The 1994 tax reform and its impact on China's rural fiscal structure

Modern China

Volumn 34, Issue 3, 2008, Pages 303-343

  Chen, An ^a  

^a NATIONAL UNIVERSITY OF SINGAPORE   (Singapore)

Author keywords

Central local relations; China's rural reform; Peasant burden; Rural finance; Taxation

Indexed keywords

CENTRAL-LOCAL RELATIONS; ECONOMIC IMPACT; FISCAL REFORM; PEASANT AGRICULTURE; RURAL ECONOMY; RURAL FINANCE; TAX REFORM; TAX SYSTEM;

ASIA; CHINA; EURASIA; FAR EAST;

EID: 44449150738     PISSN: 00977004     EISSN: 15526836     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1177/0097700408315987     Document Type: Article

References (99)

1. [AC] Anhuisheng caizhengting [Bureau of Finance, Anhui Province] (2004) "Anhui: Xiangcai xianguan baituo xiangzhen caizheng kunjing" (Anhui: The county's management of township finance helps the township get rid of its fiscal plight). Zhongguo caizheng 465 (Apr.): 29-31.
2. [ANB] Anhui nianjian bianweihui [Anhui Yearbook Editorial Committee] (2003) Anhui nianjian: 2002 (Anhui yearbook: 2002). Anhui: Anhui nianjian chubanshe.
3. Bahl, Roy (1998) "Central-provincial-local fiscal relations." Pp. 125-49 in Donald J.S. Brean (ed.), Taxation in Modern China. New York: Routledge.
4. Bahl, Roy and Christine I. Wallich (1995) "Intergovernmental fiscal relations in the Russian federation." Pp. 321-78 in Richard M. Bird, Robert D. Ebel, and Christine I. Wallich (eds.), Decentralization of the Socialist State: Intergovernmental Finance in Transition Economies. Washington, D.C.: World Bank.
5. Bernstein, Thomas P. (2000) "Instability in rural China." Pp. 95-111 in David Shambaugh (ed.), Is China Unstable? Assessing the Factors. Armonk, NY: M.E. Sharpe.
6. Bernstein, Thomas P. and Xiaobo LU (2003) Taxation without Representation in Contemporary China. New York: Cambridge Univ. Press.
7. Cai, Yongshun (2000) "Between state and peasant: Local cadres and statistical reporting in rural China." China Q. 163 (June): 783-805.
8. Caizhengbu [Ministry of Finance] (1995) Xiangzhen caizheng guanli shixing banfa (Rules for the management of township finance [for trial implementation]).
9. Caizhengbu [Ministry of Finance] (1999, 2000, 2001, 2002, 2003, 2004) Zhongguo caizheng nianjian (Finance yearbook of China). Beijing: Zhongguo caizheng zazhishe.
10. Caizhengbu [Ministry of Finance] (2005) Guanyu 2004 yusuan zhixing qingkuang he 2005 yusuan cao'an baogao (On the execution of 2004 budgets and the draft for 2005 budgets). www.chinanews.com.cn/news/2005/ 2005-03-15/26/550918.shtml. Accessed on Mar. 15.
11. Chai MI (2004) "Goodbye, agricultural tax." Beijing Rev. 47, 13 (Apr. 1): 30-31.
12. Chen Shu and LI Xinquan (2003) "Xianxiang caizheng kunnan ji chengyin fenxi" (An analysis of the difficulty of county-township finance and the causes). Zhongguo nongcun jingji 227 (Nov.): 20-24.
13. Chung, Jaeho (1995) "Beijing confronting the provinces: The 1994 tax-sharing reform and its implications for central-provincial relations in China." China Information 9, 2-3 (Winter): 1-23.
14. [CY] Caizhengbu yusuansi [Bureau of the Budget, Ministry of Finance] (1994 - 1999) Quanguo dishixian caizheng tongji ziliao (Statistical materials for the finances of prefectures, cities, and counties nationwide).
