A comparison of direct vs. self-report measures for assessing height, weight and body mass index: A systematic review

Obesity Reviews

Volumn 8, Issue 4, 2007, Pages 307-326

  Gorber, S Connor ^a   Tremblay, M ^a   Moher, D ^b,c   Gorber, B ^d  

^a STATISTICS CANADA   (Canada)

^b CHILDREN S HOSPITAL OF EASTERN ONTARIO   (Canada)

^c UNIVERSITY OF OTTAWA   (Canada)

^d Main Building ^*

Author keywords

Height; Measurement error; Self report; Weight

Indexed keywords

BODY HEIGHT; BODY MASS; BODY WEIGHT; DATA BASE; HEALTH; HUMAN; OBESITY; REVIEW; SELF REPORT;

ADULT; AGED; AGED, 80 AND OVER; BODY HEIGHT; BODY MASS INDEX; BODY WEIGHT; BODY WEIGHTS AND MEASURES; FEMALE; HUMANS; MALE; MIDDLE AGED; OBESITY; REPRODUCIBILITY OF RESULTS; SELF DISCLOSURE; SEX DISTRIBUTION;

EID: 34250682264     PISSN: 14677881     EISSN: 1467789X     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1467-789X.2007.00347.x     Document Type: Review

References (89)

1. Health Canada. Body Mass Index (BMI) Nomogram. 19 September 2003. [WWW document]. URL http://www.hc-sc.gc.ca/fn-an/nutrition/weights-poids/guide-ld- adult/bmi_chart_java-graph_imc_java_e.html (accessed 15 April 2006).
2. Katzmarzyk PT. The Canadian obesity epidemic, 1985-1998. CMAJ 2002 166 : 1039 1040.
3. World Health Organization. Obesity and Overweight. [WWW document]. URL http://www.who.int/dietphysicalactivity/publications/facts/obesity/en/prinwt. html (accessed 10 April 2006).
4. World Health Organization. World Health Report 2002 Reducing Risks, Promoting Healthy Life. [WWW document]. URL http://www.who.int/whr/2002/en/ (accessed 10 April 2006).
5. Tjepkema M. Measured Obesity. Adult Obesity in Canada: Measured Height and Weight. Nutrition: Findings from the Canadian Community Health Survey. Statistics Canada : Ottawa, 2005. Statistics Canada catalogue number 82-620-MWE2005001.
6. Shields M. Measured Obesity. Overweight Canadian Children and Adolescents. Nutrition: Findings from the Canadian Community Health Survey. Statistics Canada : Ottawa, 2005. Statistics Canada catalogue 82-620-MWE2005001.
7. Katzmarzyk PT, Janssen I. The economic costs associated with physical inactivity and obesity in Canada: an update. Can J Appl Physiol 2004 29 : 90 115.
8. Larsson D, Hemmingsson T, Allebeck P, Lundberg I. Self-rated health and mortality among young men: what is the relation and how may it be explained? Scand J Public Health 2002 30 : 259 266.
9. Af Sillen U, Nilsson J, Mansson N, Nilsson PM. Self-rated health in relation to age and gender: influence on mortality risk in the Malmo Preventive Project. Scand J Public Health 2005 33 : 183 189.
10. Heistaro S, Jousilahti P, Lahelma E, Vartiainen E, Puska P. Self rated health and mortality: a long term prospective study in eastern Finland. J Epidemiol Community Health 2001 55 : 227 232.
11. Singleton RA, Straits BC, Miller Straits M. Approaches to Social Research, 2nd edn. Oxford University Press : New York, 1993.
12. Adlaf EM, Mates D. A Comparison of Telephone and Personal Interview Surveys for Estimating Alcohol and Other Drug Use. Addiction Research Foundation : Toronto, 1994.
13. Midanik LT, Greenfield TK, Rogers JD. Reports of alcohol-related harm: telephone versus face-to-face interviews. J Stud Alcohol 2001 January 62 : 74 78.
14. Wiener L, Riekert K, Ryder C, Wood LV. Assessing medication adherence in adolescents with HIV when electronic monitoring is not feasible. AIDS Patient Care Stds 2004 18 : 527 538.
15. Statistics Canada. Canadian Community Health Survey (CCHS.): Cycle 1.1: Extending the Wealth of Health Data in Canada. 2003. [WWW document]. URL http://www.statcan.ca/english/concepts/health/cchsinfo.htm (accessed 10 February 2006).
16. St-Pierre M, Béland Y. Mode effects in the Canadian Community Health Survey: A comparison of CAPI and CATI. Proceedings of the American Statistical Association Meeting: Survey Research Methods. American Statistical Association : Toronto, 2004.
17. Rowland ML. Self-reported weight and height. Am J Clin Nutr 1990 52 : 1125 1133.
18. Jadad AR, Moore RA, Carroll D, Jenkinson C, Reynolds DJ, Gavaghan DJ, McQuay HJ. Assessing the quality of reports of randomized clinical trials: is blinding necessary? Control Clin Trials 1996 17 : 1 12.
