Effects of roughness on hypersonic boundary-layer transition

Collection of Technical Papers - 45th AIAA Aerospace Sciences Meeting

Volumn 6, Issue , 2007, Pages 3690-3718

  Schneider, Steven P ^a,b  

^a Purdue University   (United States)

^b AIAA   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

BOUNDARY LAYER FLOW; CORRELATION METHODS; MACH NUMBER; PARAMETER ESTIMATION;

HYPERSONIC EDGE MACH NUNBERS; PARAMETRIC EFFECTS;

HYPERSONIC AERODYNAMICS;

EID: 34250899243     PISSN: None     EISSN: None     Source Type: Conference Proceeding    
DOI: 10.2514/6.2007-305     Document Type: Conference Paper

References (95)

1. William S. Saric. Görtier vortices. Annual Review of Fluid Mechanics, 26:379-409, 1994.
2. L. M. Mack. Boundary layer linear stability theory. In Report 709, Special Course on Stability and Transition of Laminar Flow, pages 1-81. AGARD, March 1984.
3. W.S. Saric, H.L. Reed, and E.B. White. Stability and transition of three-dimensional boundary layers. Annual Review of Fluid Mechanics, 35:413-440, 2003.
4. D. Arnal and G. Casalis. Laminar-turbulent transition prediction in three-dimensional flows. Progress in Aerospace Sciences, 36:173-191, 2000.
5. Steven P. Schneider. Hypersonic laminar-turbulent transition on circular cones and scramjet forebodies. Progress in Aerospace Sciences, 40(1-2):1-50, 2004.
6. I.E. Beckwith and C.G. Miller III. Aerother-modynamics and transition in high-speed wind tunnels at NASA Langley. Annual Review of Fluid Mechanics, 22:419-439, 1990.
7. Steven P. Schneider. Effects of high-speed tunnel noise on laminar-turbulent transition. Journal of Spacecraft and Rockets, 38(3):323-333, May-June 2001.
8. Steven P. Schneider. Flight data for boundary-layer transition at hypersonic and supersonic speeds. Journal of Spacecraft and Rockets, 36(1):8-20, 1999.
9. Daniel C. Reda. Review and synthesis of roughness-dominated transition correlations for reentry applications. J. of Spacecraft and Rockets, 39(2): 161-167, March-April 2002.
10. S.R. Pate. Supersonic boundary-layer transition: effects of roughness and freestream disturbances. AIAA Journal, 9(5):797-803, May 1971.
11. E.R. Van Driest and W.D. McCauley. The effect of controlled three-dimensional roughness on boundary-layer transition at supersonic speeds. Journal of the Aeronautical Sciences, 27(4):261-271 plus 303, April 1960.
12. S.R. Pate and C.J. Schueler. Radiated aerodynamic noise effects on boundary-layer transition in supersonic and hypersonic wind tunnels. AIAA Journal, 7(3):450-457, March 1969.
13. S. R. Pate. Dominance of radiated aerodynamic noise on boundary-layer transition in supersonic/hypersonic wind tunnels. Technical Report AEDC-TR-77-107, Arnold Engineering Development Center, Arnold Air Force Station, Tennessee, March 1978.
14. E.R. Van Driest and C.B. Blumer. Boundary-layer transition at supersonic speeds - three-dimensional roughness effects (spheres). J. of the Aerospace Sciences, 29:909-916, August 1962.
15. A.M.O. Smith and D. W. Clutter. The smallest height of roughness capable of affecting boundary-layer transition. Journal of Aerospace Sciences, 26(4):229-245, April 1959.
16. P.S. Klebanoff, G.B. Schubauer, and K.D. Tidstrom. Measurements of the effect of two-dimensional and three-dimensional roughness elements on boundary-layer transition. Journal of the Aeronautical Sciences, 22:803-804, November 1955.
17. P.S. Klebanoff, W.G. Cleveland, and K.D. Tidstrom. On the evolution of a turbulent boundary layer induced by a three-dimensional roughness element. J. Fluid Mechanics, 237:101-187, 1992.
