Low- and zero-sulphated ash, phosphorus and sulphur anti-wear additives for engine oils

Lubrication Science

Volumn 20, Issue 2, 2008, Pages 103-136

  Spikes, Hugh ^a  

^a IMPERIAL COLLEGE LONDON   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Anti wear additives; Boron additive; Engine oil; Low SAPS; Phosphate ester; ZDDP

Indexed keywords

ENGINE OILS; PHOSPHORUS AND SULPHUR (SAPS); ZERO-SULPHATED ASH; ZINC DIALKYLDITHIOPHOSPHATE (ZDDP);

BORON; ESTERS; PHOSPHORUS; SULFUR;

LUBRICATING OILS;

EID: 42549133926     PISSN: 09540075     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1002/ls.57     Document Type: Article

References (229)

1. Koltsakis GC, Stamatelos AM. Catalytic automotive exhaust aftertreatment. Progress in Energy Combustion Science 1997; 23:1-39.
2. Matsumoto S. Recent advances in automobile exhaust catalysts. Catalyst Today 2004; 90:183-190.
3. x-aftertreatment systems for diesel engines for series introduction in North America. Proceedings of the 15th Aachener Kolloquium Fahrzeug- und Motorentechnik 2006, FKA mbH, Aachen, Germany 2006.
4. Williamson WB, Perry J, Goss RL, Gandhi HS, Beason RE. Catalyst deactivation due to glaze formation from oil-derived phosphorus and zinc. SAE Tech. Paper 841406, 1984.
5. Inoue K, Kurahashi T, Negishi T, Akiyama K, Ashimura K, Tasaka K. Effects of phosphorus and ash contents of engine oils on deactivation of monolithic three-way catalysts and oxygen sensors. SAE Tech. Paper 920654, 1992.
6. Kumar S, Ferrari V, Burk PL, Deeba M, Rogalo J. Influence of phosphorus poisoning on TWC catalysts. SAE Tech. Paper 2003-01-3735, 2003.
7. x trap. SAE Tech. Paper 2001-01-2503, 2001.
8. x reduction systems. SAE Tech. Paper 2003-01-1865, 2003.
9. Franz J, Schmidt J, Schoen C, Harperscheid M, Eckhoff S, Roesch M, Leyrer J. Deactivation of TWC as a function of oil ash accumulation - a parameter study. SAE Tech. Paper 2005-01-1097, 2005.
10. Nemoto S, Kishi Y, Matsuura K, Miura M, Togawa S, Ishikawa T, Hashimoto T, Yamazaki T. Impact of oil-derived ash on continuous regeneration-type diesel particulate filter - JCAPII oil WG report. SAE Tech. Paper 2004-01-1887, 2004.
11. ACEA European Oil Sequences. http://www.acea.be/images/uploads/pub/ 070308_ACEA_Sequences_2007_LD_and_HD.pdf [accessed 18 December 2007].
12. ILSAC GF-4 Standard for Passenger Car Engine Oils, http://www.ilma.org/ resources/ilsac_finalstd011404.pdf [accessed 18 December 2007].
13. Automotive Diesel Engine Oil Standard (JASO M35S: 2005) Application Manual. http://jalos.or.jp/onfile/pdf/DH_E0604.pdf [accessed 18 December 2007].
14. Spikes HA. The history and mechanisms of ZDDP. Tribology Letters 2004; 17:465-485.
15. Barnes AM, Bartle KD, Thibon VRA. A review of zinc dialkyldithiophosphates (ZDDPs): characterisation and role in lubricating oil. Tribology International 2001; 34:389-395.
16. Eglin M, Rossi A, Spencer ND. X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy analysis of tribostressed samples in the presence of ZnDTP: a combinatorial approach. Tribology Letters 2003; 15:199-209.
17. Kasrai M, Fuller MS, Bancroft GM, Yamaguchi ES, Ryason PR. X-ray absorption study of the effect of calcium sulfonate on anti-wear film formation generated from neutral and basic ZDDPs: part 1 - phosphorus species. Tribology Transactions 2003; 46:534-542.
18. Fujita H, Spikes HA. Formation of zinc dithiophosphate antiwear films. Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineering 2004; J218:265-277.
19. Fujita H, Glovnea RP, Spikes HA. The study of zinc dialkyldithiophosphate anti-wear film formation and removal process. Part I: experimental. Tribology Transactions 2005; 48:558-566.
20. Pidduck AJ, Smith GC. Scanning probe microscopy of automotive anti-wear films. Wear 1997; 212:254-264.
21. Martin JJ. Antiwear mechanisms of zinc dithiophosphate: a chemical hardness approach. Tribology Letters 1999; 6:1-8.
22. Masuko M, Hanada T, Okabe H. Distinction in antiwear performance between organic sulphide and organic phosphate as EP additives for steel under rolling with sliding partial EHD conditions. Lubrication Engineering 1994; 50:972-977.
23. Khorramian BA, Iyer GR, Kodali S, Natarajan P, Tupil R. Review of antiwear additives for crankcase oils. Wear 1993; 169:87-95.
