An analysis of the New York City police department's "stop-and- frisk" policy in the context of claims of racial bias

Journal of the American Statistical Association

Volumn 102, Issue 479, 2007, Pages 813-823

  Gelman, Andrew ^a   Fagan, Jeffrey ^a   Kiss, Alex ^b  

^a Och Spine at New York Presbyterian Hospitals   (United States)

^b SUNNYBROOK RESEARCH INSTITUTE   (Canada)

Author keywords

Criminology; Hierarchical model; Multilevel model; Overdispersed poisson regression; Police stops; Racial bias

Indexed keywords

EID: 35348874496     PISSN: 01621459     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1198/016214506000001040     Document Type: Article

References (82)

1. Alpert, G., MacDonald, J. H., and Dunham, R. G. (2005), "Police Suspicion and Discretionary Decision Making During Citizen Stops," Criminology, 43, 407-434.
2. Ayres, I. (2002a), "Outcome Tests of Racial Disparities in Police Practices," Justice Research and Policy, 4, 131-142.
3. _ (2002b), Pervasive Prejudice: Unconventional Evidence of Race and Gender Discrimination, Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
4. Bittner, E. (1970), Functions of the Police in Modern Society: A Reviev of Background Factors, Current Practices and Possible Role Models, Rockville, MD: National Institute of Mental Health.
5. Bratton, W., and Knobler, P. (1998), Turnaround, New York: Norton.
6. Brown v. Texas (1979), 443 U.S. 43, U.S. Supreme Court.
7. Brown v. Oneonta (2000), 221 F.3d 329, 2nd Ciruit Court.
8. Cole, D. (1999), No Equal Justice: Race and Class in the Criminal Justice System, New York: New Press.
9. Dharmapala, D., and Ross, S. L. (2004), "Racial Bias in Motor Vehicle Searches: Additional Theory and Evidence," Contributions to Economic Policy and Analysis, 3, article 12; available at www.bepress.com/ bejeap/contributions/vol13/iss1/art12.
10. Dominitz, J., and Knowles, J. (2005), "Crime Minimization and Racial Bias: What Can We Learn From Police Search Data?" PIER Working Paper Archive 05-019, University of Pennsylvania, Penn Institute for Economic Research, Dept. of Economics.
11. Durose, M. R., Schmitt, E. L., and Langan, P. A. (2005), "Contacts Between Police and the Public: Findings From the 2002 National Survey," NCJ 207845, Bureau of Justice Statistics, U.S. Department of Justice.
12. Eck, J., and Maguire, E. R. (2000), "Have Changes in Policing Reduced Violent Crime: An Assessment of the Evidence," in The Crime Drop in America, eds. A. Blumstein and J. Wallman, New York: Cambridge University Press, pp. 207-265.
13. Fagan, J. (2002), "Law, Social Science and Racial Profiling," Justice, Research and Policy, 4, 104-129.
14. Fagan, J., and Davies, G. (2000), "Street Stops and Broken Windows: Terry, Race, and Disorder in New York City," Fordham Urban Law Journal, 28, 457-504.
15. _ (2003), "Policing Guns: Order Maintenance and Crime Control in New York," in Guns, Crime, and Punishment in America, ed. B. Harcourt, New York: New York University Press, pp. 191-221.
16. Fagan, J., Zimring, F. E., and Kim, J. (1998), "Declining Homicide in New York: A Tale of Two Trends," Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology, 88, 1277-1324.
17. Fridell, L., Lunney, R., Diamond, D., Kubu, B., Scott, M., and Laing, C. (2001), "Racially Biased Policing: A Principled Response," Police Executive Research Forum; available at www.policeforum.org/racial.html.
18. Garrett, B. (2001), "Remedying Racial Profiling Through Partnership, Statistics, and Reflective Policing," Columbia Human Rights Law Review, 33, 41-148.
19. Gelman, A., Carlin, J. B., Stem, H. S., and Rubin, D. B. (2003), Bayesian Data Analysis (2nd ed.), London: Chapman & Hall.
20. Gelman, A., and Rubin, D. B. (1992), "Inference From Iterative Simulation Using Multiple Sequences" (with discussion), Statistical Science, 7, 457-511.
21. Goldberg, J. (1999), "The Color of Suspicion," New York Times Magazine, June 20, 51.
22. Gould, J., and Mastrofski, S. (2004), "Suspect Searches: Assess Police Behavior Under the U.S. Constitution," Criminology and Public Policy, 3, 315-361.
23. Greene, J. (1999), "Zero Tolerance: A Case Study of Police Policies and Practices in New York City," Crime and Delinquency, 45, 171-199.
