Bedside screening tests vs. videofluoroscopy or fibreoptic endoscopic evaluation of swallowing to detect dysphagia in patients with neurological disorders: Systematic review

Journal of Advanced Nursing

Volumn 65, Issue 3, 2009, Pages 477-493

  Bours, Gerrie J J W ^a,b   Speyer, Renée ^c   Lemmens, Jessie ^a,b   Limburg, Martien ^c   De Wit, Rianne ^a  

^a MAASTRICHT UNIVERSITY   (Netherlands)

^b ZUYD UNIVERSITY OF APPLIED SCIENCES   (Netherlands)

^c MAASTRICHT UNIVERSITY MEDICAL CENTER   (Netherlands)

Author keywords

Dysphagia; Fibreoptic endoscopic; Neurological disorders; Screening tests; Swallowing; Systematic review; Videofluoroscopy

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE; DIGESTIVE TRACT ENDOSCOPY; DYSPHAGIA; EVALUATION; FIBER OPTICS; FLUOROSCOPY; HOSPITAL INFORMATION SYSTEM; HUMAN; METHODOLOGY; NEUROLOGIC DISEASE; PHYSIOLOGY; SENSITIVITY AND SPECIFICITY; STANDARD; SWALLOWING; VIDEORECORDING;

DEGLUTITION; DEGLUTITION DISORDERS; ENDOSCOPY, DIGESTIVE SYSTEM; FIBER OPTIC TECHNOLOGY; FLUOROSCOPY; HUMANS; NERVOUS SYSTEM DISEASES; POINT-OF-CARE SYSTEMS; SENSITIVITY AND SPECIFICITY; VIDEOTAPE RECORDING;

EID: 59449094458     PISSN: 03092402     EISSN: 13652648     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1365-2648.2008.04915.x     Document Type: Article

References (70)

