메뉴 건너뛰기




Volumn 36, Issue 113, 1998, Pages

Closing the circle: How Harvey and his contemporaries played the game of truth, part 2

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords


EID: 33750121678     PISSN: 00732753     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: None     Document Type: Article
Times cited : (1)

References (98)
  • 1
    • 84996168952 scopus 로고    scopus 로고
    • appeared in
    • Part 1 appeared in History of science, xxxvi (1998), 213-32. I wish again to acknowledge Dr Jerome Bylebyl's kind permission to read a preliminary draft of his forthcoming book, "William Harvey: From heartbeat to circulation", and his agreement to my citation of the points indicated below (hereafter cited as Bylebyl, forthcoming). I have done so according to the chapters and page numbers of the copy at my disposal. Beyond this, he is not responsible for any conclusions reached here.
    • (1998) History of Science , vol.36 , Issue.1 PART , pp. 213-232
  • 2
    • 0002142391 scopus 로고
    • A coherence theory of truth and knowledge
    • A. R. Malachowski (ed.), Oxford
    • Coherence theories of truth are nothing new, but this will not be a coherence theory of truth. See, for example, D. Davidson, "A coherence theory of truth and knowledge", in A. R. Malachowski (ed.), Reading Rorty (Oxford, 1990), 120-38.
    • (1990) Reading Rorty , pp. 120-138
    • Davidson, D.1
  • 3
    • 84865920655 scopus 로고
    • Oxford, esp. chap. 3, "Coherentism discomposed"
    • For a critique of his argument, and of coherentist epistemology generally, see S. Haack, Evidence and inquiry: Towards reconstruction in epistemology (Oxford, 1993), esp. chap. 3, "Coherentism discomposed", 52-72.
    • (1993) Evidence and Inquiry: Towards Reconstruction in Epistemology , pp. 52-72
    • Haack, S.1
  • 4
    • 0004201670 scopus 로고
    • Berkeley
    • have long been influenced by the writings of Mary Hesse. See in particular The structure of scientific inference (Berkeley, 1974).
    • (1974) The Structure of Scientific Inference
  • 6
    • 0346077521 scopus 로고
    • When is a valve not a valve? The importance of an idea in the history of the study of blood flow
    • Bylebyl, forthcoming (ref. 1), chap. 6. See also R. K. French, "When is a valve not a valve? The importance of an idea in the history of the study of blood flow", Medical Sciences Historical Society, v (1986), 16-33;
    • (1986) Medical Sciences Historical Society , vol.5 , pp. 16-33
    • French, R.K.1
  • 7
    • 0012042536 scopus 로고
    • Fabricius and the 'Aristotle project' inanatomical teaching and research at Padua
    • A. Wear, R. K. French and I. M. Lonie (eds), Cambridge, 195-222
    • and A. Cunningham, "Fabricius and the 'Aristotle project' in anatomical teaching and research at Padua", in A. Wear, R. K. French and I. M. Lonie (eds), The medical renaissance of the sixteenth century (Cambridge, 1985), 195-222, pp. 206-9.
    • (1985) The Medical Renaissance of the Sixteenth Century , pp. 206-209
    • Cunningham, A.1
  • 9
    • 0014753698 scopus 로고
    • Harvey and Fludd: The irrational factor in the rational science of the seventeenth century
    • 81-105
    • See also A. Debus, "Harvey and Fludd: The irrational factor in the rational science of the seventeenth century", Journal of the history of biology, iii (1970), 81-105, pp. 95-97;
    • (1970) Journal of the History of Biology , vol.3 , pp. 95-97
    • Debus, A.1
  • 12
    • 80054250776 scopus 로고
    • Princeton
    • To me, heuristic relativism (or, more commonly, "methodological relativism") risks smuggling normativity in the back door, just as much as "methodological realism" would. Take, for example, the ambiguous, if not exaggerated, claim that "[a]s we come to recognize the conventional and artifactual status of our forms of knowing, we put ourselves in a position to realize that it is ourselves and not reality that is responsible for what we know" (S. Shapin and S. Schaffer, Leviathan and the air-pump: Hobbes, Boyle, and the experimental life (Princeton, 1985), 344). An heuristic agnostic would say "it is ourselves, and sometimes, presumably (exactly when, we do not know) the world out there, that is (or are) responsible (to what degrees, respectively, we also do not know) for what we know". In other words, for the purposes of epistemological analysis, we need to remain heuristically agnostic as to where nature's causal responsibility ends and our moral, as well as causal responsibility begins.
