Problems with Peirce's concept of abduction

Foundations of Science

Volumn 4, Issue 3, 1999, Pages 271-305

  Hoffmann, Michael ^a  

^a BIELEFELD UNIVERSITY   (Germany)

Author keywords

Abduction; Instincts; Peirce; Perception; Theorematic reasoning

Indexed keywords

EID: 33750187849     PISSN: 12331821     EISSN: 15728471     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1023/A:1009675824079     Document Type: Article

References (96)

1. A. Aliseda: 1998, Abduction as Epistemic Change: Charles S. Peirce and Epistemic Theories in Artificial Intelligence. Online: http://www.rz. unifrankfurt.de/~wirth/tt (spanish version in Analogia Filosòfica 12(1): 125-144).
2. D.R. Anderson: 1986, Creativity and the Philosophy of Charles S. Peirce. University Microfilms International, Ann Arbor, Michigan.
3. E.J. Crombie: 1997, What is Deduction? In N. Houser, D.D. Roberts and J. van Evra (eds.), Studies in the Logic of Charles Sanders Peirce. Indiana University Press, Bloomington and Indianapolis, pp. 460-476.
4. R.R. Dipert: 1995, Peirce's Underestimated Place in the History of Logic: A Response to Quine. In K.L. Ketner (ed.), Peirce and Contemporary Thought. Philosophical Inquiries. Fordham Univ. Press, New York, pp. 32-58.
5. C. Eisele: 1982, Mathematical Methodology in the Thought of Charles S. Peirce. Historia Mathematica 9: 333-341.
6. Y. Engeström: 1987, Learning by Expanding. An Activity-Theoretical Approach to Developmental Research. Orienta-Konsultit Oy, Helsinki.
7. K.T. Fann: 1970, Peirce's Theory of Abduction. Nijhoff, The Hague.
8. H. Frankfurt: 1958, Peirce's Notion of Abduction. The Journal of Philosophy 55: 593-597.
9. N. Goodman: 1983 [1954], Fact, Fiction, and Forecast, 4th edn. Harvard University Press, Cambridge/MA, London.
10. E.M. Hammer: 1996, Charles S. Peirce's Logic. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy: http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/peirce-logic/.
11. J.F. Harris and K. Hoover: 1983 [1980], Abduction and the New Riddle of Induction. In E. Freeman (ed.), The Relevance of Charles Peirce. Hegeler Institut (first published in The Monist 63: 329-341), La Salle, IL, pp. 132-144.
12. J.v. Heijenoort: 1967, Logic as Calculus and Logic as Language. Synthese 17: pp. 324-330.
13. J. Hintikka: 1983 [1980], C.S. Peirce's 'First Real Discovery' and Its Contemporary Relevance. In E. Freeman (ed.), The Relevance of Charles Peirce. Hegeler Institut, La Salle, IL, pp. 107-118.
14. J. Hintikka: 1997a, Lingua Universalis vs. Calculus Ratiocinator: An Ultimate Presupposition of Twentieth-Century Philosophy (selected papers 2). Kluwer, Dordrecht et al.
15. J. Hintikka: 1997b, On Creativity in Reasoning. In Å.E. Andersson and N.-E. Sahlin (eds.), The Complexity of Creativity. Kluwer, Dordrecht et al., pp. 67-78.
16. J. Hintikka: 1997c, The Place of C.S. Peirce in the History of Logical Theory. In J. Brunning and P. Forster (eds.), The Rule of Reason. The Philosophy of Charles S. Peirce. University of Toronto Press, Toronto, Buffalo, London, pp. 13-33.
