A comparison of pancreaticoduodenectomy with pylorus preserving pancreaticoduodenectomy: A meta-analysis of 2822 patients

European Journal of Surgical Oncology

Volumn 34, Issue 11, 2008, Pages 1237-1245

  Iqbal, N ^a   Lovegrove, R E ^b   Tilney, H S ^b   Abraham, A T ^a   Bhattacharya, S ^a   Tekkis, P P ^b   Kocher, H M ^a  

^a ROYAL LONDON HOSPITAL   (United Kingdom)

^b ST MARY S HOSPITAL   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Blood loss; Complications; Gastric emptying; Length of stay; Operative time; Survival

Indexed keywords

ABDOMINAL ABSCESS; ARTICLE; BILE DUCT FISTULA; BILE LEAKAGE; CANCER SURVIVAL; CHOLANGITIS; CLINICAL TRIAL; COMPARATIVE STUDY; HUMAN; META ANALYSIS; PANCREAS CANCER; PANCREAS FISTULA; PANCREATICODUODENECTOMY; POSTGASTRECTOMY SYNDROME; POSTOPERATIVE COMPLICATION; POSTOPERATIVE HEMORRHAGE; PRIORITY JOURNAL; PYLORUS PRESERVING PANCREATICODUODENECTOMY; QUALITY OF LIFE; REOPERATION; SURGICAL TECHNIQUE; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW; WOUND INFECTION;

HUMANS; LENGTH OF STAY; PANCREATIC NEOPLASMS; PANCREATICODUODENECTOMY; PYLORUS; SURVIVAL RATE; TREATMENT OUTCOME;

EID: 49249102122     PISSN: 07487983     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.ejso.2007.12.004     Document Type: Article

References (70)

