Reexamining the nurse scheduling problem: Staffing ratios and nursing shortages

Decision Sciences

Volumn 37, Issue 1, 2006, Pages 39-70

  Daniel Wright, P ^a,d,e,f   Bretthauer, Kurt M ^b,d,e,g   Côté, Murray J ^c,f,h  

^a VILLANOVA UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^b INDIANA UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^c UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA   (United States)

^d Pacific Institute for Research and Evaluation   (United States)

^e POMS   (Belgium)

^f INFORMS   (United States)

^g SIAM   (United States)

^h American Society for Quality   (India)

Author keywords

and Planning and Scheduling; Health Care Policy; Labor and Staff Planning; Mathematical Programming Optimization; Nurse Scheduling

Indexed keywords

EID: 33645132268     PISSN: 00117315     EISSN: 15405915     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1540-5414.2006.00109.x     Document Type: Review

References (100)

1. Abernathy, W. J., Baloff, N., Hershey, J. C., & Wandel, S. (1973). A three-stage manpower planning and scheduling model - A service sector example. Operations Research, 21(3), 693-711.
2. Adams-Wendling, L. (2003). Clocking care hours with workload measurement tools. Nursing Management, 34(8), 34.
3. Agnihothri, S. R., & Taylor, P. F. (1991). Staffing a centralized appointment scheduling department in Lourdes Hospital. Interfaces, 21(5), 1-11.
4. Aiken, L. A., Clarke, S. P., Sloane, D. M., Sochalski, J. A., & Silber, J. H. (2002). Hospital nurse staffing and patient mortality, nurse burnout, and job dissatisfaction. The Journal of the American Medical Association, 288( 16), 1987-1993.
5. Aiken, L. A., Clarke, S. P., Sloane, D. M., & Silber, J. H. (2003). Hospital nurse staffing, education, and patient mortality. LDI Issue Brief, 9(2), 1-4.
6. Andrews, B., & Parsons, H. (1989). L.L.Bean chooses a telephone agent scheduling system. Interfaces, 19(6), 1-9.
7. Andrews, B., & Parsons, H. (1993). Establishing telephone-agent staffing levels through economic optimization. Interfaces, 23(2), 14-20.
8. Artz, M. (2005). Setting nurse-patient ratios. American Journal of Nursing, 105(3), 97.
9. Baker, K. R. (1974). Scheduling a full-time work force to meet cyclic staffing requirements. Management Science, 20(12), 1561-1568.
10. Bard, J. F., & Purnomo, H. W. (2005). Preference scheduling for nurses using column generation. European Journal of Operational Research, 164(2), 510-534.
11. Bartholomew, D. J., & Forbes, A. F. (1979). Statistical techniques for manpower planning. New York: Wiley.
12. Bechtold, S. E. (1981). Work force scheduling for arbitrary cyclic demands. Journal of Operations Management, 1(4), 205-214.
13. Bechtold, S. E., & Showalter, M. J. (1987). A methodology for labor scheduling in a service operating system. Decision Sciences, 18(1), 89-107.
14. Bellanti, G., Carello, G., Croce, F. D., & Tadei, R. (2004). A greedy-based neighborhood search approach to a nurse rostering problem. European Journal of Operational Research, 153(1), 28-40.
15. Benco, L. (2004). Ratio fight goes national. Modern Healthcare, 34(24), 23-25.
16. Berliner, H. S., & Ginzberg, E. (2002). Why this hospital nursing shortage is different. The Journal of the American Medical Association, 288(21), 2742-2744.
17. Bitran, G. R., & Rivera, J. M. (1982). A combined approach to solve binary multicriteria problems. Naval Research Logistics Quarterly, 29(2), 181-201.
18. Bordoloi, S. K., & Weatherby, E. J. (1999). Managerial implications of calculating optimum nurse staffing in medical units. Health Care Management Review, 24(4), 35-44.
19. Bretthauer, K., & Côté, M. J. (1998). A model for planning resource requirements in health care organizations. Decision Sciences, 29(1), 243-270.
