Metamodeling tumor-immune system interaction, tumor evasion and immunotherapy

Mathematical and Computer Modelling

Volumn 47, Issue 5-6, 2008, Pages 614-637

  d'Onofrio, Alberto ^a  

^a EUROPEAN INSTITUTE OF ONCOLOGY   (Italy)

Author keywords

Immunotherapy; Qualitative theory of differential equations; Tumor immune system

Indexed keywords

DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS; DISEASES; FEATURE EXTRACTION; IMMUNOLOGY; MATHEMATICAL MODELS; NONLINEAR SYSTEMS;

IMMUNE SYSTEMS; IMMUNOTHERAPY; META MODELS; QUALITATIVE THEORY; QUALITATIVE THEORY OF DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS; TUMOR IMMUNE SYSTEMS;

TUMORS;

EID: 38849187163     PISSN: 08957177     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.mcm.2007.02.032     Document Type: Article

References (77)

1. Pekham M., Pinedo H.M., and Veronesi U. Oxford Textbook of Oncology (1995), Oxford Medical Publications, Oxford
2. de Vito Jr. V.T., Hellman J., and Rosenberg S.A. Cancer: Principles and Practice of Oncology (2005), J.P. Lippincott
3. d'Onofrio A., and Gandolfi A. Tumour eradication by antiangiogenic therapy: Analysis and extensions of the model by Hahnfeldt et al. (1999). Mathematical Biosciences 191 (2004) 159-184
4. Boyle P., Autier P., Bartelink H., Baselga J., Boffetta P., Burn J., Burns H.J.G., Christensen L., Denis L., Dicato M., Diehl V., Doll R., Franceschi S., Gillis C.R., Gray N., Griciute L., Hackshaw A., Kasler M., Kogevinas M., Kvinnsland S., La Vecchia C., Levi F., McVie J.G., Maisonneuve P., Martin-Moreno J.M., Newton Bishop J., Oleari F., Perrin P., Quinn M., Richards M., Ringborg U., Scully C., Siracka E., Storm H., Tubiana M., Tursz T., Veronesi U., Wald N., Weber W., Zaridze D.G., Zatonski W., and zur Hausen H. European code against cancer and scientific justification: Third version (2003). Annals of Oncology 14 (2003) 973-1005
5. Boyle P., d'Onofrio A., Maisonneuve P., Severi G., Robertson C., Tubiana M., and Veronesi U. Measuring progress against cancer in Europe: Has the 15% decline targeted for 2000 come about?. Annals of Oncology 14 (2003) 1312-1325
6. Quinn M.J., d'Onofrio A., Moeller B., Black R., Martinez-Garcia C., Moeller H., Rahu M., Robertson C., Schouten L.J., La Vecchia C., and Boyle P. Cancer mortality trends in the EU and acceding countries up to 2015. Annals of Oncology 14 (2003) 1148-1152
7. Bellomo N., and Maini P.K. Introduction to "special issue on cancer modelling". Mathematical Models & Methods in Applied Sciences 15 (2005) iii
8. Dunn G.P., Old L.J., and Schreiber R.D. The three ES of cancer immunoediting. Annual Review of Immunology 22 (2004) 322-360
9. Melief C.J.M. Cancer immunology: Cat and mouse games. Nature 437 (2005) 41-42
10. Gatenby R.A., Vincent T.L., and Gillies R.J. Evolutionary dynamics in carcinogenesys. Mathematical Models & Methods in Applied Sciences 15 (2005) 1619-1639
11. Vincent T.L., and Brown J.S. Evolutionary Game Theory, Natural Selection and Darwinian Dynamics (2005), Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
12. Pardoll D. Does the immune system see tumors as foreign or self?. Annual Review of Immunology 21 (2003) 807-839
13. Burnet F.M. Cancer-a biological approach. British Medical Journal 1 (1957) 841-847
14. Ehrlich P. Ueber den jetzigen Stand der Karzinomforschung. Nederlands Tijdschrift Geneeskunde 5 (1909) 273-290
15. d'Onofrio A. Tumor evasion form immune control: Strategies of a MISS to become a MASS. Chaos, Solitons and Fractals 31 (2007) 261-268
16. Whiteside T.L. Tumor-induced death of immune cells: Its mechanisms and consequences. Seminars in Cancer Biology 12 (2002) 43-50
17. Vicari A.P., Caux G., and Trinchieri G. Tumour escape from immune surveillance through dendritic cell inactivation. Seminars in Cancer Biology 12 (2002) 33-42
18. Abrams D. The evolution of predator-prey systems: Theory and evidence. Annual Review Ecology and Systematics 31 (2000) 79105
19. Cheon T. Evolutionary stability of ecological hierarchy. Physical Review Letters 90 (2003) Art.n. 258105
20. Kondoh M. Foraging adaptation and the relationship between food-web complexity and stability. Science 299 (2003) 1388-1391
21. Cheon T. Suppression of ecological competition by apex predator. Physical Review E 70 (2004) Art.n. 021913
22. Lacitignola D., and Tebaldi D. Effects of ecological differentiation on Lotka-Volterra systems for species with behavioral adaptation and variable growth rates. Mathematical Biosciences 194 (2005) 95-123