    • (1985) Leviathan and the Air-pump: Hobbes, Boyle, and the Experimental Life , pp. 344
    • Shapin, S.1    Schaffer, S.2
  • 15
    • 84865923872 scopus 로고    scopus 로고
    • This account is greatly oversimplified. By the later sixteenth century, many subtle differences of explanation were being offered under the category of "attraction" with regard to bloodletting. See Bylebyl, forthcoming (ref. 1), chap. 4, "Ligatures, bloodletting and tonic motion"; also, chap. 7, 45f
    • This account is greatly oversimplified. By the later sixteenth century, many subtle differences of explanation were being offered under the category of "attraction" with regard to bloodletting. See Bylebyl, forthcoming (ref. 1), chap. 4, "Ligatures, bloodletting and tonic motion"; also, chap. 7, 45f.
  • 16
    • 84865922587 scopus 로고    scopus 로고
    • "Harvey had a feel for the concrete", French, op. cit. (ref. 4), 350
    • "Harvey had a feel for the concrete", French, op. cit. (ref. 4), 350.
  • 17
    • 0018370461 scopus 로고
    • The medical side of Harvey's discovery: The normal and the abnormal
    • J. J. Bylebyl (ed.), Baltimore, 28-102
    • See J. J. Bylebyl, "The medical side of Harvey's discovery: The normal and the abnormal", in J. J. Bylebyl (ed.), William Harvey and his age (Baltimore, 1979), 28-102, pp. 68f. Much has been written about Harvey's analogy of the heart as a pump but this will all be superseded by Bylebyl, forthcoming (ref. 1), chap. 12, "Clacks and water bellows: The circulation in the prelectiones". On occult qualities,
    • (1979) William Harvey and His Age
    • Bylebyl, J.J.1
  • 18
    • 84965737247 scopus 로고
    • Occult qualities and the experimental philosophy: Active principles in pre-Newtonian matter theory
    • see J. Henry, "Occult qualities and the experimental philosophy: Active principles in pre-Newtonian matter theory", History of science, xxiv (1986), 335-81.
    • (1986) History of Science , vol.24 , pp. 335-381
    • Henry, J.1
  • 19
    • 0346077519 scopus 로고    scopus 로고
    • forthcoming (ref. 1), chap. 3, section entitled esp. pp. 10f.
    • Bylebyl, forthcoming (ref. 1), chap. 3, section entitled "The primacy of the blood", pp. 10-30, esp. pp. 10f.
    • The Primacy of the Blood , pp. 10-30
    • Bylebyl1
  • 21
    • 33750099950 scopus 로고    scopus 로고
    • Such as De motu cordis (Frankfurt, 1628), 23 or 24. See Bylebyl, forthcoming (ref. 1), chap. 3, pp. 32, 42-44; chap. 8, p. 36; chap. 10, pp. 26f. For a discussion on the spurting of arterial blood before Harvey, see chap. 2, pp. 51-53
    • Such as De motu cordis (Frankfurt, 1628), 23 or 24. See Bylebyl, forthcoming (ref. 1), chap. 3, pp. 32, 42-44; chap. 8, p. 36; chap. 10, pp. 26f. For a discussion on the spurting of arterial blood before Harvey, see chap. 2, pp. 51-53.
  • 24
    • 0016087794 scopus 로고
    • Johannes Walaeus (1604-1649) and his experiments on the circulation of the blood
    • also J. Schouten, "Johannes Walaeus (1604-1649) and his experiments on the circulation of the blood", Journal of the history of medicine and allied sciences, xxix (1974), 259-79.
    • (1974) Journal of the History of Medicine and Allied Sciences , vol.29 , pp. 259-279
    • Schouten, J.1
  • 27
    • 0346077509 scopus 로고
    • Pulse diagnosis in the Greek and Chinese traditions
    • Y. Yawakita (ed.), Tokyo
    • The pulse too was a thoroughly conventionalized phenomenon. Indeed the clinical importance of the pulse was a very basic reason for investigating its nature in the first place. For evolving ideas about the pulse in the century before Harvey see J. J. Bylebyl, "Disputation and description in the renaissance pulse controversy", in Wear (ed.), op. cit. (ref. 1), 223-45. See also Bylebyl, forthcoming (ref. 1), chap. 2, "The pulse controversy". To appreciate just how conventionalized even the "raw" sense of touch can be, see S. Kuriyama, "Pulse diagnosis in the Greek and Chinese traditions", in Y. Yawakita (ed.), History of diagnosis (Tokyo, 1987), 43-67.