18. H. L. Dryden. Transition from laminar to turbulent flow. In C.C. Lin, editor, Turbulent Flows and Heat Transfer, pages 3-74. Princeton University Press, Princeton, New Jersey, 1959. Volume V in the series on High Speed Aerodynamics and Heat Transfer.
19. H. L. Dryden. Review of published data on the effect of roughness on transition from laminar to turbulent flow. J. Aeronautical Sciences, 20:477-482, July 1953.
20. H. L. Dryden. Combined effects of turbulence and roughness on transition. Zeitschrift für angewandte Mathematik und Physik (ZAMP), 9b:249-258, 1958.
21. Albert E. Von Doenhoff and Albert L. Braslow. The effect of distributed surface roughness on laminar flow. In Gustav Lachmann, editor, Boundary layer and flow control, volume 2, pages 657-681. Pergamon Press, New York, 1961.
22. Itiro Tani. Effect of two-dimensional and isolated roughness on laminar flow. In Gustav Lachmann, editor, Boundary layer and flow control, volume 2, pages 637-656. Pergamon Press, New York, 1961.
23. R.H. Radeztsky, M.S. Reibert, and W.S. Saric. Effect of isolated micron-sized roughness on transition in swept-wing flows. AIAA J., 37(11):1370-1377, November 1999.
24. F. Gökhan Ergin and Edward B. White. Unsteady and transitional flows behind roughness elements. AIAA Journal, 44(11):2504-2514, November 2006.
25. Itiro Tani. Boundary-layer transition. Annual Reviews of Fluid Mechanics, 1:169-196, 1969.
26. Albert L. Braslow. Review of the effect of distributed surface roughness on boundary-layer transition. Report 254, AGARD, April 1960.
27. Neal Tetervin. Transition, minimum critical, minimum transition, and roughness Reynolds numbers, for seven blunt bodies of revolution in flight between Mach numbers of 1.72 and 15.1. Technical Report NOL-TR-62-25, Naval Ordnance Laboratory, August 1962. Citation AD333238 in DTIC.
28. M.R. Wool. Final summary report, passive nosetip technology (PANT) program. Technical Report TR-75-250, SAMSO, January 1975. Citation AD-A019186 in DTIC.
29. Daniel C. Reda. Correlation of nosetip boundary-layer transition data measured in ballistics-range experiments. AIAA Journal, 19(3):329-339, March 1981.
30. R. G. Batt and H.H. Legner. A review of roughness-induced nosetip transition. AIAA Journal, 21(1):7-22, January 1983.
31. M.L. Finson. Advanced reentry aeromechanics, interim scientific report, an analysis of nosetip boundary layer transition data. Report PSI-TR-52, Physical Sciences, Inc., August 1976. AFOSR-TR-76-1106.
32. M.L. Finson, A.N. Pirri, P.E. Nebolsine, G.A. Simons, and P.K.S. Wu. Advanced reentry aeromechanics; final report. Report PSI-TR-115, Physical Sciences, Inc., January 1978. AFOSR-TR-78-0607TR, citation 78N25117 in NASA STI, citation AD-A052744 in DTIC.
33. William M. Bishop. Transition induced by distributed roughness on blunt bodies in supersonic flow. Paper 77-124, AIAA, January 1977.
34. William M. Bishop. Transition induced by distributed roughness on blunt bodies in supersonic flow. Technical Report TR-76-146, SAMSO, October 1976. DTIC citation AD-A032009.
35. John J. Bertin. Hypersonic Aerothermodynamics. AIAA, Washington, DC, 1994.
36. Steven P. Schneider. Laminar-turbulent transition on reentry capsules and planetary probes. Journal of Spacecraft and Rockets, 43(6):1153-1173, Nov.-Dec. 2006.
37. Steven P. Schneider. Transition on blunt bodies with roughness and ablation. Paper 2008-XXXX, AIAA, January 2008. A 35-page manuscript with 8 figures and 96 references. To be submitted to the Aerospace Sciences Meeting.
38. Edward B. White, Robert S. Downs III, and Hillary C. Emer. Disturbances generated by random and periodic surface roughness: experiments and models. Paper 2006-3526, AIAA, June 2006.
