Abortion in Jewish religious law: Neighborly love, Imago Dei, and a hypothesis on the medieval blood libel

Review of Rabbinic Judaism

Volumn 8, Issue 1, 2005, Pages 1-34

  Barilan, Y Michael ^a  

^a TEL AVIV UNIVERSITY   (Israel)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 33746900545     PISSN: 15684857     EISSN: 15700704     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1163/157007005774513963     Document Type: Article

References (160)

1. YJ. Weinberg, Seridei Esh (Jerusalem, 1966), vol. 3, resp. 127.
2. Unterman, discussed below. A. Lichtenstein, "Induced Abortions-Halakhic Views" in T'humin (2001) 21, pp. 93-99.
3. An English translation is available at http://www.vbm-torah.org/halakha/ abortion.htm.
4. A.S. Koydnover, Emunath Shmu'el (Lember, 1885), res. 14.
5. B.M.H. Uziel, Mishpatei Uziel, part 4 (Jerusalem, 2000), resp. 46.
6. D. Schiff, Abortion in Judaism (Cambridge, 2002).
7. D.B. Sinclair, Jewish Biomedical Law: Legal and Extra-Legal Aspects (Oxford, 2003), chaps. 1-3.
8. Y.M. Barilan, "Her Sorrow Comes First: Abortion in Halakhah and Israeli Law," in Re'fuah U'mishpat, (2003) 29, pp. 72-101.
9. B. San. 52a. Sages debated capital punishment. Aqiba declared, "If I were a judge, nobody would ever be executed" (Y. Mak. 1:8).
10. I. Tranni, Shut Ma'harit (Lemberg, 1861), part I, resp. 97, 99.
11. E. Waldenberg, Tzitz Elie'zer, part 18 (Jerusalem, 1993), resp. 31.
12. Y.H. Bachrach, Havoth Ya'ir (Lemberg, 1894), resp. 31,
13. J.Z. Emdin, She'ilath Ya'avetz (Lemberg, 1888), part I, resp. 43.
14. Y.H.E. Hacham, Rav pe'alim (Jerusalem, 1901).
15. E. Westermarck, The Origin and Development of Moral Ideas (2nd ed.; London, 1912), vol. I, pp. 413-415.
16. M.E. Wiesner, Women and Gender in Early Modern Europe (Cambridge, 1993), p. 51.
17. J. Ayyash. Beth Ye'hudah (Livorno, 1746). Eben Ha'Ezer, resp. 14.
18. L. Cannold, The Abortion Myth: Feminism, Morality, and the Hard Choices Women Make (Hanover, 1995).
19. W.R. LaFleur, Liquid Life: Abortion and Buddhism in Japan (Princeton, 1992).
20. R J. Simon, Abortion: Statutes, Policies, and Public Attitudes the World Over (Westport, 1998), ch. 1.
21. S. Israeli, Amud Ha'Ye'mi'ni (Tel Aviv, 1966) resp. 32.
22. Y.M. Barilan, "Revisiting the Problem of Jewish Bioethics: The Case of Terminal Care," in Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal (2003) 13, pp. 143-170.
23. I.Y. Unterman, "On Pikuah Nefesh of the Fetus," in Noam (1963) 6, pp. 2-11.
24. M. Zweig, "On Induced Abortion," in Noam (1964) 7, pp. 35-56.
25. M. Feinstein, Iggroth Moshe, vol. VII (Bnei Berak, 1985), Hoshen Mishpath part B, resp. 69.
26. N. Bar Ilan, R. Koffman, and Y.M. Barilan, "The Very Low Birth Weight Neonate," in Assia (2004) 63-4, pp. 94-103.
27. MJ. Gorman, Abortion and the Early Church: Christian, Jewish and Pagan Attitudes in the Greco-Roman World (Eugene, 1998), p. 56.