24. Gross, S, R., and Barnes, K. Y. (2002), "Road Work: Racial Profiling and Drug Interdiction on the Highway," Michigan Law Review, 101, 653-754.
25. Gross, S. R., and Livingston, D. (2002), "Racial Profiling Under Attack," Columbia Law Review, 102, 1413-1438.
26. Harcourt, B. E. (1998), "Reflecting on the Subject: A Critique of the Social Influence Conception of Deterrence, the Broken Windows Theory, and OrderMaintenance Policing New York Style," Michigan Law Review, 97, 291.
27. _ (2001), Illusion of Order: The False Promise of Broken Windows Policing, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
28. Harris, D. A. (1999), "The Stories, the Statistics, and the Law: Why 'Driving While Black' Matters," Minnesota Law Review, 84, 265-326.
29. _ (2002), Profiles in Injustice: Why Racial Profiling Cannot Work, New York: New Press.
30. Hemenway, D. (1997), "The Myth of Millions of Annual Self-Defense Gun Uses: A Case Study of Survey Overestimates of Rare Events," Chance, 10, 6-10.
31. Illinois v. Wardlow (2000), 528 U.S. 119, U.S. Supreme Court.
32. Kelling, G., and Cole, C. (1996), Fixing Broken Windows, New York: Free Press.
33. Kelvin Daniels et al. v. City of New York (2004), Stipulation of Settlement, 99 Civ 1695 (SAS), ordered January 9, 2004; filed January 13, 2004.
34. Kennedy, R. (1997), Race, Crime and Law, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
35. Knowles, J., Persico, N., and Todd, P. (2001), "Racial Bias in MotorVehicle Searches: Theory and Evidence," Journal of Political Economy, 109, 203-229.
36. Lamberth, J. (1997), "Report of John Lamberth, Ph.D.," American Civil Liberties Union; available at www.aclu.org/court/lamberth.html.
37. Langan, P., Greenfeld, L. A., Smith, S. K., Durose, M. R., and Levin, D. J. (2001), "Contacts Between Police and the Public: Findings From the 1999 National Survey," NCJ 184957, Bureau of Justice Statistics, U.S. Department of Justice.
38. Loury, G. (2002), The Anatomy of Racial Inequality, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
39. Lundman, R. J., and Kaufman, R. L. (2003), "Driving While Black: Effects of Race, Ethnicity, and Gender on Citizen Self-Reports of Traffic Stops and Police Actions," Criminology, 41, 195-220.
40. MacDonald, H. (2001), "The Myth of Racial Profiling," City Journal, 11, 2-5.
41. Massey, D., and Denton, N. (1993), American Apartheid: Segregation and the Making of the Underclass, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
42. McCullagh, P., and Neider, J. A. (1989), Generalized Linear Models (2nd ed.), New York: Chapman & Hall.
43. Miller, J. (2000), "Profiling Populations Available for Stops and Searches," Police Research Series Paper 121, Home Office Research, Development and Statistics Directorate, United Kingdom.
44. Musto, D. (1973), The American Disease, New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
45. Pager, D. (2003), "The Mark of a Criminal Record," American Journal of Sociology, 108, 937-975.
46. People v. DeBour (1976), 40 N.Y.2d 210, 386 N.Y.S.2d 375.
47. People v. Holmes (1996), 89 N.Y.2d 838, 652 N.Y.S.2d 725.
48. R Project (2000), "The R Project for Statistical Computing," available at www.rproject.org.
49. Raudenbush, S. W., and Bryk, A. S. (2002), Hierarchical Linear Models (2nd ed.), Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
50. Reiss, A. (1971), The Police and the Public, New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
51. Richardson, M., and Pittinsky, T. L. (2005), "The Mistaken Assumption of Intentionality in Equal Protection Law: Psychological Science and the Interpretation of the Fourteenth Amendment," KSG Working Paper RWP05-011 ; available at ssrn.com/abstract=722647.
52. Rudovsky, D. (2001), "Law Enforcement by Stereotypes and Serendipity: Racial Profiling and Stops and Searches Without Cause," University of Pennsylvania Journal of Constitutional Law, 3, 296-366.
53. Russell, K. K. (2002), "Racial Profiling: A Status Report of the Legal, Legislative, and Empirical Literature," Rutgers Race and the Law Review, 3, 61-81.
54. Safir, H. (1999), "Statement Before the New York City Council Public Safety Commission," April 19; cited in Spitzer (1999).
55. Sampson, R. J., and Raudenbush, S. W. (1999), "Systematic Social Observation of Public Spaces: A New Look at Disorder in Urban Neighborhoods," American Journal of Sociology, 105, 622-630.
