Migrant workers in the ILO's Global Alliance Against Forced Labour report: A critical appraisal

Third World Quarterly

Volumn 29, Issue 7, 2008, Pages 1431-1447

  Rogaly, Ben ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF SUSSEX   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

CAPITALISM; GLOBALIZATION; INTERNAL MIGRATION; LABOR MIGRATION; LABOR RELATIONS; MIGRANT WORKER; MIGRANTS EXPERIENCE;

ASIA; EURASIA;

EID: 53449100306     PISSN: 01436597     EISSN: 13602241     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1080/01436590802386674     Document Type: Article

References (88)

1. J Lerche, 'A global alliance against forced labour? Unfree labour, neo-liberal globalization and the International Labour Organisation', Journal of Agrarian Change, 7 (4), 2007, pp 425-452.
2. D Massey, Spatial Divisions of Labour: Social Relations and the Geography of Production, Basingstoke: Macmillan, 1995.
3. G Hart, Disabling Globalisation: Places of Power in Post-apartheid South Africa, Berkeley, CA: University of California Press, 2002
4. JK Gibson-Graham, A Post-capitalist Politics, Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press, 2006
5. and P Dicken, Global Shift: Mapping the Changing Contours of the World Economy, London: Sage, 2007.
6. K Datta, C McIlwaine, Y Evans, J Herbert, J May & JWills, 'From coping strategies to tactics: London's low-pay economy and migrant labour', British Journal of Industrial Relations, 45 (2), 2007, pp 404-432.
7. C Smith, 'The double indeterminacy of labour power: Labour effort and labour mobility', Work, Employment and Society, 20 (2), 2006, pp 389-402.
8. DC Lier, 'Places of work, scales of organising: A review of labour geography', Geography Compass, 1 (4), 2007, pp 814-833.
9. Lerche, 'A global alliance against forced labour?', pp 430-431.
10. N Smith, Uneven Development: Nature, Capital and the Production of Space, Oxford: Blackwell, 1984
11. P Taylor, 'A materialist framework for political geography', Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, 7, 1981, pp15-34
12. A Herod, 'Scale: The local and the global', in S Holloway, S Rice, G Valentine & N Clifford, Key Concepts in Geography, London: Sage (second edition), forthcoming
13. D Mitchell, 'Localist ideology, large-scale production and agricultural labor's geography of resistance in 1930s California', in Mitchell, Organising the Landscape: Geographical Perspectives on Labor Unionism Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press, 1998, pp159-194
14. R Silvey, 'Power, difference and mobility: Feminist advances in migration studies', Progress in Human Geography, 28 (4), 2004, pp 490-506
15. and S Marston, JP Jones & K Woodward, 'Human geography without scale', Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, 30 (4), 2005, pp 416-432.
16. G Hart, Disabling Globalisation
17. and JK Gibson-Graham, 'Beyond the global versus local: Economic politics outside the binary frame, in A Herod & M Wright (eds), Geographies of Power: Placing Scale, Oxford: Blackwell, 2002, pp 25-60.
18. Mitchell, 'Localist ideology, large-scale production and agricultural labor's geography of resistance in 1930s California'.
19. Marston et al, 'Without scale'.
20. Ibid, p 427.
21. H Leitner & B Miller, 'Scale and the limitations of ontological debate: a commentary on Marston, Jones and Woodward', Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, 32, 2007, pp 116-125.
22. Lier, 'Places of work, scales of organising'.
23. Leitner & Miller, 'Scale and the limitations of ontological debate', p 122.
24. Silvey, 'Power, difference and mobility'.
25. Herod, 'Scale'.
26. D Mitchell, The Lie of the Land: Migrant Workers and the California Landscape, Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press, 1996
27. and KMorgan, T Marsden & J Murdoch, Worlds of Food: Place, Power and Provenance in the Food Chain, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2006.
28. J Frances, S Barrientos & B Rogaly, Temporary Workers in UK Agriculture and Horticulture, Framlingham, UK: Precision Prospecting for DEFRA, 2005.
29. ILO,Forced Labour Convention, 1930, Article 2(1), cited in ILO, A Global Alliance Against Forced Labour (GAAFL), Geneva: ILO, 2005, p 5.
30. GAAFL, p 8.
31. G Craig, A Gaus, M Wilkinson, K Skrivankova & A McQuade, Contemporary Slavery in the UK: Overview and Key Issues - Findings, York: Joseph Rowntree Foundation, 2007, p 3, emphasis added.
32. This differs from Brass' conceptualisation. For Brass debt bondage is a quintessential form of continuing unfreedom in capitalist agriculture. Labour bonded by debt is unfree, even if there has been a cash advance-labour service tie which carries no explicit interest, is for a limited duration, and involves migrant workers. Forced labour, however, is something exacted by the state. T Brass, Towards a Comparative Political Economy of Unfree Labour: Case Studies and Debates, London: Frank Cass, 1999.
33. A Sharma, 'Agrarian relations and socio-economic change in Bihar', Economic and Political Weekly, 40 (10), 2005, pp 960-972.
34. Ibid, p 970.
