SCOPUS 정보 검색 플랫폼

Studies in History and Philosophy of Science

Volumn 23, Issue 1, 1992, Pages 147-180

The birth of Bohr's complementarity: The context and the dialogues

(1) Beller, Mara a

a HEBREW UNIVERSITY OF JERUSALEM (Israel)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 38249012057 PISSN: 00393681 EISSN: None Source Type: Journal
DOI: 10.1016/0039-3681(92)90029-6 Document Type: Article

Times cited : (31)

References (133)

1
- 84918235322
- The Recent Developments in Atomic Theory and the Quantum Postulate
- Zanichelli, Bologna, reprinted in, Bohr's Collected Works vol. 6 1972–1987 North Holland Publishing Company Amsterdam, hereafter cited as BCW6
- (1928) Atti del Congresso Internazionale dei Fisici, Como, Settembre 1927
- Bohr¹

2
- 6144290104
- The Como lecture is different from the version printed in
- (1928) Nature , vol.121 , pp. 580-590

3
- 1542717744
- Foundations of Quantum Theory and Complementarity
- (1961) Nature , vol.190 , pp. 384
- Rosenfeld¹

4
- 0003714797
- Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
- (1967) New Foundation of Quantum Mechanics
- Lande¹

5
- 84918235321
- interview with A. Lande, Archive for the History of Quantum Physics, American Philosophical Society, hereafter AHQP. London's words are quoted in Lande, New Foundation

6
- 0003813308
- John Wiley, New York
- (1974) The Philosophy of Quantum Mechanics
- Jammer¹

7
- 0003609071
- North Holland, Amsterdam
- (1985) The Philosophy of Niels Bohr , pp. 108
- Folse¹

8
- 3142773500
- Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
- (1987) Particles and Paradoxes , pp. 53
- Gibbins¹

9
- 84918235320
- The English tradition of models is described in many historical studies. See for example

10
- 0003195358
- Lectures on the History of Atomic Physics
- C. Weiner, New York
- (1977) History of Twentieth Century Physics
- Heilbron¹

11
- 84918235319
- Heisenberg's efforts are presented in M. Beller, ‘The Genesis of Bohr's Complementarity Principle and the Bohr-Heisenberg Dialogue’, to appear in Boston Studies in Philosophy of Science, The Israel Colloquium, vol. 4

12
- 0003911471
- This viewpoint is argued, for example, in, McGraw Hill, New York
- (1966) The Conceptual Development of Quantum Mechanics
- Jammer¹

13
- 0010986150
- and in, University of Chicago Press, Chicago
- (1982) Scientific Explanation and Atomic Physics
- McKinnon¹

14
- 84918235318
- M. Beller, ‘Realism in Quantum Mechanics: A Historical Perspective’, to appear in Z. Bechler (ed.), 300 Years of the Principia: Realism Then and Now

15
- 84918235317
- This is the opinion of the editors of Bohr's Collected Works, BCW6, p. 30

16
- 84918235316
- BCW6, p. 78

17
- 84918235315
- BCW6, p. 78

18
- 84918235314
- BCW6, p. 70

19
- 84918235313
- BCW6, p. 77

20
- 84918235312
- BCW6, p. 77. This approach is in conflict with the particulate ontology of Heisenberg, Pauli and Born

21
- 84918235311
- BCW6, p. 69

22
- 0001170280
- Matrix Theory Before Schrödinger Philosophy Problems Consequences
- (1983) Isis , vol.74 , pp. 469-491
- Beller¹

23
- 84918235310
- M. Beller, ‘Realism in Quantum Mechanics: A Historical Perspective’, to appear in Z. Bechler (ed.), 300 Years of the Principia: Realism Then and Now. See also below

24
- 0002945812
- I.On the constitution of atoms and molecules
- 6th series
- (1913) Philosophical Magazine Series 6 , vol.26 , pp. 1
- Bohr¹

25
- 84918235309
- VII.On the use of the Interferometer for the study of band spectra
- 6th series
- (1913) Philosophical Magazine Series 6 , vol.26 , pp. 176
- Bohr¹

26
- 0013148358
- LXXIII.On the constitution of atoms and molecules
- 6th series
- (1913) Philosophical Magazine Series 6 , vol.26 , pp. 857
- Bohr¹

