From long-term patterns of seasonal hunger to changing experiences of everyday poverty: Northeastern Ghana c. 1930-2000

Journal of African History

Volumn 47, Issue 2, 2006, Pages 181-205

  Destombes, Jérôme ^a  

^a LONDON SCHOOL OF ECONOMICS   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Colonial; Ghana; Postcolonial; Poverty

Indexed keywords

HISTORICAL GEOGRAPHY; HUNGER; NUTRITIONAL STATUS; POST-COLONIALISM; POVERTY;

AFRICA; GHANA; SUB-SAHARAN AFRICA; WEST AFRICA;

EID: 33746104874     PISSN: 00218537     EISSN: 14695138     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1017/S0021853706001800     Document Type: Article

References (159)

1. S. Coll and J. Komlos, 'The biological standard of living and economic development: Nutrition, health and well being in historical perspective', in C. E. Núñez (ed.), Debates and Controversies in Economic History (Madrid, 1998), 219-82
2. R. W. Fogel, 'Economic growth, population theory, and physiology: The bearing of long-term processes on the making of economic policy', American Economic Review, 84 (1994), 383.
3. Nutritional status is defined as 'the outcome of previous nutrition, directly in terms of the presence or absence of deficiency signs, the failure of growth, or some important aspects of functional capacity', in P. Payne, 'Assessing undernutrition: The need for a reconceptualisation', in S. R. Osmani (ed.), Nutrition and Poverty (Oxford, 1992), 54.
4. Poor diet is a gross indicator, based on the quantity and quality of food intake, while undernourishment is a net indicator capturing the balance between this intake and the claims on it, including physical growth, disease, diet and labour. See Fogel, 'Economic growth', 371
5. R. H. Steckel, 'Stature and the standard of living', Journal of Economic Literature, 33 (1995), 1910-11 Literature, 33 (1995), 1910-11
6. J. Strauss and D. Thomas, 'Health, nutrition, and economic development', Journal of Economic Literature, 36 (1998), 775
7. P. Dasgupta, An Inquiry into Well-Being and Destitution (Oxford, 1993), 81-7, 401-511
8. T. N. Srinivasan, 'Destitution: A discourse', Journal of Economic Literature, 32 (1994), 1842-55.
9. P. Richards, Coping with Hunger: Hazard and Experiment in an African Rice-Farming System (London, 1986), 115-30
10. M. Watts, Silent Violence: Food, Famine and Peasantry in Northern Nigeria (Berkeley, 1983), 441-8
11. P. Richards, 'Ecological change and the politics of African land use', African Studies Review, 26 (1983), 45-6.
12. In the same issue, M. Watts, '"Good try, Mr Paul": Populism and the politics of African land use', 78-9.
13. D. Wylie, 'The changing face of hunger in southern African history', Past and Present, 122 (1989), 159-99
14. and Nutrition, Science and Racial Politics: Starving on a Full Stomach: Hunger and the Triumph of Cultural Racism in Modern South Africa (Charlottesville and London, 2001)
15. J. L. Vellut, 'Rural poverty in western Shaba, c. 1890-1930', in Robin Palmer and Neil Parsons (eds.), The Roots of Rural Poverty in Central and Southern Africa (Berkeley and Los Angeles, 1977), 294-316
16. P. Hill, Population, Prosperity and Poverty: Rural Kano 1900 and 1970 (Cambridge, 1977), ch. 11 on extreme poverty, 164-77
17. K. Good, 'The state and extreme poverty in Botswana: The San and destitutes', Journal of Modern African Studies, 37 (1999), 185-205
18. V. Bonnecase, 'Pouvoirs publics, pauvres et pauvreté au Niger dans les années 60', in C. Coquery-Vidrovitch, O. Goerg and C. Tshimanga (eds.), Histoire et devenir de l'Afrique noire au vingtième siècle: Travaux en cours (Paris, 2001), 33-52.
19. Watts, Silent Violence, xxii-xxiii, 4-5, 464
20. S. Rijpma, 'Malnutrition in the history of tropical Africa', Problèmes africains contemporains, 42 (1996), 45-63
