On the impossibility of close reading: The case of Alexander Marshack

Current Anthropology

Volumn 37, Issue 2, 1996, Pages 185-226

  Elkins, James ^a  

^a SCHOOL OF THE ART INSTITUTE OF CHICAGO   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 33747728876     PISSN: 00113204     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1086/204490     Document Type: Article

References (107)

1. BEAZLEY, JOHN DAVIDSON. 1942. Attic Red-Figure vase-painters. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
2. BINFORD, LEWIS R. 1983. In pursuit of the past: Decoding the archaeological record. New York: Academic Press.
3. _. 1984. Faunal remains from Klasies River Mouth. New York: Academic Press.
4. BOAS, F. 1955 (1927). Primitive art. New York: Dover [RW]
5. CARRIER, DAVID. 1993. Poussin's paintings: A study in art-historical methodology. University Park: Pennsylvania State University Press. [DC]
6. _. 1994. The aesthete in the city: The philosophy and practice of American abstract painting in the 1980s. University Park: Pennsylvania State University Press. [DC]
7. CHASE, P. 1990. Sifflets du Paléolithique moyen(?): Les implications d'un coprolithe de coyote actuel. Bulletin de la Société Préhistorique Française 87:165-67. [ID]
8. CHOLLOT-VARAGNAC, M. 1980. Les origines du graphisme symbolique: Essai d'analyse des écritures primitives en préhistoire. Paris: Fondation Singer-Polignac. [RW]
9. DAVIS, WHITNEY. 1987. Replication and depiction in Paleolithic art. Representations 19:111-47.
10. _. 1989. The origins of image making. CURRENT ANTHROPOLOGY 27: 193-215.
11. _. 1990. "The study of rock art in Africa," in A history of African archaeology. Edited by Peter Robertshaw, pp. 271-95. London: James Currey. [WD]
12. _. 1992a. Masking the blow: The scene of representation in late prehistoric Egyptian art. Berkeley: University of California Press.
13. _. 1992b. The deconstruction of intentionality in archaeology. Antiquity 66:334-47. [WD]
14. _. 1992c. "Finding symbols in history," in Representations in archaeology. Edited by Jean-Claude Gardin and Christopher Peebles, pp. 122-31. Bloomington: Indiana University Press. [WD]
15. _. 1994. Das Optische und das Rhetorische in Paul de Mans "historischem Materialismus." Texte zur Kunst 4(14):89-99. [WD]
16. _. 1996. Replications: Archaeology, art history, psychoanalysis. University Park: Pennsylvania State University Press. [WD]
17. DAVIDSON, I. 1990. Bilzingsleben and early marking. Rock Art Research 7:52-56. [ID]
18. _. 1991. The archaeology of language origins: A review. Antiquity 65:39-48. [ID]
19. DE MAN, PAUL. 1979. Allegories of leading: Figural language in Rousseau, Nietzsche, Rilke, and Proust. New Haven and London: Yale University Press.
20. _. 1983. "Hegel on the sublime," in Displacement: Derrida and after. Edited by Mark Krupnick, pp. 139-53. Bloomington: Indiana University Press. [WD]
21. _. 1984a. "Shelley disfigured," in The rhetoric of romanticism, pp. 39-73. New York: Columbia University Press. [WD]
22. _. 1984b. "Phenomenality and materiality in Kant," in Hermeneutics: Questions and prospects. Edited by Gary Schapiro and Alan Sica, pp. 121-44. Amherst: University of Massachusetts Press. [WD]
23. _. 1986. "Hypogram and inscription," in The resistance to theory, pp. 27-53. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press. [WD]
24. _. 1993. Romanticism and contemporary criticism: The Gauss Seminar and other papers. Baltimore and London: Johns Hopkins University Press. [TJC]
25. D'ERRICO, FRANCESCO. 1989a. "Mémoire et rythmes au Paléolithique: Le mythe des calendriers lunaires." Hominidae: Proceedings of the Second International Congress of Human Paleontology. Edited by Giacomo Giacobini, pp. 507-10. Milan.
