Cricoid Pressure in Emergency Department Rapid Sequence Tracheal Intubations: A Risk-Benefit Analysis

Annals of Emergency Medicine

Volumn 50, Issue 6, 2007, Pages 653-665

  Ellis, Daniel Y ^a   Harris, Tim ^b   Zideman, David ^c  

^a TOWNSVILLE HOSPITAL   (Australia)

^b ROYAL LONDON HOSPITAL   (United Kingdom)

^c HAMMERSMITH HOSPITAL   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

ARTIFICIAL VENTILATION; ASPIRATION PNEUMONIA; CRICOID; ENDOTRACHEAL INTUBATION; HUMAN; MEDICAL RECORD REVIEW; OUTCOMES RESEARCH; PRESSURE; PRIORITY JOURNAL; REVIEW; RISK BENEFIT ANALYSIS; TECHNIQUE;

ADULT; ANIMALS; CHILD; CRICOID CARTILAGE; EMERGENCY MEDICINE; EMERGENCY SERVICE, HOSPITAL; EVIDENCE-BASED MEDICINE; GASTROESOPHAGEAL REFLUX; HUMANS; INTUBATION, INTRATRACHEAL; LARYNGEAL MASKS; PRESSURE; RESPIRATORY ASPIRATION; RISK ASSESSMENT;

EID: 36049051073     PISSN: 01960644     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.annemergmed.2007.05.006     Document Type: Review

References (139)

