Why good thoughts block better ones: The mechanism of the pernicious Einstellung (set) effect

Cognition

Volumn 108, Issue 3, 2008, Pages 652-661

  Bilalić, Merim ^a   McLeod, Peter ^a   Gobet, Fernand ^b  

^a UNIVERSITY OF OXFORD   (United Kingdom)

^b BRUNEL UNIVERSITY   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Chess; Confirmation bias; Einstellung (set) effect; Expertise; Eye movements; Fixation; Problem solving; Thinking

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE; COGNITION; EINSTELLUNG EFFECT; EYE MOVEMENT; HUMAN; HUMAN EXPERIMENT; INFORMATION; MALE; NORMAL HUMAN; PRIORITY JOURNAL; PROBLEM SOLVING; SPORT; THINKING;

ADULT; ATTENTION; EYE MOVEMENTS; FEMALE; GAMES, EXPERIMENTAL; HUMANS; MALE; PROBLEM SOLVING; RECOGNITION (PSYCHOLOGY); SET (PSYCHOLOGY); STEREOTYPED BEHAVIOR; THINKING;

EID: 51249097724     PISSN: 00100277     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.cognition.2008.05.005     Document Type: Article

References (83)

1. Anderson C.M., Bjork A.R., and Bjork L.E. Remembering can cause forgetting: Retrieval dynamics in long-term memory. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition 20 (1994) 1063-1087
2. Atwood M.E., and Polson P.G. A process model for water jug problems. Cognitive Psychology 8 (1976) 191-216
3. Bacon F. Novum organum. In: Burtt E.A. (Ed). The English philosophers from Bacon to Mill (1939), Random House, New York 24-123 [Original work published in 1620]
4. Baron J. Thinking and deciding. 2nd ed. (1994), Cambridge University Press, New York
5. Basden D.R., and Basden B.H. Some tests of the strategy disruption interpretation of part-list cuing inhibition. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition 21 (1995) 1656-1669
6. Besnard D., and Cacitti L. Interface changes causing accidents. An empirical study of negative transfer. International Journal of Human Computer Studies 62 (2005) 105-125
7. Bilalić M., McLeod P., and Gobet F. Inflexibility of experts-Reality or myth? Quantifying the Einstellung effect in chess masters. Cognitive Psychology 56 (2008) 73-102
8. Bowden E.M., and Jung-Beeman M. Getting the right idea: Semantic activation in the right hemisphere may help solve insight problems. Psychological Science 9 (1998) 435-440
9. Charness N., Reingold E.M., Pomplun M., and Stampe D.M. The perceptual aspect of skilled performance in chess: Evidence from eye movements. Memory & Cognition 29 (2001) 1146-1152
10. Chen Z., and Mo L. Schema induction in problem solving: A multidimensional analysis. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition 30 (2004) 583-600
11. Croskerry P. The importance of cognitive errors in diagnosis and strategies to minimize them. Academic Medicine 78 (2003) 775-780
12. Dawson E., Gilovich T., and Regan D.T. Motivated reasoning and performance on the Wason selection task. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 28 (2002) 1379-1387
13. De Groot A.D., and Gobet F. Perception and memory in chess (1996), Van Gorcum, Assen, Holland
14. Defeyter M.A., and German T.P. Acquiring an understanding of design: Evidence from children's insight problem solving. Cognition 89 (2003) 133-155
15. Delaney P.F., Ericsson K.A., and Knowles M.E. Immediate and sustained effects of planning in a problem-solving task. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition 30 (2004) 1219-1234
16. Drinkwater K., Dagnall N., and Parker A. Effects of part-set cuing on experienced and novice chess players' reconstruction of a typical chess midgame position. Perceptual & Motor Skills 102 (2006) 645-653
17. Duncker K. On problem-solving. Psychological Monographs 58 ix (1945) 113
18. Elo A.E. The rating of chess players, past and present (1978), Arco, New York
19. Epelboim J., and Suppes P. A model of eye movements and visual working memory during problem solving in geometry. Vision Research 41 (2001) 1561-1574
20. Ericsson K.A., and Simon H.A. Protocol analysis: Verbal reports as data (rev. Ed.) (1993), The MIT Press, Cambridge, MA
21. Findlay J.M., and Gilchrist I.D. Eye guidance and visual search. In: Underwood G. (Ed). Eye guidance in reading and scene perception (1998), Elsevier Science, Oxford, England 295-312
22. Frensch P.A., and Sternberg R.J. Expertise and intelligent thinking: When is it worse to know better?. In: Sternberg R.J. (Ed). Advances in the psychology of human intelligence Vol. 5 (1989), Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Hillsdale, NJ 157-188
23. Friedrich J. Primary error detection and minimization (PEDMIN) strategies in social cognition: A reinterpretation of confirmation bias phenomena. Psychological Review 100 (1993) 298-319
