Some economics of public statistics

Journal of Agricultural Economics

Volumn 59, Issue 3, 2008, Pages 387-420

  Hill, Berkeley ^a  

^a IMPERIAL COLLEGE LONDON   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Agricultural and rural policy formulation; Appraisal; Data; Monitoring; Policy failure; Statistics

Indexed keywords

EID: 48949107492     PISSN: 0021857X     EISSN: 14779552     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1477-9552.2008.00174.x     Document Type: Editorial

References (109)

1. AAEA. 'Our obsolete data systems: New directions and opportunities (American Statistical Association - American Agricultural Economics Association Joint Committee on Agricultural Statistics)', American Journal of Agricultural Economics, Vol. 54, (1972) pp. 867-880.
2. AgraCEAS. Feasibility Study on the Implementation of Income of Agricultural Households Sector (IAHS) Statistics (Luxembourg: Eurostat, 2007).
3. Allanson, P. 'The distributive effects of agricultural policy on Scottish farm incomes', Journal of Agricultural Economics, Vol. 57, (2006) pp. 117-126.
4. Allanson, P. 'On the characterisation and measurement of the redistributive effect of agricultural policy', Journal of Agricultural Economics, Vol. 59, (2008) pp. 169-187.
5. Arrow, K. J. 'Organisation and information', in K. J. Arrow (ed.), The Limits of Organization (New York: W. W. Norton, 1974, pp. 33-43).
6. Avery, G. Guarantee Thresholds and the Common Agricultural Policy, Paper submitted to the 1985 Agricultural Economics Society Conference (Edinburgh, UK, 1985).
7. Barnard, C. S. 'Data in agriculture: A review with special reference to farm management research, policy and advice in Britain', Journal of Agricultural Economics, Vol. XXVI, (1975) pp. 289-334.
8. Bascou, P. 'Information on farm household income: Identifying information availability and gaps in the EU', in C. Moreddu and K. J. Poppe (eds.), Proceedings of the OECD/PACIOLI Workshop on Information Needs for the Analysis of Farm Household Income Issues (Den Haag: LEI, 2004), pp. 43-47.
9. Blandford, D. Information Deficiencies in Agricultural Policy Design, Implementation and Monitoring, OECD Food, Agriculture and Fisheries Working Paper No. 6 (Paris: OECD Publishing, 2007).
10. Bonnen, J. T. 'Improving information on agriculture and rural life', American Journal of Agricultural Economics, Vol. 57, (1975) pp. 735-763.
11. Bonnen, J. T. 'Assessment of the current agricultural data base: An information system approach', in L. R. Martin, (ed.), A Survey of Agricultural Economics Literature -Vol. 2. Quantitative Methods in Agricultural Economics, 1940s to 1970s (Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press, 1977), pp. 386-407.
12. Bonnen, J. T. 'On the role of data and measurement in agricultural economics research', Journal of Agricultural Economics Research, Vol. 41, (1989) pp. 2-5.
13. Bonnen, J. T. 'Providing economic information in an increasingly difficult policy environment', Review of Agricultural Economics, Vol. 22, (2000) pp. 500-518.
14. Brackstone, G. Managing Data Quality in a Statistical Agency, Statistics Canada, Survey Methodology, Catalogue No. 12-001-XPB (Ottawa: Statistics Canada, 1999).
15. Brooks, J. C. 'Agricultural policies in OECD countries: What do political economy models tell us?' Journal of Agricultural Economics, Vol. 47, (1996) pp. 366-389.
16. Cabinet Office. Modernising Government White Paper (London: The Stationery Office, 1999).
17. Capstick, C. W. 'Agricultural policy issues and economic analysis - Presidential address', Journal of Agricultural Economics, Vol. XXXIV, (1983) pp. 263-278.
18. CEC. Perspectives for the Common Agricultural Policy, COM(85) 333 Final - also published as Newsflash 33 (Brussels: The Commission, 1985).
19. CEC. The MEANS Collection - Evaluating Socio-economic Programmes, Six Volumes (Brussels: Directorate for the Co-ordination and Evaluation of Operations of DG XVI, 1999a).
20. CEC. Evaluation of Rural Development Programmes 2000-2006 Supported from the European Agricultural Guidance and Guarantee Fund - Guidelines, VI/ 8865/99- Rev, (Brussels: Directorate General for Agriculture, 1999b).
21. CEC. Evaluating EU Activities - A Practical Guide for the Commission Services (Brussels: DG Budget Evaluation Unit, 2004).