27
- 84915531072
- On the Quantum Theory of Line-Spectra
- reprinted in, Sources of Quantum Mechanics 1918 Dover Publications New York 95 137, Other physicists, among them P. Bridgman, looked for mechanisms of transition.
- (1918) Mémoires de l'Académie Royale des Sciences et des Lettres de Danemark , vol.4
- Bohr¹ Van Der Waerden²

28
- 84918235308
- M. Beller, ‘Realism in Quantum Mechanics: A Historical Perspective’, to appear in Z. Bechler (ed.), 300 Years of the Principia: Realism Then and Now. See also below

29
- 0000221927
- The Genesis of the Bohr Atom
- (1969) Historical Studies in the Physical Sciences , vol.1 , pp. 211-290
- Heilbron¹ Kuhn²

30
- 0003911471
- This viewpoint is argued, for example, in, McGraw Hill, New York, and other related studies
- (1966) The Conceptual Development of Quantum Mechanics
- Jammer¹

31
- 0000029355
- The Quantum Theory of Radiation
- 6th series
- (1924) Philosophical Magazine Series 6 , vol.47 , pp. 785
- Bohr¹ Kramers² Slater³

32
- 19444387031
- Über die Wirkung von Atomen bei Stossen
- (1925) Zeitschrift für Physik , vol.34 , pp. 142-157
- Bohr¹

33
- 19444387031
- Über die Wirkung von Atomen bei Stossen
- Postscript
- (1925) Zeitschrift für Physik , vol.34 , pp. 142-157
- Bohr¹

34
- 0001170280
- Matrix Theory Before Schrödinger Philosophy Problems Consequences
- For the original philosophy of matrix mechanics, see
- (1983) Isis , vol.74 , pp. 469-491
- Beller¹

35
- 84918235307
- That Schrödinger perceived matrix mechanics in this way follows from Bohr's letter to Fowler, 26 October 1926, AHQP, reprinted in BCW6, pp. 14–15

36
- 0003813308
- For Schrödinger's attempts, see, John Wiley, New York
- (1974) The Philosophy of Quantum Mechanics
- Jammer¹

37
- 0001170280
- Matrix Theory Before Schrödinger Philosophy Problems Consequences
- (1983) Isis , vol.74 , pp. 469-491
- Beller¹

38
- 84918235306
- M. Beller, ‘Realism in Quantum Mechanics: A Historical Perspective’, to appear in Z. Bechler (ed.), 300 Years of the Principia: Realism Then and Now

39
- 33744693977
- Development of Concepts in Quantum Theory
- J. Mehra, Reidel, Dordrecht/Boston
- (1973) The Physicists' Conception of Nature , pp. 264-275
- Heisenberg¹

40
- 0010328463
- Quantum Theory and its Interpretation
- S. Rozental, Interscience Publishers, New York
- (1907) Niels Bohr , pp. 94-108
- Heisenberg¹

41
- 0010328463
- Quantum Theory and its Interpretation
- S. Rozental, Interscience Publishers, New York
- (1907) Niels Bohr , pp. 101
- Heisenberg¹

42
- 84918235304
- M. Beller, ‘Realism in Quantum Mechanics: A Historical Perspective’, to appear in Z. Bechler (ed.), 300 Years of the Principia: Realism Then and Now

43
- 84918235303
- That Schrödinger perceived matrix mechanics in this way follows from Bohr's letter to Fowler, 26 October 1926, AHQP, reprinted in BCW6, pp. 14–15

44
- 84918235302
- M. Beller, ‘Realism in Quantum Mechanics: A Historical Perspective’, to appear in Z. Bechler (ed.), 300 Years of the Principia: Realism Then and Now

45
- 84918235301
- Como lecture, p. 582. The pages cited hereafter follow the pagination of the Atti del Congresso (see note 1), reproduced in BCW6

46
- 0004114892
- See for example Schrödinger's letters to Lorentz in, Philosophical Library, New York
- (1967) Letters on Wave Mechanics
- Przibram¹

47
- 84918235300
- Como lecture, p. 582. The pages cited hereafter follow the pagination of the Atti del Congresso (see note 1), reproduced in BCW6

48
- 84918235299
- Como lecture, p. 582. The pages cited hereafter follow the pagination of the Atti del Congresso (see note 1), reproduced in BCW6

49
- 84918235298
- BCW6, p. 97

50
- 0001170280
- Matrix Theory Before Schrödinger Philosophy Problems Consequences
- (1983) Isis , vol.74 , pp. 469-491
- Beller¹