28. A.S. Abraham, Nishmath Abraham (Jerusalem, 1986), vol. C, Hoshen Mishpat, p. 229.
29. J. Ariel, B'Ohala shel Torah (Kfar Darom, 1998), Hoshen Mishpat, resp. 116.
30. J. Schorr. Ko'ah Shor (Lvov, 1755), resp. 20.
31. M.A. Warren, "The Moral Significance of Birth," in Hypatia (1989) 4, pp. 46-61.
32. L.M. Prudy, "Are Pregnant Women Fetal Containers?" in Bioethics (1990) 4, pp. 273-291.
33. P. Carrick, Medical Ethics in Antiquity (Dordrecht, 1985), pp. 112-19.
34. E. Jakobovitz, Jewish Medical Ethics (new ed.; New York, 1975), pp. 45-46.
35. R. Dworkin, Life's Dominion: An Argument about Abortion, Euthanasia and Individual Freedom (New York, 1993), ch. 3, and J. Kleinig, Valuing Life (Princeton, 1991).
36. D.M. Carr, The Erotic Word: Sexuality, Spirituality and the Bible (Oxford, 2003).
37. Y. Lorberbaum, Image of God: Halakhah and Aggadah [Hebrew] (Tel Aviv, 2004).
38. AJ. Heschel, Between God and Man: An Interpretation of Judaism (New York, 1959), p. 235.
39. Y.M. Barilan, "Revisiting the Problem of Jewish Bioethics," pp. 143-70.
40. Y.M. Barilan, "The Vision of Vegetarianism and Peace: Rabbi Kook on the Ethical Treatment of Animals," in History of the Human Sciences (2004) 17(4), pp. 79-101.
41. Y.M. Barilan and G. Siegal, "Stem Cell Research: An Israeli Perspective," in W. Bender, C. Hauskeller, L. Manzei, eds., Crossing Borders. Cultural, Religious and Political Differences Concerning Stem Cell Research (Munster, 2005), pp. 221-52.
42. D. Platski, Kli Hemda (Pieterkow, 1927) on Deut. 33:1.
43. I. Efros, "Maimonides Treatise on Logic," in Proceedings of the American Academy of Jewish Research (1938) 8, pp. 34-65.
44. J.B. Schneewind, The Invention of Autonomy: A History of Modern Moral Philosophy (Cambridge, 1998), pp. 78-81.
45. J.T. Noonan, Contraception: A History of Its Treatment by Catholic Theologians and Canonists (Cambridge, 1986).
46. J.E. Salisbury, "The Latin Doctors of the Church and Sexuality," in Journal of Medieval History (1986), 12, pp. 279-89.
47. Biale, Eros and the Jews: From Biblical Israel to Contemporary America (New York, 1992), ch. 2,
48. D. Boyarin. Carnal Israel: Reading Sex in Talmudic Culture (Berkeley, 1993).
49. Gendering Desire and 'Sexuality' in the Hebrew Bible (Leiden, 1997), pp. 87-89.
50. S. HaCohen, Meshech Chokhma. Edited by J. Kupperman (Jerusalem, 1977) on Gen. 9:7.
51. J. Cohen, Be Fertile and Increase, Fill the Earth and Master It: An Ancient and Medieval Career of a Biblical Text (Ithaca, 1989), pp. 224ff and 268-69.
52. R.M. Hare, "Abortion and the Golden Rule," in Philosophy and Public Affairs (1975) 4, pp. 201-22.
53. S. Hibner, "Aborting the Fetus to Save the Mother" (in Hebrew), in HaDarom (1969) 28, pp. 31-42.
54. S. Carmy, "Halakhah and Philosophical Approaches to Abortion," in Tradition (1977) 16, pp. 126-57.
55. J.D. Bleich, Contemporary Halakhic Problems (New York, 1977).
56. J.D. Bleich, "Stem Cell Research," in Tradition (2002) 36, pp. 56-83.
57. D. Sinclair, "The Legal Basis for the Prohibition of Abortion in Jewish law," in Israel Law Review (1980) 15, pp. 109-30,
58. Cf. Hume's assertion that justice is an "artificial duty" since it necessitates arbitrary divisions. D. Hume, A Treatise on Human Nature (Oxford, 1740/1978) p. 529.
