The mysterious case of the missing paradigm: A review of critical information systems research 1991-2001

Information Systems Journal

Volumn 17, Issue 3, 2007, Pages 251-270

  Richardson, Helen ^a   Robinson, Bruce ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF SALFORD   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Critical information systems research; Critical paradigm; Positivist and interpretivist research

Indexed keywords

EID: 34249995956     PISSN: 13501917     EISSN: 13652575     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1365-2575.2007.00230.x     Document Type: Review

References (98)

1. Adam, A.E. (2001) Computer ethics in a different voice. Information and Organization, 11, 235 261.
2. Adam, A., Howcroft, D. Richardson, H. (2001) Absent friends? The gender dimension in IS research. In : Realigning Research and Practice in Information Systems Development: The Social and Organizational Perspective, Russo, N.L., Fitzgerald, B. DeGross, J.I. (eds), pp. 333 352. Kluwer, Norwell, MA, USA.
3. Adler, P. (2002) Critical in the name of whom and what? Organization, 9, 387 395.
4. Adman, P. Warren, L. (2000) Participatory sociotechnical design of organizations and information systems - an adaptation of ETHICS methodology. Journal of Information Technology, 15, 39 51.
5. Agre, P.E. Harbs, C.A. (1994) Social choice about privacy: intelligent vehicle-highway systems in the United States. Information Technology and People, 7, 63 90.
6. Alavi, M. Carlson, P. (1992) A review of MIS research and disciplinary development. Journal of Management Information Systems, 8, 45 62.
7. Alvarez, R. (2001) It was a great system: face-work and the discursive construction of technology during information systems development. Information Technology and People, 14, 385 405.
8. Alvesson, M. Deetz, S. (2000) Doing Critical Management Research. Sage, London, UK.
9. AMCIS (Americas' Conference on Information Systems) (2001) [WWW document]. URL http://amcis.aisnet.org/intro.htm (accessed 28 July 2005).
10. AMCIS (Americas' Conference on Information Systems) (2004) [WWW document]. URL http://aisel.isworld.org/proceedings/amcis/2004/program.asp (accessed 6 November 2006).
11. AMCIS (Americas' Conference on Information Systems) (2005) [WWW document]. URL http://www.ist.unomaha.edu/amcis2005/minitracks.php (accessed 6 November 2006).
12. Asaro, P.M. (2000) Transforming society by transforming technology: the science and politics of participatory design. Accounting Management and Information Technologies, 10, 257 290.
13. Aungles, A. Cook, D. (1994) Information technology and the family: electronic surveillance and home imprisonment. Information Technology and People, 7, 69 80.
14. Avgerou, C. (2005) Doing critical research in information systems: some further thoughts. Information Systems Journal, 15, 103 109.
15. Benbasat, I. Zmud, R. (2003) The identity crisis within the IS discipline: defining and communicating the disciplines's core properties. MISQ, 27, 183 194.
16. Bloomfield, B. McLean, C. (1995) Madness and organization: informed management and empowerment. In: ' Information Technology and Changes in Organizational Work' IFIP 8.2 Working Conference, Orlikowski, W., Walsham, G., Jones, M. DeGross, J.I. (eds), pp. 271 393. Springer, Cambridge, UK.
17. Bourdieu, P. (1998) Acts of Resistance Against the New Myths of Our Time. Polity Press, Cambridge, UK.
18. Bowen, F. Blackman, K. (2003) Spirals of Silence: the dynamic effects of diversity on organizational voice. Journal of Management Studies, 40, 1393 1417.
19. Brooke, C. (2002a) Critical research in information systems: issue 2. Journal of Information Technology, 17, 179 183.
20. Brooke, C. (2002b) Editorial: critical research in information systems: issue 1. Journal of Information Technology, 17, 45 47.
21. Cecez-Kecmanovic, D. (2001) Doing critical IS research: the question of methodology. In : Qualitative Research in IS: Issues and Trends, Trauth, E.M. (ed.), pp. 141 163. Idea Group Publishing, Hershey, PA, USA.
