Labor productivity in the United States and the United Kingdom during the nineteenth century

Explorations in Economic History

Volumn 43, Issue 2, 2006, Pages 257-279

  Broadberry, Stephen N ^a   Irwin, Douglas A ^b  

^a UNIVERSITY OF WARWICK   (United Kingdom)

^b Dartmouth College   (United States)

Author keywords

International comparison; Labor productivity; Per capita income; Sectoral disaggregation

Indexed keywords

EID: 33644771096     PISSN: 00144983     EISSN: 10902457     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.eeh.2005.02.003     Document Type: Article

References (88)

1. M. Abramovitz P.A. David Reinterpreting economic growth: Parables and realities American Economic Review 63 1973 428-439
2. B. Afton M. Turner The statistical base of agricultural performance in England and Wales, 1850-1914 E.J.T. Collins The agrarian history of England and Wales, 1850-1950 vol. VII 2000 Cambridge University Press Cambridge 1755-2140
3. R.C. Allen Real incomes in the English-speaking world, 1879-1913 G. Grantham M. Mackinnon Labour market evolution: The economic history of market integration, wage flexibility and the employment relation 1994 Routledge London 107-138
4. E. Ames N. Rosenberg The enfield arsenal in theory and history Economic Journal 78 1968 827-842
5. N.S. Balke R.J. Gordon The estimation of prewar gross national product: methodology and new evidence Journal of Political Economy 97 1989 38-92
6. J.V. Beckett Agricultural management and estate management E.J.T. Collins The agrarian history of England and Wales, 1850-1950 vol. VII 2000 Cambridge University Press Cambridge 693-758
7. D. Blades Capital measurement in OECD countries: An overview Technology and productivity: The challenge for economic policy 1991 OECD Paris
8. A.C. Bolino A century of human capital by education and training 1989 Kensington Washington, DC
9. G.R. Boyer T.J. Hatton K.H. O'Rourke The impact of emigration on real wages in Ireland, 1850-1914 T.J. Hatton J.G. Williamson Migration and the international labour market 1994 Routledge London 221-239
10. S.N. Broadberry Comparative productivity in British and American manufacturing during the nineteenth century Explorations in Economic History 31 1994 521-548
11. S.N. Broadberry Forging ahead, falling behind and catching-up: A sectoral analysis of Anglo-American productivity differences, 1870-1990 Research in Economic History 17 1997 1-37
12. S.N. Broadberry How did the United States and Germany overtake Britain? A sectoral analysis of comparative productivity levels, 1870-1990 Journal of Economic History 58 1998 375-407
13. S.N. Broadberry Relative per capita income levels in the United Kingdom and the United States since 1870: Reconciling time-series projections and direct-benchmark estimates Journal of Economic History 63 2003 852-863
14. S.N. Broadberry S. Ghosal From the counting house to the modern office: explaining Anglo-American productivity differences in services, 1870-1990 Journal of Economic History 62 2002 967-998
15. J.C. Carr W. Taplin A History of the British Steel Industry 1962 Blackwell Oxford
16. Y. Cassis City bankers, 1890-1914 1994 Cambridge University Press Cambridge
17. D. Chadwick On the rate of wages in Manchester and Salford, and the manufacturing districts of Lancashire, 1839-1859 Journal of the Statistical Society of London 23 1860 1-36
18. A.D. Chandler Jr. The visible hand: The managerial revolution in American business 1977 Harvard University Press Cambridge, MA
19. R. Church The history of the British coal industry, volume 3, 1830-1913: Victorian pre-eminence 1986 Clarendon Press Oxford
20. C. Clark The Conditions of Economic Progress second ed. 1951 Macmillan London
21. N.F.R. Crafts British economic growth during the industrial revolution 1985 Clarendon Press Oxford
22. P.A. David Technical choice, innovation and economic growth 1975 Cambridge University Press Cambridge
23. David, P.A., 1996. Real income and economic welfare growth in the early republic. Unpublished manuscript, All Souls College, Oxford and Stanford University.
24. P.A. David P. Solar A bicentenary contribution to the history of the cost of living in America Research in Economic History 2 1977 1-80
25. J.H. Davis An annual index of U.S. industrial production, 1790-1915 Quarterly Journal of Economics 119 2004 1177-1215
26. P. Deane W.A. Cole British economic growth 1688-1959: Trends and structure second ed. 1967 Cambridge University Press Cambridge
27. L. Drescher The development of agricultural production in Great Britain and Ireland from the early nineteenth century Manchester School 23 1955 153-183
28. R.A. Easterlin The American population L.E. Davis R.A. Easterlin W.N. Parker American economic growth: An economist's history of the United States 1972 Harper & Row New York 121-183