24. Papay AG. Antiwear and extreme-pressure additives in lubricants. Lubrication Science 1998; 10:209-224.
25. Gallopoulos NE. Thermal decomposition of metal dialkyl dithiophosphate oil blends. ASLE Transactions 1964; 7:55-63.
26. Allum KG, Forbes ES. The load-carrying properties of metal dialkyl dithiophosphates: the effect of chemical structure. Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineering 1968; 183:7-14.
27. Rowe CN, Dickert JJ. The relation of antiwear function to thermal stability and structure for metal O,O-dialkyl phosphorodithioates. ASLE Transactions 1967; 10:85-90.
28. Born M, Hipeaux JC, Marchand P, Parc G. Relationship between chemical structure and effectiveness of some metallic dialkyl and diaryl dithiophosphates in different lubricated mechanisms. Lubrication Science 1992; 4:93-116.
29. Chen B, Dong J, Chen G. Tribochemistry of gadolinium dialkyldithiophosphate. Wear 1996; 196:16-20.
30. Chen G, Chen L, Dong J. Preparation and tribological behaviour of oil-soluble cerium dioctyl dithiocarbamate. Lubrication Engineering 1997; 53:24-29.
31. Sarin R, Tuli DK, Rai MM, Mehta AK, Bhatnagar AK. Titanium dithiophosphates: a new class of multifunctional lubricant additives. Lubrication Engineering 1995; 51:313-320.
32. Zhang J, Liu W, Xue Q, Wang Q. Investigation of the friction and wear behaviours of Cu(I) and Cu(II) dioctyldithiophosphates as additives in liquid paraffin. Wear 1998; 216:35-40.
33. Willermet PA. Some engine oil additives and their effects on antiwear film formation. Tribology Letters 1998; 5:41-47.
34. Givens WA, Buck WH, Jackson A, Kaldor A, Hertzberg A, Moehrmann W, Mueller-Lunz S, Petz N, Wenninger G. Lube formulation effects on transfer of elements to exhaust after-treatment system components. SAE 2003-01-3109, 2003.
35. Sanin PI, Shepeleva ES, Ulyanova AV, Kleimenov BV. The effect of synthetic additives in lubricating oil on wear under friction. Wear 1960; 3:200-218.
36. Sanin PI, Shepeleva ES, Mannik AO, Kleimenov BV. Chemical modification of friction surfaces. Transactions of the American Society of Mechanical Engineers, Journal of Basic Engineering 1965; 87:771-777.
37. Schumacher R, Zinke H. Tribofragmentation and antiwear behaviour of isogeometric phosphorus compounds. Tribology International 1997; 30:199-208.
38. Zinke H, Schumacher R. The thermal stability and antiwear performance of some thiophosphoric acid derivatives. Wear 1994; 179:45-48.
39. Zaskal'ko PP, Parfenova VA, Markov AA, Lesninova VA, Belov PS. Amidothiophosphates - effective antiwear and extreme-pressure additives for lubricating oils. Chemistry and Technology of Fuels and Oils 1976; 12:58-60.
40. (Translation of Khim i Tekhnol Topi I Masel 1976; 1:45-48).
41. Borschchevskii SB, Shabanova EV, Trofimov GA, Karamnova VP. Antioxidant, antiwear and extreme-pressure properties of amides of dithio acids of phosphorus. Chemistry and Technology of Fuels and Oils 1981; 17:157-160.
42. (Translation of Khim. i Tekhnol. Topi. i Masel 1981; 3:51-52).
43. Vipper AB, Belov PS, Lashkhi VL, Parfenova VA, Blokhina IV, Kulagin VV. Amidothiophosphates as antifriction and antiwear additives for lubricating oils. Chemistry and Technology of Fuels and Oils 1982; 18:174-176.
44. (Translation of Khim. i Tekhnol. Topi. i Masel 1982; 4:23-24).
45. Borschchevskii SB, Shabanova EV, Markov AA, Rebrov TY. Antifriction and antiwear properties of dialkyldithioamino-phosphates. Chemistry and Technology of Fuels and Oils 1984; 20:503-506.
46. (Translation of Khim. i Tekhnol. Topi, i Masel 1984; 10:23-25).
47. Sarin R, Tuli DK, Martin V, Rai MM, Bhatnagar AK. Development of N, P and S-containing multifunctional additives for lubricants. Lubrication Engineering 1997; 53:21-27.
48. Vipper AB, Lashkhi VL, Belov PS, Parfenova VA, Blokhina IV. Antifriction and antiwear efficiency of ashless thiophosphates and dithiophosphates. Chemistry and Technology of Fuels and Oils 1983; 19:136-139.
49. (Translation of Khim. i Tekhnol. Topi. i Masel 1983; 3:21-23).
50. Borschchevskii SB, Levitina IS, Shabanova EV, Kotova GG. Additives based on dithiophosphoric acids and unsaturated compounds for lubricating oils. Chemistry and Technology of Fuels and Oils 1991; 27:326-328.
51. (Translation of Khim. i Tekhnol. Topi. i Masel 1991; 6:24-26).
52. Sharma M, Bansai V, Ray SS, Sarin R, Tuli DK, Shainagar AK. Role of alkyl moieties in the antiwear and antioxidant performance of alkyl phosphorodithiophosphates. Lubrication Science 2003; 15:321-328.
