On what it is that Buddhists think about - Apoha in the Ratnakīrti-Nibandhâvali

Journal of Indian Philosophy

Volumn 31, Issue 1-3, 2003, Pages 229-256

  Patil, Parimal G ^a  

^a NONE

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 33748863294     PISSN: 00221791     EISSN: 15730395     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1023/a:1024683224953     Document Type: Review

References (96)

1. AS = Ratnakīrti: Apoha-siddhi See: RNA.
2. BTBh = Moks{dot below}ākaragupta: Bauddha-tarka-bhās{dot below}yā. Bauddhatarkabhās{dot below}ā of Moks{dot below}ākaragupta. Edited & translated with Notes by Dr. B. N. Singh, Foreword by Dr. G. C. Pandey, Asha Prahashan, Sadanand Bazar, Varanasi 1988.
3. CAPV = Ratnakīrti: Citrâdvaita-prakāśa- vāda. See: RNA.
4. DhPr = Durvekamisra: Dharmottara-pradīpa. Pan{dot below}d{dot below}ita Durveka Miśra's Dharmottara-pradīpa [being a subcommentary on Dharmottara's Nyāya-bindu-t{dot below}īkā, a commentary on Dharmakīrti's Nyāya-bindu]. Edited by Pt. Dalsukhbhai Malvania, Kashi Prasad Jayaswal, Research Institute, Patna 1971.
5. DNCV = Siṁhasūri: Nyāyâgamânusārin{dot below}nī [Dvādaśâra-naya-cakra-vr{ring operator}tti]. Dvādaśāraṁ Nayacakraṁ of Ācārya Śrī Mallavādī Ks{dot below}amāśraman{dot below}a. With the commentary Nyāȳgamānusārin{dot below}i of Ācārya Śrī Siṁhasūri Gan{dot below}i Vādi Ks{dot below}amāśraman{dot below}a. Edited with critical notes by Muni Jambūvijayajī. Pt. II (5-8 Aras): Bhavnagar 1976.
6. DvāŚ = Diṅnāga: Dvādaśa- śatika.
7. HB = Dharmakīrti: Hetu-bindu. Steinkellner, Ernst: Dharmakīrti's Hetubinduh. Teil I. Tibetischer Text und rekonstruierter Sanskrit-Text. Veröffentlichungen der Kommission für Sprachen und Kulturen Süd- und Ostasiens 4, Hermann Böhlaus Nachf., Wien 1967.
8. HBT{dot below} = Arcat{dot below}a Bhat{dot below}t{dot below}a: Hetu-bindu-t{dot below}īkā. Sukhlalji Sanghavi and Muni Shri Jinavijayaji (eds.): Hetubindut{dot below}īkā of Bhat{dot below}t{dot below}a Arcat{dot below}a with the Sub-Commentary entitled Āloka of Durveka Miśra. Baroda Oriental Institute, Baroda 1949.
9. JNV = Anantalal Thakur (ed.): Jñānaśrīmitra- nibandha-vāli-Buddhist Philosophical Works of Jñānaś rīmitra. Tibetan Sanskrit Works Series Vol. 5, K.P. Jayaswal Research Institute, Patna 1956. [Reprinted: Patna 1987].
10. KBA = Ks{dot below}an{dot below}a-bhaṅga-siddhi-anvayâtmika. See: RNA.
11. KS = Ratnakīrti: Ks{dot below}an{dot below}a-bhaṅga-siddhi See: RNA.
12. MŚV = Kumārila: Mīmāṁsā-śloka- vārttika. Ślokavārttikaṁ Sucaritamiśra-pran{dot below}ītayā Kāśikākhyayātīkayā sametam. Edited by Sāmbaśiva Śāstri, V.A. Rāmasvāmi Śāstri. 3 Vols. Trivandrum 1926-1943.
