Optimization of experimental design parameters for high-throughput chromatin immunoprecipitation studies

Nucleic Acids Research

Volumn 36, Issue 21, 2008, Pages

  Ponzielli, Romina ^a   Boutros, Paul C ^a,b   Katz, Sigal ^a   Stojanova, Angelina ^a,b   Hanley, Adam P ^a,b   Khosravi, Fereshteh ^a   Bros, Christina ^a   Jurisica, Igor ^a,b,c   Penn, Linda Z ^a,b  

^a PRINCESS MARGARET HOSPITAL   (Canada)

^b UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO   (Canada)

^c UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO   (Canada)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

ANTIBODY; DYE; MYC PROTEIN;

ARTICLE; CELL STRAIN HL 60; CHROMATIN IMMUNOPRECIPITATION; CONTROLLED STUDY; EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN; GENE REGULATORY NETWORK; GENETIC TRANSCRIPTION; GENOMICS; HIGH THROUGHPUT SCREENING; HUMAN; HUMAN CELL; MICROARRAY ANALYSIS; PRIORITY JOURNAL; PROCESS OPTIMIZATION; SENSITIVITY AND SPECIFICITY; SYSTEMATIC ERROR; VALIDATION PROCESS; DNA MICROARRAY; IMMUNOLOGY; METABOLISM; METHODOLOGY; POLYMERASE CHAIN REACTION; REGULATORY SEQUENCE; VALIDATION STUDY;

ANTIBODIES; CHROMATIN IMMUNOPRECIPITATION; HL-60 CELLS; HUMANS; OLIGONUCLEOTIDE ARRAY SEQUENCE ANALYSIS; POLYMERASE CHAIN REACTION; PROTO-ONCOGENE PROTEINS C-MYC; REGULATORY ELEMENTS, TRANSCRIPTIONAL;

EID: 57149089456     PISSN: 03051048     EISSN: 13624962     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1093/nar/gkn735     Document Type: Article

References (61)

