Comparative study of the efficiency of buffer zones and harvest discarding on gene flow containment in oilseed rape. A modelling approach

European Journal of Agronomy

Volumn 30, Issue 3, 2009, Pages 187-198

  Colbach, Nathalie ^a,b,c   Devaux, Céline ^d   Angevin, Frédérique ^e  

^a CEMAGREF   (France)

^b UNIVERSITÉ DE BOURGOGNE   (France)

^c UNIVERSITÉ DE BOURGOGNE   (France)

^d UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA   (United States)

^e INRA   (France)

Author keywords

Brassica napus; Buffer zone; Co existence; Gene flow; GMO; Harvest discarding; Model

Indexed keywords

DISPERSAL; GENE FLOW; HARVESTING; LANDSCAPE; POLLEN; SEED;

BRASSICA NAPUS;

EID: 60649089965     PISSN: 11610301     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.eja.2008.09.007     Document Type: Article

References (49)

1. Angevin, F., Colbach, N., Meynard, J. M., Roturier, C., 2002. Analysis of necessary adjustements of farming practices. In: Bock, A.-K., Lheureux, K., Libeau-Dulos, M., Nilsagard, H., Rodriguez-Cerezo, E. (Eds.), Scenarios for Co-existence of Genetically Modified, Conventional and Organic Crops in European Agriculture. Technical Report Series of the Joint Research Center of the European Commission, EUR 20394 EN.
2. Baux A., Colbach N., and Pellet D. Crop management for optimal low-linolenic rapeseed oil production. Field experiments and modelling. 2nd International Rapeseed Congress. Wuhan, China, 26-30 March (2007) pp. 424-427
3. Beckie H.J., Warwick S.I., Nair H., and Seguin-Swartz G.S. Gene flow in commercial fields of herbicide-resistant canola (Brassica napus). Ecological Applications 13 (2003) 1276-1294
4. Begg G.S., Hockaday S., McNicol J.W., Askew M., and Squire G.R. Modelling the persistence of volunteer oilseed rape (Brassica napus). Ecological Modelling 198 (2006) 195-207
5. Blanco-Moreno J.M., Chamorro L., Masalles R.M., Recasens J., and Sans F.X. Spatial distribution of Lolium rigidum seedlings following seed dispersal by combine harvesters. Weed Research 44 (2004) 375-387
6. Bouvier A., Adamczyk K., Kiêu K., and Monod H. Computation of integrated flow of particles between polygons. Environmental Modelling and Software (2009)
7. Champolivier J., Gasquez J., Messean A., and Richard-Molard M. Management of transgenic crops within the cropping system. BCPC Symposium Proceedings No 72: Gene Flow and Agriculture: Relevance for Transgenic Crops. Farnham, UK (1999) 233-239
8. Colbach N., Clermont-Dauphin C., and Meynard J.M. GENESYS: a model of the influence of cropping system on gene escape from herbicide tolerant rapeseed crops to rape volunteers. II. Genetic exchanges among volunteer and cropped populations in a small region. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment 83 (2001) 255-270
9. Colbach N., Clermont-Dauphin C., and Meynard J.M. GENESYS: a model of the influence of cropping system on gene escape from herbicide tolerant rapeseed crops to rape volunteers. I. Temporal evolution of a population of rapeseed volunteers in a field. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment 83 (2001) 235-253
10. Colbach N., Angevin F., Meynard J.M., and Messéan A. Using the GENESYS model quantifying the effect of cropping systems on gene escape from GM rape varieties to evaluate and design cropping systems. OCL 11 (2004) 11-20
11. Colbach N., Molinari N., and Clermont-Dauphin C. Sensitivity analyses for a model simulating demography and genotype evolutions with time. Application to GENESYS modelling gene flow between rapeseed varieties and volunteers. Ecological Modelling 179 (2004) 91-113
12. Colbach N., Fargue A., Sausse C., and Angevin F. Evaluation and use of a spatio-temporel model of cropping system effects on gene flow. Example of the GENESYS model applied to three co-existing herbicide tolerance transgenes. European Journal of Agronomy 22 (2005) 417-440
