How can primary school students learn self-regulated learning strategies most effectively?. A meta-analysis on self-regulation training programmes

Educational Research Review

Volumn 3, Issue 2, 2008, Pages 101-129

  Dignath, Charlotte ^a   Buettner, Gerhard ^a   Langfeldt, Hans Peter ^a  

^a GOETHE UNIVERSITY   (Germany)

Author keywords

Meta analysis; Primary school; Review; Self regulated learning; Strategy training

Indexed keywords

EID: 52949135536     PISSN: 1747938X     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.edurev.2008.02.003     Document Type: Review

References (125)

1. Abrami P.C., Chambers B., Poulsen C., De Simone C., d'Apollonia S., and Howden J. Classroom connections: Understanding and using cooperative learning (1995), Harcourt-Brace, Toronto
2. Annevirta T., and Vauras M. Metacognitive knowledge in primary grades: A longitudinal study. European Journal of Psychology of Education 16 2 (2001) 257-282
3. Artelt C. Strategisches Lernen [Strategic learning] (2000), Waxmann, Münster
4. *Ashman A.F., and Conway R.N. Teaching students to use process-based learning strategies and problem solving strategies in mainstream classes. Learning and Instruction 3 2 (1993) 73-92
5. Bandura A. Social foundations of thought and action: A social cognitive theory (1986), Prentice-Hall, Inc., Englewood Cliffs, NJ
6. Bandura A. Social cognitive theory. In: Vasta R. (Ed). Annuals of child development, 6. Six theories of child development (1989), JAI Press, Greenwich, CT 1-60
7. *Benito Y.M., Foley C.L., Lewis C.D., and Prescott P. The effect of instruction in question/answer relationships and metacognition on social studies comprehension. Journal of Research in Reading 16 1 (1993) 20-29
8. Biemiller A., Shany M., Inglis A., and Meichenbaum D. Factors influencing children's acquisition and demonstration of self-regulation on academic tasks. In: Schunk D.H., and Zimmerman B.J. (Eds). Self-regulated learning. From teaching to self-reflective practice (1998), Guilford, New York 203-224
9. Boekaerts M. Self-regulated learning: Where we are today. International Journal of Educational research 31 6 (1999) 445-457
10. Boekaerts M., and Corno L. Self-regulation in the classroom: A perspective on assessment and intervention. Applied Psychology: An International Review 54 2 (2005) 199-231
11. *Bornas X., and Servera M. Cognitive training programs to reduce impulsivity-related achievement problems: The need of in-classroom interventions. Learning and Instruction 2 2 (1992) 89-100
12. Bronson M.B. Supporting self-regulation in primary school children. In: Bronson M.B. (Ed). Self-regulation in early childhood (2000), Guilford, New York 221-242
13. Bromme R., and Tillema H. Fusing experience and theory: The structure of professional knowledge. Learning and Instruction 5 4 (1995) 261-267
14. Brown A.L. Knowing when, where, and how to remember: A problem of metacognition. In: Glaser R. (Ed). Advances in instructional psychology 1 (1978), Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Hillsdale, NJ 77-165
15. Brown A.L., Bransford J.D., Ferrara R.A., and Campione J.C. Learning, remembering, and understanding. In: Flavell J.H., and Markman E.M. (Eds). Handbook of child psychology. Cognitive development 3 (1983), Wiley, New York 420-494
16. Brown A.L., Campione J.C., and Day J.D. Learning to learn: On training students to learn from texts. Educational Researcher 10 2 (1981) 14-21
17. *Brown R., Pressley M., Van Meter P., and Schuder T. A quasi-experimental validation of transactional strategies instruction with low-achieving second-grade readers. Journal of Educational Psychology 88 1 (1996) 18-37
18. Butler D.L. Individualizing instruction in self-regulated learning. Theory and Practice 41 2 (2002) 81-92
19. Butler D.L., and Winne P.H. Feedback and self-regulated learning: A theoretical synthesis. Review of Educational Research 65 3 (1995) 245-281
20. *Cardelle Elawar M. Effects of teaching metacognitive skills to students with low mathematics ability. Teaching and Teacher Education 8 2 (1992) 109-121
