How to read, understand, and write 'Discussion' sections in medical articles. An exercise in critical thinking

Medical Science Monitor

Volumn 12, Issue 6, 2006, Pages

  Jenicek, Milos ^a  

^a MCMASTER UNIVERSITY   (Canada)

Author keywords

'Discussion' sections in medical articles; Argumentation; Critical thinking in medicine; Medical article writing and interpretation; Uses of evidence appraisal

Indexed keywords

COMPREHENSION; CRITICAL THINKING; MEDICAL LITERATURE; METHODOLOGY; READING; REVIEW; WRITING;

COMPREHENSION; MANUSCRIPTS, MEDICAL; READING; WRITING;

EID: 33744953536     PISSN: 12341010     EISSN: 16433750     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: None     Document Type: Review

References (80)

1. Rosenfeldt FL, Dowling JT, Pepe S, Fullerton MJ: How to write a paper for publication. Heart, Lung and Circulation, 2000; 9: 82-87
2. Perneger TV, Hudelson PM: Writing a research article. Int J Qual Health Care, 2004; 16: 191-92
3. Docherty M, Smith R: The case for structuring the discussion of scientific papers. BMJ, 1999; 318: 1224-25
4. Huth EJ: How to Write and Publish Papers in the Medical Sciences. Philadelphia: iSi Press, 1982
5. Huth EJ: Writing and Publishing in Medicine. Third edition. Previously titled How to Write and Publish Papers in Medical Sciences. Baltimore, MD: Williams & Wilkins, 1999
6. Horton R: The grammar of interpretive medicine. CMAJ,1998; 159: 245-49
7. Jenicek M: A Physician's Self-Paced Guide to Critical Thinking. Chicago: American Medical Association (AMA Press), 2006
8. st Edition 1958)
9. Toulmin S, Rieke R, Janik A: An Introduction to Reasoning. New York and London: Macmillan Publishing Co, Inc. and Collier Macmillan Publishers, 1979
10. Jenicek M, Hitchcock DL: Evidence-Based Practice. Logic and Critical Thinking in Medicine. Chicago: American Medical Association (AMA Press), 2005
11. Ennis RH. Critical Thinking. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall, 1996
12. Critical Thinking Community. A Working Definition of Critical Thinking by Michael Scriven and Richard Paul (for the National Council for Excellence in Critical Thinking). 3 pages retrieved from http://lonestar.texas.net/ ∼mseifert/crit2.html on June 20, 2005
13. Austhink - Critical Thinking on the Web. Definitions. Definitions of "Critical Thinking". 6 pages retrieved from http://www.austhink.org/ critical/pages/definitions.html on December 26, 2005
14. Anon. Critical Thinking Articles: 1958-2001.56 pages retrieved from http://www.bakeru.edu/crit/literature/ct_articles.htm on December 24, 2005
15. Gay JM, Washington State U: WWWeb Leadership. Communication, Grant-Writing, Learning & Critical Thinking Sources. 27 pages retrieved from http://www.vetmed.wsu.edu/courses-jmgay/CTLinks.htm on December 24, 2005.
16. Anon. Critical Thinking Exercises by Academic Discipline. 14 pages retrieved from http://www.librairies.psu.edu/shenango/Critical%20Thinking/ Critical%20Thinking520R... on December 24, 2005
17. Carr CS: CSCA in Legal Education. 8 pages retrieved from http://d3e.open.ac.uk/csc199/Carr/Carr-paper.htm, on December 24, 2005
18. Shankar RD, Musen MA: Justification of automated decision-making: medical explanations as medical arguments. Proc AMIA Symp,1999; 395-99. See also 5 pages retrieved from smi-web.stanford.edu/pubs/SMI_Reports/SMI-1999-0794.pdf
19. Anon. Writing a Scientific Research Paper. 7 pages retrieved from umech.mit.edu/freeman/6.021J/writing/pdf on December 23, 2005
