Malingering of PTSD: forensic and diagnostic considerations, characteristics of malingerers and clinical presentations

General Hospital Psychiatry

Volumn 28, Issue 6, 2006, Pages 525-535

  Hall, Ryan C W ^a   Hall, Richard C W ^b  

^a JOHNS HOPKINS HOSPITAL   (United States)

^b UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA   (United States)

Author keywords

Forensic psychiatry; Malingering; MMPI; Posttraumatic stress disorder; PTSD; Trauma

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE; CIVIL DEFENSE; CLINICAL FEATURE; DIAGNOSTIC ERROR; DIFFERENTIAL DIAGNOSIS; DISEASE COURSE; FORENSIC PSYCHIATRY; HUMAN; INDIVIDUALITY; LEGAL ASPECT; MALINGERING; MINNESOTA MULTIPHASIC PERSONALITY INVENTORY; OFFENDER; PERSONALITY TEST; PHYSICIAN; POSTTRAUMATIC STRESS DISORDER; PSYCHIATRIC DIAGNOSIS; PSYCHOLOGIC TEST; PSYCHOTRAUMA; RECALL; SYMPTOM;

DIAGNOSIS, DIFFERENTIAL; FORENSIC PSYCHIATRY; HUMANS; MALINGERING; MMPI; SEVERITY OF ILLNESS INDEX; STRESS DISORDERS, POST-TRAUMATIC;

EID: 33750514391     PISSN: 01638343     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.genhosppsych.2006.08.011     Document Type: Article

References (111)

