The making of Chumash tradition: Replies to Haley and Wilcoxon

Current Anthropology

Volumn 39, Issue 4, 1998, Pages 477-510

  Erlandson, Jon McVey ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF OREGON   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 33751565921     PISSN: 00113204     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1086/204760     Document Type: Article

References (114)

1. ADAMS, RICHARD N. 1967. Ethics and the social anthropologist in Latin America. American Behavioral Scientist 10(10): 16-21. [BDH, LRW]
2. ALCOTT, RICH. 1987. Old bones, big money. The Independent, March 26, pp. 10 and 13. [BDH, LRW]
3. BENTLEY, G. CARTER. 1987. Ethnicity and practice. Comparative Studies in Society and History 29:24-55. [RW]
4. BILLEY-SEVIDGE, LINDA. 1988. Chumash corrections. Daily Nexus, May 27. [BDH, LRW]
5. BLACKBURN, THOMAS C. 1975. December's child: A book of Chumash oral narratives. Berkeley: University of California Press, [JME]
6. BOROFSKY, ROBERT. 1997. Reply [to comments on Cook, Lono, Obeyesekere, and Sahlins]. CURRENT ANTHROPOLOGY 38: 276-79. [BDH, LRW]
7. BOSCANA, FRAY GERÓNIMO. 1933. Chinigchinich: A revised and annotated version of Alfred Robinson's translation of Father Gerónimo Boscana's historical account of the beliefs, usages, customs, and extravagancies of the Indians of this mission of San Juan Capistrano called the Acagchemem tube. Santa Ana: Fine Arts Press. [EER]
8. BOURDIEU, PIERRE. 1990. The logic of practice. Translated by Richard Nice. Stanford: Stanford University Press. [RW]
9. BRAND, STEWART. 1988. "Indians and the counterculture, 1960S-1970S," in Handbook of North American Indians, vol. 4, History of Indian-White relations. Edited by Wilcomb E. Washburn, pp. 570-72. Washington, D.C.: Smithsonian Institution, [BDH, LRW]
10. BROWN, ALAN K. 1967. The aboriginal population of the Santa Barbara Channel. Reports of the University of California Archaeological Survey 69, [CK]
11. BURNS, MELINDA. 1987a. Chumash protest, but TV film will air. Santa Barbara News-Press, April 25.
12. _, 1987b. $1.1 million paid to Chumash. Santa Barbara News-Press, May 17.
13. _. 1988. Chumash Indian groups debate monitoring of historic sites. Santa Barbara News-Press, January 7.
14. _. 1997a. Front and center: The Environmental Defense Center's 20 years of aggressive advocacy proves that a good offense is often the best defense. Santa Barbara News-Press, October 20. [BDH, LRW]
15. _. 1997b. Chumash site spurs celebration, concern. Santa Barbara News-Press, November 24. [BDH, LRW]
16. _. 1997c. Point of contention. Santa Barbara News-Press, December 26, [BDH, LRW]
17. CASE, WALTER H. 1927. History of Long Beach and vicinity: Chicago. [EER]
18. CASTILLO, EDWARD. 1978. "The impact of Euro-American exploration and settlement," in Handbook of North American Indians, vol. 8, California. Edited by Robert F. Heizer, pp. 99-127. Washington, D.C.: Smithsonian Institution, [JME, BDH, LRW]
19. _. 1994. Gender status decline, resistance, and accommodation among female neophytes in the missions of California: A San Gabriel case study. American Indian Culture and Research Journal 18(1):67-93. [JME]
20. CONKLIN, BETH. 1998. Body paint, feathers, and VCRs: Aesthetics and authenticity in Amazonian activism. American Ethnologist 24:711-37. [BDH, LRW]
21. COOLEY, THEODORE G. 1992. "Observations on hydration measurements of obsidian deriving from buried deposits from site CA-SBA-2028, at Gaviota, Santa Barbara County, California," in Archaeological investigations of some significant sites on the central coast of California. Edited by Herb Dallas Jr. and Gary S. Breschini, pp. 27-37. Coyote Press Archives of California Prehistory 37. [JME]
22. CORNELL, STEPHEN. 1988. The return of the native: American Indian political resurgence. New York: Oxford University Press, [RW]
23. CORWIN, MILES. 1987. Heritage of Indians questioned: Genealogists cast doubt on background of Chumash group. Los Angeles Times, May 26. [BDH, LRW]
