Trickle Down? Private sector participation and the pro-poor water supply debate in Jakarta, Indonesia

Geoforum

Volumn 38, Issue 5, 2007, Pages 855-868

  Bakker, Karen ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF BRITISH COLUMBIA   (Canada)

Author keywords

Development; Indonesia; Jakarta; Poverty; Privatization; Pro poor; Water supply

Indexed keywords

HOUSEHOLD INCOME; NONGOVERNMENTAL ORGANIZATION; PARTICIPATORY APPROACH; PRIVATE SECTOR; WATER PLANNING; WATER SUPPLY;

ASIA; EURASIA; INDONESIA; JAKARTA; SOUTHEAST ASIA;

EID: 34547665622     PISSN: 00167185     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.geoforum.2005.11.011     Document Type: Article

References (104)

1. ADB. Beyond Boundaries: extending services to the urban poor (2003), Asian Development Bank, Manila
2. ADB. Water in Asian Cities: Summary of Findings of the Study and a Regional Consultation Workshop (2003), Asian Development Bank, Manila
3. Agtini M., Rooswanti S., Lesmana M., Punjabi N., Simanjuntak C., Wangsasaputra F., Nurdin D., Pulungsih P., Rofiq A., Santoso H., Pujarwoto H., Sjahrurachman A., Sudarmono P., von Seidlein L., Deen J., Ali M., Lee H., Kim D., Han O., Park J., Suwandono A., Oyofo B., Campbell J., Beecham H., Corwin A., and Clemens J. The burden of diarrhoea, shigellosis, and cholera in North Jakarta, Indonesia: findings from 24 months surveillance infectious disease 5 89 (2005)
4. Akhtar, S., 2005. Mobilizing Finance for Infrastructure Development. Speech (Director General, Southeast Asia Department, Asian Development Bank), Indonesia Infrastructure Summit. 17 January, Jakarta. (accessed 14:10:2005).
5. Almansi F., et al. Everyday Water Struggles in Buenos Aires (2003), WaterAid and Tearfund, London
6. Argo, T., 1999. Thirsty downstream: the provision of clean water in Jakarta, Indonesia. Unpublished doctoral thesis, School of Regional and Community Planning, University of British Columbia.
7. Argo T., and Firman T. To privatize or not to privatize? Reform of urban water supply services in Jabotabek, Indonesia. Built Environment 27 2 (2001) 146-155
8. Azdan, M., 2001. Water Policy Reform in Jakarta, Indonesia: A CGE analysis. Unpublished doctoral thesis. Department of Agricultural, Environmental and Development Economics: Ohio State University.
9. Bakker K. From archipelago to network: urbanisation and privatisation in cities in the South. The Geographical Journal 169 4 (2003) 328-341
10. Bakker K. The third world water forum in Kyoto. Flux 52/53 (2003) 111-116
11. Bakker, K., 2004. An uncooperative commodity: privatizing water in England and Wales.
12. Bakker K. Neoliberalizing Nature? Market environmentalism in water supply in England and Wales. Annals of the Association of American Geographers 95 3 (2005) 542-565
13. Bardhan P. Corruption and development: a review of the issues. Journal of Economic Literature 35 3 (1997) 1320-1346
14. Barlow M., and Clarke T. Blue Gold: The Fight to Stop the Corporate Theft of the World's Water (2002), The New Press, New York
15. Baye E. Experimenting with the privatization of water services in Indonesia - from Surabaya to Djakarta. In: Lorrain D. (Ed). Urban Waste Management (1997), Hydrocom, Levallois 195-211
16. Bell M. Inquiring minds and postcolonial devices: examining poverty at a distance. Annals of the Association of American Geographers 9 3 (2002) 503-527
17. Berry B. Clean water for all: equity-based urban water supply alternatives for Indonesia's cities. Urban Geography 3 4 (1982) 281-299
18. BPD, 2003. Jakarta, Indonesia: Water Supply Improvements to Marunda District. London: Building Partnerships for Development in Water and Sanitation. http://www.bpd-waterandsanitation.org/english/projects/jakarta.asp (accessed 3:01:2004).
19. Braadbaart O., and Braadbaart F. Policing the urban pumping race: industrial groundwater overexploitation in Jakarta. World Development 25 2 (1997) 199-210
20. Brennan E.M., and Richardson H.W. Asian megacity characteristics, problems and policies. International Regional Science Review 12 2 (1989) 117-129
21. In: Cairncross S., Hardoy J., and Satterthwaite D. (Eds). The Poor Die Young (1990), Earthscan, London
22. Chifos C. Meeting unmet expectations: initiatives in urban environmental service provision in Jakarta. In: Chifos C., and Yabes R. (Eds). Southeast Asian Urban Environments. Program for SEA Studies (2000), Temple University Press, Arizona State University 29-72