53. US Patent 26892598 (1954), US Patent 3197405 (1965), US Patent 3929653, US Patent 5328621 (1994), US Patent 5405544 (1995).
54. Sarin R, Gupta AK, Tuli DK, Verma AS, Rai MM, Bhatnager AK. Synthesis and performance evaluation of O,O-dialkylphosphorodithioic disulfides as potential antiwear, extreme-pressure and antioxidant additives. Tribology International 1993;26:389-394.
55. Germanaud L, Nougier R. Additives to lubricating oils having extreme-pressure, antiwear and antioxidant effects, process for preparation thereof and lubricating compositions containing said additives. US Patent 5021175, 1991.
56. Farng LO, Horodysky AG, Poole RJ. Phosphorodithioate-derived pyrrolidinone adducts as multifunctional antiwear/antioxidant additives. US Patent 5324441, 1994.
57. Ren T, Xue Q, Wang H. A study of the tribological properties of S-(1H-benzotriazol-1-yl) methyl, O,O′-dialkyldithiophosphates as additives in liquid paraffin. Wear 1994; 173:167-170.
58. Taylor LA, Glovnea R, Ribeaud M, Spikes HA. The nature and properties of antiwear additive films. Proceedings of the ITC Conference, Nagasaki, Japan, October 2000, Vol. II, 1257-1262.
59. Rossi A, Piras FM, Kim D, Gellman AJ, Spencer ND. Surface reactivity of tributyl thiophosphate: effects of temperature and mechanical stress. Tribology Letters 2006; 23:197-208.
60. Najman MN, Kasrai M, Bancroft GM. Chemistry of antiwear films from ashless thiophosphate oil additives. Tribology Letters 2004; 17:217-229.
61. Farrington BB, Clayton JO. Compounded mineral oil. US Patent 2228658, 1941.
62. Farrington BB, Clayton JO, Rutherford JT. Compounded mineral oil. US Patent 2228659, 1941.
63. Dorinson A. The antiwear action of zinc di-n-butyl phosphate. ASLE Transactions 1979; 22:190-192.
64. Yagashita K, Igarashi J, Koizumi T. Lubricating oil compositions. US patent 6656887, 2003.
65. Peale LF, Messina J, Ackerman B, Sasin R, Swern D. Evaluation of long-chain phosphorus compounds as lubricity additives. ASLE Transactions 1960; 3:48-54.
66. Xia Y, Liu W, Xue Q. Tribological properties of P- and N-containing organic compounds as potential extreme-pressure and antiwear additives. Lubrication Science 2003; 15:173-183.
67. Smalheer CV, Mastin TW. Phosphorus in the lubricants field. Petroleum Processing 1952; 7:1780-1784.
68. Kerley RV. A history of aircraft piston engine lubricants. SAE Tech. Paper 810849, 1981.
69. Beeck O, Givens JW, Williams EC. On the mechanism of boundary lubrication II. Wear prevention by addition agents. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London 1940; A177:103-118.
70. Barcroft FT, Daniel SG. The action of neutral organic phosphates as EP additives. Transactions of the American Society of Mechanical Engineers, Journal of Basic Engineering 1965; 87:761-766.
71. Godfrey D. The lubrication mechanism of tricresyl phosphate on steel. ASLE Transactions 1965; 8:1-11.
72. Faut OD, Wheeler DR. On the mechanism of lubrication by tricresylphosphate (TCP) - the coefficient of friction as a function of temperature for TCP on M-50 steel. ASLE Transactions 1983; 26:344-350.
73. Forbes ES, Upsdell NT, Battersby J. Current thoughts on the mechanisms of action of tricresyl phosphate as a load-carrying additive. Tribology Convention 1972, I. Mech. E. C4/72:7-13.
74. Wheeler DR, Faut OD. The adsorption and thermal decomposition of tricresylphosphate (TCP) on iron and gold. Applications of Surface Science 1984; 18:106-122.
75. Sakurai T, Sato K. Chemical reactivity and load carrying capacity of lubricating oils containing organic phosphorus compounds. ASLE Transactions 1970; 13:252-261.
76. Forbes ES, Silver HB. The effect of chemical structure on the load-carrying properties of organo phosphorus compounds. Journal of the Institute of Petroleum 1970; 57:90-98.
77. Forbes ES, Neustadter EL, Silver HB, Upsdell NT. The effect of chemical structure on the load-carrying properties of amine phosphates. Wear 1971; 18:269-289.
78. Barber RI. The preparation of some phosphorus compounds and their comparison as load-carrying additives by the fourball machine. ASLE Transactions 1976; 19:319-328.
79. Kawamura M, Fujita K. Organic sulphur and phosphorus compounds as extreme-pressure additives. Wear 1981; 72: 45-53.
80. Minami I, Memita M, Hirao K. Investigation of antiwear additives for synthetic esters. Lubrication Engineering 2002; 58:18-22.
81. Riga A, Cahoon J, Pistillo WR. Organophosphorous chemistry structure and performance relationships in FZG gear tests. Tribology Letters 2000; 9:219-225.
82. Minami I, Hong H-S, Mathus NC. Effect of alkenes on the antiwear mechanism of dialkyl hydrogen phosphites. Lubrication Science 2001; 13:219-230.