13. MŚVT{dot below} = Sucaritamiśra: Mīmāṁ sā-śloka-vārttika-t{dot below}īkā. See: MŚV.
14. NB = Dharmakīrti: Nyāya-bindu. See: DhPr.
15. NBhū = Bhāsarvajña: Nyāya-bhūs{dot below}an{dot below}a. Śrīmad-ācārya- Bhāsarvajña-pran{dot below}ītasya Nyāya-sārasya svôpajñaṁ vyākhyānaṁ Nyāyabhūs{dot below}an{dot below}am. Edited by Svāmī Yogīndrānanda. S{dot below}ad-darśana-prakāśana-grantha-mālā 1, Vārānasī 1968.
16. NBT = Dharmottara: Nyāya-bindu-t{dot below}īkā. See: DhPr.
17. NKan{dot below} = 'Vidhivivekah' of Mandanamisra, with commentary 'Nyayakanika,' of Vacaspatimisrah, and supercommentaries, Jusadhvankarani, and Svaditankarani of Paramesvarah, Critical and Annotated Edition. Edited by Elliot M. Stern. Unpublished Ph.D. Dissertation, University of Pennsylvania, 1998.
18. NMa = Jayantabhat{dot below}t{dot below}a: Nyāya- mañjarī. Nyāyamañjarī of Jayantabhat{dot below}t{dot below}a with T{dot below}ippan{dot below}i-nyāya-saurabha by the editor. Edited by K. S. Varadacharya, Vol. 1 & 2, Oriental Research Institute Series 116, Mysore 1969, 1983.
19. NS = Aks{dot below}apāda Gautama: Nyāya-sūtra. Gautamīyanyāyadarśana with Bhās{dot below}ya of Vātsyāyana. Edited by Anantalal Thakur. Munshiram Manoharlal, New Delhi 1997.
20. NVTT{dot below} = Vācaspatimiśra: Nyāya- vārttika-tātparya-t{dot below}ikā. Nyāyavārttika- tātparyat{dot below}īkā of Vācaspatimiśra. Edited by Anantalal Thakur. Munshiram Manoharlal, New Delhi 1996.
21. NVTTP{dot below} = Udayanācārya: Nyāya-vārttika- tātparya-t{dot below}īkā-pariśuddhi Edited by Anantalal Thakur. Munshiram Manoharlal, New Delhi 1996.
22. PS 1 = Dignāga: Pramān{dot below}a-samuccaya, Chapter 1. See: HATTORI (1968).
23. PS 2 = Dignāga: Pramān{dot below}a-samuccaya, Chapter 2. See: HAYES (1988).
24. PS 5 = Dignāga: Pramān{dot below}a-samuccaya, Chapter 5. See: HAYES (1988).
25. PSV = Dignāga: Pramān{dot below}a-samuccaya-vr{ring operator}tti, Chapter 1. See: HATTORI (1968).
26. PV 1 = Dharmakīrti: Pramān{dot below}a-vārttika I (pratyaks{dot below}a). Raniero Gnoli (ed.): The Pramān{dot below}avārttikam of Dharmakīrti, the First Chapter with the Autocommentary. Text and Critical Notes. Serie Orientale Roma 23, Roma 1960.
27. PV 2-4 = Dharmakīrti: Pramān{dot below}a-vārttika, Chapters 2, 3, 4. Yūsho Miyasaka (ed.): 'Pramāna-vārttika- kārikā(Sanskrit and Tibetan).' [Chapter 2 = Pramān{dot below}a-siddhi, Chapter 3 = Pratyaks{dot below}a, Chapter 4 = Parârthânumāna]. Acta Indologica 2 (1971/72) 1-206 [Narita]. [My numbering of Chapters 1, 2, 3 corresponds to Miyasaka's 3, 1, 2]
28. PVin 1 = Dharmakīrti: Pramān{dot below}a-viniścaya I (pratyaks{dot below}a). Tilmann Vetter (ed.): Dharmakīrti's Pramān{dot below}aviniścayah{dot below}, I. Kapitel: Pratyaks{dot below}am. Einleitung, Text der tibetischen Übersetzung, Sanskritfragmente, deutsche Übersetzung. Veröffentlichungen der Kommission für Sprachen und Kulturen Süd- und Ostasiens, Österreichische Akademie der Wissenschaften, Heft 3, Wien 1966.
