Symmetry breaking: An epistemological note

Tetrahedron Asymmetry

Volumn 15, Issue 20, 2004, Pages 3171-3175

  Ávalos, Martín ^a   Babiano, Reyes ^a   Cintas, Pedro ^a   Jiménez, José L ^a   Palacios, Juan C ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF EXTREMADURA   (Spain)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE; BIOMEDICINE; CHIRALITY; NATURAL SCIENCE; NOMENCLATURE; PRIORITY JOURNAL; STEREOCHEMISTRY;

EID: 5144233174     PISSN: 09574166     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.tetasy.2004.08.021     Document Type: Article

References (50)

1. E.L. Eliel, and S.H. Wilen Stereochemistry of Organic Compounds 1994 Wiley New York pp 1191-1210
2. IUPAC Recommendations on Stereochemistry: G.P. Moss Pure Appl. Chem. 68 1996 2193 2222
3. For a tutorial article emphasizing symmetry arguments in chemistry: J.D. Dunitz Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 93 1996 14260 14266
4. E. Heilbronner, and J.D. Dunitz Reflections on Symmetry 1993 VCH New York
5. I. Hargittai, and M. Hargittai Symmetry through the Eyes of a Chemist 1987 VCH New York
6. J.D. Donaldson, and S.D. Ross Symmetry and Stereochemistry 1972 Wiley New York
7. M. Orchin, and H.H. Jaffé Symmetry Orbitals and Spectra 1971 Wiley-Interscience New York
8. P. Curie J. Phys. Theor. Appl. (Paris) 3 1894 393 415
9. P. Curie Oeuvres 1908 Gauthier-Villars Paris (Reprinted: Archives Contemporaines: Paris, 1984)
10. 1): K. Mislow Introduction to Stereochemistry 1965 Benjamin/Cummings Reading, MA p 25
11. 6h characteristic of a planar arrangement (e.g., benzene)
12. S.L. Altmann Icons and Symmetries 1992 Clarendon Oxford p 28
13. B.C. Van Fraassen Laws and Symmetry 1989 Clarendon Oxford p 240
14. Jean Buridan (1300-1358) was Rector of the University of Paris (the Sorbonne). Curiously the animal mentioned in Buridan's commentary on Aristotle's De Caelo (On the Heavens) is actually a dog not an ass
15. We have learned that some fundamental physical laws may not be entirely symmetric. Parity or space inversion conservation is not a perfect symmetry of nature. In particle physics symmetry breaking is usually connected with the theory of supersymmetry, which relates fermions to bosons in an approach to incorporating gravity into a unified theory with strong and electroweak interactions G. Kane Supersymmetry: Unvealing the Ultimate Laws of Nature 2001 Perseus Books New York
16. For some recent essays: F. Wilczek Nature 428 2004 261
17. E. Witten Nature 429 2004 507 508
18. P.G. De Gennes N. Boccara Symmetries and Broken Symmetries in Condensed Matter Physics 1981 IDSET Paris Chapter 1
19. L.D. Landau, and E.M. Lifschitz Statistical Physics 1959 Pergamon London Chapter 3
20. For a comprehensive yet non-mathematical treatment see: J. Sivardiere La Symetrie en Mathematiques, Physique et Chimie (Symmetry in Mathematics, Physics and Chemistry) 1995 Presses Universitaires Grenoble Chapter 43, pp 715-735
21. J.S. Rutherford Cryst. Eng. 4 2001 269 281
22. L. Addadi, Z. Berkovitch-Yellin, I. Weissbuch, M. Lahav, and L. Leiserowitz Top. Stereochem. 16 1986 1 85
23. For an excellent survey: B. Kahr, and J.M. McBride Angew. Chem., Int. Ed. Engl. 31 1992 1 26
24. A.D. McNaught, and A. Wilkinson Compendium of Chemical Terminology. IUPAC Recommendations 2nd ed. 1997 Blackwell Oxford See also: Pure Appl. Chem. 66 1994 591
25. K. Mislow Top. Stereochem. 22 1999 1 82
26. K. Mislow Chirality 14 2002 126 134
27. D.H. Rouvray D.H. Rouvray Concepts in Chemistry: A Contemporary Challenge 1997 Wiley New York Chapter 1
28. Collinear electric and magnetic fields do not generate molecular chirality either. Pierre Curie ignored the role of time reversal (T), characteristic of motion-dependent chirality. Time reversal of one of the enantiomorphous states (interconverted by space inversion P) combined with any proper rotation gives rise to a homomorph of the former. Pseudoscalar properties such as natural optical activity and hence chirality are only supported by a T-invariant enantiomorphism that is, T cannot undo the effect of space inversion (P): L.D. Barron J. Am. Chem. Soc. 108 1986 5539 5542
29. L.D. Barron, and A.D. Buckingham Acc. Chem. Res. 34 2001 781 789