51
- 84918235297
- Como lecture, p. 587

52
- 84918235296
- BCW6, p. 97

53
- 84918235295
- Como lecture, p. 587

54
- 84918235294
- Como lecture, p. 582

55
- 0001170280
- Matrix Theory Before Schrödinger Philosophy Problems Consequences
- (1983) Isis , vol.74 , pp. 469-491
- Beller¹

56
- 84918235293
- Como lecture, p. 582

57
- 84918235292
- Como lecture, p. 583

58
- 84918235291
- Como lecture, p. 587

59
- 0004155955
- Allen and Unwin, London
- (1959) Physics and Philosophy , pp. 51
- Heisenberg¹

60
- 84918235290
- Como lecture, p. 578

61
- 0004114892
- Schrödinger to Einstein, 30 May 1928, Philosophical Library, New York
- (1967) Letters on Wave Mechanics
- Przibram¹

62
- 54749153680
- Are There Quantum Jumps?
- (1952) British Journal for the Philosophy of Science , vol.3 , pp. 109-123
- Schrödinger¹

63
- 0010620730
- Are There Quantum Jumps?
- (1953) British Journal for the Philosophy of Science , vol.3 , pp. 233-242
- Schrödinger¹

64
- 0003911471
- McGraw Hill, New York
- (1966) The Conceptual Development of Quantum Mechanics
- Jammer¹

65
- 4344697315
- Einstein and the Wave-Particle Duality
- (1964) Natural Philosopher , vol.3 , pp. 1-49
- Klein¹

66
- 0003429915
- Oxford University Press, Oxford
- (1978) Black-Body Theory and the Quantum Discontinuity, 1854–1912
- Kuhn¹

67
- 84968135987
- The First Phase of the Bohr-Einstein Dialogue
- (1970) Historical Studies in the Physical Sciences , vol.2 , pp. 1-39
- Klein¹

68
- 0003615615
- Science History Publications, New York
- (1974) The Compton Effect: Turning Point in Physics
- Stuewer¹

69
- 84968135987
- The First Phase of the Bohr-Einstein Dialogue
- (1970) Historical Studies in the Physical Sciences , vol.2 , pp. 1-39
- Klein¹

70
- 84918235289
- BCW6, p. 71

71
- 19444387031
- Über die Wirkung von Atomen bei Stossen
- The misinterpretation that Bohr accepted the light quanta is related, in my opinion, to the fact that many authors assume Bohr's expression about the ‘space-time picture’ to be applicable also to the wave propagation of light, and consequently conclude that the failure of space-time pictures applies also to classical wave theory. However, I am not aware of any expressions in Bohr's writings at the time supporting this point of view: wherever Bohr used the phrase ‘failure of space-time pictures’, it referred to models using point-like material particles.
- (1925) Zeitschrift für Physik , vol.34 , pp. 142-157
- Bohr¹

72
- 19444387031
- Über die Wirkung von Atomen bei Stossen
- (1925) Zeitschrift für Physik , vol.34 , pp. 142-157
- Bohr¹

73
- 84918235288
- Bohr to Fowler, 26 October 1926, AHQP

74
- 84918235287
- Bohr to Kronig, 26 October 1926, AHQP

75
- 84918235286
- Discussions following Como lecture, reprinted in BCW6, pp. 589–598

76
- 0003911471
- It is usually assumed for example, McGraw Hill, New York, that these discussions were hardly related to Bohr's message in the Como lecture. I argue for the opposite viewpoint
- (1966) The Conceptual Development of Quantum Mechanics
- Jammer¹

77
- 84918235285
- ‘Philosophical Foundations of the Quantum Theory’, BCW6, p. 70

78
- 84918235284
- Bohr to Einstein
- (1927) BCW , vol.6 , pp. 21

79
- 84918188361
- Compton's Nobel lecture, in, Elsevier, New York
- (1965) Nobel Lectures in Physics , vol.2

80
- 84918235283
- Reminiscences from the Post-War Years
- S. Rozental, Interscience Publishers, New York
- (1907) Niels Bohr , pp. 215-226
- Pais¹

81
- 0004062773
- See also, Oxford University Press, Oxford
- (1982) Subtle is the Lord … The Science and Life of Albert Einstein
- Pais¹

82
- 51149173778
- Philosophical Foundations of Quantum Theory
- (1927) Nature , vol.119 , pp. 779
- Campbell¹