22. Cecez-Kecmanovic, D. (2005) Basic assumptions of the critical research perspectives in information systems. In : Handbook of Critical Information Systems Research: Theory and Application, Howcroft, D. Trauth, E. (eds), pp. 19 46. Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, UK.
23. Chen, W.S. Hirschheim, R. (2004) A paradigmatic and methodlogical examination of information systems research from 1991 to 2001. Information Systems Journal, 14, 197 235.
24. Chua, W.F. (1986) Radical developments in accounting thought. The Accounting Review, LXI, 601 631.
25. CMS (1999) Critical Management Studies Conferences. [WWW document]. URL http://www.CMS4.org (accessed 28 July 2005).
26. CMS (2003) Critical Management Studies Conferences. [WWW document]. URL http://www.mngt.waikato.ac.nz/EJROT/cmsconference/2003/proceedings/proceedings. asp (accessed 6 November 2006).
27. Cooley, M. (1980) Architect or Bee? The Human/Technology Relationship. Langley Technical Services Publishing, Slough, UK.
28. CRIS 1 (2001) Adam, A., Howcroft, D., Richardson, H. Robinson, B. (Re)-defining critical research in IS International workshop at the University of Salford. 9-10 July 2001.
29. CRIS 2 (2004) Adam, A., Basden, A., Richardson, H. Robinson, B. (eds). ' Critical reflections on critical research in IS International workshop at the University of Salford. 14 July 2004.
30. Culnan, M. (1987) Mapping the intellectual structure of MIS, 1980-1985: a co-citation analysis. MIS Quarterly, September, 341 351.
31. Davies, L. Mitchell, G. (1994) The dual nature of the impact of IT on organizational transformations. In : Transforming Organizations with Information Technology, Baskerville, R., Ngwenyama, O., Smithson, S. DeGross, J.I. (eds), pp. 243 262. North-Holland, Amsterdam, the Netherlands.
32. Dillard, J.F. Burris, B.H. (1993) Technocracy and management control systems. Accounting, Management and Information Technologies, 3, 151 171.
33. Doolin, B. (1998) Information technology as disciplinary technology: being critical in interpretive research on information systems. Journal of Information Technology, 13, 301 311.
34. Doolin, B. McLeod, L. (2005) Towards critical interpretivism in IS research. In : Handbook of Critical Information Systems Research, Howcroft, D. Trauth, E. (eds), pp. 244 271. Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, UK.
35. Eagleton, T. (2003) After Theory. Penguin, Harmondsworth, UK.
36. Elkjaer, B., Flensburg, P., Mouritsen, J. Willmott, H. (1991) The commodification of expertise: the case of systems development consulting. Accounting, Management and Information Technologies, 1, 139 156.
37. Flynn, D. Gregory, P. (2004) The use of social theories in 20 years of WG 8.2 empirical research. In : IFIP TC8/WG 8.2 Conference 'Information Systems Research: Relevant Theory and Informed Practice', Caplan, B., Truex, D., Wastell, D., Wood-Harper, T. DeGross, J.I. (eds), pp. 365 388. Springer, Manchester, UK.
38. Foucault, M. (1982) The subject and power. Critical Inquiry, 8, 777 795.
39. Greenhill, A. (1998) Blurring the boundaries: disentangling the implications of virtual space. In: ' Information Systems: Current Issues and Future Challenges' IFIP 8.2 Working Conference (with 8.6), Larsen, T.J., Levine, L. DeGross, J.I. (eds), pp. 37 48. IFIP, Helsinki, Finland.
40. Grey, C. (2005) Critical management studies: towards a more mature politics. In : Handbook of Critical Information Systems Research: Theory and Application, Howcroft, D. Trauth, E. (eds), pp. 174 194. Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, UK.
41. Guba, E.C. (1990) The alternative paradigm dialog. In : The Alternative Paradigm Dialog, Guba, E.C. (ed.), pp. 17 30. Sage, Newbury Park, CA, USA.