35. G Rodgers & J Rodgers, Semi-feudalism meets the Market: A Report from Purnia, New Delhi: Institute for Human Development Working Paper, 2000, p 16.
36. The same is true of capitalism and slavery. As Graeber has shown, depending on how these are conceptualised, capitalism itself can be seen as slavery. D Graeber, 'Turning modes of production inside out: Or why capitalism is a transformation of slavery', Critique of Anthropology 26 (1), 2006, pp 61-85.
37. Rodgers and Rodgers do not, however, present ethnographic data on the degree to which women have bought into male labour migration as a means of increasing household income.
38. V Lenin, The Development of Capitalism in Russia: Collected Works, Vol 3, Moscow: Progress Publishers, 1964, pp 240-254.
39. See also B Rogaly, 'Dangerous liaisons? Seasonal migration and agrarian change in West Bengal', in B Rogaly, B Harriss-White & S Bose (eds), Sonar Bangla? Agricultural Growth and Agrarian Change in West Bengal and Bangladesh, New Delhi/London/Thousand Oaks: Sage, 1999, pp 357-380.
40. The two pieces cited are focused on Punjab as a destination area for bonded labourers from Bihar. M. Singh, 'Bonded migrant labour in Punjab agriculture', Economic and Political Weekly, 15 March 1997
41. and J Singh, 'Incidence and magnitude of bonded labour in Punjab', in M Singh & K Gopal Iyer (eds), Migrant Labour and Human Rights in India New Delhi: Kanishka Publishers, 2003, pp 50-77. Interestingly both M Singh and K Gopal Iyer, co-editors of the book in which J Singh's chapter appears, are among the six people acknowledged as providing productive intellectual exchanges by Tom Brass in his major book on unfree labour, which elaborates the view that any form of prior payment to workers involving a future commitment to employment should be regarded as bonded labour.
42. A Herod, 'The production of scale in United States labour relations', Area, 23 (1), 1991, pp 82-88
43. and W Larner, 'A brief history of neoliberalism', Economic Geography 82 (4), 2006, pp 449-451.
44. Smith, Uneven Development; and M Mann, Workers on the Move: The Sociology of Relocation, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1973.
45. B Rogaly, 'Who goes? Who stays back? Seasonal migration and staying put among seasonal migrant workers in West Bengal, India', Journal of International Development, 15 (5), 2003, pp 623-632.
46. Brass, Towards a Comparative Political Economy of Unfree Labour, p 28.
47. V Gidwani, 'The cultural logic of work: Explaining labour deployment and piece rate contracts in Matar Taluka, Gujarat - Parts 1 and 2', Journal of Development Studies, 38 (2), 2002, pp 57-74
48. H Bauder, Labor Movement: How Migration Regulates Labor Markets, New York: Oxford University Press, 2006
49. and A Rafique, D Massey & B Rogaly, 'Migration for hard work: A reluctant livelihood strategy for poor households in West Bengal, India', Development Research Centre on Migration, Globalisation and Poverty, Working Paper T17, 2006.
50. Gidwani, 'The cultural logic of work'
51. and Graeber, 'Turning modes of production inside out'.
52. Lerche, 'A global alliance against forced labour?', p 447.
53. S Mann, Agrarian Capitalism in Theory and Practice, Chapel Hill, NC: University of North Carolina Press, 1990.
54. J Guthman, Agrarian Dreams: The Paradox of Organic Farming in California, Berkeley, CA: University of California Press, 2004
55. and G Henderson, California and the Fictions of Capital, Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press, 1998.
56. C Hahamovitch & R Halpern, 'Not a "sack of potatoes": Why labor historians need to take agriculture seriously', International Labor and Working-Class History, 65, 2004, pp 3-10.
57. D Harvey, A Brief History of Neoliberalism, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2005.
58. B Rogaly, D Coppard, A Ra.que, K Rana, A Sengupta & J Biswas, 'Seasonal migration and welfare/illfare in eastern India: A social analysis', Journal of Development Studies, 38 (5), 2002, pp 89-115.
59. J Breman, '"Even dogs are better off"': The ongoing battle between capital and labour in the cane fields of Gujarat', Journal of Peasant Studies, 17 (4), 1990, pp 546-608.
60. This interview took place as part of the project on Social Protection by and for Temporary Work Migrants in Bangladesh and West Bengal, which I directed along with Dr Janet Seeley of the University of East Anglia (funded by the Development Research Centre on Migration, Globalisation and Poverty).
61. B Rogaly, B Harriss-White & S Bose, 'Introduction: Sonar Bangla? Agricultural growth and agrarian change in West Bengal and Bangladesh', in Rogaly et al, Sonar Bangla?
62. B Rogaly, 'Containing conflict and reaping votes: Management of rural labour relations in West Bengal', Economic and Political Weekly, 33 (42-43), 1998, pp 2729-2739.
