Opportunities and problems of standardized ethics initiatives - A stakeholder theory perspective

Journal of Business Ethics

Volumn 82, Issue 3, 2008, Pages 755-773

  Gilbert, Dirk Ulrich ^a   Rasche, Andreas ^b,c  

^a UNIVERSITY OF ERLANGEN NUREMBERG   (Germany)

^b EBS BUSINESS SCHOOL   (Germany)

^c HELMUT SCHMIDT UNIVERSITY   (Germany)

Author keywords

Accountability standards; Compliance; Corporate accountability; Ethical supply chains; Social audits; Stakeholder dialog; Stakeholder theory

Indexed keywords

EID: 54249144547     PISSN: 01674544     EISSN: 15730697     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1007/s10551-007-9591-1     Document Type: Article

References (123)

1. Andriof J., Waddock S., Husted B., R. S. Sutherland 2003, Unfolding Stakeholder Thinking 2 - Relationships, Communication, Reporting and Performance. Sheffield: Greenleaf
2. B. R. Agle R. K. Mitchell J. A. Sonnenfeld 1999 Who Matters to CEOs - An Investigation of Stakeholder Attributes and Salience Academy of Management Journal 42 5 507 525
3. Barney J. B. 2002, Gaining and Sustaining Competitive Advantage. 2nd ed. Prentice Hall: Upper Saddle River
4. M. Beck P. Walgenbach 2005 Technical Efficiency of Adaptation to Institutional Expectations? - The Adoption of ISO 9000 Standards in the German Mechanical Engineering Industry Organization Studies 26 6 841 866
5. A. R. Belal 2002 Stakeholder Accountability or Stakeholder Management: A Review of UK Firms' Social and Ethical Accounting, Auditing, and Reporting (SEAAR) Practices Corporate Social Responsibility and Environmental Management 9 1 8 25
6. S. Berman A. C. Wicks S. Kotha T. M. Jones 1999 Does Stakeholder Orientation Matter? - The Relationship Between Stakeholder Management Models and Firm Financial Performance Academy of Management Journal 42 5 488 506
7. T. Beschorner 2006 Ethical Theory and Business Practices - The Case of Discourse Ethics Journal of Business Ethics 66 1 127 139
8. Bird F. B. 1996, The Muted Conscience - Moral Silence and the Practice of Ethics in Business. Quorum: Westport
9. F. B. Bird 2003 The Value-Added Approach to Business Ethics Zeitschrift für Wirtschafts- und Unternehmensethik 4 2 148 166
10. J. R. Boatright 2000 Globalization and the Ethics of Business Business Ethics Quarterly 10 1 1 6
11. Brunsson N. 1989, The Organization of Hypocrisy - Talk, Decision, and Actions in Organizations. Chichester: John Wiley and Sons
12. Brunsson N., B. Jacobsson 2000, The Contemporary Expansion of Standardization, in N. Brunsson, B. Jacobsson (eds.), A World of Standards Oxford/New York: Oxford University Press, 1-17
13. P. Carlson M. S. Blodgett 1997 International Ethics Standards for Business - NAFTA, Caux Principles and Corporate Codes of Ethics Review of Business 18 3 20 24
14. Carroll A. B. 1989, Business and Society - Ethics and Stakeholder Management. Cincinnati/OH: South-Western
15. G. F. Cavanagh 2004 Global Business Ethics - Regulation, Code, or Self-Restraint Business Ethics Quarterly 14 4 625 642
16. Clarkson M. B. 1991, Defining, Evaluating, and Monitoring Corporate Social Performance - A Stakeholder Management Model, In J. E. Post (ed.) Research in Corporate Social Performance and Policy. Greenwich: JAI Press, 331-358
17. M. B. Clarkson 1995 A Stakeholder Framework for Analyzing and Evaluating Corporate Social Performance Academy of Management Review 20 1 92 117
18. Crane A., S. Livesey 2003, Are You Talking to Me? - Stakeholder Communication and the Risks and Rewards of Dialogue, In J. Andriof, S. Waddock, B. Husted, R. Sutherland (eds.) Unfolding Stakeholder Thinking 2 - Relationships, Communication, Reporting and Performance. Greenleaf: Sheffield, 39-52