20. FIN-1 Finnish Institutions research Paper (Hopkins). The IMRAD Research Paper Format. 2 pages retrieved from http://www.uta.fi/FAST/FIN/RESEARCH/imrad. html on December 24, 2005
21. UHWO Writing Center. Research Paper Outline. How to write an outline that will write your paper! 3 pages retrieved from http://homepages.uhwo.hawaii.edu/ ~writing/rpoutline.htm on December 24, 2005
22. 2006 New York City Metro Junior Science & Humanities Symposium. Research Paper Requirements and Guidelines. 2 pages retrieved from http://www.nyas.org/pdfs/06_JSHS_Paper_Guidelines.pdf on December 24, 2005
23. Caprette DR: Writing Research Papers. Experimental Biosciences. Introductory Laboratory-Bios 211. Updated May 2005. Retrieved from http://www.ruf.rice.edu/∼bioslabs/tools/reportform.html on December 15, 2005
24. th edition of the APA Manual) 4/11/2004-Version 5.011. APA Style Guide. Retrieved from http://www.uwsp.edu/psych/apa4b.htm on December 15, 2005
25. Cornell Laboratory of Ornithology. Educator's Guide to Bird Study. 9 sections retrieved from http://www.birds.cornell.edu/schoolyard/ 5elements_sci_paper.html on December 25, 2005
26. Writing a Scientific Paper. Chapter 1 in The ACS Style Guide: A Manual for Authors and Editors. Second Edition. Edited by JS Dodd. Washington: American Chemical Society, 1997. Retrieved from http://www.oup.com/us/samplechapters/ 0841234620/?view=usa on December 24, 2005
27. American Chemical Society: Guidelines for Preparing a Research Report. 4 pages retrieved from http://www.chemistry.org/portal/a/c/s/1/acsdisplay.html? DOC=education%5Ccpt%Cts_... on December 24, 2005
28. CHEMINFO (Indiana University). Guides for Better Science Writing. 7 pages retrieved from http://www.indiana.edu/~cheminfor/14-05.html on December 24, 2005
29. Wenderoth P: How to Write a Scientific Research Paper. 10 pages retrieved from http://vision.psy.mq.edu.au/~peterw on December 23, 2005
30. Anon. Writing a Scientific Paper. Adapted from Cox (1990). 5 pages retrieved from http://biology.luther.edu/paper.htm on December 24, 2005
31. Anon. Writing a Scientific Research Article. 5 pages retrieved from http://www.columbia.edu/cu/biology/ug/research/paper.html on December 24, 2005
32. Anon. Writing a Scientific Research Article. 6 pages retrieved from http:/www.mrcphth.com/publishorperish/overview.html on December 24, 2005
33. Steingraber S, Jolls C, Goldberg D et al: Guidelines for Writing Scientific Papers. Appendix E (Human Organismal Biology Laboratory, pp. 185-92). 8 pages retrieved from www.bms.bc.ca/library/ Guidelines%20for20%writing%20scientific%20papers.pdf on December 25, 2005
34. Wooton L: Writing a Scientific Paper. 7 pages retrieved from http://www.dentistry.leeds.ac.uk/elective/WRITE%20UP.htm on December 25, 2005
35. Department of Biology, Bates College. The Structure, Formal, Content, and Style of a Journal-Style Scientific Paper. 16 pages retrieved from http://abacus.bates.edu/~ganderso/biology/resources/writing/HTWsections.html on December 25, 2005
36. Lertzman K: Notes on Writing Papers and Theses. 11 pages retrieved from http://aerg.canberra.edu.au/pub/aerg/edulertz.htm on December 24, 2005
37. Rudner LM: Practical Assessment, Research & Evaluation. 5 pages retrieved from http://pareonline.net/getvn.asp?v=6&n=13 on December 24, 2005
38. Haynes RB, Mulrow CD, Huth EJ et al: More informative abstracts revisited. Ann Intern Med, 1990, 113: 847-51