24. Gardner H. Changing minds (2004), Harvard Business School Press, Cambridge, MA
25. Gobet F., Lane P.C.R., Croker S., Cheng P.C.H., Jones G., Oliver I., et al. Chunking mechanisms in human learning. Trends in Cognitive Sciences 5 (2001) 236-243
26. Gobet F., and Simon H.A. Templates in chess memory: A mechanism for recalling several boards. Cognitive Psychology 31 (1996) 1-40
27. Gobet F., and Simon H.A. Five seconds or sixty? Presentation time in expert memory. Cognitive Science 24 (2000) 651-682
28. Gould S.J. The mismeasure of man. 2nd ed. (1996), W. W. Norton & Company, New York
29. Graber M.L., Franklin N., and Gordon R. Diagnostic error in internal medicine. Archives of Internal Medicine 165 (2005) 1493-1499
30. Grant E.R., and Spivey M.J. Eye movements and problem solving: Guiding attention guides thought. Psychological Science 14 (2003) 462-466
31. Groopman J. How doctors think (2007), Houghton Mifflin, New York
32. Hecht H., and Proffitt D.R. The price of expertise: Effects of experience on the water-level task. Psychological Science 6 (1995) 90-95
33. Hodgson T.L., Bajwa A., Owen A.M., and Kennard C. The strategic control of gaze direction in the Tower of London task. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 12 (2000) 894-907
34. Jones G. Testing two cognitive theories of insight. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory and Cognition 29 (2003) 1017-1027
35. Just A.M., and Carpenter A.P. Eye fixations and cognitive processes. Cognitive Psychology 8 (1976) 441-480
36. Kanouse D.E. Language, labeling, and attribution. In: Jones E.E., Kanouse D.E., Kelley H.H., Nisbett R.E., Valins S., and Weiner B. (Eds). Attribution: Perceiving the causes of behavior (1972), General Learning Press, Morristown, NJ 1-26
37. Kaplan C.A., and Simon H.A. In search of insight. Cognitive Psychology 22 (1990) 374-419
38. Kassirer J.P., and Kopelman R.I. Cognitive errors in diagnosis: Instantiation, classification, and consequences. American Journal of Medicine 86 (1989) 433-441
39. Keren G. On the importance of identifying the correct 'problem space'. Cognition 16 (1984) 121-128
40. Kershaw T.C., and Ohlsson S. Multiple causes of difficulty in insight: The case of the nine-dot problem. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, & Cognition 30 (2004) 3-13
41. Keynes J.M. The general theory of employment, interest and money (1973), MacMillan, London, London [Original work published 1936]
42. Knoblich G., Ohlsson S., Haider H., and Rhenius D. Constraint relaxation and chunk decomposition in insight problem solving. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory & Cognition 25 (1999) 1534-1555
43. Knoblich G., Ohlsson S., and Raney E.G. An eye movement study of insight problem solving. Memory & Cognition 29 (2001) 1000-1009
44. Köhler W. The mentality of apes (1925), Harcourt Brace & World, New York [Original work published 1917]
45. Lippman L.G. A short report concerning the Einstellung effect. Journal of General Psychology 123 (1996) 233-235
46. Lord G.C., Ross L., and Lepper R.M. Biased assimilation and attitude polarization: The effects of prior theories on subsequently considered evidence. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 37 (1979) 2098-2109
47. Lovett M.C., and Anderson J.R. History of success and current context in problem solving: Combined influences on operator selection. Cognitive Psychology 31 (1996) 168-217
48. Luchins A.S. Mechanization in problem solving - The effect of Einstellung. Psychological Monographs 54 6 (1942) 95
49. MacCoun R.J. Biases in the interpretation and use of research results. Annual Review of Psychology 49 (1998) 259-287
50. MacGregor J.N., Ormerod T.C., and Chronicle E.P. Information processing and insight: A process model of performance on the nine-dot and related problems. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, & Cognition 27 (2001) 176-201
51. Maier N.R.F. Reasoning in humans. I. On direction. Journal of Comparative Psychology 10 (1930) 115-143
52. Maier N.R.F. Reasoning in humans. II. The solution of a problem and its appearance in consciousness. Journal of Comparative Psychology 12 (1931) 181-194
53. McCloy R., Beaman C.P., Morgan B., and Speed R. Training conditional and cumulative risk judgements: The role of frequencies, problem-structure and Einstellung. Applied Cognitive Psychology 21 (2007) 325-344
54. McKenzie C.R.M. Increased sensitivity to differentially diagnostic answers using familiar materials: Implications for confirmation bias. Memory and Cognition 34 (2006) 577-588
