'Does Broca's area exist?'. Christofredo Jakob's 1906 response to Pierre Marie's holistic stance

Brain and Language

Volumn 105, Issue 3, 2008, Pages 211-219

  Tsapkini, Kyrana ^a,b   Vivas, Ana B ^c   Triarhou, Lazaros C ^d  

^a ARISTOTLE UNIVERSITY OF THESSALONIKI   (Greece)

^b JOHNS HOPKINS UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^c City Liberal Studies   (Greece)

^d UNIVERSITY OF MACEDONIA   (Greece)

Author keywords

Aphasia; Christfried Jakob (1866 1956); Language areas; Localization of function

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE; ATAXIC APHASIA; BRAIN FUNCTION; BRAIN REGION; FUNCTIONAL MAGNETIC RESONANCE IMAGING; HUMAN; LANGUAGE; NEUROANATOMY; NEUROIMAGING; NEUROPATHOLOGY; NEUROPSYCHOLOGY; TRANSCRANIAL MAGNETIC STIMULATION;

APHASIA, BROCA; ARGENTINA; FRANCE; FRONTAL LOBE; HISTORY, 20TH CENTURY; HUMANS; NEUROANATOMY; NEUROLOGY;

EID: 43049139876     PISSN: 0093934X     EISSN: 10902155     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.bandl.2007.07.124     Document Type: Article

References (88)

