Embedded science: Critical analysis of abstinence-only evaluation research

Cultural Studies - Critical Methodologies

Volumn 8, Issue 1, 2008, Pages 50-81

  McClelland, Sara I ^a   Fine, Michelle ^a  

^a CITY UNIVERSITY OF NEW YORK   (United States)

Author keywords

Abstinence; Embedded; Evaluation; Federal funding; Mathematica; Research design

Indexed keywords

EID: 51249131599     PISSN: 15327086     EISSN: 1552356X     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1177/1532708607310782     Document Type: Article

References (110)

1. Adolescent Family Life Act of 1981, P.L. No. 97-35, 95 Stat.
2. Adolescent Family Life (AFL) Pregnancy Prevention Care Programs core evaluation instrument: User guide, (n.d.). Retrieved November 4, 2006, from http://opa.osophs.dhhs.gov/titlexx/coreinstruments/ AFL%20Prev%20Baseline%20Instrument%209-29pdf.
3. Alexander, B. (n.d.). The new lies about women's health. Glamour. Retrieved November 4, 2006, from http://www.glamour.eom/health/feature/articles/ 2006/07/l0/ newliesaboutwomenshealth06apr.
4. Angell, M. (2000). Is academic medicine for sale? New England Journal of Medicine, 342, 1516-1518.
5. Armstrong, D. (2006, July 11). Drug interactions: Financial ties to industry cloud major depression study. The Wall Street Journal, p. A1.
6. Aronowitz, S., & Ausch, R. (2003). A critique of methodological reason. Sociological Quarterly 41(4), 699-719.
7. Aronson, E. (2004). The social animal. New York: Worth.
8. Arsneault, S. (2001). Values and virtue: The politics of abstinence-only sex education. American Review of Public Administration, 31(4), 436-454.
9. Barnette, J. J. (2000). Effects of stem and Likert response option reversals on survey internal consistency: If you feel the need, there is a better alternative to using those negatively worded stems. Educational and Psychological Measurement, 60(3), 361-370.
10. Bearman, P., & Brückner, H. (2001). Promising the future: Virginity pledges and the transition to first intercourse. American Journal of Sociology, 206(4), 859-912.
11. Beil, L. (2007, July 18). Abstinence education faces an uncertain future. The New York Times. Available at http://www.nytimes.com/2007/07/18/education/ 18abstain.html
12. Benson, J., & Hocevar, D. (1985).The impact of item phrasing on the validity of attitude scales for elementary school children. Journal of Educational Measurement, 22, 231-240.
13. Bero, L. A., & Rennie, D. (1996). Influences on the quality of published drug studies. International Journal of Technology Assessment in Health Care, 12, 209-237.
14. Bodenheimer, T. (2000). Uneasy alliance - Clinical investigators and the pharmaceutical industry. New EnglandJournal of Medicine, 342, 1284-1286.
15. Borawski, E. A., Trapl, E. S., Lovegreen, L. D., Colabianchi, N., & Block, T. (2005). Effectiveness of abstinence-only intervention in middle school teens. American Journal of Health Behavior, 29(5), 423-434.
16. Boyd, E. A., & Bero, L. A. (2000). Assessing faculty financial relationships with industry: A case study. Journal of the American Medical Association, 284, 2209-2214.
17. Brückner, H., & Bearman, P. (2005). After the promise: The STD consequences of adolescent virginity pledges. Journal of Adolescent Health, 36, 271-278. Retrieved July 31, 2006, from http://www.iserp.columbia.edu/people/ downloads/after_the_promise.pdf
18. Bush, G. W. (1998, April 6). George W. Bush on families & children (Powell Lecture Series, Texas A&M University). Retrieved November 4, 2006, from http://www.ontheissues.org/Celeb/George_W_Bush_Families_+_Children.htm
19. Carter, T. (2004). Evaluation report for the Kansas Abstinence Education Program. Topeka: Kansas Department of Health and Environment.
20. Choosing the Best. (2006). About us. Retrieved November 4, 2006, from http://www .choosingthebest.org/faqs/index.html
21. Cohen, L. S., Altshuler, L. L., Harlow, B. L., Nonans, R., Newport, D. J., Viguera, A. C., et al. (2006). Relapse of major depression during pregnancy in women who maintain or discontinue antidepressant treatment. Journal of the American Medical Association, 295(5), 499-507.