15. [CYD] Caizhengbu yusuansi difangchu [Department of Localities, Bureau of the Budget, Ministry of Finance] (2001) 2000 nian quanguo xiangzhen caizheng jiben qingkuang (Basic facts about township finance nationwide in 2000).
16. Edin, Maria (2003) "State capacity and local agent control in China: CCP cadre management from a township perspective." China Q. 173 (Mar.): 35-52.
17. [GTNZ] Guojia tongjiju nongdiao zongdui [Team for Rural Investigation, State Statistics Bureau] (2003) "Jin wunian lai nongmin shouru nianjun zengzhang baifen zhi sandianba" (In the past five years peasant income has increased by 3.8 percent annually). Zhongguo tongji 255 (Apr.): 18.
18. Han Jun and Tang KA (2003) "Caizheng tizhi yu xianxiang caizheng (The fiscal structure and county-township finance). Shuishou yu shehui 9 (Sept.): 1-3.
19. HE Chengjun (2003) "Xianxiang caizheng kunnan: Xianzhuang, chengyin, chulu"(The financial difficulty of the county and township: The status quo, causes, and the way out). Zhongguo nongcun jingji 218 (Feb.): 17-22.
20. HE Xuefeng (2001) Xiangcun zuzhi jiqi caizheng zhuangkuang: Hubei J shi diaocha (Rural organizations and their finances: An investigation of J city, Hubei). Unpublished manuscript.
21. HE Xuefeng and Wang Ximing (2002) "Lun xiaoji xingzheng: Jianlun jianqing nongmin fudan de zhiben zhice" (On passive administration: a fundamental way to reduce the peasant burden). Unpublished manuscript.
22. Herschler, Stephen B. (1995) "The 1994 tax reforms: The center strikes back." China Economic Rev. 6, 2 (Fall): 239-45.
23. HU Tuoping (2001) "Xiangzhen gonggong chanpin de gongqiu maodun tanxi (An analysis of supply-demand contradictions concerning townships' public goods). Caizheng yanjiu 221 (Jul.): 31-36.
24. Ito, Junichi (2006) "Economic and institutional reform packages and their impact on productivity: A case study of Chinese township and village enterprises." J. of Comparative Economics 34, 1 (Feb.): 167-90.
25. [JCKK] Jiceng caizheng kunnan ketizu [Study Team on Grass-roots Fiscal Difficulties] (2004) "Woguo xianxiang caizheng mianlin de kunnan ji duice yanjiu" (A study of the difficulties with county and township finances in our country and the solution). Caizheng yanjiu 251 (Jan.): 41-44.
26. JI Haodong, Zhao Wei, and Yuan Jianhua (2003) "Shuifei gaige, cunji caiwu ji gonggongpin rongzi" (The tax-fee reform, village-level finance, and fund-raising for public goods). Zhongguo nongcun jingji 223 (July): 10-17.
27. Jia Kang and Bai Jingming (2002) "Xianxiang caizheng jiekun yu caizheng tizhi chuangxin" (Overcoming difficulties of public finance at the county and township levels and innovation in fiscal system). Jingji yanjiu 405 (Feb.): 3-9.
28. Jin Limin and Feng Zuyang (2000) "Jianli minzhu licai jizhi baituo xianxiang caizheng kunjing" (Establish a democratic accounting system and rid the county and township of their fiscal problems). Caishui yu kuaiji 4 (Apr.): 11-14.
29. Kung, James Kai-Sing and Yi-Min Lin (2007) "The decline of township-and-village enterprises in China's economic transition." World Development, doi: 10.1016/j.worlddev.2006.06.004.
30. Lee, Pak K. (2000) "Into the trap of strengthening state capacity: China's tax-assignment reform." China Q. 164 (Dec.): 1007-24.