24. CRAIG, STEVE, CHESTER KING, AND STAFF OF THE SANTA BARBARA INDIAN CENTER. 1978. The religious and historical significance of the Point Conception-Shisholop area to Native Americans. MS on file in Special Collections, Davidson Library, University of California, Santa Barbara, [BDH, LRW]
25. DALTON, KEITH. 1987. Indian rivalry cited in jury report. Santa Barbara News-Press, March 3. [BDH, LRW]
26. DESCARTES, RENE, 1960 (1637). "Discourse on method," in The European philosophers from Descartes to Nietzsche. Edited by Monroe Beardsley. New York: Modern Library, [RW]
27. DODDS, J. SCOTT, AND LYNNE C. GRAY. 1994. Sacred lands, white man's law. Native American Television, Inc. [EER]
28. DOLGER, JOSEPH. 1929. Antike und Christentum. Vol. 1. Munster: Aschendorffsche Verlagsbuchhandlung, [RW]
29. ERLANDSON, JON M. 1985. Early Holocene settlement and subsistence in relation to coastal paleogeography: Evidence from CA-SBA-1807. Journal of California and Great Basin Anthropology 7:103-9. [JME]
30. _. 1988a. Of millingstones and molluscs: The cultural ecology of Early Holocene hunter-gatherers on the California coast. Ann Arbor: University Microfilms International. [JME]
31. _. 1988b. The role of shellfish in coastal economies: A protein perspective. American Antiquity 53(1):102-9. [JME]
32. 14C record from southern California. Radiocarbon 30:25-39. [JME]
33. _. 1991. "Shellfish and seeds as optimal resources: Early Holocene subsistence on the Santa Barbara coast," in Hunter-gatherers of Early Holocene Coastal California. Edited by J. M. Erlandson and R. H. Colten, pp. 89-100. Los Angeles: Institute of Archaeology, UCLA, [JME]
34. _. 1994. Early hunter-gatherers of the California coast. New York: Plenum Press. [JME]
35. _. 1997. "The Middle Holocene on the western Santa Barbara coast," in Archaeology of the California coast during the Middle Holocene. Edited by Jon M. Erlandson and Michael A. Glassow, pp. 91-109. Perspectives in California Archaeology 4. [JME]
36. ERLANDSON, JON M., AND KEVIN BARTOY. 1995. Cabrillo, the Chumash, and Old World diseases. Journal of California and Great Basin Anthropology 17:153-73. [JME]
37. ERLANDSON, JON, RICHARD CARRICO, ROY DUGGER, LORI SANTORO, GEORGE TOREN, THEODORE COOLEY, AND TIMOTHY HAZELTINE. 1993. Archaeology of the western Santa Barbara coast: Results of the Chevron Point Arguello Project cultural resources program. Santa Barbara: Ogden Environmental and Energy Services Co., Inc. [JME]
38. ERLANDSON, JON, TED COOLEY, AND RICHARD CARRICO. 1987. A fluted projectile point fragment from the Southern California coast: Chronology and context at CA-SBA-1951. Journal of California and Great Basin Anthropology 9:120-28. [JME]
39. ERLANDSON, JON, ROY DUGGER, RICHARD CARRICO, AND THEODORE G. COOLEY. 1992. "Archaeological investigations at CA-SBA-97: A multicomponent coastal site at Gaviota, Santa Barbara County, California," in Archaeological investigations of some significant sites on the central coast of California. Edited by H. Dallas Jr. and G. S. Breschini, pp. 1-32. Coyote Press, Archives of California Prehistory 37. [JME]
40. ERLANDSON, J., D. J. KENNETT, B. L. INGRAM, D. A. GUTHRIE, D. P. MORRIS, M. TVESKOV, G. J. WEST, AND P. WALKER. 1996. An archaeological and paleontological chronology for Daisy Cave (CA-SMI-261), San Miguel Island, California. Radiocarbon 38:355-73.
41. ERLANDSON, JON M., AND TOM ROCKWELL. I987. "Radio-carbon reversals and stratigraphie discontinuities: Natural formation processes in coastal California archaeological sites," in Natural formation processes and the archaeological record. Edited by D. Nash and M. Petraglia, pp. 51-73. British Archaeological Reports International Series 352. [JME]
42. FLYNN, JOHNNY P. 1991. From three worlds to one: An analysis of Chumash religious history. Ph.D. diss., University of California, Santa Barbara, [BDH, LRW]
43. FLYNN, JOHNNY P., AND GARY LADERMAN. 1994. Purgatory and the powerful dead: A case study of Native American repatriation. Religion and American Culture 4(11:51-75. [BDH, LRW]
44. FRIEDMAN, JONATHAN. 1997. Comment on: The making of Chumash tradition, by B. Haley and L. Wilcoxon. CURRENT ANTHROPOLOGY 38778-79.
