Are stock assessment methods too complicated?

Fish and Fisheries

Volumn 5, Issue 3, 2004, Pages 235-254

  Cotter, A J R ^a   Burt, L ^b   Paxton, C G M ^b   Fernandez, C ^c   Buckland, S T ^b   Pan, J X ^d  

^a CENTRE FOR ENVIRONMENT   (United Kingdom)

^b UNIVERSITY OF ST ANDREWS   (United Kingdom)

^c LANCASTER UNIVERSITY   (United Kingdom)

^d KEELE UNIVERSITY   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Catch at age modelling; Fisheries data; Natural mortality; Stock assessment; Virtual population analysis; Year class curves

Indexed keywords

BAYESIAN ANALYSIS; FISHERY MANAGEMENT; FISHERY REGULATION; FISHERY STATISTICS; FISHERY SURVEY; FISHING INDUSTRY; STOCK ASSESSMENT;

ATLANTIC OCEAN; NORTH SEA;

EID: 4444253049     PISSN: 14672960     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1467-2679.2004.00157.x     Document Type: Review

References (121)

1. Aitkin, M. (1987) Modelling variance heterogeneity in normal regression using GLIM. Applied Statistics 36, 332-339.
2. Allen, M., Kilpatrick, D., Armstrong, M., Briggs, R., Course, G. and Pérez, N. (2002) Multistage cluster sampling design and optimal sample sizes for estimation of fish discards from commercial trawlers. Fisheries Research 55, 11-24.
3. Anonymous (1999) Manual for the International Bottom Trawl Surveys. Rev. VI. ICES CM 1999/D 2. Addendum 2 Ref.:G.
4. Anonymous (2000) Report of the study group on discard and by-catch information. ICES CM 2000/ACFM: 11.
5. Anonymous (2001) Report of the North Sea and Skagerrak demersal fish stock working group. ICES CM 2002/ ACFM: 01.
6. Beare, D., Castro, J., Cotter, J. et al. (2002) Evaluation of research surveys in relation to management advice (EVARES). Final report of FISH/2001/02 - Lot 1, DGXIV Fisheries, European Commission, Brussels. Available at a.j.cotter@cefas.co.uk.
7. Berg, E. and Albert, O.T. (2003) Cod in fjords and coastal waters of North Norway: distribution and variation in length and maturity at age. ICES Journal of Marine Science 60, 787-797.
8. Beverton, R.J.H. (1964) Differential catchability of male and female plaice in the North Sea and its effect on estimates of stock abundance. Rapports et Proces- verbaux des Reunions, Conseil Permanent International pour L'Exploration de la Mer 155, 103-112.
9. Beverton, R.J.H. and Holt, S.J. (1957) On the dynamics of exploited fish populations. Fishery Investigations, Series II, Vol. 19. Her Majesty's Stationery Office, London, 533 pp.
10. Bradford, M.J. (1991) Effects of ageing errors on recruitment time series estimated from sequential population analysis. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 48, 555-558.
11. Bromley, P.J. (2000) Growth, sexual maturation and spawning in central North Sea plaice (Pleuronectes platessa L.), and the generation of maturity ogives from commercial catch data. Journal of Sea Research 44, 27-43.
12. Burnham, K.P. and Anderson, D.R. (2002) Model Selection and Multimodel Inference, 2nd edn. Springer, New York.
13. Carroll, R.J. and Ruppert, D. (1988) Transformation and Weighting in Regression. (Monographs on statistics and applied probability). Chapman and Hall, New York.
14. Clark, W.G. (1999) Effects of an erroneous natural mortality rate on a simple age-structured stock assessment. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 56, 1721-1731.
15. Collie, J.S. and Sissenwine, M.P. (1983) Estimating population size from relative abundance data measured with error. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 40, 1871-1879.
16. Cook, R.M. (1997) Stock trends in six North Sea stocks as revealed by an analysis of research vessel surveys. ICES Journal of Marine Science 54, 924-933.
17. Cotter, A.J.R. (1998) Method for estimating variability due to sampling of catches on a trawl survey. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 55, 1607-1617.
18. Cotter, A.J.R. (2001) Intercalibration of North Sea International Bottom Trawl Surveys by fitting year-class curves. ICES Journal of Marine Science 58, 622-632 [Erratum. Ibid 58, 1340].
19. Cotter, A.J.R. and Buckland, S.T. (2004) Using the EM algorithm to weight data sets of unknown precision when modeling fish stocks. Mathematical Biosciences 190, 1-7.
20. Cotter, A.J.R., Course, G.P., Buckland, S.T. and Garrod, C. (2002) A PPS sample survey of English fishing vessels to estimate discarding and retention of North Sea cod, haddock, and whiting. Fisheries Research 55, 25-35.