22. CEC. Evaluation of EU Activities - An Introduction (Brussels: DG Budget Evaluation Unit, 2005).
23. CEIES. European Agricultural Statistics - Europe First or Europe Only? 26th CEIES Seminar, 9-10 Septermber 2004 (Luxembourg: Eurostat, 2004).
24. Churchman, W. The Design of Inquiring Systems (New York: Basic Books, 1971; cited in Bonnen, 1989).
25. Court of Auditors. Special Report on the Measurement of Farm Incomes by the Commission Article 33(1)(b) of the EC Treaty, together with the Commission's Replies. 2004/C 45/01 (Brussels: Court of Auditors, 2004).
26. CRER. ERDP Evidence Assessment (London: CRER, CJC Consulting, and Segal Quince Wicksteed. Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, 2002).
27. Defra Science. Delivering the Evidence: Defra's Science and Innovation Strategy (available at: http://www.ost.gov.uk/policy/advice; 2007a).
28. Defra Science. Evidence Based Policy Making (available at: http://www.defra.gov.uk/how/evidence.htm; 2007b).
29. Defra. Farm Diversification - January 2008, Statistical Press Notice (London: Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, 2008).
30. Elvers, E. and Rosen, B. 'Quality concepts for official statistics', in: Encyclopaedia of Statistical Sciences, Update Volume 3 (New York: Wiley-Interscience, 1998, pp. 621-629).
31. Eurostat. Manual on the Total Income of Agricultural Households (Rev.1), Theme 5 Series E (Luxembourg: Eurostat, 1995).
32. Eurostat. European System of Accounts: ESA 1995 (Luxembourg: Eurostat, 1996a).
33. Eurostat. 'Income statistics for the agricultural households sector', in B. Hill (ed.), Proceedings of the Eurostat International Seminar held in Luxembourg on 10 and 11 January 1996 (Luxembourg: Eurostat, 1996b; ISBN 92-827-7928-9; also published in German and French).
34. Eurostat. Manual on the Economic Accounts for Agriculture and Forestry (Rev.1). (Luxembourg: Eurostat, 1997a).
35. Eurostat. Seminar FADO (Future Agricultural Data Outline), 1999 Edition. Theme 5 (Luxembourg: Eurostat, 1999).
36. Eurostat. 'Agricultural Economic Statistics (AgES)', in P. Pauli (ed.), Proceedings of the 7th IWG-Agri seminar, Luxembourg 5-7 July 2000 (Luxembourg: Eurostat, 2000; ISBN 92-894-0281).
37. Eurostat. Income of the Agricultural Households Sector, 2001 Report, Theme 5 -CD Contains Inventory of Methodology, Special Studies, Analysis and Tables (Luxembourg: Eurostat, 2002).
38. Eurostat. Statistics in Focus 20/2006. Farm Structure Survey 2005 (Luxembourg: Eurostat, 2006).
39. Eurostat. Eurostat Guidelines for Data Quality Reporting in Community Statistical Legislation (Luxembourg: Eurostat Unit for Statistical Governance, Quality and Evaluation, 2007).
40. FAO. Conducting Agricultural Censuses and Surveys, FAO Statistical Development Series No. 6 (Rome: Food and Agriculture Organisation of the United Nations, 1995; Definition of Agricultural Holding in Glossary).
41. FAO. A System of Economic Accounts for Food and Agriculture, FAO Statistical Development Series 8 (Rome: Food and Agriculture Organisation of the United Nations, 1996).
42. Fellegi, I. P. 'Characteristics of an effective statistical system', International Statistical Review, Vol. 64 (1996), pp. 139-155.
43. Furlon, J., Hagger, H. and Furlong, C. 'Politics and evidence-based policy-making: The review of initial teacher training provision in Wales', Welsh Journal of Education, Vol. 14, (2007) pp. 117-132.
44. Furness, G. W. 'Some feature of farm income and structure variation in regions of the United Kingdom', Journal of Agricultural Economics, Vol. XXXIII, (1982), pp. 289-309.
45. Gardner, B. L. 'Changing economic perspectives of the farm problem', Journal of Economic Literature, Vol. XXX, (1992) pp. 62-101.
46. Gardner, B. L., Goodwin, B. and Ahearn, M. Economic Statistics and U.S. Agricultural Policy, Invited paper prepared for presentation at the International Association of Agricultural Economists Conference (Gold Coast, Australia, 12-18 August, 2006).