22. Committee on Government Reform, Minority Staff, Special Investigations Division. (2003, August). Politics and science in the Bush administration [Prepared for Rep. Henry A. Waxman. U.S. House of Representatives]. Available at http://oversight.house.gov/features/politics_and_science/pdfs/ pdf_politics_and_science_rep.pdf
23. Committee on Government Reform, Minority Staff, Special Investigations Division. (2004). The content of federally-funded abstinence-only education programs [Prepared for Rep. Henry A. Waxman. U.S. House of Representatives]. Retrieved November 4, 2006, from http://reform.democrats.house.gov/Documents/ 20041201102153-50247.pdf
24. Devaney, B., Johnson, A., Maynard, R., & Trenholm, C. (2002 April). The evaluation of abstinence education programs funded under Title V Section 510: Interim report. Princeton, NJ: Mathematica Policy Research.
25. Diamond, L. (2000). Sexual identity, attractions and behavior among young sexual-minority women over a 2-year period. Developmental Psychology, 36(2), 241-250.
26. Diamond, L. M. (2003). New paradigms for research on heterosexual and sexual-minority development. Journal of Clinical Child and Adolescent Psychology, 32(4), 490-498.
27. Diamond, L. M. (2005). Toward greater specificity in modeling the ecological context of desire. Human Development, 48(5), 291-297.
28. Diamond, L. M. (2006a). How do I love thee?: Implications of attachment theory for understanding same-sex love and desire. In M. Mikulincer & G. S. Goodman (Eds.), Dynamics of romantic love: Attachment, caregiving, and sex (pp. 275-292). New York: Guilford.
29. Diamond, L. M. (2006b). Introduction: In search of good sexual-development pathways for adolescent girls. New Directions for Child and Adolescent Development, 112, 1-7.
30. Diamond, L. M. (2006c). What we got wrong about sexual identity development: Unexpected findings from a longitudinal study of young women. In A. M. Omoto & H. W. Kurtzman (Eds.), Sexual orientation and mental health: Examining identity and development in lesbian, gay, and bisexual people (pp. 73-94). Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.
31. DiCenso A., Guyatt, G., Willan, A., & Griffith, L. (2002). Interventions to reduce unintended pregnancies among adolescents: systematic review of randomised controlled trials. British Medical Journal, 324, 1426-1434.
32. Dickson, N., Paul, C., Herbison, P., & Silva, P. (1998). First sexual intercourse: Age, coercion and later regrets reported by a birth cohort. British Medical Journal, 316, 29-33.
33. Dictionary.com. (2006). Retrieved November 4, 2006, from http://dictionary.reference.com/search?q=embedded.
34. Dimitraidis, G. (2008, this issue). Re-visiting the question of evidence. Critical Studies ↔ Critical Methodologies.
35. Doniger, A. S., Adams, E., Utter, C. A., & Riley, J. S. (2001). Impact evaluation of the "Not Me, Not Now" abstinence-oriented, adolescent pregnancy prevention communications program, Monroe County, New York. Journal of Health Communication, 6(1), 45-60.
36. The evaluation of abstinence education programs funded under Title V, Section 510. (n.d.). Retrieved November 4, 2006, from http://mailgate.supereva. com/gov/gov.us.fed.doc.cbd.awards/msg00118.html
37. Feijoo, A. N. (2001). Adolescent sexual health in Europe and the U.S.: Why the difference? (2nd ed.). Washington, DC: Advocates for Youth.
38. Fields, J. (2005). "Children having children": Race, innocence, and sexuality education. Social Problems, 52(4), 549-571.
39. Fine, M., & McClelland, S. I. (2006). Sexuality education and desire: Still missing after all these years. Harvard Educational Review, 76(3), 297-338.
40. Fine, M., & McClelland, S. I. (2007). The politics of teen women's sexuality: Public policy and the adolescent female body. Emory Law Journal, 56(4), 993-1038.
41. Foucault, M. (1990). The history of sexuality, vol. 1 (R. Hurley, Trans.) London: Penguin. (Original work published 1976)
42. Government Reform Minority Office. (2006). The effectiveness of abstinence-only education. Retrieved November 4, 2006, from http://www. democrats.reform.house.gov/features/politics_and_science/ example_abstinence.htm
43. Haignere, C. S., Gold, R., & McDanel, H. J. (1999). Adolescent abstinence and condom use: Are we sure we are really teaching what is safe? Health Education & Behavior, 26(1), 43-54.
44. Hauser, D. (2004). Five years of abstinence only until marriage education: Assessing the impact. New York: Advocates for Youth.