19. Crane A., D. Matten 2004, Business Ethics - A European Perspective. Oxford: Oxford University Press
20. DeRuisseau D. 2002, Social Auditing - An Auditor's Perspective, In A. G. Scherer, K.-H. Blickle, D. Dietzfelbinger, G. Hütter (eds.) Globalisierung und Sozialstandards Hampp: München/Mering, 223-234
21. T. Donaldson T. W. Dunfee 1994 Toward a Unified Conception of Business Ethics: Integrative Social Contracts Theory Academy of Management Review 19 2 252 284
22. T. Donaldson L. E. Preston 1995 The Stakeholder Theory of the Corporation - Concepts, Evidence, and Implications Academy of Management Review 20 1 65 91
23. Evan W. M., R. E. Freeman 1988, A Stakeholder Theory of the Modern Corporation - Kantian Capitalism, In T. Beauchamp, N. Bowie (eds.) Ethical Theory and Business. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall, 75-93
24. Fair Labor Association (FLA): 2006a, Workplace Code of Conduct. http://www.fairlabor.org, Accessed: 12th June 2006
25. Fair Labor Association (FLA): 2006b, Principles of Monitoring. http://www.fairlabor.org/all/code/FLA_PRINCIPLES_ OF_MONITORING.pdf, Accessed: 24th August 2006
26. Freeman R. E. 1984, Strategic Management: A Stakeholder Approach. Boston: Pitman
27. R. E. Freeman W. M. Evan 1990 Corporate Governance - A Stakeholder Interpretation The Journal of Behavioral Economics 19 4 337 359
28. R. E. Freeman D. L. Reed 1983 Stockholders and Stakeholders - A New Perspective on Corporate Governance California Management Review 25 3 88 106
29. A. L. Friedman S. Miles 2002 Developing Stakeholder Theory Journal of Management Studies 39 1 1 21
30. A. L. Friedman S. Miles 2004 Stakeholder Theory and Communication Practice Journal of Communication Management 9 1 89 97
31. R. Frost 2005 ISO 26000 Launched Business and the Environment 16 5 12 13
32. A. Fung 2003 Deliberative Democracy and International Labor Standards Governance - An International Journal of Policy, Administration, and Institutions 16 1 51 71
33. K. Gibson 2001 The Moral Basis of Stakeholder Theory Journal of Business Ethics 26 3 245 257
34. D. U. Gilbert 2001 Social Accountability 8000 - Ein praktikabeles Instrument zur Implementierung von Unternehmensethik in international tätigen Unternehmen? Zeitschrift für Wirtschafts- und Unternehmensethik 2 2 123 148
35. D. U. Gilbert 2003 Institutionalisierung von Unternehmensethik in internationalen Unternehmen - ein Ansatz zur Erweiterung der Zertifizierungsinitiative Social Accountability 8000 Zeitschrift für Betriebswirtschaft 73 1 25 48
36. Gilbert, D. U. and A. Rasche: 2007, 'Discourse Ethics and Social Accountability - The Ethics of SA 8000', Business Ethics Quarterly 17(2), 187-216
37. Global Reporting Initiative (GRI): 2002, Sustainability Reporting Guidelines on Economic, Environmental, and Social Performance. Boston: GRI
38. Goodell E. 1999, Standards of Corporate Social Responsibility. San Francisco: Social Venture Network
39. Goyder M., P. Desmond 2000, Is Ethical Sourcing Simply a Question of Good-Supply Chain Management? in Thamotheram, R. (eds.) Visions of Ethical Sourcing. London: Financial Times Prentice Hall
40. R. Gray 2001 Thirty Years of Social Accounting, Reporting and Auditing: What (if anything) Have we Learnt? Business Ethics: A European Review 10 1 9 15
41. R. Gray 2002 The Social Accounting Project and Accounting Organizations and Society Privileging Engagement, Imaginings, New Accountings and Pragmatism over Critique? Accounting, Organizations and Society 27 7 687 708
42. M. Göbbels J. Jonker 2003 AA1000 and SA8000 Compared: A Systematic Comparison of Contemporary Accountability Standards Managerial Auditing Journal 18 1 54 58