21. L. Bigman, History and Hunger in West Africa: Food Production and Entitlement in Guinea-Bissau and Cape Verde (London, 1993)
22. R. Headrick, Colonialism, Health and Illness in French Equatorial Africa, 1885-1935 (Atlanta, 1994), 184-90
23. S. Doyle, 'Population decline and delayed recovery in Bunyoro, 1860-1960', Journal of African History, 41 (2000), 430, 451-3.
24. M. Worboys, 'The discovery of colonial malnutrition between the wars', in D. Arnold (ed.), Imperial Medicine and Indigenous Societies (Manchester, 1988), 208-25
25. C. Brantley, 'Kikuyu-Maasai nutrition and colonial science: The Orr and Gilks study in late 1920s Kenya revisited', International Journal of African Historical Studies, 30 (1997), 49-86
26. and Feeding Families. African Realities and British Ideas of Nutrition and Development in Early Colonial Africa (Portsmouth NH, 2002)
27. V. Berry and C. Petty (eds.), The Nyasaland Survey Papers 1938-1943: Agriculture, Food and Health (London, 1992)
28. V. Berry (ed.), The Culwich Papers 1934-1944: Population, Food and Health in Colonial Tanganika (London, 1994).
29. These two latest publications are reviewed by respectively J. McCracken, 'Nutrition in Nyasaland', Journal of African History, 36 (1995), 157-9
30. and G. H. Maddox, 'A colonial prescription', Journal of African History, 37 (1996), 503-5.
31. Brantley's book is reviewed by M. Vaughan, 'Nutritional research in colonial Malawi', Journal of African History, 45 (2004), 149-50.
32. M. P. Cowen, 'The commercialisation of food production in Kenya after 1945', in R. I. Rotberg, Imperialism, Colonialism and Hunger: East and Central Africa (Lexington MA, 1983), 207-20
33. H. L. Moore and M. Vaughan, Cutting Down Trees: Gender, Nutrition, and Agricultural Change in the Northern Province of Zambia, 1980-1990 (London, 1994), 46-78, 178-205
34. E. Fratkin et al., 'Health consequences of pastoral sedentarization among Rendille of northern Kenya', in D. M. Anderson and V. Broch-Due (eds.), The Poor Are Not Us: Poverty and Pastoralism in Eastern Africa (Oxford, 1999), 151-61
35. M. Chastanet, 'Les crises de subsistence dans les villages soninke du cercle de Bakel, de 1858 à 1945. Problèmes méthodologiques et perspectives de recherches', Cahiers d'études africaines, 23 (1983), 5-36
36. C. Brantley, 'Ben and Maggie: Consuming data. reassessing scientific and anthropological evidence: Historical perspective on nutrition studies', in T. Falola and C. Jennings (eds.), Sources and Methods in African History: Spoken, Written, Unearthed (Rochester NY, 2003), 337.
37. J. Iliffe, The African Poor: A History (Cambridge, 1987), 2-8, 65-81, 143-63, 230-59
38. R. Roberts, 'The poor in African history: Review of J. Iliffe, The African Poor: A History', Journal of African History, 31 (1990), 493-5.
39. A. Ferro-Luzzi and F. Branca, 'Coping with poverty. The biological impact of nutrition insecurity', in M. Livi-Bacci and G. de Santis (eds.), Population and Poverty in the Developing World (Oxford, 1998), 51
40. M. Lipton, P. Payne et al., How Third World Rural Households Adapt to Dietary Energy Stress: The Evidence and the Issues (Washington DC, 1994), International Food Policy Research Institute, Food Policy Review No. 2
41. The Conferees, 'The relationship between nutrition, disease, and social conditions: A graphical presentation', in R. I. Rotberg and T. K. Rabb (eds.), Hunger and History: The Impact of Changing Food Production and Consumption Patterns on Society (Cambridge, 1983), 305-8.
42. P. Hill, Rural Hausa: A Village and a Setting (Cambridge, 1972), 58-60
43. M. Watts, 'The sociology of seasonal food shortage in Hausaland', in R. Chambers et al. (eds.), Seasonal Dimensions to Rural Poverty (London, 1981), 201-6.
44. R. W. Fogel, 'Second thoughts on the European escape from hunger: famines, chronic malnutrition, and mortality rates', in Osmani (ed.), Nutrition, 243-85
