Bilateral nephrectomy in the 19th century Uremic toxicity: From urea to potassium

Journal of Nephrology

Volumn 19, Issue SUPPL. 10, 2006, Pages

  Richet, Gabriel ^a   van Ypersele de Strihou, Charles ^b  

^a ACADÉMIE NATIONALE DE MÉDECINE   (France)

^b Academie Royale de Belgique   (Belgium)

Author keywords

Bilateral nephrectomy; Heart effects; Potassium; Urea; Uremic toxicity

Indexed keywords

NITROGEN; POTASSIUM; UREA; UREA DERIVATIVE;

ARTICLE; FRANCE; HEMODIALYSIS; HISTORY OF MEDICINE; HUMAN; MEDICAL LITERATURE; MEDICAL RESEARCH; NEPHRECTOMY; NONHUMAN; RISK ASSESSMENT; SURGICAL APPROACH; SURGICAL MORTALITY; SURGICAL RISK; SURGICAL TECHNIQUE; SURGICAL TRAINING; SURVIVAL TIME; UREA NITROGEN BLOOD LEVEL; UREMIA; URINALYSIS; URINE RETENTION; ANIMAL; DOG; HISTORY; METABOLISM;

ANIMALS; DOGS; HISTORY, 19TH CENTURY; HUMANS; NEPHRECTOMY; POTASSIUM; UREA;

EID: 33748098045     PISSN: 11218428     EISSN: 17246059     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: None     Document Type: Article

References (50)