23. Chifos, C., Hendropranoto, S., 2000. Thirty Years of Urban Infrastructure Development in Indonesia. In: Chifos, C., Yabes, R. (Eds.), Southeast Asian Urban Environments. Program for SEA Studies. Temple University Press, Arizona State University, pp. 153-181.
24. Cowherd, R., 2002. Cultural construction of Jakarta: Design, planning and development in Jabotabek, 1980-1997. Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, MIT, Department of Architecture.
25. Crane R. Water markets, market reform and the urban poor: results from Jakarta, Indonesia. World Development 22 1 (1994) 71-83
26. Crane R., and Daniere A. The contribution of environmental amenities to low-income housing: a comparative study of Bangkok and Jakarta. Urban Studies 34 9 (1997) 1495-1512
27. Crane R., and Daniere A. Measuring access to basic services in global cities: descriptive and behavioural approaches. American Planning Association. Journal of the American Planning Association 62 2 (1996) 203-221
28. Cross P., and Morel A. Pro-poor strategies for urban water supply and sanitation services delivery in Africa. Water Science and Technology 51 8 (2005) 51-57
29. DKI Jakarta. Decree 138/2005 (2005), Daerah Khusus Ibu Kota Jakarta Raya, Jakarta
30. Firman T. Land conversion and urban development in the northern region of West Java, Indonesia. Urban Studies 34 (1997) 1027-1046
31. Firman T. The restructuring of Jakarta Metropolitan Area: a "global city" in Asia. Cities 15 4 (1998) 229-243
32. Firman T. Rural to urban land conversion in Indonesia during boom and bust periods. Land Use Policy 17 (2000) 13-20
33. Firman T., and Dharmapatni I. The challenges to sustainable development in Jakarta metropolitan region. Habitat International 18 3 (1994) 79-94
34. Ford L. A model of Indonesian city structure. Geographical Review 83 4 (1993) 374-396
35. Franceys R., and Weitz A. Public-private community partnerships in infrastructure for the poor. Journal of International Development 15 8 (2003) 1083-1098
36. Gilbert A., and James D. Water pollution in Jakarta Bay. In: James D. (Ed). The Application of Economic Techniques in Environmental Impact Assessment (1994), Kluwer, Dordrecht 111-142
37. Goldman M. Imperial Nature: The World Bank and Struggles for Social Justice in the Age of Globalization (2005), Yale University Press, New Haven, CT
38. Gomez-Lobo A. Incentive based subsidies: designing output-based subsidies for water consumption. Public Policy for the Private Sector 22 (2001), World Bank, Washington
39. Gulyani S., et al. Universal (non)service? Water markets, household demand and the poor in urban Kenya. Urban Studies 42 8 (2005) 1247-1274
40. Harsono A. When water and political power intersect: a journalist probes the story of water privatization in Jakarta, Indonesia. Nieman Reports 59 1 (2005) 45-47
41. Haughton G. Market making: internationalization and global water markets. Environment and Planning A 34 5 (2002) 791-807
42. Hukka J.J., and Katko T. Refuting the paradigm of water services privatization. Natural Resource Forum 27 (2003) 142-155
43. Indonesia Times. Water Shortage Maybe Come Out of Control in year 2000 (1996), Indonesia Times 19 August
44. Jakarta Post. Water An Economic Commodity: Minister (2003), The Jakarta Post 20 September
45. Jakarta Water Supply Regulatory Body, 2004. Regulatory Approach to the Jakarta Water Supply Concession Contracts. Presentation: Lanti, A., (Member, Regulatory Body), Stockholm Water Symposium; August 16-20.
46. Jakarta Water Supply Regulatory Body, 2005. Urban Water in Jakarta. Presentation: Urban Water and Citizenship workshop, University of Indonesia, 11 May.
47. Johnstone N., and Wood L. Private Firms and Public Water: Realising Social and Environmental Objectives in Developing Countries (2001), Edward Elgar, Cheltenham
48. Kusno A. Modern beacon and the traditional polity: Jakarta in the time of Sukarno. Journal of Southeast Asian Architecture 1 (1997) 25-45
49. Kusno, A., 1998. Custodians of transnationality: metropolitan Jakarta, middle-class prestige, and the Chinese. In: Dandekar, H. (Ed.), City Space Globalization: An International Perspective, pp. 161-170.
50. Kusno A. Behind the Postcolonial: Architecture, Urban Space and Political Cultures in Indonesia (2000), Routledge, London
51. Leaf M. Building the road for BMW: culture, vision and the extended metropolitan area of Jakarta. Environment and Planning A 28 9 (1996) 1617-1635