26. _. 1989b. Palaeolithic lunar calendars: A case of wishful thinking? CURRENT ANTHROPOLOGY 30:117-18. [FD, AM]
27. _. 1989c. A reply to Alexander Marshack. CURRENT ANTHROPOLOGY 30:495-500. [FD]
28. _. 1991. Microscopic and statistical criteria for the identification of prehistoric systems of notation. Rock Art Research 8: 83-93. [FD]
29. _. 1992a. A reply to Alexander Marshack. Rock Art Research 9:59-64. [FD]
30. _. 1992b. Technology, motion, and the meaning of Epipaleolithic art. CURRENT ANTHROPOLOGY 33:94-109. [FD, AM]
31. _. 1993a. Analyse technologique de l'art mobilier le cas de l'abri des Cabônes à Ranchot (Jura). Gallia Préhistoire 35:139-76.
32. _. 1993b. La vie sociale de l'art mobilier paléolithique: Manipulation, transport, suspension des objets en os, bois de cervidés, ivoire. Oxford Journal of Archaeology 12:145-74.
33. _. 1995. A new model and its implications for the origin of writing: The La Marche antler revisited. Cambridge Archaeological Journal 5:3-46.
34. D'ERRICO, F. AND C. CACHO. 1994. Notation versus decoration in the Upper Palaeolithic: A case-study from Tossal de la Roca, Alicante, Spain. Journal of Archaeological Science 21:185-200.
35. DERRIDA, JACQUES. 1986. Mémoires: For Paul de Man. Translated by Cecile Lindsay, Jonathan Culler, and Eduardo Cadava. New York: Columbia University Press. [WD]
36. ELKINS, JAMES. 1993a. What really happens in pictures? Misreading with Nelson Goodman. Word and Image 9:349-62. [CBL]
37. _. 1993b. Before theory [review of: Masking the blow, by Whitney Davis (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1992). Art History 16:647-72.
38. _. 1995a. Marks, traces, traits, contours, orli, and splendores: Nonsemiotic elements in pictures. Critical Inquiry 21:822-60.
39. _. 1995b. The signs of writing: On some parallels between the undeciphered prehistoric Vinča script and Andrea Mantegna's The Battle of the Sea Gods. Semiotica. In press.
40. _. 1995c. "Visual schemata," in Encyclopedia of aesthetics. Edited by Michael Kelly. MS.
41. _. 1996. Pictures, and the words that fail them: On the incoherence of images. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. In press.
42. _. n.d. Our beautiful, dry, and distant texts. MS.
43. FLAMAND, G-B-M. 1921. Les pierres écrites (Hadjrat-Mektoubat): Gravures et inscriptions rupestres du nord-africain. Paris: Masson. [WD]
44. FREEMAN, LESLIE G., LEWIS R. BINFORD, AND R. WHITE. 1983. More on the Mousterian: Flaked bone from Cueva Morin. CURRENT ANTHROPOLOGY 24:366-77. [WD]
45. FRY, G. F. 1972. Comment on: Cognitive aspects of Upper Paleolithic engraving, by A. Marshack. CURRENT ANTHROPOLOGY 13:464.
46. GINZBURG, CARLO. 1980. Morelli, Freud, and Sherlock Holmes: Clues and scientific method. History Workshop 9:5-36.
47. _. 1983. "Clues: Morelli, Freud, and Sherlock Holmes." in The sign of three: Dupin - Holmes - Peirce. Edited by U. Eco and T. Sebeok, pp. 81-118. Bloomington: Indiana University Press. [GS]
48. GOMBRICH, E. H. 1960. Art and illusion. Princeton: Bollingen Series/Princeton University Press. [WD]
49. GUNN, JOEL. 1979. Comment on: Upper Paleolithic symbol systems of the Russian Plain, by A. Marshack. CURRENT ANTHROPOLOGY 20:299.
50. HILL, JAMES N., AND JOEL GUNN. Editors. 1977. The individual in prehistory. New York: Cambridge University Press. [WD]
51. ISER, WOLFGANG. 1978. The act of reading: A theory of aesthetic response. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.
52. JOHNSON, BARBARA. 1984. Rigorous unreliability. Critical Inquiry 11:278-85.
53. KOBYLINSKI, ZBIGNIEW, AND URSZULA KOBYLINSKA. 1979. Comment on : Upper Paleolithic symbol systems of the Russian Plain, by A. Marshack. CURRENT ANTHROPOLOGY 20: 301.