29. PVin 2 = Dharmakīrti: Pramāna-viniścaya, Chapter 2. Ernst Steinkellner (ed.): Dharmakīrti's Pramān{dot below}aviniścayah{dot below}, 2. Kapitel: Svārthānumā nam. Teil I. Tibetischer Text und Sanskrittexte. Veröffentlichungen der Kommission für Sprachen und Kulturen Südasiens, Österreichische Akademie der Wissenschaften, Heft 12, Wien 1973.
30. PVSV = Dharmakīrti: Pramān{dot below}a-vārttika- svavr{ring operator}tti See: PV 1.
31. PVSVT{dot below} = Karn{dot below}akagomin: Pramān{dot below}a-vārttika-svavr{ring operator}tti-t{dot below}īkā. Rāhula Sāṅkr{ring operator}tyāyana (ed.): Ācārya-Dharmakīrteh{dot below} Pramān{dot below}a-vārttikam (svârthānumāna-paricchedah{dot below}) svopajña-vr{ring operator}ttyā Karn{dot below} akagomiviracitayā tat{dot below}-t{dot below}īkayā ca sahitam. Allahabad 1943.
32. PVV = Manorathanandin: Pramān{dot below}a-vārttika-vr{ring operator}tti. The Pramān{dot below}a-vārttikam of Ācārya Dharmakīrti with Sub-commentaries: Svôpajña- vr{ring operator}tti of the Author and Pramān{dot below}a-vārttika-vr{ring operator}tti of Manorathanandin. Edited by Prof. Dr. Ram Chandra Pandeya. Motilal Banarsidass, Delhi 1989.
33. RNA = Ratnakīrti-nibandhâvalī(Buddhist Nyāya Works of Ratnakīrti). Edited by Anantalal Thakur. Tibetan Sanskrit Works Series 3; K.P. Jayaswal Research Institute, Patna 1975.
34. SāmP = Diṅn̄aga: Sāmānya-parīks{dot below}ā.
35. TSa = Śāntaraks{dot below}ita: Tattva-saṅgraha. See: TSaP.
36. 1 = Kamalaśīla: Tattva-saṅgraha- pañjikā. Tattvasaṅgraha of Ācārya Shāntaraks{dot below}ita with the Commentary 'Pañjikā' of Shri Kamalashīla, ed. Dvarikadas Shastri. 2. Vols. Varanasi 1981-1982.
37. 2 = Kamalaśīla: Tattva-saṅgraha- pañjikā. Tattvasaṅgraha of Śāntaraks{dot below}ita with the commentary of Kamalaśīla. Edited by Embar Krishnamacharya. 2 Vols., Baroda 1926.
38. VC = Jñānaśrīmitra: Vyāpti-carcā. See: JNV.
39. VyN = Ratnakīrti: Vyāpti-nirn{dot below}aya. See: RNA.
40. BALCEROWICZ 1999 = Balcerowicz, Piotr: 'How Could a Cow be Both Synchronically and Diachronically Homogeneous, or On the Jaina Notions of tiyrak-sāmānya and ūrdhva-sāmānya.' In: N.K. Wagle and Olle Qvarnstrom (eds.): Approaches to Jaina Studies: Philosophy, Logic, Rituals and Symbols. [Proceedings of the International Conference on Approaches to Jaina Studies: Philosophy, Logic, Rituals and Symbols, 31.03-2.04.1995 Toronto]. Edited by N.K. Wagle and Olle Qvarnström. South Asian Studies Papers 11, University of Toronto: Centre for South Asian Studies, Toronto 1999:211-235.
