Fell asleep and caused a fatal head-on crash? A case study of multidisciplinary in-depth analysis vs. the court

Traffic Injury Prevention

Volumn 10, Issue 1, 2009, Pages 76-83

  Radun, Igor ^a   Ohisalo, Jussi ^a   Radun, Jenni E ^a   Summala, Heikki ^a   Tolvanen, Matti ^b  

^a UNIVERSITY OF HELSINKI   (Finland)

^b UNIVERSITY OF EASTERN FINLAND   (Finland)

Author keywords

Criminal law; Fatal motor vehicle accidents; Fatigue; Liability; Sleepiness

Indexed keywords

ADOLESCENT; ADULT; AGED; ARTICLE; CAR DRIVING; FATIGUE; FEMALE; FINLAND; HUMAN; INFANT; LEGAL ASPECT; MALE; MIDDLE AGED; MORTALITY; SLEEP DEPRIVATION; STATISTICS; TRAFFIC ACCIDENT;

ACCIDENTS, TRAFFIC; ADOLESCENT; ADULT; AGED; AUTOMOBILE DRIVING; FATIGUE; FEMALE; FINLAND; HUMANS; INFANT; MALE; MIDDLE AGED; SLEEP DEPRIVATION;

EID: 61449099639     PISSN: 15389588     EISSN: 1538957X     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1080/15389580802489252     Document Type: Article

References (36)

