Systematic review of thoracic discography as a diagnostic test for chronic spinal pain

Pain Physician

Volumn 11, Issue 5, 2008, Pages 631-642

  Singh, Vijay ^a   Manchikanti, Laxmaiah ^b   Shah, Rinoo V ^c   Dunbar, Elmer E ^d   Glaser, Scott E ^e  

^a Pain Diagnostics Associates   (United States)

^b PAIN MANAGEMENT CENTER OF PADUCAH   (United States)

^c GUTHRIE RESEARCH INSTITUTE   (United States)

^d Pain Control Network PSC   (United States)

^e Pain Specialists of Greater Chicago   (United States)

Author keywords

Cervical provocation discography; Chest wall pain; Diagnostic accuracy; Discogenic pain; Facet joint; False positive response; Intervertebral disc; Lumbar provocation discography; Thoracic disc herniation; Thoracic intervertebral disc; Thoracic pain; Thoracic provocation discography

Indexed keywords

CHRONIC PAIN; CLINICAL TRIAL; DIAGNOSTIC ACCURACY; DIAGNOSTIC TEST; DIAGNOSTIC VALUE; DISCOGENIC PAIN; DISKOGRAPHY; EVIDENCE BASED MEDICINE; FUNCTIONAL STATUS; HUMAN; QUALITATIVE RESEARCH; QUALITY CONTROL; REVIEW; SCORING SYSTEM; SPINAL PAIN; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW; THORACIC DISKOGRAPHY; THORAX PAIN; ZYGAPOPHYSEAL JOINT;

BACK PAIN; CHRONIC DISEASE; CLINICAL TRIALS AS TOPIC; DATABASES, BIBLIOGRAPHIC; DIAGNOSTIC IMAGING; HUMANS; INTERVERTEBRAL DISK; REPRODUCIBILITY OF RESULTS; SPINAL DISEASES;

EID: 57649199257     PISSN: 15333159     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: None     Document Type: Review

References (106)