    • (1987) History of Diagnosis , pp. 43-67
    • Kuriyama, S.1
  • 28
    • 33750113426 scopus 로고    scopus 로고
    • note
    • Probably by now my own coherencing strategy will have been noticed. It is simply that of reinterpretation. I have reworked a lot of mostly well-known historical "facts" in order to argue that Harvey's presentation and defence of the circulation can be plausibly described as a process of constructed coherencing.
  • 29
    • 0346527239 scopus 로고    scopus 로고
    • For a survey of their objections, see French, op. cit. (ref. 4). As to why they make the ensuing consensus puzzling, see my review of French in Physis, xxxiii (1996), 357-62.
    • (1996) Physis , vol.33 , pp. 357-362
  • 30
    • 33750115644 scopus 로고    scopus 로고
    • note
    • I hope it is also clear by now that what I have been calling the UBK was not uniformly unproblematic among the circulation discussants. The phrase points to a background consensus, sometimes as assumed by an individual engaging in coherencing; sometimes as inferred by us from the participants' behaviour, as was argued for at some length in Part 1. Moreover, folk physics, an important part of that UBK, was just as subject to variations in belief from person to person (and from time to time within one person) as anything else. Therefore, an actor's assumption, or our inference, of some UBK has to be established on a case-by-case basis.
  • 32
    • 0347338706 scopus 로고
    • The reception in Holland of Harvey's theory of the circulation of the blood
    • 183-200
    • have not had access to the first edn of 1638, but have relied on a quotation by G. A. Lindeboom in "The reception in Holland of Harvey's theory of the circulation of the blood", Janus, xlvi (1957), 183-200, p. 195.
    • (1957) Janus , vol.46 , pp. 195
    • Lindeboom, G.A.1
  • 33
    • 0346077511 scopus 로고
    • ed. by C. Adam & P. Tannery Paris
    • However, essentially the same passage appears in a letter from Plemp to Descartes [January 1638], R. Descartes, Oeuvres de Descartes, ed. by C. Adam & P. Tannery (Paris, 1884-1913), i, 499.
    • (1884) Oeuvres de Descartes , vol.1 , pp. 499
    • Descartes, R.1
  • 34
    • 33750105655 scopus 로고    scopus 로고
    • (ref. 4), passim, but esp.
    • For more about Plemp, see French, Oeuvres de Descartes, op. cit. (ref. 4), passim, but esp. pp. 193-202.
    • Oeuvres de Descartes , pp. 193-202
    • French1
  • 35
    • 0346708210 scopus 로고    scopus 로고
    • (ref. 18)
    • Plemp, Fundamenta (ref. 18), 115.
    • Fundamenta , pp. 115
    • Plemp1
  • 36
  • 37
    • 0346708210 scopus 로고    scopus 로고
    • (ref. 18)
    • Plemp, Fundamenta (ref. 18), 115.
    • Fundamenta , pp. 115
    • Plemp1
  • 38
    • 33750143081 scopus 로고    scopus 로고
    • (ref. 12)
    • For example, Walaeus did a series of experiments on leg veins and arteries in the groin of a living dog. See Schouten, Fundamenta op. cit. (ref. 12), 262-4;
    • Fundamenta , pp. 262-264
    • Schouten1
  • 39
    • 84996251863 scopus 로고    scopus 로고
    • (ref. 4), passim, but esp.
    • and French, Fundamenta op. cit. (ref. 4), passim, but esp. pp. 155-62.
    • Fundamenta , pp. 155-162
    • French1
  • 40
    • 33750112611 scopus 로고    scopus 로고
    • note
    • In the passage in 1638, at least in the two sources I have used, Plemp does not say that he actually did the experiment he describes, while, in 1644, he is very emphatic about having personally done the experiments that he cites in support of the circulation, including those just mentioned. Were those contradictory "results" of 1638 the product, perhaps, of a "thought" experiment?
  • 41
    • 33750107006 scopus 로고    scopus 로고
    • note
    • In Part 1, we saw that Primrose committed himself to the rationality of "if x, therefore y, therefore z" but, unlike Plemp, never felt compelled to accept the premise that would have driven him to accept as real what he did accept as rational.
