Contrastive explanation and unrealistic models: The case of the new economic geography

Journal of Economic Methodology

Volumn 13, Issue 4, 2006, Pages 425-446

  Marchionni, Caterina ^a  

^a ERASMUS UNIVERSITY ROTTERDAM   (Netherlands)

Author keywords

Contrastives; Economic geography; Explanation; Models; New economic geography; Unrealisticness

Indexed keywords

EID: 33845728948     PISSN: 1350178X     EISSN: 14699427     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1080/13501780601048758     Document Type: Article

References (51)

1. Amin, A. and Thrift, N. (2000) 'What kind of economic theory for what kind of economic geography', Antipode 32: 4-9.
2. Baldwin, R., Forslid, R., Martin, P., Ottaviano, G. and Robert-Nicoud, F. (2003) Economic Geography and Public Policy, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
3. Berry, B. J. L. (1999) 'Déja vu, Mr Krugman', Urban Geography 20(1): 1-2.
4. Brakman, S., Garresten, H. and van Marrewijk, C. (2001) An Introduction to Geographical Economics: Trade, Location and Growth, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
5. Clark, G. L. (1998) 'Stylized facts and close dialogue: methodology in economic geography', Annals of the Association of American Geographers 88: 73-87.
6. Day, M. (2002) 'Competing explanations: exclusion and importance in historical accounts', PhD thesis, Faculty of Philosophy, University of Sheffield.
7. Duranton, G. and Rodriguez-Pose, A. (2005) 'When economists and geographers collide, or the tale of the lions and the butterflies', Environment and Planning A 37(10): 1695-1705.
8. Dymski, G. A. (1996) 'On Krugman's model of economic geography', Geoforum 27: 439-52.
9. Friedman, M. (1974) 'Explanation and scientific understanding', Journal of Philosophy 71: 5-19.
10. Fujita, M. and Thisse, J.-F. (2002) Economics of Agglomeration, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
11. Fujita, M., Krugman, P. and Venables, A. (1999) The Spatial Economy: Cities, Regions and International Trade, Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
12. Garfinkel, A. (1981) Forms of Explanation, New Haven: Yale University Press.
13. Hindriks, F. (2005) 'Unobservability, tractability, and the battle of assumptions', Journal of Economic Methodology 12(3): 383-406.
14. Hoare, T. (1992) 'Review of "Geography and Trade'", Regional Studies 26: 679.
15. Johnston, R. J. (1992) 'Review of Paul Krugman, "Geography and Trade'", Environment and Planning A 24: 1066.
16. Kincaid, H. (1986) 'Reduction, explanation, and individualism', Philosophy of Science 53(4): 492-513.
17. Kitcher, P. (1981) 'Explanatory unification', Philosophy of Science 48: 251-81.
18. Kitcher, P. (1989) 'Explanatory unification and causal structure', Minnesota Studies in the Philosophy of Science 13: 410-505.
19. Krugman, P. (1995) Development, Geography and Economic Theory, Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
20. Krugman, P. (1991a) 'Increasing returns and economic geography', Journal of Political Economy 99: 483-99.
21. Krugman, P. (1991b) Geography and Trade, Cambridge, MA and London: MIT Press: Louvain: Louvain University Press.
22. Lipton, P. (1990) 'Contrastive explanations', in D. Knowles (ed.) Explanation and its Limits, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 247-66.
23. Lipton, P. (1991) Inference to the Best Explanation, London: Routledge. Expanded 2nd edn 2004.
24. Mäki, U. (1992a) Triedman and realism', Research in the History of Economic Thought and Methodology 10: 171-95.
25. Mäki, U. (1992b) 'On the method of isolation in economics', Poznan Studies in the Philosophy of the Sciences and the Humanities 26: 317-51.
26. Mäki, U. (1998) 'Realisticness', in J. Davis, W. Hands and U. Mäki (eds) The Handbook of Economic Methodology, Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.
27. Mäki, U. (2000) 'Kinds of assumptions and their truth: shaking an untwisted Ftwist', Kyklos 53(3): 317-36.
