The lawyer who overidentifies with his client

Notre Dame Law Review

Volumn 76, Issue 3, 2001, Pages 827-841

  Noonan Jr , John T ^a  

^a U States Ct Appeals Ninth Circuit ^*  (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 33846654850     PISSN: 07453515     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: None     Document Type: Article

References (120)

1. 17 How. St. Tr. 1139 (Ex. 1743). For John Wigmore's citations of Annesley, see JOHN HENRY WIGMORE, A TREATISE ON THE ANGLO-AMERICAN SYSTEM OF EXIDENCE IN TRIALS AT COMMON LAW §§ 166, 272, 278, 280, 1013, 1099, 1130, 1154, 1361, 1362, 1364, 1431, 1487, 1605, 2213, 2290, 2291, 2294, 2298, 2310 (3d ed. 1940).
2. See JOHN T. NOONAN, JR., BRIBES 348 (1984).
3. Annesley, 17 How. St. Tr. at 1225.
4. See MODEL RULES OF PROF'L CONDUCT R. 1.6 cmt. 2 (2001).
5. See CHARLES P. CURTIS, IT'S YOUR LAW 10-25 (1954).
6. Id. at 20.
7. Id.
8. See Genesis 2:24.
9. See Charles Fried, The Lawyer as Friend: The Moral Foundations of the Lawyer-client Relation, 85 YALE L.J. 1060, 1065-76 (1976).
10. See THOMAS AQUINAS, SUMMA THEOLOGICA pt. II-II, q. 26, arts. 4-8 (Fathers of the Eng. Dominican Province trans., Benzinger Bros., Inc. 1947).
11. See William H. Simon, The Ideology of Advocacy: Procedural Justice and Professional Ethics, 1978 WIS. L. REV. 29, 108.
12. The Subcommittee of the Committee of the Judiciary of the United States Senate, On the Nomination of Louis B. Brandeis to be an Associate Justice of the Supreme Court of the United States, 64th Cong. 1104 (1916) (testimony of Abe Stein).
13. Id. at 1105.
14. Id. at 1104-05.
15. Id. at 1105.
16. Id. at 1106.
17. Id.
18. Id. at 311 (testimony of Moses J. Stroock); accord id. at 1105-06 (testimony of Abe Stein).
19. Id. at 1105-06 (testimony of Abe Stein).
20. See id. at 311 (testimony of Moses J. Stroock).
21. See id. at 312.
22. See id.
23. See id. at 775-91 (testimony of Edward F. McClennan).
24. Id. at 776.
25. See id. at 783.
26. Id. at 784.
27. See id. at 786.
28. See id. at 783.
29. See id. at 786.
30. Id. at 788.
31. See id. at 787.
32. See id.
33. Id. at 789.
34. Id. at 790.
35. Id.
36. Id.
37. Id.
38. See id. at 1119 (testimony of James T. Lennox) (stating that Brandeis was employed "absolutely" as Lennox's attorney); id. at 1087 (testimony of Moses J. Stroock) (stating his understanding that "at that time Mr. Brandeis was representing Mr. Lennox").
39. See id. at 1087-89 (testimony of Moses J. Stroock).
40. See id. at 796-800 ("Interview - Re Lennox Matter" - Sept. 5, 1907) (discussing the assignment from Patrick Lennox and James Lennox to George R. Nutter).
41. See id. at 791-96. Lennox denied that Brandeis informed him. See id. at 1115 (testimony of James T. Lennox).
42. See id. at 804 (testimony of Edward F. McClennan).
43. See id. at 287 (testimony of Sherman L. Whipple).
44. Id.
45. Id.
46. Id.
47. Id.
48. Id. at 287-88.
49. Id. at 299.
50. See id. at 288-89.
51. See 2 ROBERT T. SWAINE, THE CRAVATH FIRM AND ITS PREDECESSORS 1819-1948, at 718 (1948).