1. O'Sullivan A., and Kocher H.M. Pancreatic cancer. BMJ Clin Evid 11 (2007) 409-436
2. Neoptolemos J.P., Stocken D.D., Friess H., et al. A randomized trial of chemoradiotherapy and chemotherapy after resection of pancreatic cancer. N Engl J Med 350 12 (2004) 1200-1210
3. Kausch W. Das Carcinom der Papilla duodeni und seine radikale Entfernung. Beitr Klin Chir 78 (1912) 439-486
4. Whipple A., Parson W., and Mullins C. Treatment of carcinoma of the ampulla of Vater. Ann Surg 102 (1935) 763-779
5. Trede M., and Carter D.C. Surgery of the pancreas (1993), Churchill Livingstone, Edinburgh
6. Watson K. Carcinoma of ampulla of Vater. Successful radical resection. Br J Surg 31 (1944) 368-373
7. Braasch J.W., Deziel D.J., Rossi R.L., Watkins Jr. E., and Winter P.F. Pyloric and gastric preserving pancreatic resection. Experience with 87 patients. Ann Surg 204 4 (1986) 411-418
8. Traverso L.W., and Longmire Jr. W.P. Preservation of the pylorus in pancreaticoduodenectomy. Surg Gynecol Obstet 146 6 (1978) 959-962
9. Braasch J.W., and Rossi R.L. Pyloric preservation with the Whipple procedure. Surg Clin N Am 65 2 (1985) 263-271
10. Lin P.W., Shan Y.S., Lin Y.J., and Hung C.J. Pancreaticoduodenectomy for pancreatic head cancer: PPPD versus Whipple procedure. Hepatogastroenterology 52 65 (2005) 1601-1604
11. Seiler C.A., Wagner M., Bachmann T., et al. Randomized clinical trial of pylorus-preserving duodenopancreatectomy versus classical Whipple resection-long term results. Br J Surg 92 5 (2005) 547-556
12. Tran K.T., Smeenk H.G., van Eijck C.H., et al. Pylorus preserving pancreaticoduodenectomy versus standard Whipple procedure: a prospective, randomized, multicenter analysis of 170 patients with pancreatic and periampullary tumors. Ann Surg 240 5 (2004) 738-745
13. Kozuschek W., Reith H.B., Waleczek H., Haarmann W., Edelmann M., and Sonntag D. A comparison of long term results of the standard Whipple procedure and the pylorus preserving pancreatoduodenectomy. J Am Coll Surg 178 5 (1994) 443-453
14. Belli L., Riolo F., Romani F., Baticci F., Rossetti O., and Puttini M. Pylorus preserving pancreatoduodenectomy versus Whipple procedure for adenocarcinoma of the head of the pancreas. HPB Surg 1 3 (1989) 195-200
15. Haarmann W., Busing M., Reith H.B., Wysocki P., and Kozuschek W. The oncological approach to pylorus preserving pancreatoduodenectomy (PPPD) in pancreas malignancies. Wiad Lek 50 Suppl 1 Pt 2 (1997) 140-144
16. Mosca F., Giulianotti P.C., Balestracci T., et al. Long-term survival in pancreatic cancer: pylorus-preserving versus Whipple pancreatoduodenectomy. Surgery 122 3 (1997) 553-566
17. Takao S., Aikou T., Shinchi H., et al. Comparison of relapse and long-term survival between pylorus-preserving and Whipple pancreaticoduodenectomy in periampullary cancer. Am J Surg 176 5 (1998) 467-470
18. Roder J.D., Stein H.J., Huttl W., and Siewert J.R. Pylorus-preserving versus standard pancreatico-duodenectomy: an analysis of 110 pancreatic and periampullary carcinomas. Br J Surg 79 2 (1992) 152-155
19. Clarke M., and Horton R. Bringing it all together: Lancet-Cochrane collaborate on systematic reviews. Lancet 357 9270 (2001) 1728
20. Stroup D.F., Berlin J.A., Morton S.C., et al. Meta-analysis of observational studies in epidemiology: a proposal for reporting. Meta-analysis of Observational Studies in Epidemiology (MOOSE) group. JAMA 283 15 (2000) 2008-2012
21. Egger M., Davey Smith G., Schneider M., and Minder C. Bias in meta-analysis detected by a simple, graphical test. BMJ 315 7109 (1997) 629-634
22. Haldane J.B. The estimation and significance of the logarithm of a ratio of frequencies. Ann Hum Genet 20 4 (1956) 309-311
23. Mantel N., and Haenszel W. Statistical aspects of the analysis of data from retrospective studies of disease. J Natl Cancer Inst 22 4 (1959) 719-748
24. DerSimonian R., and Laird N. Meta-analysis in clinical trials. Control Clin Trials 7 3 (1986) 177-188
25. Sterne J.A., and Davey Smith G. Sifting the evidence-what's wrong with significance tests?. BMJ 322 7280 (2001) 226-231
26. Parmar M.K., Torri V., and Stewart L. Extracting summary statistics to perform meta-analyses of the published literature for survival endpoints. Stat Med 17 24 (1998) 2815-2834