83. 32 impurities on the behaviour of tricresylphosphate-32 as an antiwear additive. ASLE Transactions 1965; 8:12-20.
84. Forbes ES, Battersby J. The effect of chemical structure on the load-carrying and adsorption properties of dialkyl phosphites. ASLE Transactions 1974; 17:263-270.
85. Rounds FG. Some environmental factors affecting surface coating formation with lubricating oil additives. ASLE Transactions 1966; 9:88-100.
86. Lacey IN, Kelsall GH, Spikes HA, Macpherson PB. Thick antiwear films in elastohydrodynamic contacts. Part I: Film growth in rolling/sliding EHD contacts. ASLE Transactions 1985; 29:299-305.
87. Lacey IN. The antiwear performance of organo-phosphorus (III) esters. PhD Thesis, University of London, 1985.
88. Cann PM, Johnston GJ, Spikes HA. The formation of thick films by phosphorus-based anti-wear additives. Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineering 1987; C208/87:543-554.
89. Lacey IN, Kelsall GH, Spikes HA, Macpherson PB. Thick antiwear films in elastohydrodynamic contacts. Part II: Chemical nature of the deposited films. ASLE Transactions 1985; 29:306-311.
90. Verma VK, Singh R, Srivastava V, Singh PK. EP/AW performance evaluation of zinc alkyl/dialkyl/alkylaryl dithiocarbamates in four ball tests. Lubrication Science 2004; 16:195-203.
91. Braithwaite ER, Green AB. A critical analysis of the performance of molybdenum. Wear 1978; 46:405-431.
92. Chen G, Chen L, Dong J. Preparation and tribological behaviour of oil-soluble cerium dioctyl dithiocarbamate. Lubrication Engineering 1997; 53:24-29.
93. Chen L, Dong J, Chen G. The study of tribo-induced deposits from a copper-containing antiwear additive. Tribology Transactions 1997; 40:339-345.
94. Beatty HA. Organolead compounds as lubricant additives. Chemistry & Industry 1968; 8:733-736.
95. Palacios JM. Thickness and chemical composition of films formed by antimony dithiocarbamate and zinc dithiophosphate. Tribology International 1986; 19:35-39.
96. Palacios JM. Films formed by antiwear additives and their incidence in wear and scuffing. Wear 1987; 114:41-49.
97. Tuli DK, Sarin R, Gupta AK, Kumar AH, Rai MM, Bhatnagar AK. Synthetic metallic dialkyldithiocarbamates as antiwear and extreme-pressure additives for lubricating oils: role of metal on their effectiveness. Lubrication Engineering 1995; 51:298-303.
98. Taylor L, Camenzind H, Spikes HA. Film-forming properties of zinc-based and ashless antiwear additives. SAE Tech. Paper 2000-01-2030, 2000.
99. Sakurai T, Okabe H, Isoyama H. The synthesis of di-μ-thio- bis(dialkyldithiocarbamates) dimolybdenum (V) and their effects on boundary lubrication. Bulletin of the Japanese Petroleum Institute 1971; 13:243-249.
100. Isoyama H, Sakurai T. Inhibition of autooxidation by di-μ-thio- bis(dialkyldithiocarbamates) dimolybdenum. Bulletin of the Japanese Petroleum Institute 1974; 16:112-117.
101. 2 single sheet lubrication by molybdenum dithiocarbamate. Tribology International 1998; 31:737-743.
102. Topolovec Miklozic K, Graham J, Spikes H. Chemical and physical analysis of reaction films formed by molybdenum dialkyldithiocarbamate friction modifier additive using Raman and atomic force microscopy. Tribology Letters 2001; 11:71-81.
103. Graham J, Korcek S, Spikes HA. The friction-reducing properties of molybdenum dialkyldithiocarbamate additives. Part 1. Factors influencing friction reduction. Tribology Transactions 2001; 44:626-636.
104. Yamamoto Y, Gondo S. Friction and wear characteristics of molybdenum dithiocarbamate and molybdenum dithiophosphate. Tribology Transactions 1989; 32:251-257.
105. Tanaka H, Hashimoto M, Gondo S, Yamamoto Y. Friction and wear characteristics of molybdenum dithiocarbamate with alloy steels. Tribology Online I 2006; 1:9-13.
106. Plaza S. The load carrying action of organolead dithiophosphates, dithiocarbamates and xanthates. Part I: Assessment of the lubricating properties and mechanism of lubrication. Wear 1983; 85:193-204.
107. Allum KG, Forbes ES. The load-carrying properties of organic sulphur compounds. Part II. The influence of chemical structure on the anti-wear properties of organic disulphides. Journal of the Institute of Petroleum 1967; 53:173-185.
108. Allum KG, Ford JF. Influence of chemical structure on load-carrying properties of certain organo-sulphur compounds. Journal of the Institute of Petroleum 1965; 51:145-161.
109. Forbes ES, Allum KG, Neustadter EL, Reid AJD. The load-carrying properties of diester disulphides. Wear 1970; 15:341-352.