43. Habermas J. 1990, Moral Consciousness and Communicative Action. Cambridge/MA: MIT Press
44. Habermas J. 1993, Justification and Application. Remarks on Discourse Ethics. Cambridge/MA: MIT Press
45. Habermas J. 1996, Between Facts and Norms. Cambridge/MA: Blackwell Publishing
46. Habermas J. 1999, The Inclusion of the Other - Studies in Political Theory. Cambridge/MA: Blackwell Publishing
47. Habermas J. 2006, The Divided West. Cambridge: Polity Press
48. S. Hanock 1998 Fair's Fare Supply Management 3 22 22 25
49. D. Hess 1999 Social Reporting - A Reflexive Law Approach to Corporate Social Responsiveness The Journal of Corporation Law 25 4 42 84
50. D. Hess 2001 Regulating Corporate Social Performance - A New Look at Social Accounting, Auditing, and Reporting Business Ethics Quarterly 11 2 307 330
51. C. W. L. Hill T. M. Jones 1992 Stakeholder-Agency Theory Journal of Management Studies 29 2 131 154
52. A. J. Hillman G. D. Keim 2001 Shareholder Value, Stakeholder Management, and Social Issues - What's the Bottom Line? Strategic Management Journal 22 2 125 139
53. Hirschland, M. and L. Kantor: 2006, Supply Chain Compliance - A Decade of Experience and the Road Ahead, Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the Academy of Management, Atlanta
54. Institute for Social, Ethical AccountAbility: 1999, AA 1000 Framework - Standards, Guidelines and Professional Qualifications. London: ISEA
55. T. M. Jones A. C. Wicks 1999 Convergent Stakeholder Theory Academy of Management Review 24 2 206 221
56. J. Kaler 2002 Morality and Strategy in Stakeholder Identification Journal of Business Ethics 39 1-2 91 99
57. J. Kaler 2003 Differentiating Stakeholder Theories Journal of Business Ethics 46 1 71 83
58. Kant, I.: 1788/1997, Critique of Practical Reason (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
59. M. Kaptein 2004 Business Codes of Multinational Firms - What Do They Say Journal of Business Ethics 50 1 13 31
60. M. Kaptein R. van Tulder 2003 Toward Effective Stakeholder Dialogue Business and Society Review 108 2 203 224
61. Keeley M. 1988, A Social Contract Theory of Organizations. Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press
62. G. Kell 2005 The Global Compact - Selected Experiences and Reflections Journal of Business Ethics 59 1/2 69 79
63. G. Kell D. Levin 2003 The Global Compact Network - an Historic Experiment in Learning and Action Business and Society Review 108 2 151 181
64. KPMG: 2002, International Survey of Corporate Sustainability Reporting 2002 (Druckgroep Maasland, Maasland)
65. A. Kolk R. van Tulder 2004 Ethics in International Business: Multinational Approaches to Child Labor Journal of World Business 39 1 49 60
66. Leipziger D. 2001, SA 8000. The Definitive Guide to the New Social Standard. London et al.: Prentice Hall
67. Leipziger D. 2003, The Corporate Responsibility Code Book. Sheffield: Greenleaf
68. Locke, J.: 1690/1948, The Second Treatise of Civil Government and a Letter Concerning Toleration (Basil Blackwell, Oxford)
69. J. F. Lozano 2001 Proposal for a Model for the Elaboration of Ethical Codes Based on Discourse Ethics Business Ethics: A European Review 10 2 157 162
70. I. Mamic 2005 Managing Global Supply Chain: The Sports Footwear, Apparel and Retail Sectors Journal of Business Ethics 59 1 81 100
71. M. R. Mathews 1997 Twenty-Five Years of Social and Environmental Accounting Research: Is There a Silver Jubilee to Celebrate? Accounting, Auditing and Accountability Journal 10 4 481 531
72. McIntosh M., Thomas R., Leipziger D., G. Coleman 2003, Living Corporate Citizenship - Strategic Routes to Socially Responsible Business. London et al.: FT Prentice Hall
