'Like the drifting grains of sand': Vulnerability, security and adjustment by communities in the Charlands of the Damodar River, India

South Asia: Journal of South Asia Studies

Volumn 30, Issue 2, 2007, Pages 327-350

  Lahiri Dutt, Kuntala ^a   Samanta, Gopa ^b  

^a AUSTRALIAN NATIONAL UNIVERSITY   (Australia)

^b Mankar College   (India)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

RIVER BANK; RIVER CHANNEL; RIVER SYSTEM;

ASIA; DAMODAR RIVER; EURASIA; INDIA; SOUTH ASIA;

EID: 34547733587     PISSN: 00856401     EISSN: 14790270     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1080/00856400701499268     Document Type: Article

References (74)

1. Quote from our informant Naren Sarkar.
2. B. McCay, 'Edges, Fields and Regions' in The Common Property Digest Vol.54 (2000), pp.6-8.
3. CEGIS (Center for Environmental and Geographic Information Service), Riverine Chars in Bangladesh: Environment Dynamics and Management Issues (Dhaka: The University Press Limited, 2000)
4. and M.H. Sarker, Iffat Huque and M. Alam, 'Rivers, Chars and Char Dwellers of Bangladesh', in International Journal of River Basin Management, Vol.1, no.1 (2003), pp.61-80 [http://www.jrbm.net/pages/ archives/JRBMn1/Sarker.PDF].
5. R. Chambers and G. Conway, 'Sustainable Rural Livelihoods: Practical Concepts for the 21st Century', Discussion Paper No. 296 (Brighton, Sussex: Institute of Development Studies, 1991).
6. B. Wisner, 'Sustainable Suffering? Reflections on Development and Disaster Vulnerability in the Post- Johannesburg World', in Regional Development Dialogue, Vol.24, no.1 (2003), pp.135-48.
7. Steve Ashley, Kamal Kar, Abul Hossain and Shibabaata Nandi, 'The Chars Livelihood Assistance Scoping Study', Documents of Chars Livelihoods Assistance Project (Dhaka: DFID (Department for International Development), 2003).
8. Sarker et al. note that in Bangladesh alone, about 600,000 people live on chars. In India, no such major study has been undertaken yet to give a reliable estimate of the numbers involved. However, the figure would be much higher than in Bangladesh, especially if those people living within the embankments along the rivers are taken into account. However, one must remember that this is a 'floating' population, and hence these numbers are no more than (informed) guesstimates. See Sarker et al., 'Rivers, Chars and Char Dwellers of Bangladesh', p.61.
9. Gilles Saussier, Living in the Fringe (Paris: Figura Association, 1998).
10. These are catchwords of the day, often seen from the positivist angle, dealing with the issues of resilience and sustainable development, and aiming to build 'adaptive capacity' amongst human communities or even ecological systems or a 'resilience framework' linking social and ecological systems.
11. R.W. Kates, Hazard and Choice Perception in Flood Plain Management (Chicago: Department of Geography, Research Paper 78, University of Chicago, 1962).
12. For example, the vulnerability and adaptation (V & A) guidelines formulated by the IPCC, UNEP & USCSP for ful- filling the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change's (UNFCCC) core focus, have highlighted the need to know the autonomous adaptation mechanisms in the various sectors of a society such as different classes or social groups. Another study by the U.S. Country Studies Program (USCSP), in collaboration with the Government of Bangladesh, has located vulnerability and adaptation of humans to environmental changes in various sectors.
13. See J.B. Smith, S. Huq, S. Lenhart, L.J. Mata, I. Nemesova and S. Toure (eds), Vulnerability and Adaptation to Climate Change: Interim Results from the U.S. Country Studies Program (Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publishers, 1996).
14. Please note that in this paper we do not deal with the reasons why Bangladeshi unauthorised migrants are here.
15. For a geomorphological interpretation of these landmasses see M. Morisawa, Rivers: Form and Process (London: Longman, 1985)
16. and R.J. Chorley, S.A. Schumm and D.E. Sugden, Geomorphology (London:MEthuen, 1984).
17. See http://www.eurasianet.org/departments/rights/articles/ eav100101.shtml#.
18. Saussier elaborates on how char people in Bangladesh even retain property title deeds and pay taxes for lands under water with the hope of cultivating it again, once the island re-emerges: 'Land is fresh and fertile on the char. The harvest is better than on the mainland... Apart from the cyclones, life is sweet on the chars'. Saussier, Living in the Fringe, p.20.
19. Mahajabeen Chowdhury, 'Women's Technological Innovations and Adaptations for Disaster Mitigation: A Case Study of Charlands in Bangladesh', Expert Group Meeting on Environmental Management and the Mitigation of Natural Disasters: A Gender Perspective, Ankara, 6-9 November 2001.