17. N. Houser: 1997, Introduction: Peirce as Logician. In N. Houser, D.D. Roberts and J. van Evra (eds.), Studies in the Logic of Charles Sanders Peirce. Indiana University Press, Bloomington and Indianapolis, pp. 1-22.
18. N. Houser, D.D. Roberts and J. van Evra (eds.): 1997, Studies in the Logic of Charles Sanders Peirce. Indiana University Press, Bloomington and Indianapolis.
19. T. Kapitan: 1990, In What Way is Abductive Inference Creative? Transactions of the Charles S. Peirce Society 26: 499-512.
20. T. Kapitan: 1992, Peirce and the Autonomy of Abductive Reasoning. Erkenntnis 37: 1-26.
21. T. Kapitan: 1997, Peirce and the Structure of Abductive Inference. In N. Houser, D.D. Roberts and J. van Evra (eds.), Studies in the Logic of Charles Sanders Peirce. Indiana University Press, Bloomington and Indianapolis, pp. 477-496.
22. B.M. Kedrov: 1966-67 [1957], On the Question of the Psychology of Scientific Creativity (On the Occasion of the Discovery by D.I. Mendeleev of the Periodic Law). Soviet Psychology V/2: 18-37.
23. U. Kelle: 1994, Empirisch begründete Theoriebildung: Zur Logik und Methodologie interpretativer Sozialforschung (status passages and the life course 6). Dt. Studien-Verl., Weinheim.
24. K.L. Ketner: 1985, How Hintikka Misunderstood Peirce's Account of Theorematic Reasoning. Transactions of the Charles S. Peirce Society 21: 407-418.
25. S.A. Kleiner: 1983, A New Look at Kepler and Abductive Argument. Studies in the History and Philosophy of Science 14: 279-314.
26. Landesinstitut (ed.): 1994, Trends und Zusammenhänge. Materialien zur Explorativen Datenanalyse und Statistik in der Schule (Interaktive Medien im Unterricht). Landesinstitut für Schule und Weiterbildung, Paradieser Weg 64, D-59494 Soest.
27. I. Levi: 1997, Inference and Logic According to Peirce. In J. Brunning and P. Forster (eds.), The Rule of Reason. The Philosophy of Charles S. Peirce. University of Toronto Press, Toronto, Buffalo, London, pp. 34-56.
28. S.H. Levy: 1997, Peirce's Theoremic/Corollarial Distinction and the Interconnections Between Mathematics and Logic. In N. Houser, D.D. Roberts and J. van Evra (eds.), Studies in the Logic of Charles Sanders Peirce. Indiana University Press, Bloomington and Indianapolis, pp. 85-110.
29. M. Otte: 1998a, Mathematik in der Philosophie I. Naturalisierte Erkenntnistheorie. Arbeiten aus dem Institut für Didaktik der Mathematik der Universität Bielefeld, Occasional Paper 170.
30. M. Otte: 1998b, Proof and perception II. Preuve Proof Prueba. Web Newsletter Juillet/Août 1998: Online: http://www-cabri.imag.fr/Preuve/ Newsletter/980708.html.
31. Peirce: CCL, 1992, The Cambridge Conferences Lectures of 1898. In K.L. Ketner (ed.), Ch. S. Peirce, Reasoning and the Logic of Things. Harvard UP, Cambridge/London.
32. Peirce: CP, Collected Papers of Charles Sanders Peirce (Volumes I-VI, ed. by Charles Hartshorne and Paul Weiss, 1931-1935, Volumes VII-VIII, ed. by Arthur W. Burks, 1958, quotations according to volume and paragraph). Harvard UP, Cambridge, MA.
33. Peirce: EP, 1992 + 1998, The Essential Peirce. Selected Philosophical Writings, Vol. I (1867-1893), Vol. II (1893-1913) (ed. by Nathan Houser and Christian Kloesel, Peirce Edition Project). Indiana University Press, Bloomingtion and Indianapolis.