1. Addington W.R., Stephens R.E., Gilliland K. Rodriguez M. (1999) Assessing the laryngeal cough reflex and the risk of developing pneumonia after stroke. Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation 80 (2 150 154.
2. Agency for Health Care Policy and Research 1999) Diagnosis and Treatment of Swallowing Disorders (dysphagia) in Acute-Care Stroke Patients. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, AHCPR, Rockville, MD.
3. Canadian Stroke Network and the Heart and Stroke Foundation of Canada: Canadian Stroke Strategy 2006) Canadian Best Practice Recommendations for Stroke Care: 2006. Canadian Stroke Network and the Heart and Stroke Foundation of Canada: Canadian Stroke Strategy, Ottawa.
4. Chong M.S., Lieu P.K., Sitoh Y.Y. Meng Y.Y. (2003) Bedside clinical methods useful as screening test for aspiration in elderly patients with recent and previous strokes. Annals Academy of Medicine Singapore 32 (6 790 794.
5. Cochrane Collaboration 2008) Cochrane Handbook for Diagnostic Test Accuracy. Retrieved from http://srdta.cochrane.org/en/authors.html.
6. Collins M.J. Bakheit A.M. (1997) Does pulse oximetry reliably detect aspiration in dysphagic stroke patients? Stroke 28 (9 1773 1775.
7. Colodney N. (2001) Effects of age, gender, disease, and multisystem involvement on oxygen saturation levels in dysphagic persons. Dysphagia 16, 48 57.
8. Daniels S.K., McAdam C.P., Brailey K. Foundas A.L. (1997) Clinical assessment of swallowing and prediction of dysphagia severity. American Journal of Speech Language Pathology 6 (4 17 24.
9. Daniels S.K., Brailey K., Priestly D.H., Herrington L.R., Weisberg L.A. Foundas A.L. (1998) Aspiration in patients with acute stroke. Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation 79 (1 14 19.
10. De Vet H.C.W., van der Weijden T., Muris J.W.M., Heyrman J., Buntinx F. Knottnerus J.A. (2001) Systematic reviews of diagnostic research. Considerations about assessment and incorporation of methodological quality. European Journal of Epidemiology 17, 301 306.
11. Deeks J.J. (2001) Systematic reviews of evaluations of diagnostic and screening tests. British Medical Journal 323, 157 162.
12. DePippo K.L., Holas M.A. Reding M.J. (1992) Validation of the 3-oz water swallow test for aspiration following stroke. Archives of Neurology 49 (12 1259 1261.
13. Deville W.L.J.M., Bezemer P.D. Bouter L.M. (2000) Publications on diagnostic test evaluation in family medicine journals: an optimal search strategy. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology 53, 65 69.
14. Doggett D.L., Turkelson C.M. Coates V. (2002) Recent developments in diagnosis and intervention for aspiration and dysphagia in stroke and other neuromuscular disorders. Current Atherosclerosis Reports 4 (4 311 318.
15. Egger M. (1998) Meta-analysis bias in location and selection of studies. British Medical Journal 316, 61 66.
16. Egger M., Zellweger-Zähner T., Schneider M., Junker C., Lengeler C. Antes G. (1997) Language bias in randomized controlled trials published in English and German. The Lancet 350, 326 329.
17. Garon B.R., Engle M. Ormiston C. (1995) Reliability of the 3-oz water swallow test utilizing cough reflex as sole indicator of aspiration. Journal of Neurologic Rehabilitation 9 (3 139 143.
18. Glas A.F., Lijmer J.G., Prins M.H., Nonsel G.J. Bossuyt P.M.M. (2003) The diagnostic odds ratio: a single indicator of test performance. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology 56, 1129 1135.
19. Higo R., Tayama N., Watanabe T. Nito T. (2003) Pulse oximetry monitoring for the evaluation of swallowing function. European Archives of Oto-rhino-pharyngology 260 (3 124 127.
20. Hinchey J.A., Shepherd T., Furie K., Smith D., Wang D. Tonn S. (2005) Formal dysphagia screening protocols prevent pneumonia. Stroke 36, 1972 1976.
21. Horner J. Massey E.W. (1988) Silent aspiration following stroke. Neurology 38 (2 317 319.
22. Horner J., Massey E.W., Riski J.E., Lathrop D.L. Chase K.N. (1988) Aspiration following stroke: clinical correlates and outcome. Neurology 38 (9 1359 1362.
23. Horner J., Brazer S.R. Massey E.W. (1993) Aspiration in bilateral stroke patients: a validation study. Neurology 43 (2 430 433.