21. *Cardelle Elawar M. Effects of metacognitive instruction on low achievers in mathematics problems. Teaching and Teacher Education 11 1 (1995) 81-95
22. Chung M. The development of self-regulated learning. Asia Pacific Education Review 1 1 (2000) 55-66
23. De Corte E. Marrying theory building and the improvement of school practice: A permanent challenge for instructional psychology. Learning and Instruction 10 3 (2000) 249-266
24. De Corte E., Verschaffel L., Entwistle N., and van Merrienboer J. Powerful learning environments: Unravelling basis components and dimensions (2003), Pergamon, Amsterdam
25. *De Jager B., Jansen M., and Reezigt G. The development of metacognition in primary school learning environments. School Effectiveness and School Improvement 16 2 (2005) 179-196
26. *Desoete A., Roeyers H., and De Clercq A. Can offline metacognition enhance mathematical problem solving?. Journal of Educational Psychology 95 1 (2003) 188-200
27. Dochy F., Segers M., and Buehl M.M. The relation between assessment practices and outcomes of studies: The case of research on prior knowledge. Review of Educational Research 69 2 (1999) 145-186
28. Dochy F., Segers M., Van den Bossche P., and Gijbels D. Effects of problem-based learning: A meta-analysis. Learning and Instruction 13 5 (2003) 533-568
29. EU Council. Council resolution of 27 June 2002 on lifelong learning. Official Journal of the European Communities 9 (July 2002)
30. *Fuchs L.S., Fuchs D., Prentice K., Burch M., Hamlett C.L., Owen R., et al. Enhancing third-grade students' mathematical problem solving with self-regulated learning strategies. Journal of Educational Psychology 95 2 (2003) 306-315
31. Fuchs L.S., Fuchs D., Prentice K., Burch M., Hamlett C.L., Owen R., et al. Explicitly teaching for transfer: Effects on third-grade students' mathematical problem solving. Journal of Educational Psychology 95 2 (2003) 293-305
32. *Guthrie J.T., Van Meter P., Hancock G.R., Alao S., Anderson E., and McCann A. Does concept-oriented reading instruction increase strategy use and conceptual learning from text?. Journal of Educational Psychology 90 2 (1998) 261-278
33. *Guthrie J.T., Wigfield A., Barbosa P., Perencevich K.C., Taboada A., Davis M.H., et al. Increasing reading comprehension and engagement through concept-oriented reading instruction. Journal of Educational Psychology 96 3 (2004) 403-423
34. *Hasselhorn M., and Maehler C. Kategorisierungstraining bei Grund- und Sonderschülern (L): Zur Rolle metamemorialer Instruktionselemente [Training organizational strategies in learning disabled and normal children: The role of metamnemonic instruction]. Psychologie in Erziehung und Unterricht 3 3 (1992) 179-189
35. Hamman D., Berthelot J., Saia J., and Crowley E. Teachers' coaching of learning and its relation to students' strategic learning. Journal of Educational Psychology 92 2 (2000) 342-348
36. Hattie J.A. Measuring the effects of schooling. Australian Journal of Education 36 (1992) 5-13
37. Hattie J.A., Biggs J., and Purdie N. Effects of learning skills interventions on student learning: A meta-analysis. Review of Educational Research 66 2 (1996) 99-136
38. Heckhausen H., Gollwitzer P.M., and Weinert F.E. Jenseits des Rubikon: Der Wille in den Humanwissenschaften [Beyond the rubicon: Volition in the human sciences] (1987), Springer Verlag, Berlin
39. Hedges L.V., and Olkin I. Statistical methods for meta-analysis (1985), Academic Press, Inc., San Diego, CA
40. Helmke A. Die Entwicklung der Lernfreude vom Kindergarten bis zur 5. Klassenstufe [Development of affective attitudes towards learning from kindergarten to grade five]. Zeitschrift für Pädagogische Psychologie 7 2/3 (1993) 77-86
41. *Hohn R.L., and Frey B. Heuristic training and performance in elementary mathematical problem solving. The Journal of Educational Research 95 6 (2002) 374-380
42. Hunter J.E., and Schmidt F.L. Methods of meta-analysis. Correcting error and bias in research findings (1990), Sage, Newbury Park
43. Johnson, R. T., Johnson, D. W., & Smith, K. A. (2007). Cooperative learning. http://www.co-operation.org (accessed on December 20, 2007).