1. Grmek MD. Première Révolution Biologique. Paris: Payot Ed 1990; 73: 358.
2. Imbault Huart MJ. Ecole Pratique de Dissection de Paris, Thèse d'Histoire, Paris I. Service de Reproduction des Thèses, Université de Lille III, 1975; 376: 1873.
3. Comhaire JN. Dissertation inaugurate sur l'extirpation des reins, melée de quelques recherches physiologiques sur ces organes et les fluides qu'ils secrètent. Thèse no 85, 1803, Paris.
4. In the title page of his thesis, Comhaire quotes Buffon who supported experimentation: "S'il n'existait pas les animaux, la nature de l'homme serait encore plus incompréhensible" (If animals did not exist, man's nature would be even more incomprehensible).
5. Richet G. Early history of Uremia. Kidney Int 1988; 33: 1013-5
6. and "The contribution of French Speaking Scientists to the origins of Renal Physiology and Pathophysiology (1790-1910). Am J Nephrol 1993; 19: 274-9.
7. Richet G. L'urèe urinaire vient-elle du sang ou est-elle élaborée par le rein? Hist Sciences Médicales 1990; 24: 127-32.
8. Delage A. Histoire de la Thèse en Médecine. Thèse 1913; Paris.
9. Florkin M. Les origines framçaises de la Fac. de Médecine de Liège. Rev Med Liège 1953; 7: 336-54.
10. Bernard C. Introduction à l'étude de la médecine expérimentale. Paris: Delagrave éd. 1900; 7. "Reasoning will be always right when it rests on exact notions and precise facts; it will only lead to errors every time it applies to notions and facts initially tainted by errors or inexactitudes".
11. Nysten PH. Recherches de physiologie et de chimie pathologiques. Paris 1811. Premier essai de physiopathologie. Section 3: Des altérations de la sécrétion de l'urine (pp 233-292), de l'urée, des vomissements (pp 279-280) et de l'albuminurie de l'hydropisie (pp 391).
12. Florkin M. Un disciple de Bichat: Pierre H. Nysten: Revue médicale de Liège 1951; 6: 300-10.
13. Rayer P. Traité des Maladies des Reins. Paris 1839; T I, p. 52. He quotes the negative results of Comhaire and the positive ones of Tiedemann, Gmelin and Marchand. Actually, Bright, Christison and Rayer were the three founding fathers of Clinical Nephrology, each from an angle different from that of the others. The commanding clinical logic of Rayer is discussed in Richet G, from Bright's disease to modern nephrology
14. Pierre Rayer's innovative method of clinical investiga- tion. Kidney Int 1991; 39: 787-92.
15. Bilateral nephrectomies are briefly quoted, without Comhaire's name. In Richerand A (Ed). Nouveaux Eléments de Physiologie, 8ème édition, 1820, Tome I, p. 282.
16. Bernard C. ibid. Part I, Chapt II, §2, p. 57: "Intuition or sentiment generates the experimental idea".
17. Kuhn TS. The structure of scientific revolutions. Translated in French. Paris: Flammarion Edit 1983.
18. Mani M. La découverte de Furémie expérimentale par J.L. Prevost et J.B. Dumas, Genève, 1821. Genève: Médecine et Hygiène 1963; 21: 1013-5.
19. Prevost JL, Dumas JB. Examen du sang et de son action dans les divers phénormènes de la vie. Ann. Chimie Physique. Paris 1823; 80-104.
20. The text had been first read in Geneva on November 15, 1821 at the Ste de Physique et Hist. Nat. de Genève on 15/11/1821. The experiments had been performed in a fortification of the Geneva guards, on the Promenade Bel-Air, because vivisection was prohibited within the city. See Roche J. Les Sciences Biologiques et l'œuvre médicale de Jean Baptiste Dumas. Bull Acad Nat Méd 1985; 169: 50-3.
21. Urea crystallisation by nitric acid was achieved in 1797, in London, by William Cruikshank.
22. "Probabilité chimique" expresses respect for scientific doubt and refusal to preempt the future i.e. truth until proven otherwise.
23. The originality of Prevost and Dumas'work shines when compared with the thesis of J.C. Coindet from Geneva: « Quaedam de renum muneribis comlectens » (1820-Edinburgh). Coindet demonstrates that the bilateral ligation of renal vessels, arteries as well as veins, suppress all renal functions and thus concludes to the essential role of the renal blood supply. Urea retention is not investigated and the responsibility of urinary suppression as a cause of death is doubted because of the inocuity of urea injections and the assumed power of vicarious disposal ways.
24. D'Alembert JLR. Article Expérimental, Grande Encyclopédie. Genève: Edition Pellet 1778, Tome XIII; pp. 625-33. This article was initially published in the "Supplements".
25. Mani see in ref. 16.
26. Gmelin L, Tiedemann J. Versuche über das Blut. Poggendorf Annalen 1834; 31: 303.
27. Marchand RF. De l'existence de l'urée dans les parties de l'organisme animal autres que l'urine. L'expérience; 1838, 2, 43-47. Translated from German, Marchand's native language. "L'expérience", directed by Littré, lasted only 3 years. It published papers in french, either originals or translated.