29. G. Federico P. Malanima Progress, decline, and growth: Product and productivity in Italian agriculture, 1000-2000 Economic History Review 57 2004 437-464
30. C.H. Feinstein National income, expenditure and output of the United Kingdom, 1855-1965 1972 Cambridge University Press Cambridge
31. C.H. Feinstein Sources and methods of estimation for domestic reproducible fixed assets, stocks and works in progress, overseas assets and land C.H. Feinstein S. Pollard Studies in capital formation in the United Kingdom, 1750-1820 1988 Oxford University Press Oxford 257-471
32. C.H. Feinstein Changes in nominal wages, the cost of living and real wages in the United Kingdom over two centuries, 1780-1990 P. Scholliers V. Zamagni Labour's reward: Real wages and economic change in 19th- and 20th-Century Europe 1995 Edward Elgar Aldershot 3-36
33. A.J. Field On the unimportance of machinery Explorations in Economic History 22 1985 378-401
34. A.J. Field The relative productivity of American distribution, 1869-1992 Research in Economic History 16 1996 1-37
35. A. Fishlow American railroads and the transformation of the ante-Bellum economy 1965 Harvard University Press Cambridge, MA
36. E. Frickey Production in the United States, 1860-1914 1947 Harvard University Press Cambridge, MA
37. Gallman, R.E., 1960. Commodity output, 1839-1899. In: Trends in the American Economy in the Nineteenth Century. Studies in Income and Wealth, vol. 24. National Bureau of Economic Research, New York, pp. 13-67.
38. R.E. Gallman Gross national product in the US, 1834-1909 D.S. Brady Output, employment and productivity in the US after 1800 1966 National Bureau of Economic Research New York 3-76
39. R.E. Gallman The United States capital stock in the nineteenth century S.L. Engerman R.E. Gallman Long-Term factors in American economic growth 1986 Chicago University Press Chicago 165-213
40. R.E. Gallman T.J. Weiss The service industries in the nineteenth century V.R. Fuchs Production and productivity in the service industries Studies in income and wealth vol. 34 1969 National Bureau of Economic Research New York 287-351
41. F. Geary Deindustrialization in Ireland to 1851: Some evidence from the census Economic History Review 51 1998 512-541
42. Gordon, R.J., 2004. Two centuries of economic growth: Europe chasing the American frontier. CEPR Discussion Paper 4415. Available from:
43. H.J. Habakkuk American and British technology in the nineteenth century 1962 Cambridge University Press Cambridge
44. G.R. Hawke Railways and economic growth in England and Wales 1840-1870 1970 Clarendon Press Oxford
45. Y. Hayami V.W. Ruttan Agricultural development: An international perspective 1971 Johns Hopkins University Press Baltimore, MD
46. O.C. Herfindahl Development of major metal mining industries in the United States from 1839 to 1909 D.S. Brady Output, employment, and productivity in the United States after 1800 Studies in income and wealth vol. 30 1966 National Bureau of Economic Research New York 293-346
47. A.H. Imlah Economic elements in the Pax Britannica 1958 Russell & Russell New York
48. D.A. Irwin Explaining America's surge in manufactured exports, 1880-1913 Review of Economics and Statistics 85 2003 364-376
49. J.A. James J.S. Skinner The resolution of the labor-scarcity paradox Journal of Economic History 45 1985 513-540
50. Johnston, L., 2001. The growth of the service sector in historical perspective: Explaining trends in U.S. sectoral output and employment, 1840-1990. Unpublished manuscript, College of Saint Benedict, Saint John's University.
51. J. Kendrick Productivity trends in the United States 1961 Princeton University Press Princeton
52. Kloft, L.J., 1995. Problems and issues in constructing national and regional price indices for the United States: 1851-1880. Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, University of Iowa.
53. S. Kuznets Modern economic growth: Rate, structure and spread 1966 Yale University Press New Haven
54. N. Lamoreaux Insider lending: Banks, personal connections, and economic development in industrial New England 1994 Cambridge University Press Cambridge
55. S. Lebergott Labor force and employment, 1800-1960 D.S. Brady Output, employment, and productivity in the United States after 1800 Studies in income and wealth vol. 30 1966 National Bureau of Economic Research New York 117-204
56. W.A. Lewis Growth and fluctuations 1870-1913 1978 Allen & Unwin London
57. W.A. Mackenzie Changes in the standard of living in the United Kingdom, 1860-1914 Economica 3 1921 211-230
58. D.N. McCloskey Did victorian Britain fail? Economic History Review 23 1970 446-459
59. A. Maddison Monitoring the world economy, 1820-1992 1995 Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development Paris
60. A. Maddison The world economy: A millennial perspective 2001 Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development Paris