44. Johnson, D. W., Johnson, R. T., & Stanne, M. B. (2000). Cooperative learning methods: A meta-analysis. http://www.clcrc.com/pages/cl-methods.html (accessed on December 20, 2007).
45. *Kernaghan K., and Woloshyn V.E. Providing grade one students with multiple spelling strategies: Comparisons between strategy instruction, strategy instruction with metacognitive information, and traditional language arts. Applied Cognitive Psychology 9 2 (1995) 157-166
46. *Kettmann Klingner J., Vaughn S., and Schumm J.S. Collaborative strategic reading during social studies in heterogeneous fourth-grade classrooms. Elementary School Journal 99 1 (1998) 3-22
47. *Klauer K.J. Teaching inductive reasoning: Some theory and three experimental studies. Learning and Instruction 6 1 (1996) 37-57
48. *Klauer K.J. Begünstigt induktives Denken das Lösen komplexer Probleme? Experimentelle Studien zu Leutners Sahel-Problem. [Does inductive reasoning promote complex problem solving: Experimental studies on Leutner's geography computer simulation]. Zeitschrift für Experimentelle Psychologie 43 1 (1996) 85-113
49. Klieme E., Funke J., Leutner D., Reimann P., and Wirth J. Problemlösen als fächerübergreifende Kompetenz: Konzeption und erste Resultate aus einer Schulleistungsstudie [Problem solving as a interdisciplinary competence: Conception and first results from a school performance study]. Zeitschrift für Pädagogik 47 (2001) 179-200
50. Kline F.M., Deshler D.D., and Schumaker J.B. Implementing learning strategy instruction in class settings: A research perspective. In: Pressley M., Harris K.R., and Guthrie J.T. (Eds). Promoting academic competence and literacy in school (1992), Academic Press, San Diego 361-406
51. Krapp A. Entwicklung und Förderung von Interessen im Unterricht [Development and promotion of interest in instruction]. Psychologie in Erziehung und Unterricht 44 (1998) 185-201
52. Kuhl J. Motivation und Handlungskontrolle. Ohne guten Willen geht es nicht [Motivation and action control: It doesn't work without volition]. In: Heckhausen H., Gollwitzer P.M., and Weinert F.E. (Eds). Jenseits des Rubikon [Beyond the rubicon: Volition in the human sciences] (1987), Springer, Berlin 101-120
53. Kuhn D. Metacognitive development. Current Directions in Psychological Science 9 5 (2000) 178-181
54. Lin X. Designing metacognitive activities. Educational Technology Research and Development 49 2 (2001) 23-40
55. Lipsey M.W., and Wilson D.B. Practical meta-analysis (2000), Sage, Thousand Oaks, CA
56. *Loranger A.L. Comprehension strategies instruction: Does it make a difference?. Reading Psychology 18 1 (1997) 31-68
57. Lou Y., Abrami P.C., and d'Apollonia S. Small group and individual learning with technology: A meta-analysis. Review of Educational Research 71 3 (2001) 449-521
58. Lou Y., Abrami P.C., Spence J.C., Poulsen C., Chambers B., and d'Apollonia S. Within-class grouping: A meta-analysis. Review of Educational Research 66 4 (1996) 423-458
59. *Lucangeli D., Galderisi D., and Cornoldi C. Specific and general transfer effects following metamemory training. Learning Disabilities Research and Practice 10 1 (1995) 11-21
60. *Mason L.H. Explicit self-regulated strategy development versus reciprocal questioning: Effects on expository reading comprehension among struggling readers. Journal of Educational Psychology 96 2 (2004) 283-296
61. Mayer R.E., and Wittrock M.C. Problem-solving transfer. In: Berliner D., and Calfee R. (Eds). Handbook of educational psychology (1996), Macmillan, New York 45-61
62. McCaslin M., Bozack A.R., Napoleon L., Thomas A., Vasquez V., Wayman V., et al. Self-regulated learning and classroom management: Theory, research, and considerations for classroom practice. In: Evertson C.M. (Ed). Handbook of classroom management (2006), Lawrence Erlbaum Ass.