1. Hausotter W. Expert assessment of railroad accidents at the beginning of the industrial age - a medical historical excursion with reference to current circumstances. Versicherungsmedizin 48 4 (1996) 138-142
2. Hall R.C.W., Hall R.C.W., and Chapman M.J. Definition, diagnosis, and forensic implications of postconcussional syndrome. Psychosomatics 46 3 (2005) 195-202
3. Dembe A. The medical detection of simulated occupational injuries: a historical and social analysis. Int J Health Serv 28 2 (1998) 227-239
4. Sparr L. Legal aspects of posttraumatic stress disorder: uses and abuses. In: Wolf M., and Mosnaim A. (Eds). Posttraumatic stress disorder: etiology, phenomenology, and treatment (1990), APPI, Washington, DC 238-264
5. Adamou M., and Hale A. PTSD and the law of psychiatric injury in England and Wales: finally coming closer?. J Am Acad Psychiatry Law 31 3 (2003) 327-332
6. Thomann K., and Rauschmann M. "Post-traumatic stress disorder" - historical aspects of a "modern" psychiatric illness in the German language areas. Medizinhist J 38 2 (2003) 103-138
7. Thomann K., and Rauschmann M. Whiplash injury and "railway spine". Versicherungsmedizin 56 3 (2004) 131-135
8. Resnick P. Guidelines for the evaluation of malingering in posttraumatic stress disorder. In: Simon R. (Ed). Posttraumatic stress disorder in litigation: guidelines for forensic assessment (1995), APPI, Washington, DC 117-134
9. McHugh P, Treisman G. PTSD: a problematic diagnostic category. J Anxiety Disord [in press].
10. McNally R. Progress and controversy in the study of posttraumatic stress disorder. Annu Rev Psychol 54 (2003) 229-252
11. Appelbaum P., Jick R., Grisso T., et al. Use of posttraumatic stress disorder to support an insanity defense. Am J Psychiatry 150 2 (1993) 229-234
12. Resnick P. Malingering of posttraumatic disorders. In: Rogers R. (Ed). Clinical assessment of malingering and deception. 2nd ed. (1997), Guilford Press, New York 130-152
13. Wilson J. The historical evolution of PTSD diagnostic criteria: from Freud to DSM-IV. J Trauma Stress 7 4 (1994) 681-698
14. Brady K., Killeen T., Brewerton T., and Lucerini S. Comorbidity of psychiatric disorders and posttraumatic stress disorder. J Clin Psychiatry 61 Suppl. 7 (2000) 22-32
15. Guriel J., and Fremouw W. Assessing malingered posttraumatic stress disorder: a critical review. Clin Psychol Rev 23 7 (2003) 881-904
16. McGrath J., and Frueh B. Fraudulent claims of combat status in the VA?. Psychiatr Serv 53 3 (2002) 345
17. Frueh B., Elhai J., Grubaugh A., et al. Documented combat exposure of US veterans seeking treatment for combat-related post-traumatic stress disorder. Br J Psychiatry 186 (2005) 467-472 [discussion, 473-5]
18. Associated Press. FBI: medal of honor fakers outnumber true heroes. http://www.cnn.com/2006/us/04/30/medal.of.honor.ap/index.html [Accessed April 30, 2006]
19. Sparr L., and Pankratz L. Factitious posttraumatic stress disorder. Am J Psychiatry 140 8 (1983) 1016-1019
20. Lynn E., and Belza M. Factitious posttraumatic stress disorder: the veteran who never got to Vietnam. Hosp Community Psychiatry 35 7 (1984) 697-701
21. Rosen G.M. DSM's cautionary guideline to rule out malingering can protect the PTSD database. J Anxiety Disord 20 4 (2006) 530-535
22. Rosen G.M. Posttraumatic stress disorder, pulp fiction, and the press. Bull Am Acad Psychiatry Law 24 2 (1996) 267-269
23. Gorman W. Defining malingering. J Forensic Sci 27 2 (1982) 401-407
24. Wiley S. Deception and detection in psychiatric diagnosis. Psychiatr Clin North Am 21 4 (1998) 869-893
25. Resnick P. The detection of malingered psychosis. Psychiatr Clin North Am 22 1 (1999) 159-172
26. Nies K., and Sweet J. Neuropsychological assessment and malingering: a critical review of past and present strategies. Arch Clin Neuropsychol 9 6 (1994) 501-552
27. American Psychiatric Association. In: First M. (Ed). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders. 4th ed. (2000), APPI, Washington, DC 463-468 [Text revision]
28. Cunnien A. Psychiatric and medical syndromes associated with deception. In: Rogers R. (Ed). Clinical assessment of malingering and deception. 2nd ed. (1997), Guilford Press, New York 23-46
29. Greve K., and Bianchini K. Response to Butcher et al., the construct validity of the Lees-Haley Fake-Bad Scale. Arch Clin Neuropsychol 19 3 (2004) 337-339 [author reply, 341-5]