45. Horne, S., & Zimmer-Gembeck, M.J. (2006). The Female Sexual Subjectivity Inventory: Development and validation of a multidimensional inventory for late adolescents and emerging adults. Psychology of Women Quarterly, 30(2), 125-138.
46. Huber, V. (2007, July 30). Opposing view: Abstinence works. USA Today. Available at http://blogs.usatoday.com/oped/2007/07/abstinence-work.html/
47. Kaiser Family Foundation. (2005, October 7). Consultant, former member of FDA Advisory Panel resigns over handling of Plan B Application. Retrieved November 4, 2006, from http://www.kaisernetwork.org/daily_reports/rep_index.cfm? DR_ID=32989
48. Kay, J/ F. (2007, July 17). The politics of sex. Boston Globe. Available at http://www.boston.com/news/globe/editorial_opinion/oped/articles/2007/07/17/ the_politics_of_sex/
49. Kelly, H. (2006). Science policy in the United States: A commentary on the state of the art. Social Research, 73(3), 737-752.
50. Kelly, K. (2005, October 17). Just don't do it. U.S. News and World Report, 44-51.
51. Kepplinger, G. L. (2006, October 18). Abstinence education: Applicability of Section 317P of the Public Health Service Act. Retrieved November 4, 2006, from http://www.gao.gov/decisions/other/308128.pdf
52. Kirby, D. (1997). No easy answers: Research findings on programs to reduce teen pregnancy. Washington, DC: National Campaign to Prevent Teen Pregnancy.
53. Kirby, D. (2002a, October). Do abstinence-only programs delay the initiation of sex among young people and reduce teen pregnancy? Washington, DC: National Campaign to Prevent Teen Pregnancy. Retrieved October 31, 2006, from https://www.teenpregnancy.org/resources/data/pdf/abstinence_eval.pdf
54. Kirby, D. (2002b). Effective approaches to reducing adolescent unprotected sex, pregnancy, and childbearing. Journal of Sex Research, 39(1), 51-57.
55. Kirby, D., Short, L., Collins, J., Rugg, D., Kolbe, L., Howard, M., et al. (1994). School-based programs to reduce sexual risk behaviors: A review of effectiveness. Public Health Reports, 109(3), 339-360.
56. LaPiere, R. (1934). Attitudes versus action. Social Forces, 13, 230-237.
57. Lather, P. (2005, April). Scientism and scientificity in the rage for accountability: A feminist deconstruction. Paper presented at the American Educational Research Association Annual Conference.
58. LeCroy & Milligan Associates. (2003, June). Final report, Arizona Abstinence Only Education Program 1998-2003. Phoenix: Arizona Department of Health Services, Office of Women's and Children's Health. Retrieved October 27, 2007, from http://www.azdhs.gov/phs/owch/pdf/abstinence_final_report2003.pdf
59. Manlove, J., Papillio, A. R., & Ikramullah, E. (2004, September). Not yet: Programs to delay first sex among teens. Washington, DC: National Campaign to Prevent Teen Pregnancy.
60. Mann, J., McIlhaney, J. S., & Stine, C. S. (2000). Building healthy futures. Austin, TX: Medical Institute for Sexual Health.
61. Marcus, G. E. (1995). Ethnography in/of the world system: The emergence of multi-sited ethnography. Annual Review of Anthropology, 24(1), 95-117.
62. Marcus, G. E., & Fischer, M. M. (1986). Anthropology as cultural critique: An experimental moment in the human sciences. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
63. Mathematica Policy Research, Inc. (2000). Wave II survey of teen activities and attitudes. Princeton, NJ: Author.
64. Mathematica Policy Research, Inc. (2005). Press release. Retrieved November 4, 2006, from http://www.mathematica-mpr.com/Press%20Releases/ abstinence.asp
65. Mathematica Policy Research, Inc. (2007). Impacts of four abstinence education programs. Princeton, NJ: Author. Available at http://www.mathematica- mpr.com/abstinencereport.asp
66. Maynard, R. A., Trenholm, C., Devaney, B., Johnson, A., Clark, M. A., Homrighausen, J., et al. (2005, June). First-year impacts of four Title V, Section 510 abstinence education programs. Princeton, NJ: Mathematica Policy Research.
67. Medina, J. (2007, September 21). New York just says no to abstinence funding. The New York Times. Available at http://www.nytimes.com/2007/09/21/ nyregion/21schools.html?_r=2&oref= slogin&oref=slogin