110. Belov PS, Trofimov VA, Ermolaeva AN, Vipper AB, Lashkhi VL, Gusev AA. Synthesis and investigation of antiwear properties of higher esters of 5,5'-thiodivaleric acid. Chemistry and Technology of Fuels and Oils 1980; 16:461-463.
111. (Translations from Khim. i Tekhnol. Topi, i Masel 1980; 7:36-37).
112. Katafuchi T, Shimizu N. Evaluaton of the antiwear and friction reduction characteristics of mercaptocarboxylate derivatives as novel phosphorous-free additives. Tribology International 2007; 40:1017-1024.
113. Baldwin BA. The effect of adsorption and molecular structure of antiwear additives on wear mitigation. ASLE Transactions 1985; 28:381-388.
114. Ren T, Wan Y, Xue Q, Wang H. A study of alkylthiomethylbenzotraizoles as multifunctional lubricating oil additives. Lubrication Science 1995; 7:164-169.
115. Rogachevskaya TA, Lashkhi VL, Vipper AB, Malysheva TG, Kaidala EV, Kleimenova ZA. New ashless antiwear additives for lubricating oils. Chemistry and Technology of Fuels and Oils 1979; 15:601-603.
116. (Translations from Khim. i Tekhnol. Topl. i Masel 1979; 8:37-39).
117. Singh T, Singh R, Verma VK, Nakayama K. A study of N, O and S heterocyclic compounds as extreme-pressure additives. Tribology International 1990; 23:41-46.
118. Singh T, Cnandrasekharan CV. The effect of nitrogen and sulphur compounds on extreme-pressure lubrication. Tribology International 1993; 26:245-250.
119. Wei D-P, Cao L, Wang L-I. An investigation into the antiwear, antioxidation, and anticorrosion behaviour of some derivatives of 2,4-dimercapto-1,3,4-thiadiazole. Lubrication Science 1995; 7:365-377.
120. Gao Y, Wu Z, Zhang Z, Xue Q. Study on tribological properties of 2,5-dialkoxymethylthio-1,3,4-thiadiazoles. Wear 1998; 222:129-134.
121. Zhang J, Liu W, Xue Q. The effect of molecular structure of heterocyclic compounds containing N, O, and S on their tribological performance. Wear 1999; 231:65-70.
122. US patent 4908144 (1990), US patent 5199960 (1993), US Patent 5217502 (1993), US Patent 5414090 (1995), US patent 5514289 (1996).
123. Kumar S, Roy NN. Studies to evaluate the extreme-pressure and anti-wear activity of some thiuram disulfides, xanthogens and dithiocarbamates. Wear 1997; 209:1-7.
124. Xu X, Wan Y, Cao L. Tribological performance and action mechanism of S-alkyl and S-benzimidazole substituted dialkyldithiocarbamates. Wear 2000; 241:41-46.
125. Ren T, Xue Q, Wang H. The tribological study of S-(1H-benzotriazol-1-yl) methyl alkyl xanthates as additives in synthetic lubricants. Lubrication Engineering 1995; 51:847-850.
126. Ren T, Sha G, Zheng L, Xia J, Liu W, Xue Q. The tribological study of S-(1H-benzotriazol-1-yl) methyl N, N-dialkyldithiocarbamates as additives in pentaerythritol ester. Lubrication Engineering 1997; 53:39-43.
127. Huang W, Dong J, Li F, Chen B. The performance and antiwear mechanism of (2-sulfurone-benzothiazole)-3-methyl esters as additives in synthetic lubricant. Tribology International 2000; 33:553-557.
128. Huang W, Dong J, Wu G, Zhang C. A study of S-[2-(acetamido) benzothiazole-l-yl]N,N-dibutyl dithiocarbamate as an oil additive in liquid paraffin. Tribology International 2004; 37:71-76.
129. Kim Y-W, Chung K, Kim N-S, Hwang D-H, Cho W-O. Synergistic lubricating effect of several ashless dithiocarbamates with Mo-donor additives. Tribology International 2007; 40:397-404.
130. He YH, Song YP, Shao HY, Zhan WQ, Ren TH. A study of the synergistic effect of a triazine-dithiocarbamate derivative with TCP in vegetable oil. Lubrication Science 2005; 21:287-297.
131. Knipple R, Thich J. The history of aviation turbine lubricants. SAE Tech. Paper 810851, 1981.
132. McHugh KL, Smith TO. Lubricating compositions. US Patent 3242081, 1966.
133. Guevremont J, Guinther G, Szemenyei D, Jao TC. Enhancement of engine oil wear and friction control performance through titanium additive chemistry. Paper presented at STLE Annual Meeting, Philadelphia, PA, May 2007.
134. Carre DJ, Bertrand PA, Lince JR. Lead naphthenate additive tribochemistry in hydrocarbon oils. Aerospace Report No. TR-2002(8565)-2, SMC-TR-02-08, 1981.
135. Didziulis SV, Fleischauer PD. Chemistry of the extreme-pressure lubricant additive lead naphthenate on steel surfaces. Langmuir 1991; 7:2981-2990.
136. Buckley DH. Effectiveness of various organometallics as antiwear additives in mineral oil. NTIS, NASA-TP-1096, 1977.
