Laparoscopic versus Open Partial Nephrectomy: Analysis of the Current Literature

European Urology

Volumn 53, Issue 4, 2008, Pages 732-743

  Porpiglia, Francesco ^a   Volpe, Alessandro ^a   Billia, Michele ^a   Scarpa, Roberto Mario ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF TURIN   (Italy)

Author keywords

Laparoscopy; Partial nephrectomy; Renal cell carcinoma; Renal tumour

Indexed keywords

COMPUTER ASSISTED TOMOGRAPHY; HUMAN; INTERMETHOD COMPARISON; KIDNEY FUNCTION; KIDNEY TUMOR; LAPAROSCOPIC SURGERY; OUTCOME ASSESSMENT; PARTIAL NEPHRECTOMY; POSTOPERATIVE COMPLICATION; POSTOPERATIVE PERIOD; PRIORITY JOURNAL; REVIEW; SURVIVAL RATE;

CARCINOMA, RENAL CELL; CLINICAL COMPETENCE; HUMANS; KIDNEY NEOPLASMS; LAPAROSCOPY; NEPHRECTOMY; POSTOPERATIVE COMPLICATIONS; QUALITY OF LIFE; SURVIVAL ANALYSIS;

EID: 39549092419     PISSN: 03022838     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.eururo.2008.01.025     Document Type: Review

References (85)