61. A. Maddison The world economy: Historical statistics 2003 Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development Paris
62. R.F. Martin National income in the United States 1799-1938 1939 National Industrial Conference Board New York
63. R.C.O. Matthews C.H. Feinstein J.C. Odling-Smee British economic growth 1856-1973 1982 Clarendon Press Oxford
64. B.R. Mitchell British historical statistics 1988 Cambridge University Press Cambridge
65. M. O'Mahony Measures of fixed capital stocks in the post-war period B. van Ark N. Crafts Quantitative aspects of post-war European economic growth 1996 Cambridge University Press Cambridge 165-214
66. A.L. Olmstead P.W. Rhode The red queen and the hard reds: Productivity growth in American wheat, 1800-1940 Journal of Economic History 62 2002 929-966
67. W.N. Parker J.L.V. Klein Productivity growth in grain production in the United States, 1840-1860 and 1900-1910 D.S. Brady Output, employment, and productivity in the United States after 1800 Studies in income and wealth vol. 30 1966 National Bureau of Economic Research New York 523-580
68. L. Prados de la Escosura International comparisons of real product, 1820-1990 Explorations in Economic History 37 2000 1-41
69. A. Sauerbeck Prices of commodities and the precious metals Journal of the Statistical Society of London 49 1886 581-648
70. A.J. Taylor Labour productivity and technological innovation in the British coal industry, 1850-1914 Economic History Review 14 1961 48-70
71. Towne, M.W., Rasmussen, W.D., 1960. Farm gross product and gross investment in the nineteenth century. In: Trends in the American Economy in the Nineteenth Century. Studies in Income and Wealth, vol. 24. National Bureau of Economic Research, New York, pp. 255-312.
72. M.E. Turner Agricultural output, income and productivity E.J.T. Collins The agrarian history of England and Wales, 1850-1950 vol. VII 2000 Cambridge University Press Cambridge 224-320
73. U.K. Board of Trade, 1903. Report on wholesale and retail prices in the United Kingdom in 1902, with Comparative Statistical Tables for a series of years. (HC321), British Parliamentary Papers, LXVIII.
74. U.K. Board of Trade, 1908. Report of an enquiry by the board of trade into working class rents, housing and retail prices, together with the standard rates of wages prevailing in certain occupations in the principal industrial towns of the United Kingdom. (Cd. 3864), British Parliamentary Papers, CVII.
75. U.K. Board of Trade, 1911. Report of an enquiry by the board of trade into working class rents, housing and retail prices, together with the rates of wages in certain occupations in the principal industrial towns of the United States of America. (Cd. 5609), British Parliamentary Papers, LXXXVIII.
76. U.K. Board of Trade, 1913. Report of an enquiry by the board of trade into working class rents and retail prices, with the rates of wages in certain occupations in industrial towns of the United Kingdom in 1912. (Cd. 6955), British Parliamentary Papers, LXVI.
77. U.S. Congress, 1893. Wholesale prices, wages and transportation. Report by Mr. Aldrich from the Committee on Finance. G.P.O., Washington.
78. U.S. Department of Commerce, 1975. Historical Statistics of the United States: Colonial Times to 1970. GPO, Washington, DC.
79. R. Walters Labour productivity in the South Wales steam-coal industry Economic History Review 28 1975 280-303
80. M. Ward J. Devereux Measuring British decline: Direct versus long-span income measures Journal of Economic History 63 2003 826-851
81. M. Ward J. Devereux Relative U.K./U.S. output reconsidered: A reply to Professor Broadberry Journal of Economic History 64 2004 879-891
82. T.J. Weiss The service sector in the United States: 1839 through 1899 1975 Arno Press New York
83. T.J. Weiss Revised estimates of the United States workforce, 1800-1860 S.L. Engerman R.E. Gallman Long run factors in American economic growth 1986 Chicago University Press Chicago 641-676
84. T.J. Weiss U.S. labor force estimates and economic growth, 1800-1860 R.E. Gallman J.J. Wallis American economic growth and standards of living before the civil war 1992 Chicago University Press Chicago 19-75
85. T.J. Weiss Long-term changes in US agricultural output per worker, 1800 to 1900 Economic History Review 46 1993 324-341
86. J.G. Williamson The evolution of global labor markets since 1830: background evidence and hypotheses Explorations in Economic History 32 1995 141-196
87. G. Wright The origins of American industrial success, 1879-1940 American Economic Review 80 1990 651-668
88. S. Yamada V.W. Ruttan International comparisons of productivity in agriculture J.W. Kendrick B.N. Vaccara New developments in productivity measurement and analysis 1980 NBER and Chicago University Press Chicago 509-585