56. Sampson, R. J., Raudenbush, S. W., and Earls, F. (1997), "Neighborhoods and Violent Crime: A Multilevel Study of Collective Efficacy," Science, 277, 918-924.
57. Skogan, W. (1990), Disorder and Decline: Crime and the Spiral of Decay in American Cities, Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
58. Skogan, W., and Frydl, K. (eds.) (2004), The Evidence on Policing: Fairness and Effectiveness in Law Enforcement, Washington, DC: National Academy Press.
59. Skolnick, J., and Capolovitz, A. (2001), "Guns, Drugs and Profiling: Ways to Target Guns and Minimize Racial Profiling," Arizona Law Review, 43, 413-448.
60. Smith, D. A. (1986), "The Neighborhood Context of Police Behavior," in Communities and Crime: Crime and Justice: An Annual Review of Research, eds. A. J. Reiss and M. Tonry, Chicago: University of Chicago Press, pp. 313-342.
61. Smith, M., and Alpert, G. (2002), "Searching for Direction: Courts, Social Science, and the Adjudication of Racial Profiling Claims," Justice Quarterly, 19, 673-704.
62. Smith, M. R., Makarios, M., and Alpert, G. P. (2006), "Differential Suspicion: Theory Specification and Gender Effects in the Traffic Stop Context," Justice Quarterly, 23, 271-295.
63. Spiegelhalter, D., Thomas, A., Best, N., Gilks, W., and Lunn, D. (1994, 2003), "BUGS: Bayesian Inference Using Gibbs Sampling," MRC Biostatistics Unit, Cambridge, U.K.; available at www.mrc-bsu.cam.ac.uk/bugs/ .
64. Spitzer, E. (1999), "The New York City Police Department's "Stop and Frisk" Practices," Office of the New York State Attorney General; available at www. oag.state.ny us/press/reports/stop_frisk/ stop_frisk.html.
65. Sturtz, S., Ligges, U., and Gelman, A. (2005), "R2WinBUGS: A Package for Running WinBUGS From R," Journal of Statistical Software, 12 (3), 1-16.
66. Sykes, R. E., and Clark, J. P. (1976), "A Theory of Deference Exchange in Police-Civilian Encounters," American Journal of Sociology, 81, 587-600.
67. Taylor, R. B. (2000), Breaking Away From Broken Windows: Baltimore Neighborhoods and the Nationwide Fight Against Crime, Grime, Fear, and Decline, Boulder, CO: Westview Press.
68. Terry v. Ohio (1968), 392 U.S. 1, U.S. Supreme Court.
69. Thompson, A. (1999), "Stopping the Usual Suspects: Race and the Fourth Amendment," New York University Law Review, 74, 956-1013.
70. Tyler, T. R., and Huo, Y. J. (2003), Trust in the Law, New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
71. U.S. Commission on Civil Rights (2000), "Police Practices and Civil Rights in New York City," available at www.uscrr.gov/pubs/nypolice/main. htm.
72. U.S. v. Martinez-Fuerte (1976), 428 U.S. 543. U.S. Supreme Court.
73. Veneiro, P., and Zoubeck, P. H. (1999), "Interim Report of the State Police Review Team Regarding Allegations of Racial Profiling," Office of the New Jersey State Attorney General.
74. Walker, S. (2001), "Searching for the Denominator: Problems With Police Traffic Stop Data and an Early Warning System Solution," Justice Research and Policy, 3, 63-95.
75. Wang, A. (2001), "Illinois v. Wardlow and the Crisis of Legitimacy: An Argument for a "Real Cost" Balancing Test," Law and Inequality, 19, 1-30.
76. Weidner, R. R., Frase, R., and Pardoe, I. (2004), "Explaining Sentence Severity in Large Urban Counties: A Multilevel Analysis of Contextual and CaseLevel Factors," Prison Journal, 84, 184-207.
77. Weitzer, R. (2000), "Racialized Policing: Residents' Perceptions in Three Neighborhoods," Law and Society Review, 34, 129-155.
78. Weitzer, R., and Tuch, S. A. (2002), "Perceptions of Racial Profiling: Race, Class and Personal Experience," Criminology, 50, 435-456.
79. Whren et al. v. U.S. (1996), 517 U.S. 806, U.S. Supreme Court.
80. Wilson, J. Q., and Kelling, G. L. (1982), "The Police and Neighborhood Safety: Broken Windows," Atlantic Monthly, March, 29-38.
81. Zimring, F. E. (2006), The Great American Crime Decline, Oxford, U.K.: Oxford University Press.
82. Zingraff, M., Mason, H. M., Smith, W. R., Tomaskovic-Devey, D., Warren, P., McMurray, H. L., and Fenlon, C. R., et al. (2000), "Evaluating North Carolina State Highway Patrol Data: Citations, Warnings and Searches in 1998," available at www.nccrimecontrol.org/shp/ncshpreport.htm.