21. Darby, C.D. and Flatman, S. (1994) Virtual population analysis, version 3.1 (Windows/DOS) user guide. Information Technology Series 1. CEFAS. Lowestoft, UK.
22. Dempster, A.P., Laird, N.M. and Rubin, D.B. (1977) Maximum likelihood from incomplete data via the EM algorithm. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, series B 39, 1-38.
23. Deriso, R.B., Quinn, T.J. and Neal, P.R. (1985) Catch-age analysis with auxiliary information. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 42, 815-824.
24. de Valpine, P. (2002) Review of methods for fitting time-series models with process and observation error and likelihood calculations for nonlinear, non-Gaussian state-space models. Bulletin of Marine Science 70, 455-471.
25. Fabrizio, M.C. and Richards, R.A. (1996) Commercial fisheries surveys. In: Fisheries Techniques (eds B.R. Murphy and D. Willis). 2nd edn. American Fisheries Society, Bethesda, MD, pp. 625-650.
26. Fournier, D. and Archibald, C.P. (1982) A general theory for analysing catch at age data. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 39, 1195-1207.
27. Fréon, P. and Misund, O.A. (1999) Dynamics of Pelagic Fish Distribution and Behaviour: Effects on Fisheries and Stock Assessment. Fishing News Books, Blackwell Science Ltd. Oxford, UK.
28. Gilks, W.R., Richardson, S. and Spiegelhalter, D.J. (1996) Markov Chain Monte Carlo in Practice. Chapman & Hall/ CRC, London.
29. Godø, O.R. (1994) Factors affecting the reliability of groundfish abundance estimates from bottom trawl surveys. In: Marine Fish Behaviour in Capture and Abundance Estimation (eds A. Ferro and S. Olsen). Fishing News Books. Blackwell Science Ltd, Oxford, UK, pp. 166-199.
30. Graham, M. (1933) Report on the North Sea cod. Fishery Investigations. Ser. II No. XIII. 166 pp.
31. Grønnevik, R. and Evensen, G. (2001) Application of ensemble-based techniques in fish stock assessment. Sarsia 86, 517-526.
32. Gudmundsson, G. (1998) Joint time series analysis of catch-at-age and CPUE data. Alaska Sea Grant College Program. AK-SG-98-01, 199-217.
33. Harley, S.J., Myers, R.A. and Dunn, A. (2001) Is catch-per-unit-effort proportional to abundance? Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 58, 1760-1772.
34. Hilborn, R. (1992) Current and future trends in fisheries stock assessment and management. South African Journal of Marine Science 12, 975-988.
35. Hilborn, R. (2002) The dark side of reference points. Bulletin of Marine Science 70, 403-408.
36. Hilborn, R. (2003) The state of the art in stock assessment: where we are and where we are going. Scientia Marina 67(Suppl. 1), 15-20.
37. Hilborn, R. and Walters, C.J. (1992) Quantitative Fisheries Stock Assessment. Chapman and Hall, New York, 570 pp.
38. Hjellvik, V., Godø, O.R. and Tjøstheim, D. (2002a) Diurnal variation in bottom trawl survey catches: does it pay to adjust? Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 59, 33-48.
39. Hjellvik, V., Godø, O.R. and Tjøstheim, D. (2002b) The measurement error in marine survey catches: the bottom trawl case. Fisheries Bulletin 100, 720-726.
40. Hutchings, J.A. (1996) Spatial and temporal variation in the density of northern cod and a review of hypotheses for the stock's collapse. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 53, 943-962.
41. Jensen, A.J.C. (1939) On the laws of decrease in fish stocks. Rapports et Proces- verbaux des Reunions, Conseil Permanent International pour L'Exploration de la Mer 110, 85-96.
42. Kell, L.T. and Bromley, P.J. (2004) Implications for current management advice for North Sea plaice (Pleuronectes platessa L.): Part II. Increased biological realism in recruitment, growth, density-dependent sexual maturation and the impact of sexual dimorphism and fishery discards. Journal of Sea Research 51, 301-312.
43. Kell, L.T., Scott, R. and Hunter, E. (2004) Implications for current management advice for North Sea plaice: Part I. Migration between the North Sea and English Channel. Journal of Sea Research 51, 287-299.
44. Kimura, D.K. (1977) Statistical assessment of the age-length key. Journal of the Fisheries Research Board of Canada 34, 317-324.
45. Kimura, D.K. (1990) Approaches to age-structured separable sequential population analysis. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 47, 2364-2374.