45. GEERTZ, CLIFFORD. 1973. "Thick description: Toward an interpretive theory of culture," in The interpretation of cultures. New York: Basic Books. [RW]
46. GLASSOW, MICHAEL A. 1997. "Middle Holocene cultural development in the central Santa Barbara Channel region," in Archaeology of the California coast during the Middle Holocene. Edited by J. M. Erlandson and M. A. Glassow, pp. 73-90. Perspectives in California Archaeology 4. [JME]
47. HALEY, BRIAN D. 1996a. "TCP as Bad Anthropology." ACRA-L(http://lists.nonprofit.net/listproc/archives/acra-1/9611/0083.html). [BDH, LRW]
48. _. 1996b. "TCP as Bad Anth - Closure." ACRA-L (http://lists.nonprofit.net/listproc/archives/acra-1/9612/0072.html). [BDH, LRW]
49. HALEY, BRIAN D., AND LARRY R. WILCOXON. 1997. Anthropology and the making of Chumash tradition. CURRENT ANTHROPOLOGY 38:761-94. [JME]
50. HANDLER, RICHARD. 1997. Comment on: Anthropology and the making of Chumash tradition, by B. Haley and L. Wilcoxon. CURRENT ANTHROPOLOGY 38779-80. [JME]
51. HANSON, ALLAN. 1991. Reply to Langdon, Levine, and Linnekin, American Anthropologist 93:449-50. [CW]
52. HARRINGTON, JOHN P. 1933. "Annotations," in Chinigchinich: A revised and annotated version of Alfred Robinson's translation of Father Gerónimo Boscana's historical account of the beliefs, usages, customs, and extravagancies of the Indians of this mission of San Juan Capistrano called the Acagchemem tribe. Santa Ana: Fine Arts Press, [EER]
53. HOOVER, ROBERT L. 1971. Some aspects of Santa Barbara Channel prehistory. Ann Arbor: University Microfilms, [JME]
54. HUDSON, TRAVIS. Editor. 1979. Breath of the sun: Life in early California as told by a Chumash Indian, Fernando Librado to John P. Harrington. Banning: Malki Museum Press. [BDH, LRW]
55. HUDSON, TRAVIS, AND THOMAS C. BLACKBURN, 1979. The material culture of the Chumash interaction sphere. Vol. 1. Food procurement and transportation. Los Altos: Ballena Press/Santa Barbara Museum of Natural History. [JME]
56. _. 1982-87. The material culture of the Chumash interaction sphere. 5 vols. Ballena Press Anthropological Papers 25, 27, 28, 30, and 31. Menlo Park/Santa Barbara: Ballena Press/ Santa Barbara Museum of Natural History. [BDH, LRW]
57. HUDSON, D. TRAVIS, THOMAS BLACKBURN, ROSARIO CURLETTI, AND JANICE TIMBROOK. Editors. 1977. The eye of the flute: Chumash traditional history and ritual as told by Fernando Librado Kitsepawit to John P. Harrington. Santa Barbara: Santa Barbara Museum of Natural History. [CK, BDH, LRW]
58. HUDSON, TRAVIS, JANICE TIMBROOK, AND MELISSA REMPE. 1978. Tomol: Chumash watercraft as described in the ethnographic notes of John P. Harrington. Santa Barbara: Ballena Press/Santa Barbara Museum of Natural History. [JME]
59. JACKSON, ROBERT, AND EDWARD CASTILLO. 1995. Indians. Franciscans, and Spanish colonization: The impact of the mission system on California Indians. Albuquerque: University of New Mexico Press, [BDH, LRW]
