Do road planners produce more 'Honest numbers' than rail planners? An analysis of accuracy in road-traffic forecasts in cities versus peripheral regions

Transport Reviews

Volumn 26, Issue 5, 2006, Pages 537-555

  Næss, Petter ^a   Flyvbjerg, Bent ^b   Buhl, Søren ^b  

^a NORWEGIAN INSTITUTE FOR URBAN AND REGIONAL RESEARCH   (Norway)

^b AALBORG UNIVERSITY   (Denmark)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

FORECASTING METHOD; METROPOLITAN AREA; TRAFFIC MANAGEMENT;

EURASIA; EUROPE;

EID: 33747055353     PISSN: 01441647     EISSN: 14645327     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1080/01441640500532005     Document Type: Review

References (53)

1. Arge, N. and Homleid, T. and Stølan, A.(2000) Modeller på randen ... Bruk av transportmodeller i norske byområder. En evaluering. Oslo: Civitas.
2. Ascher, W.(1979) Forecasting: An Appraisal for Policy-makers and Planners. Baltimore MD: John Hopkins University Press.
3. Bøgelund, P. and Gudmundsson, H. and Hansen, C. J. and Sørensen, C. H. and Tengstr̈m, E.(2002) Bæredygtig transport - perspektiver fra forskningen. Copenhagen: Danish Transport Council.
4. Bonsall, P. and Milne, D.(2003) Urban road user charging and workplace parking levies. In Integrated Futures and Transport Choices. (pp. 259-286). Aldershot: Ashgate.
5. Cairns, S. and Atkins, S. and Goodwin, P. (2002) Disappearing traffic? The story so far Municipal Engineer, 151((1)), pp. 13-21.
6. County of North Jutland.(2004) Comments on a complaint to the Naturklagenævnet about the EIA for the Third Limfjord Crossing. Aalborg: County of North Jutland.
7. Danermark, B. and Ekström, M. and Jakobsen, L. and Karlsson, J., Ch.(2001) Explaining Society: Critical Realism in the Social Sciences. London/New York: Routledge.
8. Department for Transport.(1998) A New Deal for Transport: Better for Everyone. The Government's White Paper on the Future of Transport. London: HMSO.
9. Department for Transport (UK).(2005) Roads and Traffic. Available at: (accessed on 20 May 2005).
10. Engebretsen, Ø. and Lian, O. and Strand, S.(1998) Samferdsel og robuste bo-og arbeidsmarkedsregioner. Oslo: Institute of Transport Economics. TøI Working Paper TR/0802/1998
11. European Environment Agency.(2001) TERM 2001. Indicators on Transport and Environment Integration in the EU. Available at: (accessed on 29 December 2004).
12. European Union.(2004) EU Structural Funds. Available at: (accessed on 29 December 2004).
13. Farsund, A. A.(2002). Landbruksvareindustrien som aktør i landbrukspolitikken: Fra korporatisme til pluralisme?. paper presented at the 13th Nordiske Statskundskabskongres AalborgDenmarkAugust15-172002. In [pp.]. Available at:
14. Flyvbjerg, B. (2002) Bringing power to planning research: One researcher's praxis story Journal of Planning Education and Research, 21, pp. 353-366.
15. Flyvbjerg, B. (2005a) Measuring inaccuracy in travel demand forecasting: methodological considerations regarding ramp up and sampling Transportation Research A, 39, pp. 522-530.
16. Flyvbjerg, B.(2005b) Beyond the planning fallacy: Reference class forecasting in practice. In. (draft paper in progress)
17. Flyvbjerg, B. and Bruzelius, N. and Rothengatter, W.(2003) Megaprojects and Risk. An Anatomy of Ambition. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
18. Flyvbjerg, B. and Holm, M. S. and Buhl, S. (2002) Underestimating costs in public works projects: Error or lie? Journal of the American Planning Association, 68, pp. 279-295.
19. Flyvbjerg, B. and Holm, M. S. and Buhl, S. (2005) How (in)accurate are demand forecasts in public works projects? The case of transportation Journal of the American Planning Association, 71, pp. 131-146.
20. Fouracre, P. R. and Allport, R. J. and Thomson, J. M.(1990) The Performance and Impact of Rail Mass Transit in Developing Countries. Workingham: TRRL. Research Report No. 278
21. Goodwin, P. and Hallett, S. and Kenny, F. and Stokes, G.(1991) Transport: The new realism, report no. 624. Oxford: University of Oxford, Transport Studies Unit.
22. Johansson, H. and Nilsson, L.(2004) Klimastrategi för vägsektorn. Borlänge: Swedish Highway Directorate. Publication No. 2004:102. Available at: (accessed on 24 May 2002).
23. Kenworthy, J.(1990) Don't shoot me-I'm only the transport planner. In Transport Energy Conservation. Perth: Murdoch University.