  • 42
    • 84865922179 scopus 로고    scopus 로고
    • See Part 1 where I have argued at length that the apparently "logical" entailments of x therefore y, and y therefore z, were constructed
    • See Part 1 where I have argued at length that the apparently "logical" entailments of x therefore y, and y therefore z, were constructed.
  • 43
    • 33750114143 scopus 로고    scopus 로고
    • The very term 'conventional' embodies the notion of constraint, its strength depending only on the manner and degree of the convention's enforcement
    • The very term 'conventional' embodies the notion of constraint, its strength depending only on the manner and degree of the convention's enforcement.
  • 44
    • 0003875877 scopus 로고
    • Chicago, chap. 5
    • Constraint, of course, has been a big issue in social constructivism. Compare, for example, P. Galison, How experiments end (Chicago, 1987), chap. 5,
    • (1987) How Experiments End
    • Galison, P.1
  • 46
    • 0001986067 scopus 로고
    • Beyond constraint: The temporality of practice and the historicity of knowledge
    • J. Z. Buchwald (ed.), Chicago
    • with A. Pickering, "Beyond constraint: The temporality of practice and the historicity of knowledge", in J. Z. Buchwald (ed.), Scientific practice: Theories and stories of doing physics (Chicago, 1995), 42-55. Unlike Pickering, I do not see how consensus could have been reached, at least in the Harvey story, without a serious element of constraint coming from somewhere. However, I hope that the concept of coherencing avoids Galison's thinly disguised appeals to realism, on the one hand, and yet does not suffer the unconvincing regimentation of Ludwig Fleek's classic "thought collective" on the other (Genesis and development of a scientific fact (Chicago, 1979; originally in German, 1935)).
    • (1995) Scientific Practice: Theories and Stories of Doing Physics , pp. 42-55
    • Pickering, A.1
  • 47
    • 25944469387 scopus 로고    scopus 로고
    • "La description de la corps humain", written in 1648
    • (ref. 18)
    • See, for example, R. Descartes, "La description de la corps humain", written in 1648, in Oeuvres (ref. 18), xi, 243f.
    • Oeuvres , vol.11
    • Descartes, R.1
  • 48
    • 0017564359 scopus 로고
    • Descartes, the sceptics and the rejection of vitalism in seventeenth-century physiology
    • For a discussion of the connection between Descartes's philosophy and his physiology, see P. Sloan, "Descartes, the sceptics and the rejection of vitalism in seventeenth-century physiology", Studies in history and philosophy of science, viii (1977), 1-28.
    • (1977) Studies in History and Philosophy of Science , vol.8 , pp. 1-28
    • Sloan, P.1
  • 49
    • 25944475517 scopus 로고    scopus 로고
    • Discourse de la méthode (originally published anonymously in 1637)
    • (ref. 18)
    • R. Descartes, Discourse de la méthode (originally published anonymously in 1637), in Oeuvres (ref. 18), vi, 48f.
    • Oeuvres , vol.6
    • Descartes, R.1
  • 50
    • 0346708212 scopus 로고    scopus 로고
    • (ref. 18), 496-9
    • Letter from Plemp to Descartes [January 1638], in Descartes, Oeuvres (ref. 18), i, 496-9, p. 497.
    • Oeuvres , vol.1 , pp. 497
    • Descartes1
  • 51
    • 33750115908 scopus 로고    scopus 로고
    • Letter to Plemp, 15 February 1638 (ibid., 521-36, pp. 523 and 530f.)
    • Letter to Plemp, 15 February 1638 (ibid., 521-36, pp. 523 and 530f.).
  • 52
    • 33750119781 scopus 로고    scopus 로고
    • See also Plemp's remarks, printed in his 1638 edn and reproduced by Adam and Tannery as notes at the end of this letter, p. 535; as well as Plemp to Descartes [March, 1638], ii, 52-54, p. 54; and then Descartes to Plemp, 23 March 1638, ibid., 62-69, pp. 66-69. Harvey had already written about how individual pieces of the heart keep beating in his De motu cordis (p. 27)
    • See also Plemp's remarks, printed in his 1638 edn and reproduced by Adam and Tannery as notes at the end of this letter, p. 535; as well as Plemp to Descartes [March, 1638], ii, 52-54, p. 54; and then Descartes to Plemp, 23 March 1638, ibid., 62-69, pp. 66-69. Harvey had already written about how individual pieces of the heart keep beating in his De motu cordis (p. 27).