34. Peirce: HLP, 1997, Pragmatism as a Principle and Method of Right Thinking, by Charles Sanders Peirce (The 1903 Harvard Lectures on Pragmatism. Edited and Introduced, with a Commentary by Patricia Ann Turrisi). State University of New York Press, Albany, NY.
35. Peirce: L, Letter (numbered according to Richard S. Robin, Annotated Catalogue of the Papers of Charles S. Peirce. Worcester, MA, 1967: The University of Massachusetts Press). Available in the Peirce Microfilm edition. Pagination: CSP = Peirce/ISP = Institute for Studies in Pragmaticism.
36. Peirce: LOS, 1986, Historical Perspectives on Peirce's Logic of Science: A History of Science, 2 vols. (ed. by Carolyn Eisele). Mouton, Berlin.
37. Peirce: Microfilms, The Charles S. Peirce Papers. Houghton Library, Harvard University, Cambridge, MA.
38. Peirce: MS, The Charles S. Peirce Papers. Manuscript Collection in the Houghton Library, Harvard University (numbered according to Richard S. Robin, Annotated Catalogue of the Papers of Charles S. Peirce. Worcester, MA, 1967: The University of Massachusetts Press). Available in the Peirce Microfilm edition. Pagination: CSP = Peirce/ISP = Institute for Studies in Pragmaticism.
39. Peirce: NEM, 1976, The New Elements of Mathematics by Charles S. Peirce, Vol. I-IV (ed. by Carolyn Eisele). Mouton/Humanities Press, The Hague-Paris/Atlantic Highlands, N.J.
40. Peirce: P, 1986, Published Works (numbered according to: A Comprehensive Bibliography of the Published Works of Charles Sanders Peirce with a Bibliography of Secondary Studies, 2nd. edn. (ed. by Kenneth L. Ketner)). Philosophy Documentation Center, Bowling Green, Ohio.
41. Peirce: S&S, 1977, Semiotic and Significs. The Correspondence between Charles S. Peirce and Victoria Lady Welby (ed. by Charles S. Hardwick). Indiana University Press, Bloomington and London.
42. Peirce: 1986-1994, SEM, Charles S. Peirce, Semiotische Schriften, Vol. I-III (German ed. by Chr. Kloesel and H. Pape). Suhrkamp, Frankfurt a.M.
43. Peirce: 1982ff., W, Writings of Charles S. Peirce. A Chronological Edition, Vol. 1- ...Indiana University Press, Bloomington.
44. C.S. Peirce: 1878, Deduction, Induction, and Hypothesis. P 123: Popular Science Monthly 13: 470-482; EP I: 186-199;W 3: 323-338; CP 2.619-644.
45. C.S. Peirce: 1882, Introductory Lecture on the Study of Logic. P 225: Johns Hopkins University Circulars 2(19): 11-12; EP I: 210-214;W 4: 378-382; CP 7.59-76.
46. C.S. Peirce: 1885, On the Algebra of Logic: A Contribution to the Philosophy of Notation. P 296: American Journal of Mathematics 7: 180-202; in part in EP I: 225-228; W 5: 162-190 (with related MSS 506-508 at: 538-539); CP 3.359-403.
47. C.S. Peirce: 1887, Logical Machines. Modern Logic 7 (1997): 71-77;
48. repr. from American Journal of Psychology 1: 165-170; NEM III: 625-632.
49. C.S. Peirce: 1891, Review of William James's The Principles of Psychology (1890). The Nation 53 (2 July 1891) 15;
50. The Nation 53 (9 July 1891): 32-33; CP 8.55-61, CP 8.62-71.
