Public health in interwar England and Wales: Did it fail?

Dynamis

Volumn 28, Issue , 2008, Pages 175-198

  Gorsky, Martin ^a  

^a LONDON SCHOOL OF HYGIENE AND TROPICAL MEDICINE   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Local government; Medical officer of health; Preventive medicine; Public health

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE; HEALTH CARE POLICY; HEALTH SERVICE; HISTORY; HUMAN; LEGAL ASPECT; PUBLIC HEALTH; PUBLIC HEALTH SERVICE; UNITED KINGDOM;

ENGLAND; HEALTH POLICY; HEALTH SERVICES; HISTORY, 20TH CENTURY; HUMANS; PUBLIC HEALTH; PUBLIC HEALTH ADMINISTRATION; WALES;

EID: 63849320707     PISSN: 02119536     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.4321/s0211-95362008000100008     Document Type: Article

References (108)

1. Ministry of Health. A National Health Service. London: HMSO; 1944.
2. Bevan, Aneurin. In place of fear. London: Heinemann; 1952, p. 73.
3. Wanless, Derek. Securing good health for the whole population, final report. London: HMSO; 2004, p. 38.
4. Department of Health. Public Health White Paper Choosing health: making healthy choices easier. Cm 6374. 2004;
5. Wanless, Derek. Securing our future health: taking a long-term view, final report. London: HM Treasury; 2002, p. 119.
6. Francis, H. Public health: the decline and restoration of the tradition. In: Warren, Michael; Francis, Huw, eds. Recalling the Medical Officer of Health: writings of Sidney Chave. London: King Edward's Hospital Fund; 1987, p. 133-64 (133).
7. I largely leave aside questions of national policy and the academic literature on public health.
8. Harris, Bernard. The origins of the British welfare state: social welfare in England and Wales, 1800-1945. Basingstoke: Palgrave; 2004, p. 108-113.
9. Bell, Frances; Millward, Robert. Public health expenditures and mortality in England and Wales 1870-1914. Continuity and Change. 1998; 13 (2): 221-249;
10. Sheard, Sally. Reluctant providers? The politics and ideology of municipal hospital finance 1870-1914. In: Gorsky, Martin; Sheard, Sally, eds. Financing medicine: the British experience since 1750 Abingdon: Routledge; 2006, p. 112-29 (120).
11. Political and Economic Planning (PEP). Report on the British health services. London: PEP; 1937, ch. IV.
12. Bryder, Linda. Below the magic mountain: a social history of tuberculosis in twentieth-century Britain. Oxford: Clarendon Press; 1988, p. 36-45.
13. Harris, n. 7, p. 178, 243-261.
14. PEP, n. 9, p. 273, 276-278.
15. Levene, Alysa; Powell, Martin; Stewart, John. The development of municipal general hospitals in English county boroughs in the 1930s. Medical History. 2006; 50: 3-28.
16. Bevan, n. 2, p. 73-75.
17. Public health in England: The report of the committee of inquiry into the future development of the public health function. (Acheson Report) Cm. 289. London: HMSO; 1988.
18. Harley Williams, J. A century of public health in Britain 1832-1929. London: A&C Black Ltd; 1932, ch. IX;
19. Parlane Kinloch, John. The meaning of an adequate health service. Transactions of the Royal Sanitary Association of Scotland. 1929; 1-12;
20. Middleton Martin, J. Poor law reform and public health. British Medical Journal, 28 Aug 1926; 376-80;
21. Middleton Martin, J. The problem of medical services. Contemporary Review. 1922; 364-372.
22. Parlane Kinloch, John. Reform of the hospital services in Great Britain. The Journal of State Medicine. 1930; 38: 190-191.
23. Brockington, C Fraser. A short history of public health. London: J.A. Churchill Ltd.; 1956, p. 48-51.
24. Chave, Sidney. The rise and fall of the medical officer of health. In: Warren, Francis eds., n. 5, p. 115-130 (127).