59. H. Eilberg-Schwartz, God's Phallus (Boston, 1994), pp. 215-22.
60. A.S. Abraham, Nishmath Abraham, Orah Haim (Jerusalem, 1997), #330.
61. I. Zilberstein, "Coercing Cesarean Surgery in Order to Save the Fetus," in Assia (1999) 17 (65-66), pp. 9-12.
62. B. Tierney, The Idea of Natural Rights (Grand Rapids, 1997), p. 23,
63. J. Finnis, Natural Law and Natural Rights (Oxford, 1980), p. 206.
64. I. Ettlinger, Binyan Zion (Altona, 1868), res. 120.
65. M. Feinstein, Iggroth Moshe, part 2 (New York, 1961), Yore De'ah, resp. 332.
66. J.J. Thomson, "A Defense of Abortion," in Philosophy and Public Affairs (1971) 1, pp. 47-66.
67. B. Freedman, Duty and Healing: Foundations of a Jewish Bioethics (London, 1999), pp. 54-55.
68. J.H. Aveling, English Midwives: Their History and Prospects (London, 1872), p. 9.
69. Y.M. Barilan and M. Weintraub, "Pantagruelism: A Rabelaisian Inspiration for Understanding Poisoning, Euthanasia and Abortion in the Hippocratic Oath and in Contemporary Clinical Practice," in Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics (2001) 22, pp. 269-86.
70. Y.H. El-Haham, Rav Pe'alim, part IV (Jerusalem, 1913), Yore De'ah, #14.
71. S. Pines, The Oath of Asaf the Physician and Yohanan ben Zabda (Jerusalem, 1975).
72. e.g., M.J. O'Dowd, The History of Obstetrics and Gynecology (New York 1997), pp. 157-65,
73. V.L. Bullough and J.A. Brundage, eds., Handbook of Medieval Sexuality (New York, 1996).
74. J.S. Milne, Surgical Instruments in Greek and Roman Times (Oxford, 1907), pp. 81ff.
75. E. Shorter, A History of Women's Bodies (New York, 1982), ch. 5.
76. W. Perkins, Midwifery and Medicine in Early Modern France: Louise Bourgeois (Exeter, 1996), p. 66.
77. B. Rowland, Medieval Woman's Guide to Health: The First English Gynecological Handbook (London, 1981), p. 127.
78. R. Blumenfeld-Kosinski, Not of Woman Born: Representations of Caesarean Birth in Medieval and Renaissance Culture (Ithaca, 1990).
79. D. Trolle, The History of Cesarean Section (Copenhagen, 1982), pp. 157ff.
80. R.E. Wright-St. Claire, "A History of Mutilating Obstetric Operations," in New Zealand Medical Journal (1963) 62, pp. 468-70.
81. J.H. Young, Caesarean Section: The History and Development of the Operation from Earliest Times (London, 1944), pp. 74ff.
82. H.H. Ploss, M. Bartels and P. Bartels, Woman: An Historical, Gynecological, Anthropological Compendium (London, 1935), vol. 2 and beginning of vol. 3.
83. H. Speert, Obstetrics and Gynecology in America: A History (Chicago, 1980), pp. 63, 155.
84. F.B. Smith, The People's Health: 1830-1910 (rev. ed.; London, 1990), pp. 17-27.
85. O. Moscucci, The Science of Woman: Gynecology and Gender in England 1800-1929 (Cambridge, 1990), p. 142.
86. N.M. Filippini, Tra madre e figlio: la rivoluzione del taglio cesareo (sec. XVIII-XIX) (Milan, 1995), p. 236.
87. I. Loudon, Death in Childbirth: An International Study of Maternal Care and Maternal Mortality 1800-1950 (Oxford, 1992), pp. 132-43.
88. H.B. Dewing, trans., Procopius: The Anecdota or Secret History (London, 1935),
89. F. Adams, trans., The Seven Books of Paulus Aegineta (London, 1844), vol. II, p. 389.
90. R.J. Deferrari, ed., St. Basil, Letters (London, 1930),
91. T.S. Miller, The Birth of the Hospital in the Byzantine Empire (Baltimore, 1985), p. 213.
92. JJ. Thomson, "Killing, Letting Die and the Trolley Problem," in The Monist (1976) 59, pp. 204-17,
93. "The Trolley Problem," in Yale Law Journal (1985) 94, pp. 1395-415.
94. P. Unger, Living High and Letting Die (Oxford, 1996).
95. A.H. Deutch, Pri Ha'sadeh (Tulma, 1915), part IV, p. 24.
96. A. Steinberg, Encyclopedia of Medicine and Halakhah (Jerusalem, 1995), vol. II, p. 82, note 86.
97. J.C. Robertson, trans., Miracles for the History of Thomas Becket (London, 1875), vol. I, p. 504.
98. D.I. Kertzer, Sacrificed for Honor: Italian Infant Abandonment and the Politics of Reproductive Control (Boston, 1993), p. 20.