46. Kinas, P.G. (1996) Bayesian fishery stock assessment and decision making using adaptive importance sampling. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 53, 414-423.
47. Koeller, P., Savard, L., Parsons, D.G. and Fu, C. (2000) A precautionary approach to assessment and management of shrimp stocks in the northwest Atlantic. Journal of Northwest Atlantic Fisheries Science 27, 235-246.
48. Lai, H.-L. (1993) Optimal sampling design for using the age-length key to estimate age composition of a fish population. Fisheries Bulletin 92, 382-388.
49. Laurec, A. and Shepherd, J.G. (1983) On the analysis of catch and effort data. Journal du Conseil international pour l'Exploration de la Mer 41, 81-84.
50. Liggins, G.W., Bradley, M.J. and Kennelly, S.J. (1997) Detection of bias in observer-based estimates of retained and discarded catches from a multispecies trawl fishery. Fisheries Research 32, 133-147.
51. Marchal, P., Ulrich, C., Korsbrekke, K., Pastoors, M. and Rackham, B. (2002) Annual trends in catchability and fish stock assessments. Scientia Marina 67 (Suppl. 1), 63-73.
52. McAllister, M.K. and Ianelli, J.N. (1997) Bayesian stock assessment using catch-age data and the sampling-importance resampling algorithm. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 54, 284-300.
53. McAllister, M. and Kirchner, C. (2002) Accounting for structural uncertainty to facilitate precautionary fishery management: illustration with Namibian Orange Roughy. Bulletin of Marine Science 70, 499-540.
54. McAllister, M.K. and Kirkwood, G.P. (1998) Bayesian stock assessment: a review and example application using the logistic model. ICES Journal of Marine Science 55, 1031-1060.
55. McAllister, M.K., Pikitch, E.K., Punt, A.E. and Hilborn, R. (1994) A Bayesian approach to stock assessment and harvest decisions using the sampling/importance resampling algorithm. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 51, 2673-2687.
56. Megrey, B.A. (1989) Review and comparison of age-structured stock assessment models. American Fisheries Society Symposium 6, 8-48.
57. Meinhold, R.J. and Singpurwalla, N.D. (1983) Understanding the Kalman filter. American Statistician 37, 123-127.
58. Mertz, G. and Myers, R.A. (1997) Influence of errors in natural mortality estimates in cohort analysis. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 54, 1608-1612.
59. Millar, R.B. and Meyer, R. (2000) Bayesian state-space modeling of age-structured data: fitting a model is just the beginning. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 57, 43-50.
60. Myers, R.A. and Cadigan, N.G. (1995) Statistical analysis of catch-at-age data with correlated errors. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 52, 1265-1273.
61. Myers, R.A. and Stokes, K. (1989) Density-dependent habitat utilisation of groundfish and the improvement of research surveys. ICES CM 1989/D 15.
62. National Research Council (1998) Improving fish stock assessments. Committee on Fish Stock Assessment Methods. National Academy Press, Washington D.C. Available at http://www.nap.edu/books/0309057256/html/.
63. Nicholson, M.D., Stokes, T.K. and Thompson, A.B. (1991) The interaction between fish distribution, survey design and analysis. ICES CM 1991/D 11.
64. Paloheimo, J.E. and Dickie, L.M. (1964) Abundance and fishing success. Rapports et Proces- verbaux des Reunions. Conseil Permanent International pour L'Exploration de la Mer 155, 152-163.
65. Parma, A.M. (2002) In search of robust harvest rules for Pacific halibut in the face of uncertain assessments and decadal changes in productivity. Bulletin of Marine Science 70, 423-453.
66. Pastoors, M.A., O'Brien, C.M., Flatman, S. et al. (2001) Evaluation of market sampling strategies for a number of commercially exploited stocks in the North Sea and development of procedures for consistent data storage and retrieval (EMAS). Final report of Project 98/075. DG XIV. Fisheries. European Commission, Brussels. Available at a.j.cotter@cefas.co.uk.
67. Pella, J.J. (1993) Utility of structural time series models and the Kalman filter for predicting consequences of fishery actions. Proceedings of the International Symposium on Management strategies for exploited fish populations. Alaska Sea Grant College Program AK-SG-93-02, 571-593.
68. Pelletier, D. (1998) Intercalibration of research survey vessels in fisheries: a review and an application. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 55, 2672-2690.