83
- 51149169762
- Philosophical Foundations of Quantum Theory
- (1927) Nature , vol.119 , pp. 779
- Jordan¹

84
- 85046385223
- (1921) Nature , vol.107 , pp. 170
- Campbell¹

85
- 79956883131
- Time and Chance
- 7th series
- (1926) The London, Edinburgh, and Dublin Philosophical Magazine and Journal of Science , vol.1 , pp. 1106-1117
- Campbell¹

86
- 19444387031
- Über die Wirkung von Atomen bei Stossen
- (1925) Zeitschrift für Physik , vol.34 , pp. 142-157
- Bohr¹

87
- 19444387031
- Über die Wirkung von Atomen bei Stossen
- the translation is from BCW5
- (1925) Zeitschrift für Physik , vol.34 , pp. 142-157
- Bohr¹

88
- 3242885008
- Atomic Theory and Mechanics
- reprinted in BCW5
- (1926) Nature , vol.116 , pp. 851
- Bohr¹

89
- 79956883131
- Time and Chance
- 7th series
- (1926) The London, Edinburgh, and Dublin Philosophical Magazine and Journal of Science , vol.1 , pp. 1106-1117
- Campbell¹

90
- 0009448302
- Über den anschaulichen Inhalt der quanten-theoretischen Kinematik und Mechanik
- (1927) Zeitschrift für Physik , vol.43 , pp. 172
- Heisenberg¹

91
- 0009448302
- Über den anschaulichen Inhalt der quanten-theoretischen Kinematik und Mechanik
- (1927) Zeitschrift f�r Physik , vol.43 , pp. 198
- Heisenberg¹

92
- 84918235281
- Como lecture, p. 582. The pages cited hereafter follow the pagination of the Atti del Congresso (see note 1), reproduced in BCW6

93
- 79956883131
- Time and Chance
- 7th series
- (1926) The London, Edinburgh, and Dublin Philosophical Magazine and Journal of Science , vol.1 , pp. 1106-1117
- Campbell¹

94
- 84918235280
- M. Beller, ‘Realism in Quantum Mechanics: A Historical Perspective’, to appear in Z. Bechler (ed.), 300 Years of the Principia: Realism Then and Now

95
- 84918235279
- Como lecture, p. 578

96
- 84918235278
- Como lecture, p. 578

97
- 0009448302
- Über den anschaulichen Inhalt der quanten-theoretischen Kinematik und Mechanik
- Postscript
- (1927) Zeitschrift für Physik , vol.43 , pp. 172
- Heisenberg¹

98
- 0009448302
- Über den anschaulichen Inhalt der quanten-theoretischen Kinematik und Mechanik
- Postscript
- (1927) Zeitschrift f�r Physik , vol.43 , pp. 198
- Heisenberg¹

99
- 0009448302
- Über den anschaulichen Inhalt der quanten-theoretischen Kinematik und Mechanik
- Postscript
- (1927) Zeitschrift f�r Physik , vol.43 , pp. 198
- Heisenberg¹

100
- 0010950427
- Visualization Lost and Regained: The Genesis of the Quantum Theory in the Period 1913–1917
- J. Wechsler, Cambridge, Mass.
- (1978) On Aesthetics in Science
- Miller¹

101
- 0010950427
- Visualization Lost and Regained: The Genesis of the Quantum Theory in the Period 1913–1917
- J. Wechsler, Cambridge, Mass.
- (1978) On Aesthetics in Science
- Miller¹

102
- 0003490991
- Heisenberg to Pauli, 4 April 1927, Springer-Verlag, New York
- (1979) Wolfgang Pauli, Wissenschaftlicher Briefwechsel
- Hermann¹ Meyenn² Weisskopf³

103
- 84918235277
- Como lecture, p. 582

104
- 84918235276
- translated in
- (1927) BCW , vol.6 , pp. 37-41

105
- 84918235275
- Como lecture, p. 587

106
- 20844457712
- Quantentheoretische Umdeutung kinematischer und mechanischer Beziehungen
- (1925) Zeitschrift für Physik , vol.33 , pp. 879-893
- Heisenberg¹

107
- 19444387031
- Über die Wirkung von Atomen bei Stossen
- Cf.
- (1925) Zeitschrift für Physik , vol.34 , pp. 142-157
- Bohr¹

108
- 0001170280
- Matrix Theory Before Schrödinger Philosophy Problems Consequences
- (1983) Isis , vol.74 , pp. 469-491
- Beller¹