137. Lashkhi VL, Tsvetkov ON, Ermolov FN, Komarova NN, Vipper AB, Belov PS, Kaidala EV, Korenev KD, Kulagin VV, Markov AA. Organotin derivatives of alkylphenols as antiwear additives for lubricating oils. Chemistry and Technology of Fuels and Oils 1977; 13:289-292.
138. (Translations from Khim. i Tekhnol. Topl. i Masel 1977; 4:54-57).
139. Luo X, Wang D, Dong J. The antiwear mechanism of an organotin compound. Proceedings Eurotrib 1993; 5:88-92.
140. Liu RD, Tao DH, Fu SF, Zhao YA, Zhang JH. A study of the tribological behaviour of an organotin compound. Lubrication Science 2005; 17:419-429.
141. Kadjas CZ, Dominiak M, Firkowski A, Dabrowski JR, Misterkiewicz B. Tribochemistry of some ferrocene derivatives. ASLE Transactions 1983; 26:11-24.
142. Choudhary RB, Pande PP. Lubrication potential of boron compounds: an overview. Lubrication Science 2002; 14:213-222.
143. Shoemaker BH, Loane CM. Lubricant. US Patent 2160917, 1939.
144. Rogers DT, McNab JG. Hydrocarbon lubricant containing sulfurised aliphatic borates as stabilizers. US patent 2526506, 1950.
145. Thomas JR, Harle OL. Lubricant compositions. US Patent 2795548, 1957.
146. Cook JF. Antiwear lubricants containing boron esters. US Patent 2975134, 1961.
147. Kreuz KL, Fein RS, Dundy M. EP films from borate lubricante. ASLE Transactions 1967; 10:67-76.
148. Baldwin BA. Relative antiwear efficiency of boron and sulphur surface species. Wear 1977; 45:345-353.
149. US Patent 4370248 (1983), US Patent 4382006 (1983), US Patent 4410438 (1983), US Patent 4492640 (1985), US Patent 4584115(1986).
150. US Patent 4627930, US Patent 4629579 (1986).
151. Braid M. Borate esters and lubricant compositions containing such esters. US Patent 4547302, 1985.
152. Small VR, Liston TV. Diethylamine complexes of borated alkyl catechol and lubricating oil compositions containing the same. US Patent. 4975211, 1990.
153. Liu W, Xue Q, Zhang X, Wang H, Huang C. The performance and antiwear mechanism of tridodecyl borate ester as an oil additive. Tribology Transactions 1992; 48:475-479.
154. Liu W, Xue Q, Zhang X, Wang H. Effect of molecular structure of organic borates on their friction and wear properties. Lubrication Science 1993; 6:41-49.
155. Liu W, Jin Z, Xue Q. The performance and antiwear mechanism of S-containing organic borate as an oil additive. Lubrication Science 1994; 7:49-60.
156. Yao J, Dong J. Improvement of hydrolytic stability of borate esters used as lubricant additives. Lubrication Engineering 1995; 51:475-479.
157. Yao J. Antiwear function and mechanism of borate containing nitrogen. Tribology International 1997; 30:387-389.
158. Zhang J, Liu W, Xue Q. The tribological properties of the heterocyclic compound containing S, N, O and B as additive in liquid paraffin. Wear 1999; 224:68-72.
159. Huang W, Tan Y, Dong J, Chen B. Tribological properties of the film formed by borated dioctyl dithiocarbamate as an additive in liquid paraffin. Tribology International 2002; 35:787-791.
160. Zhang Z, Yamaguchi ES, Kasrai M, Bancroft GM. Interaction of ZDDP with borated dispersant using XANES and XPS. Tribology Transactions 2004; 47:527-536.
161. Kapadia R, Glyde R, Wu Y. In situ observation of phosphorous and non-phosphorous antiwear films using a mini traction machine with spacer layer image mapping. Tribology International 2007 (In press, doi:10.1016/j.triboint.2007.01.021).
162. Yao J, Dong J, Xiong R. Antiwear synergism of borates and copper oleate. Lubrication Engineering 1994; 50: 695-698.
163. Yao J, Dong J. Antiwear synergism of borates and dibutyl tin dilaurate. Lubrication Engineering 1996; 52:553-556.
164. Waynick JA. The development and use of metal deactivators in the petroleum industry. Energy and Fuels 2001; 15: 1325-1340.
165. Carron KT, Xue G, Lewis ML. A surface-enhanced Raman spectroscopy study of the corrosion-inhibiting properties of benzimidazole and benzotriazole on copper. Langmuir 1991; 7:2-4.
166. Rudston SG, Whitby RD. The effect of model lubricating oil constituents on the wear of steel. Journal of the Institute of Petroleum 1971;57:189-203.
167. Miller AH. Boundary lubricity studies: structure-activity correlations in alkylpyridines. Journal of the Institute of Petroleum 1973;59:27-31.
168. Ren T, Liu W, Xue Q, Wang H. The effect of molecular structure of N-containing heterocyclic compounds on their wear properties. Lubrication Science 1993; 5:205-212.
169. Wei D, Han X, Wang R. The influence of chemical structure of certain nitrogen-containg organic compounds on their antiwear effectiveness: the critical role of hydroxy group. Lubrication Science 1989; 2:63-87.