52. Leitmann J. Urban environmental profile: a global synthesis of seven urban environmental profiles. Cities 12 1 (1995) 23-39
53. Lo F.C., and Yeung Y.M. Global restructuring and emerging urban corridors in Pacific Asia. In: Yeung Y.M., and Lo F.C. (Eds). Emerging World Cities in Pacific Asia (1996), United Nations University Press, Tokyo
54. Lovei L., and Whittington D. Rent-extracting behaviour by multiple agents in the provision of municipal water supply: a study of Jakarta, Indonesia. Water Resources Research 29 7 (1993) 1965-1975
55. Mandaung, M.E., 2001. Improving the efficiency of water supply management: a case study of the Jakarta public water supply enterprise, Indonesia. Canberra: Centre for Developing Cities, University of Canberra. cities.Canberra.edu.as/publications/Policypaper/Melva.htm (accessed 12 January 2001 and 24 June 2002).
56. Martijn, E.J., 2005. Hydraulic Histories of Jakarta, Indonesia (1949-1997): Development of piped drinking water provision. Vancouver: Unpublished research report, Department of Geography, University of British Columbia.
57. McDonald D., and Ruiters G. The Age of Commodity: Privatizing Water in Southern Africa (2005), Earthscan, London
58. McGranahan G., et al. The Citizens at Risk: From Urban Sanitation to Sustainable Cities (2001), Earthscan, London
59. McIntosh, A., 2003. Asian Water Supplies: Reaching the Urban Poor. Manila: Asian Development Bank and International Water Association.
60. Mitchell T. Rule of Experts: Egypt, Techno-politics, Modernity (2002), University of California Press, Berkeley
61. Nickson A., and Franceys R. Tapping the Market: The Challenge of Institutional Reform in the Urban Water Sector (2003), Palgrave MacMillan, London
62. Nunan F., and Satterthwaite D. The influence of governance on the provision of urban environmental infrastructure and services for low-income groups. International Planning Studies 6 4 (2001) 409-426
63. PAM Jaya. Laporan Evaluasi Kinerja Tahunan. Annual Report Evaluation 2003 (2004), Perusahaan Daerah Air Mimun, Jakarta
64. Pierre J. The marketization of the state: citizens, customers and the emergence of the public market. In: Peters G., and Savoie D. (Eds). Governance in a Changing Environment (1995), The McGill-Queen's University Press, Montreal and Kingston
65. In: Pierre J. (Ed). Debating Governance (2000), Oxford University Press, New York
66. Platts' Global Water Report, 2002. Jakarta: test bed for public private partnership. Issue 146, 17 May, pp. 1-3.
67. Porter R. The Economics of Water and Waste: A Case Study of Jakarta, Indonesia (1996), Avebury, Aldershot
68. Rahnema M. Poverty. In: Sachs W. (Ed). The Development Dictionary (1992), Zed Books, London 158-176
69. Robbins P. Transnational corporations and the discourse of water privatization. Journal of International Development 15 8 (2003) 1073-1082
70. Robertson-Snape F. Corruption, collusion and nepotism in Indonesia. Third World Quarterly 20 3 (1999) 58-602
71. Rogers P., and Hall A. Effective water governance. Global Water Partnership Technical Committee. TEC Background Papers, #7 (2003), GWP, Sweden
72. Scott J. The analysis of corruption in developing nations. Comparative Studies in Society and History 11 3 (1969) 315-341
73. Shirley M. Thirsting for Efficiency: The Economics and Politics of Urban Water System Reform (2002), Elsevier, London
74. Shiva V. Water Wars: Privatization, Pollution and Profit (2002), South End Press, Boston
75. Shleifer A., and Vishny R. Corruption. The Quarterly Journal of Economics August (1993) 599-617
76. Shofiani, N.E., 2003. Reconstruction of Indonesia's drinking water utilities: assessment and stakeholders perspective of private sector participation in the capital province of Jakarta, Indonesia. TRITA-LWR M.Sc. Thesis LWR-EX-03-30, ISSN 1651-064X. Stockholm: Department of Land and Water Resources Management, Royal Institute of Technology.
77. Shofiani, N.E., 2005. Assessment of the Kimpraswil water supply project: fuel subsidy reduction compensation program for water supply. Vancouver: Unpublished report, Department of Geography, University of British Columbia.
78. Silas J. Government-community partnerships in Kampung improvement programmes in Surabaya. Environment and Urbanization 4 2 (1992) 35-36