51. C.S. Peirce: 1892, The Law of Mind. P: 477: The Monist 2: 533-559; EP I: 312-333; CP 6.102-163.
52. C.S. Peirce: 1895, Short Logic: Of Reasoning in General. MS 595; EP II: 11-26; in part in CP 2.286-291 (CSP 6-13); 2.295-296 (CSP 14-16); 2.435-443 (CSP 23-29, with the omission of p. 25); 7.555-558 (CSP 29-32).
53. C.S. Peirce: 1896, ca., The Logic of Mathematics; an Attempt to Develop my Categories from within. CP 1.417-520.
54. C.S. Peirce: 1897, Multitude and Number. CP 4.170-226.
55. C.S. Peirce: 1897, ca., That Categorical and Hypothetical Propositions Are One in Essence, with Some Connected Matters (Date according Pape in SEM; CP and Robin: 1895).MS 787; MS 787 (s) are the missing pages 6-7, and MS 812 the missing pages 8-9; SEM I: 230-268; in part in CP 2.332-339, 2.278-280, 1.564-567 (c.1899), 2.340-356. See MSS 804, 805, and pp. 23, 30-32, 38 in MS 595 for rejected pages of MS 787.
56. C.S. Peirce: 1898, The Cambridge Conferences Lectures of 1898. CCL; lect. I = MS 437 = EP II: 27-41 = CP 1.616-648 (in part); lect. IV = MS 442 + 825 = EP II: 42-56 = CP 5.574-89, 7.135-40 and 1.135-40 (in part); lect. VIII = MS 948 = NEM III: 101-115 = CP 6.185-213 (in part).
57. C.S. Peirce: 1898, ca., Habit. MS 951; CP 7.468-517.
58. C.S. Peirce: 1899, ca.-a, How Did Science Originate? MS 1292; LOS: 1122-1124.
59. C.S. Peirce: 1899, ca.-b, On Topical Geometry, in General. MS 141; CP 7.524-538 (in part).
60. C.S. Peirce: 1901a, Letter to "My dear Prof. Langley" (20.5.1901[?]). L 409, ISP 72-81.
61. C.S. Peirce: 1901b, On the Logic of Drawing History from Ancient Documents Especially from Testimonies. MS 690; LOS: 705-800; in part in EP II: 75-114 and in CP 7.162-255.
62. C.S. Peirce: 1901c, The Proper Treatment of Hypotheses: A Preliminary Chapter, toward an Examination of Hume's Argument against Miracles, in its Logic and in its History. MS 692; LOS: 890-904.
63. C.S. Peirce: 1901-2/1911, Reasoning. Baldwin's Dictionary II: 426-428, CP 2.773-778.
64. C.S. Peirce: 1902a, The Carnegie Application. L 75; NEM IV: 13-73; LOS: 1022-1041; Arisbe homepage: http://www.door.net/arisbe/menu/library/bycsp/L75/ L75.htm.
65. C.S. Peirce: 1902b, Minute Logic I: Intended Characters of this Treatise. MS 425; CP 2.1-118; in part in SEM I: 377-408.
66. C.S. Peirce: 1902c, Minute Logic III: The Simplest Mathematics §1: The Essence of Mathematics. MS 429; CP 4.227-244.
67. C.S. Peirce: 1902-3, Minute Logic IV [a digression]. CP 6.349-352.
68. C.S. Peirce: 1903a, Lectures on Pragmatism [held from March, 26. to May, 14. at Harvard University]. MSS 300-316; EP II: 133-241; HLP; CP 5.14-212; in part in SEM I: 431-462.
69. C.S. Peirce: 1903b, Logical Tracts. No. 2. On Existential Graphs, Euler's Diagrams, and Logical Algebra. MS 492; SEM II: 98-126; CP 4.418-509 (in part).
70. C.S. Peirce: 1903c, On Some Topics of Logic (Lowell Lectures: Syllabus). MS 478. Parts published in "A Syllabus of Certain Topics of Logic" by Alfred Mudge & Son (Boston); CP 1.180-202, 2.219-226, 2.274-277, 2.283-284, 2.292-294, 2.309-331, 4.394-417.