25. Lewis, Jane. What price community medicine? The philosophy, practice and politics of public health since 1919. Brighton: Wheatsheaf; 1986, p. 15.
26. Lewis, n. 20, p. 3, 8, 16.
27. Lewis, n. 20, p. 4-7, 15-17.
28. Lewis, Jane; Brookes, Barbara. The Peckham Health Centre (PEP), and the concept of general practice during the 1930s and 1940s. Medical History. 1983; 27 (2): 151-61.
29. Lewis, n. 20, p. 17, 30-33.
30. Lewis, n. 20, p. 28-30; Lewis, Jane. The prevention of diphtheria in Canada and Britain 1914-1945. Journal of Social History. 1986; 20 (1): 163-176.
31. Lewis, n. 20, p. 33; Lewis, J. The politics of motherhood: child and maternal welfare in England, 1900-39. London: Croom Helm; 1980, p. 151-154.
32. Topping, Andrew. Maternal mortality and public opinion. Public Health. July 1936, p. 342-349.
33. Webster, Charles. «Healthy or hungry» thirties? History Workshop Journal. 1982; 13: 110-129.
34. Webster, n. 28, p. 112-13;
35. Webster, Charles. Health, welfare and unemployment during the depression. Past and present. 1985; 109: 204-230; and Medical officers of health-for the record. Radical Community Medicine. 1986; 10-14.
36. Webster, Charles. Public health in decline. Healthmatters. 1992; 11: 10-11.
37. Webster, n. 30.
38. Webster, n. 29, 1986.
39. Niemi, Marjaana. Public health and municipal policy making: Britain and Sweden, 1900-1940. Aldershot Ashgate; 2007.
40. Welshman, John. The medical officer of health in England and Wales, 1900-1974: watchdog or lapdog? Journal of Public Health Medicine. 1997; 19: 443-450;
41. and: Welshman, John. Municipal medicine: public health in twentieth century Britain. Bern: Peter Lang; 2000.
42. Levene, Alysa; Powell, Martin; Stewart, John. Patterns of municipal health expenditure in interwar England and Wales. Bulletin of the History of Medicine. 2004; 78: 635-669.
43. Levene, Alysa; Powell, Martin; Stewart, John. Investment choices? County borough health expenditure in inter-war England and Wales. Urban History. 2005; 32 (3): 434-458.
44. Griffiths, Clare; Brock, Anita. Twentieth century mortality trends in England and Wales. Health Statistics Quarterly. 2003; 18: 5-16.
45. Galbraith S; McCormick, A. Infection in England and Wales. In: Charlton J;. Murphy M, eds. The health of adult Britain. Vol. 2, London: The Stationery Office; 1997, p. 1-20 (3).
46. Registrar General's Statistical Review of England and Wales. London: HMSO; 1922 No 2, 1923 No 3, 1936 No 16, 1937 No 17; infectious diseases = enteric fever, measles, scarlet fever, whooping cough, diphtheria, influenza, tuberculosis, bronchitis, pneumonia, diarrhoea, puerperal mortality; TB mortality rate calculated from «Respiratory» + «Other» TB; figures are averaged for 1922 + 1923, and 1936 + 1937.
47. Winter, J. Infant mortality, maternal mortality, and public health in Britain in the 1930s. Journal of European Economic History. 1979; 8 (2): 439-462.
48. Lee, C Regional inequalities in infant mortality in Britain, 1861 -1971 : patterns and hypotheses. Population Studies. 1991; 45: 55-65.
49. Harris, Bernard. Unemployment, insurance and health in interwar Britain. In Eichengreen B; Hatton T., eds. Interwar unemployment in international perspective. Dordrecht: Kluwer; 1988, p. 149-183.
50. Congdon, P; Southall, H. Small area variations in infant mortality in England and Wales in the inter-war period and their link with socio-economic factors. Health and Place. 2004; 10: 363-82.
51. Congdon and Southall, n. 43, p. 376, 378-379.
52. Thompson, Steven. Unemployment, poverty and health in interwar South Wales. Cardiff: University of Wales Press; 2006, p. 199.