27. Athanasiou T., Al-Ruzzeh S., Kumar P., et al. Off-pump myocardial revascularization is associated with less incidence of stroke in elderly patients. Ann Thorac Surg 77 2 (2004) 745-753
28. Egger M., and Smith G.D. Misleading meta-analysis. BMJ 311 7007 (1995) 753-754
29. Di Carlo V., Zerbi A., Balzano G., and Corso V. Pylorus-preserving pancreaticoduodenectomy versus conventional Whipple operation. World J Surg 23 9 (1999) 920-925
30. Grace P.A., Pitt H.A., and Longmire W.P. Pancreatoduodenectomy with pylorus preservation for adenocarcinoma of the head of the pancreas. Br J Surg 73 8 (1986) 647-650
31. Horstmann O., Markus P.M., Ghadimi M.B., and Becker H. Pylorus preservation has no impact on delayed gastric emptying after pancreatic head resection. Pancreas 28 1 (2004) 69-74
32. Jimenez R.E., Fernandez-del Castillo C., Rattner D.W., Chang Y., and Warshaw A.L. Outcome of pancreaticoduodenectomy with pylorus preservation or with antrectomy in the treatment of chronic pancreatitis. Ann Surg 231 3 (2000) 293-300
33. Klinkenbijl J.H., van der Schelling G.P., Hop W.C., van Pel R., Bruining H.A., and Jeekel J. The advantages of pylorus-preserving pancreatoduodenectomy in malignant disease of the pancreas and periampullary region. Ann Surg 216 2 (1992) 142-145
34. Lin P.W., and Lin Y.J. Prospective randomized comparison between pylorus-preserving and standard pancreaticoduodenectomy. Br J Surg 86 5 (1999) 603-607
35. Makhija R., Tsai P., and Kingsnorth A. Pylorus-preserving pancreatoduodenectomy with Billroth I type reconstruction: a viable option for pancreatic head resection. J Hepatobiliary Pancreat Surg 9 5 (2002) 614-619
36. McAfee M.K., van Heerden J.A., and Adson M.A. Is proximal pancreatoduodenectomy with pyloric preservation superior to total pancreatectomy?. Surgery 105 3 (1989) 347-351
37. Morel P., Mathey P., Corboud H., Huber O., Egeli R.A., and Rohner A. Pylorus-preserving duodenopancreatectomy: long-term complications and comparison with the Whipple procedure. World J Surg 14 5 (1990) 642-646
38. Ogata Y., and Hishinuma S. The impact of pylorus-preserving pancreatoduodenectomy on surgical treatment for cancer of the pancreatic head. J Hepatobiliary Pancreat Surg 9 2 (2002) 223-232
39. Ohtsuka T., Yamaguchi K., Ohuchida J., et al. Comparison of quality of life after pylorus-preserving pancreatoduodenectomy and Whipple resection. Hepatogastroenterology 50 51 (2003) 846-850
40. Patel A.G., Toyama M.T., Kusske A.M., Alexander P., Ashley S.W., and Reber H.A. Pylorus-preserving Whipple resection for pancreatic cancer. Is it any better?. Arch Surg 130 8 (1995) 838-842
41. Sadowski C., Uhl W., Baer H.U., Reber P., Seiler C.A., and Buchler M.W. Delayed gastric emptying after classic and pylorus-preserving Whipple procedure. A prospective study. Dig Surg 14 (1997) 159-164
42. Seiler C.A., Wagner M., Sadowski C., Kulli C., and Buchler M.W. Randomized prospective trial of pylorus-preserving vs. Classic duodenopancreatectomy (Whipple procedure): initial clinical results. J Gastrointest Surg 4 5 (2000) 443-452
43. Seiler C.A., Wagner M., Schaller B., Sadowski C., Kulli C., and Buchler M.W. [Pylorus preserving or classical Whipple operation in tumors. Initial clinical results of a prospective randomized study]. Swiss Surg 6 5 (2000) 275-282
44. Takada T., Yasuda H., Amano H., Yoshida M., and Ando H. Results of a pylorus-preserving pancreatoduodenectomy for pancreatic cancer: a comparison with results of the Whipple procedure. Hepatogastroenterology 44 18 (1997) 1536-1540
45. Takada T., Yasuda H., Shikata J., Watanabe S., Shiratori K., and Takeuchi T. Postprandial plasma gastrin and secretin concentrations after a pancreatoduodenectomy. A comparison between a pylorus-preserving pancreatoduodenectomy and the Whipple procedure. Ann Surg 210 1 (1989) 47-51
46. Thor P.J., Matyja A., Popiela T., Szybinski Z., Huszno B., and Sobocki J. Early effects of standard and pylorus-preserving pancreatectomy on myoelectric activity and gastric emptying. Hepatogastroenterology 46 27 (1999) 1963-1967
47. Tsao J.I., Rossi R.L., and Lowell J.A. Pylorus-preserving pancreatoduodenectomy. Is it an adequate cancer operation. Arch Surg 129 4 (1994) 405-412
48. van Berge Henegouwen M.I., Moojen T.M., van Gulik T.M., Rauws E.A., Obertop H., and Gouma D.J. Postoperative weight gain after standard Whipple's procedure versus pylorus-preserving pancreatoduodenectomy: the influence of tumour status. Br J Surg 85 7 (1998) 922-926
