Accuracy of self-reports of Pap and mammography screening compared to medical record: A meta-analysis

Cancer Causes and Control

Volumn 20, Issue 1, 2009, Pages 1-13

  Howard, Michelle ^a   Agarwal, Gina ^a   Lytwyn, Alice ^a  

^a MCMASTER UNIVERSITY   (Canada)

Author keywords

Bias; Health surveys; Mammography; Meta analysis; Papanicolaou Smear; Review systematic

Indexed keywords

ACCURACY; CANCER SCREENING; CLINICAL TRIAL; HUMAN; INTERMETHOD COMPARISON; MAMMOGRAPHY; MEDICAL RECORD; META ANALYSIS; PAPANICOLAOU TEST; PATHOLOGY; PATIENT PARTICIPATION; POPULATION AND POPULATION RELATED PHENOMENA; PRIORITY JOURNAL; RADIOLOGY; REVIEW; SELF REPORT; SENSITIVITY AND SPECIFICITY; STRATIFICATION; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW;

ADULT; AGED; BREAST NEOPLASMS; DATA COLLECTION; EARLY DETECTION OF CANCER; FEMALE; HUMANS; MAMMOGRAPHY; MEDICAL RECORDS; MIDDLE AGED; SENSITIVITY AND SPECIFICITY; VAGINAL SMEARS;

EID: 58249108551     PISSN: 09575243     EISSN: 15737225     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1007/s10552-008-9228-4     Document Type: Review

References (60)