71. C.S. Peirce: 1903-04, Lowell Lectures on Logic. MSS 447-478. Parts published in NEM III(1): 331-426; CP 1.15-26, 1.611-615, 4.510-529, 5.590-604, 6.88-97, 7.110-130, 7.182n7, 8.176; LOS: 1011-1021; SEM II: 127-165.
72. C.S. Peirce: 1903, ca.-a, Nomenclature and Division of Triadic Relations, as far as They Are Determined (a manuscript continuation of the "Syllabus"). MS 540. In part in CP 2.233-272.
73. C.S. Peirce: 1903, ca.-b, Sketch of Dichotomic Mathematics. MS 4; NEM IV: 285-300.
74. C.S. Peirce: 1905a, [Draft for a letter to Lady Welby, July 16, 1905]. In part in S&S, p. 187.
75. C.S. Peirce: 1905b, What Pragmatism Is. The Monist 15: 161-181; CP 5.411-437.
76. C.S. Peirce: 1905, ca., [Letter] To Signor Calderoni, on Pragmaticism. CP 8.205-213.
77. C.S. Peirce: 1907a, Pragmatism. MS 318. Parts published in CP 1.560-562, 5.11-13, 5.464-496; SEM III: 234-311.
78. C.S. Peirce: 1907b, Second Talk to the Phil. Club [and] Second Talk. On Deduction. MS 754.
79. C.S. Peirce: 1907, ca., Guessing. MS 687;
80. The Hound and Horn (April-June, 1929) 2: 267-282; in part in CP 7.36-48.
81. C.S. Peirce: 1908a, The Bed-Rock Beneath Pragmaticism (Bed). MS 300. Parts published in SEM III: 193-210; CP 4.561n, 4.553n2.
82. C.S. Peirce: 1908b, A Neglected Argument for the Reality of God. The Hibbert Journal 7: 90-112; MS 841; CP 6.452-480.
83. C.S. Peirce: 1908c, Some Amazing Mazes: Explanation of Curiosity the First. The Monist 18: 416-464; CP 4.594-638.
84. C.S. Peirce: 1908d, Supplement, 1908 May 24 [concerning Peirce: 1907, CP 4.639-641].MS 204; in part in CP 7.535n6 and SEM I: 38f.
85. C.S. Peirce: 1909, [Letter to William James, 25. December 1909]. L 224, NEM III: 867-878.
86. C.S. Peirce: 1913, An Essay toward improving our Reasoning in Security and in Uberty. MS 682; EP II: 463-474; SEM III: 474-494.
87. C.S. Peirce, and C. Ladd-Franklin: 1901-2/1911, Logic, Logic (exact), Logical, Logical Diagram (or Graph), Logo-, & c. Baldwin's Dictionary of Philosophy and Psychology 2: 21-28, 30; CP 2.203-218, 3.616-625 (in part).
88. H. Putnam: 1982, Peirce the Logician. Historia Mathematica 9(3): 290-301.
89. W.V.O. Quine: 1969, Natural Kinds. In Ontological Relativity and other Essays. Columbia Univ. Press, New York et al., pp. 114-138.
90. W.V.O. Quine: 1995, Peirce's Logic. In K.L. Ketner (ed.), Peirce and Contemporary Thought. Philosophical Inquiries. Fordham Univ. Press, New York, pp. 23-31.
91. N. Rescher: 1995, Peirce on Abduction, Plausibility, and the Efficiency of Scientific Inquiry. In Essays in the History of Philosophy. Avebury, Aldershot, pp. 309-326.
92. A. Richter: 1995, Der Begriff der Abduktion bei Charles Sanders Peirce. Lang, Frankfurt am Main.
93. D. Stalker (ed.): 1994, Grue. The New Riddle of Induction. Open Court, Chicago and La Salle.
94. R.A. Tursman: 1987, Peirce's Theory of Scientific Discovery. A System of Logic Conceived as Semiotic. Indiana University Press, Bloomington.
95. U. Wirth: 1993, Die Abduktive Wende der Linguistik. Kodikas, Code - Ars Semeiotica 16: 289-301.
96. J.J. Zeman: 1986, Peirce's Philosophy of Logic. Transactions of the Charles S. Peirce Society 22: 1-22.