30. Spivak H., Rodin G., and Sutherland A. The psychology of factitious disorders: a reconsideration. Psychosomatics 35 1 (1994) 25-34
31. In: Hall H., and Pritchard P. (Eds). Detecting malingering and deception: forensic distortion analysis (1996), St. Lucie Press, Delray Beach (FL) 103-121
32. Pathe M., Mullen P., and Purcell R. Stalking: false claims of victimization. Br J Psychiatry 174 (1999) 170-172
33. Jones I., and Riley W. The post-accident syndrome: variations in the clinical picture. Aust N Z J Psychiatry 21 4 (1987) 560-567
34. Lambert M., and Bonner J. Characteristics and six-month outcome of patients who use suicide threats to seek hospital admission. Psychiatr Serv 47 8 (1996) 871-873
35. Kleinman S., and Stewart L. Psychiatric-legal considerations in providing mental health assistance to disaster survivors. Psychiatr Clin North Am 27 3 (2004) 559-570
36. Sparr L.F., and Atkinson R.M. Post-traumatic stress disorder as an insanity defense: medicolegal quicksand. Am J Psychiatry 143 5 (1986) 608-613
37. Sparr L. Mental defenses and posttraumatic stress disorder: assessment of criminal intent. J Trauma Stress 9 3 (1996) 405-425
38. Walker J. Viet Nam combat veterans with legal difficulties: a psychiatric problem?. Am J Psychiatry 138 10 (1981) 1384-1385
39. Edwards C. Behavior and the law reconsidered: psychological syndromes and profiles. J Forensic Sci 43 1 (1998) 141-150
40. Silva J.A., Leong G.B., Harry B.E., Ronan J., and Weinstock R. Dangerous misidentification of people due to flashback phenomena in posttraumatic stress disorder. J Forensic Sci 43 6 (1998) 1107-1111
41. Koch W., O'Neill M., and Douglas K. Empirical limits for the forensic assessment of PTSD litigants. Law Hum Behav 29 1 (2005) 121-149
42. Lubit R., Hartwell N., van Gorp W., and Eth S. Forensic evaluation of trauma syndromes in children. Child Adolesc Psychiatr Clin N Am 11 4 (2002) 823-857
43. Rosen G., and Powel J. Use of a Symptom Validity Test in the forensic assessment of posttraumatic stress disorder. J Anxiety Disord 17 3 (2003) 361-367
44. Kato M. On the problems of diagnosis of PTSD and its legal management. Seishin Shinkeigaku Zasshi 04 12 (2002) 1175-1179
45. Tennant C. Psychological trauma: psychiatry and the law in conflict. Aust N Z J Psychiatry 38 5 (2004) 344-347
46. Breslau N., and Kessler R. The stressor criterion in DSM-IV posttraumatic stress disorder: an empirical investigation. Biol Psychiatry 50 9 (2001) 699-704
47. Ahern J., Galea S., Resnick H., and Vlahov D. Television images and probable posttraumatic stress disorder after September 11: the role of background characteristics, event exposures, and perievent panic. J Nerv Ment Dis 192 3 (2004) 217-226
48. Elhai J., Kashdan T., and Frueh B. What is a traumatic event?. Br J Psychiatry 187 (2005) 189-190
49. Zyss T. A few remarks on the so-called war pension. Arch Med Sandowej Kryminol 55 4 (2005) 328-337
50. American Psychiatric Association. In: Spitzer R.L. (Ed). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders. 3rd ed. (1980), APPI, Washington, DC 238
51. Jones E., Vermaas R., McCartney H., et al. Flashbacks and post-traumatic stress disorder: the genesis of a 20th-century diagnosis. Br J Psychiatry 182 (2003) 158-163
52. Frankel F. The concept of flashbacks in historical perspective. Int J Clin Exp Hypn 42 4 (1994) 321-336
53. Hall R., Hall R., and Chapman M. Effects of terrorist attacks on the elderly: Part 2. Posttraumatic stress, acute stress, and affective disorders. Clin Geriatr 14 (2006) 17-24
54. Geraerts E, Kozaric-Kovacic D, Merckelbach H, et al. Traumatic memories of war veterans: not so special after all. Conscious Cogn [in press]. Electronic publication ahead of print, April 2006.
55. Basoglu M., Salcioglu E., and Livanou M. Traumatic stress responses in earthquake survivors in Turkey. J Trauma Stress 15 4 (2002) 269-276
56. Merckelbach H., Dekkers T., Wessel I., and Roefs A. Amnesia, flashbacks, nightmares, and dissociation in aging concentration camp survivors. Behav Res Ther 41 3 (2003) 351-360
57. Roszell D., McFall M., and Malas K. Frequency of symptoms and concurrent psychiatric disorder in Vietnam veterans with chronic PTSD. Hosp Community Psychiatry 42 3 (1991) 293-296
58. Kozaric-Kovacic D., and Borovecki A. Prevalence of psychotic comorbidity in combat-related post-traumatic stress disorder. Mil Med 170 3 (2005) 223-226