1. A° kerstedt T. (2000) Consensus Statement: Fatigue and Accidents in Transport Operations. J. Sleep Res., Vol. 9, pp. 395-395.
2. Arnedt JT, Wilde GJS, Munt PW, Maclean AW. (2000) Simulated Driving Performance Following Prolonged Wakefulness and Alcohol Consumption: Separate and Combined Contributions to Impairment. J. Sleep Res., Vol. 9, pp. 233-241.
3. Arnedt JT, Wilde GJS, Munt PW, MacLean AW. (2001) How Do Prolonged Wakefulness and Alcohol Compare in the Decrements they Produce on a Simulated Driving Task? Accid. Anal. Prev., Vol. 33, pp. 337-344.
4. BonnetMH, Moore SE. (1982) The Threshold of Sleep-Perception of Sleep as a Function of Time Asleep and Auditory Threshold. Sleep, Vol. 5, pp. 267-276.
5. Corfitsen MT. (1999) "Fatigue" among Young Male Night-Time Car Drivers: Is There a Risk-Taking Group? Saf. Sci., Vol. 33, pp. 47-57.
6. Cunningham S. (2007) Punishing Drivers Who Kill: Putting Road Safety First? Leg. Stud., Vol. 27, pp. 288-311.
7. Curcio G, Casagrande M, BertiniM. (2001) Sleepiness: Evaluating and Quantifying Methods. Int. J. Psychophysiol., Vol. 41, pp. 251-263.
8. Dawson D, Reid K. (1997) Fatigue, Alcohol and Performance Impairment. Nature, Vol. 388, pp. 235-235.
9. Desai AV, Ellis E, Wheatley JR, Grunstein RR. (2003) Fatal Distraction: A Case Series of Fatal Fall-Asleep Road Accidents and Their Medicolegal Outcomes. Med. J. Aust., Vol. 178, pp. 396-399.
10. Donovan RJ, Jalleh G, Henley N. (1999) Executing Effective Road Safety Advertising: Are Big Production Budgets Necessary? Accid. Anal. Prev., Vol. 31, pp. 243-252.
11. Ellis E, Grunstein RR. (2001) Medico-Legal Aspects of Sleep Disorders: Sleepiness and Civil Liability. Sleep Med. Rev., Vol. 5, pp. 33-46.
12. Fletcher A, McCulloch K, Baulk SD, Dawson D. (2005) Countermeasures to Driver Fatigue: A Review of Public Awareness Campaigns and Legal Approaches. Aust. N. Z. J. Publ. Health, Vol. 29, pp. 471-476.
13. Hantula L. (1992) Development of a Case Study Method of Road Accidents in Finland. J. Traffic Med., Vol. 1, pp. 27-35.
14. Horne J, Reyner L. (1999) Vehicle Accidents Related to Sleep: A review. Occup. Environ. Med., Vol. 56, pp. 289-294.
15. Horne JA, Reyner LA. (1996) Counteracting Driver Sleepiness: Effects of Napping, Caffeine, and Placebo. Psychophysiology, Vol. 33, pp. 306-309.
16. House of Commons, Transport Committee. (2006) Roads Policing and Technology: Getting the Right Balance. The Stationery Office Limited, London. Tenth Report of Session 2005-06.
17. Jiminez v. The Queen (1992) High Court of Australia, 173 CLR 572. Available at: http://www.austlii.edu.au/au/cases/cth/HCA/1992/14. html (accessed 19 January 2009).
18. Jones CB, Dorrian J, Dawson D. (2003) Legal Implications of Fatigue in the Australian Transportation Industries. J. Ind. Relat., Vol. 45, pp. 344-359.
19. Jones CB, Dorrian J, Rajaratnam SMW. (2005) Fatigue and the Law. Ind. Health, Vol. 43, pp. 63-70.
20. Joutsen M, Lahti R, P̈ol̈onen P. (2001) Criminal Justice Systems in Europe and North America: Finland. European Institute for Crime Prevention and Control, affiliated with the United Nations. Helsinki, Finland.
21. Lamond N, Dawson D. (1999) Quantifying the Performance Impairment Associated with Fatigue. J. Sleep Res., Vol. 8, pp. 255-262.
22. Lisper HO, Laurell H, Van Loon J. (1986) Relation between Time to Falling Asleep behind the Wheel on a Closed Track and Changes in Subsidiary Reaction Time during Prolonged Driving on aMotorway. Ergonomics, Vol. 29, pp. 445-453.
23. McCutcheon JP. (1997) Involuntary Conduct and the Case of the Unconscious "Driver": Reflections on Jiminez. Crim. Law J., Vol. 21, pp. 71-79.
24. McCutcheon JP. (1998) Involuntary Conduct and the Criminal Law-The Case of the Unconscious Driver. Int. J. Law Psychiatr., Vol. 21, pp. 305-314.
25. Ministry of Justice, Finland. (2004) The Penal Code of Finland (Unofficial translation). Available at www.finlex.fi/en/laki/ Kaannokset/1889/en/18890039.pdf (accessed 14 January 2009).
26. Persaud BN, Retting RA, Lyon C. (2003) Crash Reduction Following Installation of Centerline Rumble Strips on Rural Twolane Roads. Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, Arlington, VA.
27. Radun I, Summala H. (2004) Sleep-Related Fatal Vehicle Accidents: Characteristics of Decisions Made by Multidisciplinary Investigation Teams. Sleep, Vol. 27, pp. 224-227.
28. Rajaratnam SMW, Jones CB. (2004) Lessons about Sleepiness and Driving from the Selby Rail Disaster Case: R v. Gary Neil Hart. Chronobiol. Int., Vol. 21, pp. 1073-1077.
29. Reyner LA, Horne JA. (1998) Falling Asleep Whilst Driving: Are Drivers Aware of Prior Sleepiness? Int. J. Legal Med., Vol. 111, pp. 120-123.
30. Rosen IM. (2005) DrivingWhile Sleepy Should Be a CriminalOffense. J. Clin. Sleep Med., Vol. 1, pp. 337-340.
31. Sateia, MJ. (2005) Driving While Sleepy Should Not Be a Criminal Offense: The Case for Caution. J. Clin. Sleep Med., Vol. 1, pp. 341-343.
32. Summala H, Mikkola T. (1994) Fatal Accidents among Car and Truck Drivers-Effects of Fatigue, Age, and Alcohol-Consumption. Hum. Factors, Vol. 36, pp. 315-326.
33. Supreme Court Decision no. 1998:124. Available at: http://www.finlex. fi/fi/oikeus/kko/kko/19980124 (accessed 14 January 2009).
34. Victorian Government, Department of Justice. (2004) Culpable and Dangerous Driving Laws: Discussion Paper. Melbourne, Australia.
35. Williamson AM, Feyer AM. (2000) Moderate Sleep Deprivation Produces Impairments in Cognitive and Motor Performance Equivalent to Legally Prescribed Levels of Alcohol Intoxication. Occup. Environ. Med., Vol. 57, pp. 649-655.
36. Wright NA, Stone BM, Horberry TJ, Reed N. (2007) A Review of In-Vehicle Sleepiness Detection Devices. Transport Research Laboratory, Published Project Report 157. Berkshire, UK.