170. Wei D, Song H. The wear behaviour of steel lubricated by some oxygen-containing derivatives of heterocyclic nitrogencontaining compounds (HNCC) under boundary lubrication conditions. Lubrication Science 1992; 4:219-232.
171. Basset D, Hermant M, Martin JM. Oil-soluble fluorinated compounds as antiwear and antifriction additives. ASLE Transactions 1984; 27:380-388.
172. Gong D, Zhang P, Xue Q. Studies on relationship between structure of chlorine-containing compounds and their wear and extreme-pressure behaviour. Lubrication Engineering 1990; 46:566-572.
173. Zhang J, Yang L, Liu W, Xue Q. The mechanisms of boundary lubrication and antioxidation of bromobenzo-15-crown-5 as novel additive. Wear 1999; 236:303-307.
174. Furey MJ. The formation of polymeric films directly on rubbing surfaces to reduce wear. Wear 1973; 20:369-392.
175. Furey MJ, Kajdas C, Kempinski R. Applications of the concept of tribopolymerisation in fuels, lubricants, metal working, and 'minimalist' lubrication. Lubrication Science 2002; 15:73-82.
176. Zhang J, Yang L, Liu W, Xue Q. The effect of poly(hexanedioic-1,2- propylene-glycol) ester on the wear of steel. Wear 1999; 232:61-66.
177. Müller M, Topolovec-Miklozic K, Dardin A, Spikes HA. The design of boundary film-forming PMA viscosity modifiers. Tribology Transactions 2006; 49:225-232.
178. Muller M, Fan J, Spikes HA. Influence of polymethacrylate viscosity index improvers on friction and wear of lubricant formulations. SAE Tech. Paper 2007-01-1985, 2007.
179. Chinas FC. The behaviour of colloids in lubricated contacts. PhD Thesis, University of London, 2000.
180. Bakunin VN, Suslov AY, Kuzmina GN, Parenago OP. Recent achievements in the synthesis and application of inorganic nanoparticles as lubricant components. Lubrication Science 2005; 17:127-145.
181. Zhou J, Wu Z, Zhang Z, Liu W, Xue Q. Tribological behaviour and lubricating mechanism of Cu nanoparticles in oil. Tribology Letters 2000; 8:213-218.
182. Qiu S, Zhou Z, Dong J, Chen G. Preparation of Ni nanoparticles and evaluation of their tribological performance as potential antiwear additives in oils. Transactions of the American Society of Mechanical Engineers, Journal of Tribology 2001;123:441-443.
183. Chinas-Castillo F, Spikes HA. The behavior of colloidal solid particles in elastohydrodynamic contacts. Tribology Transactions 2000; 43:387-394.
184. Chinas-Castillo F, Spikes HA. The lubricating properties of dilute colloidal solid dispersions. Proceedings of the ITC Conference, Nagasaki, Japan, October 2000, Vol. I, 649-654.
185. Xue Q, Liu W, Zhang Z. Friction and wear properties of a surface-modified TiO2 nanoparticle as an additive in liquid paraffin. Wear 1997; 213:29-32.
186. Hu ZS, Dong JX. Study of antiwear and reducing friction additive of nanometer titanium oxide. Wear 1998; 216:92-96.
187. Hu ZS, Dong JX, Chen GX. Study of antiwear and reducing friction additive of nanometer ferric oxide. Tribology International 1998; 31:355-360.
188. 3 nanocluster modified by compound containing nitrogen in liquid paraffin. Wear 1998; 218:139-144.
189. Hernandez Battez A, Fernandez Rico JE, Navas Arias A, Viesca Rodríguez JL, Chou Rodríguez R, Diaz Fernandez JM. The tribological behaviour of ZnO nanoparticles as an additive to PA06. Wear 2006; 261:256-263.
190. Wu YY, Tsui WC, Liu TC. Experimental analysis of tribological properties of lubricating oils with nanoparticle additives. Wear 2007; 262:819-825.
191. Topolovec-Miklozic K, Spikes HA, Forbus TR. The film-forming and friction properties of overbased calcium sulphonate detergents. Presented at Additives 2007 and submitted for publication in Tribology Letters.
192. Mansot JL, Hallouis M, Martin JM. Colloidal antiwear additives. 2. Tribological behaviour of colloidal additives in mild wear regime. Colloids and Surfaces 1993; 75:25-31.
193. Sims MJ. Lubricant containing dispersed borate and a polyol. US Patent 3819521, 1974.
194. Adams JH. Lubricant containing potassium borate. US Patent 3997454, 1976.
195. Adams JH. Borate - a new generation EP gear lubricant. Lubrication Engineering 1977; 33:241-246.
196. Liu W, Xue Q, Wang H, Zhang X, Huang C. The antiwear properties of sodium metaborate as an oil additive. Lubrication Engineering 1992; 48:290-293.
197. Liu W, Zhang B, Huang C, Zhang X, Xue Q, Wang H. The antiwear properties of potassium borate as an oil additive. Lubrication Engineering 1990; 47:344-347.
198. Morizur MF, Taysset O. Antiwear actions of additives in solid dispersion. Lubrication Science 1992; 4:277-299.
199. Hu ZS, Lai R, Lou F, Wang LG, Chen ZL, Chen GX, Dong JX. Preparation and tribological properties of nanometer magnesium borate as lubricating oil additive. Wear 2002; 252:370-374.