23. In: Agarwala S.A. (Ed). New Applications of Cancer Immunotherapy. Seminars in Oncology 29-3 Suppl. 7 (2003) (special issue)
24. Bleumer I., Oosterwijk E., de Mulder P., and Mulders P.F. Immunotherapy for renal cell carcinoma. European Urology 44 (2003) 65-75
25. Kaminski J.M., Summers J.B., Ward M.B., Huber M.R., and Minev B. Immunotherapy and prostate cancer. Cancer Treatment Review 29 (2004) 199-209
26. d'Onofrio A. A general framework for modeling tumor-immune system competition and immunotherapy: Mathematical analysis and biomedical inferences. Physica D 208 (2005) 220-235
27. Kirschner D., and Panetta J.C. Modeling immunotherapy of the tumor-immune interaction. Journal of Mathematical Biology 37 (1998) 235-252
28. Stepanova N.V. Course of the immune reaction during the development of a malignant tumor. Biophysics 24 (1980) 917-923
29. Kuznetsov V.A., Makalkin I.A., Taylor M.A., and Perelson A.S. Nonlinear dynamics of immunogenic tumors: Parameter estimation and global bifurcation analysis. Bulletin of Mathematical Biology 56 (1994) 295-321
30. Kuznetsov V.A., and Knott G.D. Modeling tumor regrowth and immunotherapy. Mathematical and Computer Modelling 33 (2001) 1275-1287
31. Galach M. Dynamics of the tumor-immune system competition: The effect of time delay. International Journal of Applied Mathematics and Computer Science 13 (2003) 395-406
32. Szymanska S. Analysis of the immunotherapy models in the context of cancer dynamics. International Journal of Applied Mathematics and Computer Science 13 (2003) 407-418
33. de Vladar H.P., and Gonzalez J.A. Dynamic response of cancer under the influence of immunological activity and therapy. Journal of Theoretical Biology 227 (2004) 335-348
34. de Pillis L.G., Radunskaya A.E., and Wiseman C.L. A validated mathematical model of cell-mediated immune response to tumor growth. Cancer Research 65 (2005) 7950-7958
35. d'Onofrio A. Tumor-immune system interaction: Modeling the tumor-stimulated proliferation of effectors and immunotherapy. Mathematical Models and Methods in Applied Sciences 16 (2006) 1375-1401
36. Bellomo N., and Preziosi L. Modelling and mathematical problems related to tumor evolution and its interaction with the immune system. Mathematical and Computer Modelling 32 (2000) 413-452
37. Bellomo N., Bellouquid A., and Delitala M. Mathematical topics on the modelling complex multicellular systems and tumor immune cells competition. Mathematical Models & Methods in Applied Sciences 14 (2004) 1683-1733
38. Bellouquid A., and Delitala M. Mathematical methods and tools of kinetic theory towards modelling complex biological systems. Mathematical Models & Methods in Applied Sciences 15 (2005) 1639-1667
39. Wheldon T.E. Mathematical Models in Cancer Research (1988), Hilger Publishing, Boston, Philadelphia
40. Marusic M., Bajzer Z., Freyer J.P., and Vuk-Pavlovic S. Analysis of growth of multicellular tumour spheroids by mathematical models. Cell Proliferation 27 (1994) 73-94
41. Hart D., Shochat E., and Agur Z. The growth law of primary breast cancer as inferred from mammography screening trials data. British Journal of Cancer 78 (1998) 382-387
42. Vaydia V.G., and Alexandro Jr. F.J. Evaluation of some mathematical models for tumor growth. International Journal of Biomedical Computation 13 (1982) 19-36
43. Guiot C., Degiorgis P.G., Delsanto P.P., Gabriele P., and Deisboecke T.S. Does tumor growth follow a universal law?. Journal of Theoretical Biology 225 (2003) 147-151
44. Bru A., Albertos S., Subiza J.L., Garcia-Asenjo J.L., and Bru I. The universal dynamics of tumor growth. Biophysical Journal 85 (2003) 2948-2961
45. Schmielau J., and Finn O.J. Activated granulocytes and granulocyte-derived hydrogen peroxide are the underlying mechanism of suppression of T-cell function in advanced cancer patients. Cancer Research 61 (2001) 4756-4760
46. Nani F., and Freedman H.I. A mathematical model of cancer treatment by immunotherapy. Mathematical Biosciences 163 (2000) 159-199
47. In: Bonadonna G., and Robustelli della Cuna G. (Eds). Medicina Oncologica (1994), Masson, Milano 259-272 (in Italian)
48. Kane Laird A. Dynamics of tumor growth. British Journal of Cancer 18 (1964) 490-502
49. Kane Laird A. Dynamics of tumor growth: Comparison of growth rates and extrapolation of growth curve to one cell. British Journal of Cancer 19 (1965) 278-290