59. Kessler R., Sonnega A., Bromet E., Hughes M., and Nelson C.B. Posttraumatic stress disorder in the National Comorbidity Survey. Arch Gen Psychiatry 52 12 (1995) 1048-1060
60. Brady K. Posttraumatic stress disorder and comorbidity: recognizing the many faces of PTSD. J Clin Psychiatry 58 Suppl 9 (1997) 12-15
61. Skodol A., Schwartz S., Dohrenwend B., et al. PTSD symptoms and comorbid mental disorders in Israeli war veterans. Br J Psychiatry 169 6 (1996) 717-725
62. Rosen J., Fields R., Hand A., Falsettie G., and Van Kammen D. Concurrent posttraumatic stress disorder in psychogeriatric patients. J Geriatr Psychiatry Neurol 2 2 (1989) 65-69
63. Brunello N., Davidson J., Deahl M., et al. Posttraumatic stress disorder: diagnosis and epidemiology, comorbidity and social consequences, biology and treatment. Neuropsychobiology 43 3 (2001) 150-162
64. Sparr L. Post-traumatic stress disorder. Does it exist?. Neurol Clin 13 2 (1995) 413-429
65. Franklin C., Repasky S., Thompson K., Shelton S., and Uddo M. Differentiating overreporting and extreme distress: MMPI-2 use with compensation-seeking veterans with PTSD. J Pers Assess 79 2 (2002) 274-285
66. Lees-Haley P., and Fox D. Commentary on Butcher, Arbisi, Atlis, and McNulty (2003) on the Fake Bad Scale. Arch Clin Neuropsychol 19 3 (2004) 333-336 [author reply, 341-5]
67. Miller L. Not just malingering: syndrome diagnosis in traumatic brain injury litigation. NeuroRehabilitation 16 2 (2001) 109-122
68. Elhai J., and Frueh B. Subtypes of clinical presentations in malingerers of posttraumatic stress disorder: an MMPI-2 cluster analysis. Assessment 8 1 (2001) 75-84
69. Hyer L., Fallon J., Harrison W., and Boudewyns P. MMPI overreporting by Vietnam combat veterans. J Clin Psychol 43 1 (1987) 79-83
70. Hyer L., Boudewyns P., Harrison W., et al. Vietnam veterans: overreporting versus acceptable reporting of symptoms. J Pers Assess 52 3 (1988) 475-486
71. Frueh B., Hamner M., Cahill S., Gold P., and Hamlin K. Apparent symptom overreporting among combat veterans evaluated for PTSD. Clin Psychol Rev 20 7 (2000) 853-885
72. Resnick P. Defrocking the fraud: the detection of malingering. Isr J Psychiatry Relat Sci 30 2 (1993) 93-101
73. Watson I. Flashbacks in war veterans. Br J Psychiatry 184 (2004) 185
74. Cima M., Nijman H., Merckelbach H., Kremer K., and Hollnack S. Claims of crime-related amnesia in forensic patients. Int J Law Psychiatry 27 3 (2004) 215-221
75. Hambridge D. Flashbacks and PTSD. Br J Psychiatry 183 (2003) 76 [author reply, 76-7]
76. Hellawell S., and Brewin C. A comparison of flashbacks and ordinary autobiographical memories of trauma: content and language. Behav Res Ther 42 1 (2004) 1-12
77. Ross R., Ball W., Sullivan K., and Caroff S. Sleep disturbance as the hallmark of posttraumatic stress disorder. Am J Psychiatry 146 6 (1989) 697-707
78. Pillar G., Malhotra A., and Lavie P. Post-traumatic stress disorder and sleep - what a nightmare!. Sleep Med Rev 4 2 (2000) 183-200
79. Rothbaum B., and Mellman T. Dreams and exposure therapy in PTSD. J Trauma Stress 14 3 (2001) 481-490
80. Schreuder B., Kleijn W., and Rooijmans H. Nocturnal re-experiencing more than forty years after war trauma. J Trauma Stress 13 3 (2000) 453-463
81. Esposito K., Benitez A., Barza L., and Mellman T. Evaluation of dream content in combat-related PTSD. J Trauma Stress 12 4 (1999) 681-687
82. van der Kolk B., Blitz R., Burr W., Sherry S., and Hartmann E. Nightmares and trauma: a comparison of nightmares after combat with lifelong nightmares in veterans. Am J Psychiatry 141 2 (1984) 187-190
83. Zervas I., and Soldatos C. Nightmares: personality dimensions and psychopathological attributes. Int Rev Psychiatry 17 4 (2005) 271-276
84. Kuch K., and Cox B.J. Symptoms of PTSD in 124 survivors of the Holocaust. Am J Psychiatry 149 3 (1992) 337-340
85. Merckelbach H., Dekkers T., Wessel I., and Roefs A. Dissociative symptoms and amnesia in Dutch concentration camp survivors. Compr Psychiatry 44 1 (2003) 65-69
86. Merckelbach H., and Muris P. The causal link between self-reported trauma and dissociation: a critical review. Behav Res Ther 39 3 (2001) 245-254
87. Bremner J., Steinberg M., Southwick S., Johnson D., and Charney D. Use of the structured clinical interview for DSM-IV dissociative disorders for systematic assessment of dissociative symptoms in posttraumatic stress disorder. Am J Psychiatry 150 7 (1993) 1011-1014