1. Amunts K., Weiss P.H., Mohlberg H., Pieperhoff P., Gurd J., Eickhoff S., et al. Analysis of neural mechanisms underlying verbal fluency in cytoarchitectonically defined stereotactic space: The roles of Brodmann areas 44 and 45. Neuroimage 22 (2004) 42-56
2. Benson D.F. Aphasia. In: Heilman K.M., and Valenstein E. (Eds). Clinical neuropsychology (1979), Oxford University Press, New York, Oxford 22-58
3. Bergson H. Matière et mémoire: essai sur la relation du corps à l'esprit (1896), Félix Alcan, Paris
4. Brais B. The third left frontal convolution plays no role in language: Pierre Marie and the Paris debate on aphasia (1906-1908). Neurology 42 (1992) 690-695
5. Broca P. Perte de la parole, ramollissement chronique et destruction partielle du lobe antérieur gauche du cerveau. Bulletin de la Société d'Anthropologie (Paris) 2 (1861) 235-238
6. Burton M.W., Noll D.C., and Small S.L. The anatomy of auditory word processing: Individual variability. Brain and Language 77 (2001) 119-131
7. Caramazza A., and Coltheart M. Cognitive neuropsychology twenty years on. Cognitive Neuropsychology 23 (2006) 3-12
8. Catani M., and ffytche D.H. The rises and falls of disconnection syndromes. Brain 128 (2005) 2224-2239
9. Catani M., Jones D.K., and ffytche D.H. Perisylvian language networks of the human brain. Annals of Neurology 57 (2005) 8-16
10. Daffner K.R., Schomer D.L., Cosgrove G.R., Rubin N., and Mesulam M.M. Broca's aphasia following damage to Wernicke's area: For or against traditional aphasiology?. Archives of Neurology 48 (1991) 766-768
11. Déjerine J. Sur un cas de cécité verbale avec agraphie suivi d'autopsie. Comptes Rendus des Séances de la Société de Biologie et de ses Filiales (Paris) 43 (1891) 197-201
12. Déjerine J. Contibution a l'étude anatomo-pathologique et clinique des différentes variétés de cécité-verbale. Comptes Rendus des Séances de la Société de Biologie et de ses Filiales (Paris) 44 (1892) 61-90
13. Déjerine J. L'aphasie sensorielle: sa localisation et sa physiologie pathologique. La Presse Médicale 55 (1906) 437-439
14. Déjerine J. L'aphasie motrice: sa localisation et sa physiologie pathologique. La Presse Médicale 57 (1906) 453-457
15. Donnan G.A., Carey L.M., and Saling M.M. More (or less) on Broca. Lancet 353 (1999) 1031-1032
16. Economo C.v., and Koskinas G.N. Die Cytoarchitektonik der Hirnrinde des erwachsenen Menschen (1925), Verlag von Julius Springer, Wien, Berlin
17. Editorial. Pierre Marie on aphasia. British Medical Journal 2 (1906) 1879-1880
18. Eling P. Speech and the left hemisphere: What Broca actually said. Folia Phoniatrica (Basel) 38 (1986) 13-15
19. Eling P. Neuroanniversaries 2006. Journal of the History of the Neurosciences 15 (2006) 1-4
20. Embick D., Marantz A., Miyashita Y., O'Neil W., and Sakai K.L. A syntactic specialization for Broca's area. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 97 (2000) 6150-6154
21. Fiebach C.J., Schlesewsky M., Lohmann G., Cramon D.Y.v., and Friederici A.D. Revisiting the role of Broca's area in sentence processing: Syntactic integration versus syntactic working memory. Human Brain Mapping 24 (2005) 79-91
22. Finger S. Origins of neuroscience: A history of explorations into brain function (1994), Oxford University Press, New York, Oxford [pp. 32-62, 374-385]
23. Freud S. Contribution à la conception des aphasies: une étude critique [1891] (trad. par C. van Reeth) (1983), Presses Universitaires de France, Paris
24. Geschwind N. Disconnexion syndromes in animals and man. Part I. Brain 88 (1965) 237-294
25. Geschwind N. Disconnexion syndromes in animals and man. Part II. Brain 88 (1965) 585-644
26. Geschwind, N. (1976) Selected papers on language and the brain. In R.S. Cohen & M.W. Wartofsky (Eds.) Boston studies in the philosophy of science (Vol. XVI, pp. 105-236), 2nd printing. Dordrecht, Boston: D. Reidel Publishing Company.
27. Goetz C.G. Pierre Marie: Gifted intellect, poor timing and unchecked emotionality. Journal of the History of the Neurosciences 12 (2003) 154-166
28. Grodzinsky Y. The neurology of syntax: Language use without Broca's area. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 23 (2000) 1-71
29. Grodzinsky Y., and Amunts K. Broca's region: Mysteries, facts, ideas, and history (2006), Oxford University Press, New York, Oxford
30. Hécaen H., and Angelergues R. Pathologie du langage (1965), Librairie Larousse, Paris
31. Hillis A.E., Tuffiash E., and Caramazza A. Modality-specific deterioration in naming verbs in nonfluent primary progressive aphasia. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 14 (2002) 1099-1108