1. Iyer,V.R., Horak,C.E., Scafe,C.S., Botstein,D., Snyder,M. and Brown,P.O. (2001) Genomic binding sites of the yeast cell-cycle transcription factors SBF and MBF. Nature, 409, 533-538.
2. Lieb,J.D., Liu,X., Botstein,D. and Brown,P.O. (2001) Promoter-specific binding of Rap1 revealed by genome-wide maps of protein-DNA association. Nat. Genet., 28, 327-334.
3. Lee,T.I., Rinaldi,N.J., Robert,F., Odom,D.T., Bar-Joseph,Z., Gerber,G.K., Hannett,N.M., Harbison,C.T., Thompson,C.M., Simon,I. et al. (2002) Transcriptional regulatory networks in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Science, 298, 799-804.
4. Ren,B., Robert,F., Wyrick,J.J., Aparicio,O., Jennings,E.G., Simon,I., Zeitlinger,J., Schreiber,J., Hannett,N., Kanin,E. et al. (2000) Genome-wide location and function of DNA binding proteins. Science 290, 2306-2309.
5. Bieda,M., Xu,X., Singer,M.A., Green,R. and Farnham,P.J. (2006) Unbiased location analysis of E2F1-binding sites suggests a widespread role for E2F1 in the human genome. Genome Res., 16, 595-605.
6. Carroll,J.S., Liu,X.S., Brodsky,A.S., Li,W., Meyer,C.A., Szary,A.J., Eeckhoute,J., Shao,W., Hestermann,E.V., Geistlinger,T.R. et al. (2005) Chromosome-wide mapping of estrogen receptor binding reveals long-range regulation requiring the forkhead protein FoxA1. Cell, 122, 33-43.
7. Cheng,A.S., Jin,V.X., Fan,M., Smith,L.T., Liyanarachchi,S., Yan,P.S., Leu,Y.W., Chan,M.W., Plass,C., Nephew,K.P. et al. (2006) Combinatorial analysis of transcription factor partners reveals recruitment of c-MYC to estrogen receptor-alpha responsive promoters. Mol. Cell, 21, 393-404.
8. Fernandez,P.C., Frank,S.R., Wang,L., Schroeder,M., Liu,S., Greene,J., Cocito,A. and Amati,B. (2003) Genomic targets of the human c-Myc protein. Genes Dev., 17, 1115-1129.
9. Horak,C.E., Mahajan,M.C., Luscombe,N.M., Gerstein,M., Weissman,S.M. and Snyder,M. (2002) GATA-1 binding sites mapped in the beta-globin locus by using mammalian chIp-chip analysis. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA, 99, 2924-2929.
10. Kirmizis,A., Bartley,S.M., Kuzmichev,A., Margueron,R., Reinberg,D., Green,R. and Farnham,P.J. (2004) Silencing of human polycomb target genes is associated with methylation of histone H3 Lys 27. Genes Dev. 18, 1592-1605.
11. Li,Z., Van Calcar,S., Qu,C., Cavenee,W.K., Zhang,M.Q. and Ren,B. (2003) A global transcriptional regulatory role for c-Myc in Burkitt's lymphoma cells. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA, 100, 8164-8169.
12. Mao,D.Y., Watson,J.D., Yan,P.S., Barsyte-Lovejoy,D., Khosravi,F., Wong,W.W., Farnham,P.J., Huang,T.H. and Penn,L.Z. (2003) Analysis of Myc bound loci identified by CpG island arrays shows that Max is essential for Myc-dependent repression. Curr. Biol., 13, 882-886.
13. Pokholok,D.K., Zeitlinger,J., Hannett,N.M., Reynolds,D.B. and Young,R.A. (2006) Activated signal transduction kinases frequently occupy target genes. Science, 313, 533-536.
14. Squazzo,S.L., O'Geen,H., Komashko,V.M., Krig,S.R., Jin,V.X., Jang,S.W., Margueron,R., Reinberg,D., Green,R. and Farnham,P.J. (2006) Suz12 binds to silenced regions of the genome in a cell-type-specific manner. Genome Res., 16, 890-900.
15. Weinmann,A.S., Yan,P.S., Oberley,M.J., Huang,T.H. and Farnham,P.J. (2002) Isolating human transcription factor targets by coupling chromatin immunoprecipitation and CpG island microarray analysis. Genes Dev., 16, 235-244.
16. Ishkanian,A.S., Malloff,C.A., Watson,S.K., DeLeeuw,R.J., Chi,B., Coe,B.P., Snijders,A., Albertson,D.G., Pinkel,D., Marra,M.A. et al. (2004) A tiling resolution DNA microarray with complete coverage of the human genome. Nat. Genet., 36, 299-303.
17. Takayama,K., Kaneshiro,K., Tsutsumi,S., Horie-Inoue,K., Ikeda,K., Urano,T., Ijichi,N., Ouchi,Y., Shirahige,K., Aburatani,H. et al. (2007) Identification of novel androgen response genes in prostate cancer cells by coupling chromatin immunoprecipitation and genomic microarray analysis. Oncogene, 26, 4453-4463.
18. Guo,Q.M., Malek,R.L., Kim,S., Chiao,C., He,M., Ruffy,M., Sanka,K., Lee,N.H., Dang,C.V. and Liu,E.T. (2000) Identification of c-myc responsive genes using rat cDNA microarray. Cancer Res., 60, 5922-5928.
19. Kannan,K., Kaminski,N., Rechavi,G., Jakob-Hirsch,J., Amariglio,N. and Givol,D. (2001) DNA microarray analysis of genes involved in p53 mediated apoptosis: Activation of Apaf-1. Oncogene, 20, 3449-3455.