60. JOHNSON, JOHN R. 1988. Chumash social organization: An ethnohistoric perspective. Ann Arbor: University Microfilms.
61. _. 1993. "The Chumash Indians after secularization," in The Spanish missionary heritage of the United States. Edited by Howard Benoist and María Carolina Flores, pp. 143-64. San Antonio: National Park Service, [BDH, LRW]
62. KING, CHESTER. 1975. The names and locations of historic Chumash villages (assembled by Thomas Blackburn). Journal of California Anthropology 2:171-79. [CK]
63. _. 1984. "Ethnohistoric background," in Archaeological investigations on the San Antonio Terrace, Vandenberg Air Force Base, California, appendix 1, submitted to the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Los Angeles District. Santa Ana: Chambers Consultants and Planners. [CX, BDH, LRW]
64. _. 1990. Evolution of Chumash society. New York: Garland, [CK, JME]
65. _. 1996. "TCP Surveys." ACRA-L (http://lists.nonprofit.net/ listproc/archives/acra-1/9611/0044.html). [BDH, LRW]
66. KING, CHESTER, AND STEVEN CRAIG. 1978. Cultural resources technical report no. 8 in support of Point Conception LNG project environmental impact report. MS on file at the Archaeological Information Center, Department of Anthropology, University of California, Santa Barbara, [BDH, LRW]
67. KING, CHESTER, ROBERT GIBSON, JACK HUNTER, M. KAY MARTIN, LOIS ROBERTS, AND LARRY WILCOXON. 1985. Union Oil Project/Exxon Project Shamrock and Central Santa Maria Basin Area Study EIS/EIR, Technical Appendix G, Cultural Resources. MS on file at the Archaeological Information Center, Department of Anthropology, University of California, Santa Barbara, [BDH, LRW]
68. KROEBER, ALFRED. 1910. The Chumash and Costanoan languages. University of California Publications in American Archaeology and Ethnology 9:237-72. [BDH, LRW]
69. _. 1953 (1925). Handbook of the Indians of California. Berkeley: University of California Press. [BDH, LRW]
70. LANDBERG, LEIF. 1965. The Chumash Indians of Southern California. Los Angeles: Southwest Museum. [JME]
71. GUIRE, RANDALL H. 1992. Archaeology and the First Americans. American Anthropologist 94:816-36. [EER]
72. LENDON, SALLY, AND JOHN R. JOHNSON. Editors. 1998. Cultural affiliation and lineal descent of Chumash peoples in the Channel Islands and Santa Monica Mountains. Washington, D.C.: Archaeology and Ethnography Program, National Park Service. In press.
73. GOVERN, ERNESTINE. 1988. A Chumash speaks. Daily Nexus, June 20.
74. MARX, KARL. 1972 (1852). Die achtzehnte Brumaire des Louis Bonaparte. (K. Marx and F. Engels, Werke, vol. 8.) Berlin: Dietz Verlag. [RW]
75. MEIGHAN, CLEMENT W. 1992. Some scholar's views on reburial. American Antiquity 57:704-10. [JME]
76. MOORE, JOHN H. 1994. Putting anthropology back together again: The ethnogenetic critique of cladistic theory. American Anthropologist 96:925-48. [BDH, LRW]
77. MOSK, MATTHEW. 1994. Grounds for concern. Los Angeles Times, October 20. [BDH, LRW]
78. NABOKOV, PETER. 1989. Reconstituting the Chumash: A review essay. American Indian Quarterly 13:535-43. [DDW]
79. O'CONNOR, MARY 1. 1989. "Environmental impact review and the construction of contemporary Chumash ethnicity," in Negotiating ethnicity. Edited by Susan Emley Keefe, pp. 9-17. NAPA Bulletin 8. [BDH, LRW]
80. O'MEARA, J. TIMOTHY. 1981. American Indian concerns on Los Padres National Forest. MS on file at Los Padres National Forest Headquarters, Goleta, Calif. [BDH, LRW]
81. OVERBEY, MARY MARGARET. 1994. AAA Statement on Puvungna Community. Anthropology Newsletter 33(2):39. [EER]
82. PARKER, PATRICIA L., AND THOMAS F. KING. 1990. Guidelines for evaluating and documenting traditional cultural properties. National Register Bulletin 38. [JME, BDH, LRW, RW]
83. PRESTON, WILLIAM. 1996. Serpent in Eden: Dispersal of foreign diseases into pre-mission California. Journal of California and Great Basin Anthropology 18(1):2-37. [JME]
84. RAPPAPORT, ROY A. 1992. The human environment: Assessment of the U.S. Outer Continental Shelf Environmental Studies Program, 3, Social and economic studies, appendix B. Washington, D.C.: National Academy Press. [RW]
85. REDFORD, KENT H. 1990. The ecologically noble savage. Orion 9(3):25-29, [BDH, LRW]
86. ROUSSEAU, JEAN-JACQUES. 1967 (1754). "Discourse on the origin and foundation of inequality among mankind," in The social contract and discourse on the origin of inequality. New York: Washington Square Press.
