Ideological toxicology: Invalid logic, science, ethics about low-dose pollution

Human and Experimental Toxicology

Volumn 27, Issue 8, 2008, Pages 647-657

  Shrader Frechette, K ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF NOTRE DAME   (United States)

Author keywords

Consent; Dose response curve; Ethics; Hormesis; Low dose effect; Regulation

Indexed keywords

ETHICS; HEALTH STATUS; HOMEOSTASIS; HORMESIS; HUMAN; POPULATION; PRIORITY JOURNAL; REVIEW; RISK ASSESSMENT; TOXICOLOGY;

ANIMALS; DOSE-RESPONSE RELATIONSHIP, DRUG; ENVIRONMENTAL POLLUTANTS; ENVIRONMENTAL POLLUTION; HEALTH POLICY; HUMANS; REFERENCE STANDARDS; TOXICOLOGY; TOXINS, BIOLOGICAL;

EID: 57049126277     PISSN: 09603271     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1177/0960327108098491     Document Type: Review

References (49)

1. 1 National Research Council. Intentional human dosing studies for EPA regulatory purposes. Washington, DC: National Academy Press; 2004. pp. 110, 112-113, 3.
2. Calabrese EJ. Baldwin LA. Hormesis: U-shaped dose responses and their centrality in toxicology. Trends Pharmacol Sci 2001 ; 22: 285 - 291.
3. Thayer KA. Melnick R. Burns K. Davis D. Huff J. Fundamental flaws of hormesis for public health decisions. Environ Health Perspect 2005 ; 113: 1272 - 1275.
4. Cook, R, Calabrese, EJ. The importance of hormesis to public health. Environ Health Perspect 2006; 114: 1631-1635; online 7-10-06 at http://www.ehponline.org/members/2006/8606/8606.pdf; [accessed 11.22.06].
5. Calabrese EJ. Baldwin LA. Hormesis: the dose-response revolution. Annu Rev Pharmacol Toxicol 2003 ; 43: 175 - 197.
6. Calabrese EJ. Baldwin LA. Defining hormesis. Hum Exp Toxicol 2002 ; 21: 91 - 97.
7. Calabrese EJ. Historical blunders: how toxicology got the dose-response relationship half right. Cell Mol Biol 2005 ; 51: 643 - 654.
8. Axelrod D. Burns K. Davis D. Von Larebeke N. Hormesis - an inappropriate extrapolation from the specific to the universal. Int J Occup Environ Health 2004 ; 10: 335 - 339.
9. 9 Scientific Advisory Board and FIFRA Scientific Advisory Panel. Comments on the use of data from testing of human subjects, EPA-SAB-EC-00-017. Washington, DC: EPA ; 2000.
10. Kociba RJ. Keyes DG. Beyer JE. Results of a two-year chronic toxicity and oncogenicity study of 2,3,7,8-tetrachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin in rats. Toxicol Appl Pharmacol 1978 ; 46: 279 - 303.
11. Mead MN. Sour finding on popular sweetener. Environ Health Perspect 2006 ; 114: 739 - 785 [accessed 11.22.06] http://www.ehponline.org/docs/2006/114-3/ ss.html.
12. Reir SE. Martin DC. Bowman RE. Domowski WP. Becker JL. Endometriosis in rhesus monkeys (Macaca mulatta) following chronic exposure to 2,3,7,8-tetrachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin. Fundam Appl Toxicol 1993 ; 21: 433 - 441.
13. Calabrese EJ. Baldwin LA. Toxicology rethinks its central belief. Nature 2003 ; 421: 691 - 692.
14. 14 US National Research Council. Pesticides in the diets of infants and children. Washington, DC: National Academy Press ; 1993.
15. 15 Shrader-Frechette KS. Risk and rationality. Berkeley: University of California Press ; 1991. p. 100 - 145.
16. 16 Shrader-Frechette KS. Ethics of scientific research. New York: Rowman and Littlefield; 1994. p. 9-12, 23-118.
17. Association of Schools of Public Health. Ethics and public health. In: B Jennings. J Kahn. A Mastroianni. L Parker., (eds), Washington, DC: ASPH ; 2003.
18. 18 Hume D. A treatise of human nature. Oxford: Clarendon Press ; 1975.
19. 19 Aristotle. Nicomachean Ethics [Irwin, T, Trans.]. Indianapolis: Hackett ; 1985.
20. Calabrese EJ. Cook R. Hormesis: how it could affect the risk assessment process. BELLE 2005 ; 12: 22 - 27.
21. Calabrese EJ. Baldwin LA. Reevaluation of the fundamental dose: response relationship. BioScience 1999 ; 49: 725 - 732.
22. Lang L. Strange brew: assessing risk of chemical mixtures. Environ Health Perspect 1995 ; 103: 142 - 145 [accessed 11.22.06] http://www.ehponline.org/ docs/1995/103-2/focus.html.
23. Calabrese EJ. Baldwin LA. Radiation hormesis. Hum Exp Toxicol 2000 ; 19: 2.
24. Calabrese EJ. Baldwin LA. Scientific foundations of hormesis. Crit Rev Toxicol 2001 ; 31: 351 - 624.
25. 25 National Research Council. Health risks from exposure to low levels of ionizing radiation, BEIR VII. Washington, DC: National Academy Press ; 2005.
26. Shrader-Frechette KS. Using a thought experiment to clarify a radiobiological controversy. Synthese 2001 ; 128: 319 - 342.