45. J. Komlos (ed.), The Biological Standard of Living on Three Continents: Further Explorations in Anthropometric History (Boulder, 1995)
46. D. Eltis, 'Welfare trends among the Yoruba in the early nineteenth century: The anthropometric evidence', Journal of Economic History, 50 (1990), 521-40.
47. P. Svedberg, Poverty and Undernutrition: Theory, Measurement and Policy (Oxford, 2000), 189-98.
48. J. S. Weiner, 'Work and well-being in savanna environments: physiological considerations', in D. R. Harris (ed.), Human Ecology in Savanna Environments (London, 1980), 148-50
49. E. F. Wheeler, 'Nutritional status of savanna people', in Harris (ed.), Human Ecology, 439-55.
50. Iliffe, African Poor, 4.
51. Ibid. 6.
52. Iliffe, African Poor, 161.
53. Moore and Vaughan, Cutting, xvii.
54. P. D. Curtin, 'Nutrition in African history', in Rotberg and Rabb (eds.), Hunger, 173.
55. Brantley, 'Ben and Maggie', 335-45.
56. J. M. Hunter, 'Seasonal hunger in a part of the West African savanna: A survey of bodyweights in Nangodi, north-east Ghana', Transactions (Institute of British Geographers), 41 (1967), 167-85.
57. M. Fortes and S. L. Fortes, 'Food in the domestic economy of the Tallensi', Africa, 9 (1936), 254.
58. Interview (hereafter Int.) 70 with Sandoo Woberug (Tindongo Nayiri section, Zourib lineage). Tapes and transcripts are held by the author.
59. Int. 55 with Yagzoga Woberug (Tindongo Nayiri section, Zourib lineage).
60. M. Fortes, The Dynamics of Clanship among the Tallensi (London, 1945), 8.
61. Fortes and Fortes, 'Food', 260.
62. Public Record Office (hereafter PRO) (now the National Archives), CO 96, 751/14 (1938), Agriculture in North Mamprussi, pamphlet by C. W. Lynn, Agricultural Superintendent (Accra, 1937), 37.
63. Fortes, Dynamics, 12.
64. R. S. Rattray, The Tribes of the Ashanti Hinterland (Oxford, 1932), 1, XV.
65. Lieutenant-Colonel H. P. Northcott, Report on the Northern Territories of the Gold Coast (London, 1899), Intelligence Division, War Office, 13.
66. A. W. Cardinall, The Natives of the Northern Territories of the Gold Coast: Their Customs, Religion and Folklore (London, 1921), 85.
67. Public Records and Archives Administration Department (hereafter PRAAD), Accra branch (hereafter Ac.), ADM 56/1/28, 'Report on the food supply in Frafra', by Captain H. Wheeler, Acting Provincial Commissioner, North Eastern Province, Zuarungu, 31 May 1911.
68. Rattray, Tribes, xiv.
69. A. A. Iliasu, 'The establishment of British administration in Mamprugu, 1898-1937', Transactions of the Historical Society of Ghana, 16 (1975), 1-2
70. R. B. Bening, 'Land policy and administration in northern Ghana, 1898-1976', Transactions of the Historical Society of Ghana, 16 (1975), 234-5.
71. K. Hart, 'The economic basis of Tallensi social history in the early twentieth century', in G. Dalton (ed.), Research in Economic Anthropology (Greenwich CT, 1978), 194, 197, 209.
72. Fortes, Dynamics, 16.
73. J. M. Hunter, 'The clans of Nangodi. A geographical study of the territorial basis of authority in a traditional state of the West African savanna', Africa, 38 (1968), 377-412
74. Rattray, Tribes, 364-73
75. Fortes, Dynamics, 14-16
76. K. Hart, 'Migration and tribal identity among the Frafras [sic] of Ghana', Journal of Asian and African Studies, 6 (1971), 21-2
77. T. E. Hilton, 'Le peuplement de Frafra, district du Nord-Ghana', Bulletin de l'I.F.A.N., 27 sér. B (1965), 678-700
78. J. Goody, 'The political systems of the Tallensi and their neighbours 1888-1915', Cambridge Anthropology, 14 (1990), 7-9, 16-17, 20-2
79. M. Schlottner, '"We stay, others come and go": Identity among the Mamprussi in northern Ghana'
80. and C. Lentz, 'Contested identities: The history of ethnicity in north-western Ghana', in C. Lentz and P. Nugent (eds.), Ethnicity in Ghana: The Limits of Invention (London, 2000), 137-61, 49-67.
