Stories from the sharp end: Case studies in safety improvement

Milbank Quarterly

Volumn 84, Issue 1, 2006, Pages 165-200

  McCarthy, Douglas ^b   Blumenthal, David ^a  

^a MASSACHUSETTS GENERAL HOSPITAL   (United States)

^b NONE

Author keywords

Delivery of health care; Organizational culture; Patient safety; Quality of care

Indexed keywords

HEALTH CARE FACILITY; HEALTH CARE QUALITY; HEALTH SERVICES RESEARCH; HUMAN; MEDICAL ERROR; ORGANIZATION; ORGANIZATION AND MANAGEMENT; REVIEW; SAFETY; UNITED STATES;

HEALTH FACILITIES; HUMANS; MEDICAL ERRORS; ORGANIZATIONAL CASE STUDIES; ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE; QUALITY OF HEALTH CARE; SAFETY MANAGEMENT; UNITED STATES;

EID: 33644844674     PISSN: 0887378X     EISSN: 14680009     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1468-0009.2006.00442.x     Document Type: Review

References (86)

1. Advisory Committee on the Safety of Nuclear Installations (ACSNI) 1993 Organising for Safety. ACSNI Study Group on Human Factors Third Report London Health and Safety Executive Quoted in IAEA 2002
2. Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ) 2005 Patient Safety Network Glossary Rockville Md U.S. Department of Health and Human Services Available at
3. Akins R.B. and B.R. Cole 2005 Barriers to Implementation of Patient Safety Systems in Healthcare Institutions Journal of Patient Safety 1 9 16
4. Bagian J.P. J. Gosbee C.Z. Lee L. Williams S.D. McKnight and D.M. Mannos 2002 The Veterans Affairs Root Cause Analysis System in Action Joint Commission Journal on Quality and Safety 28 531 45
5. Bagian J.P. C. Lee J. Gosbee J. DeRosier E. Stalhandske N. Eldridge R. Williams and M. Burkhardt 2001 Developing and Deploying a Patient Safety Program in a Large Health Care Delivery System: You Can't Fix What You Don't Know About Joint Commission Journal on Quality and Safety 27 522 32
6. Bellomo R. D. Goldsmith S. Uchino J. Buckmaster G.K. Hart H. Opdam W. Silvester L. Doolan and G. Gutteridge 2003 A Prospective Before-and-After Trial of a Medical Emergency Team Medical Journal of Australia 179 283 87
7. Bellomo R. D. Goldsmith S. Uchino J. Buckmaster G. Hart H. Opdam W. Silvester L. Doolan and G. Gutteridge 2004 Prospective Controlled Trial of Effect of Medical Emergency Team on Postoperative Morbidity and Mortality Rates Critical Care Medicine 32 916 21
8. Berenholtz S.M. P.J. Pronovost P.A. Lipsett D. Hobson K. Earsing J.E. Farley S. Milanovich E. Garrett-Mayer B.D. Winters H.R. Rubin T. Dorman and T.M. Perl 2004 Eliminating Catheter-Related Bloodstream Infections in the Intensive Care Unit Critical Care Medicine 32 2014 20
9. Berman S 2004 An Interview with Peter Pronovost Joint Commission Journal on Quality and Safety 30 659 64
10. Clancy C.M. 2005 Training Health Care Professionals for Patient Safety American Journal of Medical Quality 20 277 79
11. Cohen M. M.A. Eustis and R.E. Gribbins 2003 Changing the Culture of Patient Safety: Leadership's Role in Health Care Quality Improvement Joint Commission Journal on Quality and Safety 29 329 35
12. Comden S.C. and J. Rosenthal 2002 Statewide Patient Safety Coalitions: A Status Report Portland Maine National Academy for State Health Policy
13. DeFontes J. and S. Surbida 2004 Preoperative Safety Briefing Project Permanente Journal 8 2 21 27
14. Dellinger E.P. S.M. Hausmann D.W. Bratzler R.M. Johnson D.M. Daniel K.M. Bunt G.A. Baumgardner and J.R. Sugarman 2005 Hospitals Collaborate to Decrease Surgical Site Infections American Journal of Surgery 190 9 15
15. DeRosier J. E. Stalhandske J.P. Bagian and T. Nudell 2002 Using Health Care Failure Mode and Effect Analysis Joint Commission Journal on Quality and Safety 28 248 67
16. Devers K.J. H.H. Pham and G. Liu 2004 What is Driving Hospitals' Patient-Safety Efforts? Health Affairs 23 2 103 15