87. RUYLE, EUGENE E. 1993. Lies, bribes, and archaeology. Cross-Roads, no. 36, pp. 21-22. [EER]
88. _. 1994. University officials, Indians at odds over archaeological site. Society for California Archaeology Newsletter 28(2): 17-18. [EER]
89. _. 1995. CSULB lawsuits raise ethical issues for anthropologists. Anthropology Newsletter 36(9):15-16. [EER] San Jose Mercury. 1972a. Indians occupy Jolon Mission. March 17. [BDH, LRW]
90. _. 1972b. Indians demand all mission lands in Jolon Mission occupation. March 18. [BDH, LRW]
91. _. 1972c. Indians to share mission land at Jolon with craft group. March 21. [BDH, LRW]
92. _. 1972d. Jolon Mission Indian occupiers receive eviction notice. March 22. [BDH, LRW]
93. _. 1972e. Indians fire chief in Jolon Mission dispute. March 24. [BDH, LRW]
94. SANTA BARBARA COUNTY GRAND JURY. 1987. Interim report on monitoring of archaeologically sensitive construction sites. Santa Barbara: County of Santa Barbara, [BDH, LRW]
95. SAPIR, EDWARD. 1961. "Culture, genuine and spurious," in Culture, language, and personality: Selected essays. Edited by David G. Mandelbaum. Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press, [RW]
96. SEILER, MICHAEL. 1974. An alternative to the reservation. Los Angeles Times, December 4. [BDH, LRW]
97. _. 1977- Postscript: Indian group builds pride as community rises in brushland, Los Angeles Times, December 5, [BDH, LRW]
98. SINGER, MILTON, 1984. Man's glassy essence: Explorations in semiotic anthropology. Bloomington: Indiana University Press. [RW]
99. SKOMAL, SUSAN N. 1997. Puvungna prevails in round 4. Anthropology Newsletter 38(2):18. [EER]
100. TONKIN, ELIZABETH. 1992. Narrating our pasts: The social construction of oral history. New York: Cambridge University Press. [BDH, LRW]
101. TRIGGER, BRUCE G. 1968a. Beyond history: The methods of prehistory. New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston. [BDH, LRW]
102. _. 1968b. Major concepts of archaeology in historical perspective. Man 3:527-41. [BDH, LRW]
103. _. 1989. Review of: Archaeological approaches to cultural identity, edited by S.J. Shennan (London: Unwin Hyman, 1989). Man 24:687-88. [BDH, LRW]
104. TRIGGER, DAVID S. 1997- Comment on: Anthropology and the making of Chumash tradition, by B. Haley and L. Wilcoxon. CURRENT ANTHROPOLOGY 38786. [BDH, LRW]
105. USDI (U.S. DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR). 1991. How to apply the National Register criteria for evaluation. National Register Bulletin 15. [RW]
106. WAGNER, ROY. 1981. Revised edition. The invention of culture. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. [RW]
107. WALKER, PHILLIP, L., AND TRAVIS HUDSON. 1993. Chumash healing: Changing health and medical practices in an American Indian society. Banning: Malki Museum Press. [JME]
108. WARREN, CLAUDE N., AND DONNA J. HODGE. 1980. Apolonio, the canoe builder, and the use of mission records. Journal of California and Great Basin Anthropology 2:298-304. [BDH, LRW]
109. WILCOXON, LARRY R., REBECCA CONARD, KAY MARTIN, PHYLLIS OLIVERA, AND JULIA G. COSTELLO. 1986. Draft cultural resource technical inventories for the permanent Vista Del Mar School at Las Cruces, Santa Barbara County, California. MS on file, Santa Barbara Museum of Natural History. [JME]
110. WINTHROP, ROBERT H. 1986. Survival and adaptation among the Shasta Indians. U.S. Forest Service, Klamath National Forest, Yreka, Calif. [RW]
111. _. 1990. "Persistent peoples: Mechanisms of cultural survival in southern Oregon and northwestern California," in Living with the land: The Indians of southwest Oregon. Edited by Nan Hannon and Richard K. Olmo. Medford: Southern Oregon Historical Society. [RW]
112. WINTHROP, ROBERT H., AND JOHNSON MENINICK. 1996. Inventory and evaluation of traditional cultural properties associated with the Condit hydroelectric project. Draft. 2 vols. Prepared for PacifiCorp (Portland, Ore.) and Yakama Indian Nation (Toppenish, Wash.). [RW]
113. ZARATE, MICHAEL. 1988. The truth about the Chumash. Daily Nexus, May 25. [BDH, LRW]
114. ZIEGLER, CHRIS. 1988, Non-Chumash group still monitoring sites. Daily Nexus, May 20. [BDH, LRW]