68. Metcalfe, J. A., & Shimamura, A. P. (1994). Metacognition: Knowing about knowing. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
69. Mooney, C. (2005). The republican war on science. New York: Basic Books.
70. Mooney, C. Z., & Lee, M. (1995). Legislating morality in the American states: The case of pre-Roe abortion regulation reform. American Journal of Political Science, 39, 599-627.
71. Mooney, C. Z., & Lee, M. (1999). Morality policy reinvention: Death penalty policy in the American states. Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, 566, 80-93.
72. National Public Radio, Kaiser Family Foundation, & Harvard University. (2004, January). Sex education in America: General public/parents survey. Menlo Park, CA: Kaiser Family Foundation. Retrieved July 31, 2006, from http://www.npr.org/programs/morning/features/2004/jan/kaiserpoll/publicfinal.pdf
73. Nelson, T. O. (1992). Metacognition: Core readings. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
74. O'Sullivan, L. F., Meyer-Bahlburg, H. F. L., McKeague, I. W. (2006). The development of the sexual self-concept inventory for early adolescent girls. Psychology of Women Quarterly, 30, 139-149.
75. Office of Adolescent Pregnancy Programs. (2006). AFL Abstinence Education Demonstration Projects FY 2005/2006. Retrieved November 4, 2006, from http://opa.osophs.dhhs.gov/titlexx/afl-grantees-ae.html
76. Oswald, D. L., & Russell, B. L. (2006). Perceptions of sexual coercion in heterosexual dating relationships: The role of aggressor gender and tactics. Journal of Sex Research, 43(1), 87-95
77. Pinkerton, S. D. (2001). A relative risk-based, disease-specific definition of sexual abstinence failure rates. Health Education & Behavior, 28(1), 10-20.
78. Popper, K. (1945). The open society and its enemies. London: Routledge.
79. Regan, D. T., & Fazio, R. H. (1977). On the consistency between attitudes and behavior: Look to the method of attitude formation. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 13, 38-45.
80. Remez, L. (2000). Oral sex among adolescents: Is it sex or is it abstinence?. Family Planning Perspectives, 32(6). Retrieved November 4, 2006, from http://www.guttmacher.org/pubs/journals/3229800.html
81. Robb, A. (2007, October 18). Abstinence 1, S-chip 0. The New York Times. Available at http://www.nytimes.com/2007/10/18/opinion/18robb.html
82. Rosario, M., Schrimshaw, E. W., Hunter, J., & Braun, L. (2006). Sexual identity development among lesbian, gay, and bisexual youths: Consistency and change over time. Journal of Sex Research, 43(1), 46-58.
83. Rose, T. (2003). Longing to tell. New York: Farrar, Straus & Giroux.
84. A sad day for science at the FDA [Editorial]. (2005, September 22). New England Journal of Medicine.
85. Schaffner, L. (2004). Capturing girls' experiences of "community violence" in the United States. In C. Alder & A. Worrall (Eds.), Girls' violence (pp. 105-129). Albany: SUNY Press.
86. Seiler, N. (2002, April). Is teen marriage a solution? Washington, DC: Center for Law and Social Policy.
87. Sessions Stepp, L. (2007, April 14). Study casts doubt on abstinence-only programs. Washington Post, p. AO2. Available at http://www.washingtonpost.com/ wp-dyn/content/article/2007/04/13/AR2007041301003. html?hpid=topnews
88. Sexuality Information and Education Council of the U.S. (2004). State profiles (2004): A portrait of sexuality education and abstinence only until marriage programs in the States. Washington, DC: Author. Retrieved July 31, 2006, from http://www.siecus.org/policy/states/
89. Sexuality Information and Education Council of the U.S. (2005). A brief explanation of federal abstinence-only-until-marriage funding. Washington, DC: Author. Retrieved July 31, 2006, from http://www.siecus.org/policy/states/2005/ explanation.html
90. Sexuality Information and Education Council of the U.S. (2006, July 19). States and communities push back against abstinence-only-until-marriage dictates from Washington while proliferation of programs continues. Washington, DC: Author. Retrieved October 31, 2006, from http://www.siecus.org/media/press/ press0130.html
91. Shorto, R. (2006, May 7). Contra-contraception. The New York Times Magazine. Retrieved October 27, 2007, from http://www.nytimes.com/2006/05/07/ magazine/07contraception.html? ex+1304654400&en=fd92772f01a5c709&ei= 5088&partner=rssnyt&emc=rss