42. Harvey, L. (1997) A genealogical exploration of gendered genres in IT cultures. Information Systems Journal, 7, 153 172.
43. Harvey, L. (1998) Visibility, silencing and surveillance in an IT needs analysis project. In: ' Information Systems: Current Issues and Future Challenges' IFIP 8.2 Working Conference (with 8.6), Larsen, T.J., Levine, L. DeGross, J.I. (eds), pp. 131 148. IFIP, Helsinki, Finland.
44. Hirschheim, R. Klein, H. (1992) Paradigmatic influences on information systems development methodologies: evolution and conceptual advances. In : Advances in Computers, Yovits, M. (ed.), pp. 293 392. Academic Press, New York, NY, USA.
45. Hirschheim, R. Klein, H.K. (1994) Realizing emancipatory principles in information-systems development - the case for ETHICS. MISQ Quarterly, 18, 83 109.
46. Hirschheim, R. Klein, H.K. (2003) Crisis in the IS field? A critical reflection on the state of the discipline. Journal of the Association for Information Systems, 4, 237 293.
47. Howcroft, D. (2001) After the goldrush: deconstructing the myths of the dot.com market. Journal of Information Technology, 16, 195 204.
48. Howcroft, D. Trauth, E. (2004) The choice of critical IS research. In : IFIP TC8/WG 8.2 Conference 'Information Systems Research: Relevant Theory and Informed Practice', Caplan, B., Truex, D., Wastell, D., Wood-Harper, T. DeGross, J.I. (eds), pp. 195 212. Springer, Manchester, UK.
49. Howcroft, D. Trauth, E. (eds) (2005) Handbook of Critical Research in Information Systems. Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, UK.
50. Howcroft, D. Truex, D. (eds) (2001) Special issue on critical analyses of ERP systems: the macro level. DataBase, 32, 577 596.
51. Howcroft, D. Wilson, M. (2003) Paradoxes of participatory practices: the Janus role of the systems developer. Information and Organization, 13, 1 24.
52. Hull, R. (1997) Governing the conduct of computing: computer science, the social sciences and frameworks of computing. Accounting, Management and Information Technologies, 7, 213 240.
53. Information Systems Journal Special Issue (2007) Exploring the Critical Agenda in Information Systems Research. [WWW document]. URL http://disc.brunel. ac.uk/isj/ (accessed 28 July 2005). (in press)
54. Information Technology and People (2006) Critical Research in Information Systems. 19 : 3.
55. Introna, L. Whittaker, L. (2004) Truth, journals and politics: the case of MIS quarterly. In : IFIP TC8/WG 8.2 Conference 'Information Systems Research: Relevant Theory and Informed Practice', Caplan, B., Truex, D., Wastell, D., Wood-Harper, T. DeGross, J.I. (eds), pp. 365 388. Springer, Manchester, UK.
56. Janson, M.A. Taillieu, T. (1994) Informatization and communicative action. In : 'Information Technology and Changes in Organizational Work' IFIP 8.2 Working Conference, Orlikowski, W., Walsham, G., Jones, M. DeGross, J.I. (eds), pp. 153 173. North-Holland, Cambridge, UK.
57. Jones, M. (2000) The moving finger: the use of social theory in WG8.2 conference papers 1975-1999. In : The Social and Organisational Perspectives on Research and Practice in Information Technology, Baskerville, R., Stage, J. De Gross, J.I. (eds), 15 32. Kluwer, Boston, MA, USA.
58. Kincheloe, J.L. McLaren, P.L. (1994) Rethinking critical theory and qualitative research. In : Handbook of Qualitative Research, Denzin, N. Lincoln, Y. (eds), pp. 138 157. Sage, Thousand Oaks, CA, USA.
59. Klein, H.K. (1999) Knowledge and methods in IS research: from beginnings to the future. In : New Information Technologies in Organizational Processes - Field Studies and Theoretical Reflections on the Future of Work, Ngwenyama, O., Introna, L., Myers, M.D. DeGross, J.I. (eds), pp. 13 25. IFIP Kluwer Academic Publishers, Boston, MA, USA.