39. Mulrow CM, Oxman A (Editors): How to Conduct a Cochrane Systematic Review. Third Edition. San Antonio: San Antonio Cochrane Center, 1996
40. Counsell C: Formulating questions and locating primary studies for inclusion in systematic reviews. Ann Intern Med,1997; 127: 380-87
41. Horton R: The rhetoric of research. BMJ,1995; 310: 985-87
42. University of Calgary e-Learning, Online Learning Tutorials. Writing Research Papers. 1 page retrieved from http://elearn.ucalgary.ca/olt/ research_paper.htm on December 20, 2005
43. Cal State L.A. University Writing Center. Writing the Discussion Section. Retrieved from http://www.calstatela.edu/centers/write_cn/sbrespr3htm on December 15, 2005
44. Anon. Basic Helps for Practical Reasoning. 6 pages retrieved from http://www.engl.niu.edu/wac/reason.html on December 27, 2005
45. ©2001 Wertanen. Toulmin, Stephen. How is a unit of Argument Created? 1 page retrieved from http://www.rhetoric.umn.edu/foundation_courses/rhetoric- 1223/Assets/Attachments/Debtoulmin.pdf#search=Toulmin%20model%20of%20argument' on December 27, 2005
46. Sullivan D: Rhetoric Notes. Basic Helps for Practical Reasoning. 9 pages retrieved from http://www.hu.mtu.edu/dsulliva/rn/cn/reason.htm on December 22, 2005
47. ChangingMinds.org. Toulmin's argument model. 3 pages retrieved from http://changingminds.org/disciplines/argument/making_argument/toulmin.htm on December 22, 2005
48. Reynolds C. What is the Toulmin Model? 3 pages retrieved from http://www.concentric.net/~Creyn266/COMM335/Toulmin.htm on December 22, 2005
49. Anon. Toulmin Model of Argument. 9 pages retrieved from http://commfaculty.fullerton.edu/rgass/toulmin2.htm on December 26, 2005
50. Anon. Suggestions for Teaching the Toulmin System. 5 pages retrieved from cwbacon.personed.com/bookbind/pubbooks/ramage2_ab/...toulmin.pdf on December 20, 2005
51. Swadley CR. The Toulmin Model of Argument. 4 pages retrieved from http://students.ou.edu/S/Charles.R.Swadley-1/argumentation.htm on December 26, 2005
52. Erduran S, Simon S, Osborne J. TAPping into argumentation: Developments in the Application of Toulmin's argument pattern for studying science discourse. Sci Educ, 2004: 88: 915-33
53. Prakken H: AI & Law, Logic and Argument Schemes. 14 pages retrieved from www.cs.uu.nl/groups/IS/archive/heury/argspiss05.pdf on December 20, 2005
54. Carr CS: Computer Supported Collaborative Argumentation: Supporting Problem-based Learning in Legal Education. 8 pages retrieved from http://www.II.unimaas.nl/euro-cscl/Papers/25.pdf on December 26, 2005.
55. See also Carr CS. Using computer supported argument visualization to teach legal argumentation. Chapter 4, pp. 75-96 in: Visualizing Argumentation: Software Tools for Collaborative and Educational Sense-Making. PA Kirschner, SJ Buckingham Shum and CS Carr Editors. London and Berlin: Springer-Verlag, 2003
56. ABBA Systems, Inc. Argument in Business Writing. SOM Business Writing Topics - Argument in Business Writing. 3 pages retrieved from http://www.umass.edu/buscomm/argument.html on December 26, 2005
57. Shapiro H: Using Evidence to prove Your Point in Business Writing. 5 pages retrieved from http://www1.esc.edu/personalfac/hshapiro/writing_program/ students/reference/main/evid... on December 26, 2005
58. Alexander I: Modeling Argumentation, Toulmin Style. 4 pages retrieved from http://easyweb.easynet.co.uk/~iany/consultancy/argumentation/argumentation. htm on December 26, 2005
