparent in an individual carrying the allele. See: J. Lackie The Dictionary of Cell and Molecular Biology, (Academic Press, 2007).
38. H. Lodish. A. Berk C. A. Kaiser Molecular Cell Biology (New York, W. H. Freeman and Company, 2001), pp. G-7-G-8.
39. Article 2 para 3 (a) Draft Protocol on Genetic Testing for Health Purposes, approved by the CDBI on 8 June 2007 during its 32nd plenary meeting, CDBI/INF (2007) 5.
40. OECD 2008 Draft Guidelines for Human Biobanks and Genetic Research Databases, 2008. Retrieved June 30, 2008 〈http://www.oecd.org/document/63/ 0,3343,en-2649-34537-40305535-1-1-1-1,00.html〉
41. L. Hood J. R. Heath M. E. Phelps B. Lin"Systems Biology and the New Technologies Enable Predictive and Preventative Medicine", 306 Science, 22 October 2004, 640. (Pubitemid 39440903)
42. CM. Mazzoni A LegalFramework forBioethics (The Hague, Kluwer, 1998), p. 57.
43. Article 2 (a) Directive 95/46/EC on the protection of individuals with regard to the processing of personal data and on the free movement of such data, 24 October 1995, O. J. L 281, 23.11. 1995.
44. Recital 26 of the Preamble of the Directive 95/46/EC.
45. D. Beyleveld"Data Protection and Genetics: Medical Research and the Public Good", 18 Kings Law Journal No. 2, 2007, 275-289.
46. They may be regarded as potential health indicators indirectly as they can show genetic relationships.
47. 'However, the definition has been worded in such a way that covers also genetic data which are not considered to be medical data in the recommendation' in: Explanatory Memorandum to the Recommendation (97) 5 on the protection of medical data Supra note 36, para. 44.
48. Article 27 para. 2 (7) Polish Data Protection Act, 29 August 1996, (Dz. U. 1997 Nr. 133 poz. 883 z pozn. zm).
49. The latest research showed, however, that people have more SNPs than originally expected. SNPs - single nucleotide polymorphisms - are DNA sequence variations that occur when a single nucleotide (A, T, C, or G) in the genome sequence is altered, which means the variation between humans are bigger. See: The International HapMap Consortium. 2007. "A second generation human haplotype map of over 3.1 million SNPs" 449 Nature, October 17. 851-861.
50. R. D. Workin"Playing God: Genes, Clones and Luck", in: R. Dworkin (ed.) Sovereign virtue: The theory and practice of Equality, (Cambridge, Mass Harvard University Press, 2000), pp. 427-52.
51. See e.g.: R. A. Spinello"Property rights in genetic information", 6 Ethics and Information Technology, No. 1, 2004, 30; M. Sutter"Whose Genes Are These Anyway?: Familial Conflicts over Access to Genetic Information", 91 Michigan Law Review 1993, 95; J. Sandor"Genetic information: Science, Society and Legal Norms", in: J. Sandor (ed.) Society and Genetic Information (New York - Budapest, CEU Press, 2003), p. 113 J. A. Bovenberg Property Rights in Blood, Genes and Data: Naturally Yours? (Leiden - Boston, M. Nijhoff Publishers, 2006), p. 34 T. Murray"Genetic Exceptionalism and Future Diaries: Is Genetic Exceptionalism Different From Other Medical Information?", in: Rothstein (ed.) Genetic Secrets: Protecting Privacy and Confidentiality in the Genetic Era (New Heaven, Yale University Press, 1997), p. 58 G. Laurie Genetic Privacy. Challenge to medico-legal norms, (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press 2002), p. 107.
52. L. O. Gostin"Genetic Privacy" 23 Journal of Law, Medicine and Ethics No. 4, 1995, 326.
53. Art. 4 a (iv) UNESCO Declaration on Human Genetic Data, supra note 23.
54. Art. 4 b supra.
55. Draft Additional Protocol to the Convention on Human Rights and Biomedicine on Genetic Testing for Health Purposes supra note 33.
56. Human Genetics Commission 2000, 2001, 2002. Protection of Genetic Information: An International Comparison. September 2000 〈http://www.hgc. gov. uk/UploadDocs/DocPub/Document/international- regulations.pdf〉, Whose hands on your genes. November 2000 〈http://www.hgc.gov. uk/UploadDocs/DocPub/Document/business-consultations2maintext.pdf〉, Inside Information Balancing interest regarding personal genetic data. May 2002 〈http://www.hgc.gov. uk/Client/Content.asp?ContentId=557〉.
57. A. Coote"Risk and Public Policy: Towards a High-Trust Democracy", in: Franklin, (ed.) The Politics of Risk Society (Cambridge, Polity Press, 1998), p. 129.
58. U. Beck"Politics of Risk Society", in: supra, p. 14.
59. T. Murray"Genetic Exceptionalism and Future Diaries: Is Genetic Exceptionalism Different From Other Medical Information?", in: Rothstein (ed.) supra note 52, p. 60.
60. L. O. Gostin J. G. Hodge Jr. "Genetic Privacy and the Law: An End to Genetic Exceptionalism", 40 Jurimetrics: journal of law, science and technology No. 21, 1999, 21-58.
61. J. Dupre The Disorder of Things. Metaphysical Foundations of the Disunity of Science (Cambridge, Harvard University Press, 1996), p. 121.
62. UNESCO Universal Declaration of Human Rights and Human Genome, 11 November 1997 〈http://portal.unesco.org/en/ev.php-URL-ID=13177&URL-DO= DO-TOPIC&URL-SECTION=201.html〉.
63. Council of Europe, Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Dignity of the Human Being with regard to the Application of Biology and Medicine: Convention on Human Rights and Biomedicine, Oviedo, 4 April 1997, ETS 164.
64. European Council Charter of Fundamental Rights of the EU, Nice, 7 December 2000, OJ. EU 18.12. 2000 C 364/3.
65. Article 7 UNESCO Declaration on Human Genetic Data (2003) supra note 23.
66. See e.g.: Jane Kaye 2006. "Do we need a uniform regulatory system for biobanks across Europe?", 14 European Journal of Human Genetics., November 25, 245-248 or B. M. Knoppers"Biobanking: International Norms", 33 The Journal of Law, Medicine and Ethics. Regulation of Biobanks., No. 1, 2005, 9. In these two papers the authors notice the variety of names and terms used to describe collections of human biological samples and data. However, they do neither discuss the ambivalence of the term 'biobank' as such. (Pubitemid 43135869)
67. J. A. Bovenberg Supra note 52, p. 28.
68. R. Damm supra note 34, p. 731.
69. F. Ewald, supra note 22, 81-91.
70. Human Genetics Commission, Inside Information. Balancing interests in the use of personal genetic data. May 2002, p. 367.