17. Dudley R.A. A. Frolich D.L. Robinowitz J.A. Talavera P. Broadhead and H.S. Luft 2004 Strategies to Support Quality-Based Purchasing: A Review of the Evidence Technical Review 10 Rockville Md Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality
18. Frankel A. E. Graydon-Baker C. Neppl T. Simmonds M. Gustafson and T.K. Gandhi 2003 Patient Safety Leadership Walkrounds Joint Commission Journal on Quality and Safety 29 16 26
19. Gallagher T.H. A.D. Waterman A.G. Ebers V.J. Fraser and W. Levinson 2003 Patients' and Physicians' Attitudes Regarding the Disclosure of Medical Errors Journal of the American Medical Association 289 1001 7
20. Galvin R.S. S. Delbanco A. Milstein and G. Belden 2005 Has the Leapfrog Group Had an Impact on the Health Care Market? Health Affairs 24 1 228 33
21. Gosfield A.G. and J.L. Reinertsen 2005 The 100,000 Lives Campaign: Crystallizing Standards of Care for Hospitals Health Affairs 24 1560 70
22. Haig K. 2003 One Hospital's Journey toward Patient Safety - A Cultural Evolution Medscape Money & Medicine 4 August 29 Available at
23. Heget J.R. J.P. Bagian C.Z. Lee and J.W. Gosbee 2002 John M Eisenberg Patient Safety Awards. System Innovation: Veterans Health Administration National Center for Patient Safety. Joint Commission Journal on Quality and Safety 28 660 65
24. Helmreich R.L. 2000 On Error Management: Lessons from Aviation British Medical Journal 320 781 85
25. Helmreich R.L. and A.C. Merritt 1998 Culture at Work in Aviation and Medicine: National, Organizational, and Professional Influences Burlington Vt Ashgate
26. Hibbard J.H. E. Peters P. Slovic and M. Tusler 2005 Can Patients Be Part of the Solution? Views on Their Role in Preventing Medical Errors Medical Care Research and Review 62 601 16
27. Hibbard J.H. J. Stockard and M. Tusler 2005 Hospital Performance Reports: Impact on Quality, Market Share, and Reputation Health Affairs 24 1150 60
28. Hudson P. 2003 Applying the Lessons of High Risk Industries to Health Care Quality and Safety in Health Care 12 7 12
29. Infectious Disease Society of America (IDSA) 2005 States Publicize Hospital Data on Infection Rates IDSA News (September 1) Available at
30. Institute for Healthcare Improvement (IHI) 2004a Rapid Response Teams: Heading off Medical Crises at Baptist Memorial Hospital-Memphis Boston
31. Institute for Healthcare Improvement (IHI) 2004b Trigger Tool for Measuring Adverse Drug Events Boston
32. Institute for Healthcare Improvement (IHI) 2005a Failure Modes and Effects Analysis Tool Boston
33. Institute for Healthcare Improvement (IHI) 2005b 100K Lives Campaign Overview Boston
34. Institute of Medicine (IOM) 1999 To Err Is Human: Building a Safer Health Care System edited by Kohn L.T. Corrigan J.M. and Donaldson M.S. Washington D.C. National Academy Press
35. Institute of Medicine (IOM) 2001 Crossing the Quality Chasm: A New Health System for the 21st Century Washington D.C. National Academy Press
36. International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) 2002 Safety Culture in Nuclear Installations: Guidance for Use in the Enhancement of Safety Culture Vienna
37. Knox G.E. K.R. Simpson and T.J. Garite 1999 High Reliability Perinatal Units: An Approach to the Prevention of Patient Injury and Malpractice Claims Journal of Healthcare Risk Management 19 2 24 32
38. Krause T.R. K.J. Seymour and K.C.M. Sloat 1999 Long-Term Evaluation of a Behavior-Based Method for Improving Safety Performance Safety Science 32 1 18
39. Leape L. 2002 Reporting of Adverse Events 2002 New England Journal of Medicine 347 1633 38
40. Leape L. 2005 Ethical Issues in Patient Safety Thoracic Surgery Clinics 15 493 501
41. Leatherman S. D. Berwick D. Iles L.S. Lewin F. Davidoff T. Nolan and M. Bisognano 2003 The Business Case for Quality: Case Studies and an Analysis Health Affairs 22 2 17 30
42. Leonard M. S. Graham and D. Bonacum 2004 The Human Factor: The Critical Importance of Effective Teamwork and Communication in Providing Safe Care Quality and Safety in Health Care 13 suppl. 1 i85 i90