19. Downs SH, Black N. The feasibility of creating a checklist for the assessment of the methodological quality both of randomised and non-randomised studies of health care interventions. J Epidemiol Community Health 1998 52 : 377 384.
20. Deeks JJ, Dinnes J, D'Amico R, Sowden AJ, Sakarovitch C, Song F, Petticrew M, Altman DG. Evaluating non randomized intervention studies. Health Technol Assess 2003 7 : 1 173.
21. Engstrom JL, Paterson SA, Doherty A, Trabulsi M, Speer KL. Accuracy of self-reported height and weight in women: an integrative review of the literature. J Midwifery Womens Health 2003 48 : 338 345.
22. Kuczmarski MF, Kuczmarski RJ, Najjar M. Effects of age on validity of self-reported height, weight, and body mass index: findings from the Third National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey, 1988-1994. J Am Diet Assoc 2001 101 : 28 34.
23. Villanueva EV. The validity of self-reported weight in US adults: a population based cross-sectional study. BMC Public Health 2001 1 : 11. Epub 2001 Nov 6.
24. Gillum RF, Sempos CT. Ethnic variation in validity of classification of overweight and obesity using self-reported weight and height in American women and men: the Third National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey. Nutr J 2005 4 : 27.
25. US Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. National Centre for Health Statistics. National Health and Nutrition Survey 2005-2006 Overview. 2005. [WWW document]. URL http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/nhanes/OverviewBrochureEnglish_May05.pdf (accessed 15 April 2006).
26. Stunkard AJ, Albaum JM. The accuracy of self-reported weights. Am J Clin Nutr 1981 34 : 1593 1599.
27. Schlichting P, Hoilund-Carlsen PF, Quaade F. Comparison of self-reported height and weight with controlled height and weight in women and men. Int J Obes 1981 5 : 67 76.
28. LeJarraga H, Laspuir M, Adamo P. Validity of reported parental height in outpatient growth clinics in Buenos Aires city. Ann Hum Biol 1995 22 : 163 166.
29. Allison DB, Nathan JS, Albu JB, Heymsfield SB, Duprat LJ, Pi-Sunyer FX. Measurement challenges and other practical concerns when studying massively obese individuals. Int J Eat Disord 1998 24 : 275 284.
30. Alvarez-Torices JC, Franch-Nadal J, Alvarez-Guisasola F, Hernandez-Mejia R, Cueto-Espinar A. Self-reported height and weight and prevalence of obesity. Study in a Spanish population. Int J Obes Relat Metab Disord 1993 17 : 663 667.
31. Avila-Funes JA, Gutierrez-Robledo LM, Ponce De Leon RS. Validity of height and weight self-report in Mexican adults: results from the national health and aging study. J Nutr Health Aging 2004 8 : 355 361.
32. Bolton-Smith C, Woodward M, Tunstall-Pedoe H, Morrison C. Accuracy of the estimated prevalence of obesity from self-reported height and weight in an adult Scottish population. J Epidemiol Community Health 2000 54 : 143 148.
33. Booth ML, Hunter C, Gore CJ, Bauman A, Owen N. The relationship between body mass index and waist circumference: implications for estimates of the population prevalence of overweight. Int J Obes Relat Metab Disord 2000 24 : 1058 1061.
34. Bostrom G, Diderichsen F. Socioeconomic differentials in misclassification of height, weight and body mass index based on questionnaire data. Int J Epidemiol 1997 26 : 860 866.
35. Brown JK, Feng JY, Knapp TR. Is self-reported height or arm span a more accurate alternative measure of height? Clin Nurs Res 2002 11 : 417 432.
36. Cash TF, Counts B, Hangen J, Huffine CE. How much do you weigh?: determinants of validity of self-reported body weight. Percept Mot Skills 1989 69 : 248 250.
37. Chor D, Coutinho ES, Laurenti R. Reliability of self-reported weight and height among state bank employees. Rev Saude Publica 1999 33 : 16 23.
38. DelPrete LR, Caldwell M, English C, Banspach SW, Lefebvre C. Self-reported and measured weights and heights of participants in community-based weight loss programs. J Am Diet Assoc 1992 92 : 1483 1486.