79. Simanjuntak C.H., Larasati W., Arjoso S., Putri M., Lesmana M., Oyofo B.A., Sukri N., Nurdin D., Kusumaningrum R.P., Punjabi N.H., Subekti D., Djelantik S., Sukarma, Sriwati, Muzahar, Lubis A., Siregar H., Mas'ud B., Abdi M., Sumardiati A., Wibisana S., Hendarwanto, Setiawan B., Santoso W., Putra E., Sarumpaet S., Ma'ani H., Lebron C., Soeparmanto S.A., Campbell J.R., and Corwin A.L. Cholera in Indonesia in 1993-1999. American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 65 6 (2001) 788-797
80. Smith L. The murky waters of the second wave of neoliberalism: corporatization as a service delivery model in Cape Town. Geoforum 35 4 (2002) 375-393
81. Soto Montes de Oca, G., et al., 2003. Assessing the willingness to pay for maintained and improved water supplies in Mexico City. CSERGE Working Paper ECM-2003-11.
82. Surjadi C. Households Environmental Problems in Jakarta (1994), Stockholm Environment Institute, Stockholm
83. Surjadi C. Public Private Partnerships and the Poor: Drinking Water Concessions Case study - Jakarta, Indonesia (2002), International Institute for Environment and Development, London
84. Surjadi C. Public Private Partnerships and the Poor: Drinking Water Concessions, A Study for Better Understanding Public-private Partnerships and Water Provision in Low-income Settlements (2003), Water, Engineering and Development Centre, Loughborough
85. Susantono, B., 2001. Informal Water Services in Metropolitan Cities of Developing World: The Case of Jakarta, Indonesia. Berkeley: Doctoral thesis, Department of City and Regional Planning, University of California.
86. Swyngedouw E. Power, nature, and the city. The conquest of water and the political ecology of urbanization in Guayaquil, Ecuador: 1880-1990. Environment and Planning A 29 2 (1997) 311-332
87. 2O: the contested terrain of water privatization. Capitalism Nature Socialism 16 1 (2005) 81-98
88. Taylor, John Lewis., 1983. An evaluation of selected impacts of Jakarta's Kampung improvement program. Los Angeles: Unpublished Doctoral thesis; Urban Planning, UCLA.
89. Taylor, J., 1983. An Evaluation of Selected Impacts of Jakarta's Kampung Improvement Program. Unpublished phd thesis, Department of Urban Planning, UCLA.
90. The Economist, 2004. Third world water and the private sector - How not to help those in need. The Economist, 28 August, 11.
91. Trawick P. Against the privatization of water: an indigenous model for improving existing laws and successfully governing the commons. World Development 31 6 (2003) 977-996
92. WaterAid. Does PSP Benefit the Poor: The Synthesis Report (2003), WaterAid and Tearfund, London
93. Whittington D. Possible adverse effects of increasing block water tariffs in developing countries. Economic Development and Cultural Change 41 1 (1992) 75-87
94. WHO. Global Water Supply and Sanitation Assessment. 2000 Report (2000), World Health Organization, UNICEF, and Water Supply & Sanitation Collaborative Council, Geneva
95. Winpenny J. Managing Water As An Economic Resource (1994), Routledge, London
96. Winpenny, J., 2003. Financing water for all: report of the world panel on financing water infrastructure. World Water Council, Third World Water Forum, Global Water Partnership.
97. World Bank. Indonesia: Urban Public Infrastructure Services (1993), World Bank, East Asia Region, Washington
98. World Bank. Infrastructure for Development. World Development Report 1994 (1994), World Bank, Washington
99. World Bank. The State in a Changing World. World Development Report 1997 (1997), World Bank Group, Washington
100. World Bank. Water Sector Adjustment Loan: Sectoral Environmental Assessment. E-267 (1999), World Bank and Jakarta: Government of Indonesia, Inter-Agency Task Force on Water Sector Policy Reform, Washington
101. World Bank. Making Services Work for Poor People. World Development Report 2004 (2004), World Bank Group, Washington
102. World Bank, 2004b. Indonesia: averting an infrastructure crisis: a framework for policy and action. Indonesia Infrastructure Department, East Asia and Pacific Region, World Bank.
103. World Bank, 2005. Implementation Completion Report (SCL-44690) on a loan in the amount of US $300 Million to the Republic of Indonesia for the Water Resources Sector Adjustment. Washington and Jakarta: Rural Development and Natural Resources Sector Unit; Indonesia Country Office; East Asia and Pacific Region, World Bank. Report No 32 6565. June.
104. Yepes, G., 1999. Do cross subsidies help the poor to benefit from water and wastewater services? Lessons from Guayaquil. UNDP - WB Water and Sanitation Program Working Paper.