  • 53
    • 84865930678 scopus 로고    scopus 로고
    • Indeed, Plemp saw Descartes's response as being "so painstaking and intricate" ("ita operosa et contortuplicate") as to suggest that Descartes was a man under pressure, p. 536
    • Indeed, Plemp saw Descartes's response as being "so painstaking and intricate" ("ita operosa et contortuplicate") as to suggest that Descartes was a man under pressure, p. 536.
  • 54
    • 33750107007 scopus 로고    scopus 로고
    • Letter to Descartes [March 1638], in Descartes, Oeuvres (ref. 18), ii, 52-54, p. 53. Descartes had raised the issue in his previous letter (i, 523), and, when Plemp responded this way, Descartes then raised new objections, built upon new potentials for incoherence that Plemp unavoidably imported with this latest dodge (ii, 65)
    • Letter to Descartes [March 1638], in Descartes, Oeuvres (ref. 18), ii, 52-54, p. 53. Descartes had raised the issue in his previous letter (i, 523), and, when Plemp responded this way, Descartes then raised new objections, built upon new potentials for incoherence that Plemp unavoidably imported with this latest dodge (ii, 65).
  • 55
    • 33750104580 scopus 로고    scopus 로고
    • Ibid., ii, 64f. and 54, respectively
    • Ibid., ii, 64f. and 54, respectively.
  • 56
    • 84865922181 scopus 로고    scopus 로고
    • I have taken the term "coherence conditions" from Hesse (op. cit. (ref. 2), 51-54), whose work stimulated me to think along these lines in the first place. However, I alone am responsible for the ways in which I am employing that phrase here
    • I have taken the term "coherence conditions" from Hesse (op. cit. (ref. 2), 51-54), whose work stimulated me to think along these lines in the first place. However, I alone am responsible for the ways in which I am employing that phrase here.
  • 60
    • 0347787622 scopus 로고
    • Paris
    • Although the Hofmann text was first published posthumously in J. Riolan, fils, Opuscula anatomica, varia & noua. Imprimis de motu sanguinis, eiusque circulatione vera, ex doctrina Hippocratis (Paris, 1652), and entitled "Digressio, in circulationem sanguinis, nuper in Anglia natam", 357-64, a draft of it had probably been given to Harvey when he visited Hofmann in 1636. Contrary to Whitteridge's label on her English translation, however, it was clearly not a letter to Harvey.
    • (1652) Opuscula Anatomica, Varia & Noua. Imprimis de Motu Sanguinis, Eiusque Circulatione Vera, Ex Doctrina Hippocratis , pp. 357-364
    • Riolan, J.1
  • 62
    • 0347612996 scopus 로고
    • The new riddle of induction
    • London
    • One is reminded of Nelson Goodman's riddle of "grue", except that the issue here is one of projecting predicates across supposed domains of nature, rather than across time. Under the objection that vivisection produces unnatural conditions in principle, none of the predicates (i.e., associations) so generated is projectible within the domain of the natural. Even Quine's answer to Goodman - grue things are not natural kinds - faintly echoes this seventeenth-century move (N. Goodman, "The new riddle of induction", in Fact, fiction & forecast (London, 1954), 63-83;
    • (1954) Fact, Fiction & Forecast , pp. 63-83
    • Goodman, N.1
  • 65
    • 33750099137 scopus 로고    scopus 로고
    • An issue recently reopened in science studies
    • An issue recently reopened in science studies.
  • 66
    • 33750093330 scopus 로고    scopus 로고
    • note
    • Obviously, it is particularly within the domain of coherence conditions that larger-scale social and cultural values and forces will influence the constitution of scientific knowledge. Nevertheless, as I hope will become clearer in the sequel, there is every reason to suspect that a set of associations, as powerfully coherenced as in the idea of the circulation, can also help to reshape coherence conditions.
  • 67
    • 0020809094 scopus 로고
    • William Harvey and the way of the anatomists
    • See Andrew Wear, "William Harvey and the way of the anatomists", History of science, xxi (1983), 223-49.