63. McCombs B.L., and Marzano R.J. Putting the self into self-regulated learning: The self as agent in integrating will and skill. Educational Psychologist 25 1 (1990) 51-69
64. Moely B.E., Hart S.S., Leal L., Santulli K.A., Rao N., Johnson T., et al. The teacher's role in facilitating memory and study strategy development in the elementary school classroom. Child Development 63 3 (1992) 653-672
65. Moely B.E., Santulli K.A., and Obach M.S. Strategy instruction, metacognition, and motivation in the elementary school classroom. In: Weinert F.E., and Schneider W. (Eds). Memory performance and competencies: Issues in growth and development (1995), Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Inc., Hillsdale, NJ, England 301-321
66. Overton R.C. A comparison of fixed-effects and mixed (random-effects) models for meta-analysis tests of moderator variable effects. Psychological Methods 3 3 (1998) 354-379
67. Papaleontiou-Louca E. The concept and instruction of metacognition. Teacher Development 7 1 (2003) 9-30
68. Paris S.G., and Newman R.S. Developmental aspects of self-regulated learning. Educational Psychologist 25 1 (1990) 87-102
69. Paris S.G., and Paris A.H. Classroom applications of research on self-regulated learning. Educational Psychologist 36 2 (2001) 89-101
70. Pauli C., and Reusser K. Zur Rolle der Lehrperson beim kooperativen Lernen [The role of the teacher during cooperative learning]. Schweizerische Zeitschrift für Bildungswissenschaften 22 3 (2000) 421-442
71. Perels F., Guertler T., and Schmitz B. Training of self-regulatory and problem-solving competence. Learning and Instruction 15 2 (2005) 123-139
72. Perels F., Otto B., Schmitz B., and Bruder R. Evaluation of a training program to improve mathematical as well as self-regulatory competences. In: Prenzel M. (Ed). Studies on the educational quality of schools. The final report on the DFG Priority Programme (2007), Waxmann, Münster 197-220
73. Perry N.E., Phillips L., and Dowler J. Examining features of tasks and their potential to promote self-regulated learning. Teachers College Record 106 9 (2004) 1854-1878
74. Perry N.E., and VandeKamp K.O. Creating classroom context that support young children's development of self-regulated learning. International Journal of Educational Research 33 (2000) 821-843
75. Perry N.E., VandeKamp K.O., Mercer L.K., and Nordby C.J. Investigating teacher-student interactions that foster self-regulated learning. Educational Psychologist 37 1 (2002) 5-15
76. Pintrich P.R. The role of motivation in promoting and sustaining self-regulated learning. International Journal of Educational Research 31 6 (1999) 459-470
77. Pintrich P.R. The role of metacognitive knowledge in learning, teaching, and assessing. Theory Into Practice 41 4 (2002) 219-225
78. Puustinen M., and Pulkkinen L. Models of self-regulated learning: A review. Scandinavian Journal of Educational Research 45 3 (2001) 269-286
79. Randi J. Teachers as self-regulated learners. Teachers College Record 106 9 (2004) 1825-1853
80. Rosenthal R. Metaanalytic procedures for social research (1991), Sage, Newbury Park
81. Rozendaal J.S., Minnaert A., and Boekaerts M. The influence of teacher perceived administration of self-regulated learning on students' motivation and information processing. Learning and Instruction 15 2 (2005) 141-160
82. Rustenbach S.J. Metaanalyse. Eine anwendungsorientierte Einführung [Meta-analysis: An application-oriented introduction] (2003), Göttingen, Huber
83. Schmitz B. Self-Monitoring zur Unterstützung des Transfers einer Schulung in Selbstregulation für Studierende. Eine prozessanalytische Untersuchung [Self-monitoring to support the transfer of a self-regulation instruction for students: A process study]. Zeitschrift für Pädagogische Psychologie 15 3/4 (2001) 181-197
84. Schneider W., and Lockl K. The development of metacognitive knowledge in children and adolescents. In: Perfect T.J., and Schwartz B.L. (Eds). Applied metacognition (2002), University Press, Cambridge 224-257
85. *Schober B., and Ziegler A. Das Münchner Motivationstraining (MMT): Theoretischer Hintergrund, Förderziele und exemplarische Umsetzung (The Munich motivational training: Theoretical background, aims and a first evaluation). Zeitschrift für Pädagogische Psychologie 15 3/4 (2001) 168-180
86. *Schreblowski S., and Hasselhorn M. Zur Wirkung zusätzlicher Motiv-änderungskomponenten bei einem metakognitiven Textverarbeitungstraining [On the effectiveness of a motive modification supplement to a metacognitive reading program]. Zeitschrift für Pädagogische Psychologie 15 3/4 (2001) 145-154
87. *Schunk, D. H. (April 1994). Goal and self-evaluative influences during children's mathematical skill acquisition. Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, New Orleans, USA.