39. Daniel C. Reda. Comparative transition performance of several nosetip materials at defined by ballistics-range testing. In Proceedings of the 25th International Instrumentation Symposium held May 7-10, 1979, Anaheim, California, pages 89-104, May 1979. See also the journal version in ISA Transactions, vol. 19, no. 1, Jan. 1980.
40. James L. Hunt and Robert A. Jones. Effects of several ramp-fairing, umbilical, and pad configurations on aerodynamics heating to Apollo command module at Mach 8. Technical Memorandum NASA-TM-X-1640, NASA, September 1968.
41. Max E. Wilkins and John F. Darsow. Finishing and inspection of model surfaces for boundary-layer-transition tests. Memorandum NASA-MEMO-1-19-59A, NASA, February 1959. NASA STI citation 19980232015.
42. P. Klebanoff and K. Tidstrom. Two-dimensional roughness element induces boundary-layer transition. Physics of Fluids, 15(7):1173-1188, 1972.
43. H. W. Liepmann and Gertrude H. Fila. Investigations of effects of surface temperature and single roughness elements on boundary-layer transition. Report 890, NACA, 1947.
44. Mark V. Morkovin. On the many faces of transition. In C. Sinclair Wells, editor, Viscous Drag Reduction, pages 1-31. Plenum Press, New York, 1969.
45. A. Demetriades. Transition in high-speed shear layers. In M. Y. Hussaini and R.G. Voigt, editors, Instability and Transition, Volume I, pages 52-67, Berlin, 1990. Springer-Verlag.
46. D. Papamoschou and A. Roshko. The compressible turbulent shear layer: an experimental study. J. of Fluid Mechanics, 197:453-477, 1988.
47. Luigi de Luca, Gennaro Cardone, Dominique Chevalerie, and Alain Fonteneau. Viscous interaction phenomena in hypersonic wedge flow. AIAA Journal, 33(12):2293-2299, December 1995.
48. Eli Reshotko and Anatoli Tumin. Role of transient growth in roughness-induced transition. AIAA Journal, 42(4):766-770, April 2004.
49. Hans W. Liepmann. Investigations on laminar boundary-layer stability and transition on curved boundaries. Wartime Report W-107, NACA, August 1943. NASA STI citation 93R23000.
50. Rudolph A. King and Kenneth S. Breuer. Acoustic receptivity and evolution of two-dimensional and oblique disturbances in a Blasius boundary layer. Journal of Fluid Mechanics, 432:69-90, 2001.
51. R.W. Wlezien. Measurement of acoustic receptivity. Paper 94-2221, AIAA, June 1994.
52. A.H. Whitehead, Jr. Flowfield and drag characteristics of several boundary-layer tripping elements in hypersonic flow. Technical Note TN-D-5454, NASA, October 1969.
53. A.L. Braslow and E. A. Horton. Effects of surface roughness on transition. In NACA Conference on High-Speed Aerodynamics, pages 439-450, March 1958. Paper is NASA citation 71N75317, conference is citation 71N75285, NASA-TM-X-67369.
54. Paul F. Holloway and James R. Sterrett. Effect of controlled surface roughness on boundary-layer transition and heat transfer at Mach numbers of 4.8 and 6.0. Technical Note TN-D-2054, NASA, April 1964.
55. Raymond M. Hicks and William R. Harper, Jr. A comparison of spherical and triangular boundary-layer trips on a flat plate at supersonic speeds. Technical Memorandum TM-X-2146, NASA, December 1970.
56. Scott Berry, Aaron Auslender, Arthur D. Dilley, and John Calleja. Hypersonic boundary-layer trip development for Hyper-X. Journal of Spacecraft and Rockets, 38(6):853-864, Nov.-Dec. 2001.
57. Albert L. Braslow. A review of factors affecting boundary-layer transition. TN D-3384, NASA, August 1966.