55. Metcalfe J. Premonitions of insight predict impending error. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition 12 (1987) 623-634
56. Metcalfe J., and Fisher R.P. The relation between recognition memory and classification learning. Memory and cognition 14 (1987) 164-173
57. Nickerson R.S. Confirmation bias: A ubiquitous phenomenon in many guises. Review of General Psychology 2 (1998) 175-220
58. Norman D.A. Categorization of action slips. Psychological Review 88 (1981) 1-15
59. Ohlsson S. Information-processing explanations of insight and related phenomena. In: Keane M., and Gilhooly K. (Eds). Advances in the psychology of thinking (1992), Harvester-Wheatsheaf, London 1-44
60. Rayner K. Eye movements in reading and information processing: 20 years of research. Psychological Bulletin 124 (1998) 372-422
61. Reason J. Human error (1990), Cambridge University Press, New York
62. Reingold E.M., Charness N., Pomplun M., and Stampe D.M. Visual span in expert chess players: Evidence from eye movements. Psychological Science 12 (2001) 48-55
63. Reingold E.M., Charness N., Schultetus R.S., and Stampe D.M. Perceptual automaticity in expert chess players: Parallel encoding of chess relations. Psychonomic Bulletin and Review 8 (2001) 504-510
64. Roediger L.H. Inhibition in recall from cueing with recall targets. Journal of Verbal Learning & Verbal Behavior 12 (1973) 644-657
65. Rokeach M. The open and closed mind (1960), Basic Books, Oxford, England
66. Saariluoma P. Apperception and restructuring in chess players' problem solving. In: Gilhooly K.J., Keane M.T.G., Logie R.H., and Erdos G. (Eds). Lines of thought: Reflections on the psychology of thinking (1990), Wiley, London 41-57
67. Saariluoma P. Error in chess: The apperception-restructuring view. Psychological Research 54 (1992) 17-26
68. Schooler J., Ohlsson S., and Brooks K. Thoughts beyond words: When language overshadows insight. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General 122 (1993) 166-183
69. Schwartz B. Reinforcement-induced behavioral stereotypy: How not to teach people to discover rules. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General 111 (1982) 23-59
70. Schwartz D., Bransford J., and Sears D. Efficiency and innovation in transfer. In: Mestre J. (Ed). Transfer of learning from a modern multidisciplinary perspective (2005), Information Age Publishing, Greenwich, CT 1-51
71. Simon H.A. Rational choice and the structure of the environment. Psychological Review 63 (1956) 129-138
72. Simon H.A. Alternative visions of rationality. In: Moser P.K. (Ed). Rationality in action: Contemporary approaches (1990), Cambridge University Press, New York 189-204
73. Singley M.K., and Anderson J.R. The transfer of cognitive skill (1989), Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA
74. Smith M.S. Fixation, incubation, and insight in memory and creative thinking. In: Smith M.S., Ward B.T., and Finke A.R. (Eds). The creative cognition approach (1995), The MIT Press, Cambridge, MA 135-156
75. Tetlock P. Expert political judgement: How good is it? How can we know? (2005), Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ
76. Thorndike E.L., and Woodworth R.S. The influence of improvement in one mental function upon the efficiency of other functions. Psychological Review 8 (1901) 247-261
77. Tikhomirov O.K., and Poznyanskaya E. An investigation of visual search as a means of analyzing heuristics. Soviet Psychology 5 (1966) 2-15
78. Van Gog T., Paas F., and Van Merrienboer J.J.G. Uncovering expertise-related differences in troubleshooting performance: Combining eye movement and concurrent verbal protocol data. Applied Cognitive Psychology 19 (2005) 205-221
79. Wason C.P. On the failure to eliminate hypotheses in a conceptual task. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology 12 (1960) 129-140
80. Watkins M.J., Schwartz D.R., and Lane D.M. Does part-set cueing test for memory organization? Evidence from reconstruction of chess positions. Canadian Journal of Psychology 38 (1984) 498-503
81. Westen D., Kilts C., Blagov P., Harenski K., and Hamann S. The neural basis of motivated reasoning: An fMRI study of emotional constraints on political judgment during the U.S. Presidential election of 2004. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 18 (2006) 1947-1958
82. Wiley J. Expertise as mental set: The effects of domain knowledge in creative problem solving. Memory and Cognition 26 (1998) 716-730
83. Woltz D.J., Gardner M.K., and Bell B.G. Negative transfer errors in sequential cognitive skills: Strong-but-wrong sequence application. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition 26 (2000) 601-625