24. Kalf J.G. (2002) Slikscreening na een beroerte: een evidence based review. Logopedie en Foniatrie 74 (3 76 83.
25. Kidd D., Lawson J., Nesbitt R. MacMahon J. (1993) Aspiration in acute stroke: a clinical study with videofluoroscopy. Quarterly Journal of Medicine 86 (12 825 829.
26. Koopman W.J., Wiebe S., Colton-Hudson A., Moosa T., Smith D. Nicolle M.W. (2004) Prediction of aspiration in myasthenia gravis. Muscle and Nerve 29 (2 256 260.
27. Kwaliteitsinstituut voor de Gezondheidszorg: CBO 2008) Diagnostiek, behandeling en zorg voor patiënten met een beroerte. CBO, Utrecht.
28. Lam K., Lam F.K., Lau K.K., Chan Y.K., Kan E.Y., Woo J., Wong F.K. Ko A. (2007) Simple clinical tests may predict severe oropharyngeal dysphagia in Parkinson's disease. Movement Disorders 22 (5 640 644.
29. Lambert H.C. Gisel E.G. (1996) The assessment of oral, pharyngeal and esophageal dysphagia in elderly persons. Physical & Occupational Therapy in Geriatrics 14 (4 1 25.
30. Langmore S.E., Schatz K. Olson N. (1991) Endoscopic and videofluoroscopic evaluations of swallowing and aspiration. Annals of Otology, Rhinology, and Laryngology 100 (8 678 681.
31. Leder S.B. Espinosa J.F. (2002) Aspiration risk after acute stroke: comparison of clinical examination and fiberoptic endoscopic evaluation of swallowing. Dysphagia 17 (3 214 218.
32. Lijmer J.G., Mol B.W., Heisterkamp S., Bonsel G.J., Prins M.H., van der Meulen J.H.P. Bossuyt P.M.M. (1999) Empiracel evidence of design-related bias in studies of diagnostic tests. Journal of the American Medical Association 282 (11 1061 1063.
33. Lim S.H.B., Lieu P.K., Phua S.Y., Seshadri R., Venketasubramanian N., Lee S.H. Choo P.W.J. (2001) Accuracy of bedside clinical methods compared with fiberoptic endoscopic examination of swallowing (FEES) in determining the risk of aspiration in acute stroke patients. Dysphagia 16 (1 1 6.
34. Linden P. Siebens A.A. (1983) Dysphagia: predicting laryngeal penetration. Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation 64 (6 281 284.
35. Logemann J.A., Veis S. Colangelo L. (1999) A screening procedure for oropharyngeal dysphagia. Dysphagia 14 (1 44 51.
36. Mann G.D. (2002) MASA: the Mann Assessment of Swallowing Ability. In Dysphagia Series (the author, ed Singular Thomson Learning, New York, NY, pp. 56.
37. Mann G., Hankey G.J. Cameron D. (1999) Swallowing function after stroke: prognosis and prognostic factors at 6 months. Stroke 30 (4 744 748.
38. Mari F., Matei M., Ceravolo M.G., Pisani A., Montesi A. Provinciali L. (1997) Predictive value of clinical indices in detecting aspiration in patients with neurological disorders. Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery, and Psychiatry 63 (4 456 460.
39. Martino R., Pron G. Diamant N. (2000) Screening for oropharyngeal dysphagia in stroke: insufficient evidence for guidelines. Dysphagia 15 (1 19 30.
40. Massey R. Jedlicka D. (2002) The Massey bedside swallowing screen. Journal of Neuroscience Nursing 34 (5 252 253, 257 260.
41. McCullough G.H., Wertz R.T. Rosenbek J.C. (2001) Sensitivity and specificity of clinicalbedside examination signs for detecting aspiration in adults subsequent to stroke. Journal of Communication Disorders 34 (1-2 55 72.
42. Murray J. (ed. 1999a) The clinical swallowing examination. In Manual of Dysphagia Assessment in Adults, Singular, San Diego, CA, pp. 37 112.
43. Murray J. (ed. 1999b) Manual of Dysphagia Assessment in Adults. Singular, San Diego, CA.
44. NANDA 2007) Nursing Diagnosis: Definitions & Classifications 2007-2008. NANDA International, Philadelphia, PA.
45. Nishiwaki K., Tsuji T., Liu M., Hase K., Tanaka N. Fujiwara T. (2005) Identification of a simple screening tool for dysphagia in patients with stroke using factor analysis of multiple dysphagia variables. Journal of Rehabilitation Medicine 37 (4 247 251.
46. Ott D.J. Pikna L.A. (1993) Clinical and videofluoroscopic evaluation of swallowing disorders. American Journal of Roentgenology 161 (3 507 513.
47. Perry L. (2001) Screening swallowing function of patient with acute stroke. Part two: detailed evaluation of the tool used by nurses. Journal of Clinical Nursing 10 (4 474 481.