31. LI Changping (2002) Wo xiang zongli shuo shihua (I spoke the truth to the premier). Beijing: Guangming ribao chubanshe.
32. LI Feng, LI Xinying, Zou Xiaoqi, Feng Yingge, and Zhu Xiaoyi (2002) "Difang xiangzhenji caizheng fuzhai de fengxian guibi" (Avoiding the risk of debt at the township level). Caizheng yanjiu 238 (Dec.): 56-59.
33. Li QI (2003) "Nongcun shuifei gaige de shijian yu wanshan chutan" (A study of the practice and perfection of the rural fee-turned-tax reform). Caizheng yanjiu 240 (Feb.): 43-46.
34. LI Tana (2003) "Xianxiang caizheng kunnan de caizheng tizhixing yinsu fenxi" (An analysis of the elements in the fiscal structure that have caused the financial difficulties of the county and township). Lilun yanjiu 1 (Jan.): 47-49.
35. Li, Xiande (2003) "Rethinking the peasant burden: Evidence from a Chinese village." J. of Peasant Studies 30, 3-4 (Apr.-July): 45-74.
36. LI Xiangyun, DU Yuanyu, and Jin Zhixun (2004) "Woguo caizheng zhuanyi zhifu xianzhuang fenxi ji zhengce jianyi" (An analysis of our country's fiscal transfer payment and suggestions). Caikuai yanjiu 9 (Sept.): 6-7.
37. Liu Dequan, Zhang Peng, and LI Youhua (2003) "Nongcun fenpei guanxi de helixing wenti yanjiu" (A study of the rationality of rural distributional relations). Caizheng yanjiu 247 (Sept.): 33-35.
38. Liu Mingda (2002) "Huanjie xianxiang caizheng kunnan de xiangfa he chubu zuofa" (Views of and methods for solving the fiscal difficulties of county-township finances). Caizheng yanjiu 232 (June): 58-60.
39. Liu Peiying (2002) "Jiceng caizheng kuisun yu fuzhai maodun tuchu de pouxi" (An analysis of the shortfall of basic-level finance and sharpened debt problems). Wuliu keji 25, 90 (Mar.): 52-54.
40. LU Hongyou (1998) "Feishui caizheng shouru yanjiu" (A study of non-tax revenue). Jingji yanjiu 362 (June): 55-61.
41. Lu Wei (2003) "Dangqian caizheng tizhi yu zhengce yunxing de liudian sikao" (Six points on the current fiscal system and policy implementation). Caizheng yanjiu 244 (June): 6-12.
42. Lu, Xiaobo (1997) "The politics of peasant burden in reform China." J. of Peasant Studies 25, 1 (Oct.): 113-38.
43. MA Jun (1998) Lun zhuanyi zhifu (On transfer payments). Beijing: Zhongguo caizheng jingji chubanshe.
44. Mao Ying'E (2003) "Nongcun shuifei gaige dui xiangzhen caizheng de yingxiang" (The influence of the rural tax-fee reform on township finance). Caizheng yanjiu 242 (Apr.): 47-49.
45. Michelson, Ethan (2006) "Peasants' burdens and state response: exploring state concession to popular tax resistance in rural China." Paper presented at the Association for Asian Studies Annual Meeting, April 6-9. www.indiana.edu/~emsoc/Publications/ Michelson_burdens.pdf.
46. Michelson, Ethan (2008) "Justice from above or justice from below? Popular strategies for resolving grievances in rural China." China Q. 193 (Mar.).
47. [NBSC] National Bureau of Statistics of China (1995, 1997, 2002) China Statistical Yearbook. Beijing: China Statistics Press.
48. North, Douglas (1990) Institutions, Institutional Change and Economic Performance. Cambridge, Eng.: Cambridge Univ. Press.
49. O'Brien, Kevin and Lianjiang LI (1995) "The politics of lodging complaints in rural China." China Q. 143 (Sept.): 756-83.
