Fearing a non-existing Minotaur? The ethical challenges of research on cytoplasmic hybrid embryos

Journal of Medical Ethics

Volumn 34, Issue 11, 2008, Pages 821-825

  Camporesi, S ^a,c,d   Boniolo, G ^a,b,c  

^a European School of Molecular Medicine SEMM   (Italy)

^b FIRC INSTITUTE OF MOLECULAR ONCOLOGY   (Italy)

^c UNIVERSITY OF MILAN   (Italy)

^d c/o IFOM IEO Campus ^*  (Italy)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

ANIMAL EXPERIMENT; BIOETHICS; CHIMERA; ECONOMICS; EMBRYO RESEARCH; ETHICS; HUMAN; REVIEW;

ANIMAL EXPERIMENTATION; BIOETHICAL ISSUES; CHIMERA; EMBRYO RESEARCH; HUMANS; RESEARCH EMBRYO CREATION; WEDGE ARGUMENT;

EID: 57149129941     PISSN: 03066800     EISSN: 14734257     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1136/jme.2008.024877     Document Type: Review

References (41)

1. Human Fertilisation and Embryo Authority. HFEA statement on its decision regarding hybrid embryos. 5 Sep 2007. http://www.hfea.gov.uk/en/1581. html (accessed 24 Sep 2008).
2. Oxford English Dictionary definition for chimera. http://www.askoxford.com/concise_oed/chimera?view=uk (accessed 24 Sep 2008).
3. Tecirlioglu RT, Guo J, Trounson AO, et al. Interspecies somatic cell nuclear transfer and preliminary data for horse-cow/mouse iSCNT. Stem Cell Rev 2006;2:277-87.
4. Malan V, Vekemans M, Turleau C, et al. Chimera and other fertilization errors. Clin Genet 2006;70:363-73.
5. Eggan K, Akutsu H, Loring J, et al. Hybrid vigor, fetal overgrowth, and viability of mice derived by nuclear cloning and tetraploid embryo complementation. PNAS 2001;98:6209-14.
6. Behringer RB. Human-animal chimeras in biomedical research. Cell stem cell 2007;1:259-62.
7. Lensch WM, Schlaeger MT, Zon LI, et al. Teratoma formation assays with human embryonic stem cells: a rationale for one type of human-animal chimera. Cell Stem Cell 2007;1:253-8.
8. Hyun I, Taylor P, Testa G, et al. Ethical standards for human to animal experiments in stem cell research. Cell Stem Cell 2007;1:159-63.
9. Short RV. The contribution of the mule to scientific thought. J Reprod Fertil 1975;23:359-64.
10. Department of Health. Human Tissue and Embryo (Draft) Bill. 17 May 2007:98-9. http://www.dh.gov.uk/en/Publicationsandstatistics/Publications/ PublicationsLegislation/DH_074718 (accessed 24 Sep 2008).
11. Wilmut I, Schnieke AE, McWhir J, et al. Viable offspring derived from fetal and adult mammalian cells. Nature 1997;385:810- 3.
12. Beyhan Z, Iager AE, Cibelli JB. Interspecies nuclear transfer: implications for embryonic stem cell biology. Cell Stem Cell 2007;1:502-12.
13. Rossant J. Stem cells and lineage development in the mammalian blastocyst. Reprod Fertil Dev 2007;19:111-18.
14. McLaren A. Free range eggs? Science 2007;316:339.
15. Chen Y, He ZX, Liu A, et al. Embryonic stem cells generated by nuclear transfer of human somatic nuclei into rabbit oocytes. Cell Res 2003;13:251-63.
16. Illmensee K, Levanduski M, Zavos PM. Evaluation of the embryonic preimplantation potential of human adult somatic cells via an embryo interspecies bioassay using bovine oocytes. Fertil Steril 2006;85:1248-60.
17. Minger S. Interspecies SCNT-derived human embryos - a new way forward for regenerative medicine. Regenerative Med 2007;2:103-6.
18. Byrne JA, Pederson DA, Mitalipov SM, et al. Producing primate embryonic stem cells by somatic cell nuclear transfer. Nature 2007;450:497-502.