47. Gasson, R. 'Farm diversification and rural development', Journal of Agricultural Economics, Vol. 39, (1988) pp. 175-182.
48. Gasson, R. 'Part-time farming - A note on definitions: A reply', Journal of Agricultural Economics, Vol. 42, (1991) pp. 200-201.
49. Ghelfi, L., Gundersen, C., Johnson, J., Morehart, M., Kassel, K., Kuhn, B., Mishra, A., Offutt, S., Tiehen, L. and Whitener, L. A. 'Safety net for farm households?' Agricultural Outlook (Washington, DC: Economic Research Service, U.S. Department of Agriculture, 2000).
50. Giles, A. K. 'The AES, 1926-2001: A view from the archives', Journal of Agricultural Economics, Vol. 52, (2001) pp. 1-21.
51. Giles, A. K. and Cawley, D. P. 'The farm management survey: Its origins, development and use', in A. K. Giles, (ed.), Windows on Agricultural Economics and Farm Management (Reading: Department of Agricultural Economics and Farm Management, University of Reading, 1993).
52. Gundersen, C., Morehart, M., Whitener, L., Ghelfi, L., Johnson, J., Kassel, K., Kuhn, B., Mishra, A., Offutt, S. and Tiehen, L. A Safety Net for Farm Households, Agricultural Economic Report No. 788 (Washington, DC: Economic Research Service, U.S. Department of Agriculture, 2000).
53. Hardman, H. 'Reflections upon economics and agricultural policy', Journal of Agricultural Economics, Vol. XXXI, (1980) pp. 283-296.
54. Hill, B. 'Concepts and measurement of the incomes, wealth and economic well-being of farmers', Journal of Agricultural Economics, Vol. XXXIII, (1982) pp. 311-324.
55. Hill, G. P. 'Measuring farm incomes under conditions of inflation: The gains from borrowing', Journal of Agricultural Economics. Vol. XXXV, (1984) pp. 51-60.
56. Hill, B. 'In search of the Common Agricultural Policy's 'agricultural community'', Journal of Agricultural Economics, Vol. 41, (1990) pp. 316-326.
57. Hill, B. 'The implications for agricultural statistics of changes in the system of national accounts', Journal of Agricultural Economics, Vol. 49, (1998) pp. 359-377.
58. Hill, B. Developments in the Area of Economic Accounts for Agriculture Versus Micro-level - Total Income of Agricultural Households and to What Extent they are Dependent on Agricultural Activities, Paper presented to the Meeting on Food and Agricultural Statistics in Europe (Conference of European Statisticians), May 1999, (Geneva: ECE/FAO/Eurostat/OECD, 1999).
59. Hill, B. 'The illusory nature of balance sheets in agricultural economic statistics: A note', Journal of Agricultural Economics, Vol. 51, (2000a) pp. 463-467.
60. Hill, B. 'Linking the established subsystems of economic statistics to provide a rounded view of agriculture', in P. Pauli, (ed.), Agricultural Economic Statistics, Proceedings of the Seventh IWG-AGRI Seminar, Luxembourg, 5-7 July (Luxembourg: Eurostat, 2000b, pp. 46-74).
61. Hill, B. Farm Incomes, Wealth and Agricultural Policy, 3rd edn (Aldershot: Ashgate, 2000c).
62. Hill, B. Determining DEFRA's Rural Statistics - Discussion Document (London: Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, 2002a, 49 pp; published on DEFRA website).
63. Hill, B. 'Developed country agricultures: Preparing statistical systems for the policy needs of the new millennium', in F. Piersimoni, (ed.), Conference on Agricultural and Environmental Statistical Applications in Rome -CAESAR, 2nd World Conference of Agricultural Statisticians, Volume 1 (Rome: National Statistical Institute of Italy (ISTAT), 2002b, pp. 59-68; essays no. 12/2002. ISBN 88-458-0835-1).
64. Hill, B. Business Competence, Report Commissioned by Defra to Review Recent Research into Business Competence amongst Farmers, to Carry out a Stock Take of Publicly Funded Measures Aimed at Raising Business Competence amongst Farmers in England, and to Consider the Implications for Policy (London: Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, 2007).
65. Hill, B. 'Agricultural incomes: A damaging history of disjunction between policy concern and evidence', Chapter 4, in: J. Bouchard (ed.), Contested Countryside (London: I B Tauris, 2008), pp. 81-116.