50. O'Brien, Kevin and Lianjiang LI (1999) "Selective policy implementation in rural China." Comparative Politics 31, 2 (Jan.): 167-86.
51. O'Brien, Kevin and Lianjiang LI (2006) Rightful Resistance in Rural China. New York: Cambridge Univ. Press.
52. Oi, Jean C. (1999) Rural China Takes Off: Institutional Foundations of Economic Reform. Berkeley: Univ. of California Press.
53. Pan Xiaoshou (2006) "Guan duo wei huan: Yiqie Zhongguo shehui wenti de zonggenyuan" (Too many officials: The fundamental source of all China's social problems). www.2.chinesenewsnet.com/MainNews/Forums/ BackStage/2006_8_31_8_22_32_375.htm. Accessed on Sept. 20.
54. Peng, Yusheng (1999) "Agricultural and nonagricultural growth and inter-county inequality in China, 1985-1991." Modern China 25, 3 (July): 235-63.
55. Ren Baoyu (2002) "Caizheng shijiao xiade xiangcun zhili" (Financial governance in rural areas). Pp. 20-45 in Xu Yong (ed.), Zhongguo nongcun yanjiu (Studies of rural China). Beijing: Zhongguo shehui kexue chubanshe.
56. Reporter (2005) "Zhongguo xianxiang zhengfu zhaiwu tupo yiwanyi" (The debts of China's counties and townships exceed one trillion). http://finance.sina.com.cn/g/20050322/10281449702.shtml. Accessed on Mar 22.
57. Rong Jingben (1998) Cong yalixing tizhi xiang minzhu hezuo tizhi de zhuanbian: Xianxiang liangji zhengzhi tizhi gaige (Transformation from the pressure system to a democratic system of cooperation: Political reform at the county and township levels). Beijing: Zhongyang bianyi chubanshe.
58. [SCBW] Shayangxian caizheng bianzuan weiyuanhui [Editorial Committee of the Shayang County Financial Yearbook] (1988-2001) Shayangxian caizheng nianjian (The financial yearbook of Shayang county).
59. Song Hongyuan et al. (2004) Zhongguo xiangcun caizheng yu gonggong guanli yanjiu (A study of finance and public management in the Chinese countryside). Beijing: Zhongguo caizheng jingji chubanshe.
60. Su Min (2003) "Guomin jingji zhuanxing shiqi gongnong guanxi, chengxiang guanxi he guomin shouru fenpai guanxi de yanjiu" (A study of the worker-peasant and urban-rural relationships and the distribution of national income during the transformation of the national economy). Caizheng yanjiu 242 (Apr.): 2- 8.
61. Sun Donghai (2002) "Xianxiang caizheng ruhe zouchu kunjing" (How can the finance of the county and township get out of the dilemma?). Juece zixun 4 (Apr.): 8-10.
62. Tan Qiucheng (2002) "Difang fenquan yu xiangzhen caizheng zhineng" (Local division of powers and the functions of township finance). Zhongguo nongcun guancha 43 (Mar.): 2-12.
63. Walder, Andrew (1995) "Local governments as industrial firms." American J. of Sociology 101, 2 (Sept.): 263-301.
64. Wang, Shaoguang (1997) "China's 1994 fiscal reform: An initial assessment." Asian Survey 37, 9 (Sept.): 801-17.
65. Wang, Shaoguang (2002) "Zhongguo caizheng zhuanyi zhifu de zhengzhi luoji" (The political logic of China's fiscal transfer payments). Zhanlüe yu guanli 52 (May-June).
66. Wang, Shaoguang and HU Angang (2001) The Chinese Economy in Crisis: State Capacity and Tax Reform. Armonk, NY: M.E. Sharpe.
67. Wang, Rong (2004) "Jiaoyu shuiping de chayi yu gonggong jiaoyu ziyuan fenpei de bupingdeng" (The different educational levels and unequal distribution of public educational resources). Beida jiaoyu jingji yanjiu 4 (Sept.): 1-22.