1. Lindblom K. Diagnostic disc puncture of intervertebral discs in sciatica. Acta Orthop Scandinav 1948; 17:231-239.
2. Dandy W. Loose cartilage from intervertebral disc simulating tumor of the spinal cord. Arch Surg 1929; 19:660.
3. Wolfer L, Derby R, Lee JE, Lee SH. Systematic review of lumbar provocation discography in asymptomatic subjects with a meta-analysis of false-positive rates. Pain Physician 2008; 11:513-538.
4. Mixter WJ, Barr JS. Rupture of the intervertebral disc with involvement of the spinal canal. N Eng J Med 1934; 211:210-215.
5. Mixter WJ, Ayers JB. Herniation or rupture of the intervertebral disc into the spinal canal. N Engl J Med 1935; 213:385-395.
6. Pang WW, Mok MS, Lin ML, Chang DP, Hwang MH. Application of spinal pain mapping in the diagnosis of low back pain - analysis of 104 cases. Acta Anaesthesiol Sin 1998; 36:71-74.
7. Manchikanti L, Singh V, Pampati V, Damron K, Barnhill R, Beyer C, Cash K. Evaluation of the relative contributions of various structures in chronic low back pain. Pain Physician 2001; 4:308-316.
8. Schwarzer AC, Aprill CN, Derby R, Fortin J, Kine G, Bogduk N. The prevalence and clinical features of internal disc disruption in patients with chronic low back pain. Spine 1995; 20:1878-1883.
9. Bogduk N, Aprill C. On the nature of neck pain, discography and cervical zygapophysial joint blocks. Pain 1993; 54:213-217.
10. Yin W, Bogduk N. The nature of neck pain in a private pain clinic in the United States. Pain Med 2008; 9:196-203.
11. Crock HV. A reappraisal of intervertebral disc lesions. Med J Aust 1970; 1:983-989.
12. Ohnmeiss DD, Vanharanta H, Ekholm J. Degree of disc disruption and lower extremity pain. Spine 1997; 22:1600-1605.
13. Wheeler AH, Murrey DB. Chronic lumbar spine and radicular pain: Pathophysiology and treatment. Curr Pain Headache Rep 2002; 6:97-105.
14. Falco FJ, Zhu J, Irwin L, Onyewu CO, Kim D. Thoracic discography. In Manchikanti L, Singh V (eds). Interventional Techniques in Chronic Spinal Pain. ASIPP Publishing, Paducah KY, 2007, pp 553-566.
15. Simmons EH, Segil CM. An evaluation of discography in the localization of symptomatic levels in discogenic disease of the spine. Clin Orthop 1975; 108:57-69.
16. Schellhas KP, Pollei SR, Dorwart RH. Thoracic discography. A safe and reliable technique. Spine 1994; 19:2103-2109.
17. Winter RB, Schellhas KP. Painful adult thoracic Scheuermann's disease: Diagnosis by discography and treatment by combined arthrodesis. Am J Orthop 1996; 25:783-786.
18. Wood KB, Schellhas KP, Garvey TA, Aeppli D. Thoracic discography in healthy individuals. A controlled prospective study of magnetic resonance imaging and discography in asymptomatic and symptomatic individuals. Spine 1999; 24:1548-1555.
19. Guyer RD, Ohnmeiss DD. Lumbar discography. Position statement from the North American Spine Society diagnostic and therapeutic committee. Spine 1995; 20:2048-2059.
20. Singh V. Thoracic discography. Pain Physician 2004; 7:451-458.
21. Fernstrom U. A discographical study of ruptured lumbar discs. Acta Chirurg Scand 1960; 258:1-60.
22. Hirsch C. An attempt to diagnose level of disc lesion clinically by disc puncture. Acta Orthop Scand 1948; 18:132-140.
23. Malmivaara A. Disc degeneration in the thoracolumbar junctional region. Evaluation by radiography and discography in autopsy. Acta Radiol 1987; 28:755-760.
24. Fortin JD. Precision diagnostic disc injections. Pain Physician 2000; 3:271-288.
25. Collins CD, Stack JP, O'Connell DJ, Walsh M, McManus FP, Redmond OM, Ennis JT. The role of discography in lumbar disc disease: A comparative study of magnetic resonance imaging and discography. Clin Radiol 1990; 42:252-257.
26. El-Khoury GY, Renfrew DL. Percutaneous procedures for the diagnosis and treatment of lower back pain: Diskography, facet-joint injection, and epidural injection. Am J Roentgenol 1991; 157:685-691.
27. Schellhas KP, Pollei SR. The role of discography in the evaluation of patients with spinal deformity. Orthop Clin North Am 1994; 25:265-273.
28. Simmons JW, Emery SF, McMillin JN, Landa D, Kimmich SJ. Awake discography. A comparison study with magnetic resonance imaging. Spine 1991; 16: S216-S221.
29. Skubic JW, Kostuik JP. Thoracic pain syndromes and thoracic disc herniation. In Frymoyer JW (ed). The Adult Spine: Principles and Practice. Raven Press, New York, 1991, pp 1443-1461.
30. Walsh TR, Weinstein JN, Spratt KF, Lehmann TR, Aprill C, Sayre H. Lumbar discography in normal subjects. A controlled, prospective study. J Bone Joint Surg Am 1990; 72:1081-1088.