53. Thompson, n. 45, p. 245.
54. Thompson, n. 45, p. 118-123.
55. Loudon, Irvine. Death in childbirth: an international study of maternal care and maternal mortality 1800-1950. Oxford: Clarendon Press; 1992, ch. 13.
56. Loudon, n. 49, ch. 15.
57. Loudon, n. 49, p. 272-273.
58. Topping, n. 27, p. 345: «many will appreciate how one or two real 'snags' will push up the rate in a town with just over 1,000 births a year».
59. 1936: 3.65 (4 deaths) and 1937 6.4 (7 deaths).
60. Topping, n. 27, p. 347-348.
61. Niemi, n. 33; Walker-Smith, John. Sir George Newman, infant diarrhoeal mortality and the paradox of urbanism. Medical History. 1998; 42: 347-361.
62. Fildes, Valerie. Infant feeding practices and infant mortality in England, 1900-1919. Continuity and Change. 1998; 13 (2): 251-280 (260-1,263-7);
63. Atkins, Peter. Mother's milk and infant death in Britain, circa 1900-1940. Anthropology of Food [annual electronic journal] 2003 [cited 20 August 2007], Available at: http://aof.revues.org/document310.html.
64. Levene et al. report these figures not for the tax year, as in the underlying source, but for the calendar year.
65. McFarlane, Neil. Hospitals, housing, and tuberculosis in Glasgow, 1911-51. Social History of Medicine. 1989; 2: 59-85; Bryder, n. 10, p. 197-198, 258-260.
66. Background, see Durbach, Nadja. «They might as well brand us»: working-class resistance to compulsory vaccination in Victorian England. Social History of Medicine. 2000; 13: 45-62.
67. Gorsky, Martin; Mohan, John; Willis, Tim. Mutualism and health care: hospital contributory schemes in twentieth-century Britain. Manchester: Manchester University Press; 2006, ch. 6.
68. Parsons, A. County of Somerset: Further Survey Report The National Archives (TNA) MH 66/215, p. 37; Lewis, n. 20, p. 28.
69. City and county of Bristol Annual Report of the Medical Officer of Health 1924 (BL AR MOH). Bristol; 1925. p. 5-16; BL AR MOH 1934, Bristol; 1935. p. 8-9; by 1934 only about 10% of Bristol children were immunised.
70. Gloucestershire County Council, Annual Report of the Medical Officer of Health for the Administrative County of Gloucester for 1938, (GCC AR MOH). Gloucester; 1939.
71. See also Welshman, n. 34, 1997, p. 445.
72. BL AR MOH. 1934; Bristol; 1935. p. 3, 6.
73. BL AR MOH. 1937; Bristol; 1938. p. 298-312.
74. Parry, R. Some thoughts on the future of public health and of the M.O.H. Public Health. 1948; March: 102-104 (p. 102);
75. Parry, R. The need for overlapping. The Lancet. 1955; March: 609-610.
76. The notable exception is Thompson, n. 45, ch. V.
77. Annual Reports of the Medical Officer of Health for the City and Port of Gloucester, 1920 (GCB AR MOH). Gloucester; 1921.
78. Somerset County Council, Report of the Medical Officer of Health for the year 1929, (SCC AR MOH). p. 42-43; SCC AR MOH 1930, p. 35-69; SCC AR MOH 1945, p. 31.
79. Fawcett, H. The medical officer's practice of housing. Public Health. 1935; October: 6-19, p. 6.
80. SCC AR MOH. 1936; p. 48-49.
81. Annual Report of the Medical Officer of Health and the Chief Inspector of Nuisances for the Year 1920 (BA AR MOH). Bath: 1921, p. 7.
82. BL AR MOH, 1934-1938, passim.
83. Malpass, Peter; Walmsley, Jenny. 100 years of council housing in Bristol, Bristol: University of the West of England; 2005, p. 4-5.
84. Savage, W. Our future. Public health. 1935; 49 (Nov): 42-47.
85. Lewis, n. 20, p. 28.
86. nd ed. London: J & A. Churchill; 1941, p. 6.
87. Parsons, A. Administrative County of Somerset: Report on a Survey of Health Services. TNA MH/66/210 p. 12, 20-21, 125.