1. DM Parkin P Pisani J Ferlay 1999 Global cancer statistics CA Cancer J Clin 49 33 64 10.3322/canjclin.49.1.33
2. U.S. Preventive Services Task Force (2002) Screening for breast cancer. Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality, Washington, DC
3. DT Janerich O Hadjimechael PE Schwartz 1995 The screening histories of women with invasive cervical cancer, Conneticut Am J Public Health 85 791 794
4. EP McCarthy RB Burns SS Coughlin 1998 Mammography use helps to explain differences in breast cancer stage at diagnosis between older black and white women Ann Intern Med 128 773 775
5. CJ Maxwell CM Bancej J Snider SA Vik 2001 Factors important in promoting cervical cancer screening among Canadian women: findings from the 1996-97 National Population Health Survey (NPHS) Can J Public Health 92 127 133
6. EK Adams N Breen PJ Joski 2007 Impact of the national breast and cervical cancer early detection program on mammography and Pap test utilization among white, Hispanic and African American women: 1996-2000 Cancer 109 348 358 10.1002/cncr.22353
7. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention DoCPaC (2004) The National breast and cervical cancer detection program: saving lives through screening. Center for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, GA
8. AD Stein RI Lederman S Shea 1996 Reproducibility of the women's module of the behavioral risk factor surveillance system questionnaire Ann Epidemiol 6 47 52 10.1016/1047-2797(95)00092-5
9. DS May AE Trontell 1998 Mammography use by elderly women: a methodological comparison of two national data sources Ann Epidemiol 8 439 444 10.1016/S1047-2797(98)00010-6
10. J Swan N Breen RJ Coates BK Rimer NC Lee 2003 Progress in cancer screening practices in the United States: results from the 2000 National Health Interview Survey Cancer 97 1528 1540 10.1002/cncr.11208
11. RB Warnecke S Sudman TP Johnson D O'Rourke AM David JB Jobe 1997 Cognitive aspects of recalling and reporting health-related events: Papanicolaou smears, clinical breast examinations, and mammograms Am J Epidemiol 146 982 992
12. K Armstrong JA Long JA Shea 2004 Measuring adherence to mammography screening recommendations among low-income women Prev Med 38 754 760 10.1016/j.ypmed.2003.12.023
13. GH Rauscher TP Johnson YI Cho JA Walk 2008 Accuracy of self-reported cancer-screening histories: a meta-analysis Cancer Epidemiol Biomarkers Prev 17 748 757 10.1158/1055-9965.EPI-07-2629
14. SW Vernon P Briss JA Tiro RB Warnecke 2004 Some methodologic lessons learned from cancer screening research Cancer 101 1131 1145 10.1002/cncr.20513
15. K Stange SJ Zyzanski TF Smith 1998 How valid are medical records and patient questionnaires for physician profiling and health services research? A comparison with direct observation of patient visits Med Care 36 851 867 10.1097/00005650-199806000-00009
16. SA Newell A Girgis RW Sanson-Fisher NJ Savolainen 1999 The accuracy of self-reported health behaviors and risk factors relating to cancer and cardiovascular disease in the general population Am J Prev Med 17 211 229 10.1016/S0749-3797(99)00069-0
17. PMM Bossuyt JB Reitsma DE Bruns 2003 The STARD statement for reporting studies of diagnostic accuracy: explanation and elaboration Ann Intern Med 138 W1 W12
18. D Saslow CD Runowicz D Solomon 2002 American Cancer Society guideline for the early detection of cervical neoplasia and cancer CA Cancer J Clin 52 346 362
19. JR Landis GG Koch 1977 The measurement of observer agreement for categorical data Biometrics 33 159 174 10.2307/2529310
20. A Barrat J Cockburn D Smith S Redman 1999 Reliability and validity of women's recall of mammographic screening Aust N Z J Public Health 24 79 81 10.1111/j.1467-842X.2000.tb00728.x
21. JA Bowman R Sanson-Fisher S Redman 1997 The accuracy of self-reported Pap smear utilisation Soc Sci Med 44 969 976 10.1016/S0277-9536(96)00222-5
22. MR DiMatteo JD Robinson J Heritage M Tabbarah SA Fox 2003 Correspondence among patients' self-reports, charts, and audio/videotapes of medical visits Health Commun 15 393 413 10.1207/S15327027HC1504-02
23. S Etzi DS Lane R Grimson 1994 The use of mammography vans by low-income women. The accuracy of self-reports Am J Public Health 84 107 109
24. LM Martin M Leff N Calonge C Garrett DE Nelson 2000 Validation of self-reported chronic conditions and health services in a managed care population Am J Prev Med 18 215 218 10.1016/S0749-3797(99)00158-0
25. SJ McPhee TT Nguyen SJ Shema 2002 Validation of recall of breast and cervical screening by women in an ethnically diverse population Prev Med 35 1463 1473 10.1006/pmed.2002.1096
26. DE Montano WR Phillips 1995 Cancer screening by primary care physicians: a comparison of rates obtained from physician self-report, patient survey, and chart audit Am J Public Health 85 795 800
27. JG Zapka C Bigelow T Hurley 1996 Mammography use among socioeconomically diverse women. The accuracy of self-report Am J Public Health 86 1016 1021
28. JA Bowman S Redman JA Dickinson R Gibberd RW Sanson-Fisher 1991 The accuracy of Pap smear utilization self-report: a methodological consideration in cervical screening research Health Serv Res 26 197 207
29. S Newell A Girgis R Sanson-Fisher M Ireland 2000 Accuracy of patients' recall of Pap and cholesterol screening Am J Public Health 90 1431 1435