99. Y.M. Halevi-Epstein, Aruch HaShulhan. Orah Haim (Warsaw, 1908), #330, 8.
100. J. Jakobowitz, Jewish Medical Ethics (New York, 1959), pp. 130-31.
101. S. Duran, Tashbetz, hut Ha'Meshulash (Lemberg, 1891), part I, resp. 110.
102. A.E. Harkavi, Teshuvoth HaGeonim (Berlin, 1887), #508.
103. N. Bar Ilan, "On a Donor of a Liver and a Heart," in Assia (1990) pp. 47-48, 131-41.
104. I.L. MacKinney, "Childbirth in the Middle Ages as Seen in Manuscript Illustrations," in Ciba Symposium (1960) 8, pp. 5-6.
105. F. Weindler, Geschichte der gynakologisch-anatomischen abbildung (Dresden, 1908).
106. H. Speert, Obstetrics and Gynecology: A History and Iconography (San Francisco, 1994).
107. E. Berroit-Salvadore, "The Discourse of Medicine and Science" in G. Duby, M. Perrot, N. Zemon-Davis, and P. Schmitt-Panel, eds., A History of Women in the West: Renaissance and Enlightenment Paradoxes (Cambridge, 2000), pp. 381-83.
108. P. Gall, L'iconografia del taglio cesareo (Milan, 1936), p. 51.
109. T. HaCohen, MaAsse Tuvia (Venice, 1705), book III, ch. 18.
110. C.G. Ryan, "The Chapel and the Operating Room: The Struggle of Roman Catholic Clergy, Physicians, and Believers with the Dilemmas of Obstetric Surgery, 1800-1900," in Bulletin of the History of Medicine (2002) 76, pp. 461-94; citation from p. 467.
111. M. Summers, trans., Malleus Maleficarum (London, 1948), part II, ch. 13.
112. T.R. Forbes, The Midwife and the Witch (New Haven 1966), p. 127.
113. G.J. Fraser, African American Midwifery in the South: Dialogues of Birth, Race and Memory (Cambridge, 1998), pp. 90-91, 98.
114. E.D. Plass, "Forceps and Cesarean Section," in White House Conference on Child Health and Protection (New York, 1933), pp. 215-47.
115. M.C. Pouchelle, The Body and Surgery in the Middle Ages (New Brunswick, 1990), ch. 5.
116. K. Park, "The Criminal and the Saintly Body: Autopsy and Dissection in Renaissance Italy," in Renaissance Quarterly (1994) 47, pp. 1-33.
117. S.D. Goitein, A Mediterranean Society: The Jewish Communities of the Arab World as Portrayed in the Documents of the Cairo Geniza (Berkeley, 1978), vol. 3, p. 232.
118. L.A. Pollock, Forgotten Children: Parent-Child Relations from 1500 to 1900 (Cambridge, 1983), pp. 124ff and 203-12.
119. G. McMurray Gibson, "Scene and Obscene: Seeing and Performing Late Medieval Childbirth," in Viator 29 (1999), pp. 7-24.
120. P. Diepgen, Die frau und frauen-heilkunde in Mittlealter (Stuttgart, 1963).
121. M.L. Price, "Imperial Violence and the Monstrous Mother," in G. Salisbury, E. Donavin, and M.L. Price, eds., Domestic Violence in Medieval Texts (Gainesville, 2002), pp. 272-98.
122. J. Boswell, The Kindness of Strangers: The Abandonment of Children in Western Europe from Late Antiquity to the Renaissance (New York, 1988), p. 329.
123. D.A. Amundsen, Medicine Society and Faith in the Ancient and Medieval Worlds (Baltimore, 1996), p. 63.
124. D.A. Amundesen, "Visogothic Medical Legislation," in Bulletin of the History of Medicine (1971) 45, pp. 553-59.
125. E.g., Boswell, op. cit., and P. Gavitt, "Infant Death in Late Medieval Florence: The Smothering Hypothesis Reconsidered," in C. Jorgensen-Itnyre, ed., Medieval Family Roles (New York, 1996), pp. 137-56.