31. Weinstein J, Claverie W. Gibson S. The pain of discography. Spine 1998; 13:1344-1348.
32. Whitecloud TS, Seago RA. Cervical discogenic syndrome: Results of operative intervention in patients with positive discography. Spine 1987; 12:313-316.
33. Zucherman J, Derby R, Hsu K, Picetti G, Kaiser J, Schofferman J, Goldthwaite N, White A. Normal magnetic resonance imaging with abnormal discography. Spine 1988; 13:1355-1359.
34. Cloward RB. The anterior surgical approach to the cervical spine: The Cloward Procedure: Past, present, and future. The presidential guest lecture, Cervical Spine Research Society. Spine 1988; 13:823-827.
35. Wood KB, Garvey TA, Gundry C, Heithoff KB. Thoracic MRI evaluation of asymptomatic individuals. J Bone Joint Surg [Am] 1995; 77:1631-1638.
36. Bogduk N, Modic MT. Lumbar discography. Spine 1996; 21:402-404.
37. Bland JH. Diagnosis of thoracic pain syndromes. In Giles LGF, Singer KP (eds). Clinical Anatomy and Management of Thoracic Spine Pain, Vol. 2. Butterworth-Heinemann, Oxford, 2000, pp 145-156.
38. McInerney J, Ball PA. The pathophysiology of thoracic disc disease. Neurosurg Focus 2000; 9:e1.
39. Cloward RB. Anterior herniation of a ruptured lumbar intervertebral disk; comments on the diagnostic value of the diskogram. AMA Arch Surg 1952; 64:457-463.
40. Lindblom K. Technique and results in myelography and disc puncture. Acta Radiol 1950; 34:321-330.
41. Antti-Poika I, Soini J, Tallroth K, Yrjonen T, Konttinen YT. Clinical relevance of discography combined with CT scanning. A study of 100 patients. J Bone Joint Surg Br 1990; 72:480-485.
42. Singh V. The role of cervical discography in interventional pain management. Pain Physician 2004; 7:249-255.
43. Jensen MC, Brant-Zawadzki MN, Obuchowski N, Modic MT, Malkasian D, Ross JS. Magnetic resonance imaging of the lumbar spine in people without back pain. N Engl J Med 1994; 331:69-73.
44. Horton WC, Daftari TK. Which disc as visualized by magnetic resonance imaging is actually a source of pain? A correlation between magnetic resonance imaging and discography. Spine 1992; 17: S164-S171.
45. Boden SD, Davis DO, Dina TS, Patronas NJ, Wiesel SW. Abnormal magnetic-resonance scans of the lumbar spine in asymptomatic subjects. A prospective investigation. J Bone Joint Surg Am 1990; 72:403-408.
46. Wood KB, Blair JM, Aepple DM, Schendel MJ, Garvey TA, Gundry CR, Heithoff KB. The natural history of asymptomatic thoracic disc herniations. Spine 1997; 22:525-529.
47. Smith GW, Nichols P Jr. The technique of cervical discography. Radiology 1957; 68:718-720.
48. Buenaventura RM, Shah RV, Patel V, Benyamin R, Singh V. Systematic review of discography as a diagnostic test for spinal pain: An update. Pain Physician 2007; 10:147-164.
49. Shah RV, Everett C, McKenzie-Brown A, Sehgal N. Discography as a diagnostic test for spinal pain: A systematic and narrative review. Pain Physician 2005; 8:187-209.
50. Merskey H, Bogduk N. Thoracic discogenic pain. In Classification of Chronic Pain. Descriptions of Chronic Pain Syndromes and Definition of Pain Terms, 2nd ed. International Association for the Study of Pain. IASP Press, Seattle, 1994, p 116.
51. Merskey H, Bogduk N. Lumbar discogenic pain. In Classification of Chronic Pain. Descriptions of Chronic Pain Syndromes and Definition of Pain Terms, 2nd ed. International Association for the Study of Pain. IASP Press, Seattle, 1994, pp 180-181.
52. Merskey H, Bogduk N. Cervical discogenic pain. In Classification of Chronic Pain. Descriptions of Chronic Pain Syndromes and Definition of Pain Terms, 2nd ed. International Association for the Study of Pain. IASP Press, Seattle, 1994, p 108.
53. Bogduk N. Thoracic disc stimulation (provocation discography). In Practice Guidelines for Spinal Diagnostic and Treatment Procedure. International Spine Intervention Society (ISIS), San Francisco, 2004, pp 287-294.
54. Bogduk N. Cervical disc stimulation (provocation discography). In Practice Guidelines for Spinal Diagnostic and Treatment Procedures. International Spine Intervention Society (ISIS), San Francisco, 2004, pp 95-111.
55. Bogduk N. Lumbar disc stimulation (provocation discography). In Practice Guidelines for Spinal Diagnostic and Treatment Procedures. International Spine Intervention Society (ISIS), San Francisco, 2004, pp 20-46.
56. Laslett M, Aprill CN, McDonald B, Oberg B. Clinical predictors of lumbar provocation discography: A study of clinical predictors of lumbar provocation discography. Eur Spine J 2006; 15:1473-1484.