13. Colbach N., Molinari N., Meynard J.M., and Messéan A. Spatial aspects of gene flow between rapeseed varieties and volunteers: an application of the GENESYS model based on a spatio-temporal sensitivity analysis. Agronomy for Sustainable Development 25 (2005) 355-368
14. Colbach N., Angevin F., and Messéan A. Effect of the quality of sown rape seed lots and of the genotype of GM varieties on harvest adventitious presence in the case of co-existing GM, non-GM and organic crops. In: Messean A., Angevin F., Gómez-Barbero M., Menrad K., and Rodríguez-Cerezo E. (Eds). New Case Studies on the Coexistence of GM and Non-GM Crops in European Agriculture (2006), Joint Research Center of the European Commission, Sevilla, Spain
15. Colbach N., Dürr C., Gruber S., and Pekrun C. Modelling the seed bank evolution and emergence of oilseed rape volunteers for managing co-existence of GM and non-GM varieties. European Journal of Agronomy 28 (2008) 19-32
16. Colbach, N., Monod, H., Lavigne, C. A simulation study of the effects of field patterns on cross-pollination rates in oilseed rape. Ecological Modelling, in press.
17. Crawley M.J., and Brown S.L. Spatially structured population dynamics in feral oilseed rape. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London Series B-Biological Sciences 271 (2004) 1909-1916
18. Darmency, H., Sausse, C., Cordeau, S., Gasquez, J., Messéan, A., 2007. Contribution des repousses à la production de graines. Cas du colza génétiquement modifié. In: AFPP - 20ème Conférence du COLUMA. Journées Internationales sur la Lutte contre les Mauvaises Herbes., Dijon, 11-12 décembre 2007.
19. Devaux, C., 2006. Estimation et modélisation de la dispersion efficace du pollen de colza à longue distance, dans un paysage agricole et dans un champ. Ph.D. Thesis. Université Paris XI-Orsay.
20. Devaux C., Lavigne C., Austerlitz F., and Klein E.K. Modelling and estimating pollen movement in oilseed rape (Brassica napus) at the landscape scale using genetic markers. Molecular Ecology 16 (2007) 487-499
21. Devaux C., Klein E.K., Lavigne C., Sausse C., and Messéan A. Environmental and landscape effects on cross-pollination rates observed at long-distance among French oilseed rape (Brassica napus) commercial fields. Journal of Applied Ecology 45 (2008) 803-812
22. Dupont S., Brunet Y., and Jarosz N. Eulerian modelling of pollen dispersal over heterogeneous vegetation canopies. Agricultural and Forest Meteorology 141 (2006) 82-104
23. E.C., 2001. Scientific Committee on Plants, opinion from 13 March 2001.
24. E.C., 2003. Regulation (EC) no. 1830/2003 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 22 September 2003 concerning the traceability and labelling of genetically modified organisms and the traceability of food and feed products produced from genetically modified organisms and amending Directive 200/18/EC. JOCE L268, pp. 24-28.
25. Eastham K., and Sweet J.B. Genetically modified organisms (GMOs): the significance of gene flow through pollen transfer. European Environment Agency (2002) 75
26. Fargue A., Colbach N., and Meynard J.M. Introduction of genotypic effects into GENESYS-RAPE: the example of height and male sterility. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment 108 (2005) 318-328
27. Fargue A., Colbach N., Pierre J., Picault H., Renard M., and Meynard J.M. Predictive study of the advantages of cleistogamy in rapeseed. Euphitica 151 (2006) 1-13
28. Garnier, A., 2006. Dynamique et dispersion d'une espèce cultivée échappée des champs:le cas du colza. Pd Thesis. Université Paris-Sud XI-Orsay.
29. Habekotté B. A model of the phenological development of winter oilseed rape (Brassica napus L.). Field Crops Research 54 (1997) 127-136
30. Hall L., Topinka K., Huffman J., Davis L., and Good A. Pollen flow between herbicide-resistant Brassica napus is the cause of multiple-resistant B. napus volunters. Weed Science 48 (2000) 688-694