68. Wang Ximing and HE Xuefeng (2002) "Dui nongye xiangzhen sheli yiji caizheng de zhiyi" (Questioning the establishment of township-level finance). Jingmen zhiye jishu xueyuan xuebao 5 (Oct.): 1-9.
69. Wang Yong (2003) "Dui woguo nongcun shuifei zhidu gaige de sikao" (Reflections on the reform of the rural tax-fee system in our country). Caizheng yanjiu 240 (Feb.): 41-43.
70. Wedeman, Andrew (1997) "Stealing from the farmers: Institutional corruption and the 1992 IOU crisis." China Q. 152 (Dec.): 805-31.
71. West, Loraine A. and Christine P.W. Wong (2001) "Fiscal decentralization and growing regional disparities in rural China." Pp. 331-46 in Ross Garnaut and Yiping Huang (eds.), Growth Without Miracles: Readings on the Chinese Economy in the Era of Reform. New York: Oxford Univ. Press.
72. Whiting, Susan H. (2001) Power and Wealth in Rural China: The Political Economy of Institutional Change. New York: Cambridge Univ. Press.
73. [WNC] Woguo nongcun caizheng zhidu chuangxin yu zhengce xuanze ketizu [Study Group on Innovations in China's Rural Fiscal System and Policy Options] (2002) "Xiangzhen caizheng: Zhidu kuangjia yu zhengce gaige" (Township finance: Institutional context and policy change). Zhongguo nongcun jingji 208 (Apr.): 4 - 10.
74. Wong, Christine P.W. (1997a) "Overview of issues in local public finance in the PRC." Pp. 27-60 in Christine Wong (ed.), Financing Local Government in the People's Republic of China. Hong Kong: Oxford Univ. Press.
75. Wong, Christine P.W. (1997b) "Rural public finance." Pp. 167-212 in Christine Wong (ed.), Financing Local Government in the People's Republic of China. Hong Kong: Oxford Univ. Press.
76. World Bank (2002) China: National Development and Sub-national Finance - A Review of Provincial Expenditures. www.worldbank.org.cn/English/ content/978u6325395.shtml. Accessed on June 25, 2003.
77. World Bank (1988) World Development Report 1988. New York: Oxford Univ. Press.
78. WU Licai (2002) "The political consequences of the rural fee-to-tax reform in mainland China: A case study of Anhui province." Hong Kong J. of Social Sciences 24 (Winter): 61-84.
79. WU Licai and LI Zhilan (2003) "Xiangzhen caizheng jiqi gaige chutan: Hongzhen diaocha" (A preliminary study of township finance and its reform: An investigation of Hong township). Zhongguo nongcun guancha 51 (July): 13-24.
80. [XCCZYB] Xiangzhen caizheng chizi yu zhaiwu yanjiu baogao [A report on the budget deficit and debt of townships] (2003) www.chinaelections.com/ readnews.asp?newsid={5F261178D19D-445B-9A3E-7E4B87201066. Accessed on May 3.
81. Yang, Dali L. (1996) Calamity and Reform in China: State, Rural Society, and Institutional Change since the Great Leap Famine. Stanford, CA: Stanford Univ. Press.
82. Yang, Dali L. (1997) Beyond Beijing: Liberalization and the Regions in China. New York: Routledge.
83. Yang, Dali L. (2004) Remaking the Chinese Leviathan: Market Transition and the Politics of Governance in China. Stanford, CA: Stanford Univ. Press.
84. Yang Minghua (2003) "Jiejue xianxiang caizheng wenti de duice sikao" (Thoughts on the solution to fiscal problems of the county and township). Dongnan daxue xuebao-zhexue shehui kexue ban 5, 3 (May): 29-32.