39. Doll HA, Fairburn CG. Heightened accuracy of self-reported weight in bulimia nervosa. A useful cognitive 'distortion'. Int J Eat Disord 1998 24 : 267 273.
40. Fonseca MJ, Faerstein E, Chor D, Lopes CS. [Validity of self-reported weight and height and the body mass index within the 'Pro-saude' study]. [Portuguese]. Rev Saude Publica 2004 38 : 392 398.
41. Forster JL, Jeffery RW, Snell MK. One year follow up study to a worksite weight control program. Prev Med 1988 17 : 129 133.
42. Giles E, Hutchison DL. Stature- and age-related bias in self-reported stature. J Forensic Sci 1991 36 : 765 780.
43. Gunnell D, Berney L, Holland P, Maynard M, Blane D, Frankel S, Smith GD. How accurately are height, weight and leg length reported by the elderly, and how closely are they related to measurements recorded in childhood? Int J Epidemiol 2000 29 : 456 464.
44. Hensley WE. The measurement of height. Adolescence 1998 33 : 629 635.
45. Hill A, Roberts J. Body mass index: a comparison between self-reported and measured height and weight. J Public Health Med 1998 20 : 206 210.
46. Imrhan SN, Imrhan V, Hart C. Can self-estimates of body weight and height be used in place of measurements for college students. Ergonomics 1996 39 : 1445 1453.
47. Jacobson BH, DeBock DH. Comparison of Body Mass Index by self-reported versus measured height and weight. Percept Mot Skills 2001 92 : 128 132.
48. Jalkanen L, Tuomilehto J, Tanskanen A, Puska P. Accuracy of self-reported body weight compared to measured body weight. A population survey. Scand J Soc Med 1987 15 : 191 198.
49. Kinney EL. Accuracy of self-reported weight in a non-normal population. Clin Invest Med 1988 11 : 347 350.
50. Klag MJ, He J, Mead LA, Ford DE, Pearson TA, Levine DM. Validity of physicians' self reports of cardiovascular disease risk factors. Ann Epidemiol 1993 3 : 442 447.
51. Kuskowska-Wolk A, Bergstrom R, Bostrom G. Relationship between questionnaire data and medical records of height, weight and body mass index. Int J Obes Relat Metab Disord 1992 16 : 1 9.
52. Kuskowska-Wolk A, Rossner S. The 'true' prevalence of obesity. A comparison of objective weight and height measures versus self-reported and calibrated data. Scand J Prim Health Care 1989 7 : 79 82.
53. Lackland DT, Wheeler FC. The need for accurate nutrition survey methodology: the South Carolina experience. J Nutr 1990 120 : 1433 1436.
54. Larson MR. Social desirability and self-reported weight and height. Int J Obes Relat Metab Disord 2000 24 : 663 665.
55. Lawlor DA, Bedford C, Taylor M, Ebrahim S. Agreement between measured and self-reported weight in older women. Results from the British Women's Heart and Health Study. Age Ageing 2002 31 : 169 174.
56. Masheb RM, Grilo CM. Accuracy of self-reported weight in patients with binge eating disorder. Int J Eat Disord 2001 29 : 29 36.
57. McCabe RE, McFarlane T, Polivy J, Olmstead MP. Eating disorders dieting and the accuracy of self-reported weight. Int J Eat Disord 2001 29 : 59 64.
58. de Araujo DS, de Araujo CG. Self-perception and dissatisfaction with weight does not depend on the frequency of physical activity. Arq Bras Cardiol 2003 80 : 235 249.
59. Nakamura K, Hoshino Y, Kodama K, Yamamoto M. Reliability of self-reported body height and weight of adult Japanese women. J Biosoc Sci 1999 31 : 555 558.
60. Nawaz H, Chan W, Abdulrahman M, Larson D, Katz DL. Self-reported weight and height: implications for obesity research. Am J Prev Med 2001 20 : 294 298.
61. Niedhammer I, Bugel I, Bonenfant S, Goldberg M, Leclerc A. Validity of self-reported weight and height in the French GAZEL cohort. Int J Obes Relat Metab Disord 2000 24 : 1111 1118.
62. Nieto-Garcia FJ, Bush TL, Keyl PM. Body mass definitions of obesity: sensitivity and specificity using self-reported weight and height. Epidemiology 1990 1 : 146 152.
63. Palta M, Prineas RJ, Berman R, Hannan P. Comparison of self-reported and measured height and weight. Am J Epidemiol 1982 115 : 223 230.
64. Payette H, Kergoat MJ, Shatenstein B, Boutier V, Nadon S. Validity of self-reported height and weight estimates in cognitively-intact and impaired elderly individuals. J Nutr Health Aging 2000 4 : 223 228.