20. O'Connell,B.C., Cheung,A.F., Simkevich,C.P., Tam,W., Ren,X., Mateyak,M.K. and Sedivy,J.M. (2003) A large scale genetic analysis of c-Myc-regulated gene expression patterns. J. Biol. Chem., 278 12563-12573.
21. Stanelle,J., Stiewe,T., Theseling,C.C., Peter,M. and Putzer,B.M. (2002) Gene expression changes in response to E2F1 activation. Nucleic Acids Res., 30, 1859-1867.
22. Watson,J.D., Oster,S.K., Shago,M., Khosravi,F. and Penn,L.Z. (2002) Identifying genes regulated in a Myc-dependent manner. J. Biol. Chem. 277, 36921-36930.
23. Johnson,D.S., Li,W., Gordon,D.B., Bhattacharjee,A., Curry,B., Ghosh,J., Brizuela,L., Carroll,J.S., Brown,M., Flicek,P. et al. (2008) Systematic evaluation of variability in ChIP-chip experiments using predefined DNA targets. Genome Res., 18, 393-403.
24. Oberley,M.J. and Farnham,P.J. (2003) Probing chromatin immunoprecipitates with CpG-island microarrays to identify genomic sites occupied by DNA-binding proteins. Methods Enzymol., 371, 577-596.
25. Ren,B. and Dynlacht,B.D. (2004) Use of chromatin immunoprecipitation assays in genome-wide location analysis of mammalian transcription factors. Methods Enzymol., 376, 304-315.
26. Oberley,M.J., Tsao,J., Yau,P. and Farnham,P.J. (2004) High-throughput screening of chromatin immunoprecipitates using CpG-island microarrays. Methods Enzymol., 376, 315-334.
27. Paris,J., Virtanen,C., Lu,Z. and Takahashi,M. (2004) Identification of MEF2-regulated genes during muscle differentiation. Physiol. Genomics 20, 143-151.
28. Liu,C.L., Schreiber,S.L. and Bernstein,B.E. (2003) Development and validation of a T7 based linear amplification for genomic DNA. BMC Genomics, 4, 19.
29. O'Geen,H., Nicolet,C.M., Blahnik,K., Green,R. and Farnham,P.J. (2006) Comparison of sample preparation methods for ChIP-chip assays. Biotechniques, 41, 577-580.
30. Bammler,T., Beyer,R.P., Bhattacharya,S., Boorman,G.A., Boyles,A., Bradford,B.U., Bumgarner,R.E., Bushel,P.R., Chaturvedi,K., Choi,D. et al. (2005) Standardizing global gene expression analysis between laboratories and across platforms. Nat. Methods, 2, 351-356.
31. Guo,L., Lobenhofer,E.K., Wang,C., Shippy,R., Harris,S.C., Zhang,L., Mei,N., Chen,T., Herman,D., Goodsaid,F.M. et al. (2006) Rat toxicogenomic study reveals analytical consistency across microarray platforms. Nat. Biotechnol., 24, 1162-1169.
32. Shippy,R., Fulmer-Smentek,S., Jensen,R.V., Jones,W.D., Wolber,P.K., Johnson,C.D., Pine,P.S., Boysen,C., Guo,X., Chudin,E. et al. (2006) Using RNA sample titrations to assess microarray platform performance and normalization techniques. Nat. Biotechnol., 24 1123-1131.
33. Shi,L., Reid,L.H., Jones,W.D., Shippy,R., Warrington,J.A., Baker,S.C., Collins,P.J., de Longueville,F., Kawasaki,E.S., Lee,K.Y. et al. (2006) The MicroArray Quality Control (MAQC) project shows inter- and intraplatform reproducibility of gene expression measurements. Nat. Biotechnol., 24, 1151-1161.
34. Patterson,T.A., Lobenhofer,E.K., Fulmer-Smentek,S.B., Collins,P.J., Chu,T.M., Bao,W., Fang,H., Kawasaki,E.S., Hager,J., Tikhonova,I.R. et al. (2006) Performance comparison of one-color and two-color platforms within the MicroArray Quality Control (MAQC) project. Nat. Biotechnol., 24, 1140-1150.
35. Tong,W., Lucas,A.B., Shippy,R., Fan,X., Fang,H., Hong,H., Orr,M.S., Chu,T.M., Guo,X., Collins,P.J. et al. (2006) Evaluation of external RNA controls for the assessment of microarray performance. Nat. Biotechnol., 24, 1132-1139.
36. Canales,R.D., Luo,Y., Willey,J.C., Austermiller,B., Barbacioru,C.C., Boysen,C., Hunkapiller,K., Jensen,R.V., Knight,C.R., Lee,K.Y. et al. (2006) Evaluation of DNA microarray results with quantitative gene expression platforms. Nat. Biotechnol., 24, 1115-1122.
37. Wei,C., Li,J. and Bumgarner,R.E. (2004) Sample size for detecting differentially expressed genes in microarray experiments. BMC Genomics, 5, 87.
38. Heisler,L.E., Torti,D., Boutros,P.C., Watson,J., Chan,C., Winegarden,N., Takahashi,M., Yau,P., Huang,T.H., Farnham,P.J. et al. (2005) CpG Island microarray probe sequences derived from a physical library are representative of CpG Islands annotated on the human genome. Nucleic Acids Res., 33, 2952-2961.
39. Gentleman,R.C., Carey,V.J., Bates,D.M., Bolstad,B., Dettling,M., Dudoit,S., Ellis,B., Gautier,L., Ge,Y., Gentry,J. et al. (2004) Bioconductor: Open software development for computational biology and bioinformatics. Genome Biol., 5, R80.