43. Leonard M. S. Graham and B. Taggart 2004 Effective Teamwork and Communication in Patient Safety In Achieving Safe and Reliable Healthcare edited by Leonard M. Frankel A. and Simmonds T. 37 64 Chicago Health Administration Press
44. Marchev M. J. Rosenthal and M. Booth 2003 How States Report Medical Errors to the Public: Issues and Barriers Portland Maine National Academy of State Health Policy
45. McCarthy D. 2004 Case Study: Improving ICU Care at the Porter Valparaiso Hospital Campus Quality Matters Newsletter New York Commonwealth Fund (December)
46. McCarthy D. 2005a Case Study: The National Surgical Quality Improvement Program Quality Matters Newsletter New York Commonwealth Fund (May)
47. McCarthy D. 2005b Case Study: Using Baldrige Criteria to Achieve Performance Excellence at the Robert Wood Johnson University Hospital Hamilton Quality Matters Newsletter New York Commonwealth Fund (February)
48. McCarthy D. and E. Staton 2005 Case Study: The Harvard Center for Medical Simulation's Labor and Delivery Crisis Resource Management Course Quality Matters Newsletter New York Commonwealth Fund (March)
49. McFerran S. J. Nunes D. Pucci and A. Zuniga 2005 Perinatal Patient Safety Project: A Multicenter Approach to Improve Performance Reliability at Kaiser Permanente Journal of Perinatal and Neonatal Nursing 19 37 45
50. Musson D.M. and R.L. Helmreich 2004 Team Training and Resource Management in Health Care: Current Issues and Future Directions Harvard Health Policy Review 5 25 35
51. National Patient Safety Foundation (NPSF) 2003 National Agenda for Action: Patients and Families in Patient Safety. Nothing about Me, without Me North Adams Mass
52. Neily J. 2003 Using Aggregate Root Cause Analysis to Improve Patient Safety Joint Commission Journal on Quality and Safety 29 434 39
53. Niedowski E. 2003 From Tragedy, a Quest for Safer Care Baltimore Sun December 15 Available at
54. Nunes J. and S. McFerran 2005 The Perinatal Patient Safety Project: New Can Be Great Permanente Journal 9 1 25 27
55. O'Leary D. 2003 Patient Safety: Instilling Hospitals with a Culture of Continuous Improvement. Testimony before the U.S. Senate Committee on Governmental Affairs, June 11 Washington D.C. U.S. Government Printing Office
56. Paine L.A. D.R. Baker B. Rosenstein and P.J. Pronovost 2004 The Johns Hopkins Hospital: Identifying and Addressing Risks and Safety Issues Joint Commission Journal on Quality and Safety 30 543 50
57. Perlin J. R.M. Kolodner and R.H. Roswell 2004 The Veterans Health Administration: Quality, Value, Accountability, and Information as Transforming Strategies for Patient-Centered Care American Journal of Managed Care 10 828 36
58. Ponte P.R. G. Conlin J.B. Conway S. Grant C. Medeiros J. Nies L. Shulman P. Branowicki and K. Conley 2003 Making Patient-Centered Care Come Alive: Achieving Full Integration of the Patient's Perspective Journal of Nursing Administration 33 2 82 90
59. Preston P. J. Nunes S. McFerran B. Merle and G. Escobar 2004 Simulation Training in Perinatal Safety. Abstracts of the 2004 Meeting of the Society for Technology in Anesthesia, the 2004 International Meeting on Medical Simulation, and XXIV Computers in Anesthesia Meeting Anesthesia and Analgesia 98 5, Suppl. S1 54
60. Pronovost P. S. Berenholtz T. Dorman P.A. Lipsett T. Simmonds and C. Haraden 2003 Improving Communication in the ICU Using Daily Goals Journal of Critical Care 18 71 75
61. Pronovost P.J. and S.M. Berenholtz 2004 Improving Sepsis Care in the Intensive Care Unit: An Evidence-Based Approach VHA Research Series Irving Tex VHA
62. Pronovost P. B. Weast B. Rosenstein J.B. Sexton C.G. Holzmueller L. Paine R. Davis and H.R. Rubin 2005 Implementing and Validating a Comprehensive Unit-Based Safety Program Journal of Patient Safety 1 33 40
63. Quality Interagency Coordination Task Force (QuIC) 2000 Doing What Counts for Patient Safety: Federal Actions to Reduce Medical Errors and Their Impact Washington D.C. Available at