28. Mäki, U. (2004) 'Theoretical isolation and explanatory progress: transaction cost economics and the dynamics of dispute', Cambridge Journal of Economics 28: 319-46.
29. Mäki, U. (2005) 'Models are experiments, experiments are models', Journal of Economic Methodology 12(2): 303-15.
30. Mäki, U. and Marchionni, C. (2005) 'On the structure of explanatory unification: the case of geographical economics', in C. Marchionni 'Unity, plurality and explanation: the case of geographical economics and its neighbours', Academic dissertation, Erasmus Institute for Philosophy and Economics, Erasmus University of Rotterdam, pp. 27-56.
31. Malmberg, M. and Maskell, P. (2002) 'The elusive concept of localization economies: towards a knowledge-based theory of spatial clustering', Environment and Planning A 34: 429-49.
32. Marchionni, C. (2004) 'Geographical economics versus economic geography: towards a clarification of the dispute', Environment and Planning A 36(10): 1737-53.
33. Marchionni, C. and Oinas, P. (2005) 'The many explanations of spatial clustering: rival or complementary?', in C. Marchionni 'Unity, plurality and explanation: the case of geographical economics and its neighbours', Academic dissertation, Erasmus Institute for Philosophy and Economics, Erasmus University of Rotterdam, pp. 87-121.
34. Martin, R. (1999) 'The "new" geographical turn in economics: some critical reflections', Cambridge Journal of Economics 23: 65-91.
35. Mill, J. S. (1843) A System of Logic, vols VII-VIII of the Collected Works, Toronto: Toronto University Press.
36. Morgan, M. (2002) 'Model experiments and models in experiments', in L. Magnani and N. Nersessian (eds) Model-Based Reasoning: Science, Technology, Values, New York: Kluwer Academy/Plenum, pp. 41-58.
37. Morgan, M. (2003) 'Experiments without material intervention: model experiments, virtual experiments and virtually experiments' [University of Amsterdam Research Memorandum (2000)], in H. Radder (ed.) The Philosophy of Scientific Experimentation, Pittsburgh: University of Pittsburgh Press.
38. Morton, A. (1990) 'Mathematical modelling and contrastive explanation', Canadian Journal of Philosophy 16: 251-70.
39. Morton, A. (1993) 'Mathematical models: questions of trustworthiness', British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 44(4): 659-74.
40. Musgrave, A. (1981) '"Unreal assumptions" in economic theory: the F-twist untwisted', Kyklos 34: 377-87.
41. Olsen, J. (2002) 'On the units of geographical economics', Geoforum 33(2): 153-64.
42. Ottaviano, G. (2003) 'Regional policy in the global economy: insights from new economic geography', Regional Studies 37(6&7): 665-73.
43. Ottaviano, G. and Puga, D. (1998) 'Agglomeration in the global economy: a survey of the "new economic geography'", World Economy 21(6): 707-31.
44. Ottaviano, G. and Thisse, J.-F. (2005) 'New economic geography: what about the N?', Environment and Planning A 37(10): 1707-25.
45. Scitovsky, T. (1954) 'Two concepts of external economies', Journal of Political Economy 62: 143-51.
46. Scotchmer, S. and Thisse, J.-F. (1992) 'Space and competition: a puzzle', Annals of Regional Science 26: 269-86.
47. Sjöberg, O. and Sjöholm, F. (2002) 'Common ground? Prospects for integrating the economic geography of geography and economists', Environment and Planning A 34: 467-86.
48. Starrett, D. (1978) 'Market allocations of location choice in a model with free mobility', Journal of Economic Theory 17: 21-37.
49. Woodward, J. (2000) 'Explanation and invariance in the special sciences', British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 51: 197-254.
50. Woodward, J. (2003) Making Things Happen, New York: Oxford University Press.
51. Ylikoski, P. (2001) 'Understanding interests and causal explanation', Academic dissertation, Department of Moral and Social Philosophy, University of Helsinki.