19. Human Fertilisation and Embryo Authority. HFEA Statement on licensing of applications to carry out research using human-animal cytoplasmic hybrid embryos. 17 January 2008. http://www.hfea.gov.uk/en/1640.html (accessed 24 Sep 2008).
20. Human Fertilisation and Embryo Authority. HFEA license Committee for Lyle Armstrong's group. 28 November 2007 http://www.hfea.gov.uk/docs/ HFEA_Licence_Committee_minutes_for_R0179_Newcastle_-
21. Human Fertilisation and Embryo Authority. HFEA license Committee for Stephen Minger's group. 28 November 2007. http://www.hfea.gov.uk/docs/ HFEA_Licence_Committee_minutes_for_R0180_Kings_-_November_2007_and_January_2008. pdf (accessed 24 Sep 2008).
22. Hall VJ, Compton D, Stoijkovic P, et al. Developmental competence of human in vitro aged oocytes as host cells for nuclear transfer. Human Reprod 2007;22:52-62.
23. Lavoir MC, Weier J, Conaghan J, et al. Poor development of human nuclear transfer embryos using failed fertilized oocytes. Reprod Biomed Online 2005;11:740-4.
24. Egli D, Rosains J, Birkhoff G, et al. Developmental reprogramming after chromosome transfer into mitotic mouse zygotes. Nature 2007;447:679-85.
25. Takahashi K, Yamanaka S. Induction of pluripotent stem cells from mouse embryonic and adult fibroblast cultures by defined factors. Cell 2006;126:663-76.
26. Takahashi K, Tanabe K, Ohnuki M, et al. Induction of pluripotent stem cells from adult human fibroblasts by defined factors. Cell 2007;131:861-72.
27. Yu J, Vodyanik MA, Smuga-Otto K, et al. Induced pluripotent stem cell lines derived from human somatic cells. Science 2007;318:1917-20.
28. Gottweis H, Minger S. iPS cells and the politics of promise. Nat Biotechnol 2008;26:271-2.
29. Camporesi S. The context of embryonic development and its ethical relevance. Biotechn J 2007;2:1147-53.
30. Cervera RP, Stojkovic M. Human embryonic stem cell derivation and nuclear transfer: impact on regenerative therapeutics and drug discovery. Clin Pharmacol Ther 2007;82:310-5.
31. Beyhan Z, Iager AE, Cibelli JB. Interspecies nuclear transfer: implications for embryonic stem cell biology. Cell Stem Cell 2007;1:502-12.
32. Practice Committee of the American Society for Reproductive Medicine. Ovarian hyperstimulation syndrome. Fertil Steril 2006;86(5 Suppl):178-83.
33. The Ethics Committee of the American Society for Reproductive Medicine. Financial incentives in recruitment of oocyte donors. Fertil Steril 2000;74:216-20.
34. Magnus D, Cho MK. Issues in oocyte donation for stem cell research. Science 2005;308:1747-8.
35. Nussbaum MC. Hiding from humanity. Disgust, shame, and the law. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2004.
36. Boniolo G. Methodological hints concerning the ethical and social implications of protocells. In: Bedau MA, Parke E, eds. The social and ethical implications of the creation of living technology. Cambridge (Mass.): MIT Press, 2008. In press.
37. Boniolo G, Valentini S. Vaguennes, Kant, and topology. A study of formal epistemology. J Phil Logic 2008;37:141-68.
38. Bortolotti L, Harris H. Disability, enhancement and the harm-benefit continuum. in: Spencer J, Pedain A, eds. Freedom and responsibility in reproductive choice. Oxford and Oregon: Hart Publishing, 2006:31-49.
39. Gould SJ. Non moral nature. Nat Hist 1982;91:19-26.
40. Putnam H. Ethics without ontology. Harvard: Harvard University Press, 2004.
41. Editorial. Defining 'natural'. Visceral reactions to an act should not distract from the real ethical issues. Nature 2008;452:665-6. | doi:10.1038/452665b.