31. Hoyle M., and Cresswell J.E. The effect of wind direction on cross-pollination in wind-pollinated GM crops. Ecological Applications 17 (2007) 1234-1243
32. Ingram J. The separation distances required to ensure cross-pollination is below specified limits in non-seed crops of sugar beet, maize and oilseed rape. Plant Varieties and Seeds 13 (2000) 181-199
33. Ingram J. The separation distances required to ensure cross-pollination is below specified limits in non-seed crops of sugar beet, maize and oilseed rape. Plant Varieties and Seeds 13 (2002) 181-199
34. Jørgensen T., Hauser T.P., and Jørgensen R.B. Adventitious presence of other varieties in oilseed rape (Brassica napus) from seed banks and certified seed. Seed Science Research 17 (2007) 115-125
35. Klein E.K., Lavigne C., Picault H., Renard M., and Gouyon P.H. Pollen dispersal of oilseed rape: estimation of the dispersal function and effects of field dimensions. Journal of Applied Ecology 43 (2006) 1141-1151
36. Lavigne C., Klein E.K., Vallée P., Pierre J., Godelle B., and Renard M. A pollen-dispersal experiment with transgenic oilseed rape. Estimation of the average pollen dispersal of an individual plant within a field. Theoretical and Applied Genetics 96 (1998) 886-896
37. Lutman P.J.W., Berry K., Payne R., Simpson E., Sweet J., Champion G.T., May M., Wightman P., Walker K.C., and Lainsbury M. Persistence of seeds from crops of conventional and genetically modified herbicide tolerant oilseed rape (Brassica napus). Royal Society, London B 272 (2005) 1909-1915
38. Messéan A., Sausse C., Gasquez J., and Darmency H. Occurrence of genetically modified oilseed rape seeds in the harvest of subsequent conventional oilseed rape over time. European Journal of Agronomy 27 (2007) 115-122
39. Mullins E., Tricault Y., Colbach N., Flanagan P., and Fealy R. Developing strategies to assist in the coexistence of GM and non-GM oilseed rape crops on an Irish landscape. International Conference on Implications of GM-Crop Cultivation at Large Spatial Scales (GMLS). Bremen, Germany, April 2-4 (2008)
40. Ramsay G., Thompson C., and Squire G. Quantifying landscape-scale gene flow in oilseed rape. Defra (2003)
41. Reboud X. Effect of a gap on gene flow between otherwise adjacent transgenic 8 Brassica napus crops. Theoretical and Applied Genetics 106 (2003) 1048-1058
42. Rew L.J., and Cussans G.W. Horizontal movement of seeds following tine and plough cultivation: implications for spatial dynamics of weed infestations. Weed Research 37 (1997) 247-256
43. Richter O., and Seppelt R. Flow of genetic information through agricultural ecosystems: a generic modelling framework with application to pesticide-resistance weeds and genetically modified crops. Ecological Modelling 174 (2004) 55-66
44. Sausse, C., Gauffreteau, A., Colbach, N., Squire, G.R., Young, M.W., Le Bail, M., 2007. Sensitivity to oilseed rape gene flow in two European contrasted regions. In: GMCC07, Sevilla, 20-21 November 2007, 109-112.
45. Shaw M.W., Harwood T.D., Wilkinson M.J., and Elliott L. Assembling spatially explicit landscape models of pollen and spore dispersal by wind for risk assessment. Proceedings of the Royal Society B-Biological Sciences 273 (2006) 1705-1713
46. Simpson E., McRoberts N., and Sweet J. Out-crossing between genetically modified herbicide-tolerant and other winter oilseed rape cultivars. Plant Genetic Resources 4 (2006) 96-107
47. Wallach D., and Goffinet B. Mean squared error of prediction in models for studying ecological and agronomic systems. Biometrics 43 (1987) 561-573
48. Wallach D., and Goffinet B. Mean squared error of prediction as a criterion for evaluating and comparing system models. Ecological Modelling 44 (1989) 299-306
49. Weekes R., Deppe C., Allnutt T., Boffey C., Morgan D., Morgan S., Bilton M., Daniels R., and Henry C. Crop-to-crop gene flow using farm scale sites of oilseed rape (Brassica napus) in the UK. Transgenic Research 14 (2005) 749-759