66. Hill, B. and Cahill, C. 'Taxation of EU farmers', EuroChoices, Vol. 6, (2007) pp. 44-48.
67. Hogwood, B. W. and Gunn, L. A. Policy Analysis for the Real World (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1984).
68. Holt, T. 'Official statistics and their contribution to public policy', in Information and Knowledge: The Role of Statistics, Proceedings of the 86th DGINS Conference, Porto, June 2000. Theme 1 General Statistics (Luxembourg: Eurostat, 2001), pp. 95-109.
69. Holt, T. and Jones, T. 'Quality work and conflicting policy objectives', 84th DGINS Conference, 28-29 May (Stockholm: Office of National Statistics, 1998).
70. Hubbard, L. J., Allanson, P. E. and Renwick, A. W. 'Farm income and economic welfare considerations', Journal of Agricultural Economics, Vol. 49, (1998) pp. 34-39.
71. Hunt, K. E. 'The concern of agricultural economists in Great Britain since the 1920s', Journal of Agricultural Economics, Vol. 27, (1976) pp. 285-296.
72. Keeney, M. 'The distributional impact of direct payments on Irish farm incomes', Journal of Agricultural Economics, Vol. 51, (2000) pp. 252-265.
73. Kirk, J. H. 'Some objectives of agricultural support policies', Journal of Agricultural Economics, Vol. XIII, (1962) pp. 134-152.
74. Kirk, J. H. 'The economic activities of the Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Food', Journal of Agricultural Economics, Vol. XVI, (1964) pp. 164-179.
75. Kirsch, L. and Joret, F. 'Development of farm income', in C. Moreddu and K.J. Poppe, (eds.), LEI/OECD (2004) Proceedings of the OECD/PACIOLI Workshop on Information Needs for the Analysis of Farm Household Income Issues (Den Haag: LEI, 2004, Report 8.04.04; ISBN 90-5242-949-9).
76. Kraenzle, C. A. A Review of the Activities of AAEA's Economic Statistics and Information Resources Committee, USDA Rural Business Cooperative Service Staff Report 93-S3 (Washington, DC: USDA, 2000).
77. Lund, P. 'Eating out: Statistics and society - Presidential address', Journal of Agricultural Economics, Vol. 49, (1998) pp. 279-294.
78. Lund, P.J. and Watson, J.M. 'Agricultural incomes: A review of the data and recent trends', Economic Trends, Vol. 338, (1981) pp. 103-121.
79. Matthews, A. Farm Incomes: Myths and Reality, Undercurrents Series (Cork: Cork University Press, 2000, 88 pp.; ISBN 1-85918-241-0).
80. McDonough, A. M. Information Economics and Management Systems (New York: McGraw-Hill, 1963).
81. Mishra, A. K., El-Osta, H. S., Morehart, M, Johnson, J. D. and Hopkins, J. W. Income, Wealth and the Economic Well-Being of Farm Households. Agricultural Economics Report No. 812 (Washington, DC: Farm Sector Performance and Well-Being Branch, Resource Economics Division, Economic Research Service, U.S. Department of Agriculture, 2002).
82. Moreddu, C. and Poppe, K.J. Proceedings of the OECD/PACIOLI Workshop on Information Needs for the Analysis of Farm Household Income Issues (LEI/ OECD: Den Haag, 2004).
83. Moyer, H. W. and Josling, T. E. Agricultural Policy Reform: Politics and Process in the EC and USA (Ames, IA: Iowa State University Press, 1990).
84. Moyer, W. and Josling, T. Agricultural Policy Reform: Politics and Process in the EU and in the US in the 1990s (Aldershot: Ashgate Publishing, 2002).
85. Napolitan, I. 'The statistical activities of the M.A.F.F', Journal of Agricultural Economics, Vol. XXVI, (1975).
86. OECD. Adjustment in OECD Agriculture: Issues and Policy Responses, Also OECD A Review of Farm Household Incomes in OECD Countries, Background Paper to this Publication (Paris: Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development, 1995).
87. OECD. Agriculture in a changing world. Which policies for tomorrow? Press Communiqué. Meeting of the OECD Committee for Agriculture at Ministerial level (SG/COM/NEWS(98)22), 5-6 March (Paris: OECD, 1998).
88. OECD. Farm Household Income: Issues and Policy Responses (Paris: OECD, 2003, ISBN 92-64-09965-4).
89. OECD. Policy Brief: Farm Household Income: Towards Better-Informed Policies (Paris: Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development, 2005a).