1. Sellick B.A. Cricoid pressure to control regurgitation of stomach contents during induction of anaesthesia. Lancet 2 (1961) 404-406
2. Simpson J.Y. The alleged case of death from the action of chloroform. Lancet 1 (1848) 175-176
3. Mendelson C.L. The aspiration of stomach contents into the lungs during obstetric anaesthesia. Am J Obstet Gynecol 52 (1946) 191-205
4. Ministry of Health. Report on Confidential Enquiries into Maternal Deaths in England and Wales, Started: 1952-54 (continued on 3 yearly cycle) (1957), HMSO, London
5. Stept W.J., and Safar P. Rapid induction-intubation for prevention of gastric-content aspiration. Anesth Analg 49 (1970) 633-636
6. Thwaites A.J., Rice C.P., and Smith I. Rapid sequence induction: a questionnaire survey of its routine conduct and continued management during a failed intubation. Anaesthesia 54 (1999) 376-381
7. Pinnock C., Lin T., and Smith T. Fundamentals of Anaesthesia (1999), Greenwich Medical Media Ltd, London, England 58
8. Smith C.E. Rapid-sequence intubation in adults: indications and concerns. Clin Pulm Med 8 (2001) 147-165
9. Walls R.M., Luten R.C., Murphy M.F., et al. Emergency Airway Management (2000), Lippincott Williams & Wilkins, Philadelphia, PA
10. Li J., Murphy-Lavoie H., and Bugas C. Complications of emergency intubation with and without paralysis. Am J Emerg Med 17 (1999) 141-143
11. Sackles J., Laurin E., Rantapaa A., et al. Airway management in the emergency department: a one year study of 610 tracheal intubations. Ann Emerg Med 31 (1998) 398-400
12. Graham C., Beard D., Oglesby A., et al. Rapid sequence intubation in Scottish urban emergency departments. Emerg Med J 20 (2003) 3-5
13. Walls R.M. Airway. In: Marx J., Hockberger R., and Walls R. (Eds). Rosen's Emergency Medicine. 5th ed. (2002), Mosby, St Louis, MO
14. Ddanzy D.F. Advanced airway support. In: Tintinelli J., Kelen G., and Strpczynski J. (Eds). Emergency Medicine: A Comprehensive Study Guide. 4th ed. (1996), McGraw-Hill, New York, NY 41
15. Thwaites A.J., Rice C.P., and Smith I. Rapid sequence induction: a questionnaire survey of its routine conduct and continued management during a failed intubation. Anaesthesia 54 (1999) 376-381
16. Cook T.M., and McCrirrick A. A survey of airway management during induction of general anaesthesia in obstetrics: are the recommendations in the Confidential Enquiries into Maternal Deaths being implemented?. J Obstet Anaesth 3 (1994) 143-145
17. Morris J., and Cook T.M. Rapid sequence induction: a national survey of practice. Anaesthesia 56 (2001) 1090-1097
18. Engelhardt T., Strachan L., and Johnston G. Aspiration and regurgitation prophylaxis in paediatric anaesthesia. Paediatr Anaesth 11 (2001) 147-150
19. Edington R.D., King F.G., and LeDez K.M. Utilization of cricoid pressure in a teaching hospital. [abstract]. Can J Anesth 46 (1999) A11
20. Schlesinger S., and Blanchfield D. Modified rapid-sequence induction of anaesthesia: a survey of current clinical practice. AANA J 69 (2001) 291-298
21. Rosen M. Anesthesia for obstetrics. Anaesthesia 36 (1981) 145-146
22. Schwartz D.E., and Cohen N.H. Questionable effectiveness of cricoid pressure in preventing aspiration. [letter]. Anaesthesiology 83 (1995) 432
23. Brimacombe J., and Berry A. Cricoid pressure in chaos. Anaesthesia 52 (1997) 924-926
24. Brock-Utne J.G. Is cricoid pressure necessary?. Paediatr Anaesth 12 (2002) 1-4
25. Benhamou D. Cricoid pressure is unnecessary in obstetric general anaesthesia. Proposer. Int J Obstet Anesth 4 (1995) 30-31
26. Priebe H.J. Cricoid pressure: an alternative view. Semin Anaesth Perioperative Med Pain 24 (2005) 120-126
27. Kalinowski C.P., and Kirsch J.R. Strategies for prophylaxis and treatment for aspiration. Best Pract Res Clin Anaesthesiol 18 (2004) 719-737
28. Butler J., and Sen A. Cricoid pressure in emergency rapid sequence induction. Best bets, best evidence topics (2004). http://www.bestbets.org.uk Available at: http//www.bestbets.org.uk. Accessed June 13, 2006.
29. Knill R.L. Difficult laryngoscopy made easy with a "BURP.". Can J Anaesth 40 (1993) 279-282