52. See 2 id. at 141.
53. See 2 id. at 142-43.
54. E.g., Raoul Berger, associate concertmaster of the Cincinnati Symphony Orchestra, who was later a law teacher. See Deaths Elsewhere, DAYTON DAILY NEWS, Sept. 3, 2000, at 7B.
55. See 2 SWAINE, supra note 51, at 143.
56. See 2 id.
57. See 2 id.
58. See 2 id.
59. 2 id.
60. WILLIAM O. DOUGLAS, GO EAST, YOUNG MAN: THE EARLY YEARS; THE AUTOBIOGRAPHY OF WILLIAM O. DOUGLAS 151 (1974).
61. See id.
62. 2 SWAINE, supra note 51, at 144.
63. 2 id. at 574 n.1.
64. See generally 2 id. (describing Moore's extensive work for Bethlehem).
65. 2 id.
66. See H.R. REP. No. 79-1639, at 26 (1946).
67. See id. at 27.
68. See id. at 26.
69. See id.
70. See id.
71. See id. at 26-27.
72. See id.
73. See id. at 1.
74. See id. at 43-44.
75. See id. at 44.
76. See id. at 40.
77. See id. at 40-41.
78. See H.R. REP. No. 79-1640 (1946) ("Accepting the Renunciation by Albert W. Johnson of Pension under Section 260 of the Judicial Code.").
79. See Conduct of Albert IV. Johnson and Albert L. Watson, United States District Judges, Middle District of Pennsylvania, Hearings Before the House Committee on the Judiciary, 79th Cong. 789 (1945) [hereinafter Johnson Hearings] (testimony of Harry W. Mumford).
80. See id. at 27.
81. See id. at 218-19 (testimony of Hoyt A. Moore) (discussing the appointment of receivers); JOSEPH BORKIN, THE CORRUPT JUDGE: AN INQUIRV INTO BRIBERY AND OTHER HIGH CRIMES AND MISDEMEANORS IN THE FEDERAL COURTS 169 (1962).
82. See Root Refining Co. v. Universal Oil Prods. Co., 169 F.2d 514, 517 (3d Cir. 1948).
83. See Johnson Hearings, supra note 79, at 220 (testimony of Hoyt A. Moore).
84. See H.R. REP. No. 79-1639, at 27 (1946).
85. Id. at 30.
86. See id. at 31-33.
87. Johnson Hearings, supra note 79, at 781-83 (testimony of Harry W. Mumford).
88. See id. at 782.
89. Id. at 784.
90. Id. at 783.
91. Id.
92. Id. at 784.
93. Id.
94. Id. at 804 (testimony of John Memolo).
95. Id.
96. See H.R. REP. No. 79-1639, at 31 (1946).
97. See id.
98. See id. at 32.
99. See id. at 31.
100. See id. at 31-32.
101. See BORKIN, supra note 81, at 181.
102. See H.R. REP. No. 79-1639, at 35 (1946).
103. See id. at 32.
104. Johnson Hearings, supra note 79, at 808 (testimony of John Memolo).
105. Id.
106. See id. at 622 (testimony of Robert E. McMath, Financial Vice President and Secretary of Bethlehem).
107. See id. at 621.
108. See id. at 623; id. at 776 (testimony of Edward J. Maloney) (stating that Bethlehem paid Maloney $31,075).
109. See id. at 622 (testimony of Robert E. McMath).
110. See id. at 819 (testimony of John Memolo).
111. See id. at 820.
112. Id. at 576-78 (testimony of Hoyt A. Moore).
113. Id. at 770 (testimony of Jacob Greenes).
114. Id. at 793 (testimony of Harry W. Mumford).
115. Id. at 797.
116. Id. at 800.
117. See id. at 580 (testimony of Hoyt A. Moore).
118. See id. at 602-03 (grand jury testimony of Hoyt A. Moore).
119. See PLATO, THE REPUBLIC bk. I, §§ 341-346, at 16-22 (A.D. Lindsay trans., 1992).
120. See id. § 341, at 16-17.