48. Perry L. Love C.P. (2001) Screening for dysphagia and aspiration in acute stroke: a systematic review. Dysphagia 16 (1 7 18.
49. Prosiegel M., Schelling A. Wagner-Sonntag E. (2004) Dysphagia and multiple sclerosis. The International MS Journal 11 (1 22 31.
50. Ramsey D.J., Smithard D.G. Kalra L. (2003) Early assessments of dysphagia and aspiration risk in acute stroke patients. Stroke 34 (5 1252 1257.
51. Ramsey D., Smithard D. Kalra L. (2005) Silent aspiration: what do we know? Dysphagia 20, 218 225.
52. Rao N., Brady S.L., Chaudhuri G., Donzelli J.J. Wesling M.W. (2003) Gold-standard?: analysis of the videofluoroscopic and fiberoptic endoscopic swallow examinations. Journal of Applied Research 3 (1 89 96.
53. Rosenbek J.C., McCullough G.H. Wertz R.T. (2004) Is the information about a test important?: applying the methods of evidence-based medicine to the clinical examination of swallowing. Journal of Communication Disorders 37 (5 437 450.
54. Royal College of Physicians 2004) National Clinical Guidelines for Stroke. Prepared by the Intercollegiate Stroke Working Party, RCP, London.
55. Scott A., Perry A. Bench J. (1998) A study of interrater reliability when using videofluoroscopy as an assessment of swallowing. Dysphagia 13 (4 223 227.
56. Shaw J.L., Sharpe S., Dyson S.E., Pownall S., Wa;ters S., Saul C., Enderby P., Healy K. O'Sullivan H. (2004) Bronchial auscultation: an effective adjunct to speech and language therapy bedside assessment when detecting dysphagia and aspiration? Dysphagia 19 (4 211 218.
57. Sherman B., Nisenboum J.M., Jesberger B.L., Morrow C.A. Jesberger J.A. (1999) Assessment of dysphagia with the use of pulse oximetry. Dysphagia 14 (3 152 156.
58. Smith Hammond C.A. Goldstein L.B. (2006) Cough and aspiration of food and liquids due to oral-pharyngeal dysphagia: ACCP evidence-based clinical practice guidelines. Chest 129 (Suppl. 1 154S 168S.
59. Smith H.A., Lee S.H., O'Neill P.A. Connolly M.J. (2000) The combination of bedside swallowing assessment and oxygen saturation monitoring of swallowing in acute stroke: a safe and humane screening tool. Age and Ageing 29 (6 495 499.
60. Smithard D.G., O'Neill P.A., Park C., Morris J., Wyatt R., England R. Martin D.F. (1996) Complications and outcome after acute stroke: does dysphagia matter? Stroke 27 (7 1200 1204.
61. Smithard D.G., O'Neill P.A., Park C., England R., Renwick D.S., Wyatt R., Morris J. Martin D.F. (1998) Can bedside assessment reliably exclude aspiration following acute stroke? Age and Ageing 27 (2 99 106.
62. Splaingard M.L., Hutchins B., Sulton L.D. Chaudhuri G. (1988) Aspiration in rehabilitation patients: videofluoroscopy vs bedside clinical assessment. Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation 69 (8 637 640.
63. Tohara H., Saitoh E., Mays K.A., Kuhlemeier K.V. Palmer J.B. (2003) Three tests for predicting aspiration without videofluorography. Dysphagia 18 (2 126 134.
64. Trapl M., Enderle P., Nowotny M., Teuschl Y., Matz K., Dachenhausen A. Brainin M. (2007) Dysphagia bedside screening for acute stroke patients. The gugging swallowing screen. Stroke 38, 2948 2952.
65. Wang T.G., Chang Y.C., Chen S.Y. Hsiao T.Y. (2005) Pulse oximetry does not reliably detect aspiration on videofluoroscopic swallowing study. Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation 86 (4 730 734.
66. Warms T. Richards J. (2000) "Wet Voice" as a predictor of penetration and aspiration in oropharyngeal dysphagia. Dysphagia 15 (2 84 88.
67. Westergren A. (2006) Detection of eating difficulties after stroke: a systematic review. International Nursing Review 53, 143 149.
68. Wu C.H., Hsiao T.Y., Chen J.C., Chang Y.C. Lee S.Y. (1997) Evaluation of swallowing safety with fiberoptic endoscope: comparison with videofluoroscopic technique. Laryngoscope 107 (5 396 401.
69. Wu M.C., Chang Y.C., Wang T.G. Lin L.C. (2004) Evaluating swallowing dysfunction using a 100-ml water swallowing test. Dysphagia 19 (1 43 47.
70. Zenner P.M., Losinski D.S. Mills R.H. (1995) Using cervical auscultation in the clinical dysphagia examination in long-term care. Dysphagia 10 (1 27 31.