1. Jemal A., Siegel R., Ward E., Murray T., Xu J., and Thun M.J. Cancer statistics, 2007. CA Cancer J Clin 57 (2007) 43-66
2. Hock L.M., Lynch J., and Balaji K.C. Increasing incidence of all stages of kidney cancer in the last 2 decades in the United States: an analysis of surveillance, epidemiology and end results program data. J Urol 167 (2002) 57-60
3. Chow W.H., Devesa S.S., Warren J.L., and Fraumeni Jr. J.F. Rising incidence of renal cell cancer in the United States. JAMA 281 (1999) 1628-1631
4. Lee C.T., Katz J., Shi W., Thaler H.T., Reuter V.E., and Russo P. Surgical management of renal tumors 4 cm. or less in a contemporary cohort. J Urol 163 (2000) 730-736
5. Fergany A.F., Hafez K.S., and Novick A.C. Long-term results of nephron sparing surgery for localized renal cell carcinoma: 10-year followup. J Urol 163 (2000) 442-445
6. Lesage K., Joniau S., Fransis K., and Van Poppel H. Comparison between open partial and radical nephrectomy for renal tumours: perioperative outcome and health-related quality of life. Eur Urol 51 (2007) 614-620
7. McKiernan J., Simmons R., Katz J., and Russo P. Natural history of chronic renal insufficiency after partial and radical nephrectomy. Urology 59 (2002) 816-820
8. Ljungberg B., Hanbury D.C., Kuczyk M.A., et al. Renal cell carcinoma guideline. Eur Urol 51 (2007) 1502-1510
9. Miller D.C., Hollingsworth J.M., Hafez K.S., Daignault S., and Hollenbeck B.K. Partial nephrectomy for small renal masses: an emerging quality of care concern?. J Urol 175 (2006) 853-857 discussion 858
10. Gill I.S., Desai M.M., Kaouk J.H., et al. Laparoscopic partial nephrectomy for renal tumor: duplicating open surgical techniques. J Urol 167 (2002) 467-469 discussion 475-6
11. Zucchi A., Mearini L., Mearini E., Costantini E., Vivacqua C., and Porena M. Renal cell carcinoma: histological findings on surgical margins after nephron sparing surgery. J Urol 169 (2003) 905-908
12. Spaliviero M., and Gill I.S. Laparoscopic partial nephrectomy. BJU Int 99 (2007) 1313-1328
13. Wright J.L., and Porter J.R. Laparoscopic partial nephrectomy: comparison of transperitoneal and retroperitoneal approaches. J Urol 174 (2005) 841-845
14. Haber G.P., and Gill I.S. Laparoscopic partial nephrectomy: contemporary technique and outcomes. Eur Urol 49 (2006) 660-665
15. Ng C.S., Gill I.S., Ramani A.P., et al. Transperitoneal versus retroperitoneal laparoscopic partial nephrectomy: patient selection and perioperative outcomes. J Urol 174 (2005) 846-849
16. Kaul S., Laungani R., Sarle R., et al. Da Vinci-assisted robotic partial nephrectomy: technique and results at a mean of 15 months of follow-up. Eur Urol 51 (2007) 186-192 (discussion 191-2)
17. Uzzo R.G., and Novick A.C. Nephron sparing surgery for renal tumors: indications, techniques and outcomes. J Urol 166 (2001) 6-18
18. Thompson R.H., Leibovich B.C., Lohse C.M., Zincke H., and Blute M.L. Complications of contemporary open nephron sparing surgery: a single institution experience. J Urol 174 (2005) 855-858
19. Patard J.J., Pantuck A.J., Crepel M., et al. Morbidity and clinical outcome of nephron-sparing surgery in relation to tumour size and indication. Eur Urol 52 (2007) 148-154
20. Häcker A., Albadour A., Jauker W., et al. Nephron-sparing surgery for renal tumours: acceleration and facilitation of the laparoscopic technique. Eur Urol 51 (2007) 358-365
21. Rosales A., Salvador J., De Graeve N., Angerri O., and Villavicencio H. Clamping of the renal artery in laparoscopic partial nephrectomy: an old device for a new technique. Eur Urol 47 (2005) 98-101
22. Bollens R., Rosenblatt A., Espinoza B.P., et al. Laparoscopic partial nephrectomy with "on-demand" clamping reduces warm ischemia time. Eur Urol 52 (2007) 804-810
23. Guillonneau B., Bermudez H., Gholami S., et al. Laparoscopic partial nephrectomy for renal tumor: single center experience comparing clamping and no clamping techniques of the renal vasculature. J Urol 169 (2003) 483-486
24. Verhoest G., Manunta A., Bensalah K., et al. Laparoscopic partial nephrectomy with clamping of the renal parenchyma: initial experience. Eur Urol 52 (2007) 1340-1346
25. Steffens J., Humke U., Ziegler M., and Siemer S. Partial nephrectomy with perfusion cooling for imperative indications: a 24-year experience. BJU Int 96 (2005) 608-611
26. Fergany A.F., Saad I.R., Woo L., and Novick A.C. Open partial nephrectomy for tumor in a solitary kidney: experience with 400 cases. J Urol 175 (2006) 1630-1633 discussion 1633
27. Gill I.S., Abreu S.C., Desai M.M., et al. Laparoscopic ice slush renal hypothermia for partial nephrectomy: the initial experience. J Urol 170 (2003) 52-56
28. Janetschek G., Abdelmaksoud A., Bagheri F., Al-Zahrani H., Leeb K., and Gschwendtner M. Laparoscopic partial nephrectomy in cold ischemia: renal artery perfusion. J Urol 171 (2004) 68-71
29. Landman J., Rehman J., Sundaram C.P., et al. Renal hypothermia achieved by retrograde intracavitary saline perfusion. J Endourol 16 (2002) 445-449
