Grade retention: Decision-making and effects on learning as well as social and emotional development

School Effectiveness and School Improvement

Volumn 19, Issue 1, 2008, Pages 1-19

  Bonvin, P ^a   Bless, G ^a   Schuepbach, M ^b  

^a UNIVERSITY OF FRIBOURG   (Switzerland)

^b Paedagogische Hochschule Solothurn   (Switzerland)

Author keywords

Evaluation research; Grade retention; School failure

Indexed keywords

EID: 40749131293     PISSN: 09243453     EISSN: 17445124     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1080/09243450701856499     Document Type: Article

References (55)

1. Alexander, K.L., Entwisle, D.R., & Dauber, S.L. (1994). On the success of failure: A reassessment of the effects of retention in the primary grades. New York: Cambridge University Press.
2. Allai, L., & Ntamakiliro, L. (1997). Echec précoce et maîtrise de l'écrit [Early failure in school and the mastery of written language]. In C. Barré-De Miniac & B. Leté (Eds.), L'illetrisme: De la prévention chez l'enfant aux stratégies deformation chez l'adulte (pp. 83-101). Brussels, Belgium.: DeBoeck.
3. Andrews, T.J., Wisniewski, JJ., & Mulick, J.A. (1997). Variables influencing teachers' decisions to refer children for school psychological assessment services. Psychology in the Schools, 34, 239-244.
4. Bless, G. (2002). Zur Wirksamkeit der Integration. Forschungsüberblick, praktische Umsetzung einer integrativen Schulform, Untersuchungen zum Lernfortschritt [The efficiency of inclusion: Literature review, practical development of an inclusive school system, and research on learning outcomes]. Bern/Stuttgart/Wien: Haupt-Verlag.
5. Bless, G., Bonvin, P., & Schuepbach, M. (2005). Le redoublement scolaire: Ses déterminants, son efficacité, ses conséquences [Grade retention: Determinants, efficiency, and consequences]. Bern/Stuttgart/Wien: Haupt-Verlag.
6. Bless, G., & Kronig, W. (1999). Wie integrationsfähig ist die Schweizer Schule geworden? Eine bildungsstatistische Analyse über schulorganisatorische Maßnahmen bei "Normabweichungen" [How inclusive have Swiss schools become? An analysis of educational statistics concerning school system-level measures for dealing with deviations from the norm]. Vierteljahresschrift für Heilpädagogik und ihre Nachbargebiete VHN, 68, 414-426.
7. Bonvin, P. (2003). The role of teacher attitudes and judgement in decision-making: The case of grade retention. European Educational Research Journal, 2, 277-294.
8. Bonvin, P. (2005). Le personnel enseignant face à l'échec scolaire: Attitudes, évaluations et décisions vis-à-vis du redoublement [Teachers faced with failure in school: Attitudes, evaluations, and decisions with regard to grade retention]. Fribourg, Switzerland: Centre Universitaire de Pédagogie curative.
9. Byrnes, B.M. (1986). Self-concept/academic achievement relations: An investigation of dimensionality, stability, and causality. Canadian Journal of Behavioural Science, 18, 173-186.
10. Byrnes, D.A., & Yamamoto, K. (1986). Views on grade repetition. Journal of Research and Development in Education, 20, 14-20.
11. Cadigan, D., Entwisle, D.R., Alexander, K.L., & Pallas, A.M. (1988). First-grade retention among low achieving students: A search for significant predictors. Merrill Palmer Quarterly, 34, 71-88.
12. Carstens, A.A. (1985). Retention and social promotion for the exceptional child. School Psychology Review, 41, 48-63.
13. Cattell, R.B., Weiss, R., & Osterland, J. (1997). Grundintelligenztest Skala 1 [Culture-free intelligence test 1] (5th ed.). Göttingen, Germany: Hogrefe.
14. Dauber, S.L., Alexander, KL., & Entwisle, D.R. (1993). Characteristics of retainees and early precursors of retention in grade: Who is held back? Merrill Palmer Quarterly, 39, 326-343.
15. Forster, J.E. (1993). Reviews of research: Retaining children in grade. Childhood Education, 70, 38-43.
16. Georgiou, S.N., Christou, C., Stavrinides, P., & Panaoura, G. (2002). Teacher attributions of student failure and teacher behavior toward the failing student. Psychology in the Schools, 39, 583-595.
17. Gomolla, M., & Radtke, F.O. (2002). Institutionelle Diskriminierung. Die Herstellung ethnischer Differenz in der Schule [Institutional discrimination: The construction of ethnic differences in schools]. Opladen, Germany: Leske & Budrich.
18. Haeberlin, U., Moser, U., Bless, G., & Klaghofer, R. (1989). Integration in die Schulklasse. Fragebogen zur Erfassung von Dimensionen der Integration von Schülern FDI 4-6 [Integration in the classroom. Questionnaire about the dimensions of pupils' integration FDI 4-6]. Bern/Stuttgart/Wien: Haupt.
19. Hagborg, W.J., Masella, G., Palladino, P., & Shepardson, J. (1991). A follow-up study of high school students with a history of grade retention. Psychology in the Schools, 28, 310-316.
20. Harter, S. (1985). Manual for the self-perception profile for children: Revision of the Perceived Competence Scale for Children. Denver, CO: University of Denver.
21. Hauser, R.M. (1999). Should we end social promotion? Truth and consequences. Madison, WI: University of Wisconsin-Madison, Center for Demography and Ecology.
22. Hauser, R.M., Pager, D.I., & Simmons, S.J. (2001). Race-ethnicity, social background, and grade retention. An analysis of the last thirty years. CEIC Review, 19(5), 11-12.
23. Holmes, C.T. (1990). Grade level retention effects: A meta-analysis of research studies. In L. Shepard & M. Smith (Eds.), Flunking grades: Research and policies on retention (pp. 16-33). London/New York/Philadelphia: Falmer Press.