30. Levitan R.M., Mickler T., and Hollander J.E. Bimanual laryngoscopy: a videographic study of external laryngeal manipulation by novice intubators. Ann Emerg Med 40 (2002) 30-37
31. Vanner R.G. Gastro-oesophageal reflux and regurgitation during general anaesthesia for termination of pregnancy. Int J Obstet Anaesth 1 (1992) 123-128
32. Lawes E.G., Duncan P.W., Bland B., et al. The cricoid yoke-a device for providing consistent and reproducible cricoid pressure. Br J Anaesth 58 (1986) 925-931
33. Warner M.A., Warner M.E., and Weber J.G. Clinical significance of pulmonary aspiration during the perioperative period. Anaesthesiology 78 (1993) 56-62
34. Ezri T., Szmuk P., Stein A., et al. Peripartum general anaesthesia without tracheal intubation: incidence of aspiration pneumonia. Anaesthesia 55 (2000) 421-426
35. Lockey D.J., Coats T., and Parr M.J. Aspiration in severe trauma: a prospective study. Anaesthesia 54 (1999) 1097-1098
36. Tiret L., Desmonts J.M., Hatton F., et al. Complications associated with anaesthesia-a prospective survey in France. Can Anaesth Soc J 33 3 pt 1 (1986) 336-344
37. Benhamou D. French obstetric anaesthetists and acid aspiration prophylaxis. Eur J Anaesthesiol 10 (1993) 27-32
38. Olsson G.L., Hallen B., and Hambraeus-Jonzon K. Aspiration during anaesthesia: a computer-aided study of 185,358 anaesthetics. Acta Anaesthesiol Scand 30 (1986) 84-92
39. Borland L.M., Sereika S.M., Woelfel S.K., et al. Pulmonary aspiration in pediatric patients during general anaesthesia: incidence and outcome. J Clin Anesth 10 (1998) 95-102
40. Warner M.A., Warner M.E., Warner D.O., et al. Perioperative pulmonary aspiration in infants and children. Anaesthesiology 90 (1999) 66-71
41. Warner M.A., Warner M.E., and Weber J.G. Clinical significance of pulmonary aspiration during the perioperative period. Anaesthesiology 78 (1993) 56-62
42. Schwartz D.E., Matthay M.A., and Cohen N.H. Death and other complications of emergency airway management in critically ill adults. Anesthesiology 82 (1995) 367-376
43. Oswalt J.L., Hedges J.R., Soifer B.E., et al. Analysis of trauma intubations. Am J Emerg Med 10 (1992) 511-514
44. Thibodeau L.G., Verdile V.P., and Bartfield J.M. Incidence of aspiration after urgent intubation. Am J Emerg Med 15 (1997) 562-565
45. Redan J.A., Livingston D.H., Tortella B.J., et al. The value of intubating and paralyzing patients with suspected head injury in the emergency department. J Trauma 31 (1991) 371-375
46. Rashkin M.C., and Davis T. Acute complications of endotracheal intubation: relationship to reintubation, route, urgency, and duration. Chest 89 (1986) 165-167
47. Taryle D.A., Chandler J.E., Good J.T., et al. Emergency room intubations: complications and survival. Chest 75 (1979) 541-543
48. Ufberg J.W., Bushra J.S., Karras D.J., et al. Aspiration of gastric contents: association with prehospital intubation. Am J Emerg Med 23 (2005) 379-382
49. Mort T.C. Emergency tracheal intubation: complications associated with repeated laryngoscopic attempts. Anesth Analg 99 (2004) 607-613
50. Sakles J.C., Laurin E.G., Rantapaa A.A., et al. Airway management in the emergency department: a one year study of 610 tracheal intubations. Ann Emerg Med 31 (1998) 325-332
51. Tayal V.S., Riggs R.W., Marx J.A., et al. Rapid-sequence intubation at an emergency medicine residency: success rate and adverse events during a two-year period. Acad Emerg Med 6 (1999) 31-37
52. Levitan R.M., Rosenblatt B., Meiner E.M., et al. Alternating day EM and anesthesia resident responsibility for management of the trauma airway: a study of laryngoscopy performance and intubation success. Ann Emerg Med 43 (2004) 48-53
53. Reid C., Chan L., and Tweeddale M. The who, where, and what of rapid sequence intubation: prospective observational study of emergency RSI outside the operating theatre. Emerg Med J 21 (2004) 296-301
54. Graham C.A., Beard D., Oglesby A.J., et al. Rapid sequence intubation in Scottish urban emergency departments. Emerg Med J 20 (2003) 3-5
55. Ng A., and Smith G. Gastroesophageal reflux and aspiration of gastric contents in anaesthetic practice. Anesth Analg 93 (2001) 494-513