30. Abukora F., Albqami N., Nambirajan T., Ziegerhofer J., Leeb K., and Janetschek G. Long-term functional outcome of renal units after laparoscopic nephron-sparing surgery under cold ischemia. J Endourol 20 (2006) 790-793
31. Novick A.C. Partial nephrectomy for renal cell carcinoma. Urol Clin North Am 14 (1987) 419-433
32. Jacobs S.C., Berg S.I., and Lawson R.K. Synchronous bilateral renal cell carcinoma: total surgical excision. Cancer 46 (1980) 2341-2345
33. Sutherland S.E., Resnick M.I., Maclennan G.T., and Goldman H.B. Does the size of the surgical margin in partial nephrectomy for renal cell cancer really matter?. J Urol 167 (2002) 61-64
34. Carini M., Minervini A., Masieri L., Lapini A., and Serni S. Simple enucleation for the treatment of PT1a renal cell carcinoma: our 20-year experience. Eur Urol 50 (2006) 1263-1271 (discussion 1269-71)
35. Hafez K.S., Novick A.C., and Butler B.P. Management of small solitary unilateral renal cell carcinomas: impact of central versus peripheral tumor location. J Urol 159 (1998) 1156-1160
36. Campbell S.C., and Novick A.C. Expanding the indications for elective partial nephrectomy: is this advisable?. Eur Urol 49 (2006) 952-954
37. Kubinski D.J., Clark P.E., Assimos D.G., and Hall M.C. Utility of frozen section analysis of resection margins during partial nephrectomy. Urology 64 (2004) 31-34
38. ® as haemostatic treatment versus standard suturing in kidney tumour resection: a randomised prospective study. Eur Urol 52 (2007) 1156-1163
39. Jackman S.V., Cadeddu J.A., Chen R.N., et al. Utility of the harmonic scalpel for laparoscopic partial nephrectomy. J Endourol 12 (1998) 441-444
40. Porpiglia F., Fiori C., Terrone C., Bollito E., Fontana D., and Scarpa R.M. Assessment of surgical margins in renal cell carcinoma after nephron sparing: a comparative study: laparoscopy vs open surgery. J Urol 173 (2005) 1098-1101
41. Van Poppel H., and Joniau S. How important are surgical margins in nephron-sparing surgery?. Eur Urol Suppl 6 (2007) 533-539
42. Breda A., Stepanian S.V., Liao J., et al. Positive margins in laparoscopic partial nephrectomy in 855 cases: a multi-institutional survey from the United States and Europe. J Urol 178 (2007) 47-50 discussion 50
43. Venkatesh R., Weld K., Ames C.D., et al. Laparoscopic partial nephrectomy for renal masses: effect of tumor location. Urology 67 (2006) 1169-1174 discussion 1174
44. Bove P., Bhayani S.B., Rha K.H., Allaf M.E., Jarrett T.W., and Kavoussi L.R. Necessity of ureteral catheter during laparoscopic partial nephrectomy. J Urol 172 (2004) 458-460
45. Simmons M.N., and Gill I.S. Decreased complications of contemporary laparoscopic partial nephrectomy: use of a standardized reporting system. J Urol 177 (2007) 2067-2073 discussion 2073
46. Orvieto M.A., Chien G.W., Tolhurst S.R., et al. Simplifying laparoscopic partial nephrectomy: technical considerations for reproducible outcomes. Urology 66 (2005) 976-980
47. Porpiglia F., Renard J., Billia M., Morra I., Terrone C., and Scarpa R.M. Biological glues and collagen fleece for hemostasis during laparoscopic partial nephrectomy: technique and results of prospective study. J Endourol 21 (2007) 423-428
48. Breda A., Stepanian S.V., Lam J.S., et al. Use of haemostatic agents and glues during laparoscopic partial nephrectomy: a multi-institutional survey from the United States and Europe of 1347 cases. Eur Urol 52 (2007) 798-803
49. Gill I.S., Ramani A.P., Spaliviero M., et al. Improved hemostasis during laparoscopic partial nephrectomy using gelatin matrix thrombin sealant. Urology 65 (2005) 463-466
50. Gill I.S., Kavoussi L.R., Lane B.R., et al. Comparison of 1,800 laparoscopic and open partial nephrectomies for single renal tumors. J Urol 178 (2007) 41-46
51. Ghavamian R., Cheville J.C., Lohse C.M., Weaver A.L., Zincke H., and Blute M.L. Renal cell carcinoma in the solitary kidney: an analysis of complications and outcome after nephron sparing surgery. J Urol 168 (2002) 454-459
52. Bhayani S.B., Allaf M.E., Link R.E., et al. Laparoscopic partial nephrectomy in patients with neoplasia in a solitary kidney. Urology 64 (2004) 35-37
53. Gill I.S., Colombo Jr. J.R., Moinzadeh A., et al. Laparoscopic partial nephrectomy in solitary kidney. J Urol 175 (2006) 454-458
54. Ramani A.P., Desai M.M., Steinberg A.P., et al. Complications of laparoscopic partial nephrectomy in 200 cases. J Urol 173 (2005) 42-47
55. Frank I., Colombo Jr. J.R., Rubinstein M., Desai M., Kaouk J., and Gill I.S. Laparoscopic partial nephrectomy for centrally located renal tumors. J Urol 175 (2006) 849-852
56. Becker F., Siemer S., Humke U., Hack M., Ziegler M., and Stöckle M. Elective nephron-sparing surgery should become standard treatment for small unilateral renal cell carcinoma: long-term survival data of 216 patients. Eur Urol 49 (2006) 308-313
57. Link R.E., Bhayani S.B., Allaf M.E., et al. Exploring the learning curve, pathological outcomes and perioperative morbidity of laparoscopic partial nephrectomy performed for renal mass. J Urol 173 (2005) 1690-1694