58. Albert L. Braslow, Eugene C. Knox, and Elmer A. Horton. Effect of distributed three-dimensional roughness and surface cooling on boundary-layer transition and lateral spread of turbulence at supersonic speeds. TN D-53, NASA, October 1959.
59. E. Leon Morrisette, David R. Stone, and Allen H. Whitehead, Jr. Boundary-layer tripping with emphasis on hypersonic flows. In C. Sinclair Wells, editor, Viscous Drag Reduction, pages 33-51. Plenum Press, New York, 1969.
60. J.R. Sterrett, E.L. Morrisette, A.H. Whitehead, Jr., and R.M. Hicks. Transition fixing for hypersonic flow. In Conference on Hypersonic Aircraft Technology, pages 203-222, May 1967. Paper is NASA citation 74N73064, conference is citation 74N73049, NASA-SP-148.
61. Albert L. Braslow, Raymond M. Hicks, and Roy V. Harris, Jr. Use of grit-type boundary-layer transition trips on wind-tunnel models. Technical Note TN-D-3579, NASA, September 1966.
62. E. Leon Morrisette, David R. Stone, and Aubrey M. Cary, Jr. Downstream effects of boundary-layer trips in hypersonic flow. In Compressible Turbulent Boundary Layers, pages 437-453. NASA, January 1969. NASA citation 70N10442.
63. E.R. Van Driest and C.B. Blumer. Summary report on studies on boundary layer transition for years 1963-1964. Technical Report SID 64-2191, North American Aviation, Inc., Space Sciences Laboratory, December 1964. Cited in Morrisette et al. 1969. Not available from any known archive.
64. Robert Korkegi. Transition studies and skin-friction measurements on an insulated flat plate at a Mach number of 5.8. J. of the Aeronautical Sciences, 23(2):97-107 and 192, February 1956.
65. J.L. Potter and J.D. Whitfield. Effects of unit Reynolds number, nose bluntness, and roughness on boundary layer transition. Technical Report AEDC-TR-60-5, Arnold Engineering Development Center, March 1960.
66. J.L. Potter and J.D. Whitfield. Boundary-layer transition under hypersonic conditions, pages 1-62. AGARD, May 1965. AGARDograph 97, Part III.
67. W.D. McCauley, A.R. Saydah, and J.F. Bueche. The effect of controlled three-dimensional roughness on hypersonic boundary-layer transition. Paper 66-26, AIAA, January 1966.
68. W.D. McCauley, A.R. Saydah, and J.F. Bueche. Effect of spherical roughness on hypersonic boundary-layer transition. AIAA Journal, 4(12):2142-2148, December 1966.
69. E.R. Van Driest and J. Christopher Boison. Experiments on boundary-layer transition at supersonic speeds. Journal of the Aeronautical Sciences, 24:885-899, December 1957.
70. John J. Bertin, E.S. Idar III, and Winston D. Goodrich. Effect of surface cooling and roughness on transition for the shuttle orbiter. J. of Spacecraft and Rockets, 15(2):113-119, March-April 1978.
71. Daniel Arnal and Jean Delery. Laminar-turbulent transition and shock wave/boundary-layer interaction. In Critical technologies for hypersonic vehicle development. NATO RTO, December 2005. Paper 4 in RTO-EN-AVT-116, 46 pages. NASA STI citation 20060010492.
72. E.R. Van Driest, C.B. Blumer, and C.S. Wells, Jr. Boundary layer transition on blunt bodies - effects of roughness. AIAA Journal, 5:1913-1915, October 1967.
73. J. Leith Potter and Jack D. Whitfield. Effects of slight nose bluntness and roughness on boundary-layer transition in supersonic flows. J. of Fluid Mechanics, 12:501-535, 1961.
74. Paul F. Holloway and E. Leon Morrisette. Roughness effects on boundary-layer transition for blunt-leading-edge plates at Mach 6. Technical Note TN-D-3517, NASA, August 1966.
75. M.R. Wool. Interim report, passive nosetip technology (PANT) program, volume X, Summary of experimental and analytical results (for the period May 1973 to December 1974). Technical Report TR-74-86-Vol-X, SAMSO, January 1975. Citation AD-A020708 in DTIC.