85. Yu Jianrong (2003) "Zhongguo mouxie xiangzhen zhengfu cheng 'l'eduoxing zhengfu'" (Some township governments in China have become predatory governments). www.6.chinesenewsnet.com/MainNews/Forums/ BackStage/2003_7_8_20_9_0_674.html. Accessed on July 9.
86. YU Lichun (2002) "Xianxiang caizheng shouru hunku shenji zhi shensi" (Thoughts on auditing the county-township mixed fiscal revenue). Hebei shenji 4 (Apr.): 28-29.
87. Yu Tao and Zhao Yue (2003) "Suben tanyuan: Zhu xianxiang caizheng tuopin" (Seek the root causes: How to help the county and township shake off poverty). Liaoning caishui 269 (Jan.): 55-56.
88. Yuan Xinwei and Yang Hongying (2002) "Tan nongcun shuifei gaige houde xianxiang caizheng gongzuo" (A talk on county-township finances following the rural tax-fee reform). Caishui yu kuaiji 9 (Sept.): 8-10.
89. Zhang Haiqing (2003) "Jiexi 'shinanyi, yinanjue, juenanxing': jianyi nongcun gongyi shiye de chulu" (An analysis of the difficulties in discussing, deciding, and providing rural public goods). www.chinavillage.org/ReadNews.asp?NewsID=343&newsnameID= 11&newsname=????. Accessed on June 11.
90. Zhang Jing (2000) Jiceng zhengquan: Xiangcun zhidu zhu wenti (Basic-level governments: Problems with the rural system). Hangzhou: Zhejiang renmin chubanshe.
91. Zhang Jun (2000) "Nongcun caizheng jianshe yu nongcun gonggong fuwu" (Rural fiscal structuring and public service). In Zhu Gang, Zhang Yuanhong, and Zhang Jun (eds.), Jujiao Zhongguo nongcun caizheng (Focusing on China's rural finance). Taiyuan: Shanxi jingji chubanshe.
92. Zhang Xiangtao (2005) Zhongguo nongcun gaige yanjiu (A study of the reform in the Chinese countryside). Changsha: Hunan renmin chubanshe.
93. Zhao Yang (2005) "Nongcun shuifei gaige kaocha: Jixiao, wenti ji duice" (An investigation of rural tax-fee reform: Its effects, problems, and solutions). In Chen Xiwen (ed.), Zhongguo nongcun gonggong caizheng zhidu (China's rural public financial system). Beijing: Zhongguo fazhan chubanshe.
94. Zhao Yang and Zhou Feizhou (2000) "Peasant burdens and rural finance." Hong Kong J. of Social Sciences 17 (Autumn): 67-85.
95. Zhao Yunqi (2000) "Shilun xiangzhen caizheng chizi de chengyin he duice" (On the causes of county-township fiscal deficits and the solution). Caizheng yanjiu 206 (Apr.): 73-76.
96. Zheng Zixuan (2003) "Zhuanyi zhifu zhidu: Xianshi yu lixiang de chaju" (The system of transfer payments: The difference between reality and the ideal). http://business.sohu.com/2003/12/27/45/ article217514580.shtml. Accessed on Dec. 27.
97. Zhou Feizhou (2006) "Zhuanyi zhifu heyi jiejiu xianxiang caizheng" (How can transfer payments help county-township finances?). www.nfcmag.com/ReadNews.asp?NewsID=5242. Accessed on May 26.
98. Zhu Feina, Liu Jianfeng, and Yang Liangmin (2003) "Wuda yinsu daozhi xianxiang caizheng weiji (Five factors cause the county and township fiscal crisis). www.chinaelections.com/readnews.asp?newsid= {9FF7458B-8DBA-4349-9FFAF9C1543E26AO. Accessed on May 3.
99. [ZWBWX] Zhonggong Wuxishi Binhuqu weiyuanhui xuanchuanbu [Propaganda Department of the CCP Binhu Committee] (2003) Wuxishi Binhuqu (Binhu district, Wuxi city). Pamphlet.