40. Smyth,G.K. (2004) Linear models and empirical bayes methods for assessing differential expression in microarray experiments. Stat. Appl. Genet. Mol. Biol., 3, Article3.
41. Storey,J.D. and Tibshirani,R. (2003) Statistical significance for genomewide studies. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA, 100, 9440-9445.
42. Stajich,J.E., Block,D., Boulez,K., Brenner,S.E., Chervitz,S.A., Dagdigian,C., Fuellen,G., Gilbert,J.G., Korf,I., Lapp,H. et al. (2002) The Bioperl toolkit: Perl modules for the life sciences. Genome Res., 12, 1611-1618.
43. Tatusova,T.A. and Madden,T.L. (1999) BLAST 2 Sequences, a new tool for comparing protein and nucleotide sequences. FEMS Microbiol. Lett., 174, 247-250.
44. Karolchik,D., Baertsch,R., Diekhans,M., Furey,T.S., Hinrichs,A., Lu,Y.T., Roskin,K.M., Schwartz,M., Sugnet,C.W., Thomas,D.J. et al. (2003) The UCSC Genome Browser Database. Nucleic Acids Res., 31 51-54.
45. Altschul,S.F., Madden,T.L., Schaffer,A.A., Zhang,J., Zhang,Z., Miller,W. and Lipman,D.J. (1997) Gapped BLAST and PSI-BLAST: A new generation of protein database search programs. Nucleic Acids Res., 25, 3389-3402.
46. Birnie,G.D. (1988) The HL60 cell line: A model system for studying human myeloid cell differentiation. Br. J. Cancer Suppl, 9, 41-45.
47. Branham,W.S., Melvin,C.D., Han,T., Desai,V.G., Moland,C.L., Scully,A.T. and Fuscoe,J.C. (2007) Elimination of laboratory ozone leads to a dramatic improvement in the reproducibility of microarray gene expression measurements. BMC Biotechnol., 7, 8.
48. Fare,T.L., Coffey,E.M., Dai,H., He,Y.D., Kessler,D.A., Kilian,K.A., Koch,J.E., LeProust,E., Marton,M.J., Meyer,M.R. et al. (2003) Effects of atmospheric ozone on microarray data quality. Anal. Chem. 75, 4672-4675.
49. Bachtiary,B., Boutros,P.C., Pintilie,M., Shi,W., Bastianutto,C., Li,J.H., Schwock,J., Zhang,W., Penn,L.Z., Jurisica,I. et al. (2006) Gene expression profiling in cervical cancer: An exploration of intratumor heterogeneity. Clin. Cancer Res., 12, 5632-5640.
50. Viganò,M.A., Lamartine,J., Testoni,B., Merico,D., Alotto,D., Castagnoli,C., Robert,A., Candi,E., Melino,G., Gidrol,X., et al. (2006) New p63 targets in keratinocytes identified by a genome-wide approach. EMBO J., 25, 5105-5116.
51. Zeller,K.I., Jegga,A.G., Aronow,B.J., O'Donnell,K.A. and Dang,C.V. (2003) An integrated database of genes responsive to the Myc oncogenic transcription factor: Identification of direct genomic targets. Genome Biol., 4, R69.
52. Krieg,A.J., Hammond,E.M. and Giaccia,A.J. (2006) Functional analysis of p53 binding under differential stresses. Mol. Cell Biol., 26 7030-7045.
53. Semeralul,M.O., Boutros,P.C., Likhodi,O., Okey,A.B., Van Tol,H.H. and Wong,A.H. (2006) Microarray analysis of the developing cortex. J. Neurobiol., 66, 1646-1658.
54. Dobbin,K., Shih,J.H. and Simon,R. (2003) Statistical design of reverse dye microarrays. Bioinformatics, 19, 803-810.
55. Dobbin,K.K., Kawasaki,E.S., Petersen,D.W. and Simon,R.M. (2005) Characterizing dye bias in microarray experiments. Bioinformatics, 21, 2430-2437.
56. He,Y.D., Dai,H., Schadt,E.E., Cavet,G., Edwards,S.W., Stepaniants,S.B., Duenwald,S., Kleinhanz,R., Jones,A.R., Shoemaker,D.D. et al. (2003) Microarray standard data set and figures of merit for comparing data processing methods and experiment designs. Bioinformatics, 19, 956-965.
57. Dafforn,A., Chen,P., Deng,G., Herrler,M., Iglehart,D., Koritala,S., Lato,S., Pillarisetty,S., Purohit,R., Wang,M. et al. (2004) Linear mRNA amplification from as little as 5 ng total RNA for global gene expression analysis. Biotechniques, 37, 854-857.
58. Marko,N.F., Frank,B., Quackenbush,J. and Lee,N.H. (2005) A robust method for the amplification of RNA in the sense orientation. BMC Genomics 6, 27.
59. Pan,W., Lin,J. and Le,C.T. (2002) How many replicates of arrays are required to detect gene expression changes in microarray experiments? A mixture model approach. Genome Biol., 3, research0022.
60. Peixoto,B.R., Vencio,R.Z., Egidio,C.M., Mota-Vieira,L., Verjovski-Almeida,S. and Reis,E.M. (2006) Evaluation of reference-based two-color methods for measurement of gene expression ratios using spotted cDNA microarrays. BMC Genomics, 7, 35.
61. Shih,J.H., Michalowska,A.M., Dobbin,K., Ye,Y., Qiu,T.H. and Green,J.E. (2004) Effects of pooling mRNA in microarray class comparisons. Bioinformatics, 20, 3318-3325.