200. Normand V, Martin JM, Ponsonnet L, Inoue K. Micellar calcium borate as an antiwear additive. Tribology Letters 1998; 5:235-242.
201. Chen GX, Hu ZS, Nai R, Wang LG, Peng Y, Dong JX. Preparation and tribology of ultrafine and amorphous strontium borate. Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineering 2001; J215:133-140.
202. Hu ZS, Shi YG, Wang LG, Peng Y, Chen GX, Dong JX. Study of antiwear and reducing friction additive of nanometer aluminium borate. Lubrication Engineering 2001; 57:23-27.
203. Hu ZS, Dong JX. Study on antiwear and reducing friction additive of nanometer titanium borate. Wear 1988; 216: 87-91.
204. Dong JX, He ZS. A study of the anti-wear and friction-reducing properties of the lubricant additive, nanometer zinc borate. Tribology International 1998; 31:219-223.
205. Hu ZS, Dong JX, Chen GX, He JZ. Preparation and tribological properties of nanoparticle lanthanum borate. Wear 2000; 243:43-47.
206. Qiao Y, Liu W, Qi S, Xue Q, Xu B, Ma S. The tribochemical mechanism of the borate modified by N-containing compound as oil additive. Wear 1998; 215:165-169.
207. Gupta BK, Bhushan B. Fullerene particles as an additive to liquid lubricants and greases for low friction and wear. Lubrication Engineering 1994; 50:524-528.
208. Ginzburg BM, Kireenko OF, Shepelevskii AA, Shibaev LA, Tochilnikov DG, Leksovskii AM. Thermal and tribological; properties of fullerene-containing composite systems. Part 2. Formation of tribo-polymer films during boundary sliding friction in the presence of fullerene C60. Journal of Macromolecular Science 2005; 44:93-115.
209. Chen CS, Chen XH, Xu LS, Yang Z, Li WH. Modification of multi-walled carbon nanotubes with fatty acid and their tribological properties as lubricant additive. Carbon 2005; 43:1660-1666.
210. Peng Y, Hu Y, Wang H. Tribological behaviors of surfactant-functionalized carbon nanotubes as lubricant additives in water. Tribology Letters 2006; 25:247-253.
211. 2 nanoparticles. Surfaces and Coatings 2002; 160:282-287.
212. Tenne R. Inorganic nanotubes and fullerene-like nanoparticles. Nature Nanotechnology 2006; 1:103-111.
213. 2 under boundary lubrication. Tribology Letters 2005; 18:477-485.
214. 2 as additive in paraffin oil. Tribology Letters 2005; 20:247-250.
215. 2 particles in a Hertzian contact. Journal of Applied Physics 2006; 99:023524.
216. Chinas Castillo F, Spikes HA. Mechanism of action of colloidal solid dispersions. Transactions of the American Society of Mechanical Engineers, Journal of Tribology 2003; 125:552-557.
217. Perfiliev V, Moshkovith A, Verdyan A, Tenne R, Rapoport L. A new way to feed nanoparticles to friction interfaces. Tribology Letters 2006; 21:89-93.
218. Nakazato M, Magarifuchi J, Isozaki Y. Low phosphorous engine oil compositions and additive compositions. US Patent 5629272, 1997.
219. Arrowsmith S, Diggs NZ, Ritchie AJD, Pain JO. Lubricating oil compositions. US Patent 7018958, 2006.
220. Abraham WD, Kelby JC, Vilardo JS. Molybdenum, sulphur and boron containing lubricating oil composition. US Patent 6777378, 2004.
221. Robson R, Glyde RW, Brown AJ, Chung SSM, Arrowsmith S. Lubricating oil compositions. US Patent 7026273, 2006.
222. Holt DGL, Vernon PDF, Atherton JI. Lubricant compositions containing antiwear combination. US Patent 6187723, 2001.
223. Gatto VJ. Lubricant composition containing phosphorous, molybdenum, and hydroxyl-substituted dithiocarbamates. US Patent 7112558, 2006.
224. Cartwright SJ. Long life lubricating oil composition with very low phosphorus content. US Patent 7183241, 2007.
225. Evans RD, More KL, Darragh CV, Nixon HP. Transmission electron microscopy of boundary-lubricated bearing surfaces. Part II: mineral oil lubricant with sulphur- and phosphorus-containing gear oil additives. Tribology Transactions 2005; 48:299-307.
226. Feng I-M, Perilstein WL, Adams MR. Solid film deposition and non-sacrificial boundary lubrication. ASLE Transactions 1963; 6:60-65.
227. Dong J, Chen G, Luo X, Chen L, Shi ZE. A new concept -formation of permeating layers from nonactive antiwear additives. Lubrication Engineering 1994; 50:17-22.
228. Chamberlin WB, Kelly JC, Wilk MA. The impact of passenger car motor oils on emissions performance. SAE Tech. Paper 2003-01-1988, 2003.
229. Selby TW. Phosphorus volatility of engine oils: the use of the phosphorus emission index. Tribotest 2005; 11:247-267.