30. S Eaker I Adami P Sparen 2001 Reasons women do not attend screening for cervical cancer: a population-based study in Sweden Prev Med 32 491 10.1006/pmed.2001.0844
31. SD Walter EA Clarke H Hatcher LW Sitt 1988 A comparison of physician and patient reports of Pap smear history Am J Epidemiol 41 401 410
32. JG Boyce RG Fruchter L Romanzi FH Sillman M Maiman 1990 The fallacy of the screening interval for cervical smears Obstet Gynecol 76 627 632
33. JB Fowles E Fowler C Croft CE McCoy 1997 Comparing claims data and self-reported data with the medical record for Pap smear rates Eval Health Prof 20 324 342 10.1177/016327879702000305
34. RG Fruchter K Rones T Roth CA Webber L Camilien JG Boyce 1992 Pap smear histories in a medical clinic: accuracy of patients' self-reports NY State J Med 92 421 424
35. MT McKenna M Speers K Mallin R Warnecke 1992 Agreement between patient self-reports and medical records for Pap smear histories Am J Prev Health 8 287 291
36. J Pizzaro TR Schneider P Salovey 2002 A source of error in self-reports of Pap test utilization J Commun Health 27 351 356 10.1023/A:1019888627113
37. J Betz Brown ME Adams 1992 Patients as reliable reporters of medical care process. Recall of ambulatory encounter events Med Care 30 400 411 10.1097/00005650-199205000-00003
38. LS Caplan MT Mandelson LA Anderson 2003 Validity of self-reported mammography: examining recall and covariates among older women in a health maintenance organization Am J Epidemiol 157 267 272 10.1093/aje/kwf202
39. D Fulton-Kehoe M Burg DS Lane 1992 Are self-reported dates of mammograms accurate? Public Health Rev 20 233 240
40. ES King BK Rimer B Trock A Balshem P Angstrom 1990 How valid are mammography self-reports? Am J Public Health 80 1386 1388
41. VA Lawrence C DeMoor E Glenn 1999 Systematic differences in validity of self-reported mammography behavior: a problem for intergroup comparisons? Prev Med 29 577 580 10.1006/pmed.1999.0575
42. B Thompson V Taylor H Goldberg M Mullen 1999 Mammography status using patient self-reports and computerized radiology database Am J Prev Med 17 203 206 10.1016/S0749-3797(99)00068-9
43. L Crane CP Kaplan R Bastani SCM Schimshaw 1996 Determinants of adherence among health department patients referred for a mammogram Women Health 24 43 64 10.1300/J013v24n02-03
44. LS Caplan DV McQueen JR Qualters M Leff C Garrett N Calonge 2003 Validity of women's self-reports of cancer screening test utilization in a managed care population Cancer Epidemiol Biomarkers Prev 12 1182 1187
45. NP Gordon RA Hiatt DI Lampert 1993 Concordance of self-reported data and medical record audit for six cancer screening procedures J Natl Cancer Inst 85 566 570 10.1093/jnci/85.7.566
46. RA Hiatt EJ Perez-Stable C Quesenberry Jr F Sabogal R Otero-Sabogal SJ McPhee 1995 Agreement between self-reported early cancer detection practices and medical audits among Hispanic and non-Hispanic white health plan members in Northern California Prev Med 24 278 285 10.1006/pmed.1995.1045
47. PG McGovern N Lurie KL Margolis JS Slater 1998 Accuracy of self-report of mammography and Pap smear in a low-income urban population Am J Prev Med 14 201 208 10.1016/S0749-3797(97)00076-7
48. LM Tumiel-Berhalter MF Finney CR Jaen 2004 Self-report and primary care medical record documentation of mammograhpy and Pap smear utilization among low-income women J Natl Med Assoc 96 1632 1639
49. JA Sawyer J Earp RH Fletcher FF Daye TM Wynn 1989 Accuracy of women's self-report of their last Pap smear Am J Public Health 79 1036 1037
50. VL Champion U Menon D Hollinden-McQuillen C Scott 1998 Validity of self-reported mammography in low-income African-American women Am J Prev Med 14 111 117 10.1016/S0749-3797(97)00021-4
51. D Degnan R Harris J Ranney D Quade J Earp J Gonzolez 1992 Measuring the use of mammography: two methods compared Am J Public Health 82 1386 1388
52. SA Norman AR Localio L Zhou 2003 Validation of self-reported screening mammography histories among women with and without breast cancer Am J Epidemiol 158 264 271 10.1093/aje/kwg136
53. CS Johnson J Archer D Campos-Outcalt 1995 Accuracy of Pap smear and mammogram self-reports in a southwestern Native American tribe Am J Prev Med 11 360 363
54. L Suarez DA Goldman NS Weiss 1995 Validity of Pap smear and mammogram self-reports in a low-income Hispanic population Am J Prev Health 11 94 98
55. ED Paskett CM Tatum DW Mack H Hoen L Douglas Case R Velez 1996 Validation of self-reported breast and cervical cancer screening tests among low-income minority women Cancer Epidemiol Biomarkers Prev 5 721 726
56. S Sudman NM Bradburn 1973 Effects of time and memory factors on response in surveys J Am Stat Assoc 68 805 815 10.2307/2284504
57. EF Loftus MR Klinger KD Smith J Fiedler 1990 A tale of two questions: benefits of asking more than one question Public Opin Q 54 330 345 10.1086/269210
58. PZ Siegel JR Qualters PD Mowery S Campostrini C Leutzinger DV McQueen 2001 Subgroup-specific effects of questionnaire wording on population-based estimates of mammography prevalence Am J Public Health 91 817 820
59. MC Reid MS Lacks AR Feinstein 1995 Use of methodologic standards in diagnostic test research. Getting better but still not good JAMA 274 645 651 10.1001/jama.274.8.645
60. JJ Deeks 2001 Systematic reviews in health care. Systematic reviews of evaluations of diagnostic and screening tests Br Med J 323 157 162 10.1136/bmj.323.7305.157