57. Laslett M, Oberg B, Aprill CN, McDonald B. Centralization as a predictor of provocation discography results in chronic low back pain, and the influence of disability and distress on diagnostic power. Spine J 2005; 5:370-380.
58. Yrjama M, Tervonen O, Vanharanta H. Ultrasonic imaging of lumbar discs combined with vibration pain provocation compared with discography in the diagnosis of internal anular fissures of the lumbar spine. Spine 1996; 21:571-575.
59. Ohnmeiss DD, Guyer RD, Mason SL. The relation between cervical discographic pain responses and radiographic images. Clin J Pain 2000; 16:1-5.
60. Hancock MJ, Maher CG, Latimer J, Spindler MF, McAuley JH, Laslett M, Bogduk N. Systematic review of tests to identify the disc, SIJ or facet joint as the source of low back pain. Eur Spine J 2007; 16:1539-1550.
61. Linton SJ, Hellsing AL, Hallden K. A population based study of spinal pain among 35-45-year-old individuals. Spine 1998; 23:1457-1463.
62. Wilson PR. Thoracic facet joint syndrome - a clinical entity? Pain Suppl 1987; 4:S87.
63. Dreyfuss P, Tibiletti C, Dreyer SJ. Thoracic zygapophyseal joint pain patterns: A study in normal volunteers. Spine 1994; 19:807-811.
64. Fukui S, Ohseto K, Shiotani M. Patterns of pain induced by distending the thoracic zygapophyseal joints. Reg Anesth 1997; 22:332-336.
65. Manchikanti L, Singh V, Pampati VS, Beyer CD, Damron KS. Evaluation of the prevalence of facet joint pain in chronic thoracic pain. Pain Physician 2002; 5:354-359.
66. Manchikanti L, Boswell MV, Singh V, Pampati VS, Damron KS, Beyer CD. Prevalence of facet joint pain in chronic spinal pain of cervical, thoracic, and lumbar regions. BMC Musculoskelet Disord 2004; 5:15.
67. Manchukonda R, Manchikanti KN, Cash KA, Pampati V, Manchikanti L. Facet joint pain in chronic spinal pain: An evaluation of prevalence and false-positive rate of diagnostic blocks. J Spinal Disord Tech 2007; 20:539-545.
68. Seghal N, Dunbar EE, Shah RV, Colson JD. Systematic review of diagnostic utility of facet (zygapophysial) joint injections in chronic spinal pain: An update. Pain Physician 2007; 10:213-228.
69. Malmivaara A, Videman T, Kuosma E, Troup JDG. Facet joint orientation, facet and costovertebral joint osteoarthrosis, disc degeneration, vertebral body osteophytosis, and Schmorl's nodes in the thoracolumbar junctional region of cadaveric spines. Spine 1987; 12:458-463.
70. Manchikanti L, Singh V, Derby R, Schultz DM, Benyamin RM, Prager JP, Hirsch JA. Reassessment of evidence synthesis of occupational medicine practice guidelines for interventional pain management. Pain Physician 2008; 11:393-482.
71. Manchikanti L, Singh V, Derby R, Helm S, Trescot AM, Staats PS, Prager JP, Hirsch JA. Review of occupational medicine practice guidelines for interventional pain management and potential implications. Pain Physician 2008; 11:271-289.
72. Manchikanti L, Singh V, Helm S, Trescot AM, Hirsch JA. A critical appraisal of 2007 American College of Occupational and Environmental Medicine (ACOEM) practice guidelines for interventional pain management: An independent review utilizing AGREE, AMA, IOM, and other criteria. Pain Physician 2008; 11:291-310.
73. Berg AO, Allan JD. Introducing the third U.S. Preventive Services Task Force. Am J Prev Med 2001; 20:21-35.
74. West S, King V, Carey TS, Lohr KN, McKoy N, Sutton SF, Lux L. Systems to Rate the Strength of Scientific Evidence, Evidence Report, Technology Assessment No. 47. AHRQ Publication No. 02-E016. Rockville, MD: Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality, 2002. www.thecre.com/pdf/ ahrq-system-strength.pdf
75. Reid MC, Lachs MS, Feinstein AR. Use of methodological standards in diagnostic test research. Getting better but still not good. JAMA 1995; 274:645-651.
76. Lijmer JG, Mol BW, Heisterkamp S, Bonsel GJ, Prins MH, van der Meulen JH, Bossuyt PM. Empirical evidence of design-related bias in studies of diagnostic tests. JAMA 1999; 282:1061-1066.
77. Whiting P, Rutjes A, Reitsma J, Bossuyt P, Kleijnen J. The development of QUADAS: A tool for the quality assessment of studies of diagnostic accuracy included in systematic reviews. BMC Med Res Methodol 2003; 3:25.
78. Bossuyt PM, Reitsma JB, Bruns DE, Gatsonis CA, Glasziou PP, Irwig LM, Lijmer JG, Moher D, Rennie D, de Vet HC; Standards for Reporting of Diagnostic Accuracy. Towards complete and accurate reporting of studies of diagnostic accuracy: The STARD initiative. Clin Chem 2003; 49:1-6.