49. van Berge Henegouwen M.I., van Gulik T.M., DeWit L.T., et al. Delayed gastric emptying after standard pancreaticoduodenectomy versus pylorus-preserving pancreaticoduodenectomy: an analysis of 200 consecutive patients. J Am Coll Surg 185 4 (1997) 373-379
50. Wang T.Y., Shyr Y.M., Su C.H., Wu C.W., and Lui W.Y. Comparison of pylorus-preserving and classic pancreaticoduodenectomy. Zhonghua Yi Xue Za Zhi (Taipei) 62 3 (1999) 152-158
51. Watanapa P., and Williamson R.C. Resection of the pancreatic head with or without gastrectomy. World J Surg 19 3 (1995) 403-409
52. Wenger F.A., Jacobi C.A., Haubold K., Zieren H.U., and Muller J.M. [Gastrointestinal quality of life after duodenopancreatectomy in pancreatic carcinoma. Preliminary results of a prospective randomized study: pancreatoduodenectomy or pylorus-preserving pancreatoduodenectomy]. Chirurg 70 12 (1999) 1454-1459
53. Williamson R.C., Bliouras N., Cooper M.J., and Davies E.R. Gastric emptying and enterogastric reflux after conservative and conventional pancreatoduodenectomy. Surgery 114 1 (1993) 82-86
54. Yamaguchi K., Kishinaka M., Nagai E., et al. Pancreatoduodenectomy for pancreatic head carcinoma with or without pylorus preservation. Hepatogastroenterology 48 41 (2001) 1479-1485
55. Yamaguchi K., Yokohata K., Nakano K., et al. Which is a less invasive pancreatic head resection: PD, PPPD, or DPPHR?. Dig Dis Sci 46 2 (2001) 282-288
56. Zerbi A., Balzano G., Patuzzo R., Calori G., Braga M., and Di Carlo V. Comparison between pylorus-preserving and Whipple pancreatoduodenectomy. Br J Surg 82 7 (1995) 975-979
57. Mosca F., Giulianotti P.C., Balestracci T., et al. [Preservation of the pylorus in duodenocephalopancreatectomy in pancreatic and periampullary carcinoma]. Chir Ital 46 2 (1994) 59-67
58. Kovacs I., Toth P., Arkosy J., Hamori J., and Sapy P. Surgical treatment of pancreatic head and periampullary tumours. Acta Chir Hung 36 1-4 (1997) 172-173
59. Takahashi S., Aiura K., Saitoh J., Hayatsu S., Kitajima M., and Ogata Y. Treatment strategy for pancreatic head cancer: Pylorus-Preserving Pancreaticoduodenectomy, Intraoperative Radiotherapy and Portal Catheterization. Digestion 60 Suppl 1 (1999) 130-134
60. Paquet K.J. Vergleich der partiellen Duodenopankreatektomi (Whipple-Operation) mit der pyloruserhaltenden Zephaloduodenopankreatektomie-eine prospektiv kontrollierte, randomisierte Langzeitstudie. Chir Gastroenterol 14 (1998) 54-58
61. Schoenberg M.H., Gansauge F., and Kunz R. Die Wertigkeit der pyloruserhaltenden partiellen Duodenopankreatektomie beim duktalen Pankreascarcinom. Chirurg 68 12 (1997) 1262-1267
62. Heise J.W., Becker H., Borchard F., and Roher H.D. Zum Radikalitatsrisiko der pyloruserhaltenden Duodenopamkreatektomie beim duktalen Carcinom. Chirurg 65 (1994) 780-784
63. Hocking M.P., Harrison W.D., and Sninsky C.A. Gastric dysrhythmias following pylorus-preserving pancreaticoduodenectomy. Possible mechanism for early delayed gastric emptying. Dig Dis Sci 35 10 (1990) 1226-1230
64. Tanaka M., and Sarr M.G. Total duodenectomy: feect on canine gastrointestinal motility. J Surg Res 42 5 (1987) 483-493
65. Tanaka M., and Sarr M.G. Role of the duodenum in the control of canine gastrointestinal motility. Gastroenterology 94 3 (1988) 622-629
66. Fraser R., Fone D., Horowitz M., and Dent J. Cholecystokinin octapeptide stimulates phasic and tonic pyloric motility in healthy humans. Gut 34 1 (1993) 33-37
67. Yeo C.J., Barry M.K., Sauter P.K., et al. Erythromycin accelerates gastric emptying after pancreaticoduodenectomy. A prospective, randomized, placebo-controlled trial. Ann Surg 218 3 (1993) 229-237 discussion 237-228
68. Bar-Natan M., Larson G.M., Stephens G., and Massey T. Delayed gastric emptying after gastric surgery. Am J Surg 172 1 (1996) 24-28
69. Garcea G., Dennison A.R., Ong S.L., et al. Tumour characteristics predictive of survival following resection for ductal adenocarcinoma of the head of pancreas. Eur J Surg Oncol 33 7 (2007) 892-897
70. Kleeff J., Michalski C.W., Friess H., and Buchler M.W. Surgical treatment of pancreatic cancer: the role of adjuvant and multimodal therapies. Eur J Surg Oncol 33 7 (2007) 817-823