73. R. K. Mitchell B. R. Agle D. J. Wood 1997 Toward a Theory of Stakeholder Identification and Salience: Defining the Principle of Who and What Really Counts Academy of Management Review 22 4 853 886
74. Nonet P, P. Selznick 1978, Law and Society in Transition - Toward Responsive Law. New York: Harper
75. B. O'Dwyer G. Madden 2006 A Survey of Code Content and Enforcement Procedures Journal of Business Ethics 63 3 217 236
76. G. Ortmann H. Salzman 2002 Stumbling Giants -The Emptiness, Fullness, and Recursiveness of Strategic Management Soziale Systeme 8 2 205 230
77. E. W. Orts 1995 Reflexive Environmental Law Northwestern University Law Review 89 4 1227 1340
78. D. L. Owen T. A. Swift C. Humphrey M. Bowerman 2000 The New Social Audits - Accountability, Managerial Capture or the Agenda of Social Champions European Accounting Review 9 1 81 99
79. Owen, D. L., T. A. Swift and K. Hunt: 2001, 'Questioning the Role of Stakeholder Engagement in Social and Ethical Accounting, Auditing and Reporting', Accounting Forum 25(3), 264-282
80. K. Pajunen 2006 Stakeholder Influences in Organizational Survival Journal of Management Studies 43 6 1261 1288
81. Penrose E. 1995, The Theory of the Growth of the Firm. Oxford/New York: Oxford University Press
82. Phillips R. 2003, Stakeholder Theory and Organizational Ethics. Berrett-Koehler: San Francisco
83. R. Phillips E. R. Freeman A. C. Wicks 2003 What Stakeholder Theory is Not Business Ethics Quarterly 13 4 479 502
84. C. N. Pitelis M. W. Wahl 1998 Edith Penrose - Pioneer of Stakeholder Theory Long Range Planning 31 2 252 261
85. M. Power R. Laughlin 1996 Habermas, Law and Accounting Accounting, Organizations and Society 21 5 441 465
86. A. M. Preston D. J. Cooper D. P. Scarbrough R. C. Chilton 1995 Changes in the Code of Ethics of the U.S. Accounting Profession, 1917 and 1988 - The Continual Quest for Legitimation Accounting, Organizations and Society 20 6 507 546
87. Rawls J. 1971, A Theory of Justice. Cambridge/MA: Harvard University Press
88. A. Rasche D. E. Esser 2006 From Stakeholder Management to Stakeholder Accountability - Applying Habermasian Discourse Ethics to Accountability Research Journal of Business Ethics 65 3 251 267
89. Rasche, A. et al.: 2007, 'Corporations as Political Actors: A Report on the First Swiss Master Class in Corporate Social Responsibility', Journal of Business Ethics, Forthcoming
90. D. Reed 1999 Stakeholder Management Theory - A Critical Theory Perspective Business Ethics Quarterly 9 3 453 483
91. K. Rohitratana 2002 SA 8000 - a Tool to Improve Quality of Life Managerial Auditing Journal 17 1/2 60 64
92. W Ruigrok H. Wagner 2003 Internationalization and Performance: an Organizational Learning Perspective Management International Review 43 1 63 83
93. K. Sandberg 2006 Groundwork Laid for ISO 26000 Business and the Environment 17 1 14
94. G. T. Savage T. W. Nix C. J. Whitehead J. D. Blair 1991 Strategies for Assessing and Managing Organizational Stakeholders Academy of Management Executive 5 2 61 75
95. Scherer, A. G. and G. Palazzo: 2007, 'Towards a Political Conception of Corporate Responsibility: Business and Society Seen from a Habermasian Perspective', Academy of Management Review 32(4), 1096-1120
96. E. Schnebel 2000 Values in Decision-making Processes. Systematic Structures of J. Habermas and N. Luhmann for the Appreciation of Responsibility in Leadership Journal of Business Ethics 27 1 79 89
97. S. P. Sethi 1999 Codes of Conduct for Multinational Corporations - An Idea Whose Time Has Come Business and Society Review 104 3 225 241