32. Jackson J.H. On the nature of the duality of the brain. Medical Press Circle New Series 17 (1874) 19-21 [pp. 41-44, 63-66]
33. Jacyna S. Freud's critical study. Cortex 41 (2005) 101-102
34. Jakob C. Existe ó no un centro de Broca?. La Semana Médica (Buenos Aires) 13 (1906) 677-678
35. Jakob C. Consideraciones anátomo-biológicas sobre los centros del lenguaje. La Semana Médica (Buenos Aires) 13 (1906) 733-737
36. Jakob, C. (1923). Elementos de Neurobiologi{dotless}́a, volumen I: Parte Teórica (pp. 219-234). (Biblioteca Humanidades, Tomo III). La Plata, República Argentina: Facultad de Humanidades y Ciencias de la Educación de la Universidad Nacional de La Plata.
37. Jellinger K.A. A short history of neurosciences in Austria. Journal of Neural Transmission 113 (2006) 271-282
38. Kertesz A., Hudson L., Mackenzie I.R., and Muñoz D.G. The pathology and nosology of primary progressive aphasia. Neurology 44 (1994) 2065-2072
39. Klein D., Zatorre R.J., Chen J.K., Milner B., Crane J., Belin P., et al. Bilingual brain organization: A functional magnetic resonance adaptation study. Neuroimage 31 (2006) 366-375
40. Klippel M. Discussions sur l'aphasie. Revue Neurologique (Paris) 16 (1908) 611-636 [pp. 974-1023, 1025-1047]
41. Koehler P.J., and Jagella C. Constantin von Monakow (1853-1930). Journal of Neurology 249 (2002) 115-116
42. Lecours A.R. Aphasie: querelles. Revue Neurologique (Paris) 155 (1999) 833-847
43. Lecours A.R., Basso A., Moraschini S., and Nespoulous J.-L. Where is the speech area, and who has seen it?. In: Caplan D., Lecours A.R., and Smith A. (Eds). Biological perspectives on language (1984), MIT Press, Cambridge, MA 220-246
44. Lecours A.R., and Joanette Y. François Moutier or "from folds to folds". Brain and Cognition 3 (1984) 198-230
45. Lorch M.P. The unknown source of John Hughlings Jackson's early interest in aphasia and epilepsy. Cognitive and Behavioral Neurology 17 (2004) 124-132
46. Lotmar F., and de Montet C. Examen de l'intelligence dans un cas d'Aphasie de Broca. Revue Neurologique (Paris) 14 (1906) 1063-1080
47. Marie P. Revision de la question de l'aphasie: la troisième circonvolution frontale gauche ne joue aucun rôle spécial dans la fonction du langage. La Semaine Médicale (Paris) 26 (1906) 241-247
48. Marie P. Revision de la question de l'aphasie: que faut-il penser des aphasie sous-corticales (aphasies pures)?. La Semaine Médicale (Paris) 26 (1906) 493-500
49. Marie P. Revision de la question de l'aphasie: l'aphasie de 1861 à 1866; essai de criticque historique sur la genèse de la doctrine de Broca. La Semaine Médicale (Paris) 26 (1906) 565-571
50. Marie P., and Moutier F. Examen du cerveau d'un cas d'aphasie de Broca. Bulletin et Mémoirs de la Société Médicale des Hôpitaux de Paris 23 (1906) 743-744
51. Marie P., and Moutier F. Sur un cas de ramollissement du pied de la troisième circonvolution frontale gauche chez un droitier, sans aphasie de Broca. Bulletin et Mémoirs de la Société Médicale des Hôpitaux de Paris 23 (1906) 1152-1155
52. Marie P., and Moutier F. Nouveau cas d'aphasie de Broca sans lésion de la troisième frontale. Bulletin et Mémoirs de la Société Médicale des Hôpitaux de Paris 23 (1906) 1180-1183
53. Marie P., and Moutier F. Nouveau cas de lésion corticale du pied de la troisième frontale gauche chez un droitier sans trouble du langage. Bulletin et Mémoirs de la Société Médicale des Hôpitaux de Paris 23 (1906) 1295-1298
54. McCarthy D.J., and Mills C.K. Discussion on aphasia, especially with reference to the views of Marie. Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease 34 (1906) 459-473
55. Meyer L. Cristofredo Jakob: a veinticinco años de su muerte. Acta Psiquiátrica y Psicológica de la América Latina 27 (1981) 13-14
56. Miceli G., and Caramazza A. Dissociation of inflectional and derivational morphology. Brain and Language 35 (1988) 24-65
57. Mohr J.P., Pessin M.S., Finkelstein S., Funkenstein H.H., Duncan G.W., and Davis K.R. Broca aphasia: Pathologic and clinical. Neurology 28 (1978) 311-324
58. Monakow C.v. Gehirnpathologie, zweite Aufl (1905), Hölder, Wien
59. Monakow C.v. Aphasie und Diaschisis. Neurologisches Centralblatt (Leipzig) 25 (1906) 1026-1038
60. Moutier F. Examen nécropsique d'un cas d'aphasie de Broca. Bulletin et Mémoirs de la Société Médicale des Hôpitaux de Paris 23 (1906) 1018-1020
61. Musso M., Weiller C., Kiebel S., Muller S.P., Bulau P., and Rijntjes M. Training-induced brain plasticity in aphasia. Brain 122 (1999) 1781-1790