54. LEROI-GOURHAN, A. 1993. Gesture and speech. Cambridge: MIT Press. [RW]
55. LEWIS-WILLIAMS, J., AND T. DOWSON. 1989. Theory and data: A brief critique of A. Marshack's research methods and position on Upper Paleolithic shamanism. Rock Art Research 6:42-50.
56. LITTAUER, MARY AIKEN. 1974. On Upper Paleolithic engraving. Anthropology Today 15:328.
57. LYNCH, THOMAS F. 1972. Comment on: Cognitive aspects of Upper Paleolithic engraving, by A. Marshack. CURRENT ANTHROPOLOGY 13:467.
58. MARSHACK, ALEXANDER. 1972a. The roots of civilization: The cognitive beginnings of man's first art, symbol, and notation. New York: McGraw-Hill.
59. _. 1972b. Cognitive aspects of Upper Paleolithic engraving. CURRENT ANTHROPOLOGY 13:445-77.
60. _. 1973. Analyse préliminaire d'une gravure à système de notation de la grotte du Täi (St. Nazaire-en-Royans, Drôme). Etudes Préhistoriques 4:13-17. [AM]
61. _. 1974. "The Chamula calendar board: An internal and comparative analysis," in Mesamerican archaeology: New approaches. Edited by Norman Hammond, pp. 255-70. Austin: University of Texas Press.
62. _. 1975. Exploring the mind of Ice Age man. National Geographic 147(1):62-89. [AM]
63. _. 1976. Some implications of the Paleolithic symbolic evidence for the origin of language. CURRENT ANTHROPOLOGY 17:274-82.
64. _. 1977. "The meander as a system: The analysis and recognition of iconographic units in Upper Paleolithic compositions," in Form in indigenous art. Edited by P. V. Ucko, pp. 286-317. Canberra: Australian Institute of Aboriginal Studies.
65. _. 1979a. Upper Paleolithic symbol systems of the Russian Plain: Cognitive and comparative analysis. CURRENT ANTHROPOLOGY 20:271-95.
66. _. 1979b. Reply [to commentators]. CURRENT ANTHROPOLOGY 20:303.
67. _. 1984. Concepts théoriques conduisant à de nouvelles méthodes analytiques, de nouveaux procédés de recherche et catégories de données. L'Anthropologie 88:85-100. [WD]
68. _. 1985a. A lunar-solar year calendar stick from North America. American Antiquity 50:27-51.
69. _. 1985b. Hierarchical evolution of the human capacity: The Paleolithic evidence. (Fifty-fourth James Arthur Lecture on "The Evolution of the Human Brain," 1984.) New York: American Museum of Natural History. [AM]
70. _. 1987. "L'évolution et la transformation du décor du début de l'Aurignacien au Magdalénien final," in L'ait des objets au Paléolithique, vol. 2, Les voies de la recherche. Edited by Jean Clottes, pp. 140-62. Paris: Musées de France.
71. _. 1988a. "Paleolithic image," in Encyclopedia of human evolution and prehistory. Edited by Ian Tattersall et al., pp. 421-19. New York: Garland.
72. _. 1988b. "North American Indian calendar sticks: The evidence for a widely distributed tradition," in World archaeoastronomy. Edited by Anthony Aveni, pp. 308-24. New York: Cambridge University Press.
73. _. 1989. On wishful thinking and lunar "calendars." CURRENT ANTHROPOLOGY 30:491.
74. _. 1991a. The Taï plaque and calendrical notation in the Upper Paleolithic. Cambridge Archaeological Journal 1:25-61.
75. _. 1991b. 2d edition, revised and expanded. The roots of civilization: The cognitive beginnings of man's first art, symbol, and notation. Mount Kisco, N.Y.: Moyer Bell.
76. _. 1991c. The female image, a "time-factored" symbol: A study in style and aspects of image use in the Upper Paleolithic. Proceedings of the Prehistoric Society 57(1):17-31.
77. _. 1992a. "The analytical problem of subjectivity in the maker and user," in The limitations of archaeological knowledge. Edited by Talia Shay and Jean Clottes, pp. 181-210. Paris: Université de Liège.
78. _. 1922b. A reply to F. d'Errico. Rock Art Research 9: 37-59. [FD]
79. _. 1994. Comment on: Symboling and the Middle-Upper Paleolithic transition, by A. M. Byers. CURRENT ANTHROPOLOGY 35:386-87.