41. BRONKHORST 1999 = Bronkhorst, Johannes: 'Nāgārjuna and Apoha.' In KATSURA (1999: 17-24).
42. CHIERCHIA-MCCONNELL-GINET 1990 = Chierchia, Gennaro; McConnell-Ginet, Sally (eds.): Meaning and Grammar. Cambridge Mass, MIT Press, Cambridge 1990.
43. DESHPANDE 1992 = Deshpande, Madhav: The Meaning of Nouns: Semantic Theory in Classical and Medieval India (Nāmārthanirn{dot below}aya of Kaun{dot below}d{dot below}abhat{dot below}t{dot below}a), Studies in Classical India, 13. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht 1992.
44. DUNNE 1996 = Dunne, John D.: 'Thoughtless Buddha, Passionate Buddha.' JAAR 64/3 (1996) 525-556.
45. DUNNE 1999 = Dunne, John D.:'Foundations of Dharmakīrti's Philosophy: A Study of the Central Issues in his Ontology, Logic and Epistemology with Particular Attention to the Svopajñav{ring operator}rtti.' Unpublished Ph.D. Dissertation, Harvard University, 1999.
46. FRAUWALLNER 1930-1935 = Frauwallner, Erich: 'Beiträge Zur Apohalehre.' WZKM 37 (1930) 259-283;
47. WZKM 39 (1932) 247-285 ;
48. WZKM 40 (1933) 51-94;
49. WZKM 42 (1935) 93-102;
50. WZKM 44 (1936) 233-287.
51. FRAUWALLNER 1959 = Frauwallner, Erich: 'Dignāga, sein Werk und seine Entwicklung.' WZKSO 3 (1959) 83-164.
52. GANERI 1995 = Ganeri, Jonardon: 'Vyād{dot below}i and the Realist Theory of Meaning.' Journal of Indian Philosophy 23 (1995) 403-428.
53. GANERI 1996 = Ganeri, Jonardon: 'Meaning and Reference in Classical India.' Journal of Indian Philosophy 24 (1996) 1-19.
54. GANERI 1999a = Ganeri, Jonardon: Semantic Powers: Meaning and the Means of Knowing in Classical Indian Philosophy. Clarendon Press, Oxford 1999.
55. GANERI 1999b = Ganeri, Jonardon. (1999a) 'Dharmakīrti's Semantics for the Particle eva(only).' In KATSURA (1999: 101-116).
56. GANERI 2001 = Ganeri, Jonardon: Philosophy in Classical India. Routledge, New York 2001.
57. GILLON 1991 = Gillon, Brendan S.: 'Dharmakīrti and the Problem of Induction.' In STEINKELLNER (1991: 53-58).
58. GILLON 1999 = Gillon, Brendon S.: 'Another Look at the Sanskrit Particle eva.' In KATSURA (1999: 117-130).
59. HALE 1999 = Hale, Bob: 'Semantic Value' In HALE-WRIGHT (1999: 684).
60. HALE-WRIGHT 1999 = Hale, Bob; Wright, Crispin (eds.): Companion to the Philosophy of Language. Blackwell, Oxford 1999.
61. HATTORI 1968 = Hattori, Masaaki: Dignāga, On Perception, being the Pratyaks{dot below}a-pariccheda of Dignāga's Pramān{dot below}a-samuccaya, edition of Tibetan translations and the Sanskrit text as well as the English translation of the Chapter I. Harvard University Press 1968.
62. HATTORI 1977 = Hattori, Masaaki: 'The Sautrāntika Background of the Apoha Theory.' In: Leslie S. Kawamura and Keith Scott (eds.): Buddhist Thought and Asian Civilizations. Essays in Honor of Herbert V. Guenther on his Sixtieth Birthday, Emeryville, Dharma Publishing, CA 1977: 47-58.
