Flawed population viability analysis can result in misleading population assessment: A case study for wolves in Algonquin park, Canada

Biological Conservation

Volumn 141, Issue 3, 2008, Pages 669-680

  Patterson, Brent R ^a   Murray, Dennis L ^a  

^a TRENT UNIVERSITY   (Canada)

Author keywords

Protected area; PVA; Scientific method; Time series analysis; Wolf

Indexed keywords

ASSESSMENT METHOD; CANID; CONSERVATION STATUS; POPULATION DENSITY; POPULATION VIABILITY ANALYSIS; WILDLIFE MANAGEMENT;

ALGONQUIN PROVINCIAL PARK; CANADA; NORTH AMERICA; ONTARIO [CANADA];

CANIDAE;

EID: 40349101963     PISSN: 00063207     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.biocon.2007.12.010     Document Type: Article

References (76)

1. Akcakaya H.R. Viability analyses with habitat-based metapopulation models. Population Ecology 42 (2000) 45-53
2. Aspi J., Roininen E., Ruokonen M., Kojola I., and Vila C. Genetic diversity, population structure, effective population size and demographic history of the Finnish wolf population. Molecular Ecology 15 (2006) 1561-1576
3. Ballard W.B., Whitman J.S., and Gardner C.L. Ecology of an exploited wolf population in south-central Alaska. Wildlife Monograph (1987) 98
4. Barry D., and Oelschlaeger M. A science for survival: values and conservation biology. Conservation Biology 10 (1996) 905-911
5. Beissinger S., and Westphal M.I. On the use of demographic models of population viability in endangered species management. Journal of Wildlife Management 62 (1998) 821-841
6. Blockstein D.E. How to lose your political virginity while keeping your scientific credibility. BioScience 52 (2002) 91-96
7. Boertje R.D., Valkenburg P., and McNay M.E. Increases in moose, caribou, and wolves following wolf control in Alaska. Journal of Wildlife Management 60 (1996) 474-489
8. Brook B.W., Lim L., Hareden R., and Frankham R. Does population viability analysis software predict the behaviour of real populations? A retrospective study on the Lord Howe Island woodhen, Tricholimnas sylvestris (Sclater). Biological Conservation 82 (1997) 119-128
9. Brook B.W., and Bradshaw C.J.A. Strength of evidence for density dependence in abundance time series of 1198 species. Ecology 87 (2006) 1445-1451
10. Brook B.W., Burgman M.A., Akçakaya H.R., O'Grady J.J., and Frankham R. Critiques of PVA ask the wrong questions: throwing the heuristic baby out with the numerical bath water. Conservation Biology 16 (2002) 262-263
11. Burch J.W., Adams L.G., Follmann E.H., and Rextad E.A. Evaluation of wolf density estimation from radiotelemetry data. Wildlife Society Bulletin 33 (2005) 1225-1236
12. Burnham K.P., and Anderson D.R. Model Selection and Multimodel Inference (2002), Springer-Verlag, New York
13. Carmichael L.E., Nagy J.A., Larter N.C., and Strobeck C. Prey specialization may influence patterns of gene flow in wolves of the Canadian northwest. Molecular Ecology 10 (2001) 2787-2798
14. Caswell H. Matrix Population Models: Construction, Analysis and Interpretation. second ed. (2001), Sinauer Associates, Sunderland, Massachusetts
15. Caughley G., and Gunn A. Conservation Biology in Theory and Practice (1996), Blackwell Scientific, Cambridge, MA
16. Conservation Breeding Specialists Group (SSC/IUCN). The Wolves of Algonquin Park PHVA: Briefing Book (2000), Apple Valley, MN: CSBG
17. Corsi F., Duprè E., and Boitani L. A large-scale model of wolf distribution in Italy for conservation planning. Conservation Biology 13 (1999) 150-159
18. COSEWIC, 2007. Canadian Species at Risk. Committee on the Status of Endangered Wildlife in Canada, January 2007. p. 84.
19. Coulson T., Mace G.M., Hudson E., and Possingham H. The use and abuse of population viability analysis. Trends in Ecology and Evolution 16 (2001) 219-221
20. Crouse D., Crowder L., and Caswell H. A stage-based population model for loggerhead sea turtles and implications for conservation. Ecology 68 (1987) 1412-1423
21. Dennis B., and Taper M.L. Density dependence in time series observations of natural populations: estimation and testing. Ecological Monographs 64 (1994) 205-224
22. Dennis B., Munholland P.L., and Scott J.M. Estimation of growth and extinction parameters for endangered species. Ecological Monographs 61 (1991) 115-143
23. Dixon P.M., and Pechmann J.H.K. A statistical test to show negligible trend. Ecology 86 (2005) 1751-1756
24. Ellner S.P., Fieberg J., Ludwig D., and Wilcox C. Precision of population viability analysis. Conservation Biology 16 (2002) 258-261