50. Olea N., Villalobos M., Nunez M.I., Elvira J., and Ruiz de Almodovar J.M. Evaluation of the growth rate of MCF-7 breast cancer multicellular spheroids using three mathematical models. Cell Proliferation 27 (1994) 213-227
51. Bassukas I.D. Gompertzian re-evaluation of the growth patterns of transplantable mammary tumours in sialoadenectomized mice. Cell Proliferation 27 (1994) 201-211
52. Parfitt A.M. Gompertzian growth curves in parathyroid tumours: Further evidence for the set-point hypothesis. Cell Proliferation 30 (1994) 341-649
53. Rygaard K., and Spang-Thomsen M. Quantitation and Gompertzian analysis of tumor growth. Breast Cancer Research and Treatment 46 (1997) 303-312
54. Ballangrud A.M., Yang W.H., Dnistrian A., et al. Growth and characterization of LNCaP prostate cancer cell spheroids. Clinical Cancer Research 5 Suppl. 10 (1999) 3171S-3176S
55. Cameron D.A. The relative importance of proliferation and cell death in breast cancer growth and response to tamoxifen. European Journal of Cancer 37 (2001) 1545-1553
56. Castro M.A.A., Klamt F., Grieneisen V.A., Grivicich I., and Moreira J.C.F. Gompertzian growth pattern correlated with phenotypic organization of colon carcinoma, malignant glioma and non-small cell lung carcinoma cell lines. Cell Proliferation 36 (2003) 65-73
57. Gyllenberg M., and Webb G. Quiescence as an explanation of Gompertzian tumor growth. Growth, Development and Aging 53 (1989) 25-33
58. Calderon C., and Kwembe T. Modeling tumor growth. Mathematical Biosciences 103 (1991) 97-114
59. Afenya E.K., and Calderon C.P. Diverse ideas on the growth kinetics of disseminated cancer cells. Bulletin of Mathematical Biology 62 (2000) 527-542
60. Afenya E.K., and Calderon C.P. Growth kinetics of cancer cells prior to detection and treatment: An alternative view. Discrete and Continuous Dynamical Systems-B 5 (2004) 25-28
61. Molski M., and Konarski J. Coherent states of Gompertzian growth. Physical Review E 68 (2003) Art. no. 021916
62. P. Castorina, D. Zappala, Tumor Gompertzian growth by cellular energetic balance. arXiv:q-bio.CB/0407018 v2, 21 Dec 2004
63. P. Castorina, D. Zappala, Energetic model of tumor growth. arXiv:q-bio.TO/0412040 v1, 22 Dec 2004
64. Steel G.G. Growth Kinetics of Tumours (1977), Clarendon Press, Oxford
65. Piantadosi S. A model of growth with first-order birth and death rates. Computers and Biomedical Research 18 (1985) 220-232
66. Demicheli R., Foroni R., Ingrosso A., Pratesi G., Soranzo C., and Tortoreto M. An exponential-Gompertzian description of lovo cell tumor growth from in vivo and in vitro data. Cancer Research 49 (1989) 6543-6546
67. Collings J.B. The effects of functional response on the bifurcation behavior of a mite predator-prey interaction model. Journal of Mathematical Biology 36 (1997) 149-168
68. Ruan S., and Xiao D. Global analysis in a predator-prey system with nonmonotonic functional response. SIAM Journal of Applied Analysis 61 (2001) 1445-1472
69. Murray J.D. Mathematical Biology. 3rd ed. vol. I (2003), Springer Verlag, Heidelberg
70. Kennedy B.J. Cyclic leukocyte oscillations in chronic myelogenous leukemia during hydroxyurea therapy. Blood 35 (1970) 751-760
71. Vodopick H., Rupp E.M., Edwards C.L., Goswitz F.A., and Beauchamp J.J. Spontaneous cyclic leukocytosis and thrombocytosis in chronic granulocytic leukemia. New England Journal of Medicine 286 (1972) 284-290
72. Tsao H., Cosimi A.B., and Sober A.J. Ultra-late recurrence (15 years or longer) of cutaneous melanoma. Cancer 79 (1997) 2361-2370
73. Zhivkov P., and Waniewski J. Modelling tumor-immunity interaction with different stimulation functions. International Journal of Applied Mathematics and Computer Science 13 (2003) 307-315
74. Forys U., Waniewski J., and Zhivkov P. Anti-tumor immunity and tumor anti-immunity in a mathematical model of tumor immunotherapy. Journal of Biological Systems 14 (2006) 13-30
75. Bell I. Predators-preys equation simulating immune response. Mathematical Biosciences 16 (1973) 291-314
76. Ortega H. Un Modelo Logistico para Crecimiento Tumoral en Presencia de Celulas Asesinas. Revista Mexicana de Ingenieria Biomedica 20 (1999) 61-67 (in Spanish)
77. Al-Dwery F.M.O., Guirado D., Lallena A.M., and Pedraza V. Effect of tumour control of time interval between surgery and postoperative radiotherapy: An empirical approach using Monte Carlo simulation. Physics in Medicine and Biology 49 (2004) 2827-2839