20. Abdul Baqee, Peopling in the Land of Allah Jaane: Power, Peopling and Environment, the Case of Charlands of Bangladesh (Dhaka: The University Press Limited, 1998), p.1.
21. M.Q. Zaman, 'The Social and Political Context of Adjustment to Riverbank Erosion Hazard and Population Resettlement in Bangladesh', in Human Organization, Vol.48, no.3 (1989), p.197.
22. Both of us did our Doctoral research on the region's urbanisation and rural-urban interactions.
23. B. Wisner, 'Who? What? Where? When? in an Emergency: Notes on Possible Indicators of Vulnerability and Resilience by Phase of the Disaster Management Cycle and Social Actor,' in E. Plate (ed.), Environment and Human Security: Contribution to a Workshop in Bonn (23-25 October 2002).
24. ISDR/UN/WMO, Water and Disaster: Be Informed and Be Prepared (Geneva: WMO Publication No.971, 2004).
25. UNDP (United Nations Development Programme), Reducing Disaster Risk: A Challenge for Development (New York: Bureau for Crisis Prevention and Recovery, 2004).
26. Ane Schjolden, 'Are Vulnerability and Adaptability Two Sides of the Same Coin?', in IHDP Newsletter, No.4 (2003), pp.12-14.
27. Piers Blaikie, Terry Cannon, Ian Davis and Ben Wisner, At Risk: Natural Hazards, People's Vulnerability and Disasters (London: Routledge, 1994), pp.8-9.
28. H.G. Bohle, 'Land Degradation and Human Security', paper presented at an international workshop on Environment and Human Security, Bonn, 2002.
29. J.J. Bogardi, 'Hazards, Risk and Vulnerability: A New Look on the Flood Plains', Proceedings, international workshop on Water Hazards and Risk Management, Tsukuba, 20-22 January 2004.
30. See for example Heather A. Smith, 'Facing Environmental Security', in Journal of Military and Strategic Studies (Winter 2000/Spring 2001) [http://www.jmss.org/2001/article3.html, accessed 1 Feb. 2007]
31. and J. Ikeme, 'Equity, Environmental Justice and Sustainability: Incomplete Approaches in Climatic Changes Politics', in Global Environmental Change, Vol.13 (2003), pp.195-206.
32. P.M. Kelly and W.N. Adger, 'Theory and Practice in Assessing Vulnerability to Climate Change and Facilitating Adaptation', in Climatic Change, Vol.47, no.4 (2000), pp.325-52.
33. Karen O''Brien, Siri Eriksen, Ane Schjolden and Lynn Nygaard, Whats in a Word? Conflicting Interpretations of Vulnerability in Climate Change Research, Working Paper No.2004:04 (Blinden, Norway: Centre for International Climate and Environmental Research, 2004), p.1.
34. Sabina Alkire, 'Conceptual Framework for Human Security', in Excerpt from Working Definition and Executive Summary: Report of the Commission on Human Security (New York: CHS Secretariat, 2002).
35. Amartya Sen, 'Why Human Security', Text of Presentation at the International Symposium on Human Security in Tokyo, 28 July 2000 [http://www.humansecurity-chs.org/activities/outreach/Sen2000.pdf].
36. Smith, 'Facing Environmental Security'.
37. See for example Arun Agrawal and K. Sivaramakrishnan, Social Nature: Resources, Representations and Rule in India (New Delhi: Oxford University Press, 2001).
38. For a detailed discussion of such concepts see Andrew Linklater, 'The Achievement of Critical Theory', in Steve Smith, Ken Booth and Marysia Zalewski (eds), International Theory: Positivism and Beyond (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 1996)
39. and George C. Bond and Angela Gilliam, Social Reconstruction of the Past: Representation as Power (London: Routledge, 1994).
40. Blaikie et al., At Risk: Natural Hazards, People's Vulnerability and Disasters.
41. IPCC (Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change), 'Summary for Policy Makers', in Third Assessment Report- Climate Change 2001: The Scientific Basis (Geneva: World Meteorological Organization and United Nations Environment Programme ISDR, 2001) [http://www.grida.no/ climate/ipcc_tar/wg1/].
42. Blaikie et al., At Risk: Natural Hazards, People's Vulnerability and Disasters, p.31.
43. Schjolden, 'Are Vulnerability and Adaptability Two Sides of the Same Coin?', pp.12-14.
44. M.B. Anderson and P.J. Woodrow, Rising from the Ashes: Development Strategies in Times of Disaster (Colorado: Westview Press, 1989).
45. Susan L. Cutter, Bryan J. Boruff and W. Lynn Shirley, 'Social Vulnerability to Environmental Hazards', in Social Science Quarterly Vol.84, no.2 (2003), pp.242-61.
46. Blaikie et al., At Risk: Natural Hazards, People's Vulnerability and Disasters
47. and K. Hewitt, Regions of Risk: A Geographical Introduction to Disasters (Harlow, Essex: Longman, 1997).