92. Sides, H. (2003, March 24). Unembedded. The New Yorker. Available at www/newyorker.com/talk/content/?030324ta_talk_sides
93. Smith, E., Dariotis, J., & Potter, S. (2003). Evaluation of the Pennsylvania Abstinence Education and Related Services Initiative: 1998-2002. Philadelphia: Pennsylvania Department of Health, Maternal and Child Health Bureau of Family Health. Retrieved November 4, 2006, from http://www.dsf.health. state.pa.us/health/lib/health/familyhealth/ evaluationpaabstinence1998-20021. pdf
94. Smith, R. (2001). Maintaining the integrity of the scientific record. British Medical Journal, 323, 588.
95. Smith, W. (2007, September 28). SIECUS statement on temporary Title V extension. Sexuality Information and Education Council of the United States. Available at http://www.siecus.org/media/press/press0152.html
96. Sonfield, A. (2005, November). The uses and abuses of science in sexual and reproductive health policy debates. The Guttmacher Report on Public Policy. Available at http://www.guttmacher.org/pubs/tgr/08/4/gr080401.html
97. Thompson, S. (1990). Putting a big thing into a little hole: Teenage girls' accounts of sexual initiation. Journal of Sex Research, 27(3), 341-361.
98. Tolman, D. L. (1994). Doing desire: Adolescent girls' struggles for/with sexuality. Gender & Society, 8(3), 324-342.
99. Tolman, D. L. (2002). Dilemmas of desire. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
100. Tolman, D. L. (2006). In a different position: Conceptualizing female adolescent sexuality development within compulsory heterosexuality In L. Diamond (Ed.), New directions in child and adolescent development: Positive female adolescent sexuality, No. 112 (pp. 71-89). San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
101. Tolman, D. L., Striepe, M., & Harmon, P. (2003). Gender matters: Constructing a model of adolescent sexual health. Journal of Sex Research, 40(1), 4-12.
102. Trenholm, C., Devaney, B., Forton, K., Quay, L., Wheeler, J., & Clark, M. (2007). Impacts of Four Title V, Section 510 Abstinence Education Programs. Princeton, NJ: Mathematica Policy Research. Available at http://www.mathematica-mpr.com/publications/PDFs/impactabstinence.pdf
103. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. (2003). Understanding Title V of the Social Security Act: A guide to the provisions of the federal maternal and child health block grants. Rockville, MD: Maternal and Child Health Bureau. Retrieved August 4, 2006, from http://www.dph.state.ct.us/BCH/Family%20Health/ cyshcn/understandingtitlev.pdf
104. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. (2006). Family and Youth Services Bureau: Administration on children, youth, and families; Community-based abstinence education program (Request for proposals. Funding opportunity number: HHS-2006-ACF-ACYF-AE-0099). Rockville, MD: Author. Retrieved August 4, 2006, from http://www.acf.hhs.gov/grants/pdf/HHS-2006-ACF-ACYF-AE- 0099.pdf
105. U.S. Government Accountability Office. (2006, October). Abstinence education: Efforts to assess the accuracy and effectiveness of federally funded programs (Report to Congressional Requesters). Washington, DC: Author. Available at: http://www.gao.gov/new.items/d0787.pdf
106. U.S. Office of Management and Budget. (2006, August 4). Health and human services: Enhancing the faith-based and community initiative. Washington, DC: Author. Retrieved August 4, 2006, from http://www.whitehouse.gov/omb/budget/ fy2007/hhs.html
107. Vesely, R. (2006, October 23). Some states abstain from abstinence-only funding. Women's E-News. Retrieved November 4, 2006, from http://www. womensenews.org/article.cfm?aid=2932
108. Waxman, H. A. (2006, May 9). [Letter to Michael O. Leavitt]. Retrieved November 4, 2006, from http://www.democrats.reform.house.gov/Documents/ 20060509105051-30240.pdf
109. Wicker, A. W. (1969). Attitudes versus actions: The relationship of verbal and overt behavioral responses to attitude objects. Journal of Social Issues, 25(4), 41-78.
110. Woolley, J. T., & Peters, G. (n.d.a) The American Presidency Project [online]. Santa Barbara: University of California (hosted), Gerhard Peters (database). Available at http://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/ws/?pid=18393