88. Schunk D. Social cognitive theory and self-regulated learning. In: Zimmerman B.J., and Schunk D. (Eds). Self-regulated learning and academic achievement. Theoretical perspectives (2001), Lawrence Erlbaum Ass., Mahwah, NJ 125-151
89. Schunk D.H. Commentary on self-regulation on school contexts. Learning and Instruction 15 2 (2005) 173-177
90. *Schunk D.H., and Swartz C.W. Goals and progress feedback: Effects on self-efficacy and writing achievement. Contemporary Educational Psychology 18 3 (1993) 337-354
91. Schunk D.H., and Zimmerman B.J. Self-regulated learning. From teaching to self-reflective practice (1998), Guilford, New York
92. Sipe T.A., and Curlette W.L. A meta-synthesis of factors related to educational achievement: A methodological approach to summarizing and synthesizing meta-analyses. International Journal of Educational Research 25 7 (1997) 583-698
93. Sivin-Kachala, J., & Bialo, E. R. (1994). Report on the effectiveness of technology in schools, 1990-1994 (ERIC Document Reproduction Service no. ED 371 726).
94. Slavin R.E. Research for the future. Research on cooperative learning and achievement: What we know, what we need to know. Contemporary Educational Psychology 21 (1996) 43-69
95. *Souvignier E., and Mokhlesgerami J. Using self-regulation as a framework for implementing strategy instruction to foster reading comprehension. Learning and Instruction 16 1 (2006) 57-71
96. *Sovik N., Heggberget M., and Samuelstuen M. Strategy training related to children's text production. British Journal of Educational Psychology 66 2 (1996) 169-180
97. Spörer N., and Brunstein J.C. Erfassung selbstregulierten Lernens mit Selbstberichtsverfahren. Ein Überblick zum Stand der Forschung. Zeitschrift für Pädagogische Psychologie 20 3 (2006) 147-160
98. Stock W.A. Systematic coding for research synthesis. In: Cooper H., and Hedges L.V. (Eds). The handbook of research synthesis (1994), Sage, New York 125-138
99. Stoeger H., and Ziegler A. Evaluation of an elementary classroom self-regulated learning program for gifted mathematics underachievers. International Education Journal 6 2 (2005) 261-271
100. Swanson H.L., Carson C., and Saches-Lee C.M. A selective synthesis of intervention research for students with learning disabilities. School Psychology Review 25 3 (1996) 370-391
101. Tomic, W., & Kingma, J. (1997). Accelerating intelligence development through an inductive reasoning training. (Report no. 143). Heerlen, Netherlands: The Open University (ERIC Document Reproduction Service no. ED 413 053).