56. Scott D.B. Mendelson's syndrome. Br J Anaesth 50 (1978) 977-978
57. Kluger M.T., and Short T.G. Aspiration during anaesthesia: a review of 133 cases from the Australian Anaesthetic Incident Monitoring Study (AIMS). Anaesthesia 54 (1999) 19-26
58. Sellick B.A. The prevention of regurgitation during induction of anaesthesia. First Eur Congress Anaesthesiol 89 (1962) 1-4
59. Fanning G.L. The efficacy of cricoid pressure in preventing regurgitation of gastric contents. Anaesthesiology 32 (1970) 553-555
60. Salem M.R., Wong A.Y., and Fizzotti G.F. Efficacy of cricoid pressure in preventing aspiration of gastric contents in paediatric patients. Br J Anaesth 44 (1972) 401-404
61. Salem M.R., Joseph N.J., Heyman H.J., et al. Cricoid compression is effective in obliterating the esophageal lumen in the presence of a nasogastric tube. Anaesthesiology 63 (1985) 443-446
62. Vanner R.G., and Pryle B.J. Regurgitation and oesophageal rupture with cricoid pressure: a cadaver study. Anaesthesia 47 (1992) 732-735
63. Wraight W.J., Chamney A.R., and Howells T.H. The determination of an effective cricoid pressure. Anaesthesia 38 (1983) 461-466
64. Neelakanta G. Cricoid pressure is effective in preventing esophageal regurgitation. Anaesthesiology 99 (2003) 242
65. Whittington R.M., Robinson J.S., and Thompson J.M. Fatal aspiration (Mendelson's) syndrome despite antacids and cricoid pressure. Lancet 2 (1979) 228-230
66. Williamson R. Cricoid pressure. Can J Anaesth 36 (1989) 601
67. Howells T.H., Chamney A.R., Wraight W.J., et al. The application of cricoid pressure. An assessment and a survey of its practice. Anaesthesia 38 (1983) 457-460
68. Kopka A., and Crawford J. Cricoid pressure: a simple, yet effective biofeedback trainer. Eur J Anaesthesiol 21 (2004) 443-447
69. Cheney F.W. Aspiration: a liability hazard for the anaesthesiologist?. ASA Newsl 64 (2000) 1-3
70. Morgan M. The Confidential Enquiry into Maternal Deaths. Anaesthesia 41 (1986) 689-691
71. Ministry of Health. Report on Confidential Enquiries into Maternal Deaths in England and Wales 1973-1975 (1979), HMSO, London, England
72. Ministry of Health. Report on Confidential Enquiries into Maternal Deaths in England and Wales 1985-1987 (1991), HMSO, London, England
73. Tournadre J.P., Chassard D., Berrada K.R., et al. Cricoid cartilage pressure decreases lower esophageal sphincter tone. Anaesthesiology 86 (1997) 7-9
74. Thorn K., Thorn S.E., and Wattwil M. The effects of cricoid pressure, remifentanil, and propofol on esophageal motility and the lower esophageal sphincter. Anesth Analg 100 (2005) 1200-1203
75. Skinner H.J., Bedforth N.M., Girling K.J., et al. Effect of cricoid pressure on gastro-oesophageal reflux in awake subjects. Anaesthesia 54 (1999) 798-800
76. Garrard A., Campbell A.E., Turley A., et al. The effect of mechanically-induced cricoid force on lower oesophageal sphincter pressure in anaesthetised patients. Anaesthesia 59 (2004) 435-439
77. Wenzel V., Idris A.H., Banner M.J., et al. The influence of tidal volume on the distribution of gas between the lungs and stomach in the non-intubated patient receiving positive pressure ventilation. Crit Care Med 26 (1998) 364-368
78. Salem M.R., Wong A.Y., Mani M., et al. Efficacy of cricoid pressure in preventing gastric inflation during bag-mask ventilation in pediatric patients. Anaesthesiology 40 (1974) 96-98
79. Lawes E.G., Campbell I., and Mercer D. Inflation pressure, gastric insufflation and rapid sequence induction. Br J Anaesth 59 (1987) 315-318
80. Petito S.P., and Russell W.J. The prevention of gastric inflation-a neglected benefit of cricoid pressure. Anaesth Intensive Care 16 (1988) 139-143
81. Moynihan R.J., Brock-Utne J.G., Archer J.H., et al. The effect of cricoid pressure on preventing gastric insufflation in infants and children. Anaesthesiology 78 (1993) 652-656
82. Wenzel V., Keller C., Idris A.H., et al. Effects of smaller tidal volumes during basic life support ventilation in patients with respiratory arrest: good ventilation, less risk?. Resuscitation 43 (1999) 25-29