63. HATTORI 1980 = Hattori, Masaaki: 'Apoha and Pratibhā.' In: M. Nagatomi et al. (eds.): Sanskrit and Indian Studies, Essays in Honor of Daniel H.H. Ingalls Reidel Publishing, Dordrecht 1980: 61-74.
64. HATTORI 2000 = Hattori, Masaaki: 'Dignāga's Theory of Meaning: An Annotated Translation of the Pramān{dot below}asamuccayavr{ring operator}tti: Chapter V: Anyāpoha-parīks{dot below}ā(I).' In: Jonathan A. Silk ed., Wisdom, Compassion, and Understanding: The Buddhist Studies Legacy of Gadjin M. Nagao. University of Hawaii Press, Honolulu 2000: 137-146.
65. HAYES 1986 = Hayes, Richard P.: 'Aninterpretation of anyāpoha in Diṅnāga's general theory of inference,' in MATILAL-EVANS (1986: 31-57).
66. HAYES 1988 = Hayes, Richard P.: Dignāga on the Interpretation of Signs. Studies of Classical India 9, Kluwer Academic Press, Dordrecht 1988.
67. HAYES-GILLON 1991 = Hayes, Richard P.; Gillon, Brendon S.: 'Introduction to Dharmakīrti's Theory of Inference as Presented in Pramān{dot below}avarttika Svopajñāvr{ring operator}tti 1-10: Journal of Indian Philosophy 19 (1991) 1-74.
68. HERZBERGER 1986 = Herzberger, Radhika: Bhartr{ring operator}hari and the Buddhists. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht 1986.
69. KAJIYAMA 1966 = Kajiyama, Yuichi: An Introduction to Buddhist Philosophy: An Annotated Translation of the Tarkabhās{dot below}ā of Moks{dot below}ākaragupta. Memoirs of the Faculty of Letters of Kyoto University 10, Kyoto 1966.
70. KATSURA 1979 = Katsura, Shoryu: 'The apoha Theory of Dignāga.' Indogaku Bukkyogaku Kenkyū28 (1979) 16-20.
71. KATSURA 1983 = Katsura, Shoryu: 'Dignāga on trairūpya.' Journal of Indian and Buddhist Studies 32 (1983) 15-21.
72. KATSURA 1984 = Katsura, Shoryu: 'Dharmakīrti's Theory of Truth.' Journal of Indian Philosophy 12 (1984) 215-235.
73. KATSURA 1986 = Katsura, Shoryu: 'Jñānaśrīmitra on Apoha.' In MATILAL-EVANS (1986).
74. KATSURA 1991 = Katsura, Shoryu: 'Dignāga and Dharmakīrti on apoha.' In STEINKELLNER (1991: 129-144).
75. KATSURA 1993 = Katsura, Shoryu: 'On Perceptual Judgement.' In: N.K. Wagle and F. Watanabe (eds.): Studies in Buddhism in Honor of Professor A.K. Warder. University of Totonto Center for South Asian Studies, Toronto 1993: 66-75.
76. KATSURA 1999 = Shoryu Katsura (ed.): Dharmakīrti's Thought and its Impact on Indian and Tibetan Philosophy. Proceedings of the Third International Dharmakīrti Conference, Hiroshima, November 4-6, 1997. Verlag der Österreichischen Akademie der Wissenschaften: Beiträge zur Kultur- und Geistesgeschichte Asiens Nr. 32, Wien 1999.
77. MATILAL 1971 = Matilal, Bimal Krishna: Epistemology, Logic, and Grammar in Indian Philosophical Analysis. Janua Linguarum: Studia Memoriae Nicolai Van Wijk Dedicata, Series Minor 111. Mouton, The Hague-Paris 1971.
78. MATILAL 1985 = Matilal, Bimal Krishna: Logic, Language, and Reality. Motilal Banarsidass, Delhi 1985.
79. MATILAL 1986 = Matilal, Bimal Krishna: Perception: An Essay on Classical Indian Theories of Knowledge. Clarendon Press, Oxford 1986.