69. Pennington, M. and Godø, O.R. (1995) Measuring the effect of changes in catchability on the variance of marine survey abundance indices. Fisheries Research 23, 301-310.
70. Pennington, M., Burmeister, L.-M. and Hjellvik, V. (2002) Assessing the precision of frequency distributions estimated from trawl-survey samples. Fishery Bulletin 100, 74-80.
71. Pope, J.G. (1972) An investigation of the accuracy of virtual population analysis using cohort analysis. ICNAF Research Bulletin 9, 65-74.
72. Pope, J.G. (1977) Estimation of fishing mortality, its precision and implications for the management of fisheries. In: Fisheries Mathematics (ed. J.H. Steele), Academic Press, London, pp. 63-76.
73. Pope, J.G. (1979) Population dynamics and management: current status and future trends. Investigación Pesquera 43, 199-221.
74. Pope, J.G. (1982) Response to the note by M.S.M. Siddeek. Journal du Conseil international pour l'Exploration de la Mer 40, 306.
75. Pope, J.G. (1989) Multispecies extensions to age-structured assessment models. American Fisheries Society Symposium 6, 102-111.
76. Pope, J.G. and Shepherd, J.G. (1982) A simple method for the consistent interpretation of catch-at-age data. Journal du Conseil international pour l'Exploration de la Mer 40, 176-184.
77. Pope, J.G. and Shepherd, J.G. 1985. A comparison of the performance of various methods for tuning VPAs using effort data. Journal du Conseil international pour l'Exploration de la Mer 42, 129-151.
78. Punt, A.E. and Hilborn, R. (1997) Fisheries stock assessment and decision analysis: the Bayesian approach. Reviews in Fish Biology and Fisheries 7, 35-63.
79. Punt, A.E. and Hilborn, R. (2001) BAYES-SA: Bayesian stock assessment methods in fisheries. User's manual. FAO Computerized Information Series (Fisheries) 12. FAO, Rome.
80. Quinn, T.J. II and Deriso, R.B. (1999) Quantitative Fish Dynamics. Oxford University Press, Oxford.
81. Rencher, A.C. (1995) Methods of Multivariate Analysis. J. Wiley & Sons, New York.
82. Richards, L.J. and Schnute, J.T. (1998) Model complexity and catch-at-age analysis. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 55, 949-957.
83. Richards, L.J., Schnute, J.T., Kronlund, A.R. and Beamish, R.J. (1992) Statistical models for the analysis of ageing error. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 49, 1801-1815.
84. Richards, L.J., Schnute, J.T. and Olsen, N. (1997) Visualizing catch-age analysis: a case study. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 54, 1646-1658.
85. Ricker, W.E. (1975) Computation and interpretation of biological statistics of fish populations. Bulletin of the Fisheries Research Board of Canada 191, 382 pp.
86. Rivard, D. (1989) Overview of the systematic, structural, and sampling errors in cohort analysis. American Fisheries Society Symposium 6, 49-65.
87. Rochet, M.-J., Péronnet, I. and Trenkel, V.M. (2002) An analysis of discards from the French trawler fleet in the Celtic Sea. ICES Journal of Marine Science 59, 538-552.
88. Rose, G.A. and Kulka, D.W. (1999) Hyperaggregation of fish and fisheries: how catch-per-unit-effort increased as the northern cod (Gadus morhua) declined. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 56, 118-127.
89. Saila, S.B., Lorda, E. and Walker, H.A. (1985) The analysis of parameter error propagation in simple fishery models. Marine Resource Economics 1, 235-246.
90. Sampson, D.B. (1987) Variance estimators for Virtual Population Analysis. Journal du Conseil international pour l'Exploration de la Mer 43, 149-158.
91. Schnute, J.T. (1994) A general framework for developing sequential fisheries models. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 51, 1676-1688.
92. Schnute, J.T. and Richards, L.J. (1995) The influence of error on population estimates from catch-age models. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 52, 2063-2077.
93. Sen, A.R. (1986) Methodological problems in sampling commercial rockfish landings. Fishery Bulletin 84, 409-421.
94. Shepherd, J.G. (1997) Prediction of year-class strength by calibration regression analysis of multiple recruit index series. ICES Journal of Marine Science 54, 741-752.
95. Shepherd, J.G. (1999) Extended survivors analysis: an improved method for the analysis of catch-at-age data and abundance indices. ICES Journal of Marine Science 56, 584-591.
96. Shepherd, J.G. (2003) Fishing effort control: could it work under the common fisheries policy? Fisheries Research 63, 149-153.