83. Smith K.J., Ladak S., Choi P.T., et al. The cricoid cartilage and the esophagus are not aligned in close to half of adult patients. Can J Anaesth 49 (2002) 503-507
84. Smith K.J., Dobranowski J., Yip G., et al. Cricoid pressure displaces the esophagus: an observational study using magnetic resonance imaging. Anaesthesiology 99 (2003) 60-64
85. Vanner R.G., and Pryle B.J. Nasogastric tubes and cricoid pressure. Anaesthesia 48 (1993) 1112-1113
86. Werner S.L., Smith C.E., Goldstein J.R., et al. Pilot study to evaluate the accuracy of ultrasonography in confirming endotracheal tube placement. Ann Emerg Med 49 (2007) 75-80
87. Allman K.G. The effect of cricoid pressure application on airway patency. J Clin Anesth 7 (1995) 197-199
88. Hartsilver E.L., and Vanner R.G. Airway obstruction with cricoid pressure. Anaesthesia 55 (2000) 208-211
89. Hocking G., Roberts F.L., and Thew M.E. Airway obstruction with cricoid pressure and lateral tilt. Anaesthesia 56 (2001) 825-828
90. Saghaei M., and Masoodifar M. The pressor response and airway effects of cricoid pressure during induction of general anaesthesia. Anesth Analg 93 (2001) 787-790
91. Palmer J.H., and Yentis S.M. Cricoid pressure application to awake volunteers: discomfort cannot be used to indicate appropriate force. Can J Anaesth 52 (2005) 114-115
92. Georgescu A., Miller J.N., and Lecklitner M.L. The Sellick maneuver causing complete airway obstruction. Anesth Analg 74 (1992) 457-459
93. Ho A.M., Wong W., Ling E., et al. Airway difficulties caused by improperly applied cricoid pressure. J Emerg Med 20 (2001) 29-31
94. MacG Palmer J.H., and Ball D.R. The effect of cricoid pressure on the cricoid cartilage and vocal cords: an endoscopic study in anaesthetised patients. Anaesthesia 55 (2000) 263-268
95. Brimacombe J.R. Laryngeal Mask Anesthesia, Principles and Practice. 2nd ed. (2006), Saunders, Philadelphia, PA 309
96. Brimacombe J., White A., and Berry A. Effect of cricoid pressure on ease of insertion of the laryngeal mask airway. Br J Anaesth 71 (1993) 800-802
97. Brimacombe J. Cricoid pressure and the laryngeal mask airway. Anaesthesia 46 (1991) 986-987
98. Ansermino J.M., and Blogg C.E. Cricoid pressure may prevent insertion of the laryngeal mask airway. Br J Anaesth 69 (1992) 465-467
99. Asai T., Barclay K., Power I., et al. Cricoid pressure impedes placement of the laryngeal mask airway. Br J Anaesth 74 (1995) 521-525
100. Asai T., Barclay K., Power I., et al. Cricoid pressure impedes placement of the laryngeal mask airway and subsequent tracheal intubation through the mask. Br J Anaesth 72 (1994) 47-51
101. Aoyama K., Takenaka I., Sata T., et al. Cricoid pressure impedes positioning and ventilation through the laryngeal mask airway. Can J Anaesth 43 (1996) 1035-1040
102. Asai T., Barclay K., McBeth C., et al. Cricoid pressure applied after placement of the laryngeal mask prevents gastric insufflation but inhibits ventilation. Br J Anaesth 76 (1996) 772-776
103. Difficult Airway Society. Failed intubation and failed ventilation. Available at: http://www.das.uk.com/guidelines/cvci.html. Accessed April 30, 2007.
104. Turgeon A.F., Nicole P.C., Trepanier C.A., et al. Cricoid pressure does not increase the rate of failed intubation by direct laryngoscopy in adults. Anaesthesiology 102 (2005) 315-319
105. Vanner R.G., Clarke P., Moore W.J., et al. The effect of cricoid pressure and neck support on the view at laryngoscopy. Anaesthesia 52 (1997) 896-900
106. McCaul C.L., Harney D., Ryan M., et al. Airway management in the lateral position: a randomized controlled trial. Anesth Analg 101 (2005) 1221-1225
107. Levitan R.M., Kinkle W.C., Levin J.L., et al. Laryngeal view during laryngoscopy, comparing cricoid pressure, backward-upward-rightward-pressure and bimanual laryngoscopy. Ann Emerg Med 47 (2006) 548-555
108. Noguchi T., Koga K., Shiga Y., et al. The gum elastic bougie eases tracheal intubation while applying cricoid pressure compared to a stylet. Can J Anaesth 50 (2003) 712-717
109. Haslam N., Parker L., and Duggan J.E. Effect of cricoid pressure on the view at laryngoscopy. Anaesthesia 60 (2005) 41-47
110. Williamson R. Cricoid pressure. Can J Anaesth 36 (1989) 601