25. Fieberg J., and Ellner S.P. When is it meaningful to estimate an extinction probability?. Ecology 81 (2000) 2040-2047
26. Fuller T.K. Population dynamics of wolves on north-central Minnesota. Wildlife Monographs (1989) 105
27. Fuller T.K., Mech L.D., and Cochrane J.F. Wolf population dynamics. In: Mech L.D., and Boitani L. (Eds). Wolves: Behavior, ecology, and Conservation (2003), University of Chicago Press, Chicago, Illinois 161-191
28. Gaillard J.-M., Festa-Bianchet M., and Yoccoz N.G. Population dynamics of large herbivores: variable recruitment with constant adult survival. Trends in Ecology and Evolution 13 (1998) 58-63
29. Galimberti F., Sanvito S., Boitani L., and Fabiani A. Viability of the southern elephant seal population of the Falkland Islands. Animal Conservation 4 (2001) 81-88
30. Geffen E., Anderson M.J., and Wayne R.K. Climate and habitat barriers to dispersal in the highly mobile grey wolf. Molecular Ecology 13 (2004) 2481-2490
31. Grewal S.K., Wilson P., Kung T.K., Shami K., Theberge M.T., Theberge J.B., and White B.N. A genetic assessment of the Eastern Wolf (Canis Lycaon) in Algonquin Provincial Park. Journal of Mammalogy 85 (2004) 625-632
32. Groom M.J., and Pascual M.A. The analysis of population persistence: an outlook on the practice of viability analysis. In: Fiedler P.L., and Kareiva P.M. (Eds). Conservation Biology for the Coming Decade (1997), Chapman and Hall, New York 3-33
33. Haydon D.T., Laurenson M.K., and Sillero-Zubiri C. Integrating epidemiology into population viability analysis: managing the risk posed by rabies and canine distemper to the Ethiopian wolf. Conservation Biology 16 (2002) 1372-1385
34. Hayes R.D., and Harestad A.S. Demography of a recovering wolf population in the Yukon. Canadian Journal of Zoology 78 (2000) 36-48
35. Hebblewhite M., White C.A., Nietvelt C.G., McKenzie J.A., Hurd T.E., Fryxell J.M., Bayley S.E., and Paquet P.C. Human activity mediates a trophic cascade caused by wolves. Ecology 86 (2005) 2135-2144
36. Heinsohn R., Lacy R.C., Lindenmayer D.B., Marsh H., Kwan D., and Lawler I. Unsustainable harvest of dugongs in Torres Strait and Cape York (Australia) waters: two case studies using population viability analysis. Animal Conservation 7 (2004) 1-9
37. Keith L.B. Population dynamics of wolves. In: Carbyn L.N. (Ed). Wolves in Canada and Alaska: Their Status, Biology, and Management (1983), Canadian Wildlife Service, Edmonton, Alberta 66-77
38. Keppie D.M. Context, emergence, and research design. Wildlife Society Bulletin 34 (2006) 242-246
39. Kyle C.J., Johnson A.R., Patterson B.R., Wilson P.J., Shami K., Grewal S.K., and White B.N. Genetic nature of eastern wolves: past, present and future. Conservation Genetics 7 (2006) 273-287
40. Lande R., Engen S., and Saether B.-E. Stochastic Population Dynamics in Ecology and Conservation (2003), Oxford University Press, Oxford, UK
41. Longino H.E. Science as Social Knowledge: Values and Objectivity in Scientific Inquiry (1990), Princeton University Press, Princeton, New Jersey
42. Lotts K.C., Waite T.C., and Vucetich J.A. Reliability of absolute and relative predictions of population persistence based on time series. Conservation Biology 18 (2004) 1224-1232
43. Lubchenco J. Entering the century of the environment: a new social contract for science. Science 279 (1998) 491-497
44. Ludwig D. Management of stocks that may collapse. Oikos 83 (1998) 397-402
45. Ludwig D. Is it meaningful to estimate the probability of extinction?. Ecology 80 (1999) 298-310
46. McCallum H. Population Parameters: Estimation for Ecological Models (2000), Blackwell-Science, Oxford University Press, New York
47. McCarthy M.A. The allee effect, finding mates, and theoretical models. Ecological Modeling 103 (1997) 99-102
48. McCarthy M.A., Possingham H.P., Day J.R., and Tyre A.J. Testing the accuracy of population viability analysis. Conservation Biology 15 (2001) 1030-1038
49. Menges E. Population viability analysis for an endangered plant. Conservation Biology 4 (1990) 52-62
50. Messier F. Social organization, spatial distribution, and population density of wolves in relation to moose density. Canadian Journal of Zoology 63 (1985) 1068-1077
51. Mills, K.J., 2006. Wolf (Canis lycaon) pup survival, dispersal, and movements in Algonquin Provincial Park, Ontario, Canada. Thesis, Trent University, Peterborough, Ontario.