102. Van Hout-Wolters B., Simons R.-J., and Volet S. Active learning: Self-directed learning and independent work. In: Simons R.-J., Van der Linden J., and Duffy T. (Eds). New learning: Three ways to learn in a new balance (2002), Kluwer, New York 21-36
103. *Vauras M., Kinnunen R., and Rauhanummi T. The role of metacognition in the context of integrated strategy intervention. European Journal of Psychology of Education 14 4 (1999) 555-569
104. Veenman M.V.J. The assessment of metacognitive skills: What can be learned from multi-method designs?. In: Artelt C., and Moschner B. (Eds). Lernstrategien und Metakognition. Implikationen für Forschung und Praxis [Learning strategies and metacognition. Implications for research and practice] (2005), Waxmann, Münster 77-100
105. Veenman S., Kenter B., and Post K. Cooperative learning in Dutch primary classrooms. Educational Studies 26 3 (2000) 281-302
106. Veenman M.V.J., Van Hout-Wolters B.H.A.M., and Afflerbach P. Metacognition and learning: Conceptual and methodological considerations. Metacognition and Learning 1 1 (2006) 3-14
107. *Verschaffel L., De Corte E., Lasure S., Van Vaerenbergh G., Bogaerts H., and Ratinckx E. Learning to solve mathematical application problems: A design experiment with fifth graders. Mathematical Thinking and Learning 1 3 (1999) 195-229
108. Waeytens K., Lens W., and Vandenberghe R. 'Learning to learn': Teachers' conceptions of their supporting role. Learning and Instruction 12 3 (2002) 305-322
109. Weiner B. An attributional theory of motivation and emotion (1986), Springer, New York
110. Weinert F.E. Concept of competence: A conceptual clarification. In: Rychen D.S., and Salganik L.H. (Eds). Defining and selecting key competencies (2001), Hogrefe, Bern
111. Weinstein C.E., and Mayer R.E. The teaching of learning strategies. In: Wittrock M. (Ed). The handbook of research on teaching (1986), Macmillan, New York 315-327
112. Whitebread D. Interactions between children's metacognitive abilities, working memory capacity, strategies and performance during problem-solving. European Journal of Psychology of Education 14 4 (1999) 489-507
113. Whitebread D. Interpretations of independent learning in the early years. International Journal of Early Years Education 8 3 (2000) 243-252
114. Whitebread, D. (2007, August). Towards a pedagogy for teaching thinking and developing metacognitive abilities in young children. Paper presented at the 12th Biennial Conference for Research on Learning and Instruction. Budapest, Hungary.
115. *Williams W.M., Blythe T., White N., Li J., Gardner H., and Sternberg R.J. Practical intelligence for school: Developing metacognitive sources of achievement in adolescence. Developmental Review 22 2 (2002) 162-210
116. Wilson S.J., and Lipsey M.W. Wilderness challenge programs for delinquent youth: A meta-analysis of outcome evaluations. Evaluation and Program Planning 23 1 (2000) 1-12
117. Winne P.H. Inherent details in self-regulated learning. Educational Psychologist 30 4 (1995) 173-187
118. Winne P.H. A perspective on state-of-the-art research on self-regulated learning. Instructional Science 33 5/6 (2005) 559-565
119. Wolters C.A., and Pintrich P.R. Contextual differences in student motivation and self-regulated learning in mathematics, English, and social studies classrooms. Instructional Science 26 (1998) 27-47
120. Zeidner M., Boekaerts M., and Pintrich P. Self-regulation: Directions and challenges for future research. In: Boekaerts M., Pintrich P., and Zeidner M. (Eds). Handbook of self-regulation (2000), Academic Press, San Diego, CA 750-768
121. Zimmerman B.J. A social cognitive view of self-regulated academic learning. Journal of Educational Psychology 81 3 (1989) 329-339
122. Zimmerman B.J. Self-regulated learning and academic achievement: An overview. Educational Psychologist 25 1 (1990) 3-17
123. Zimmerman B.J. Developing self-fulfilling cycles of academic regulation: An analysis of exemplary instructional models. In: Schunk D.H., and Zimmerman B.J. (Eds). Self-regulated learning. From teaching to self-reflective practice (1998), Guilford, New York 1-20
124. Zimmerman B.J., and Bandura A. Impact of self-regulatory influences on writing course attainment. American Educational Research Journal 31 4 (1994) 845-862
125. Zimmerman B.J., and Martinez-Pons M. Construct validation of a strategy model if students self-regulated learning. Journal of Educational Psychology 80 3 (1988) 284-290