48. Melissa Haw, Chris Cocklin and David Mercer, 'A Pinch of Salt: Landowner Perception and Adjustment to the Salinity Hazard in Victoria, Australia', in Journal of Rural Studies, Vol.16 (2000), pp.155-69.
49. Kanangopal Bagchi, The Ganges Delta (Calcutta: Calcutta University, 1994).
50. R. Mukherjee, The Changing Face of Bengal: A Study in Riverine Economy (Calcutta: Calcutta University Press, 1938).
51. Kuntala Lahiri-Dutt, 'Imagining Rivers', in Economic and Political Weekly, Vol.35, no.27 (2000), pp.2395-400.
52. Kuntala Lahiri-Dutt, 'People, Power and Rivers: Experiences from the Damodar River, India', in Water Nepal, Vols.9/10, nos.1 & 2 (2003), pp.251-67.
53. Khaslands are new lands coming under government control. A piece of land has to be in existence for at least 20 years on a continuous basis before it can be legally designated as 'land'. Thus, many char lands are non - lands, as the Bangladeshi residents are non-people.
54. Patta is legal right to land written in a paper that is given by the Land Revenue Department. It is most important for a squatter to have a patta to establish ownership rights to the land. Getting a patta can be a bitterly-prolonged affair taking many years.
55. Kuntala Lahiri - Dutt and Gopa Samanta, 'Fleeting Land, Fleeting People: Bangladeshi Women in a Charland Environment in Lower Bengal, India', in Asia Pacific Migration Journal, Vol.13, no.4 (2004), pp.475-95
56. and Gopa Samanta and Kuntala Lahiri - Dutt, 'Marginal Lives in Marginal Lands: Livelihood Strategies of Women - Headed Households in Char ands of the Damodar, Lower Bengal, India', paper presented at XI National Conference of the Indian Association for Women's Studies, Goa, 3-6 May 2005.
57. This is close to the Indian threshold urban density of 400 persons per sq. km.
58. Kuntala Lahiri - Dutt, 'Urbanization in the Lower Damodar Valley: A Case Study in Urban Geography', unpublished PhD thesis, University of Burdwan, 1985
59. and Gopa Samanta, 'Rural-Urban Interaction in Burdwan and its Adjoining Areas', unpublished PhD thesis, University of Burdwan, 2002.
60. Mary Ann Brocklesby and Mary Hobley, 'The Practice of Design: Developing the Chars Livelihoods Programme in Bangladesh', in Journal of International Development, Vol.15, no.7 (2003), pp.893-909.
61. DFID (Department for International Development), 'Chars Livelihood Programme', in Project Memorandum (Dhaka: Department for International Development, 2002).
62. K. Maudood Elahi and John R. Rogge, Riverbank Erosion, Flood and Population Displacement in Bangladesh (Dhaka: Jahangirnagar University, Riverbank Erosion Impact Study, 1990).
63. K. Rudra, The Encroaching Ganga and Social Conflicts: The Case of West Bengal, India (Habra: Department of Geography, Habra S.C. Mahavidyalaya, 2002) [http://www.ibaradio.org/India/ganga/resources/ Rudra.pdf, accessed 17 Feb. 2006].
64. Aditya Ghosh, 'Shifting River Erases Villages and Identities', The Times of India (Kolkata) (24 Nov. 2004).
65. See Ian Burton and Robert W. Kates, 'The Flood Plain and the Sea Shore: A Comparative Analysis of Hazard Zone Occupance', in Geographical Review, Vol.64 (1964), pp.366-85
66. Thomas Frederick Saarinen, Perception of the Drought Hazard on the Great Plains (Chicago: Department of Geography, Research Paper 106, University of Chicago, 1996)
67. Ian Burton, Robert W. Kates and Rodman E. Snead, The Human Ecology of Coastal Flood Hazard in Megalopolis (Chicago: Department of Geography, Research Paper 115, University of Chicago, 1969)
68. David Lowenthal (ed.), Environmental Perception and Behavior (Chicago: Department of Geography, Research Paper 109, University of Chicago, 1967)
69. James K. Mitchell, Community Response to Coastal Erosion: Individual and Collective Adjustments to Hazard on the Atlantic Shore (Chicago: Department of Geography, Research Paper 156, University of Chicago, 1974)
70. and Thomas Frederick Saarinen, David Seamon and James L. Sell (eds), Environmental Perception and Behavior: An Inventory and Prospect (Chicago: Department of Geography, Research Paper 209, University of Chicago, 1984).
71. J. Sonnenfeld, 'Environmental Perception and Adaptation Levels in the Arctic', in D. Lowenthal (ed.) Environmental Perception and Behavior (Chicago: Chicago University Press, 1967), p.42.
72. Sarker et al., 'Rivers, Chars and Char Dwellers of Bangladesh', p.76.
73. M. Leaf, 'Local Control Versus Technocracy: The Bangladesh Flood Response Study', in Journal of International Affairs, Vol.51, no.1 (1997), pp.179-200.
74. J.J. Bogardi, 'Water Hazards, Risks and Vulnerabilities in a Changing Environment', paper presented at the International Conference on Space and Water: Towards Sustainable Development and Human Security, Santiago de Chile, 1-2 April 2004.