28. Intellectual life in Geneva was illustrated in those days by the vegetal physiologist N.T. de Saussure (1767-1848), the chemist G. de la Rive (1770-1834) and the botanist A.P. de Candolle (1778-1841) who advised Dumas "You should direct all your efforts towards chemistry: physiology without chemistry is impossible". We should also remember J.F. Coindet (1774-1834) who pioneered the prevention and treatment of goiters with iodine.J.B. Dumas' first work was the discovery of iodine in the ashes of sponges utilized in China for goiter therapy as well as the methodology needed to prepare iodine salts to be distributed together with NaC1 in the Swiss valleys. Numerous clinical and experimental investigations were carried out in Geneva. See G. Richer. La médecine dans le Rapport Historique sur les Progrès des Sciences Naturelles de Georges Cuvier, 1810. Histoire des Sciences Médicales 2000; 34: 71-95.
29. On the Seine's banks, von Humboldt was known as the most Parisian of German scientists.
30. The story is recounted in M. Crosland. The Society of Arcueil. Harvard University Press 1967; 442-3.
31. Ségalas d'Etchepare PS, Vauquelin NL. Sur de nouvelles expériences relatives aux propriétés médicamenteuses de l'urée. J Physio Exp (Magendie) 1822; 2: 354-63.
32. Bernard C, Barreswil Ch. Sur les voies d'élimination de l'urée après extirpation des reins. Arch Gén Méd 1847; 13: 449-65.
33. Bernard C. Les liquides de l'organisme II. Paris: Baillière éd. 1859; 46-52.
34. Picard J. De la présence de l'urèe dans le sang et de sa diffusion dans l'organisme à l'état physiologique et à l'état pathologique. Thèse Strasbourg, 1856. Picard successfully adapted Liebig's method to measure physiological blood concentrations of urea. Renal venous level reached only 50 % of the renal arterial level. He was the first to dissociate clearly albuminuria, a sign of renal involvement, from elevated blood urea levels, predictors of the terminal uraemic coma and distinguished the latter from vascular cerebral accidents. Had the literature retained his thesis, the development of clinical nephrology would have been very different.
35. Recklinghausen F. v. Über Picard's Bestimmunggsmethod des Harnstoff's im Blute. Virchow's Archiv 1858; 14: 476-8.
36. Le Canu, L.R. Etudes chimiques sur le sang humain, Thèse médecine Paris 1837. He failed to obtain urea nitrate crystals from 1000 g of normal human blood.
37. Frerichs, first an ophtalmologist, became later an internist. He founded the first German chair of experimental pathology. He discovered the presence of leucine and tyrosine in the urine and described the acute yellow liver atrophy.
38. Frerichs F.T. Die Brights'che Nierenkrankheit und deren Behandlung. Einc Monographie, 1851, 296 pp. This mainly clinical work reached a large audience. In the section (pp. 87-114) devoted to "Üraemisch Intoxication", the author emphasizes the role of humoral disorders at the expense of anatomical distortions. He further reports (pp. 278-281) the inocuity of urea in 6 binephrectomized dogs. On his thesis' title page he quotes Marshall Hall (1790-1857): "To become a good and enlightened practioner, we must become an able physiologist".
39. Bernard C. Ref. 30 pp 34-6.
40. Feltz V, Ritter E. De l'uriémie expérimentale. 1881, 1 Vol pp. 347 pages Berger Levrault Ed. Nancy. Although a little lengthy, this book is very clear: each phase of the experimentation ends with a critical conclusion which never deviates from the facts. Thanks to its logic it is still worth reading.
41. Voit C. Über das Verhalten des Kreatins, Kreatinins und Harnstoffs im Thierkorper. Ztschr F Biol 1868; 4: 77-162.
42. Ringer S. A Further contribution regarding the influence of different constituents of the blood on the contraction of the heart. J Physiol 1883; 4: 29-42.
43. Smillie WG. Potassium poisoning in nephritis Arch Int Med 1915; 6: 330-9.
44. Bouchard C, Roger H. Nouveau traité de pathologie générale. II, Paris 1914. Toxicity of normal urine (pp 245-254) during uraemia (pp 283-286). The quoted sentence is on p. 247.
45. Let us remember that this work preceeds by 6 years R. Bright's princeps observation.
46. Blood chemistry became part of the clinical assessment thanks to technical progresses reducing the size of blood samples required for the determination of various compounds as well as to the introduction in 1898 of needle sampling. See G. Richet Le prélèement à l'aiguille de H. Strauss. Début de la biochimie du sang. Presse Médicale 1992; 21: 1053-4.
47. Bright R. Reports of medical cases. The symptoms and cure of diseases by reference to morbid anatomy. 2 Vol. London: Longmam and al. 1927.
48. Naets J.P. The role of the kidney in erythropolesis. J Clin Invest 1960; 1: 102-110.
49. van Ypersele de Strihou C, Stragier A. Effect of bilateral nephrectomy on transfusion requirements of patients under-going chronic dialysis. Lancet 1969; ii: 705-7.
50. Caillens H, Pruszezynski W, Meyrier A, Kim Seng A, Rousselet F, Ardaillou R. Relationship between change in volemia at constant osmolality and plasma antidiuretic hormone. Miner Electr Met 1980; 4: 161-71.