20. Brusco, M. J., Jacobs, L. W., Bongiorno, R. J., Lyons, D. V., & Tang, B. (1995). Improving personnel scheduling at airline stations. Operations Research, 43(5), 741-751.
21. Buffa, E. S., Cosgrove, M. J., & Luce, B. J. (1976). An integrated work shift scheduling system. Decision Sciences, 7(4), 620-630.
22. Burns, R. N., & Carter, M. W. (1985). Workforce size and single shift schedules with variable demands. Management Science, 31(5), 599-607.
23. Burns, R. N., & Koop, G. J. (1987). A modular approach to optimal multiple-shift manpower scheduling. Management Science, 35(1), 100-110.
24. California Department of Health Services. (2004). Finding of emergency R-01-04E (www.dhs.ca.gov).
25. Campbell, G. M. (1999). Cross-utilization of workers whose capabilities differ. Management Science, 45(5), 722-732.
26. Carter, M. R. (2004). The ABCs of staffing decisions. Nursing Management, 35(6), 16.
27. Cheang, B., Li, H., Lim, A., & Rodrigues, B. (2003). Nurse rostering problems A bibliographic survey. European Journal of Operational Research, 151(3), 447-460.
28. Clarke, S. P. (2004). The policy implications of staffing-outcomes research. Journal of Nursing Administration, 35(1), 17-19.
29. Cline, D., Reilly, C., & Moore, J. F. (2003). What's behind RN turnover? Nursing Management, 34(10), 50-53.
30. Coffman, J. M., Seago, J. A., & Spetz, J. (2002). Minimum nurse-to-patient ratios in acute care hospitals in California. Health Affairs, 21(5), 53-64.
31. Coile, R. C., Jr. (2002). Futurescan (2002): A forecast of healthcare trends 2002-2006. Chicago: Health Administration Press.
32. Côté, M. J. (2005). A note on bed allocation techniques based on census data. Socio-Economic Planning Sciences, 39(2), 183-192.
33. Curtin, L. L. (2003). An integrated analysis of nurse staffing and related variables: Effects on patient outcomes. Online Journal of Issues in Nursing, 8(3), 1-12.
34. Downsland, K. A. (1998). Nurse scheduling with tabu search and strategic oscillation. European Journal of Operational Research, 106(2-3), 393-407.
35. Dijkstra, M. C., Kron, L. G., Salomon, M., van Nunen, J. A., & van Wassenhove, L. N. (1994). Planning the size and organization of KLM's aircraft maintenance personnel. Interfaces, 24(6), 47-58.
36. Duchene, P. (2002). Staff ratios: Just about numbers? Nursing Management, 33(7), 10.
37. Easton, F. F., & Goodale, J. C. (2005). Schedule recovery: Unplanned absences in service operations. Decision Sciences, 36(3), 459-488.
38. Easton, F. F., & Rossin, D. F. (1991a). Sufficient working subsets for the tour scheduling problem. Management Science, 37(11), 1441-1451.
39. Easton, F. F., & Rossin, D. F. (1991b). Equivalent alternative solutions for the tour scheduling problem. Decision Sciences, 22(5), 985-1007.
40. Easton, F. F., & Rossin, D. F. (1996). A stochastic goal program for employee scheduling. Decision Sciences, 27(3), 541-568.
41. Easton, F. F., Rossin, D. F., & Borders, W. S. (1992). Analysis of alternative scheduling policies for hospital nurses. Production and Operations Management, 1(2), 159-174.
42. Evans, M. (2005). CNA wins latest staff-ratio battle. Modern Healthcare, 35(11), 20.
43. Gardner, A., & Gemme, E. M. (2003). Virtual scheduling: A 21st-century approach to staffing. Nursing Administration Quarterly, 27(1), 77-82.
44. Goodale, J. C., Verma, R., & Pullman, M. E. (2003). A market utility-based model for capacity scheduling in mass services. Production and Operations Management, 12(2), 165-185.
45. Gonzalez, R. (2005). The 109th Congress gets down to business. American Journal of Nursing, 105(5), 16.
46. Grinold, R. C., & Marshall, K. T. (1977). Manpower planning models. New York: North-Holland.