80. MATILAL 1990 = Matilal, Bimal Krishna: The Word and the World. Oxford University Press, Delhi 1990.
81. MATILAL-EVANS 1986 = Matilal, Bimal Krishna; Evans, Robert D. (eds.): Buddhist Logic and Epistemology. D. Reidel Publishing Company, Dordrecht 1986.
82. MEINDERSMA 1991 = Meindersma, T.E.: 'A Brief Reference to apoha Theory in the Section on paralokasiddhi in Pramān{dot below}avārttika II.' In STEINKELLNER (1991: 169-174).
83. MOOKERJEE 1935 = Mookerjee, Satkari: The Buddhist Philosophy of Universal Flux-An Exposition of the Philosophy of Critical Realism as Expounded by the School of Dignāga. University of Calcutta, Calcutta 1935 [Reprinted: Motilal Banarsidass, Delhi 1993].
84. MUCH 1994 = Much, Michael T.: 'Uddyotakaras Kritik der Apoha-Lehre (Nyāyavārttika ad NS II 2, 66).' WZKS 38 (1994) 351-366.
85. PANDEYA 1989 = See PVV.
86. PIND 1991 = Pind, Ole H.: 'Dignāga on śabdasāmā nya and śabdaviśes{dot below}a.' In STEINKELLNER (1991: 269-280).
87. PIND 1999 = Pind, Ole H.: 'Dharmakīrti's Interpretation of Pramānasamuccayavr{ring operator}tti V 36: śabdo 'rthāntaranivr{ring operator}ttiviśis{dot below}t{dot below}ān eva bhāvān āha.' In KATSURA (1999: 317-324).
88. RAJA 1986 = Raja, K.K.: 'Apoha Theory and Pre-Diṅnāga Views on Sentence Meaning.' In MATILAL-EVANS (1986: 185-192).
89. SCHARF 1996 = Scharf, Peter M.: The Denotation of "Generic Terms in Ancient Indian Philosophy: Grammar, Nyāya, and Mīmāṁ sā. Transactions of the American Philosophical Society Held at Philadelphia for Promoting Useful Knowledge, 86/3, American Philosophical Society, Philadelphia 1996.
90. SIDERITS 1986 = Siderits, Mark: 'Word Meaning, Sentence Meaning, and Apoha.' Journal of Indian Philosophy 13 (1986) 133-151.
91. SIDERITS 1991 = Siderits, Mark: Indian Philosophy of Language: Studies in Selected Issues. Studies in Linguistics and Philosophy, Vol. 46. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht 1991.
92. STALNAKER 1999 = Stalnaker, Robert: 'Reference and Necessity.' In HALE-WRIGHT (1999: 534-554).
93. STEINKELLNER 1991 = Steinkellner, Ernst (ed.): Studies in the Buddhist Epistemological Tradition-Proceedings of the Second International Dharmakīrti Conference, Vienna, June 11-16, 1989, Österreichische Akademie der Wissenschaften, philosophisch-historische Klasse, Denkschriften, 222. Band; Verlag der Österreichischen Akademie der Wissenschaften, Wien 1991.
94. STEINKELLNER-KRASSER 1989 = Steinkellner, Ernst und Helmut Krasser: Dharmottaras Exkurs zur Definition gültiger Erkenntnis im Pramānaviniścaya. Tibetischer Text, Sanskritmaterialien und Übersetzung. Wien 1989.
95. TILLEMANS 1999 = Tillemans, Tom J.F.: Scripture, Logic, and Language: Essays on Dharmakirti and his Tibetan Successors. Studies in Indian and Tibetan Buddhism. Wisdom Publications, Boston 1999.
96. Woo 1999 = Woo, Jeson(ed.): Ks{dot below}an{dot below}abhaṅgasiddhi- Anvayātmika: An Eleventh-Century Buddhist Work on Existence and Causal Theory. Unpublished Ph.D. Dissertation, University of Pennsylvania, 1999.