76. Rudolph Swigart. Roughness-induced boundary-layer transition on blunt bodies. AIAA J., 10(10):1355-1356, October 1972.
77. A.H. Boudreau. Correlation of artificially induced boundary-layer transition data at hypersonic speeds. Journal of Spacecraft and Rockets, 18(2):152-156, March-April 1981.
78. K.F. Stetson. Nosetip bluntness effects on cone frustum boundary layer transition in hypersonic flow. Paper 83-1763, AIAA, July 1983.
79. Catherine B. McGinley, Scott A. Berry, Gerald R. Kinder, Maria Barnwell, Kuo C. Wang, and Benjamin S. Kirk. Review of orbiter flight boundary layer transition data. Paper 2006-2921, AIAA, June 2006.
80. Scott A. Berry, H. Harris Hamilton II, and Kathryn E. Wurster. Effect of computational method on discrete roughness correlations for shuttle orbiter. J. of Spacecraft and Rockets, 43(4):842-852, July-August 2006.
81. J.J. Bertin, K.S. Stetson, S. A. Bouslog, and J.M. Caram. Effects of isolated roughness elements on boundary-layer transition for shuttle orbiter. J. of Spacecraft and Rockets, 34(4) :426-436, July-August 1997.
82. M.C. Fischer. Spreading of a turbulent disturbance. AIAA Journal, 10(7):957-959, 1972.
83. Brenda M. Kulfan. Reynolds number considerations for supersonic flight. Paper 2002-2839, AIAA, June 2002.
84. James C. Daugherty and Raymond M. Hicks. Measurements of local skin friction downstream of grit-type boundary-layer transition trips at Mach 2.17 and zero heat transfer. AIAA Journal, 8(5):940-941, May 1970.
85. John B. Peterson, Jr. Boundary-layer velocity profiles downstream of three-dimensional transition trips on a flat plate at Mach 3 and 4. Technical Note TN-D-5523, NASA, November 1969.
86. I. Beckwith, F. Chen, S. Wilkinson, M. Malik, and D. Tuttle. Design and operational features of low-disturbance wind tunnels at NASA Langley for Mach numbers from 3.5 to 18. Paper 90-1391, AIAA, June 1990.
87. Thomas J. Juliano, Erick O. Swanson, and Steven P. Schneider. Transition research and improved performance in the Boeing/AFOSR Mach-6 quiet tunnel. Paper 2007-0535, AIAA, January 2007.
88. Steven P. Schneider. Fabrication and testing of the Purdue Mach-6 quiet-flow Ludwieg tube. Paper 2000-0295, AIAA, January 2000.
89. Steven P. Schneider. Design of a Mach-6 quiet-flow wind-tunnel nozzle using the e**N method for transition estimation. Paper 98-0547, AIAA, January 1998.
90. Jim J. Jones. Experimental investigation of the heat-transfer rate to a series of 20-deg. cones of various surface finishes at a Mach number of 4.95. Technical Memorandum NASA-MEMO-6-10-59L, NASA, June 1959.
91. Winston D. Goodrich, Stephen M. Derry, and John J. Bertin. Shuttle orbiter boundary layer transition at flight and wind tunnel conditions. In Shuttle Performance: Lessons Learned, pages 753-780, March 1983. NASA-CP-2283, Part I.
92. Winston D. Goodrich, Stephen M. Derry, and John J. Bertin. Shuttle orbiter boundary layer transition: A comparison of flight and wind tunnel data. Paper 83-0485, AIAA, January 1983.
93. Scott A. Berry, Thomas J. Horvath, Amy M. Cassaday, Benjamin S. Kirk, K.C. Wang, and Andrew J. Hyatt. Boundary layer transition results from STS-114. Paper 2006-2922, AIAA, June 2006.
94. D.M. Tellep and H. Hoshizaki. X-17 re-entry test vehicle: R-26 final flight report. Technical Report LMSD-2600, Lockheed Aircraft Corp., November 1957. Citation AD802033 in DTIC.
95. D.I.A. Poll. Laminar-turbulent transition. In William S. Saric, Jean Muylaert. and Christian Dujarric, editors, Hypersonic Experimental and Computational Capability, Improvement and Validation, pages 3-1 to 3-20. AGARD, May 1996. AR-319 v. I.