109
- 84918235274
- Bohr to Geiger, 21 April 1925, AHQP, reprinted in BCW5, p. 353

110
- 84918235273
- Como lecture, p. 571

111
- 0003609071
- North Holland, Amsterdam
- (1985) The Philosophy of Niels Bohr , pp. 47
- Folse¹

112
- 3142773500
- Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
- (1987) Particles and Paradoxes , pp. 53
- Gibbins¹

113
- 84918235272
- Bohr to Schrödinger, AHQP, translated in
- (1928) BCW , vol.6 , pp. 48-50

114
- 84918235272
- Bohr to Schrödinger, AHQP, translated in
- (1928) BCW , vol.6 , pp. 48-50

115
- 0003490991
- Pauli to Bohr, 17 October 1927, Springer-Verlag, New York, translated in BCW6
- (1979) Wolfgang Pauli, Wissenschaftlicher Briefwechsel
- Hermann¹ Meyenn² Weisskopf³

116
- 0003490991
- Pauli to Bohr, 13 January 1928, Springer-Verlag, New York, reprinted in BCW6, p. 435
- (1979) Wolfgang Pauli, Wissenschaftlicher Briefwechsel
- Hermann¹ Meyenn² Weisskopf³

117
- 0002301173
- Die allgemeinen Prinzipien der Wellenmechanik
- Band 24, 1. Teil (Berlin)
- (1933) Handbuch der Physik
- Pauli¹

118
- 0003490991
- Pauli to Bohr, 17 October 1927, Springer-Verlag, New York
- (1979) Wolfgang Pauli, Wissenschaftlicher Briefwechsel
- Hermann¹ Meyenn² Weisskopf³

119
- 6144290104
- The Quantum Postulate and the Recent Development of Atomic Theory
- suppl.
- (1928) Nature , vol.121 , pp. 580
- Bohr¹

120
- 6144290104
- The Quantum Postulate and the Recent Development of Atomic Theory
- suppl.
- (1928) Nature , vol.121 , pp. 590
- Bohr¹

121
- 6144290104
- The Quantum Postulate and the Recent Development of Atomic Theory
- suppl.
- (1928) Nature , vol.121 , pp. 590
- Bohr¹

122
- 84918235271
- and BCW6, Como lecture

123
- 84918235270
- ‘If one immediately starts with the supposition “there are both waves and particles”, everything can be made contradictory free’ wrote Heisenberg disapprovingly to Pauli (May 1927)

124
- 0003490991
- Springer-Verlag, New York, two months after the uncertainty paper
- (1979) Wolfgang Pauli, Wissenschaftlicher Briefwechsel
- Hermann¹ Meyenn² Weisskopf³

125
- 0004202755
- New York
- (1971) Physics and Beyond: Encounters and Conversations , pp. 79
- Heisenberg¹

126
- 0004114892
- Einstein to Schrödinger, 31 May 1928, Philosophical Library, New York
- (1967) Letters on Wave Mechanics
- Przibram¹

127
- 0004155955
- Allen and Unwin, London
- (1959) Physics and Philosophy , pp. 51
- Heisenberg¹

128
- 0004155955
- Allen and Unwin, London
- (1959) Physics and Philosophy , pp. 51
- Heisenberg¹

129
- 0003911471
- McGraw Hill, New York
- (1966) The Conceptual Development of Quantum Mechanics
- Jammer¹

130
- 0011942341
- The Roots of Complementarity
- reprinted in his, Thematic Origins of Scientific Thought 1973 Harvard University Press Cambridge, Mass
- (1970) Daedalus , vol.99 , pp. 1015-1055
- Holton¹

131
- 30244552164
- How Do Sums Count? On the Cultural Origins of Statistical Causality
- L. Krüger, L.J. Daston, M. Heidelberger, MIT Press, Cambridge, Mass
- (1987) The Probabilistic Revolution , vol.1
- Wise¹

132
- 30244552164
- How Do Sums Count? On the Cultural Origins of Statistical Causality
- L. Krüger, L.J. Daston, M. Heidelberger, MIT Press, Cambridge, Mass
- (1987) The Probabilistic Revolution , vol.1
- Wise¹

133
- 0038537719
- Dover Publications, New York
- (1955) A History of Modern Philosophy , vol.2
- Høffding¹

* 이 정보는 Elsevier사의 SCOPUS DB에서 KISTI가 분석하여 추출한 것입니다.