88. Savage, n. 78; the Index Medicus records 28 articles published 1930-39, eg. Pasteurisation in relation to milk distribution. Lancet. 1931; 1: 543-554;
89. Discussion on milkborne streptococcus epidemics. Proceedings of the Royal Society of Medicine. 1931; 24: 111-120;
90. Prevention of human tuberculosis of bovine origin. Journal of the Royal Sanitary Institute. 1933; 54: 11-17;
91. Presidential address on water and sewage schemes in rural areas. Journal of the Royal Sanitary Institute. 1936; 57: 339-345,
92. Ice cream food poisoning outbreak due to B. dysenteriae (Sonne). Journal of Hygiene. 1938; 38: 331-337.
93. Somerset County Council, Public Assistance Committee Minute Book from Dec, 1929. to Dec, 1932, 25 November 1930. SRO C/WS/PA 1; Savage, W. Somerset County Council Health Department: A preliminary report upon the accommodation for the sick and other inmates in poor law institutions in Somerset, February 12th 1930; p. 14.
94. Lebas, Elisabeth. «When every street became a cinema». The film work of Bermondsey Borough Council's Public Health Department, 1923-1953. History Workshop Journal. 1995; 39: 42-55.
95. BL AR MOH, 1944, p. 15-16; BA AR MOH, 1944, p. 26.
96. Although studies by the National Birthday Trust Fund, previously considered robust evidence for the desirability of nutritional supplements in depressed areas, have been shown to have been flawed in design, data collection and reporting: A. Susan Williams, Relief and research: the nutrition work of the National Birthday Trust Fund, 1935-9, Smith, David F., ed. Nutrition in Britain: Science, scientists and politics in the twentieth century. London: Routledge; 1996, p. 99-122.
97. Finer, H. English Local Government. London: Methuen; 1933, p. 393-434.
98. Figures for 1919/20-1944/5, from City of Bath, Abstract of Accounts 1921 -45. Bath Record Office; City and County of Bristol: Abstract of the Treasurer's accounts, 1921-47. Bristol Record Office (BRO); Gloucestershire County Council, Abstract of Accounts, 1918-47, City of Gloucester, Abstract of accounts, 1931-44. Gloucestershire Archives; Administrative County of Somerset: An abstract of the accounts of the County Council, 1924-46. Somerset Archives and Record Service.
99. BL AR MOH, 1928. Bristol; 1929; BL AR MOH, 1938. Bristol: 1939; BL AR MOH, 1939-1942. Bristol: 1943.
100. Gorsky, Martin. The Gloucestershire Extension of Medical Services Scheme: an experiment in the integration of health services in Britain before the NHS. Medical History. 2006; 50: 491-512.
101. SCC AR MOH, 1931, p.32.
102. Parry, R. Health centres. Journal of the Royal Sanitary Institute. 1947; 67: 111-120.
103. See Pyrs Gruffudd. «Science and the stuff of life»: modernist health centres in 1930s London. Journal of Historical Geography. 2001 ; 27: 395-416 for a critical evaluation of Peckham compared to municipal efforts.
104. Health Committee HC, 1/1/1930; Council Minutes, 8/4/1930. BRO.
105. Adams, J. The last years of the workhouse. In: Bornat J. et al., eds. Oral History, health and welfare. London: Routledge; 2000; p. 98-118 (104, 106-107, 112-113).
106. Berridge, Virginia; Christie, D;Tansey, E., eds. Public health in the 1980s and 1990s: decline and rise? London: Wellcome Trust; 2006; Francis, n. 5, p. 133-641.
107. Public Health in England: the report of the Committee of Inquiry into the future development of the public health function (Acheson Report), Cm. 289, London: HMSO; 1988.
108. Newsholme, Arthur. Medicine and the state: the relation between private and official practice of medicine with special reference to public health, London: Allen and Unwin; 1932, p. 34-35, 257-266.