24. Ministry of the Environment (Norway).(1993) Governmental Policy Provisions on Coordinated Land Use and Transport Planning. Oslo: Ministry of the Environment.
25. Ministry of the Environment (Norway).(2002) St. meld. nr. 23 (2001-2002) Bedre miljø i byer og tettsteder. Oslo: Ministry of the Environment.
26. Ministry of Transport (Denmark).(1990) Transporthandlingsplan [Transport Action Plan]. Copenhagen: Ministry of Transport.
27. Ministry of Transport (Denmark). (1993) Trafik 2005. Problemstillinger, mål og strategier. Copenhagen: Ministry of Transport.
28. Ministry of Transport (Denmark).(2003) Trafikministeriets sektoranalyse af vejområdet. Copenhagen: Ministry of Transport.
29. Ministry of Transport (Norway).(2002) St. meld. nr 26 (2001-2002) Bedre kollektivtransport. Oslo: Ministry of the Environment.
30. Mogridge, M. J. H. (1997) The self-defeating nature of urban road capacity policy. A review of theories, disputes and available evidence Transport Policy, 4, pp. 5-23.
31. Næss, P.(2004) Bedre behovsanalyser. Erfaringer og anbefalinger om behovsanalyser i store offentlige investeringsprosjekter. Oslo: Norwegian Institute for Urban and Regional Research. NIBR Report No. 2004:15
32. Næss, P.(2005) Maps of investigated road links in the project 'Systematism in the lop-sidedness?' In. Oslo: Norwegian Institute for Urban and Regional Research. Unpublished Working Paper, March 2005
33. Næss, P. (2006) Cost-benefit analyses of transportation investments: Neither critical nor realistic Journal of Critical Realism, 5((1)). (forthcoming).
34. Næss, P. and Mogridge, M. J. H. and Sandberg, S. L. (2001) Wider roads, more cars Natural Resources Forum, 25((2)), pp. 147-155.
35. Newman, P. W. G. and Kenworthy, J. R.(1989) Cities and Automobile Dependence. Aldershot: Gower.
36. Nielsen, O. A. and Fosgerau, M.(2005). Overvurderes tidsbenefit af vejprojekter? [Is the time benefit of road projected exaggerated?]. paper presented at the Conference Trafikdage på August 22-23 2005. In [pp.].
37. Noland, R. B. and Lem, L. L. (2002) A review of the evidence for induced travel and changes in transportation and environmental policy in the US and the UK Transportation Research Part D, 7, pp. 1-26.
38. Nordjyllands Amt, Aalborg Kommune and Vejdirektoratet.(2003) VVM-redegørelse til 3. Limfjordsforbinelse.
39. NOU.(1999) Gardermoprosjektet. Evaluering av planlegging og gjennomføring [The Gardermoen Airport High-speed Rail Line. Evaluation of Planning and Implementation]. NOU 1999:28. Available at:
40. Nyborg, K. and Spangen, I.(1993) Politiske beslutninger om investeringer i veger [Political decisions on road investments]. Oslo: Institute of Economics. TøI-notat 1026/1993
41. Olsen, J. P. (1992) Analysing institutional dynamics Statswissenscaften und Staatspraxsis, 2, pp. 247-271.
42. Owens, S. (1995) From 'predict and provide' to 'predict and prevent'?: pricing and planning in transport policy Transport Policy, 2((1)), pp. 43-49.
43. Richardson, T. (2001) The pendulum swings again: In search of new transport rationalities Town Planning Review, 72, pp. 299-319.
44. SACTRA.(1999) Transport and the Economy. London: Standing Advisory Committee on Trunk Road Appraisal.
45. Strand, A. and Moen, B.(2000) Lokal samordning - finnes den?. Oslo: Norwegian Institute for Urban and Regional Research. Prosjektrapport 2000:18
46. Tappe, M.(2001). Fuel qualities in Europe from the environmental view point. paper presented at the 3rd International Colloquium Fuels, Technische Akademie Esslingen January17-18 2001. In [pp.]. Available at: (accessed on 24 May 2005).
47. Tengström, E.(1999) Towards Environmental Sustainability? A Comparative Study of Danish, Dutch and Swedish Transport Policies in a European context. Aldershot: Ashgate.
48. Tennøy, A.(2003). Bidrar bruk av transportanalyser i byplanleggingen til vekst i biltrafikken?. paper presented at the Conference 'Trafikdage på Aalborg universitet' August 25-26 2003. In [pp.].
49. Thomsen, J. P. F.(2000) Magt og indflydelse. Århus: Magtudredningen.
50. Vejdirektoratet.(1982) Perspektivplan for hovedlandevejene. Copenhagen: Danish Highway Directorate.
51. Vigar, G.(2001) The Politics of Mobility: Transport Planning, the Environment and Public Policy. London: Routledge.
52. Wachs, M. (1989) When planners lie with numbers Journal of the American Planning Association, 55, pp. 476-479.
53. Whitelegg, J.(1997) Critical Mass. Transport, Environment and Society in the Twenty-first Century. London: Pluto.