52. Mills L.S., Hayes S.G., Baldwin C., Wisdom M.J., Citta J., Mattson D.J., and Murphy K. Factors leading to different viability predictions for a grizzly bear data set. Conservation Biology 10 (1996) 863-873
53. Morris W.F., and Doak D.F. Quantitative Conservation Biology (2002), Sinauer Associates, Sunderland, Massachusetts
54. Morris W.M., Bloch P.R., Hudgens B.R., Moyle L.C., and Stinchcombe J.R. Population viability analysis in species recovery plans: past use and future improvements. Ecological Applications 12 (2002) 708-712
55. Murray D.L. On improving telemetry-based survival estimation. Journal of Wildlife Management 70 (2006) 1530-1543
56. Nilsson T. Integrating effects of hunting policy, catastrophic events, and inbreeding depression, in PVA simulation: the Scandinavian wolf population as an example. Biological Conservation 115 (2003) 227-239
57. Ontario Ministry of Natural Resources. 2002. Notice of decision for Proposal, EBR Registry Number: RB01E6005. http://www.ebr.gov.on.ca/ERS-WEB-External/displaynoticecontent.do?notice Id=MTcyMTM=&statusId=MTcyMTM=&language=en (accessed 12 October 2007).
58. Patterson B.R., Quinn N.W.S., and Becker E.F. Estimating wolf densities in forested areas using network sampling of tracks in snow. Wildlife Society Bulletin 32 (2004) 938-947
59. Potvin F., Jolicoeur H., and Breton L. Evaluation of an experimental wolf reduction and its impact on deer in Papineau-Labelle, Quebec. Canadian Journal of Zoology 70 (1992) 1595-1603
60. Reed J.M., Mills L.S., Dunning Jr. J.B., Menges E.S., McKelvey K.S., Frye R., Beisinger S.R., Anstett M.-C., and Miller P. Emerging issues in population viability analysis. Conservation Biology 16 (2002) 7-19
61. Ripple W.J., and Beschta R.L. Wolves, elk, willows, and trophic cascades in the upper Gallatin Range of Southwestern Montana, USA. Forest Ecology and Management 200 (2004) 161-181
62. Royama T. Analytical Population Dynamics (1992), Chapman & Hall, London
63. Rykiel E.J. Scientific Objectivity, Value Systems, and Policymaking 51 (2001) 433-436
64. Saether B.-E., and Engen S. Pattern of variation in avian population growth rates. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London, Series B. 357 (2002) 1185-1195
65. Sinclair A.R.E. Population regulation in mammals. In: Cherrett J.M. (Ed). Ecological Concepts (1989), Blackwell Scientific publications, Oxford 197-242
66. Sokal R.R., and Rohlf F.J. Biometry: The Principles and Practice of Statistics in Biological Research (1995), W.H. Freeman, New York
67. Steury T.D., and Murray D.L. Modeling the reintroduction of lynx to the southern portion of its range. Biological Conservation 117 (2004) 127-141
68. Stinchcombe, J., Moyle, L.C., Hudgens, B.R., Bloch, P.L., Chinnadurai, S., Morris, W.F., 2002. The influence of the academic conservation biology literature on endangered species recovery planning. Conservation Ecology 6, 15. [online] URL: http://www.consecol.org/vol6/iss2/art15.
69. Strickland D. Trees of Algonquin Provincial Park. The Friends of Algonquin Park (1993), Whitney, Ontario
70. Theberge J.B., and Theberge M.T. The Wolves of Algonquin Park: A 12 Year Ecological Study (2004), University of Waterloo, Department of Geography publication 56, Ontario
71. Theberge J.B., Theberge M.T., Vucetich J.A., and Paquet P.C. Pitfalls of applying adaptive management to a wolf population in Algonquin Provincial Park, Ontario. Environmental Management 37 (2006) 451-460
72. Veit R.R., and Lewis M.A. Dispersal, population growth, and the allee effect: dynamics of the house finch invasion of eastern North America. The American Naturalist 148 (1996) 255-274
73. Vucetich J.A., Peterson R.O., and Waite T.A. Effects of social structure and prey dynamics on extinction risk in gray wolves. Conservation Biology 11 (1997) 957-965
74. Vucetich, J., Paquet, P., 2000. The demographic population viability of Algonquin wolves. Unpublished report prepared for the Algonquin Wolf Advisory Committee, [online] URL: www.cpaws-ov.org/algonquinwolves/docs/vucetichpaquet.pdf (accessed 12 October 2007).
75. White G.C. Population viability analysis: data requirements and essential analyses. In: Boitani L., and Fuller T.K. (Eds). Research Techniques in Animal Ecology: Controversies and Consequences (2000), Columbia University Press, New York 288-331
76. Williams B.K., Nichols J.D., and Conroy M.J. Analysis and Management of Animal Populations (2002), Academic Press, New York