88. Bremner J., Southwick S., Brett E., et al. Dissociation and posttraumatic stress disorder in Vietnam combat veterans. Am J Psychiatry 149 3 (1992) 328-332
89. McNally R. Is traumatic amnesia nothing but psychiatric folklore?. Cogn Behav Ther 33 2 (2004) 97-101
90. Pope Jr. H., Barry S., Bodkin A., and Hudson J. Tracking scientific interest in the dissociative disorders: a study of scientific publication output 1984-2003. Psychother Psychosom 75 1 (2006) 19-24
91. Ross C., Joshi S., and Currie R. Dissociative experiences in the general population: a factor analysis. Hosp Community Psychiatry 42 3 (1991) 297-301
92. Sparr L.F., and Bremner J.D. Post-traumatic stress disorder and memory: prescient medicolegal testimony at the International War Crimes Tribunal?. J Am Acad Psychiatry Law 33 1 (2005) 71-78
93. Resnick P. The detection of malingered mental illness. Presented at the American Psychiatric Association's 159th Annual Meeting, Toronto Canada, May 23 (2006)
94. Scheibe S., Bagby R., Miller L., and Dorian B. Assessing posttraumatic stress disorder with the MMPI-2 in a sample of workplace accident victims. Psychol Assess 13 3 (2001) 369-374
95. Elhai J., Gold S., Sellers A., and Dorfman W. The detection of malingered posttraumatic stress disorder with MMPI-2 fake bad indices. Assessment 8 2 (2001) 221-236
96. Fairbank J., McCaffrey R., and Keane T. Psychometric detection of fabricated symptoms of posttraumatic stress disorder. Am J Psychiatry 142 4 (1985) 501-503
97. Elhai J., Naifeh J., Zucker I., et al. Discriminating malingered from genuine civilian posttraumatic stress disorder: a validation of three MMPI-2 infrequency scales (F, Fp, and Fptsd). Assessment 11 2 (2004) 139-144
98. Elhai J., Ruggiero K., Frueh B., et al. The infrequency-posttraumatic stress disorder scale (Fptsd) for the MMPI-2: development and initial validation with veterans presenting with combat-related PTSD. J Pers Assess 79 3 (2002) 531-549
99. McCaffrey R., and Bellamy-Campbell R. Psychometric detection of fabricated symptoms of combat-related post-traumatic stress disorder: a systematic replication. J Clin Psychol 45 1 (1989) 76-79
100. Lees-Haley P. Efficacy of MMPI-2 validity scales and MCMI-II modifier scales for detecting spurious PTSD claims: F, F-K, Fake Bad Scale, ego strength, subtle-obvious subscales, DIS, and DEB. J Clin Psychol 48 5 (1992) 681-689
101. Elhai J., Gold P., Frueh B., and Gold S. Cross-validation of the MMPI-2 in detecting malingered posttraumatic stress disorder. J Pers Assess 75 3 (2000) 449-463
102. Munley P., Bains D., Bloem W., and Busby R. Post-traumatic stress disorder and the MMPI-2. J Trauma Stress 8 1 (1995) 171-178
103. Bagby R., Nicholson R., and Buis T. Utility of the deceptive-subtle items in the detection of malingering. J Pers Assess 70 3 (1998) 405-415
104. Perconte S., and Goreczny A. Failure to detect fabricated posttraumatic stress disorder with the use of the MMPI in a clinical population. Am J Psychiatry 147 8 (1990) 1057-1060
105. Rogers R., Sewell K., Martin M., and Vitacco M. Detection of feigned mental disorders: a meta-analysis of the MMPI-2 and malingering. Assessment 10 2 (2003) 160-177
106. Orr S.P., and Pitman R.K. Psychophysiologic assessment of attempts to simulate posttraumatic stress disorder. Biol Psychiatry 33 2 (1993) 127-129
107. Keane T., Kolb L., Kaloupek D., et al. Utility of psychophysiological measurement in the diagnosis of posttraumatic stress disorder: results from a Department of Veterans Affairs Cooperative Study. J Consult Clin Psychol 66 6 (1998) 914-923
108. Morgan III C.A., Wang S., Rasmusson A., et al. Relationship among plasma cortisol, catecholamines, neuropeptide Y, and human performance during exposure to uncontrollable stress. Psychosom Med 63 3 (2001) 412-422
109. Morgan III C.A., Rasmusson A.M., Wang S., et al. Neuropeptide-Y, cortisol, and subjective distress in humans exposed to acute stress: replication and extension of previous report. Biol Psychiatry 52 2 (2002) 136-142
110. Liberzon I., and Martis B. Neuroimaging studies of emotional responses in PTSD. Ann N Y Acad Sci 1071 (2006) 87-109
111. Rauch S., Shin L., and Phelps E. Neurocircuitry models of posttraumatic stress disorder and extinction: human neuroimaging research - past, present, and future. Biol Psychiatry 60 4 (2006) 376-382