81. PRO, CO 96, 751/14, 66-9, 80.
82. Fortes and Fortes, 'Food', 238.
83. Ibid. 254.
84. G. Saunders, 'A report on blindness in Wa and Tumu Districts, Gold Coast, West Africa', Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene, 36 (1933), 5-6
85. K. D. Patterson, 'River blindness in northern Ghana, 1900-50', in G. W. Hartwig and K. D. Patterson (eds.), Disease in African History (Durham NC, 1978), 88-1 17
86. J. M. Hunter, 'River blindness in Nangodi. A hypothesis of cyclical advance and retreat', Geographical Review, 56 (1966), 398-416
87. Destombes, 'Nutrition', 193-211.
88. Destombes, 'Nutrition', 18-20, 51-61
89. N. J. K. Brukum, 'Studied neglect or lack of resources? The socio-economic underdevelopment of northern Ghana under British colonial rule', Transactions of the Historical Society of Ghana, New Series, 2 (1998), 117-31
90. N. K. Plange, 'Underdevelopment in northern Ghana: Natural causes or colonial capitalism?', Review of African Political Economy, 15/16 (1976), 4-14
91. I. Sutton, 'Colonial agricultural policy: The non-development of the Northern Territories of the Gold Coast', International Journal of African Historical Studies, 22 (1989), 637-69.
92. Colonial Office, Report on a Preliminary Economic Survey of the Northern Territories of the Gold Coast, by John R. Raeburn (London, June 1950), 8.
93. W. Birmingham et al., A Study of Contemporary Ghana (London, 1967), 1, 90-2
94. P. L. Davey, 'Household budgets in rural areas', Economic Bulletin of Ghana, 7 (1963), 18.
95. PRAAD, Ac., ADM 56/1/28, 'Report'.
96. PRAAD, Ac., CSO 8/1/12, 'Food supplies in the Northern Territories, 1930-31'.
97. PRAAD, Tamale (hereafter Tam.), NRG 8/11/3, Navrongo, food crop areas (1931), Letter from Dr. W. E. McCulloch, Dietetics Research Office, Nigeria, sent from England, 11 May 1931, Cheshire, to the Chief Commissioner, Tamale, Northern Province, with an attached report, 'Food shortage at Navrongo, Gold Coast', 1, 2, 7.
98. PRAAD, Ac., ADM 56/1/28, 'Report';
99. Cardinall, Natives, 82
100. Fortes and Fortes, 'Food', 247.
101. Cardinall, Natives, 84-5.
102. Rhodes House (hereafter RH), Gold Coast government, Medical Department Annual Reports, 1931-2, 33.
103. Fortes, Dynamics, 7.
104. Ibid.
105. Ibid. 173-5.
106. Colonial Office Reports, Nutrition: Policy in the Colonial Empire, Despatch from the Secretary of State for the Colonies, 18 Apr. 1936, no. 21.
107. PRAAD, Ac., ADM 11/1/1294 (1937-41), Human nutrition, standing committee to study the important question of, Report, 'Northern Territories', Section 1, 26 Nov. 1939, 76
108. Report, 'Diet and Nutrition in Mamprussi', 12 Dec. 1939, 3.
109. J. Destombes, Nutrition and Economic Destitution in Northern Ghana: A Historical Perspective on Nutritional Economics, 1930-1957, London School of Economics and Political Science, Working Papers in Economic History, Jan. 1999, Number 49, 47-9.
110. PRO, CO 859, 68/1, Research survey (nutrition), Gold Coast, note on Dr. F. M. Purcell's report on nutrition in the Gold Coast, hand-written comments by A. I. Richards, 17 Sept. 1941
111. PRAAD, Tam., NRG 18/8/1, Diet and nutrition (1930-57)
112. Letter from J. A. Amstrong, District Commissioner, Dagomba, Yendi, to the Chief Commissioner of the Northern Territories, Tamale, 4 Mar. 1940; note attached to the letter by J. A. Amstrong, which presents the reactions of district officers to Purcell's report; Letter from the Agricultural Superintendent, Samuel N. K. A. Mozu, Department of Agriculture, Zuarungu, to the Chief Commissioner of the Northern Territories, Tamale, 21 Feb. 1940.
113. PRAAD, Ac., ADM 11/1/1294, 'Northern Territories', 75
114. West African Review, June 1946, 'Nutrition in West Africa', 17, no. 225, 618.
115. PRAAD, Ac., ADM 11/1/1294, 77.
116. PRAAD, Ac., ADM 11/1/1294, 'Diet and nutrition in Mamprussi', 64.
117. Ibid. 64-6.