    • (1983) History of Science , vol.21 , pp. 223-249
    • Wear, A.1
  • 68
    • 84865922180 scopus 로고    scopus 로고
    • The "U" in UBK might be thought of as standing for "unexamined" and "unspoken", as well as (and because) "unproblematic"
    • The "U" in UBK might be thought of as standing for "unexamined" and "unspoken", as well as (and because) "unproblematic".
  • 70
    • 84887772973 scopus 로고
    • See, for example, Bylebyl's article on Harvey in the Dictionary of scientific biography, vi (1972), 150-61. Various publications over the intervening years will now be superseded by idem, forthcoming (ref. 1), where the theme comes up repeatedly; see esp. chap. 2, 65f. as well as chaps. 11 and 12.
    • (1972) Dictionary of Scientific Biography , vol.6 , pp. 150-161
  • 72
    • 0015092454 scopus 로고
    • The chequered career of Galen's doctrine on the pulmonary veins
    • (with W. Pagel), "The chequered career of Galen's doctrine on the pulmonary veins", Medical history, xv (1971), 211-29;
    • (1971) Medical History , vol.15 , pp. 211-229
    • Pagel, W.1
  • 73
    • 0017530027 scopus 로고
    • Nutrition, quantification and circulation
    • "Nutrition, quantification and circulation", Bulletin of the history of medicine, li (1977), 369-85;
    • (1977) Bulletin of the History of Medicine , vol.51 , pp. 369-385
  • 75
    • 84865930680 scopus 로고
    • ref. 14, and forthcoming (ref. 1), esp. chap. 2, "The pulse controversy"
    • Bulletin of the history of medicine, li (op. cit. (ref. 14, 1985); and forthcoming (ref. 1), esp. chap. 2, "The pulse controversy".
    • (1985) Bulletin of the History of Medicine , vol.51
  • 76
    • 0015307444 scopus 로고
    • Sauvages, Whytt and the motion of the heart: Aspects of eighteenth-century animism
    • An important exception was the cause of the heart's movement. See, for example, R. French, "Sauvages, Whytt and the motion of the heart: Aspects of eighteenth-century animism", Clio medica, vii (1972), 35-54.
    • (1972) Clio Medica , vol.7 , pp. 35-54
    • French, R.1
  • 77
    • 33750104306 scopus 로고    scopus 로고
    • note
    • For some, this might be grounds for dismissing the story as too atypical. I take the opposite view: its special characteristics help us to uncover things about how people go about scientific knowledge production that are obscured by the greater complexities of other examples. Perhaps I and such critics can at least agree that we are just using different coherence conditions.
  • 78
    • 0003748669 scopus 로고
    • Chicago
    • "Animals are capable of incredibly fine discriminations among objects in their environment without the benefits of social conventions ... the fact of widespread agreement does not require social explanation. The explanations of evolutionary biology and physiology are sufficient" (R. Giere, Explaining science: A cognitive approach (Chicago, 1988), 109,
    • (1988) Explaining Science: A Cognitive Approach , pp. 109
    • Giere, R.1
  • 79
    • 0011638849 scopus 로고    scopus 로고
    • A field guide to recent species of naturalism
    • 1-29
    • as quoted in A. Rosenberg, "A field guide to recent species of naturalism", The British journal for the philosophy of science, xlvii (1996), 1-29, p. 12, emphasis added).
    • (1996) The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science , vol.47 , pp. 12
    • Rosenberg, A.1
  • 81
    • 33750127948 scopus 로고    scopus 로고
    • Harvey and experimental philosophy
    • (ref. 4)
    • See the final chapter, "Harvey and experimental philosophy", in French, Harvey and the Oxford physiologists op. cit. (ref. 4), 310-86. French is surely right that Harvey's successful use of experiments must have played a far more important role than has been generally recognized, in stimulating the explosion of renewed interest (by Boyle, among others) in this ancient form of life.
    • Harvey and the Oxford Physiologists , pp. 310-386
    • French1
  • 82
    • 0003410567 scopus 로고
    • Chicago
    • In other words, my "coherencing" is Hacking's "consilience" among people, things and marks ("The self-vindication of the laboratory sciences", in A. Pickering (ed.), Science as practice and culture (Chicago, 1992), 29-64). My complaint in Part 1 was only that, if applied to the Harvey story at least, Hacking's "consilience" would not give enough prominence to the role of people to allow us to come to any plausible conclusion as to how consensus came about.