126. L. Rose, Massacre of the Innocent: Infanticide in Great Britain 1800-1939 (London, 1986), ch. 14.
127. E. Baumgarten, "So Say the Wise Midwives," in Zion 65 (2000), pp. 45-74.
128. E. Baumgarten, Mothers and Children: Jewish Family Life in Medieval Europe (Princeton, 2004), ch. 2.
129. W. Schleiner, Medical Ethics in the Renaissance (Washington, 1995), ch. 3.
130. J. Shatzmiller, Jews, Medicine and Medieval Society (Berkeley, 1995) pp. 121ff.
131. C. Roth, A History of the Jews in England (Oxford, 1941).
132. R.P. Hsia, The Myth of Ritual Murder: Jews and Magic in Reformation Germany (New Haven, 1988).
133. G. Langmuir, History, Religion and Antisemitism (Berkeley, 1990).
134. A. Dundes, ed., The Blood Libel Legend (Madison, 1992).
135. C. Roth, "The Feast of Purim and the Origins of the Blood Accusation," in Speculum (1933) 4, pp. 520-26.
136. M. Schultz, "The Blood Libel: A Motif in the History of Childhood," in Journal of Psychohistory (1986) 14, pp. 1-24.
137. IJ. Yovel, "The Revenge and the Libel," in Zion 48 (1994), pp. 33-90 [Hebrew].
138. J. Soloveitchik, Principles and Pleasures [Hebrew] (Tel Aviv, 2003), pp. 113-21.
139. J. Cohen, The Friars and the Jews: The Evolution of Medieval Anti-Semitism (Ithaca, 1982), pp. 43ff.
140. M. Frank, "Manuscript Anatomic Illustration of the Pre-Vesalian Period," in Choulant, et al., A History and Bibliography of Anatomic Illustration (rev. ed.; New York, 1945), pp. 21ff.
141. R. French and A. Cunningham, Before Science: The Invention of the Friars' Natural Philosophy (Aldershot, 1996).
142. W.S. Heckscher, Rembrandt's Anatomy of Dr. Nicolaas Tulp (New York, 1958), pp. 87, 101.
143. A. Cunningham, The Anatomical Renaissance: The Resurrection of the Anatomical Projects of the Ancients (Aldershot, 1997), p. 147.
144. J.Y. Simpson, "Notes on the Employment of the Inhalation of Sulphoric Ether in the Practice of Midwifery," in Monthly Journal of Medical Science (1847) 7, pp. 721-28.
145. J. Flemming, "Folklore, Fact and Legend," in Irish Journal of Medical Science (1953) 326, pp. 50-63 at 57,
146. J. Sawday, The Body Emblazoned: Dissection and the Human Body in Renaissance Culture (London, 1995).
147. L. Thorndike, University Records and Life in the Middle Ages (New York, 1971), pp. 283-84.
148. J. Berengario da Capri, Commentaria cum apilissimis additionibus super anatomia (Bologna, 1521), p. 518f.
149. C.E. Fonrobert, Menstrual Purity: Rabbinic and Christian Reconstructions of Biblical Gender (Standford, 2000).
150. J. Hauptman. Rereading the Rabbis: A Woman's Voice (Boulder, 1998).
151. E.g., King in Southern California Practitioner (1899), vol. 14, p. 273.
152. C.C. Ekwempu, "Embryotomy Versus Caesaren Section," in Tropical Doctor (1978) 8, pp. 195-97.
153. O.B. Fasubaa, et al., "Analysis of Obstetrical Labor in Wesley Guild Hospital, Ilesha," in Nigeria Journal of Clinical Practice (1999) 2, pp. 39-41.
154. G.S. Melah, et al., "Obstructed Labor: A Public Health Problem in Gombe, Gombe State, Nigeria," in Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology (2003) 23, pp. 369-73.
155. M. Artschwager Kay, ed., Anthropology of Human Birth (Philadelphia, 1982), pp. 193-210.
156. C. Strong, Ethics of Reproductive and Prenatal Medicine (New Haven, 1997), ch. 9.
157. G.J. Engelmann, Labor among Primitive Peoples (St. Louis, 1884), p. 208.
158. Soranus. O. Temkin, ed., Soranos gynaecology (Baltimore, 1956), pp. 189-96 (IV, 9-13).
159. W.G. Spencer, trans., Celsus, De Medicina (Cambridge, 1979), VII, 29.
160. A.T. Riesenberger, "Birth Stools in General and Ovna'im in Particular," in Beth Miqra 3 (1993), pp. 248-53.