24. Holmes, C.T., & Matthews, K.M. (1984). The effects of non-promotion on elementary and junior high school pupils: A meta-analysis. Review of Educational Research, 54, 225-236.
25. Jackson, G.B. (1975). The research evidence on the effects of grade retention. Review of Educational Research, 45, 613-635.
26. Jimerson, S.R. (2001). Meta-analysis of the effects of grade retention 1990 - 1999. The CEIC Review, 10, 5.
27. Jimerson, S.R., Anderson, G.E., & Whipple, A.A. (2002). Winning the battle and losing the war: Examining the relation between grade retention and dropping out of high school. Psychology in the Schools, 39, 441-457.
28. Jimerson, S.R., Carlson, E., Rotert, M., Egeland, B., & Sroufe, L.A. (1997). A prospective, longitudinal study of the correlates and consequences of early grade retention. Journal of School Psychology, 35, 3-25.
29. Karweit, N.L. (1999). Grade retention: Prevalence, timing, effects. Baltimore: John Hopkins University.
30. Krueger, H.-P. (1976). Soziometrie in der Schule. Verfahren und Ergebnisse zu sozialen Determinanten der Schülerpersönlichkeit [Sociometry in schools: Methodology and results concerning the social determinants of the pupils' personality]. Basel, Switzerland: Weinheim.
31. Lee, Y.T., Jussim, L.J., & McCauley, C.R., (Eds.). (1995). Stereotype accuracy: Toward appreciating group differences. Washington, DC: APA.
32. Mantzicopoulos, P., & Morrison, D.C. (1992). Kindergarten retention: Academic and behavioural outcomes through the end of second grade. American Educational Research Journal, 29, 182-198.
33. Marsch, H.W. (1990). Influences of internal and external frames of reference on the formation of math and English self-concepts. Journal of Educational Psychology, 82, 107-116.
34. McCoy, A.R.J., & Reynolds, A. (1999). Grade retention and school performance: An extended investigation. Journal of School Psychology, 37, 273-298.
35. Meisels, S.J., & Liaw, F.-R. (1993). Failure in grade: Do retained students catch up? Journal of Educational Research, 87, 69-77.
36. Nason, R.B. (1991). Retaining children: Is it the right decision? Childhood Education, 67, 300-304.
37. Niklason, L.B. (1984). Non-promotion: a pseudoscientific solution. Psychology in the Schools, 21, 485-499.
38. Paul, J.-J. (1996). Le redoublement: Pour ou contre [Grade retention: Pros and cons]. Paris: ESF.
39. Peterson, S.E., De Gracie, J.S., & Ayabe, CR. (1987). A longitudinal study of the effects of retention/promotion on academic achievement. American Educational Research Journal, 24, 107-118.
40. Pierson, L.H., & Connell, J.P. (1992). Effect of grade retention on self-system processes, school engagement, and academic performance. Journal of Educational Psychology, 84, 300-307.
41. Pini, G. (1991). Effets et méfaits du discours pédagogique: Échec scolaire et redoublement vus par les enseignants [Uses and misuses of pedagogical discourse: Failure in school and grade retention as viewed by teachers]. Education et Recherche, 13, 255-272.
42. Plummer, D.L., & Graziano, W.G. (1987). Impact of grade retention on the social development of elementary school children. Developmental Psychology, 23, 267-275.
43. Pomplun, M. (1988). Retention: The earlier, the better? Journal of Educational Research, 81, 281-287.
44. Reynolds, A.J. (1992). Grade retention and school adjustment: An explanatory analysis. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 14, 101-121.
45. Safer, D.J. (1986). Nonpromotion correlates and outcomes at different grade levels. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 19(8), 500-503.
46. Setencich, J. (1994). The impact of early grade retention on academic achievement and self-esteem of seventh and eighth grade students. Annual Convention of the National Association of School Psychologists, 26, 1-11.
47. Shepard, L.A. (1995). Grade repeating. In L.W. Anderson (Ed.), International encyclopedia of teaching and teacher education (pp. 324-326). Oxford: Elsevier Science.
48. Shepard, L.A., & Smith, M.L. (1987). Effects of kindergarten retention at the end of first grade. Psychology in the Schools, 24, 346-357.
49. Shepard, L. A., & Smith, M.L., (Eds.). (1990). Flunking grades: Research and policies on retention. Philadelphia: The Falmer Press.
50. Stanovich, PJ., Jordan, A., & Perot, J. (1998). Relative differences in academic self-concept and peer acceptance among students in inclusive classrooms. Remedial and Special Education, 19, 120-126.
51. Schuepbach, M. (2004). Effizienz der Klassenrepetition auf der Primarschulstufe als Massnahme zur Begegnung von Lernschwierigkeiten in den schulischen Kernfächern [The efficiency of grade retention in primary school as a measure dealing with learning difficulties in main subjects]. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of Fribourg, Switzerland.
52. Tomchin, E.M., & Impara, J.C. (1992). Unravelling teachers' beliefs about grade retention. American Educational Research Journal, 29, 199-223.
53. Tweed, B.S. (2001). How is a child's perception of self affected by retention? Unpublished doctoral dissertation, East Tennessee State University, Johnson City, TN.
54. Wang, M.C., Haertel, G.D., & Walberg, H.J. (1993). Toward a knowledge base for school learning. Review of Educational Research, 63(3), 249-294.
55. Wasik, B.H., Wasik, J.L., & Frank, R. (1993). Sociometric characteristics of kindergarten children at risk for school failure. Journal of School Psychology, 31, 241-257.