    • (1992) Science as Practice and Culture , pp. 29-64
  • 83
    • 33750100221 scopus 로고    scopus 로고
    • note
    • Although probably not relevant in this case, the pertinent community of Harvey's day could well have shared gender biases, for example. Yet, had any such existed, these too might have been eliminated eventually, especially if the community came to include, say, women who had the resources and motivation to look for and to demonstrate the incoherences of such biases to the satisfaction of the community as a whole. The point is, of course, that coherences can (though do not necessarily) outlive the historical contingencies of their birth, and can continue to be "improved", not only through strengthening from additional coherences but also by the elimination of others that do not pass the (now changed) community tests of coherence. It is no doubt this that contributes to our feeling both of the "growth" of scientific knowledge and its increasing approximation to the "truth".
  • 84
    • 33750125636 scopus 로고    scopus 로고
    • The reader will no doubt understand why, just by consulting his or her own folk physics
    • The reader will no doubt understand why, just by consulting his or her own folk physics.
  • 85
    • 84996259973 scopus 로고    scopus 로고
    • (ref. 18)
    • Descartes, Oeuvres (ref. 18), xi, 232 and 241-5.
    • Oeuvres , vol.11 , pp. 232
    • Descartes1
  • 86
    • 33750115907 scopus 로고    scopus 로고
    • Harvey explicitly disagrees with Descartes on precisely this point
    • (Cambridge, 1649)
    • In his second letter to Riolan, Harvey explicitly disagrees with Descartes on precisely this point (Exercitatio anatomica de circulatione sanguinis (Cambridge, 1649), 119-22).
    • Exercitatio Anatomica de Circulatione Sanguinis , pp. 119-122
    • Riolan1
  • 87
    • 33750118737 scopus 로고    scopus 로고
    • Bylebyl, forthcoming (ref. 1), offers overwhelming evidence of that coherencing in Harvey's work
    • Bylebyl, forthcoming (ref. 1), offers overwhelming evidence of that coherencing in Harvey's work.
  • 88
    • 25944446584 scopus 로고
    • Popper, science and rationality
    • A. O'Hear (ed.), Cambridge, 13-30
    • Analyses of scientific knowledge production tend to focus either on cognitive processes in the individual mind, or on large-scale forces in society. I share with authors like Popper and W. H. Newton-Smith (see his "Popper, science and rationality", in A. O'Hear (ed.), Karl Popper: Philosophy and problems (Cambridge, 1995), 13-30, pp. 23f. and 28), the view that something in between is also needed, a sort of social cognition. Unfortunately, the Harvey story, like those of Copernicus, Galileo, Newton and others, too easily lends itself to an idiocentric explanation. I'd like to think that, besides offering an account of social cognition, the notion of coherencing also makes understandable our tendency at times to overemphasize either the idiocentric or the macrosocial.
    • (1995) Karl Popper: Philosophy and Problems
    • Popper1    Newton-Smith, W.H.2
  • 91
    • 84865926028 scopus 로고    scopus 로고
    • (ref. 4), chap. 7, "The reception of the pulmonary circuit: 1559-1628"
    • Colombo, for example, described the pulmonary transit of the blood, but, by 1628, no consensus had developed around this idea, despite a great deal of discussion and some further experimentation in connection with it. See Bylebyl, Egg and sperm in Restoration England", op. cit. (ref. 4), chap. 7, "The reception of the pulmonary circuit: 1559-1628", pp. 349-402.
    • Egg and Sperm in Restoration England , pp. 349-402
    • Bylebyl1
  • 94
    • 0014257932 scopus 로고
    • Harvey and the problem of the 'capillaries'
    • V. Elkana and J. Goodfield, "Harvey and the problem of the 'capillaries'", Isis, lix (1968), 61-73.
    • (1968) Isis , vol.59 , pp. 61-73
    • Elkana, V.1    Goodfield, J.2
  • 96
    • 0346708197 scopus 로고
    • London
    • A century after Harvey's death, William Hunter felt that the phenomena of anatomy and surgery "so evidently proclaim the circulation, that there seems to have been nothing more required for the making the discovery, than laying aside gross prejudices, and considering fairly some obvious truths" (Two introductory lectures (London, 1784), 43). According to Dr Helen Brock, who very kindly brought this passage to my attention, the lecture was actually given in 1767.
    • (1784) Two Introductory Lectures , pp. 43


* 이 정보는 Elsevier사의 SCOPUS DB에서 KISTI가 분석하여 추출한 것입니다.