90. OECD. Taxation and Social Security in Agriculture (Paris: Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development, 2005b; main author Hill, B.).
91. Offutt, S. 'What is agriculture?', in: F. Piersimoni, (ed.), Conference on Agricultural and Environmental Statistical Applications in Rome - CAESAR, 2nd World Conference of Agricultural Statisticians; Volume 1 (Rome: National Statistical Institute of Italy (ISTAT), 2002a, pp. 41-47; essays no. 12/2002. ISBN 88-458-0835-1).
92. Offutt, S. 'The future of farm policy analysis: A household perspective. Presidential Address', American Journal of Agricultural Economics, Vol. 84, (2002b) pp. 1189-1201.
93. ONS. National Statistics Code of Practice: Statement of Principles (London: Her Majesty's Stationery Office, 2002).
94. Penn State University. Workshop on the Farm Household-Firm Unit: Its Importance in Agriculture and Implications for Statistics (PA: Department of Agricultural Economics and Rural Sociology, The Pennsylvania State University, State College, 2002; available at: http://household.aers.psu.edu).
95. Peters, G. H. (ed.). Agriculture: Review of United Kingdom Statistical Sources, Volume XXIII (London: Royal Statistical Society and The Economic and Social Research Council/Chapman and Hall, 1988).
96. Peterson, G. M. 'Wealth, income and living', Journal of Farm Economics, Vol. 15, (1933) pp. 421-451.
97. Phimister, E., Roberts, D. and Gilbert, A. 'The dynamics of farm incomes: Panel data analysis using the Farm Accounts Survey', Journal of Agricultural Economics, Vol. 55, (2004) pp. 197-220.
98. Ramsay, J. M. 'The development of agricultural statistics', Journal of Agricultural Economics, Vol. VI, (1940), pp. 117-129.
99. Robson, N. 'Practical and legal challenges of developing pluriactivity and non-farm incomes data using the EU's Farm Accountancy Data Network', in B. Hill, (ed.), Income Statistics for the Agricultural Households Sector (Luxembourg: Eurostat, 1996, pp. 69-77).
100. Sempic, J., Becker, S. and Bryman, A. 'The quality of research evidence in social policy: Consensus and dissension among researchers', Evidence and Policy, Vol. 3, (2007) pp. 407-423.
101. Shaxson, L. 'Is your evidence robust enough? Questions for policy makers and practitioners', Evidence and Policy, Vol. 1, (2005) pp. 101-111.
102. Statistics Sweden. Availability and Feasibility of Collecting Data on Off-farm Income and Other Income - A Feasibility Study on Collection of Data on Off-farm Income and on Other Income in FADN, Statistics Sweden, Rural Economy Research Centre (Estonia) and Agricultural Economics Research Institute (Hungary). Contract Reference No. AGRI-2005-401 (Brussels: The Commission, 2006).
103. Stigler, G. J. 'The economics of information', Journal of Political Economy, Vol. 69, (1961) pp. 213-225.
104. UK Presidency [of the Council]. Rebalancing Statistical Priorities in the European Union (Brussels: The European Council, 2005).
105. UN. System of National Accounts 1993 (Brussels/Luxembourg, New York, Paris, Washington, DC: United Nations, World Bank, Commission of the European Communities -Eurostat, International Monetary Fund, Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development, 1993, ISBN 92-1-16352-3).
106. UNECE. in J. Karlsson and B. Hill, (eds.), The Wye Group Handbook: Rural Households' Livelihood and Well-Being - Statistics on Rural Development and Agricultural Household Income (Geneva: United Nations Economic Commission for Europe, 2005/2007; on behalf of the Intersecretariat Working Group on Agricultural Statistics and Rural Indicators (IWG.AgRI) (UNECE, Eurostat, FAO, OECD, World Bank) for IWG-Agri) Electronic Version 2005, Hard Copy Edition (with revisions) 2007).
107. Vogel, F. and Johnson, J. 'Measuring agricultural income with the changing face of agriculture', in P. Pauli, (ed.), Proceedings of the Seventh IWG-AGRI Seminar (Luxembourg: Eurostat, 2000, pp. 257-284).
108. de Vries, W. F. M. 'How are we doing? Performance indicators for national statistical systems', Netherlands Official Statistics Vol. 13, (1998) pp. 5-13.
109. Wilson, P., Seabrook, M. and Price, R. 'Developments in national farm business data sources: Implications and opportunities', Journal of Farm Management, Vol. 12, (2006) pp. 464-476.