60. Kraft, P. Truex, D. (1994) Postmodern management and information technology in the modern industrial corporation. In : 'Information Technology and Changes in Organizational Work' IFIP 8.2 Working Conference, Orlikowski, W., Walsham, G., Jones, M. DeGross, J.I. (eds), pp. 113 127. North-Holland, Cambridge, UK.
61. Kvasny, L. Keil, M. (2006) The challenges of redressing the digital divide: a tale of two U.S. cities. Information Systems Journal, 16, 23 53.
62. Kvasny, L. Richardson, H. (2004) Call for Papers. [WWW document]. URL http://www.itandpeople.org/itp/criticalspecialissue.htm (accessed 15 March 2005).
63. Kvasny, L. Truex, D. (2000) Information technology and the reproduction of social order: a research paradigm. In : 'Organizational and Social Perspectives on Information Technology' IFIP 8.2 Working Conference, Baskerville, R., Stage, J. DeGross, J.I. (eds), pp. 279 294. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Boston, MA, USA.
64. Kvasny, L. Truex, D. (2001) Defining away the digital divide: the influence of institutions on popular representations of technology. In : Realigning Research and Practice in Information Systems Development: The Social and Organizational Perspective, Russo, N.L., Fitzgerald, B. DeGross, J.I. (eds), pp. 399 414. Kluwer, Norwell, MA, USA.
65. Lyytinen, K. (1992) Information systems and critical theory. In : Critical Management Studies, Alvesson, W. (ed.), pp. 159 180. Sage, London, UK.
66. McGrath, K. (2005) Doing critical research in information systems: a case of theory and practice not informing each other. Information Systems Journal, 15, 85 101.
67. Mitev, N. (2005) Are social constructivist approaches critical? The case of IS failure. In : Handbook of Critical Information Systems Research, Howcroft, D. Trauth, E. (eds), pp. 70 103. Edward Elgar, Howcroft, UK.
68. Mitev, N. (2006) Postmodernism and criticality in Information Systems Research: what critical management studies can contribute. Social Science Computer Review, 24, 310 325.
69. Munro, R. (1993) Just when you thought it was safe to enter the water: accountability, language games and multiple control technologies. Accounting, Management and Information Technologies, 3, 249 271.
70. Myers, M.D. (1995) Dialectical hermeneutics - a theoretical framework for the implementation of information-systems. Information Systems Journal, 5, 51 70.
71. Myers, M.D. (1997) Critical ethnography in information systems. In : Information Systems and Qualitative Research, Lee, A.S., Liebenau, J. DeGross, J.I. (eds), pp. 276 300. Chapman and Hall, London, UK.
72. Ngwenyama, O.K. Lee, A.S. (1997) Communication richness in electronic mail: critical social theory and the contextuality of meaning. MISQ Quarterly, 21, 145 167.
73. Nissen, H., Klein, H. Hirschheim, R. (1991) Information Systems Research Contemporary Approaches and Emergent Traditions. Elsevier, the Netherland.
74. Orlikowski, W.J. Baroudi, J.J. (1991) Studying information technology in organisations: research approaches and assumptions. Information Systems Research, 2, 1 28.
75. Päivärinta, T. (2001) The concept of genre within the critical approach to information systems development. Information and Organization, 11, 207 234.
76. Richardson, H. Howcroft, D. (2006) The contradictions of CRM - a critical lens on call centres. Information and Organization, 16, 56 81.
77. Robey, D. Boudreau, M. (1999) Accounting for contradictory organizational consequences of information technology: theoretical directions and methodological implications. Information Systems Research, 10, 167 185.
78. Robinson, B. Richardson, H. (1999) The crisis of the information systems discipline: a vygotskyan analysis. In The Proceedings of the Critical Management Studies Conference, University of Manchester, 14th-17th July 1999.
79. Robinson, B. Wilson, F. (2003) Soft systems methodology and dialectics in an information environment: a case-study of the battle of Britain. Systems Research and Behavioral Science, 20, 255 268.