47. Hall, R. W. (1991). Queueing methods for services and manufacturing. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.
48. Hanssmann, F., & Hess, S. W. (1960). A linear programming approach to production and employee scheduling. Management Technology, 1(1), 46-51.
49. Health Policy Tracking Service. (2005). 2005 state health care priorities survey report. Falls Church, VA: Netscan iPublishing Inc.
50. Henderson, W. B., & Berry, W. L. (1976). Heuristic methods for telephone operator shift scheduling: An experimental analysis. Management Science, 22(12), 1372-1380.
51. Hershey, J. C., Abernathy, W. J., & Baloff, N. (1974). Comparison of nurse allocation policies - A Monte Carlo model. Decision Sciences, 5(1), 58-72.
52. Holt, C. C., Modigliani, F., & Simon, H. A. (1955). A linear decision rule for production and employment scheduling. Management Science, 2(1), 1-30.
53. Hopkins, B. (2005). Nurses push more hiring. Knight Ridder Tribune Information Services, Mar. 9, p. 1.
54. Hueter, J., & Swart, W. (1998). An integrated labor-management system for Taco Bell. Interfaces, 28(1), 75-91.
55. Hur, D., Mabert, V. A., & Bretthauer, K. (2004). Real time work schedule adjustment decisions: An investigation and evaluation. Production and Operations Management, 13(4), 322-339.
56. Ikem, F. M., & Reisman, A. M. (1990). An approach to planning for physician requirements in developing countries using dynamic programming. Management Science, 38(4), 607-618.
57. Institute of Medicine. (2004). Keeping patients safe: Transforming the work environment of nurses. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press.
58. Jarrah, A. I., Bard, J. F., & deSilva, A. H. (1994). Solving the large-scale scheduling problem. Management Science, 40(9), 1124-1144.
59. Kao, E. P., & Queyranne, M. (1985). Budgeting costs of nursing in a hospital. Management Science, 31(5), 608-621.
60. Kazahaya, G. (2005). Harnessing technology to redesign labor cost management reports. Healthcare Financial Management, 59(4), 94-100.
61. Kennedy, M. S. (2005). What's the right nurse-to-patient ratio?: 'Nursing skill mix' and type of unit must be considered when asking the question. American Journal of Nursing, 105(1), 20.
62. Kolesar, P. J., & Green, L. V. (1998). Insights on service system design from a normal approximation to Erlang's delay formula. Production and Operations Management, 7(3), 282-293.
63. Koop, G. J. (1988). Multiple shift workforce lower bounds. Management Science, 34(10), 1221-1230.
64. Lanser, E. G. (2001). A model workplace: Creating an effective nursing environment. Healthcare Executive, 16(4), 6-11.
65. Lapierre, S. D., Goldsman, D., Cochran, R., & DuBow, J. (1999). Bed allocation techniques based on census data. Socio-Economic Planning Sciences, 33(1), 25-38.
66. Loucks, J. S., & Jacobs, F. R. (1991). Tour scheduling and task assignment of a heterogeneous work force: A heuristic approach. Decision Sciences, 22(4), 719-738.
67. Love, R. R., & Hoey, J. M. (1990). Management science improves fast-food operations. Interfaces, 20(2), 21-29.
68. Lovern, E. (2002). Rx for nurses, final version of staffing legislation in the works. Modern Healthcare, 32(1), 10.
69. Mabert, V. A. (1979). A case study of encoder shift scheduling under uncertainty. Management Science, 25(7), 623-631.
70. Mabert, V. A., & Watts, C. A. (1982). A simulation analysis of tour-shift construction procedures. Management Science, 28(5), 520-532.
71. Mason, A. J., Ryan, D. M., & Panton, D. M. (1998). Integrated simulation, heuristic and optimisation approaches to staff scheduling. Operations Research, 46(2), 161-175.
72. Mellichamp, J. M., & Love, R. M. (1978). Production switching heuristics for the aggregate planning problem. Management Science, 24(12), 1242-1251.