98. Sethi, S. P.: 2003, "Global Compact is Another Exercise in Futility", The Financial Express, 8th September 2003, 1
99. S. P. Sethi O. F. Williams 2000 Creating and Implementing Global Codes of Conduct - an Assessment of the Sullivan Principles as a Role Model for Developing International Codes of Conduct: Lessens Learned and Unlearned Business and Society Review 105 2 169 200
100. A. Sharplin L. D. Phelps 1989 A Stakeholder Apologetic for Management Business and Professional Ethics Journal 8 2 41 53
101. Smith D. 2002, Demonstrating Corporate Values - Which Standard for your Company? London: Institute of Business Ethics
102. Social Accountability International: 2001, SA 8000 Guidance Document. New York: SAI
103. Social Accountability International: 2005, About Social Accountability 8000. http://www.sa-intl.org/AboutSAI/AboutSAI.htm, Accessed: 20th December 2005
104. R. C. Solomon L. Lewis 2002 Incentives and Disincentives for Corporate Environmental Disclosure Business Strategy and the Environment 11 3 154 169
105. C. Stoney D. Winstanley 2001 Stakeholding - Confusion or Utopia? Mapping the Conceptual Terrain Journal of Management Studies 38 5 603 626
106. M. Suchman 1995 Managing Legitimacy - Strategic and Institutional Approaches Academy of Management Review 20 3 571 610
107. Tamm-Hallström K. 2000, Organizing the Process of Standardization, in N. Brunsson, B. Jacobsson (eds.) A World of Standards. Oxford/New York: Oxford University Press, 85-99
108. Tamm-Hallström, K.: 2006, ISO Expands Its Business Into Social Responsibility (SR), Paper Presented at the Annual Colloquium of the European Group for Organization Studies (EGOS), Bergen/Norway
109. G. Teubner 1983 Substantive and Reflexive Elements in Modern Law Law and Society Review 17 2 239 285
110. G. Teubner 1984 Autopoiesis in Law and Society - A Rejoinder to Blankenburg Law and Society Review 18 2 291 302
111. R. Thaler-Carter 1999 Social Accountability 8000 HR Magazine 44 6 106 112
112. T. Thomas J. R. Schermerhorn J. W. Dienhart 2004 Strategic Leadership of Ethical Behavior in Business Academy of Management Executive 18 2 56 66
113. J.-P. Thérien V. Pouliot 2006 The Global Compact - Shifting the Politics of International Development Global Governance 12 1 55 75
114. R. v. Tulder A. Kolk 2001 Multinationality and Corporate Ethics: Codes of Conduct in the Sporting Goods Industry Journal of International Business Studies 32 2 267 283
115. Ulrich, P.: 1998, Integrative Economic Ethics - Towards a Conception of Socio-Economic Rationality. Working Paper No. 82 (University of St. Gallen, St. Gallen, Switzerland)
116. J. Unerman M. Bennett 2004 Increased Stakeholder Dialogue and the Internet - Towards Greater Corporate Accountability or Reinforcing Capitalist Hegemony Accounting, Organizations and Society 29 7 685 708
117. United Nations: 2006, The Global Compact, http://www.unglobalcompact.org, Accessed: 7th September 2006
118. M. Velasquez 2000 Globalization and the Failure of Ethics Business Ethics Quarterly 10 1 343 352
119. S. Waddock 2004 Creating Corporate Accountability - Foundational Principles to Make Corporate Citizenship Real Journal of Business Ethics 50 4 313 327
120. S. Waddock N. Smith 2000 Corporate Responsibility Audits - Doing Well by Doing Good Sloan Management Review 41 2 75 83
121. Ward, A.: 2000, 'Companies Come Under Pressure to Alter course of Ethical Investment', Financial Times, 8th July, 35
122. O. F. Williams 2004 The UN Global Compact - The Challenge and the Promise Business Ethics Quarterly 14 4 755 774
123. S. Zadek 2004 The Path to Corporate Responsibility Harvard Business Review 82 12 125 132