79. Guyatt G, Gutterman D, Baumann MH, Addrizzo-Harris D, Hylek EM, Phillips B, Raskob G, Lewis SZ, Schünemann H. Grading strength of recommendations and quality of evidence in clinical guidelines. Report from an American College of Chest Physicians Task Force. Chest 2006; 129:174-181.
80. Fluke M. To the Editor. Thoracic discography: A safe and reliable technique. Spine 1995; 20:1740.
81. Schellhas KP. In response to thoracic discography: A safe and reliable technique. Spine 1995; 20:1740-1741.
82. Weinstein JN, Walsh TR, Spratt KF, Lehman TR, Sayre H. Lumbar discography: A controlled, prospective study of normal volunteers to determine the false-positive rate. Orthopaedic Transactions 1989; 13:647-648.
83. Deeks JJ. Systematic reviews in health care: Systematic reviews of evaluations of diagnostic and screening tests. BMJ 2001; 323:157-162.
84. Knottnerus JA, van Weel C, Muris JW. Evaluation of diagnostic procedures. BMJ 2002; 324:477-480.
85. Saal JS. General principles of diagnostic testing as related to painful lumbar spine disorders. Spine 2002; 27:2538-2545.
86. Derby R, Kim BJ, Lee SH, Chen Y, Seo KS, Aprill C. Comparison of discographic findings in asymptomatic subject discs and negative discs of chronic LBP patients: Can discography distinguish asymptomatic discs among morphologically abnormal discs? Spine J 2005; 5:389-394.
87. Schellhas KP, Smith MD, Gundry CR, Pollei SR. Cervical discogenic pain. Prospective correction of magnetic resonance imaging and discography in asymptomatic subjects and pain sufferers. Spine 1996; 21:300-311.
88. Klafta LA Jr, Collis JS Jr. The diagnostic inaccuracy of the pain response in cervical discography. Cleveland Clin Q 1969; 36:35-39.
89. Cohen S, Hurley RW. The ability of diagnostic spinal injections to predict surgical outcomes. Pain Med 2007; 105:1756-1775.
90. Derby R, Lee SH, Kim BJ, Chen Y, Aprill C, Bogduk N. Pressure-controlled lumbar discography in volunteers without low back symptoms. Pain Med 2005; 6:213-221.
91. Carragee EJ, Alamin TF, Carragee JM. Low-pressure positive discography in subjects asymptomatic of significant low back pain illness. Spine 2006; 31:505-509.
92. Carragee EJ, Chen Y, Tanner CM, Hayward C, Rossi M, Hagle C. Can discography cause long-term back symptoms in previously asymptomatic subjects? Spine 2000; 25:1803-1808.
93. Carragee EJ, Barcohana B, Alamin T, van den Haak E. Prospective controlled study of the development of lower back pain in previously asymptomatic subjects undergoing experimental discography. Spine 2004; 29:1112-1117.
94. Derby R. Lumbar discometry. Newsletter of International Spine Injection Society 1993; 1:8-17.
95. Derby R, Howard MW, Grant JM, Lettice JJ, Van Peteghem PK, Ryan DP. The ability of pressure-controlled discography to predict surgical and nonsurgical outcomes. Spine 1999; 24:364-371; discussion 371-362.
96. Shin D, Kim H, Jung J, Sin D, Lee J. Diagnostic relevance of pressure-controlled discography. J Korean Med Sci 2006; 21:911-916.
97. Manchikanti L, Singh V, Pampati VS, Fellows B, Beyer C, Damron K, Cash KA. Provocative discography in low back pain patients with or without somatization disorder: A randomized prospective evaluation. Pain Physician 2001; 4:227-239.
98. Fagan A, Moore R, Vernon Roberts B, Blumbergs P, Fraser R. The innervation of the intervertebral disc: A quantitative analysis. Spine 2003; 28:2570-2576.
99. Ashton IK, Roberts S, Jaffray DC, Polak JM, Eisenstein SM. Neuropeptides in the human intervertebral disc. J Orthop Res 1994; 12:186-192.
100. Roofe PG. Innervation of annulus fibrosis and posterior longitudinal ligament. Arch Neurol Psych 1940; 44:100-103.
101. Malinsky J. The ontogenetic development of nerve trigeminations in the intervertebral discs of man. Acta Anat 1959; 38:96-113.
102. Roberts S, Eisenstein SM, Menage J, Evans EH, Ashton IK. Mechanoreceptors in intervertebral discs. Spine 1995; 24:2645-2651.
103. Freemont AJ, Watkins A, Le Maitre C, Baird P, Jeziorska M, Knight MT, Ross ER, O'Brien JP, Hoyland JA. Nerve growth factor expression and innervation of the painful intervertebral disc. J Pathol 2002; 197:286-292.
104. Burke JG, G Watson RW, Conhyea D, McCormack D, Dowling FE, Walsh MG, Fitzpatrick JM. Human nucleus pulposus can respond to a pro-inflammatory stimulus. Spine 2003; 28:2685-2693.
105. Stilwell DL. The nerve supply of the vertebral column and its associated structures in the monkey. Anat Rec 1956; 125:139-169.
106. Kuslich SD, Ulstrom CL, Michael CJ. The tissue origin of low back pain and sciatica: A report of pain response to tissue stimulation during operation on the lumbar spine using local anesthesia. Orthop Clin North Am 1991; 22:181-187.