63. Buddhadeb Bhattacharya, 'We cannot fail people's expectations', Public letter to Sumit Sarkar in response to Professor Sarkar's statement on conflicts over the acquisition the agricultural land for large-scale industry, 11 January 2007. More recently, West Bengal's Chief Minister has claimed that industrial growth does not need the involvement of the state except to ensure corporate social responsibility. 'There is no need for any political interference in the process of industrialisation', cited in S Banerjee, 'Goodbye socialism', Economic and Political Weekly, 26 January 2008, p13. The national secretary of the CPI(M), Prakash Karat, reinforced the party's emphasis on large-scale units: 'If some argue that small and medium industries are sufficient, the CPI(M) does not agree. Large-scale units, particularly in manufacturing, are necessary'.
64. People's Democracy, New Delhi, 24 March 2007.
65. EAS Sarma, 'Help the rich, hurt the poor: Case of Special Economic Zones', Economic and Political Weekly, 26 May 2007, p 1901.
66. In one of the worst incidents, on 14 March 2007 at Nandigram, 14 people were killed and 162 people were injured when police fired on a crowd. Data extracted from West Bengal High Court Order in AST 205, 2007.
67. BBC News, 'Countdown to India's retail revolution', at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/pr/fr/-/2/hi/business/4662642.stm, accessed 29 February 2008
68. and Mark Milner, 'UK urges India to welcome in supermarkets', Guardian, 15 November 2005. Similarly, two years earlier, the US Consulate-General had urged West Bengal to 'realize' its 'potential' by allowing 'groundbreaking investments' by US food processing companies and, following a report by McKinsey on the prospects for agribusiness in the state, accelerating moves towards reorganising parts of agriculture around contract farming. 'The shift in rural economic/political relations is still underway and it has encountered some resistance. That is natural, since all change involves some dislocation. But once the advantages have become clear, the prospects will open up for floriculture, horticulture, and animal husbandry.
69. As the food processing industry grows, commercial possibilities will open up in areas like cold chain and logistics management.' Speech delivered by US Consul General George N Sibley to the Indo-American Chamber of Commerce, Kolkata, 11 December 2003, at http://calcutta.usconsulate.gov/121103.html, accessed 29 February 2008.
70. Barbara Harriss-White, Rural Commercial Capital: Agricultural Markets in West Bengal, New Delhi: Oxford University Press, 2008, pp 317-318.
71. Breman, '"Even dogs are better off"'.
72. Harvey, A Brief History of Neoliberalism, pp 76-77.
73. B Rogaly, 'Intensification of work-place regimes in British horticulture: The role of migrant workers', Population, Space and Place, forthcoming.
74. Promar International, 'The future of UK horticulture', UK National Horticulture Forum, 2006.
75. Felicity Lawrence, Not on the Label, London: Penguin, 2004.
76. Carey McWilliams, Ill Fares the Land: Migrants and Migratory Labour in the United States, London: Faber and Faber, 1945.
77. A Geddes, S Scott & KB Nielsen, 'Gangmasters Licensing Authority evaluation study: Baseline report', Nottingham: Gangmasters Licensing Authority, 2007
78. and S Scott, A Geddes, KB Nielsen & P Brindley, 'Gangmasters Licensing Authority annual review', Nottingham: Gangmasters Licensing Authority, 2007. According to the authors of these studies, the legislation applies to roughly 10% of temporary agency workers in the UK.
79. Even the regulatory measures announced following the conclusion of the latest Competition Commission report on supermarket-supplier relations released on 15 February 2008 lacked teeth. See http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/ shared/bsp/hi/pdfs/15_02_2008_Supply_Chain_Remedies%20.pdf, accessed 29 February 2008.
80. Mervyn King, Governor of the Bank of England, Speech at the Eden Project, Cornwall, 12 October 2004, available at http://www.bankofengland.co.uk/publications/speeches/2004/speech229.pdf, accessed 29 April 2008.
81. Audit Commission, Crossing Borders: Responding to the Local Challenges of Migrant Workers, London: Audit Commission, 2007.
82. B Anderson & B Rogaly, Forced Labour and Migration to the UK, London: Trades Union Congress, 2005.
83. B Anderson, M Ruhs, B Rogaly & S Spencer, Fair Enough? Central and East European Migrants in lowwage Employment in the UK, York: Joseph Rowntree Foundation, 2006.
84. Rogaly, forthcoming.
85. N Puwar, 'Speaking positions in global politics', Multitudes, 2004, available at http://multitudes.samizdat.net/article1321.html.
86. H Pai, 'Damning report on migrants delayed as government fears poll backlash', Guardian, 3 February 2005, at http://www.guardian.co.uk/politics/2005/feb/03/ immigrationasylumandrefugees.immigration andasylum.
87. Examples of such challenges include actions by contract cleaners in London, and cross-sectoral action by undocumented migrant workers in the USA. J Wills, 'Making class politics possible: Organising contract cleaners in London', International Journal for Urban and Regional Research, forthcoming
88. and W Robinson, '"Aqui estamos y no nos vamos!" Global capital and immigrant rights', Race and Class, 48 (2), 2006, pp 77-91.