59. Skelton JR, Edwards SJL: The function of the discussion section in academic medical writing. BMJ, 2000; 320: 1269-70
60. Hess DR: How to write an effective discussion. Respir Care, 2004; 49: 1238-41
61. Thornton J: The discussion section. (Editorial.) BJOG, 2003; 110: 449
62. Crandall SJ, McGaghie WC: Discussion and Conclusion: Interpretation. Pp. 942-44 in: Joint Task Force of Academic Medicine and the GEA RIME Committee. Review Criteria for Research Manuscripts. Acad Med, 2001; 76: 897-978. (N.B. GEA: Group of Educational Affairs; RIME: Research in Medical Education)
63. International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE). Uniform requirements for manuscripts submitted to biomedical journals: Writing and editing for biomedical publication. Updated October 2004. 15 pages at http://www.icmje.online.pdf Accessed June 25, 2005
64. Altman DG, Schulz KF, Moher D et al. for the CONSORT Group: The revised CONSORT statement for reporting randomized trials: Explanation and elaboration. Ann Intern Med, 2001; 134: 663-94
65. How to Write a Paper. Edited by GM Hall. London: BMJ Publishing Group, 1994. (Pp. 1-5: Hall GM. Structure of a scientific paper. Pp. 30-41: Spence AA. Discussion)
66. Siwek J, Gourlay ML, Slawson DC, Shaughnessy AF: How to write an evidence-based clinical review article. Am Fam Physician, 2002; 65: 251-58
67. Gallin J: Writing a Scientific Paper. 38 slides retrieved from http://www.aaas.org/international/eca/present/SciPaper/ on December 24, 2005
68. George Mason University. A Guide to Writing in the Biological Sciences. The Scientific Paper: Discussion. 2 pages retrieved from http://classweb.gmu. edu/biologyresources3writingguide/Discussion.htm on December 25, 2005
69. Muhlenberg College (Wolfe C). Writing Empirical APA Papers for Beginners. Introduction, Method, Results & Discussion/Abstract & References. General Primer on Empirical APA Papers. 8 pages retrieved from http://www.muhlenberg.edu/depts/psychology/Empirical/Primer.htm. on December 15, 2005
70. Caprette DR: Assessing Research Papers. Experimental Biosciences. Introductory Laboratory - Bios 211. Updated May 2005. 4 pages retrieved from http./www.ruf.rice.edu/~bioslabs/assessment/papers_ass.htm on December 15, 2005
71. Pakes GE: Writing manuscripts describing clinical trials: A guide to pharmaceutical researchers. Ann Pharmacother, 2001; 35: 770-79
72. Marusic A, Marusic M: Teaching students how to read and write science: A mandatory course on scientific research and communication in medicine. Acad Med, 2003; 78: 1235-39
73. Witt P: Research Writing Tips. Discussion, conclusion, reference sections. Phys Ther,1980; 60: 1049-50
74. Horton R: The hidden research paper. JAMA, 2002; 287: 2775-78
75. Clarke M, Chalmers I: Discussion sections in reports of controlled trials published in general medical journals. Islands in search of continents? JAMA, 1998; 280: 280-82
76. De Bono E: The Use of Lateral Thinking. London and New York: Penguin Books, 1967
77. Alexandrov AV: How to write a research paper. Cerebrovasc Dis, 2004: 18: 135-38
78. Macintyre S, Chalmers I, Horton R, Smith R: Using evidence to inform health policy: case study. BMJ, 2001; 322: 222-25
79. Clarke M, Alderson P, Chalmers I: Discussion sections in reports of controlled trials published in general medical journals. JAMA, 2002; 287: 2799-801
80. Jenicek M: Foundations of Evidence-Based Medicine. New York and Boca Raton: Parthenon Publishing/CRC Press, 2003.