80. Saravanamuthu, K. (2002) The political lacuna in participatory systems design. Journal of Information Technology, 17, 185 198.
81. Sawyer, S. Crowston, K. (2004) Information systems in organizations and society: speculating on the next 25 years of research. In : Information Systems Research: Relevant Theory and Informed Practice, Kaplan, B., Truex, D., Wastell, D., Wood-Harper, T. Gross, J.I. (eds), pp. 35 52. Kluwer Academic Press, Boston, MA, USA.
82. Schultze, U. (1998) Investigation the contradictions in knowledge management. In : 'Information Systems: Current Issues and Future Challenges' IFIP 8.2 Working Conference (with 8.6), Larsen, T.J., Levine, L. DeGross, J.I. (eds), pp. 155 174. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Helsinki, Finland.
83. Schwandt, T.R. (1990) Paths to inquiry in the social disciplines. In : The Alternative Paradigm Dialog, Guba, E.C. (ed.), pp. 258 276. Sage, Newbury Park, CA, USA.
84. Smith, S. (1988) How much change at the store? The impact of new technologies and labour processes on mangers and staff in retail distribution. In : New Technology and the Labour Process, Knights, D. Willmott, H. (eds), pp. 143 162. Macmillan, London, UK.
85. Suchman, L. (1994) Do categories have politics? The language/action perspective reconsidered. Computer Supported Cooperative Work, 2, 177 190.
86. Tapia, A. (2004) Resistance or deviance? A high tech workplace during the bursting of the dot com bubble. In : Relevant Theory and Informed Practice: Looking Forward from a 20 Year Perspective on IS Research, Kaplan, B., Truex, D., Wastell, D., Wood-Harper, T. DeGross, J. (eds), pp. 577 597. Kluwer Academic Publishers, London, UK.
87. Tsoukas, H. (1992) Panoptic reason and the search for totality: a critical assessment of the critical systems perspective. Human Relations, 45, 637 657.
88. Wainwright, D. (1997) Can sociological research be qualitative, critical and valid? The Qualitative Report, 3, [WWW document]. URL http://www.nova.edu/ SSSS/QR/QR3-2/wain.html (accessed 6 November 2006).
89. Walsham, G. (2005a) Learning about being critical. Information Systems Journal, 15, 111 117.
90. Walsham, G. (2005b) Critical engagement: why, what and how? In : Handbook of Critical Information Systems Research: Theory and Application, Howcroft, D. Trauth, E. (eds), pp. 225 243. Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, UK.
91. Watson, H. Wood-Harper, A.T. (1996) Deconstruction contexts in interpreting methodology. Journal of Information Technology, 11, 59 70.
92. Wilson, F. (1995) Managerial control strategies within the networked organization. Information Technology and People, 8, 57 72.
93. Wilson, F. (1996) The socio-cybernetic paradox of the networked firm. Information Technology and People, 9, 3 23.
94. Wilson, F. (1997) The truth is out there: the search for emancipatory principles in information systems design. Information Technology and People, 10, 187 204.
95. Wilson, F. (1999) Flogging a dead horse: the implications of epistemological relativism within information systems methodological practice. European Journal of Information Systems, 8, 161 169.
96. Wilson, M. (2001) A new paradigm for considering gender in information systems development research. In : Realigning Research and Practice in Information Systems Development: The Social and Organizational Perspective, Russo, N.L., Fitzgerald, B. DeGross, J.I. (eds), pp. 353 366. Kluwer, Norwell, MA, USA.
97. Wilson, M. Howcroft, D. (2000) The role of gender in user resistance and information systems failure. In: ' Organizational and Social Perspectives on Information Technology' IFIP 8.2 Working Conference, Baskerville, R., Stage, J. DeGross, J.I. (eds), pp. 453 472. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Aalborg, Denmark.
98. Zald, M.N. (2002) Spinning disciplines: critical management studies in the context of the transformation of management education. Organization, 9, 365 385.