27. 27 Faden R. Beauchamp T. A history and theory of informed consent. New York: Oxford University Press ; 1986.
28. 28 Beauchamp T. Childress J. Principles of biomedical ethics. New York: Oxford University Press ; 1989.
29. 29 Shrader-Frechette KS. Taking action, saving lives: our duties to protect environmental and public health. New York: Oxford University Press ; 2007.
30. 30 Krimsky S. Science in the private interest. New York: Rowman and Littlefield ; 2003.
31. Oleskey C. Fleishman A. Goldman LR. Pesticide testing in humans. Environ Health Perspect 2004 ; 112: 114 - 119.
32. Lockwood AH. Human testing of pesticides. Am J Public Health 2004 ; 94: 1908 - 1915.
33. 33 US National Research Council. Health implications of perchlorate ingestion. Washington, DC: National Academy Press ; 2005.
34. US Congress, House of Representatives, Committee on Energy and Commerce.. Department of defense attempts to exempt itself from environmental laws and regulations. Washington, DC: CEC; 2006. Available at http://www.house.gov/ commerce_democrats/DODexemptions/dod.shtml; [accessed 11.22.06].
35. 35 US General Accounting Office. Military munitions: DOD needs to develop a comprehensive approach for cleaning up contaminated sites, GAO-04-147. Washington, DC: GAO ; 2003.
36. 36 Environmental Working Group. Rocket fuel in drinking water: perchlorate pollution spreading nationwide. Washington, DC: EWG; 2006. Available at http://www.ewg.org/reports/rocketwater/; [accessed 11.22.06].
37. Esler, P. Pollution cleanups pit Pentagon against regulators. USA Today 10-14-04, Available at http://www.usatoday.com/news/nation/2004-10-14- coverpollution_x.htm; [accessed 11.22.06].
38. Clark R. Control of low-level radiation exposure: time for a change. J Radiol Prot 1999 ; 19: 107 - 115.
39. Calabrese, EJ, Baldwin, LA. Chemical hormesis: scientific foundations, unpublished final report of the Texas Institute for Advancement of Chemical Technology, 1998. http://cheweb.tamu.edu/tiact/index_files/Page536.htm; [accessed 11.22.06].
40. Calabrese EJ. Baldwin LA. Holland C. Hormesis: a highly generalizable and reproducible phenomenon with important implications for risk assessment. Risk Anal 1999 ; 19: 261 - 281.
41. Calabrese, EJ. Faculty. University of Massachusetts Intercampus Graduate School of Marine Sciences and Technology, 2006, available at http://www.umassmarine.net/faculty/showprofs.cfm?prof_ID=30 and accessed 11-22-06. This was the most up-to-date resume found on the internet for Dr Calabrese, and it was copyrighted 2006, by his employer, as an "official page/publication of the University of Massachusetts. © 2006"; this same resume (with the same material), accessed January 30, 2007, appears again as an "official page/publication of the University of Massachusetts. © 2007." Although an older, more complete resume ("Edward J. Calabrese, Ph.D., Curriculum Vitae, April 2002") appears on the University of Massachusetts website, with a 2002 date, at http://people.umass.edu/nrephc/ EJCCVApril02.pdf (accessed 30 January 2007), it has more than $3 million in grants/contracts whose sources of funding are not named; some named sources include Exxon, ARCO, Dow Chemical, Reynolds, Rohm and Haas. Even an out-of-date or shortened resume should not selectively reveal funding sources, both because readers will be misled; because readers expect that state-university employees, in particular, reveal their funding sources; and because most science-ethics groups endorse full disclosure.
42. World Health Organization. Effects of air pollution on children's health. Bonn: WHO; 2005. p. 144, 155.
43. Health and Human Services and National Cancer Institute. Health status objectives. Cancer 1991 ; 16: 416 - 440.
44. 44 McGinnis JM. Attributable risk in practice. In: Institute of Medicine, (ed), Estimating the contributions of lifestyle-related factors to preventable death. Washington, DC: National Academy Press; 2005. p. 17-19.
45. Lichtenstein P. Holm N. Verkasalo P. Iliadou A. Kaprio J. Koskenvuo M. Environmental and heritable factors in the causation of cancer. N Engl J Med 2002 ; 343: 78 - 85.
46. Thayer KA. Melnick R. Huff J. Burns K. Davis D. Hormesis: a new religion. Environ Health Perspect 2006 ; 114: 632 - 633.
47. 47 US National Research Council. Valuing ecosystem services. Washington, DC: National Academy Press ; 2004.
48. Calabrese EJ. Baldwin LA. Hormesis and high-risk groups. Regul Toxicol Pharmacol 2002 ; 35: 414 - 428.
49. Calabrese EJ. Baldwin LA. Hormesis: a revolution in toxicology, risk assessment and medicine. EMBO Reports 2004 ; (Suppl. 1): S37 - S40.