118. A. Ferro-Luzzi, S. Sette, M. Franklin and W. P. T. James, 'A simplified approach of assessing adult chronic energy deficiency', European Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 46 (1992), 177.
119. PRAAD, Ac., ADM 11/1/1294, 'Diet and Nutrition in Mamprussi', 65.
120. PRAAD, Ac., ADM 11/1/1294, 'Northern Territories', 4-5.
121. Destombes, 'Nutrition', 99-102, 185-93.
122. Ibid. 95-7, 126-31
123. B. G. Der, 'Agricultural policy in northern Ghana during the colonial era', Universitas, 8 (1987), 5-6.
124. PRAAD, Ac., ADM 11/1/1294, 'Northern Territories', 65-70
125. Human nutrition on the Gold Coast, Section (Aii), Observations on nutrition by the Medical Department, 25 Feb. 1937, 5-7.
126. PRAAD, Ac., ADM 11/1/1294, 'Northern Territories', 77.
127. Ibid. 74.
128. Colonial Office Reports, Nutrition: Policy in the Colonial Empire, Part I, Cmd. 6050, 34-8, 50-1
129. and Summary of Information Regarding Nutrition in the Colonial Empire, Part II, Cmd. 6051, 37, 123, Economic Advisory Council/Committee on Nutrition in the Colonial Empire, 1939.
130. PRO, CO 96, 751/14, 37, 1.
131. RH, Gold Coast government, Report of the Commission of Inquiry into the Health Needs of the Gold Coast (Accra, 1952), 52-3
132. Report of a joint FAO/WHO mission to Ghana, 27 Oct. - 6 Dec. 1958, by B. S. Platt and J. Mayer, FAO/59/5/3880, May 1959, unpublished, 21.
133. PRAAD, Tam., NRG 9/4/20: Regional Food and Nutrition Board 1961-4, Letter from the Secretary to the Regional Commissioner, Bolgatanga, Upper Region, to A. S. A. Abban, Chairman of the National Food and Nutrition Board, Accra, 26 July 1961.
134. See also P. L. Davey, 'A nutrition survey of Ghana', Economic Bulletin of Ghana, 6 (1962), 15-20.
135. G. M. Culwick, 'Nutrition in East Africa', Africa, 14 (1944), 401.
136. FAO, Report of a joint, 13.
137. Ibid. 12-13.
138. B. M. Nicol, 'The caloric requirements of Nigerian peasant farmers', British Journal of Nutrition, 13 (1959), 304, 306.
139. Davey, 'Nutrition survey'
140. R. Orraca-Tetteh, 'The need for a nutrition policy in national development', Universitas, 1 (1972) 3, 47-67.
141. W. Z. Billewicz, 'A note on body weight measurements and seasonal variation', Human Biology (1967) 39, 241-9.
142. FAO, Report of a joint; Orraca-Tetteh, 'Need', 48-9.
143. Hunter, 'Seasonal hunger', 180-1.
144. Destombes, 'Nutrition', 198
145. Ferro-Luzzi et al., 'Simplified', 177.
146. S. Dercon and P. Krishnan, 'In sickness and in health: Risk sharing within house-holds in rural Ethiopia', Journal of Political Economy, 108 (2000), 693-5.
147. A. E. Dugdale and P. Payne, 'A model of seasonal changes in energy balance', Ecology of Food and Nutrition, 19 (1987), 238
148. T. Alemu and B. Lindt Jøarn, 'Physical activity, illness and nutritional status among adults in a rural Ethiopian community', International Journal of Epidemiology, 24 (1995), 981-2.
149. M. P. Miracle, '"Seasonal hunger": A vague concept and an unexplored problem', Bulletin de l'I.F.A.N., 23 sér. B (1961), 273-83
150. Hunter, 'Seasonal', 183-5
151. Dugdale and Payne, 'Model', 231-2, 238, 241-4
152. P. Payne, 'Public health and functional consequences of seasonal hunger and malnutrition', in D. Sahn (ed.), Seasonal Variability in Third World Agriculture (Baltimore, 1989), 27-32
153. Svedberg, Poverty, 301-10.
154. Ferro-Luzzi and Branca, 'Coping', 55-6.
155. P. A. Higgins and H. Alderman, 'Labour and women's nutrition. The impact of work effort and fertility on nutritional status in Ghana', Journal of Human Resources, 33 (1997), 581-3
156. Ferro-Luzzi et al., 'Simplified', 177.
157. Destombes, 'Nutrition', 173-226.
158. Ibid. 121-31, ch. 4.
159. As David Henige wrote, 'Africanists can hardly afford' not 'to regard all evidence from the past as evidence for the past as well'. In Falola and Jennings (eds.), Sources and Methods, 331.