111. Lyons G. Failed intubation. Six years' experience in a teaching maternity unit. Anaesthesia 40 (1985) 759-762
112. Benumof J.L., and Cooper S.D. Qualitative improvement in laryngoscopic view by optimal external laryngeal manipulation. J Clin Anesth 8 (1996) 136-140
113. Ralph S.J., and Wareham C.A. Rupture of the oesophagus during cricoid pressure. Anaesthesia 46 (1991) 40-41
114. Vanner R.G., and Pryle B.J. Regurgitation and oesophageal rupture with cricoid pressure: a cadaver study. Anaesthesia 47 (1992) 732-735
115. Heath K.J., Palmer M., and Fletcher S.J. Fracture of the cricoid cartilage after Sellick's manoeuvre. Br J Anaesth 76 (1996) 877-878
116. Cicala R.S., Kudsk K.A., Butts A., et al. Initial evaluation and management of upper airway injuries in trauma patients. J Clin Anesth 3 (1991) 91-98
117. Shorten G.D., Alfille P.H., and Gliklich R.E. Airway obstruction following application of cricoid pressure. J Clin Anesth 3 (1991) 403-405
118. Donaldson III W.F., Towers J.D., and Doctor A. A methodology to evaluate motion of the unstable spine during intubation techniques. Spine 18 (1993) 2020-2023
119. Gabbott D.A. The effect of single-handed cricoid pressure on neck movement after applying manual in-line stabilisation. Anaesthesia 52 (1997) 586-588
120. Helliwell V., and Gabbott D.A. The effect of single-handed cricoid pressure on cervical spine movement after applying manual in-line stabilisation-a cadaver study. Resuscitation 49 (2001) 53-57
121. Criswell J.C., Parr M.J., and Nolan J.P. Emergency airway management in patients with cervical spine injuries. Anaesthesia 49 (1994) 900-903
122. Mills P., Poole T., and Curran J. Cricoid pressure and the pressor response to tracheal intubation. Anaesthesia 43 (1988) 788-791
123. Fairweather N.L. Cricoid pressure: beware the patient with a goitre. Anaesth Intensive Care 31 (2003) 451-454
124. Putland J., and Ballin M.S. Subconjunctival haemorrhage following rapid sequence induction in pregnancy. Anaesthesia 53 (1998) 313
125. Vanner R.G. Tolerance of cricoid pressure by conscious volunteers. Int J Obstet Anesth 1 (1992) 195-198
126. Vanner R.G., and Asai T. Safe use of cricoid pressure. Anaesthesia 54 (1999) 1-3
127. Meek T., Gittins N., and Duggan J.E. Cricoid pressure: knowledge and performance amongst anaesthetic assistants. Anaesthesia 54 (1999) 59-62
128. Walton S., and Pearce A. Auditing the application of cricoid pressure. Anaesthesia 55 (2000) 1028-1029
129. Clayton T.J., and Vanner R.G. A novel method of measuring cricoid force. Anaesthesia 57 (2002) 326-329
130. Herman N.L., Carter B., and Van Decar T.K. Cricoid pressure: teaching the recommended level. Anesth Analg 83 (1996) 859-863
131. Koziol C.A., Cuddeford J.D., and Moos D.D. Assessing the force generated with application of cricoid pressure. AORN J 72 (2000) 1018-1028 1030
132. Owen H., Follows V., Reynolds K.J., et al. Learning to apply effective cricoid pressure using a part task trainer. Anaesthesia 57 (2002) 1098-1101
133. Clark R.K., and Trethewy C.E. Assessment of cricoid pressure application by emergency department staff. Emerg Med Australas 17 (2005) 376-381
134. Olsen J.C., Gurr D.E., and Hughes M. Video analysis of emergency medicine residents performing rapid-sequence intubations. J Emerg Med 18 (2000) 469-472
135. Kopka A., and Robinson D. The 50 ml syringe training aid should be utilized immediately before cricoid pressure application. Eur J Emerg Med 12 (2005) 155-158
136. Escott M.E., Owen H., Strahan A.D., et al. Cricoid pressure training: how useful are descriptions of force?. Anaesth Intensive Care 31 (2003) 388-391
137. Sackett R.B., Haynes P., Tugwell G., et al. Clinical Epidemiology: A Basic Science for Clinical Medicine (1991), Lippincott Williams & Wilkins, Baltimore, MD
138. Morley P.T., and Zaritsky A. The evidence evaluation process for the 2005 International Consensus Conference on cardiopulmonary resuscitation and emergency cardiovascular care with treatment recommendations. Resuscitation 67 (2005) 167-170
139. Cormack R.S., and Lehane J. Difficult tracheal intubation in obstetrics. Anaesthesia 39 (1984) 1105-1111