64. Reason J. 1990 Human Error Cambridge Cambridge University Press
65. Reason J. 1997 Managing the Risks of Organizational Accidents Burlington Vt. Ashgate
66. Roberts K.H. 1993 Cultural Characteristics of Reliability Enhancing Organizations Journal of Managerial Issues 5 165 81
67. Rosenthal J. and M. Booth 2004 State Patient Safety Centers: A New Approach to Promote Patient Safety Portland Maine National Academy for State Health Policy
68. Rosenthal M.B. R. Fernandopulle H.R. Song and B. Landon 2004 Paying for Quality: Providers' Incentives for Quality Improvement Health Affairs 23 2 127 41
69. Rozich J.D. and R.K. Resar 2001 Medication Safety: One Organization's Approach to the Challenge Journal of Clinical Outcome Management 8 10 27 34
70. Runy L.A. 2004 The American Hospital Association Quest for Quality Prize Hospitals and Health Networks September 9 Available at
71. Sexton J.B. 2005 Safety Culture at Work: How to Measure, Improve, and Sustain over Time Speech presented at the 2005 Patient Safety and Health Information Technology Conference Washington D.C. June 6-10 Available at
72. Sexton J.B. and E.J. Thomas 2003 The Safety Climate Survey: Psychometric and Benchmarking Properties Technical Report 03-03 Houston Center of Excellence for Patient Safety Research and Practice, University of Texas
73. Sexton J.B. E.J. Thomas and R.L. Helmreich 2000 Error, Stress, and Teamwork in Medicine and Aviation: Cross Sectional Surveys British Medical Journal 320 745 49
74. Sexton J.B. E.J. Thomas R.L. Helmreich T.B. Neilands K. Rowan K. Vella J. Boyden and P.R. Roberts 2004 Frontline Assessments of Healthcare Culture: Safety Attitudes Questionnaire Norms and Psychometric Properties Technical Report 04-01 Houston Center of Excellence for Patient Safety Research and Practice, University of Texas
75. Sirio C.A. K.T. Segel D.J. Keyser E.I. Harrison J.C. Lloyd R.J. Weber C.A. Muto D.G. Webster V. Pisowicz and K.W. Feinstein 2003 Pittsburgh Regional Healthcare Initiative: A Systems Approach for Achieving Perfect Patient Care Health Affairs 22 5 157 65
76. Uhlig P.N. J. Brown A.K. Nason A. Camelio and E. Kendall 2002 John M Eisenberg Patient Safety Award for System Innovation: Concord Hospital. Joint Commission Journal on Quality and Safety 28 666 72
77. VanGeest J.B. and D.S. Cummins 2003 An Educational Needs Assessment for Improving Patient Safety North Adams Mass National Patient Safety Foundation
78. Veterans Health Administration (VHA) 2002 VHA National Patient Safety Improvement Handbook Washington D.C. U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs
79. Walshe K. and S.M. Shortell 2004 When Things Go Wrong: How Health Care Organizations Deal with Major Failures Health Affairs 23 3 103 11
80. Weeks W.B. and J.P. Bagian 2000 Developing a Culture of Safety in the Veterans Health Administration Effective Clinical Practice 6 270 76
81. Weick K.E. 1987 Organizational Culture as a Source of High Reliability California Management Review 29 112 27
82. Weick K.E. 2002 The Reduction of Medical Errors through Mindful Interdependence In Medical Error: What Do We Know? What Do We Do? edited by Rosenthal M.M. and Sutcliffe K.M. 177 99 San Francisco Jossey/Bass
83. Weissman J.S. C.L. Annas A.M. Epstein E.C. Schneider B. Clarridge L. Kirle C. Gatsonis S. Feibelmann and N. Ridley 2005 Error Reporting and Disclosure Systems: Views from Hospital Leaders Journal of the American Medical Association 293 1359 66
84. Whittington J. and H. Cohen 2004 OSF Healthcare's Journey in Patient Safety Quality Management in Health Care 13 53 59
85. Wood K.E. and D.B. Nash 2005 Mandatory State-Based Error-Reporting Systems: Current and Future Prospects American Journal of Medical Quality 20 297 303
86. Yates G.R. R.F. Hochman S.M. Sayles and C.A. Stockmeier 2004 Sentara Norfolk General Hospital: Accelerating Improvement by Focusing on Building a Culture of Safety Joint Commission Journal on Quality and Safety 30 434 542