62. Ombredane A. L'aphasie et l'élaboration de la pensée explicite (1951), Presses Universitaires de France, Paris
63. Orlando J.C. Christofredo Jakob: Su Vida y Obra (1966), Editorial Mundi, Buenos Aires
64. Passingham R.E. Broca's area and the origins of human vocal skill. Philosophical Transaction of the Royal Society of London Series B (Biological Sciences) 292 (1981) 167-175
65. Pearce J.M.S. A note on Pierre Marie (1853-1940). Journal of Neurology Neurosurgery and Psychiatry 75 (2004) 1583
66. Pedace E.A. Contribución de la Escuela Neurobiológica Argentina del Profesor Chr. Jakob en el estudio del lóbulo frontal. Archivos de Neurocirugi{dotless}́a 6 (1949) 464-466
67. Petrides M., Alivisatos B., Evans A.C., and Meyer E. Dissociation of human mid-dorsolateral from posterior dorsolateral frontal cortex in memory processing. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 90 (1993) 873-877
68. Plotkin M.B. Freud in the Pampas: The emergence and development of a psychoanalytic culture in Argentina (2001), Stanford University Press, Stanford, CA
69. Rizzolatti G., and Craighero L. The mirror-neuron system. Annual Review of Neuroscience 27 (2004) 169-192
70. Romani C., Olson A., Semenza C., and Granà A. Patterns of phonological errors as a function of a phonological versus an articulatory locus of impairment. Cortex 38 (2002) 541-567
71. Schuell H., Jenkins J., and Jimenez-Pabon E. Aphasia in adults: Diagnosis, prognosis and treatment (1964), Harper & Row, New York
72. Schwartz S. Effect of neonatal cortical lesions and early environmental factors on adult rat behavior. Journal of Comparative and Physiological Psychology 57 (1964) 72-77
73. Shapiro K.A., Pascual-Leone A., Mottaghy F.M., Gangitano M., and Caramazza A. Grammatical distinctions in the left frontal cortex. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 13 (2001) 713-720
74. Sluming V., Brooks J., Howard M., Downes J.J., and Roberts N. Broca's area supports enhanced visuospatial cognition in orchestral musicians. Journal of Neuroscience 27 (2007) 3799-3806
75. Souques A. Aphasie motrice sans lésion de la troisième circonvolution frontale. Bulletin et Mémoirs de la Société Médicale des Hôpitaux de Paris 23 (1906) 971-977
76. Thompson C.K. Neuroplasticity: Evidence from aphasia. Journal of Communication Disorders 33 (2000) 357-366
77. Thompson-Schill S.L., Bedny M., and Goldberg R.F. The frontal lobes and the regulation of mental activity. Current Opinion in Neurobiology 15 (2005) 219-224
78. Triarhou L.C., and del Cerro M. Semicentennial tribute to the ingenious neurobiologist Christfried Jakob (1866-1956). 1. Works from Germany and the first Argentina period, 1891-1913. European Neurology 56 (2006) 176-188
79. Triarhou L.C., and del Cerro M. Semicentennial tribute to the ingenious neurobiologist Christfried Jakob (1866-1956). 2. Publications from the second Argentina period, 1913-1949. European Neurology 56 (2006) 189-198
80. Triarhou L.C., and del Cerro M. Pioneers in Neurology: Christfried Jakob (1866-1956). Journal of Neurology 254 (2007) 124-125
81. Tyler L.K., Bright P., Fletcher P., and Stamatakis E.A. Neural processing of nouns and verbs: The role of inflectional morphology. Neuropsychologia 42 (2004) 512-523
82. Vivas A.B., Tsapkini K., and Triarhou L.C. 'Anatomo-biological considerations on the centers of language': An Argentinian contribution to the 1906 Paris debate on aphasia. Brain and Development (2007) 10.1016/j.braindev.2007.03.007
83. Watkins K., and Paus T. Modulation of motor excitability during speech perception: The role of Broca's area. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 16 (2004) 978-987
84. Weiller C., Isensee C., Rijntjes M., Huber W., Muller S., Bier D., et al. Recovery from Wernicke's aphasia: A positron emission tomographic study. Annals of Neurology 37 (1995) 723-732
85. Wernicke C. Der Aphasische Symptomencomplex: Eine psychologische Studie auf Anatomischer Basis (1874), Cohn und Weigert, Breslau
86. Whatmough C., Chertkow H., Murtha S., Templeman D., Babins L., and Kelner N. The semantic category effect increases with worsening anomia in Alzheimer's type dementia. Brain and Language 84 (2003) 134-147
87. Will B., Galani R., Kelche C., and Rosenzweig M.R. Recovery from brain injury in animals: Relative efficacy of environmental enrichment, physical exercise or formal training (1990-2002). Progress in Neurobiology 72 (2004) 167-182
88. Wise R.J.S., Greene J., Büchel C., and Scott S.K. Brain regions involved in articulation. Lancet 353 (1999) 1057-1061