65. Pirie P, Jacobs D, Jeffery R, Hannan P. Distortion in self-reported height and weight data. J Am Diet Assoc 1981 78 : 601 606.
66. Roberts RJ. Can self-reported data accurately describe the prevalence of overweight? Public Health 1995 109 : 275 284.
67. Rona RJ, Chinn S, Manning R. The validity of reported parental height in inner city areas in England. Ann Hum Biol 1989 16 : 41 44.
68. Santillan AA, Camargo CA. Body mass index and asthma among Mexican adults: the effect of using self-reported vs measured weight and height. Int J Obes Relat Metab Disord 2003 27 : 1430 1433.
69. Schmidt MI, Duncan BB, Tavares M, Polanczyk CA, Pellanda L, Zimmer PM. Validity of self-reported weight - a study of urban Brazilian adults. Rev Saude Publica 1993 27 : 271 276.
70. Smith GT, Hohlsteing LA, Atlas JG. Accuracy of self-reported weight: covariation with binger or restrainer status and eating disorder symptomatology. Addict Behav 1992 17 : 1 8.
71. Spencer EA, Appleby PN, Davey GK, Key TJ. Validity of self-reported height and weight in 4808 EPIC-Oxford participants. Public Health Nutr 2002 5 : 561 565.
72. Stewart AL. The reliability and validity of self-reported weight and height. J Chronic Dis 1982 35 : 295 309.
73. Stewart AW, Jackson RT, Ford MA, Beaglehole R. Underestimation of relative weight by use of self-reported height and weight. Am J Epidemiol 1987 125 : 122 126.
74. Tell GS, Jeffery RW, Kramer FM, Snell MK. Can self-reported body weight be used to evaluate long-term follow-up of a weight-loss program? J Am Diet Assoc 1987 87 : 1198 1201.
75. Tienboon P, Wahlqvist ML, Rutishauser IH. Self-reported weight and height in adolescents and their parents. J Adolesc Health 1992 13 : 528 532.
76. Vailas LI, Nitzke SA. Self-reported versus measured weight and height in an older adult meal program population. J Gerontol A Biol Sci Med Sci 1998 53 : M481 M483.
77. van der Voort DJ, Brandon S, Dinant GJ, van Wersch JW. Screening for osteoporosis using easily obtainable biometrical data. Diagnostic accuracy of measured, self-reported and recalled BMI, related costs of bone mineral density measurements. Osteoporos Int 2000 11 : 233 239.
78. Wada K, Tamakoshi K, Tsunekawa T, Otsuka R, Zhang H, Murata C et al. Validity of self-reported height and weight in a Japanese workplace population. Int J Obes 2005 29 : 1093 1099.
79. Wing RR, Epstein LH, Ossip DJ, LaPorte RE. Reliability and validity of self-report and observers' estimates of relative weight. Addict Behav 1979 4 : 133 140.
80. Ziebland S, Thorogood M, Fuller A, Muir J. Desire for the body normal: body image and discrepancies between self-reported and measured height and weight in a British population. J Epidemiol Community Health 1996 50 : 105 106.
81. Clemente L, Moreira P, Oliveira B, Almeida MD. Body mass index: sensitivity and specificity. Acta Med Port 2004 17 : 353 358. Epub 2004 December 20.
82. Quiles IJ, Vioque J. [Validity of notified anthropometric data for determining the prevalence of obesity]. [Spanish]. Med Clinica 1996 106 : 725 729.
83. Wang DY, DeStavola BL, Allen DS, Fentiman IS, Bulbrook RD, Hayward JL, Reed MJ. Breast cancer risk is positively associated with height. Breast Cancer Res Treat 1997 43 : 123 128.
84. O'Connell KJ, Osborne LM, Westhoff C. Measured and reported weight change for women using a vaginal contraceptive ring vs. a low-dose oral contraceptive. Contraception 2005 72 : 323 327.
85. Black DR, Taylor AM, Coster DC. Accuracy of self-reported body weight: stepped approach to model component assessment. Health Educ Res 1998 13 : 301 307.
86. Zhang J, Feldblum PJ, Fortney JA. The validity of self-reported height and weight in perimenopausal women. Am J Public Health 1993 83 : 1052 1053.
87. Brunet MEI. Development and validation of the Screening Test for at Risk Individuals for Eating Disorders (STARVED). Dissertation Abstracts International Section A: Humanities and Social Sciences 2003 March 63 (8A 2804.
88. Bowman RL, DeLucia JL. Accuracy of self-reported weight: a meta analysis. Behav Ther 1992 23 : 637 655.
89. Engstrom JL. Assesment of the reliability of physical measures. Res Nurs Health 1988 11 : 383 389.