73. Miller, H. E., Pierskalla, W P., & Rath, G. J. (1976). Nurse scheduling using mathematical programming. Operations Research, 24(5), 857-870.
74. Morris, J. G., & Showalter, M. J. (1983). Simple approaches to shift, days-off and tour scheduling problems. Management Science, 29(8), 942-950.
75. Mullinax, C., & Lawley, M. (2002). Assigning patients to nurses in neonatal intensive care. Journal of the Operational Research Society, 53(1), 25-35.
76. Nanda, R., & Browne, J. (1992). Introduction to employee scheduling. New York: Van Nostrand Reinhold.
77. Quinn, P., Andrews, B., & Parsons, H. (1991). Allocating telecommunications resources at L.L.Bean, Inc. Interfaces, 21(1), 75-91.
78. Reilly, P. (2004). Ratio law hits hard in Calif. Modern Healthcare, 34(2), 16.
79. Ritzman, L., Krajewski, L., & Showalter, M. (1976). The disaggregation of aggregate manpower plans. Management Science, 22(11), 1204-1214.
80. Ross, S. M. 2000). Introduction to probability models (7th ed.). New York: Harcourt Press.
81. Schaffner, J. W., & Ludwig-Beymer, P. (2003). Rx for the nursing shortage: A guidebook. Chicago: Health Administration Press.
82. Segal, M. (1974). The operator-scheduling problem: A network-flow approach. Operations Research, 32(4), 808-823.
83. Stamps, P. L. (1997). Nurses and work satisfaction: An index for measurement (2nd ed.). Chicago: Health Administration Press.
84. Stanton, M. W. (2004). Hospital nurse staffing and quality of care. Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality's. Research in Action, March (14), AHRQ Pub. No. 04-0029.
85. Summer, J., & Townsend-Rocchiccioli, J. (2003). Why are nurses leaving nursing? Nursing Administration Quarterly, 27(2), 164-171.
86. Sze, D. Y. (1984). A queueing model for telephone operator staffing. Operations Research, 32(2), 229-249.
87. Taubert, W. H. (1968). A search decision rule for the aggregate scheduling problem. Management Science, 14(6), B343-B359.
88. Thompson, G. M. (1990). Shift scheduling in services when employees have limited availability: An L.P. approach. Journal of Operations Management, 9(3), 352-370.
89. Thompson, G. M. (1995a). Improved implicit optimal modeling of the labor shift scheduling problem. Management Science, 41(4), 595-607.
90. Thompson, G. M. (1995b). Labor scheduling using NPV estimates of the marginal benefit of additional labor capacity. Journal of Operations Management, 13(1), 67-86.
91. Thompson, G. M. (1997a). Labor staffing and scheduling models for controlling service levels. Naval Research Logistics, 44(8), 719-740.
92. Thompson, G. M. (1997b). Assigning telephone operations to shifts at New Brunswick Telephone Company. Interfaces, 27(4), 1-11.
93. Tibrewala, R., Philippe, D., & Browne, J. (1972). Optimal scheduling of two consecutive idle periods. Management Science, 19(1), 71-75.
94. Tieman, J. (2001). Standing by on nurse staffing. Modern Healthcare, 31(36), 28.
95. Tieman, J. (2002a). Absolute minimum. Modern Healthcare, 32(4), 8-11.
96. Tieman, J. (2002b). But does it work? Measuring the effect of the staffing ratios could be tough. Modern Healthcare, 32(9), 10.
97. Trivedi, V. M., & Warner, D. M. (1976). A branch and bound algorithm for optimum allocations of float nurses. Management Science, 22(9), 972-981.
98. Venkataraman, R., & Brusco, M. J. (1996). An integrated analysis of nurse staffing and scheduling policies. Omega, 24(1), 57-71.
99. Warner, D. M. (1976). Scheduling nursing personnel according to nursing preference: A mathematical programming approach. Operations Research, 24(5), 842-856.
100. Warner, D. M., & Prawda, J. (1972). A mathematical programming model for scheduling nursing personnel in a hospital. Management Science, 19(4), 411-422.