97. Shepherd, J.G. and Nicholson, M.D. (1986) Use and abuse of multiplicative models in the analysis of fish catch-at-age. The Statistician 35, 221-227.
98. Shepherd, J.G. and Nicholson, M.D. (1991) Multiplicative modelling of catch-at-age data, and its application to catch forecasts. Journal du Conseil international pour l'Exploration de la Mer 47, 284-294.
99. Siddeek, M.S.M. (1982) A note on Pope's cohort analysis. Journal du Conseil international pour l'Exploration de la Mer 40, 209-210.
100. Sinclair, A.F. (2001) Natural mortality of cod (Gadus morhua) in the Southern Gulf of St. Lawrence. ICES Journal of Marine Science 58, 1-10.
101. Smith, P.J. (1989) Is two-phase sampling really better for estimating age composition? Journal of the American Statistical Association 84, 916-921.
102. Smith, A.D.M. and Punt, A.E. (1998) Stock assessment of gemfish (Resea solandri) in eastern Australia using maximum likelihood and Bayesian methods. Alaska Sea Grant College Program, AK-SG-98-01.
103. Smith, P.J., Jamieson, A. and Birley, A.J. (1990) Electrophoretic studies and the stock concept in marine teleosts. Journal du Conseil international pour l'Exploration de la Mer 47, 231-245
104. Sparholt, H. (1990) Improved estimates of the natural mortality rates of nine commercially important fish species included in the North Sea Multispecies VPA model. Journal du Conseil international pour l'Exploration de la Mer 46, 211-223.
105. Stratoudakis, Y., Fryer, R.J. and Cook, R.M. (1998) Discarding practices for commercial gadoids in the North Sea. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 55, 1632-1644.
106. Stratoudakis, Y., Fryer, R.J., Cook, R.M. and Pierce, G.J. (1999) Fish discarded from Scottish demersal vessels: estimators of total discards and annual estimates for targeted gadoids. ICES Journal of Marine Science 56, 592-605.
107. Sullivan, P.J. (1992) A Kalman filter approach to catch-at-length analysis. Biometrics 48, 237-257.
108. Sullivan, P.J., Lai, H.-L. and Gallucci, V.F. (1990) A catch-at-length analysis that incorporates a stochastic model of growth. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 47, 184-198.
109. Swain, D.P. and Sinclair, A.F. (1994) Fish distribution and catchability: what is the appropriate measure of distribution? Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 51, 1046-1054.
110. Tamsett, D. and Janacek, G. (1999) Sampling trips for measuring discards in commercial fishing based on mulitlevel modelling of measurements in the North Sea from NE England. Fisheries Research 42, 103-115.
111. Tamsett, D., Janacek, G. and Emberton, M. (1999a) A comparison of methods for onboard sampling of discards in commercial fishing. Fisheries Research 42, 127-135.
112. Tamsett, D., Janacek, G., Emberton, M., Lart, B. and Course, G. (1999b) Onboard sampling for measuring discards in commercial fishing based on multilevel modelling of measurements in the Irish Sea from NW England and N Wales. Fisheries Research 42, 117-126.
113. Tanaka, S. (1953) Precision of age-composition of fish estimated by double sampling method using the length stratification. Bulletin of the Japanese Society of Scientific Fisheries 19 657-670.
114. Thompson, H. (1928) Haddock biology (North Sea). A brief survey of recent data, methods and results. Rapports et Proces- verbaux des Reunions, Conseil Permanent International pour L'Exploration de la Mer 54, 135-165.
115. Thompson, S. (1992) Sampling. J. Wiley, New York.
116. Trenkel, V.M., Elston, D.A. and Buckland, S.T. (2000) Fitting population dynamics models to count and cull data using sequential importance sampling. Journal of the American Statistical Association 95, 363-374.
117. van Beek, F.A. (1998) Discarding in the Dutch beam trawl fishery. ICES CM 1998/BB: 5.
118. Verbyla, A.P. (1993) Modelling variance heterogeneity: residual maximum likelihood and diagnostics. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society. Series B 55, 493-508.
119. Vetter, E.F. (1988) Estimation of natural mortality in fish stocks: a review. Fishery Bulletin 86, 25-43.
120. Vinje, F., Heino, M., Dieckmann, U., Godø, O.R. and Mork, J. (2003) Spatial structure in length at age of cod in the Barents Sea. Journal of Fish Biology 62, 549-564.
121. Walters, C. and Martell, S.J.D. (2002) Stock assessment needs for sustainable fisheries management. Bulletin of Marine Science 70, 629-638.