80. _. 1995a. Öküzini: Categorical variation in the symbolic imagery," in Fouilles à Öküzini: Une site du Paléolithique final au sud de la Turquie. In press.
81. _. 1995b. Images of the Ice Age. Archaeology 40(4):28-39.
82. _. 1995c. Methodology and the search for notation among engraved pebbles on the European Late Palaeolithic. Antiquity 69.
83. _. 1996a. The La Marche antler: D'Errico's re-analysis reviewed. Cambridge Archaeological Journal 6(1).
84. _. 1996b. A Middle Paleolithic symbolic composition from the Golan Heights: The earliest known depictive image. CURRENT ANTHROPOLOGY 37:357-65.
85. MINNAERT, M. 1954. The nature of light and colour in the open air. Translated by H. M. Kremer-Priest, revised by K. E. Brian Jay. New York: Dover.
86. MORELLI, GIOVANNI [IVAN LERMOLIEFF]. 1886. Le opere dei maestri italiani nelle, gallerie di Monaco, Dresda, e Berlino. Bologna: N. Zanichelli. [WD]
87. MOVIUS, HALLAM L. 1972. Comment on: Cognitive aspects of Upper Paleolithic engraving, by A. Marshack. CURRENT ANTHROPOLOGY 13:486.
88. MUNN, N. 1973. Walbiri iconography: Graphic representation, and cultural symbolism in a Central Australian society. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. [RW]
89. O'FARRELL, M., AND R. WHITE. 1995. "Experimental and microscopic approaches to Early Aurignacian repetitive marking: The comparison of two objects from Abri Blanchard," in Les industries sur matières dures animales. Edited by H. Camps-Fabrer, P. Cattelain, and C. Bellier. Liège: ERAUL. [RW]
90. PALES, L. 1969. Les gravures de la Marche. Vol. 1. Félins et ours. Bordeaux: Delmas. [RW]
91. _. 1976. Les gravures de la Marche. Vol. 2. Les humains. Paris: Ophrys. [RW]
92. _. 1981. Les gravures de la Marche. Vol. 3, Equidés et bovidés. Paris: Ophrys. [RW]
93. _. 1989. Les gravures de la Marche. Vol. 4. Cervidés, mammouths et divers. Paris: Ophrys. [RW]
94. PILLING, ARNOLD R. 1972. Reply [to Marshack 1972b]. CURRENT ANTHROPOLOGY 13:469.
95. PREZIOSI, DONALD. 1989. Rethinking art history: Meditations on a coy science. New Haven: Yale University Press.
96. SCHMANDT-BESSERAT, DENISE. 1992. Before writing. Vol. I. From counting to cuneiform. Austin: University of Texas Press.
97. SCHIFFER, MICHAEL B. 1987. Formation processes of the archaeological record. Albuquerque: University of New Mexico Press. [WD]
98. SCHIFF, RICHARD. 1989. On criticism handling history. History of the Human Sciences 2(1):63-87. [DC]
99. SONESSON, GÖRAN. 1989. Pictorial concepts. Lund: Lund University Press. [GS]
100. _. 1994a. Prolegomena to the semiotic analysis of prehistoric visual displays. Semiotica 100-2/4:267-331. [GS]
101. _. 1994b. "On pictoriality: The impact of the perceptual model in the development of visual semiotics," in Advances in visual semiotics. Edited by T. Sebeok and J. Umiker-Sebeok, pp. 67-108. Berlin and New York: Mouton de Gruyter. [GS]
102. _. 1995. An essay on images. From rhetoric to semiotics by way of ecological physics. Semiotica. In press. [GS]
103. STATEN, HENRY, 1990. The birth of tragedy reconstructed. Studies in Romanticism 29:9-37.
104. VENCL, SLAVOMIL. 1972. Comment on: Cognitive aspects of Upper Paleolithic engraving, by A. Marshack. CURRENT ANTHROPOLOGY 13:470.
105. WHITE, RANDALL. 1982. The manipulation of burins in incision and notation. Canadian Journal of Anthropological/Revue Canadienne d'Anthropologie 2:129-35.
106. WHITE, R. 1994. Les archives paléolithiques. La Recherche 25: 746-50. [RW]
107. WITTGENSTEIN, LUDWIG. 1983. Remarks on the foundation of mathematics. Edited by G. H. von Wright, R. Rhees, and G. E. M. Anscombe. Cambridge: MIT Press.