58. Derweesh I.H., and Novick A.C. Mechanisms of renal ischaemic injury and their clinical impact. BJU Int 95 (2005) 948-950
59. Ludens J.H., Hook J.B., Brody M.J., and Williamson H.E. Enhancement of renal blood flow by furosemide. J Pharmacol Exp Ther 163 (1968) 456-460
60. Harvey R.B. Vascular resistance changes produced by hyperosmotic solutions. Am J Physiol 199 (1960) 31-34
61. Novick A.C. Renal hypothermia: in vivo and ex vivo. Urol Clin North Am 10 (1983) 637-644
62. Thompson R.H., Frank I., Lohse C.M., et al. The impact of ischemia time during open nephron sparing surgery on solitary kidneys: a multi-institutional study. J Urol 177 (2007) 471-476
63. Gill I.S., Matin S.F., Desai M.M., et al. Comparative analysis of laparoscopic versus open partial nephrectomy for renal tumors in 200 patients. J Urol 170 (2003) 64-68
64. Bhayani S.B., Rha K.H., Pinto P.A., et al. Laparoscopic partial nephrectomy: effect of warm ischemia on serum creatinine. J Urol 172 (2004) 1264-1266
65. Porpiglia F., Renard J., Billia M., et al. Is renal warm ischemia over 30 minutes during laparoscopic partial nephrectomy possible? One-year results of a prospective study. Eur Urol 52 (2007) 1170-1178
66. Shekarriz B., Upadhyay J., Shekarriz H., et al. Comparison of costs and complications of radical and partial nephrectomy for treatment of localized renal cell carcinoma. Urology 59 (2002) 211-215
67. Lerner S.E., Hawkins C.A., Blute M.L., et al. Disease outcome in patients with low stage renal cell carcinoma treated with nephron sparing or radical surgery. J Urol 155 (1996) 1868-1873
68. Belldegrun A., Tsui K.H., deKernion J.B., and Smith R.B. Efficacy of nephron-sparing surgery for renal cell carcinoma: analysis based on the new 1997 tumor-node-metastasis staging system. J Clin Oncol 17 (1999) 2868-2875
69. Campbell S.C., Novick A.C., Streem S.B., Klein E., and Licht M. Complications of nephron sparing surgery for renal tumors. J Urol 151 (1994) 1177-1180
70. Steinbach F., Stockle M., Muller S.C., et al. Conservative surgery of renal cell tumors in 140 patients: 21 years of experience. J Urol 148 (1992) 24-29 discussion 29-30
71. Moll V., Becht E., and Ziegler M. Kidney preserving surgery in renal cell tumors: indications, techniques and results in 152 patients. J Urol 150 (1993) 319-323
72. Schiff J.D., Palese M., Vaughan Jr. E.D., Sosa R.E., Coll D., and Del Pizzo J.J. Laparoscopic vs open partial nephrectomy in consecutive patients: the Cornell experience. BJU Int 96 (2005) 811-814
73. Abukora F., Nambirajan T., Albqami N., et al. Laparoscopic nephron sparing surgery: evolution in a decade. Eur Urol 47 (2005) 488-493 (discussion 493)
74. Porpiglia F., Volpe A., Billia M., Renard J., and Scarpa R.M. Assessment of risk factors for complications of laparoscopic partial nephrectomy. Eur Urol 53 (2008) 590-598
75. Lotan Y., and Cadeddu J.A. A cost comparison of nephron-sparing surgical techniques for renal tumour. BJU Int 95 (2005) 1039-1042
76. Becker F., Siemer S., Hack M., Humke U., Ziegler M., and Stöckle M. Excellent long-term cancer control with elective nephron-sparing surgery for selected renal cell carcinomas measuring more than 4 cm. Eur Urol 49 (2006) 1058-1064 (discussion 1063-4)
77. Leibovich B.C., Blute M.L., Cheville J.C., Lohse C.M., Weaver A.L., and Zincke H. Nephron sparing surgery for appropriately selected renal cell carcinoma between 4 and 7 cm results in outcome similar to radical nephrectomy. J Urol 171 (2004) 1066-1070
78. Patard J.J., Shvarts O., Lam J.S., et al. Safety and efficacy of partial nephrectomy for all T1 tumors based on an international multicenter experience. J Urol 171 (2004) 2181-2185 quiz 2435
79. Herr H.W. Partial nephrectomy for unilateral renal carcinoma and a normal contralateral kidney: 10-year followup. J Urol 161 (1999) 33-34 discussion 34-5
80. Pahernik S., Roos F., Hampel C., Gillitzer R., Melchior S.W., and Thuroff J.W. Nephron sparing surgery for renal cell carcinoma with normal contralateral kidney: 25 years of experience. J Urol 175 (2006) 2027-2031
81. Hafez K.S., Fergany A.F., and Novick A.C. Nephron sparing surgery for localized renal cell carcinoma: impact of tumor size on patient survival, tumor recurrence and TNM staging. J Urol 162 (1999) 1930-1933
82. Kwon E.D., Carver B.S., Snyder M.E., and Russo P. Impact of positive surgical margins in patients undergoing partial nephrectomy for renal cortical tumors. J Urol 175 (2006) 362 (abstract no. 1125)
83. Lane B.R., and Gill I.S. 5-year outcomes of laparoscopic partial nephrectomy. J Urol 177 (2007) 70-74 discussion 74
84. Permpongkosol S., Bagga H.S., Romero F.R., Sroka M., Jarrett T.W., and Kavoussi L.R. Laparoscopic versus open partial nephrectomy for the treatment of pathological T1N0M0 renal cell carcinoma: a 5-year survival rate. J Urol 176 (2006) 1984-1988 discussion 1988-9
85. Permpongkosol S., Colombo Jr. J.R., Gill I.S., and Kavoussi L.R. Positive surgical parenchymal margin after laparoscopic partial nephrectomy for renal cell carcinoma: oncological outcomes. J Urol 176 (2006) 2401-2404