30. I.C. Paul, and D.Y. Curtin G.R. Desiraju Organic Solid State Chemistry 1987 Elsevier Amsterdam Chapter 9
31. Y.R. Shen The Principles of Nonlinear Optics 1984 Wiley-Interscience New York
32. P. Ball Made to Measure. New Materials for the 21st Century 1984 Princeton University Princeton, NJ pp 51-52
33. T. Verbiest, and A. Persoons M.M. Green R.J.M. Nolte E.W. Meijer Materials-Chirality, Topics in Stereochemistry Vol. 24 2003 Wiley New York 519 570 and references cited therein
34. E. Bauer, G. Hilscher, H. Michor, C. Paul, E.W. Scheidt, A. Gribanov, Yu. Seropegin, H. Noël, M. Sigrist, and P. Rogl Phys. Rev. Lett. 92 2004 027003
35. For a commentary: S.S. Saxena, and P. Monthoux Nature 427 2004 799
36. In magnetic superconductors such as metals or alloys, the state wave function can be separated into two parts, one depending only on the spatial coordinates and the other only on the spin coordinates. In crystals with space-inversion (parity) symmetry, the interchange of the spatial coordinates of the electrons gives rise to a state indistinguishable from the original. Therefore, the probability distribution of the electrons in the state wave function remains unaffected. A second interchange gives back the initial quantum state, with a phase factor of +1 or -1, that is, the spatial part must be either symmetric or antisymmetric. If the complete state has to be antisymmetric (electron states have momenta equal in magnitude, but opposite in direction), the spin part of the wave function must be antisymmetric (it must have the opposite symmetry under electron interchange). This implies a spin-singlet state, typical of metals such as aluminum. Conversely, an antisymmetric spatial wave function requires a symmetric spin wave function (corresponding to a spin-triplet state)
37. (a) See Ref. 1, p 1193
38. J. Jacques, A. Collet, and S.H. Wilen Enantiomers, Racemates and Resolutions 1981 Wiley New York p 370
39. N.A. Hassan, E. Bayer, and J.C. Jochims J. Chem. Soc., Perkin Trans. 1 1998 3747 3757
40. In other words the observable pattern, which has in principle no relation with the intimate structure. In crystallography, the packing may present low symmetry as revealed by the asymmetry of the electron diffraction pattern, although the single crystals be highly symmetric. For an excellent discussion: C. De Rosa M.M. Green R.J.M. Nolte E.W. Meijer Materials-Chirality, Topics in Stereochemistry Vol. 24 2003 Wiley New York 71 155 (especially pp 109-121)
41. N. Bouropoulos, S. Weiner, and L. Addadi Chem. Eur. J. 7 2001 1881 1888
42. C.A. Orme, A. Noy, A. Wierzbicki, M.T. McBride, M. Grantham, H.H. Teng, P.M. Dove, and J.J. DeYoreo Nature 411 2001 775 779
43. Conglomerate refers to a mechanical mixture of two enantiomers forming a eutectic. The term is reserved for a mixture of macroscopic chiral domains although it is not only confined to crystals but also to two-dimensional conglomerates such as Langmuir films. For chiral morphologies of Langmuir monolayers see: N. Nandi, and D. Vollhardt Chem. Rev. 103 2003 4033 4075 In stark contrast true racemates contain equal numbers of enantiomeric molecules within the unit cell, that is, they are composed of achiral domains containing chiral elements of opposite handedness forming an achiral system
44. D.M. Walba M.M. Green R.J.M. Nolte E.W. Meijer Materials-Chirality, Topics in Stereochemistry Vol. 24 2003 Wiley New York 457 518
45. C. McManus Right Hand, Left Hand. The Origins of Asymmetry in Brains, Bodies, Atoms and Cultures 2002 Harvard University Cambridge, MA Chapter 14
46. Achiral symmetry breaking is also to be discouraged because supramolecular aggregates composed of chiral nonracemic molecules may display no chirality (achiral phases), such as in mesogenic structures; see for instance: H.H.v. Doren, E. Smits, J.M. Pestman, J.B.F.N. Engberts, and R.M. Kellogg Chem. Soc. Rev. 29 2000 183 199
47. See Ref. 1, pp 88-91 and references cited therein
48. R.W. Hoffmann Angew. Chem., Int. Ed. 42 2003 1096 1109
49. P.J. Walsh, A.E. Lurain, and J. Balsells Chem. Rev. 103 2003 3297 3344
50. K. Mikami, and M. Yamanaka Chem. Rev. 103 2003 3369 3400